大会演讲·中文精读

马斯克、恩达·肯尼、舍文·皮舍瓦尔与马克·利特尔——Web Summit 2013

Elon Musk, Enda Kenny, Shervin Pishevar & Mark Little - Web Summit 2013

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2008年12月24日,圣诞夜,下午六点。

特斯拉的融资在这一刻完成交割。如果再晚几个小时,这家公司几天后就会破产。

五年之后,都柏林RDS会展中心,Web Summit的最后一场对话,马斯克提起这件事,语气平得像在念别人的账本。现有投资人凑了一轮,他把手里剩下的钱全部投进去,还向朋友借了钱。融资在最后一个小时关掉。

主持人、Storyful创始人马克·利特尔(Mark Little)在旁边补了一句:现在所有人都觉得特斯拉是一夜成功。

这场对话发生在2013年10月。同台的还有爱尔兰总理恩达·肯尼(Enda Kenny)和舍帕创投(Sherpa Ventures)的联合创始人舍文·皮舍瓦尔(Shervin Pishevar)。那几年爱尔兰刚从债务危机里往外爬,肯尼把这段经历形容成一场马桶事故:先掉进去,再被冲到另一边,然后一点点捞出来、甩干、放回高地。

这个时间点很微妙。Model S刚被《消费者报告》打出史上最高分,SpaceX已经能把飞船送上天再完整接回来,而欧洲大部分地方还在危机的余震里发抖。都柏林这座城市正努力把自己重新包装成“创业者可以来的地方”。

这间展厅的前身,是一场办了五十年的中学生科学展

利特尔提到一个细节:这栋楼过去五十年一直是爱尔兰青年科学家展览的举办地,这周换成Web Summit,等于换了一代人的舞台。

马斯克跟爱尔兰有点旧缘。他说上一次来是大约三分之一世纪以前,当时七岁,玩得很开心,一直想再来,只是拖了太久。

肯尼抓住机会当场招商。他提起亨利·福特,上世纪初福特在科克(Cork)办起了汽车厂,一待六十年。然后他看着马斯克说,如果特斯拉要来欧洲,爱尔兰愿意和最好的对手竞争,给个机会,工人不会让你失望。

马斯克的回应是“这个我们私下聊”。全场笑。

21岁那年,他列了一张五件事的清单

利特尔问,十几岁的时候有没有某个瞬间,让你决定要改变世界。

马斯克说,十几岁没有,大概21岁才有。

少年时期他喜欢打游戏,喜欢写软件,想过去做职业游戏开发,“那看起来是件挺好玩的事”。到了大学,他才开始认真想一个问题:什么最影响世界的走向。

他的答案是五件事。三件他认为确定是好事,值得去做;另外两件他打了问号,没说是哪两件。

后来的事情大家都知道了。互联网、可持续能源、太空,那三件他都参与了:Zip2、PayPal、特斯拉、SolarCity、SpaceX。

利特尔追问,PayPal卖掉之后,别的创业者可能会在同一个赛道再做一个成功产品,你为什么会跳到完全不相干的领域。

马斯克给的理由很朴素:他一直在等。

等阿波罗计划之后那条线继续往下走。月球基地、太空酒店、载人火星任务。年复一年,一件都没发生。

他最初的判断是,人们失去了意愿。

后来他发现自己判断错了。意愿并不缺,缺的是一条不会把经济搞破产的路径。只要人们相信存在这样一条路,意愿立刻就会回来。

所以他去做火箭,去把发射成本往下压。他的表述很克制:我不敢说我们一定能把人送上火星,但至少可以把这件事往前推。

利特尔提到一个数字:历史上只有四个实体把太空舱送进轨道又完整带回来,美国、俄罗斯、中国,还有马斯克。

马斯克的反应是把功劳推开。SpaceX有一大群极有才华的人,外界给我的关注太多了,这不对。人们需要一个具体的面孔去认同,这很自然,但真正把事情做成的是团队。

火星不是逃生舱,是给文明买保险

利特尔让他把时间拨到二十年后。

马斯克的答案是火星上有一个基地,并且正在朝自给自足的方向稳步推进。他把这件事称为确保文明长期存活最有力的手段。

他的表述很物理。人类一旦成为多行星物种,社会的尺度和规模会大得多。一个只在单一星球运转的文明,所有鸡蛋放在一个篮子里。

还有一层跟生存无关,跟情绪有关。

地球上永远会有问题,解决完一批还会长出下一批。但人也需要一些让人愿意早上爬起来的事情。一个明亮的太空未来,属于这一类。

这段话在2013年听起来像科幻。放到今天再看,可回收火箭已经飞了几百次,星舰还在炸。方向没变。

三次爆炸之后,第四次是最后一张牌

舍文·皮舍瓦尔把话题拉到了台上不常谈的地方:创业者必须有能力直面死亡,然后活下来。他请马斯克讲讲2008到2009年。

马斯克给了个短版本。2007、2008、2009三年极其艰难,2010年上半年也没好到哪去。最低点是2008年底。

SpaceX的前三次发射,连续失败。

创办公司的时候他算过账,资金够三次发射。三次打完,钱没了,团队勉强又凑出第四次的钱。

2008年底,第四次发射成功。那是最后一张牌。

利特尔问,火箭点火升空那一刻,你脑子里在想什么。

马斯克的回答后来被引用过很多次。

太紧张了。成功的时候我没有感到喜悦,只是压力释放,就这些。(马斯克)

利特尔追问,成功和失败并排站在同一个瞬间,这种经历会不会把人逼疯。马斯克承认那段时间非常激烈。

特斯拉那边同时在烧另一根引线。2008年夏天他们在融资,然后金融危机来了,通用汽车和克莱斯勒相继破产。在这种时候给一家创业电动车公司募资,用马斯克的话说,人们会因为你提起这个话题而生气。

钱只能从老股东那里拿。他把剩下的全部身家投了进去,又向朋友借钱。融资在2008年12月24日下午六点关掉,晚几天就是破产。

所有人都拿德罗宁劝他别造车

利特尔问,美国公众那么爱汽油车,说服他们接受电动车有多难。

马斯克说,难在第一印象。

那时候美国人脑子里的电动车形象就是高尔夫球车:不好看、跑不快、操控差、续航短。有了这个先入为主的框架,你说“电动车”三个字,对方脑子里跳出来的就是那台球车。

所以特斯拉先动手的是车本身,环保叙事往后放。Roadster就是为此而生,一台电动跑车,要有吸引力,要有推背感,要能过弯,要跑得远。

改变认知靠的是一次一次试驾,一个人一个人地改。

马斯克在这里开了个玩笑:如果每次有人跟我提德罗宁(DeLorean),我都能拿到一美元,我就不需要IPO了。

德罗宁是八十年代初在北爱尔兰生产的跑车,公司三年就倒了,成了“欧洲小地方造车必失败”的经典案例。马斯克在都柏林讲这个梗,全场秒懂。

转折点出现在2013年。全球最挑剔的那批汽车评论人开始试Model S,《消费者报告》给了他们有史以来给过的最高评分。

马斯克马上泼了盆冷水。全球每年生产近一亿辆新车,路上的存量大约18亿辆。就算明天开始所有新车都是电动的,替换完整个车队也要二十年。

这段话透露的是耐心。电动车不是打赢一场发布会就能赢的生意,它是一场按车龄计算的替换战。

乔布斯留下的是细节上的偏执

利特尔提到有人的说法:特斯拉对个人交通的意义,相当于iPhone对通信的意义。

马斯克没有直接接这个类比,他谈的是乔布斯。

他说乔布斯身上有一点非常值得敬佩:极端的产品导向,细到极小的细节。苹果的人在高层面和低层面同时用力,让那些让人愉悦的小东西真的发生。产品本身就能让你开心。

Model S想做的就是同一件事。每一个能想到的细节,都要给车主带来愉悦。

2013年说这话的时候,特斯拉还在产能地狱的门口,Model S刚交付一年。马斯克已经在讲“细节带来愉悦”,不是讲马力参数。

利特尔顺势问,欧洲这些右舵市场什么时候能有车。马斯克说右舵版本2014年3月投产,估计三月底到四月。

411查号台,和那张飞去都柏林的机票

舍文·皮舍瓦尔是这场对话里最会讲故事的人。他说爱尔兰改变了他的人生。

两年前,他匆匆飞来都柏林,在谢尔本酒店(Shelbourne)见特拉维斯·卡兰尼克。那时候Uber还很小,9000个客户,其中7000在旧金山。这轮投资抢得很凶。

他的判断很直接:如果那天他没来都柏林,这轮投资他拿不下来。当晚在谢尔本签了投资意向书,交易close。后来他把这次出手称为一次转折性的事件,也把一个转折性的公司带进了自己的组合。

第二年他又来了。这次同行的是当时在高盛管全球互联网业务、后来成为他舍帕创投联合创始人的斯科特·斯坦福。一位叫康纳的朋友安排了车,带他们一路开到爱尔兰最西边的小村庄,去看康纳家的房子。车停在莫赫悬崖,舍帕创投的雏形就在那儿定下来。

康纳不久前去世了。舍文在台上专门提到他,说那是个了不起的人。

另一个故事更早。

舍文一家移民美国的时候一无所有。父亲在华盛顿开出租车,母亲打扫酒店房间。他小时候读很多书,梦想做点有价值的事。

在伯克利读大四那年,他创办了第一家公司。有位导师教他一句话:你不问,答案永远是no;你开始问,就会拿到一些yes。

他把这句话记住了。那时候他白天上学,晚上当保安,没钱。

有一天他读到一篇文章,说杰米·戴蒙(Jamie Dimon)被花旗银行解雇了,人还在纽约的办公室,和秘书待着,等下一步。

他当时二十二三岁,脑子里冒出的念头是:哦,他现在有空。

他打411查号台,问纽约杰米·戴蒙的电话。接线员把电话转了过去。响了几声,他问“我能和杰米·戴蒙说话吗”,对面说“我就是”。

舍文说,他知道自己大概只有六十秒。

他压下恐惧,报了名字,讲了自己那家公司的想法。戴蒙听了几分钟,说听起来不错,来纽约吃个饭。

那顿饭之后,戴蒙写了他最早的天使投资支票之一。

舍文在台上的总结是:如果没打那个电话,如果没坐上飞都柏林的那架飞机,人生会完全不同。那些关键节点,你得打那个电话,得上那架飞机。

他讲完之后,利特尔笑着对台下说,现在所有人都想拿到你的电话号码,好去查你的411。

小树苗长在红杉林里,是最容易死的位置

利特尔念了一个推特上征集的问题:如果你是爱尔兰总理,会给三个什么建议,把这个国家推到数字前沿。

马斯克先说他对“数字”这件事有一阵没想了,然后把答案落在“任何前沿都通用”的层面。

第一,人才必须集中。他打了个比方,组建一支世界级运动队,你不能把好手散在各个城市,得让他们在一个地方一起训练。公司也是一群人聚在一处做出一个产品或服务。

第二,监管、税收、政府支持要覆盖公司的整个生命周期,从初创一直到中期。

第三,也是最容易被忽略的一条:大部分公司倒下的位置在中间那一段,不在最开始。

就像一棵小树苗长在红杉林里。周围全是参天大树,你拿不到那一点阳光和养分,游戏就结束了。(马斯克)

这个比喻说的是逃逸速度。一家新公司对上成熟巨头,缺的往往不是点子,是可信度。客户凭什么把订单给一个没听过名字的团队,银行凭什么给你授信。这一段如果没有托举,很多公司会在这里断气。

肯尼接话,说爱尔兰是小国,资源有限,只能挑几个方向集中投入,比如大数据、物流。他提到爱尔兰这些年推的一件事:让大公司带小公司,让有经验的人给年轻人做mentor。

他还提了一个人口结构:未来25年,爱尔兰是欧洲人口结构最好的国家。克林顿来的时候说过,这些年轻人会跳过别的国家必须经历的那些苦。

工程学费全免,条件是你得留下来

马斯克补了一条他觉得“不是空话”的建议。

技术公司要工程师。所以爱尔兰的大学应该鼓励工程专业,甚至可以考虑工程学费全免。

然后他加了个条件,全场笑了:免费可以,但你得留下来,你得在爱尔兰创建你的公司。

这个条件的逻辑很清楚。人才是流动的,学费补贴如果只是替别的国家培养工程师,那这笔钱花得不值。要绑定的不是学籍,是公司注册地。

舍文接过这个话题,讲了美国的Startup Visa Act。他和戴夫·麦克卢尔(Dave McClure)等一批创业者、投资人一起推动这个法案,目的是让创业者移民美国的手续变快。

他觉得爱尔兰也该做同样的事。爱尔兰有全世界最好的人、最好的文化、最好的品牌之一,那就该做一个startup visa,把创业者吸过来,在这里开公司。本土人才要培养,外面的人才要进口。

他甚至把马斯克的条件往前推了一步:工程学费应该对全世界想来爱尔兰的人免费。理由还是那一条,技术人才需要密度。

肯尼回应说爱尔兰已经放宽了签证。有想法、有资金的创业者可以来,甚至能拿到居留权,参与进这个国家的创业能量里。

一个讲师,对着45个学生,还是4500万个

肯尼谈了他对教育的判断。

第三级和第四级教育的关系正在变。老师面对的处境不一样了:学生能调取的数据太多,会被淹掉。讲师的角色会从讲授者变成导师、驱动者、发现人才在哪里的人。

他提到MOOC。一个讲师不再是对着45个学生讲话,可能是对着4500万个学生。

这段话放在2013年说,相当超前。那时候Coursera和Udacity才起来一年多。

但他也没把话说满:我们仍然需要技术学院培养技术员,需要大学培养工程师,再把学术界和商业界接起来,潜力就在那儿。

恐惧是有限的,希望是无限的

最后一个问题,利特尔问得很具体:此刻在会场里、在网上看直播的人里,一定有人有个好想法,但被恐惧钉在原地,不敢迈那一步。你会对他说什么。

舍文先答。他讲了前面那个411的故事,然后给了一句总结。

恐惧是有限的,希望是无限的。(舍文·皮舍瓦尔)

他的意思是,硅谷的人也怕失败,怕得一点都不少。但怕归怕,不会因此不试,因为心里抱着“这次可能成”的希望。有些地方失败不是选项,硅谷失败是选项。人们甚至会高看那些摔过跟头还继续往前走的人。

马斯克的回答更工程化。

第一,不理性的恐惧应该被忽略。

第二,就算恐惧是理性的,只要赌注足够值得,还是应该往前走。

第三,做新东西要从第一性原理推理,不要从类比推理。这是物理学的框架。别人怎么做、行业惯例是什么,这些都是类比。回到最基本的事实和约束,从头推一遍,你会得到不一样的答案。

第四,主动去要批评。他说朋友不会主动告诉你产品哪里不对,因为不想伤你。你得去磨,得把真话从他们嘴里挤出来。

肯尼的角度是政治人物的角度。他说如果有人带着想法来找他,他会先提醒对方把专利保护做好,然后给对方信心和勇气去执行。

他讲了一句挺重的话。一个想法如果一直憋在心里,会像政客不解决的问题一样发酵。时间过去,人会变成一个苦涩的老人,为自己当年没有勇气去做而难受。人生没有时间可以浪费。

利特尔用贝克特的话收尾。

试过了。失败了。没关系。再试一次,再失败一次,失败得更好一点。(塞缪尔·贝克特)

十年后回看,哪些判断站住了

可回收火箭从概念变成了常规操作,猎鹰9号的一级助推器已经复用了十几次。电动车从高尔夫球车的刻板印象里走出来,全球年销量从2013年的几十万辆涨到千万级。火星基地还没有影子,星舰还在试飞,但每一次爆炸后迭代的速度,确实是当年那套逻辑的延长线。

倒是马斯克那句“太多注意力放在我身上,这不对”,越来越像一句预言。个体的光环越亮,组织的真实能力越容易被遮蔽。2013年他说这话时是客气,现在再看,更像是提醒。

这场对话里最实用的部分,其实不在火星,也不在火箭,在那些关于恐惧、关于中间阶段、关于主动索取反馈的段落。这些东西不需要造火箭的资本,今天就能用。

  • 给那个你不敢打的电话设一个60秒倒计时。舍文当年知道自己只有一分钟,恐惧被时间压缩之后反而能执行。先想清楚六十秒里你要说什么,然后拨出去。
  • 把你想做的事用第一性原理重写一遍。删掉所有“行业通常这么做”的句子,只留最基础的事实、约束和成本,看结论会不会变。
  • 找三个朋友,明确要求他们说缺点,并且当场承诺不翻脸。不主动索取,你听到的永远是客套。
  • 算清楚自己手里有几张牌。马斯克当年算的是三次发射的钱,第四次是借来的。你得知道哪一次是最后一次,才知道什么时候该把全部押上去。
  • 如果你是政策制定者或大公司管理者,把资源往中间阶段挪一点。最早期有补贴,成熟期有市场,死在中间那批没人管。
  • 学工程,或者招工程师。技术公司的人才密度比任何战略文档都重要,把好手放在一个地方,别散着。
  • 把失败写下来。记的不是情绪,是哪一步判断错了。下次再试的时候,失败得更好一点。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00[Music] now that's some entrance befitting the last session of this web Summit and I have to say I just I don't want it to end and in some ways it doesn't have to and I I think this is what I'd like to do with our very special guests here is to make sure that as every one of us walk walks out of this room tonight we will think as individuals what we can take from the last couple of days to change not just the companies that you might work for that you founded but the communities you live in and I hope also in the case of Ireland t- shuk the nation that we live in as well and for that reason I think we could have no better guests with us to talk about the time we live in I

0:51think Elon youan said about this is the a great time to be alive as a Creator this is a time abely where the balance of power is in our favor yeah I I don't think you could ask for a better time in history yeah absolutely I think people sometimes forget that but it it is you have to say realistically where when else would you want to be alive but it's also I suppose that t- a difficult time right it's it's a A disruption you have about the worst job in the world to some extent don't you in terms of trying to recover an economy that fell into the toilet and now we're back at a point where you do feel something moving in this country but it's still tough a lot of people out

1:28there very fearful of Chang change yeah well it didn't just fall into the toilet it got flushed out the other side and it's been a long process to take it out of that tank let me tell you and shake it up and dry it off and put it on high ground but I I think it's the extraordinary privilege for us here in Ireland to have two innovators entrepreneurs thinkers about the future here in at this web Summit and no

1:52matter what you do it has to be about people at the end of the day and as an island nation that has been traveling since the fth and sixth Century we understand interdependence and our you know the common thread of our Humanity we rely upon each other in so many ways and I think that what's happened in Dublin this week has been quite extraordinary the collegiality the challenge the bar the understanding that it is from this kind of interaction of people like this that new ideas come for new ways of doing things to create that future that's actually coming at us with and and changing be bewildering speed and that's why many of the young companies who are here in the RDS this

2:35week will explode in terms of their potential in the next 5 years they've never been heard of their products their ideas the ways the new ways of doing things are going to impact on the lives of hundreds of millions of people just as has happened here already so in that sense it's the it's the question that president Xi Jinping asked me when he came here from Washington how do you build a sense of community in your country because they know about that and as as an island nation we understand that and it's to get that sense of community throughout our common humanity is where the challenge and the answers Lie To The Future Sherin you you have

3:10vested interest in this web Su in the sense that this has been very good to you in your business let me tell me a little bit about the last two websms and what came out of it in terms of practical change in your life Ireland has actually changed my life and I have a lot to be thankful for and grateful for both for this nation and also for Patty and and the founders conference and the web Summit two years ago I flew here in a rush to

3:39meet Travis kenck at at the summit and in Dublin at the shelborne we met up and he was the founder of uber I don't know how many of you have heard about Uber before it's at the time the company was 9,000 customers 7,000 of them were in San Francisco so it was still a very small company and it was a hotly

4:06contested investment lots of competition if I hadn't come here I wouldn't have won that investment I wouldn't had the the blessing and the privilege to to to be involved signed the term sheet in at the shelborn that night and and closed that investment and that was a transformational event and it was a transformational company as well to be involved in and I clips of more in particular last year the following year absolutely the following year I came together with my co-founder of Sherpa Ventures Scott Stanford who was at Goldman Sachs at the time he haded up all of the Global Internet practice and we got in a car that was arranged by an amazing man named aan OK Conor a

4:52few who recently passed and he's a great man and we got in a car and we drove to the tip of Ireland to see his house in this little village and at the Cliffs of mohor is where we came up and finalized the idea of Sherpa so those two years have been a really transformational time and Sherpa is a whole new way of thinking about how to invest in companies and help entrepreneurs Mark isn't it a funny thing in a way that here in this building is where the young scientist exhibition has taken place for the last 50 years and here you have the web Summit this this week which is another another the new direction for all of that I I think it's it's absolutely

5:33fitting that this is where it should be because it's a it's the next platform I think this it's fair to say that we just can't take for granted the scale of this remarkable moment I mean one of the super connectors of Silicon Valley sitting beside me on my right and somebody and Elon I I had to go to find a quote from one of your former employees which I thought really summed up a lot of what you have achieved that he said he is W verer bron bron Howard Hughes Henry Ford Bill Gates Steve Jobs and every other badass rolled into [Music]

6:12one I yeah that's probably a bit generous but talk about generosity now you you are moderately busy running to billion dollar companies that are stretching the boundaries of space and time and energy and you came to Dublin what was the attraction of this event this time I understand there really going to be a great party tonight I think he missed it it was last night yeah no I you know I wanted to come back to Ireland for a while I was last time I was here was about a third of a century ago I was like 7 years old and had a great time as a kid wanted been wanting to come back for for a long time so this was a good opportunity to do so don't leave it so

6:53long next time you keep coming back here you hear me absolutely we need you we need you remind me we were reminding Elon about the fact that Henry Ford came here to set up his car company obviously with the Tesla car which I've just had the privilege of of getting a short spin in here extraordinary vehicle extraordinary when you lift the the Bonnet as we call it at irand they've got a trunk in the front and a trunk in the back and you can make it into an even bigger vehicle if you wish but it's quite extraordinary but Henry Ford started off his his motor industry in Cork at the turn of the last century and was here for 60 years so if you're looking for a good base

7:41yeah we certainly we certainly give you an opportunity seriously let me say this to you if you're going to come to Europe with Tesla we will compete with the best okay so if you're going to do that you give us a chance we'll give you a fair hearing and our workers will not let you down believe you me all [Applause] right okay let's keep that between ourselves I just want also just get some water up here I don't our guests to die of dehydration before we get to the end of our session here but if we can get some water on stage but I I just want to go back Elon to your your your years growing up when obviously 12 years old I think you sold your first video

8:23game that you had programmed yeah but at what point in your teenage years was there a life bul moment where you said I really do want to change the world teenage years maybe maybe I was probably like 21 or something like that so it was like a little little Beyond teenage years I mean when as a teenager I I didn't really know what I was going to do I like playing video games I like writing software you know and so I thought well maybe I'll write you know professionally write video game software that seemed like a pretty fun thing and then and when I was in college I

8:59I I just sort of think about what what's what's going to most affect the world and there were actually sort of I thought there were five things that I thought would most affect the world three of which I thought would definitely be positive things to solve two of which are slight question mark and and then as it turned out I was able to get involved in all three of those things you being the internet sustainable energy and space now obviously you you revolutionized online payments but after PayPal other innovators might have moved on into the same area to have another success you chose a completely different set of challenges to address I mean space what

9:41what was the thinking there why you just follow your money back into online Commerce for example well I guess the the thing that motivated me there was that I kept expecting that there'd be a man Mission Tom Mars that was the continu of the dream of Apollo we went to the moon then there was supposed to be a base on the moon there were supposed to be space hotels there was there were going to be missions human missions to Mars and year after year that stuff didn't happen and and at first I I thought well you know maybe people have lost the will to do that and and I S came up with this idea to do a mission to M to kind of get people excited about that stuff

10:30again but I came to the conclusion that that that I was actually wrong about that assumption and there's plenty of will and it's really about making sure that there's a way if people think there's a way to do it without bankrupting the economy I think there's plenty of Will and so that's that I thoughted basic to try to improve rocket technology and just do as much as we

10:52can to advance that towards event you know make I'm not saying we'll take people to Mars but we want to try to move things forward as much as possible what I'm fascinated by was you started out to try to get people excited again in space and then you ended up with this fact there are only four entities that ever sent a Space Capsule into space and brought it back us Russia China Elon

11:22Musk I have a lot of really great people at at SpaceX so yeah and we we've got an awesome team at SpaceX and actually I think one of the things that that that isn't recognized is that I I mean there's way too much attention paid to me and it's really that's not that's not right I mean people want to focus they want to identify with an individual and so that that's sort of naturally is what occurs but you know there's a super talented group of people at at SpaceX who make it happen you've done something remarkable in a couple of years but can I just take you forward let's say 20 years in your mind what is your your vision for Humanity in 20 years time and particularly about space

12:05exploration well I think the thing that would be really great is to have a base on Mars and to ultimately with and be making steady progress towards having it be a self-sustaining civilization on Mars and I think that's the you know the most powerful thing we can do to ensure the long-term survival of civilization and it's just a very exciting future I think if you imagine a future where we're out there exploring the stars and we're multiplet species the scope in scale of society is that much greater and I find that that sort of view of the future really exciting and inspiring and and there need to be things that that are inspiring you know it it there are

12:51lots of problems on Earth and we'll we always have problems on Earth but but there also need to be things that are inspiring that that make you want to get out of bed in the morning morning and and having a bright future in space I think is one of those things I just want to touch on something that isn't talked about as much especially about what how Elon got there is that Founders and

13:15entrepreneurs have have to have the ability to face death in the fa right in the face and survive to be able to start a company and not give up and put everything you have your heart and soul into that company to bring it to life and one of the things that Elon did with both his companies is an incredible example of that in terms of what you did in 2008 2009 if you could touch on that and tell that story I think it's so inspiring and it it really exe exemplifies what it means to be a Founder sure I can maybe give the yeah the short short account of that time and things were very very tough in that 2007 8 and9 period and even sort of the first half of 2010 and the the

14:05low point was was late 2008 because the the first three launches at of the rocket at SpaceX that didn't work we had three failures in a row and and when I started the company I I I thought you know I'll I'll make sure there's enough capital for three launches like but we managed to just barely scrape together enough to do a fourth launch and and in late 2008 that that fourth launch worked and that was our last chance but El if that that was the last chance right somebody would have gone to the wall if the fourth game over yeah so what's going through your mind as you're watching that rocket blasting off for the fourth time I mean I you know they say about like like a white

14:49knuckled flight I mean it was like yeah I mean it was so tense that when it succeeded I didn't I didn't actually feel Elation I didn't feel feel I just felt like stress relief that's all it was but having having I think this is something about Founders is having success and failure sitting side by side in a moment does it not drive you mad I mean to have to cope with that level of pressure yeah that was pretty intense so

15:21and there were some other compounding things cuz at Tesla we we were trying we we were rais around in summer of 2008 and then the financial crisis hit and he had General mtiv and Chrysler going bankrupt so trying to raise money for a startup electric car company in the face of that was like I mean people angry that you even brought up the subject and so the we're only able

15:49to raise money from the existing investors and I I put everything I had remaining and had to borrow money from Friends for the the Tesla Finance around and it closed on the last hour of the last day that it could close which was 600 p.m. Christmas Eve 2008 and we would have gone bankrupt a few days later and they all think it's an overnight success I think one of the lessons we can learn from this weekend here Mark is the is exactly what what the two gentlemen are talking about and that's to to have a culture of not being afraid that something might go wrong that something might fail and I think for all the young people in the country who are our future really it's from a

16:28political perspective perspective it is to open the doors of opportunity and give them the give them that chance to to to build their dreams that they they won't all work obviously but it's it's it's to kind of encourage them not to be afraid to follow that and if it doesn't work that you start again the wrong view about that in this country for many years I think that's something you see in Silicon Valley that there's no fear of failure but culturally in this part that's true no I think there's fear of failure I certainly have fear of failure you know but it didn't stop no but I think it's an inherent thing though like when when Irish people have

17:04gone away and they gone all over the world you know they might try three or four Ventures before something actually actually works in the way they want but in in a confined in a confined Island the tradition has been if it goes down well that's a you know it's it's a bad Mark against you that shouldn't be the way and when I find going through the the secondary schools and the colleges of technology and the universities there's a different attitude and that's inspired by people like like what you do there is I'll I'll touch on fear a little bit because it's one of the things that I've I've realized is is fear fear is finite hope is infinite and and I think

17:42what's happened in Silicon Valley is that as Elon said we are afraid of of of failure but it doesn't stop us from trying because we hold on to the hope that we will finally actually succeed regardless of the three failures that happened in those rocket laun laes you were hoping that forth would work and I think the mentality has to be that failure is actually an option it is an option and in other places failure is not an option and that we look up to people who actually fail but they keep going forward but it's also to listen to where the where a new Venture might actually be for hundreds of thousands of years we measure the volume of Timber by

18:28measuring the height of the tree in the circumference and calculate the volume in cork tree matics have cracked this 3D version you can put the entire matter Grosso on a computer determine the value and the quantity of the and the volume of timber that's there it's a whole new way of doing things why is it that it's taken Elon after 50 years of analysis on space travel to be able to to to Define and make a reusable rocket we've had you know America NASA Russia China Japan Europe here's one that flies and comes back down and is usable again in a few hours and as he said himself it you know it's it cuts the cost by over a 100 over 100 fold which is incredible can I

19:09ask a question it seems to me that in many ways Elon you you relish the status of Outsider I think you're talking about how you're fighting to get this program the Space Program together and you said it was like a little child wrestling sumo wrestlers and I thought it was a great image of you as an outsider is there a sense that may come from a an immigrant experience so you know the Irish immigrants went over they fought against an elite in the United States both of you guys have been born in other countries is that a factor in a lot of the great innovators of Our Generation Well I wouldn't say that I I I relish being an outsider I really just you

19:43know there's I'm agnostic as to whether it's sort of Outsider or Insider it's just that you in the case of SpaceX and Tesla and Solar City this you we're trying to do something useful and and rather we weren't an outsider honestly it's I think like ultimately in order for SpaceX to be successful it really has to become part of the system you know it can't be an outsider for forever and I think we're gradually getting there with the with for example NASA is our biggest customer that's about a quarter of valones of for NASA and we're

20:23launching GPS satellites and other things weather satellites and essentially it's important to do useful things in kind of the Earth orbit arena in order to earn the money necessary to develop interplanetary transport technology but but being an outsider one or Insider I wouldn't say is is all all that important except to the degree that you don't want to you don't want to compromise the the fundamental goals and values of of the organization in order to become an Insider Sher do you think it's a sense that you you know there is a sense of that celebrating the iconic last in in American IND inovative culture what defines a great innovator what are the qualities you

21:03need think the great innovator is not following the crowd is is not following Trends it's thinking ahead of the curve is having the the kind of confidence to believe in your vision and to never give give up on that Vision the greatest innovators that I've seen in my life and I've been blessed to work with from you know Travis onwards and friends like Elon and and seeing what they accomplish what you notice in them is

21:33that they have an opinion they actually have an opinion they have a vision of their own they're not influenced by a lot of outside Trends and they're trying to force that Vision onto the world and and shape the world in a new way and they're have the courage to confront any of the fears that they might have in in the path to make those that Vision come true Let's Pretend elon's not here for a moment I know you're a very good friend of his some people do stand Head and Shoulders above others I think it's fair to say Elon what makes somebody like Elon Musk special different better I think it's it's it's much of what I said is is is that ability

22:21to say I believe in this and I'm willing to put everything I have on the line it's something that I've seen many entrepreneurs that I've been able to be blessed to to invest and do it's something that I've had to do in my own life is is be able to say here's everything I have and I'm putting it all on the table and if you're not willing to risk everything to to again you know face your fears if you're not willing to do that if you don't have the courage to do that you can't stand up high and be someone that people can look up to and say that's how how I would love to live my life both professionally and personally I would say I would say it's

23:06the it's driven by the power of imagination it was Einstein who said that imagination is the greatest Force because it encircles the entire the entire sphere and for somebody like like Elon to imagine the something that's going to be different and to have the conviction and the belief to actually follow it through despite the Nayer of the cynicism it is about making decisive moves and have the courage to follow that imaginative Force out of which may come success and may not like his Christmas Eve in 208 but it it it happened but it's driven by somebody having a view a thought an inspiration an imaginative quality say I this is what I believe in and whether it

23:48be you know Jac who sto or the sea so many years ago on the whole Marine business are the the evolution of space travel and where we're going and how to get there and the impact of that on humankind it's driven essentially by an imaginative quality the personality of the person carries that followed by belief and conviction and really good people to make that become a reality and neon sometimes that puts you against the conventional wisdom so I'm thinking now while you are giving us ways to get out of off Earth and go and colonize other places and planets you were also trying to make life better here so the solar energy is a big Focus for you Tesla

24:24obviously how it difficult was it to convince the United States a public that is in love with the car and we're talking about the gasoline powered car sure to embrace the idea of an electric car well it was tricky at first and I mean essentially we're going against the preconceived notion of what an electric car was which was kind of like a golf cart so people that was literally their experience with an electric car so they used to a car that didn't look good wasn't fast couldn't handle well had low range and a golf car and so if that's people's if that's the framework that people are coming from then then obviously when you say the word electric

25:03car they're not going to have good associations and so the the the first order business for Tesla was to try to create a car that that broke the mold or you know really fundamentally changed those perceptions and that's that's why we did we did the Tesla Roadster and an electric sports car so it it had to be in order to be seible had to be something that that that had some sex appeal had great acceleration handling long range those things were were really important to fundamentally change the perception and it still took a took a long time and but we're able to change people's minds one by one by giving them a test drive so like here's the the proofers in

25:42the pudding here's the car take it take it for a ride and it was very slow going at first and I mean if if if I had a sort of a dollar for every time someone mentioned Tucker lauran I would not have needed an IPO so it was it was it was tough going in the beginning there but I think I think it it was just by making a product initially just a demonstration article and then going into limited production with the Roadster and then going to much higher level of production with the model S I think people's minds have gradually changed and then this year with the some of the the toughest critics in the world are reviewing the model S and and saying it's you know the

26:29best car in the world Consumer Reports gave it the highest rating they've ever given any car and I think that's this year really has been been a turning point there's still a huge huge way to go because the number of electric cars going on the road is is Tiny still I mean there's there's almost 100 million new cars made every year there's an existing base of about 1.8 billion cars so even if all

26:57cars were Electric El all new cars made were electric tomorrow would still take you know in the order of 20 years to replace the fleet that car will sell very well in Ireland I hope so there's one for everyone in the audience by the way that only works if you're actually Irish and another Late Late Show here but but I when I hear you talking about the Tesla it resonates with me what Steve Jobs used to talk about with the iPhone you know the sense of intimacy with this not just a product do you and I've heard someone say that the Tesla will have the impact on personal transport that the iPhone had on Telecommunications well let's it's kind of say that the

27:30iPhone was a really great invention I mean I I do I do think you know just being something that Steve Jobs was that that I that I think was quite admirable was he was Ultra product focused like down to the little details and and and he and other people at Apple would would really try hard to have these both at at a high level and a small level these delightful things happen so just the the product was just it just made you happy and and that's that's what we try to do with with the model S is is just every little detail that we can think of to to really bring joy to the owner of the car that's what we want to do and what can we expected on the roads of places like

28:16Ireland or this part of the world well we we should have the right-and drive version in production in March and so I I would imagine late March April that time frame and yeah I hope there's many people who will buy it in in Ireland it would be great and listen I can't ask you to come to Ireland and not give a bit of advice perhaps to the t- I I was tweeting out this week saying anyone got some good questions it was a great question from somebody which said Elon Musk if you were the t- shuk of Ireland could you give us three pointers of what you would do to make us put us there on the digital Frontier the digital Frontier okay well I haven't really thought about digital stuff for a

28:57while but any Frontier any Frontier well I think that the most important thing for creating companies is is you need a concentration of talent you know you it's it's like creating a you know think of like a like a world sports team or something you you really want to focus your talent on a particular area and and that's what world company is is a group of people that got together to create a product or service so in order to have a great company you've got to have You' got to you focus your energies on a particular area and yeah and and then make sure that

29:43from a regulatory standpoint and and from you know terms of regulations and Taxation and government support that it's there for startup companies and and that it goes from startup all the way through the medium phase of company cuz where where most companies tend to to not make it is not so much at that very beginning stage it's that it's that intermediate stage so they'll you can they sort of reach escape velocity as as a company and and when when a new company's formed when you're going up against established you know big established companies you're trying to build some kind of credibility and it's incredibly important that companies are nurtured through that

30:26phase I mean it's just like a little sapling growing in a redwood forest you know you've got these giant companies if if you don't get a little bit of sunlight nutrition it's game over that's an important piece of advice actually as a small country we don't have the resources to you know spend on all the things that you might like to follow through so we've looked at the the the areas where Ireland could concentrate on like big data or Logistics or whatever and one of the things that is growing in importance here Elon is the capacity of many firms to Mentor smaller firms and newer entrepreneurs coming through to give the benefit of my experience let's

31:02look at where you're headed and there's a lot of that going on I think it is very true to say that the more you get them together the more the the challenge and the results actually come from that and if you Ally that to a sort of an openness to say look we're going to we're going to give you the opportunity to have a go at this if it works great if it doesn't we're going to start again I think that's where the future we have the best demographics of any country in Europe for the next 25 years when President Clinton was here he said all these young people they're actually going to Short Circuit the the the rigors that so many other countries had

31:35to go through coming out of a coming out of a recession so it's it's in there there is there's certainly real potential and I thank you for that and if you're sending that spacecraft off Tom Mars I have a few people that could put on it for you as well maybe they could send it from Shannon we could actually get SpaceX to Shannon that was another suggestion I had from the Twitter machine well listen this man either of you are welcome here anytime you've you you've done very well so far Elon we're a different kind of people personality of our people has been all around the world for centuries we're open pragmatic work very hard not afraid of that and I think the young

32:09challenge you have in the country really the essence of it was here all week speaks for itself about their imaginative capacity to change the world and create the future and anything we can do as a sort of a a catalst for that is our responsibility to open those doors and let them follow their dreams and and and build through to reality as you have done and will do for the future yeah and absolutely I was trying to think of like is there anything what what useful things can I can I say I'm trying to say something that isn't just sort of a bland platitude the I think

32:41if if you know if for technology companies you need Engineers so to the degree that there can be encouragement of of that course of study at at Irish universities I think that would be really really powerful the yeah it like maybe like maybe engineering could be like tuition free or something like that you know

33:09so what do you think these [Music] are well but then tie it to like they got to stay in Ireland they can't just fail so it's like free free engineering tuition but you got to like hang out you you got to create your company here I guess that's the kind of thing that that i' probably that I think would be would be effective for creating technology companies what do you think T well I think I think the whole area of of third and fourth level education is changing the relationship between lecturers and teachers is going to change because the student now has so much capacity in terms of drawing down data that they get swamped with it completely so lecturers are are going to

33:49be different kind of mentors drivers indicators of where where people's Talent really lies I think that's all going to change in the next decade with the muks and the capacity of you know universities and colleges of Technology with online courses that can be done worldwide lecturers aren't speaking any more to 45 students could be 45 million students and I think that's where the that's where the next big change is actually coming but it's creativity and all of that that makes a difference we do need technicians coming from our colleges of Technology we do need Engineers coming from our universities and Ally that to the world of Academia and business and you've got a you know a

34:24thriving potential put it that way sure you're yeah I'll add one more idea to to Elon the in the US we co-founded something called the startup Visa act and started Visa movement with Dave McClure and number of other entrepreneurs and VCS and the idea was was really to expedite the ability for for entrepreneurs to immigrate to America and the thing about Ireland is Ireland has one of the greatest people in the world and one of the greatest cultures one of the greatest Brands and I would do something very similar as well just do a startup Visa here in Ireland attract entrepreneurs to come here and start their companies in Ireland so that you're importing

35:07Talent on top of growing and hom grown home grown like that tuition thing I'd say make it make it free for anyone that wants to come here from around the world from all over the world yeah cuz you need that concentration of technical Talent yeah we have relaxed the Visa system we give we give entrepreneurs who wish to come here even with a right of residency if they've got an idea and and some Capital to be able to come here and and get involved if you like in the in the energy that's coming off all of these creators that are in the country at the moment I'm sorry to say t but I've been i' probably dragged off stage now cuz gone way over it's it's

35:41been a remarkable conversation I have to say an honor for me can I just ask one very final question of each one of you there's so many people here tonight but there's also people watching live laptops and their tablets and somewhere out there there's probably somebody was a great idea but it's kind of paralyzed by fear they don't know they don't want to take that chance could you just talk for a moment Sher first of all what would you say to that young potential entrepreneur who just doesn't know if they can take the risk it's a great question I I you know when I we immigrated to us so we we came from nothing really my my father was a taxi driver in DC and my mom

36:20cleaned hotel rooms and and all we had was the American dream and I grew up just reading a lot of books and dreaming that I could be something and do something of of of value and when I went to Berkeley I started my first company senior year of college and and one of my mentors taught me that you should always ask that the answer is always no if you don't ask and as soon as you start asking you you actually get some yeses and so I applied that in my very first company when I first started I had nothing I was working at night as a security guard while going to school had no money and I read an article about a guy named Jamie Diamond who's now

37:10the head of JP Morgan and he the article said he was fired by City Bank by City And he was in his office with his secretary and kind of waiting for his next move and I was 22 23 years old and in my mind I was like oh he's available I I'm going to call him and he's one of the most powerful people in in banking and finance and so I call 411 which is directory information and I say can I get the number for Jamie Diamond in New York and they connect the call and it rings and I go may I speak to Jamie Diamond and someone answers and the voice says this is him I'm like oh sorry sorry he's never heard that word before I heard that before and I go so I knew I had

37:59like 60 seconds I had to face my fear and I and I said you know Mr Diamond this is my name is Sheran I have this dream for this company and after a couple minutes of listening to me he says that sounds really good come up to New York we'll have dinner and I did that and he wrote my one of my first checks as an angel investor and that changed my whole life if I hadn't made that call or if I hadn't flown to Ireland to to to meet with Travis on Uber those pivotal moments you just got to make that call get on that plane and you know what's happening now everyone's looking for your phone number so that they can give you directory 411 Elon can I ask you about that one message to that

38:40potential entrepreneur waiting to make the jump well I mean certainly I think people people should ignore fear if it's irrational and and and if if it's but even if it's rational and the the stake is worth it it's still worth proceeding and you know I'll say a few of the things that some people may have heard me say before which is I think if you're creating a company doing something new it's important to reason from first principles which is kind of a physics framework rather than Reason by analogy and TR try to get as much critical feedback as possible from friends and you have to ask that you have to coax it out of them because they'll be reluctant

39:29to say it because they don't want to hurt you but they if they know what's wrong with your product just yeah need to get it out of them so yeah know thanks teach I think if somebody came to me as they do occasionally Mark with ideas I think i' I'd make arrangements to protect their patent because that's always an issue but I think it's about giving them the confidence and the courage to follow through with it because if it's inside you it's a bit like in my business politics if you don't deal with that you grow into an old person bitter at not having had the courage to go and do it so if an entrepreneur an initiator somebody with an idea if they don't

40:06follow it it's always festers inside them and time passes by and they miss the opportunity we have no days to waste in life and no time to waste in dealing with the problems that we face so it's about confidence and courage and giving people the opportunity to follow their dreams I'm going to have to leave that the last word TI and I want to say I mean I remember being told the Samuel Becket line that great line he said ever tried ever failed no matter try again fail again fail better and that's what sort of keeps me going I suppose in manyways so that's it for us I just want to say what an absolute privilege it has been on your behalf as well to welcome shervin and to tiak

40:43and Elon Musk thank you so much for your time your Insight and I think we before we go I think Patty's going to come back up and before he comes up I actually shared the first web Summit three four years ago and by God Has It come on and I just want to say that a huge round of applause to Patty carra and the team of the webs for doing this

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份