访谈·中文精读

马斯克与理查德·布兰森爵士谈创业(2013)

Elon Musk and Sir Richard Branson talks Entrepreneurship (2013)

B 站版本为网友搬运,时间点可能差几秒
中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2008年12月24日,平安夜。Elon Musk 签完了特斯拉最后一轮融资的文件。那是融资窗口的最后一天,过了这天,公司就得关门。

差不多同一时间,他的另一家公司 SpaceX 刚熬过第三次发射失败。前三次,全炸了。他原本只给火箭预留了三次发射的钱。

五年后,2013年,他和 Richard Branson 出现在一场 Google+ Hangout 的两端。布兰森在加勒比海的 Necker 岛,马斯克在加州,连线的还有约翰内斯堡、纽卡斯尔、蒙特哥贝、波哥大几个城市的创业者。两位都经历过差点归零的时刻,所以整场对话里没什么励志口号,全是具体的人和具体的事。

最难的一关,是把最后一点钱分给两家快死的公司

主持人问马斯克,做企业到现在最难的一件事是什么。

他没说火箭爆炸,也没说睡在工厂地板上。他说的是2008年那个决定。

当时特斯拉和 SpaceX 同时缺钱,而他卖掉 PayPal 给 eBay 拿到的钱,差不多快花完了。手上剩下的钱只够救一家,或者勉强分给两家。

这就像你有两个孩子,食物只够一份,你不确定把食物分开喂,两个孩子是不是都能活下来。如果因为我分散了最后一点钱,导致两家公司都死了,那会是非常糟糕的结果。(马斯克)

他最后把钱分开了。SpaceX 的第四次发射在2008年底成功,特斯拉的融资在平安夜签完。两家都活了下来。

这一段值得停下来想一想。多数创业者讲的"最难时刻"是产品做不出来、客户不买单、团队散了。马斯克讲的是资源配置层面的生死题:手里只有一份筹码,面前是两个都不能死的局。这种难,难在心理,不在体力。

"去他妈的,干就完了"与"主动去找最难听的反馈"

主持人抛给两个人的第一个问题很直接:给今天的创业者什么建议。

布兰森的回答很短。

如果你有一个好想法,觉得它能改善别人的生活,那就去做。我有一句话:去他妈的,干就完了。(布兰森)

他说自己见过太多人,想法很好,被身边人说一句"这不太行",然后就没了。他的建议是,先干起来,摔个狗啃泥,爬起来再干。

马斯克的方向不太一样,两者并不矛盾。他说创业的本质,是一群人凑在一起做一个产品或服务。这家公司要存在得有意义,产品就必须足够好,否则公司根本没有存在的理由。

所以他给的建议是:尽可能多地从尽可能多的人那里拿反馈,尤其是负面反馈。

你应该主动去找负面反馈,特别是从朋友那里。你要用一些技巧把真话挖出来,因为朋友不想伤害你的感情,不愿意直接告诉你哪里不对。但他们往往知道。(马斯克)

两条建议放在一起看挺有意思。布兰森说的"别听劝",指的是那些泛泛的"你不行";马斯克说的"多听劝",指的是具体的"你这个东西哪里有问题"。前者是情绪噪音,后者是产品信号。分不清这两者的人,要么被劝退,要么把产品做死。

硅谷为什么只有一个:人才浓度,但失败率一样高

主持人问了个很多人想问的问题:为什么创业集中在某些地方?为什么硅谷只能是硅谷?以色列为什么创业氛围那么浓?

马斯克的回答挺实在。他说硅谷能成,核心是全世界创业人才的聚集,尤其是科技领域。但他补了一句,大部分在硅谷创立的公司其实并不属于科技行业,各行各业都有。

他觉得外界感觉硅谷创业特别密集,一部分原因是 Facebook、Twitter、Google 这些公司带来的曝光度,让硅谷在全世界眼里被放大了。

不过他也没给硅谷贴金。他提到硅谷公司的失败率其实也很高,跟世界其他地方差不多。待在硅谷不等于你就会成功。

这其实是一场极端的达尔文式筛选,我会这么说。(马斯克)

但他仍然承认,如果你要做科技公司,没有第二个地方像硅谷。会计、法律、房地产,一整套配套基础设施都成熟到极致,这里已经非常擅长"制造公司"这件事。

布兰森补了一层解释。他说硅谷的优势是"先发者优势",先跑起来,攒下了"这里有伟大公司"的名声,然后全世界想干这事的人都往那儿跑。

他顺手举了英国的情况。维珍一直在游说英国政府,与其只发助学金让人去上大学,不如也发一笔钱让人去创业。他的设想是,如果能从政府拿到一到两万英镑启动资金,再靠这笔钱去吸引其他创业者的投资,很多公司就能起步了。

小公司像蝌蚪,需要有人替它挡一挡

谈到政府该做什么,马斯克的比喻很直接。

一家年轻的小公司就像一只小蝌蚪,非常脆弱,成功的概率很低。所以任何能让它长大一点、让它在面对大公司时能撑住的事情,都极其重要。(马斯克)

他说大公司会想方设法把小公司掐死。政府该做的,是尽量给这些小公司挡一挡,让它们有机会长大、变得有竞争力。

话题自然就转到了布兰森和英国航空当年的那场官司。马斯克主动把这个案例抛了出来,说这段经历很值得讲。

布兰森讲得挺直接。当年英航用了各种非常手段想把维珍挤掉,维珍把他们告上法庭,赢了,拿到的是英国法院历史上金额最高的一笔诽谤赔偿。英航从那儿以后就收手了。

如果当年我们没打那场官司,我不认为维珍今天还在。(布兰森)

给他这个建议的是前一家航空公司的老板 Freddie Laker。Laker 当年就是被大公司搞垮的,他告诉布兰森:告那帮混蛋,因为他们也会对你来这一套。

这个故事在美国又重演了一次。布兰森说,美联航正在用各种办法挤压维珍美国,在维珍的航线上大量投放运力,让维珍很难赚钱。他的应对办法是绕开价格战,把产品做好,好到乘客愿意绕路来坐维珍美国。

他总结了一句:你必须在自己的领域做到最好。这句和马斯克前面说的"产品必须足够好",其实是一回事。

创业的真面目:嚼玻璃渣,盯着深渊

主持人问失败在他们各自的经历里扮演了什么角色。

马斯克的回答有一个时间表,值得所有准备创业的人记住。

公司刚起步的时候,一切看起来都很乐观、很美好、很让人兴奋。大概前六个月到一年吧,还不错。然后事情开始出问题。至少我的经验是这样。(马斯克)

他说接下来你会犯错,会撞上没预料到的问题,会踩到地雷。第二年到第四、第五年,通常非常难。

他引用了一个朋友形容创业的说法,自己觉得挺准确:

创业就像一边嚼玻璃渣,一边盯着深渊。(马斯克)

这个阶段里,公司一直处在可能死掉的边缘。作为联合创始人或 CEO,你得干一大堆你不想干、本身也没什么意思的活。这就是"嚼玻璃渣"的部分。如果你不把这些杂活干完,公司就活不下来。没有哪件活是太小、不值得 CEO 亲自干的。

然后他讲了 SpaceX 的具体数字。前三次发射,全部失败。

我们当时就是太笨了,不知道怎么把火箭送进轨道。(马斯克)

他当时做的预算就是三次发射的钱。第三次也炸了之后,他们勉强凑出了第四次发射的资金。那是2008年底。第四次成功了。如果那次也没成,SpaceX 今天就不存在。

同一段时间,特斯拉在2008年融资,赶上金融危机,那一轮融资谈崩了。最后在平安夜签下来,那是能签的最后一天,过了这天公司就破产。

那段时间压力很大,我得这么说。(马斯克)

布兰森接话,说他在那段时间就认识马斯克,很惊讶他的头发到现在还是黑的,没变白。

布兰森自己的版本是这样的:维珍唱片当时做得很好,然后他去搞航空公司,回来发现银行经理坐在门口,说周五来的,周一就要把维珍集团清盘。他们整个周末到处救火,把透支额度压到银行经理要求的水平,一周之内又找了一家新银行。

成功和失败之间只有一条很细的分界线。建一家公司,唯一重要的事情就是活下来。(布兰森)

他还给了一个比例:十家公司里有八家活不下来。所以如果你失败了,不用太沮丧,从里面学到东西,再来一次。有限公司这种制度的存在,某种意义上就是为了鼓励人们去试。

超级高铁的起点,是一列比飞机还慢的高铁

主持人替朋友问 Hyperloop(超级高铁)的进展。马斯克先说了一段背景,这段背景比结论更有意思。

他说自己最初开始想这件事,是因为看到加州的高铁项目。他很失望。

它算不上真正的高铁,平均时速大概只有125到130英里。走的路线还稍微绕一点,从洛杉矶到旧金山。所以它其实比坐飞机还差。我宁愿坐维珍美国的飞机,也不想坐那趟火车。(马斯克)

他觉得奇怪:为什么要花一大笔钱做一个比现有方案更慢、而且大概率更贵的项目?

他还提到另一件让他难过的事:协和飞机退役之后,超音速民航就没了。他希望未来比过去更好,但有些地方正在倒退。

于是他开始想一个问题:从一个城市到另一个城市,在什么条件下,什么才是最优解?

他给出的判断是:城市之间的距离在一千英里以内,情况特殊。这段距离里,飞机爬升和下降占的时间比例很大。超过一千英里,就该坐超音速飞机。低于这个距离,需要另想办法。

他列了几条"理想交通工具"的标准:速度大概是次优方案的两倍,成本更低,更安全,不受天气影响,更方便。如果真有这么个东西,大部分人都会选它,两个城市之间的人员流动反而会增加。他甚至设想,那时候有人可以住在旧金山,在洛杉矶上班。

他拿太平洋铁路举了个例子。当年修铁路的时候,有人说加州根本没多少人住,这条线是傻事。测算出来的客运量很低,因为那时候人们靠马车出行,极其不方便。铁路修通之后,情况完全变了。

Hyperloop 的具体形态,他说是在一根管道里跑,但不是真空管道,是低摩擦。洛杉矶到旧金山要在半小时内到,平均时速得在700英里左右,也就是超过音速。

细节他说周一(2013年8月12日)会全部公开,这次先不展开。

这一段透露的思考方式比技术本身更值得注意。他一开始问的是"现有方案为什么不够好、正确的问题该怎么问",而非"我想造个酷东西"。他自己也说了:

你得先问,正确的问题是什么,这件事应该怎么框定。(马斯克)

带团队:目标说清楚,不认同的人得走

约翰内斯堡的创业者问马斯克:你带过各种团队,也鼓励颠覆现状,让一群想颠覆的人好好合作的秘诀是什么?

马斯克的回答核心是两个词:mission 和 vector alignment。

他说首先得让每个人都清楚公司的使命是什么、目标是什么。人加入公司的时候,得是认同这个目标的,不能只是为了工资来的。目标定清楚了、大家都点头了,后面才有依据。当某个人的行为跟公司目标不匹配,你可以直接跟他说:你这里得改。绝大多数情况下,人会改。

但偶尔有人不改。

极少数情况下,如果有人就是不改,你得准备好让他离开团队。因为如果团队的目标互相冲突,这事就成不了。(马斯克)

他把 CEO 的根本工作定义成"向量对齐":让所有人朝一个方向使劲,让每个人发挥出最大潜力,让大家早上愿意来上班。做到这一步,人就不想走了,因为他们在享受过程,也在获得进展。

布兰森在同一场对话里反复强调另一件事:倾听。

他说太多人以为自己什么都懂,就爱听自己说话。好的倾听者能从别人那儿拿到大量想法,用来判断自己的主意到底行不行。他后来在回答蒙特哥贝的提问时又补了一层:好的领导者不会什么事都自己干,好的领导者愿意让别人去犯错,也愿意让别人去做成事。

同时开两家公司,他自己都劝你别学

约翰内斯堡的另一位提问者问:创业最重要的原则之一是极度聚焦,那你怎么能同时盯这么多项目,还保持这种专注?

马斯克的回答很清楚:

我绝对不建议同时创建两家公司。(马斯克)

他说公司早期资源极其有限,如果不聚焦、把资源摊薄,成功的概率会大幅下降。他一开始根本没打算管特斯拉,是后来不得不接手。他形容这件事"工作量比想象的大太多"。

他给创业者的建议是:只专注一家公司,把所有能投入的时间都投进去。从早干到晚,睡觉都在想,一周七天,不休息。他做 Zip2 和 PayPal 的时候就是百分之百聚焦。

他说自己一直希望特斯拉不是必要的。等到看清楚大车厂不会自己去做电动车,这件事才变得必要。

布兰森在这个问题上补了一个很实用的建议,路线跟马斯克正好相反。他说,在公司历史很早期的时候,就要找到一个能日常运营这家公司的人,最好比你强。

大多数人就是抽不出时间去找那个真正合适的人,然后自己整个被埋进去。但你要腾出时间去找人,找到之后你才能去想更大的图景,才能去开下一段冒险,才能有家庭生活,才能照顾身体。(布兰森)

他说如果你什么都自己扛太久,人会垮掉,而且你未必是日复一日运营这家公司的最佳人选。总能找到跟你一样好、或者比你更好的人。

主持人问马斯克是不是不同意。马斯克的回答有点苦涩。

很遗憾,我在这件事上没成功。我在特斯拉试过几次,都没成。也许将来某个时候吧。(马斯克)

招世界级人才靠什么:一个值得赌的目标

波哥大的创业者问了一个很实际的问题:创业初期,钱不够,怎么招到并留住最好的人才?

马斯克先讲了个体育队的比喻。赢球的队伍是拥有最好球员的那支,但球员之间配合得好不好,会再乘上一个系数。战略是球队整体拿出来的东西。

然后他说,要招到最好的人,你必须有一个非常有说服力的目标。把自己放到一个世界级人才的位置上去想:他要做的是真正能改变点什么的事,是一家有可能做成大事的公司。这很自然,因为到这个层级的人,本来就是这样自我定义的。

接下来两件事必须成立:

  • 对方得相信这家公司有做出伟大成果的潜力
  • 对方得相信公司的领导者本人

他说第二点尤其难,特别是从成熟公司挖人的时候。你等于是在说服对方,放弃一个相对确定的东西,去换一个创业公司的不确定。所以对方必须相信这件事足够有意思、能改变世界,同时自己的付出会在财务上得到回报。

财务回报这一点,可以说是相对最不重要的,但它仍然应该是一个因素。(马斯克)

商业本身是向善的力量,但先活下来

主持人问布兰森,他一直相信商业是向善的力量,最近忙了些什么。

布兰森的回答分两层。第一层:做企业这件事本身就是向善的,因为你在创造对别人生活有正面影响的东西。第二层:等你把公司做成功了,你可以用创业者的能力去看那些看起来无解的世界难题,政客和社会工作者未必有这样的工具箱。

他举了维珍孵化的一批非营利组织:Carbon War Room(碳战争室)、The Elders(长者会)、Oceanic Elders(海洋长者会),还有最新的 The B Team。B Team 的目标是让全世界的公司不只盯着利润,也考虑环境足迹,考虑人,把企业联合起来去处理全球性问题。

但他在回答约翰内斯堡那位做学生公寓的创业者时,把顺序讲得很清楚:

刚开始建公司的时候,你首先要确保它活下来。这个过程里尽量做让自己骄傲的事,但你还不在一个能大规模改变世界的位置上。等你把公司建起来了,再去想我能为这个世界做点什么真正大的事。(布兰森)

马斯克对"商业是向善的力量"这个说法态度更冷静。他说,一家公司就是一群人凑在一起做产品或服务。只要这家公司没有被某种立法保护,也没有不合理的垄断,那它存在的正当性就取决于它为别人做了多少有用的事。

所谓"善"有一点主观。但可以说,大部分公司只有在做有用的事的时候才存在。(马斯克)

他说自己看旗下公司的角度就是这样:我们怎么做出人们真正想要、真正觉得有用的东西。这个逻辑本身很朴素。

两个人互相怎么看

快结束的时候,主持人问两人有没有想问对方的问题,或者给对方的建议。

马斯克说他们认识很久了,是朋友。跟布兰森相处总是很有意思,在维珍群岛喝一杯 Bushwacker 是件不错的事,当然线上聊也不错。

布兰森对马斯克的评价是:

我对 Elon 有极大的敬意,他做到的事情难以置信。他是个年轻得让人讨厌的人,我为此恨他。他显然还有非常多的事情要去完成,我很期待着迷地看着接下来会发生什么。(布兰森)

接着他给了马斯克一个具体的建议。前面聊到了授权,他希望马斯克能找到一些真正出色的人来帮他。他提到马斯克有五个孩子,都是男孩,当年第一次见的时候都还不到四岁。

他需要在未来这些年里,为孩子们腾出足够的时间。他得找到一些好人来帮他。(布兰森)

马斯克的回应很直接:

我同意。我今年的新年决心就是多花一点时间在乐趣和家庭上。我觉得我有一点进步,你说得完全对。(马斯克)

下一步是电动超音速飞机,也许不该由他来做

蒙特哥贝的创业者问马斯克:你被称为今天的亨利·福特,有人甚至说你是最接近托尼·斯塔克的人。你在交通领域攻城略地,太空、陆地,还参与创造了支付平台。除了超级高铁,下一步是什么?机器人?瞬移?

马斯克说瞬移确实很酷。但他手上已经太多了,SpaceX 和特斯拉,还得留一点时间给 SolarCity(太阳城)。不过 SolarCity 有非常出色的人在管日常运营,他去主要是听好消息。

然后他说了真正想做的事:

如果我未来要再创办一家公司,我不觉得会很快,那会是尝试造一架超音速、垂直起降的电动飞机。我认为那是交通的终极形态。(马斯克)

他解释了几层逻辑。超级高铁适合的是"两个城市距离很近、之间流量巨大"的特殊场景,通用情况下,最优解就是超音速垂直起降电动飞机。

电动,有环境上的好处,也更安静。超音速,非常快。如果飞得足够高、机身形面设计得当,音爆可以做到不比现在的飞机更响。垂直起降意味着你可以降落在离目的地很近的地方,无需降落在那些有着超长跑道的巨型机场。

他说他特别希望有人去做这件事。

如果没人做,也许未来某个时候我会去做。(马斯克)

布兰森在结尾对全场创业者说了一段话,可以当作这场对话的落点。他说你们现在谈的生意可能只有五千、一万美元的规模,但从这些生意里,有一天你可能开始想垂直起降飞机这种事。当然你得从零开始,得花很多很多年才能走到那里。

但是,把梦想做大。有一天,这些梦想有希望变成现实。(布兰森)

这场对话里真正能拿走的几条

整场聊下来,两个人风格差异很大。布兰森讲的是人、是授权、是活下来、是给出去。马斯克讲的是产品、是负反馈、是向量对齐、是把问题问对。但有几条是重叠的,也是这场对话里最值得带走的部分。

失败属于默认路径。十家公司八家活不下来,硅谷的失败率跟别处一样高,SpaceX 前三次发射全炸,特斯拉的融资卡在破产前最后一天。这些谈不上戏剧化叙事,它们就是创业的基准线。知道基准线在哪,你才不会被第一次撞墙吓退。

公司早期真正的考验是活下来和聚焦,创意反倒排在后面。资源摊薄是致命的。马斯克自己都说,同时开两家公司这事他绝对不建议。如果非要干,就得准备好一周七天、睡觉都在想。

产品必须足够好,这是所有事的底层。马斯克说公司存在的意义就是做出足够好的产品,布兰森说必须做到你所在领域的最好,好到客户愿意绕路来找你。两种说法,一个意思。

授权这件事,越早越好。布兰森的建议是公司早期就去找一个能日常运营的人,最好比你强。马斯克承认自己在特斯拉试过几次都没成功。这条建议值多少钱,取决于你愿不愿意承认自己无法全能。

想清楚问题,比想清楚答案更重要。超级高铁的起点是加州那趟又慢又贵的铁路带来的失望,并非"我想造个酷东西"的冲动。马斯克自己说:你得先问,正确的问题是什么。

以下是给正在或者准备创业的人,可以直接上手做的几件事:

  • 列出三到五个你最信任、也最敢跟你说真话的朋友,把产品或者方案拿给他们,明确要求他们只说问题、不说好话。朋友不会主动开口,你得逼出来。
  • 给公司写一句话的使命陈述,发给团队每个人,问他们是否认同。不认同的人,现在就谈,别拖到执行阶段才发现方向不一致。
  • 把手上所有事情列出来,砍到只剩一件最核心的。早期资源摊薄比方向选错更致命。
  • 在公司早期就开始物色一个能管日常运营的人,哪怕现在请不起。把人选记下来,保持联系,不要等到自己快垮了才开始找。
  • 给自己设一个"家庭与健康"的硬性时间,写进日历,像对待董事会一样对待它。这条来自布兰森专门给马斯克的建议,同样适用于所有人。
  • 遇到大公司用不正当手段挤压你,先把证据留好,再考虑法律手段。布兰森当年那场官司,是维珍活下来的关键之一。
  • 每隔一段时间问自己一次:我现在解的是正确的问题吗?还是我只是在很努力地解一个错的问题?
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:22hi everybody this is yra brunini I work for Google Iran marketing for Google in Europe Middle East Africa I'll be hosting this hangout today we've got our special guest ours Richard Branson from necar Island hi Richard and Elon Musk joining us from California hi Elon hi we've also got offices of entrepreneurs from around the world Johannesburg hello and

0:54Bot and we've got Newcastle hi hi hi everybody and last but not least monteo Bay hi hi so what we'll do is 20 minutes of a chat between Richard and Elon and then we'll hand it over to the other offices to ask their questions and we'll wrap it up in an hour so before I ask the first question I just want to say how excited I am both at a personal as well as at a professional level to be hosting this hangout with two such amazing people personal because I come from a country that's very Pride itself in being entrepreneurial I'm Turkish and I come from a family of entrepreneurs and engineers and excited at a professional level because the company I

1:42work for Google has very entrepreneurial Roots a DNA even though we're much bigger than when we started very entrepreneurial in our spirits and we work with millions of small businesses around the world and it's very much a part of what we're passionate about at Google but not just these reasons but also to such entrepreneurs who do crazy things and have a healthy disregard for the impossible just thinking of their space Ventures so that's also very exciting and not only that but they truly believe and represent that business can be a force for goods so that's all about my excitement we'll have a lively discussion over the next hour so I'll just kick off with my first question

2:26Richard and Elon there are all these budding entrepreneurs hanging on every word you're going to say no pressure and they want to know I'm sure what would be your advice in this day's economy and in in the way the world economy is today what would be your advice to them to budding

2:46entrepreneurs since elon's not speaking I'll speak the I think if you've got a great idea that you think can improve other people's lives just just get on and do it I mean I I have a phrase which says screw it just do it and and and and that's what I would recommend and and so you know the

3:07important thing is you know is doing it and there's so many people who come up with great ideas that you know are told it's not such a great idea or or just don't end up doing it but you know but but you the key thing is give it a try if you fall fat on your face pick yourself up and try again are you being to ask that question or are you being are you being told that something's impossible and crazy and you're doing it anyway right now I think most most of these most

3:39things that we've done at virgin somebody you know people have said you know it's mad to do it I mean when we went into the airline business when we when we owned a record company and you know people said what on Earth is somebody from the entertainment business wanting to start an airline and I think you know what they didn't realize was actually people on airlines want to be entertained they want to have have a you know a fun good EXP experience which they didn't have when we started the airline business 30 years ago so I think you know most of most most of the things that we've done there have been plenty of people who said you know not a

4:11good idea Elon your turn where are you sure well I think I think it's it's it's important to I think it's important to take as much feed feedback as you can from as many people as you can about whatever idea you have so the whole idea about around creating a company is that you're you're you're you're putting together a group of people to create a product or a service and in order for that

4:49that for it to make sense for that group of people called a company to to exist it has to be a really good product or service otherwise there's no point in that company existing so you want to just be extremely rigorous about making the best possible thing that you can and seeking every trying to find everything that's wrong with it and fix it that's that's really really important so something I often say is you should seek negative feedback particularly from friends so seek critical feedback ask them what's wrong you often have to draw it out in a nuanced way to figure out what's wrong because friends don't want to tell you exactly what's wrong they don't want to

5:32hurt your feelings but they often know and and so that that can be really helpful and and then you keep trying to make it better and better and and then if if your product service is sufficiently better than what whatever else is out there or if there's nothing else like it then the company will succeed excellent thank you yes Richard sorry no no I'm just going to add to what Elon just said and that is it it's so important to be a good listener and there there are too many people who think they know it all and like like hearing their own voice but being being a good listener you you know there's you're gonna you can get so many other ideas from other people to to

6:16work out whether your idea is a good one or not I'm listening no okay all right okay so the SEC my second my other question I've been really dying to ask you is it looks like entrepreneurship is concentrated disproportionately so in some parts of the world why is Silicon Valley only in Silicon Valley why is Israel so much more entrepreneurial shouldn't there be more such places scattered around the world and should you do something about it should we do something about it well I think Elon can start the answer on this one since he's from Silicon Valley I to Silicon Valley

6:59from South Africa I mean I've spent probably most of my life in Silicon Valley or silic Valley like environments and you know I think the thing that makes Silicon Valley work is is really the people that that it happens to be a concentration of entrepreneurial Talent from all around the world and in particularly in technology obviously Sil Valley is very technology oriented but they most businesses that start are not are not technology businesses they're in in in all sorts of other sectors so when I think the reality is that there's a great deal of entrepreneurial activity throughout the world it just so happens that in in recent decades or recent years even Silicon Valley has

7:44has gained a lot of awareness because of things like facebbook Twitter Google obviously and and so so I think it may have a disproportionate awareness in the world because of of some of those things and but but it is if you want to start a technology business there's there's no place like like Silicon Valley there's just no place that has the infrastructure you know whether it's accounting legal real estate and it's just just gotten really good at at at creating companies however it should also be said that Silicon Valley like most companies the Silicon Valley fail so there's a pretty high failure rate of Sil Valley companies as there is around

8:27around the rest of the world so it's not as though if you're there you you will succeed it's it's an extreme D warning exercise I would say it's silic Valley but in terms of what the rest of the world can do you know what's sort of a use think of a useful thing I could say it's it's do do whatever you can to Foster the growth of of young small companies because you know a young small company is it's it's like a it's like a little tadpole you it's got a very it's it's it's very fragile odds of success are very low so anything that can be done to allow it to grow a little bit and to sustain itself in the face of much larger companies is extremely

9:10important and so that would be my advice to say governments or or or you know on regional state level is do whatever you can to to to Shield the smaller companies and allow them to to grow and be competitive because big companies will try to stamp them out and I know I know Richard had it an incredible battle with with the British Airways and and thank goodness you

9:36know that that that worked out because virgin is awesome so and and yeah that I mean I don't know Rich if you that's an anecdote you you'd want to share but it's it's pretty I think that that that whole story of of your battle with British Airways is pretty incredible yeah yeah well big companies will try to Stamp Out small companies and and it's government's role generally to try to make sure that doesn't happen governments don't always play that role very well and and and therefore you know in in the end it's up to you to shout foul and use you know what whatever means you can and to to defend yourself and and when British Airways went to extraordinary lengths to

10:25get rid of us we took them to court we won the biggest sort of liable damages ever in in the British courts and and British their alwayss backed off and you know if we haven't done that I don't think virgin you know virgin would be would be around today and it was a a a previous head of an airline Freddy Laker who gave me the advice sue the sue the bastards if because they will they put him out of business and they said they will try the same to to you in America we've we've got United doing everything they can to try to get rid of Virgin America by you know loading

11:04capacity onto all our routs which where where where it's going to be very difficult for them to actually make make money and you know we're we're fighting our you know fighting our Corner hard fortunately the the the quality of the product is so much better than theirs that you know people will go out of their way to travel Virgin America and therefore you know I think we will survive and we will Thrive and you know that's an important lesson you've just got to be the you've got to be the best you the best in your field as Elon said earlier and I mean just going back to the original question I think you know Silicon Valley has

11:38the advantage of being first mover so they got they got in there they they they they built a reputation for having great companies and therefore they attracted people from all over the world who wanted to go and work there you know in in in a small country like Great Britain you know we've urged the government to set up something you know where instead of just just getting grants to go to university you can get grants from the government to set up your business business and your business idea and I think that you know that could be fantastic I mean you know if you can get 10 20,000 PS to set up your business from the government or or you know or or you should you

12:19should be able to therefore attract some money from other entrepreneurs as well and and that's all you all you need often to start a business you just just getting that that that that initial seed money so I think if if governments could do things like that more around the world that would be good great both of you are saying similar things around governments playing a a bigger role in this what about failure you mentioned this earlier Elon you were also saying there's a lot of failed startups in in Silicon Valley how how is fail failure played a role in your success so to speak or in your careers so to speak well in all of the companies that

13:03that I've been involved with there's always been a very difficult time in the very difficult time is usually shortly after the beginning actually it's you when you first start out the company things seem very optimistic and Rosy and and exciting I think maybe for the first six months to almost a year it's it's pretty good and then things start to go wrong at least been my experience and you make mistakes that that you encounter issues you didn't expect you step on landmines and I mean it just it's just it's bad like and that so like years two

13:44through four or five usually quite quite difficult and you know there's a friend of mine who's got a saying about starting a company which is it which is a bit I think a bit true it's a it's it's a bit like eating glass and staring into the abys in that in the most cases companies go through this this phase where you've got to you're you're in constant danger of the company dying just constant and and then if

14:18you're the co-founder or CEO you've got to do all sorts of things all sorts of jobs like and tasks that you may not wish to do that that are not intrinsically interesting to you and so that's the the eating glass part there's quite a bit of that too and if and if you don't do your do your chores essentially then the company will not succeed and and and you really got to be prepared to do do whatever whatever it takes work whatever hours and and no task is too menial I think that's the the way the right attitude for the CEO of a startup and

14:57anyway so that's but that's been the case actually with with every company that I've been a part of so if you take it say say say SpaceX the first three launches that we conducted failed and it was it was very very painful exercise and we were just too stupid to know how to make a rocket go to orbit and and I'd actually set aside money for that I budgeted I thought okay we could afford three launches and then the third one failed and and we were just just barely able to scrape together enough money for for a fourth launch and and this is in late 2008 and and that succeeded and if that had not succeeded the space sex would not be around today in that same time period

15:47Tesla was was Raising financing in 2008 and then the whole financial crisis hit and financing round fell apart and we just make a long story short we we we were able to finally close a financing round on Christmas Eve 2008 which was the last hour the last day that a financing could be closed after which the company would go bankrupt that was a stressful time I have to say so things have things have improved quite a bit since then but it wasn't that long ago that the companies were almost dead

16:30yeah I think well I knew Elon in those days and and I'm surprised his hair is still still it's still black and not gray but they I think I think that you know I think what Elon what Elon is saying is basically that there's there's a very thin dividing line between success and failure and and all that matters when you're building a company is survival and and if you go the wrong side of that dividing line you you're obviously not going to survive and if you can just stay the right side you can survive and at virgin you

17:13know we we've had similar situations when we launched the airline we had a very successful record company came back to find the bank manager sitting on our doorstep saying that he will you know on that that was on the Friday that he was going to for close on the Virgin group on the Monday and and we had to you know scramble over the weekend to you know get our overdraft facility down to the level that he wanted it and then by the end of that week we had to find another bank and so you know so fighting to survive is is is it goes without saying but it's absolutely critical and and and most

17:50companies do not survive and so so I think the you know the important thing to learn from it is is you're going to learn an enormous amount by actually you know building a company and if you if you don't survive you're one of you know like eight out of 10 companies do not survive so you know so you shouldn't feel completely downhearted from it you should you should learn from that and and just try again and that's what limited companies are for that it's there to encourage entrepreneurs to you know give it a go do everything you can to survive work day and night to make sure you do survive but if if it doesn't if you don't just you know pick yourself

18:30up again and try again and keep and keep trying until you finally succeed and you know there are many big entrepreneurs in the world who've had companies that have failed in in in their lifetimes thanks thanks for that I think I'd like to ask one last question to each of you and and then ask the other offices to join the the Q&A

18:58first to Richard Richard I know you believe business is a big Force for good can you tell us what you've been doing in that area recently I think you're doing some really inspiring stuff could you share that with us well I mean business business in itself is a Force for good because what you're doing is you're creating something which is going to make a positive difference to other people's lives so just just being an entrepreneur I think is is a very positive thing having said that I think if if you are an entrepreneur and you and you've built a successful company you can use your entrepreneurial skills to look at some of the you know seemingly

19:44intractable problems of this world and and see if you can address them which sometimes politicians or social workers may not be fully equipped to do and that you know burgon we we've incubated you know quite a lot of not for-profit organizations like the carbon warum like the elders you know

20:06like the the the oceanic Elders like like the B team which is our newest not for profit which is designed to trying to get companies around the world not just to think about the bottom line which is very important but also to think about you know their their their environmental footprint also to think about people and and and and and trying to unite businesses to try to get out there and get on top of the world's problems and I think if if business if if bu enough Business Leaders can work in it we can get on top of the world's problems but we need it we need every every every business in the world to give it a go and Elon as Richard said you know

20:55each business each entrepreneur is a even if it's for profit Prof it can be a force for good and you've got a lot of work to prove that as well there were a lot of my friends told me to ask you about hyperloop I just thought if you'd share a few of the latest updates on that I think you've got an update August 12th coming up but I wondered if there's anything you could share with this exclusive audience well yeah I mean I think you know we'll just answer the first part of the question I a company is is like I said a group of people working together create a product or service so as long as that as long as they're not protected by some sort of legislation or

21:37or somehow you know have a an unreasonable Monopoly on things then they only exist to the degree that they're doing useful things for their you for for other other people out there you know and so I think it's you know forceable good I mean there there's a bit of subjectivity as to what what good represents but but it's fair to say that that that a that most companies only exist if they're doing something useful and and I mean that's the way I certainly view view things for my companies is like how how do we how do we make things that people would would really like and would find really useful in their lives that's that's the the goal it's really pretty common

22:22sensical I think and and then well let's see on the hyperloop what can I say I was trying you know I say a bit about where the Hy Loop's coming from and what I think the goal of such a thing would be I originally sort of started thinking about it when I read about California's highspeed Rail Project which was somewhat disappointing because it's not a very highspeed rail it's got an average speed of I think 125 or 130 mil hour and takes a slightly securest route from Los Angeles to San Francisco and so it's actually worse than say taking the plane I I mean I'd much rather take Virgin America plane than than take the train and so it seems like

23:14why why would one want to do a big expensive project like that which is slower than Alternatives and likely I think will be more expensive than Alternatives and and so I get sad when when when when things aren't getting better in the future and and and another example would be like the the the Concord being retired and the fact that there's no supersonic passenger transport I think I think that's quite sad because you want the future to be better than the past and or at least I I I do quite a bit and anyway so I got to thinking about what what could be the best way to get from LA to San Francisco or essentially what would be the the optimal solution

23:58solution in the special case of a city pair that is less than say a th000 miles and where there's a great deal of traffic between those those City pairs I think once you get to the sort of thousand mile range you you should just take a supersonic plane but less than that you you spend a lot of time climbing and descending so so since the climb Descent Part is significant for routes less than 1,000 miles or 1500 kilometers 6 km I should say it it may be better to figure some other means of doing it so so so so one necessary so you think of like the criteria AP me if this is going on too long just cut me off the the

24:47you have to first say what is the right question to ask how should this be framed and I think you you want a transport mechanism that let's say is on roughly twice was passed as the next best alternative that costs less that is safer that is not subject to weather and and and and is more convenient like if there was such a thing then obviously I think most people would take it in fact it would it would increase the travel between such City pairs because of the increased convenience and and and you so mean you could conceivably live in San Francisco and work in La so you know just as the UN when the unip Pacific joined California people were saying oh there's hardly anyone

25:35that lives in California this this whole Railway line is a silly thing and they calculated the number of people that were travel as being very low because there wasn't anywhere to go to but that was because people were going by wagon which is extremely inconvenient anyway so so the the hypop you know is something that what

25:59go effectively faster than the speed of sound but you know because you'd have to travel at an average speed of around 700 miles an hour from La San Francisco to to get there in half an hour and it it does involve does involve a tube but not a not a vacuum tube but a frictionless not no it's really diff not frictionless but very low friction anyway the the full details sorry for the laborious an up will be on Monday okay thanks a lot it seems like you're both have frustration with something as a starting point I don't know if that's a fair observation I think I heard Richard say that once but that's interesting to observe and to Listen to As we hear you both speak

27:01but before I think sorry many of the best idea many of the best ideas come out of personal frustration and I'm sure a lot of the entrepreneurs who listening have started their businesses from from personal frustration which is an admirable way of starting a business absolutely frustration is good that's my one thing I'll I'll note down from this so okay I know there's lots of burning questions in the other locations to both of you start with Johannesburg Branson Center for entrepreneurship Gavin hi hi Gavin hi hi Richard hi it's gav the Bron Center here in South Africa since we moved here to our new home in Johannesburg in October 2010 the Branson Center has trained and

27:47provides continuous support to 500 entrepreneurs from 460 businesses spanning 21 Industries and today we have 70 of those entrepreneurs is hanging out with you here at the center before we ask our questions Richard we look forward to spending some time with you when you next visit your Center here in jandsburg and to Elon this serves as a a formal invitation for you to visit us here at the center when you next travel to South Africa all right sounds good I look forward to visiting it yeah yeah our first question is for you Elon and it's from our bran and Cent entrepreneur Denise Sherman hi Elon and and owner of customized training videos my question

28:31to you you've worked with a wide range of teams and you actively encourag disrupting the status quo what is your secret to keeping a team of disruptors working well together well I think it's important that everyone understand exactly what the mission is you know what what the goal is and that when they join the company that they're bought into that overall goal so long as people as long as that's that that goal is clearly defined and and and understood and and people are are saying yes they agree with that goal when they join the company so not they're not just joining you know for a salary or something like that but they believe in in what the company's

29:12doing then I think you can always go back to them and say hey look if if their activity is not aligned with with the company say hey you need to change your behavior in this particular way and then they usually do on rare occasions when somebody does not then you have to be prepared to let them go from the team you know because it it it doesn't work if if if if the team is is at Cross purposes so and I think that's that's really important and and and the fundamental job of the of the CEO is is I think is is Vector alignment is getting getting everyone aligned and allowing them to work to their maximum potential and making sure that people look forward to

29:54coming to work in the morning and and the result is then people don't want to leave because they're enjoying themselves and they're they're making progress and that's what people generally want to do thank you thanks Denise hi Richard your question is from another brand and Center entrepreneur

30:20CPUs hi Rich I'm the owner of blessing SS I believe every person was to live a meaningful life with purpose my question for you is as a business Ty do you feel like you have AIS responsibility to change people's life through entrepreneurship sorry your your voice cut out just as you're asking the question could you say it again as a as a business tycoon do you feel like you have a responsibility to change people's life through entrepreneurship to change the world through entrepreneurship yes is that right yeah yes I think so I mean I think I think that I I I think all every single

31:09one of you who who are building your businesses are making a difference in the world and and there will come a time once you've built your business where you can make an enormous difference in this in the world and but you know initially when you're building your business you just got to make sure they they survived obviously try to do things you you're you're proud of in in the process but you're not going to be in a position where you know you could you're really going to make a massive difference in the world as as you're building the business the important thing is that you survive and and and and build your business in in the first stage but once you've actually got

31:48your business established then then I think you can you know think what what can I do to make a real big difference in the world and and as I said ear you know I would really encourage you to aim aim one day to do that tell me what what's the business you're doing I'm into student

32:11accommodation and how you how you managing yeah well there are challenges you know as a small as as small and as we are running small companies there are lot of challenges so I would say the center has been really helpful to us by providing us with the tools that can take our companies to another

32:40level well I I look forward to seeing you in October when I come and wish you all the best with it and I'm sure Elon does as well absolutely thanks I come here to see you thanks Richard thanks and finally from asset bring center it's a very special thanks to John from Google Google South Africa who has pulled together this event with the with the many parties today so over to you John thanks Kevin hi my question is for Elon I've always heard that one of the most important things in getting a business right is is Extreme focus on one thing I'd be really interested to understand how you keep focus on so many different projects and different buses

33:24and still maintain such philosophy well yeah I think that it's it's certainly true that if you're particularly at the early stages of of a company you have such limited resources if you don't focus them then then and you diffuse them then your chances of success are much less so it's and

33:43and I I would definitely not recommend trying to create two companies at once as as sort of happened with SpaceX and Tesla in fact it wasn't originally my intention to run Tesla but I I I had to do so in the end but yeah but I I really wouldn't recommend it honestly it's it's quite a lot of it's more work than yeah it's too much and so I I yeah I would really

34:14strongly advise someone to just focus on on one company as and and throw as many hours as it as you possibly can Really Work Work morning till night think about in your sleep 7 days a week no breaks nothing that's what you should do when you're starting a company and when I did my first two companies sub two and then PayPal I mean that's that's was 100% focused and

34:44yeah I I yeah I was always hoping that Tesla wouldn't be necessary but it was when when when it became clear that the big car companies were not going to do electric cars by themselves then that's when it became necessary I think Can can I add something there please sorry no I I I think the

35:07the absolute the the absolute key I mean I agree with everything Elon said but then the other thing I think you just got to do is quite early on in the in the in in your company's history is f find somebody to run that company on a day-to-day basis who is hopefully better than you I mean most people just don't have find the time to go out there and find that really good person and they get completely over you know they stay completely immersed in it and but you know but finding the time to find somebody else to then run it on a day-to-day basis then you know frees you up to think about the bigger picture frees you up maybe to move into another

35:48adventure frees you up to have a family life frees you up to look after your body and you know make make sure you're healthy and fit and and and you know if you try to do everything yourself for too long you you you you run yourself down and you're not necessarily the best person you know to to run the company on a day-to-day basis you can always find somebody as good as yourself or or better than yourself thank you very much face doesn't look doesn't it doesn't look like he agrees with it well no it's unfortunately I was not successful in doing that I tried that at Tesla few times but it was not successful but

36:29yeah maybe at some point in the future thanks Richard thanks Elon for your insights and we for you seeing at The Ransom Center in South Africa soon back to you youra thanks John I think we've got Pete wood now from Newcastle from startup loans Pete can you hear me hi yes I can hi guys first of all

36:51yeah we're from Virgin money we're based in a not so Sunny Newcastle unfortunately in the northeast of England so yeah I'm Pete wood I look after social Enterprise projects for Virgin money and one of the schemes we're involved in is the startup loans scheme which offers lowc cost low finance and mentoring for young budding entrepreneurs and I just so happen to have three of them with me this afternoon so I'll start by introducing Claire on my right cla's running a hair and beauty training company called the number one Training Academy yeah and we have Nikki Nick runs food and nutrition

37:36business which is just starting off called optimal you and also at the end we've got Dan Dan's in the process of setting up a rather unusual business which is a community Cinema and that kicks off in the middle of September so good luck with that and the first question we've got is actually from Nick so Nick over to you and I think it's directed at Elon yes thanks Pon hi Richard and Elon it's great to have the opportunity to talk to you both today I'm a positive psychologist and my business optimal U is centered on overcoming client barriers to personal growth so Elon I'd like to ask what the hardest thing is that you've had to do in business to

38:18date the hardest thing well I guess there always think of hard like you know one sort of emotionally hard I suppose you know what was sort of really emotionally hard and what was kind of hard work I think the most difficult emotionally hard thing was was in 2008 which I talked about a little bit where both Tesla and SpaceX were in dire need of of fin of of money to keep going and I'd basically run out of the money that or almost run out of the money that that i' gotten from my the sale of PayPal to eBay and and then I had a very difficult decision to make which is that I could either take the money that I had left and allocate it to one company or or or two

39:15and anyway that that that was really difficult because if if I'd you know if if I if I if IID only allocated to one company then it's sort of like you got two kids and it's like you you know you only have you're not you're not sure if if if you if you spread the food around will both kids make it so it could would have been a very unfortunate thing if both companies had failed because I'd spread what what little I had left between the two that was the most difficult thing I think emotionally and then you know hard workwise I think it was just that for for well since then

39:59and and and continuing to now that is just running two companies directly is extremely difficult so the workload is is super high but I I do think things are are getting a bit better on that front particularly this year so I think that that's probably hard to answer that thank you okay thanks and Dan you had a question as well yeah hi I'm Dan Ellis and I'm open a charitable Community Cinema jamj C in my hometown Whitley Bay which is really exciting more than that we work with a lot of volunteers who each bring with them really creative and exciting ideas so my question is for you Richard and when someone comes to you with an idea or a proposal for a partnership what criteria

40:44do you use to determine the viability of that idea or the partnership well I think the mo the most important thing is is the is the individual whe whether or not the whether or not you feel the individual's capable of doing the idea I mean there are many many people who have similar ideas and great ideas it's just whe whether whether they can actually deliver that idea so you know so you know trying to work out whether the person has you know will will will work work all the hours that needed to deliver it whether they're good U motivator of other people and

41:28and you know so as with it was a company is simply a group of people and you just want to be absolutely sure that the person that you know the person who's coming to you with the idea is somebody that you you you you feel can deliver and then everything else flows from that great okay thanks guys and that's our questions done I think yes okay then now it's Virgin Mobile Colombia I hi there the lively bunch hi

42:00how you doing y Guido I think Guido you had a question right yes I'm will Sak I'm lead of marketing of vir mobile columia we're just starting our fifth month of operation thankfully we have had lots of success but even greater fun and today we're very happy to and proud to be here with Andy for the future which is an initiative that

42:27hi hi I'm ion I'm from and for the future we are an entrepreneurship program that has presence in five cities and we are around 300 entrepreneurs I'm here with five of the of the 300 EST cam Diego and Felipe and we hope to see you down here soon to to meet all the amazing things that are happening here in Colombia so I have one question for Richard and why do you think big companies and corporate Rel should support and get involved with entrepreneurship and

43:04help well first of all I'm looking looking forward to coming to Colombia later this year and look look forward to seeing you all there and it's also wonderful that Columbia's back back on its feet again and that some of the the nightmares you've been through seem to be you seem to been able to put into the past the oh my God I think we gotten what question you asked now what was can you say it again please is that as we are part of of a National Business Association that way we are called Andy for the future because we we want to build the next generation of companies in Colombia I was wondering what do you think that the big companies and and corporations

43:47should get involved in in and support entrepreneurship and how I yeah I mean I I I certainly feel that people like Elon and myself who are fortunate enough to you know have had the fortunate breaks that that have given us the success that we've got need to help other people who who are trying to build their companies and you know whether it's through you know entrepreneurial schools whether it's giving up you know I mean elon's just given up an hour of his time to you know talk talk to people around the world today you know sharing sharing his ideas you know whether it's campaigning with governments to try to make life easier for entrepreneurs

44:36you know I think there there are plenty of ways I think that that those entrepreneurs who've been successful can give back by helping other people you know get get set up you know whether it's even by you know putting some money aside to help to help young entrepreneurs you know get set up I mean very very small amounts of money can be all that it takes to set up a company I mean I I I've set virgin up on on a 200 pounds that my mother had managed to claim with from a necklace which she'd handed into the police station and nobody claimed it and and she gave me the money and and and it is literally very small amounts of money like that that that can be the start

45:21of of what can turn into Empires you know many many years later anyway good luck to you all in Colombia thank you I'm gonna let ask another question and and introduce one of our entrepreneurs he's actually from medin so let St speak hi hi everybody and I'm speaking on behalf of all the entrepreneurs here in Colombia first of all I want to thank you El and Richard for your time and for this terrific experience of sharing your

45:57your experiences with us my question is for Elan and it's about Talent it is a fact that Talent is the most important asset in any company however for us for the entrepreneurs in a starting phase it is difficult to recruit and retain Talent not only for for the economic perspective so my question is what are your recommendation to retain and recruit the best talent in that critical moment of the company which is the starting phase well it's it's certainly true that I mean the talent is is extremely important I mean it's really just like a like a sports team you know if you've got the team that we win is the one that has the best individual players

46:49but but but then there's a multiplier by how those play how well those players work together and and the the strategy that they employ collectively so in order to recruit the best people I think you have to have a very compelling goal that you you're going to to you know goal for the company it's that if you put yourself in the shoes of someone who's who's say talented at the at the World level then they they're going to want to do something that really makes a difference that that really like this is a company that's going to be something significant that stands to reason because you know that that's what somebody who's at that level me it's always self-defining

47:37really so you have to have they they they have to believe that that this is going to have a has the potential for for a great outcome and they they have to believe in whoever the leader of the company is so that's it's critical that that they that you convince them that that that you're the right guy to work with and that that's a very that can be a very difficult thing particularly when you're trying to attract people from existing companies because then you're trying to convince them that they should give up something which is a a sort of a relatively sure thing for the uncertainty of a startup and yeah

48:17so they have to believe that it's going to be interesting that it's going to change the world and that that the their that their efforts will be rewarded financially but that that's that's arguably the least important but but it still still should be a factor thanks a lot back to you thank

48:38you last but not least bye last but not least we're going to Montego Bay and the BR the noisy ones Sor the noisy ones go on show us your noise hi hi everyone from Branson Center Caribbean in warm sunny Jamaica you know it's great to hang out with you again Richard hi Elon and everybody else out there Hi since we last hung out Richard we have grown significantly in fact we've doubled in number with 75 entrepreneurs in house now we have

49:15a few of them sitting here with us along with team members hey and we really wouldn't miss this for anything so as we the last ones we want to move on on quickly we'll start with our entrepreneur Brian Brown's question hi Richard this question is for you the name of my company is Livewire act a disruptive marketing and entertainment company now as an Entertainer and socially active citizen I'm increasingly aware of the influences and temptations that can come at you so my question is what is the most challenging part of balancing changing

49:53the world personally and professionally without allowing the World to Change you just that was me was it what was the most you just said it once again and I'll I'll try to get it I'll try to get what was the most what is the most challenging part of balancing changing the world professionally and personally without in turn allowing the world to change who you are as a person yeah I mean I think I think

50:27I love Elon to to give to give his answer as well but I I think the most important thing is you not not to let not to let your your business completely absorb absorb your life 100% especially if you've got a family or if you know if you've got a partner you've got children so so you know trying trying to get a balance a balance in your life is really really important trying to make sure you do have the time to look after yourself is really really important and and as I said earlier it is just so important that you surround yourself with other people who can share share the burden with you people who you can enjoy the good times with get through the bad times with and who

51:14who can take some of the load off your shoulders and and so you know I think as a good leader does not try to do everything themselves a good leader is somebody who's willing to you know to to to you know let you know let let other let let other people make mistakes as as well as make good things and so I think as as early as possible just find you know F find people to work with you who can you know share share the burden and and don't feel that you're you're the only person that knows all the answers okay so on to our second question which is from entrepreneur Dwayne Samuels hello Richard hi Elon I'm from zorus my name is Dwayne Samu and my

52:05question is for you Elon you've been regarded as today's Henry Ford and some would even say you're the closest thing we have to Tony stock you're conquering transportation and in space and land and also you help to create a platform for money what what's next apart from hyperloop what's next robots teleportation teleportation would be cool certainly the well I think

52:31I'm somewhat I probably have a bit too much on my play as it is with with SpaceX and Tesla and then I I still have to allocate a little bit of time to to solo city although fortunately in the case of Solar City there there are some really great guys there that that run it day-to-day and and are just fantastic so I mostly just show up to hear the good news at solo city and yeah so but as far as I mean the thing that I think would be if I were to start another company in the future which I don't think would be anytime soon it would be in to try to create an aircraft that is a supersonic vertical takeoff and Landing electric jet I think that's the that's sort of

53:18the ultimate form of Transport with with the with the exception of of what I was mentioning earlier which is city city pairs that are really close together and have a huge amount of traffic between them that's where the hyperloop could could could win would win on that special case but in the general case it's it's it's it's a supersonic vertical takeover Landing electric plane because obviously

53:42would have some environmental benefits being electric and be quieter supersonic would be very fast and if you fly high enough and have the right geometry of the plane you can make make the sonic boom no louder than current planes and then the vertical take and Landing part would mean that you could land much closer to your destination instead of landing at these huge airports with with super long runways and I think that would really be great I I like I wish somebody would do that and so if somebody doesn't do that maybe at some point in the future I will thanks a lot okay thank you very much for answering our questions and back to you thanks Sharon so we've got around

54:29three minutes left I guess one thing one thing other is one one thing we haven't done is is does Richard or Elon have any questions for each other or advice for each other well we know each other pretty well actually we've been friends for a long time yeah so I always enjoy Richard's company it's it's a who's

54:52always a great guy to hang out with actually usually life of course as oos to also virtually I hope yeah virtually too so yeah it's yeah we've had great times hanging out and having a a Bushwacker which is a good drink in the Virgin Island or a Virgin Mary right so yeah yeah I think anyway

55:27enor have enormous respect for Elon and incredible what what he's achieved he's a horribly young man I hate him for that and obviously has has has enormous amount enormous amount more to more to more to achieve and looking looking forward to watching with with Fascination and interest what you know what what what's what's next and I just hope that you know we talk we talk about delegation I hope he can find some really wonderful people to to help him so he can he's got five five I think children all all boys all under the age of four well they're old now but all right you first saw them were all right and but anyway he's just yeah just we need to he needs to he needs

56:18to yeah I hope I hope you can find lots of time for them in the years to come and but so he's just got to find got to find some good people to help you I think I agree I agree my my New Year's resolution was to was to to spend bit more time on on fun and family this year so I think I'm making a little bit of progress and I I think you're absolutely right about that so great well hopefully we'll see more of you then and and to all all the people listening in thanks so much for your time and good luck to all your all your adventures and and and and the the fun thing you know listening to somebody like Elon you know you're all all talking about you know

56:58businesses which may be only you know $10,000 or $5,000 or you know but out of those you can start thinking about vertical takeoff planes one day I me but you have to obviously start start from scratch build it and and it takes many many many years to get there but but but but dream big and one day one day those dreams hopefully can can become reality and good luck to all of you and thanks very much for your time AB thank you and thanks to Google thank you and thanks Sean for organizing this thank you so much Richard and Elon cheers thanks bye bye thanks

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份