访谈·中文精读

晚宴对谈:超越无限——杰夫·斯科尔对话马斯克与金巴尔·马斯克

Dinner Program - To Infinity and Beyond: Jeff Skoll Talks with Elon and Kimbal Musk

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

1995年,硅谷。一个级别不低的高管把一本厚厚的黄页电话簿摔在两个二十出头的年轻人面前,问他们:你们真的觉得,互联网能取代这个东西?

四年后,这本黄页上的那些公司,成了这两个年轻人的客户名单。摔书的那位,后来也成了他们的投资人。

这两个人是亲兄弟,埃隆·马斯克(Elon Musk)和金巴尔·马斯克(Kimbal Musk)。他们的第一家公司 Zip2 在 1999 年卖给康柏(Compaq),价格略高于三亿美元。那年埃隆二十八岁。

2013 年,米尔肯研究所(Milken Institute)的晚宴上,杰夫·斯科尔(Jeff Skoll)把兄弟俩请上台做了一场对谈。这是他们第一次同台。斯科尔是 eBay 第一位全职员工,后来创办了斯科尔基金会和参与者传媒,投过三十九部电影,拿过五座奥斯卡。他和马斯克家的关系有点特殊:1995 年他认识埃隆,因为埃隆在跟他一个同学约会;不久之后,他和同一个女孩约会了。

我那时候就意识到,埃隆这个人,凡事都喜欢当第一。(杰夫·斯科尔)

兄弟俩第一次合伙,是开街机厅

在南非,埃隆十四岁,金巴尔十三岁。两个人想开一家电子游戏厅。

理由很扎实:他们自己就是玩家,知道什么游戏受欢迎。租约签了,机器也订了,最后卡在一张证明上。去市政厅办手续,对方说签字的人必须年满十八岁。他们从头到尾没跟父母提过这件事,等到父母知道,一切都被叫停。

埃隆在台上回忆这件事,语气里还带着遗憾:本来会非常成功的。

斯科尔问他们互相欣赏对方什么。金巴尔说的是一件很小的事:埃隆七岁那年想要摩托车,金巴尔六岁。在南非,这个年纪要摩托车并不常见。埃隆想要,就一直要,然后真的拿到了。

金巴尔说,他这辈子看着哥哥做这件事,做了一辈子。

埃隆的回答更短。他说金巴尔是他认识的人里最好的一个,活了这么久,从没见过金巴尔故意做一件刻薄的事。

1994 年那趟公路旅行,和"人类长出神经系统"

Zip2 的起点是一趟车程。1994 年,兄弟俩从硅谷开车去费城。那时候埃隆在一家叫 Rocket Science 的游戏公司上班,同时在做电动车用的超级电容。两个人都在念书,同年毕业,因为埃隆修了双学位。

第一个想法是做一个医疗数据库,一个医生和患者的匹配网络。后来推翻重来,反复改了很多轮。

到 1995 年,他们真正押注的判断是这件事:互联网会从根本上改变人类。

埃隆在台上用了一个说法,这个说法后来被很多人引用,在 2013 年听起来仍然不算过时:

互联网让人类获得了一套神经系统。以前人们传递信息靠渗透,靠 osmosis。你想查资料,得去国会图书馆,而且只有你本人站在书架前,你才碰得到那些信息。有了互联网,你在世界上任何一个角落,只要连上线,全人类的信息都在你手边。人类正在变成一个超个体,而我们想参与搭建它的神经系统。(埃隆·马斯克)

问题在于,当时几乎没人知道互联网是什么。连硅谷的人都不知道。它属于大学和政府部门,普通公司不会在上面做任何事,更谈不上赚钱。

那个摔黄页的高管,是他们的重要客户之一。他真心认为互联网不可能取代那本厚厚的电话簿。

几年后,他成了 Zip2 的投资人。

一台电脑当服务器,晚上编程,睡办公室

1995 年公司刚起来的时候,他们只有一台电脑。白天这台机器跑网站服务器,晚上埃隆在上面写代码。

两个人睡在办公室。洗澡去 YMCA。因为办公室的月租比公寓便宜,租办公室然后住进去,是当时的算术题。

吃饭是最难的部分。帕洛阿尔托晚上十点以后基本没什么开着,剩下的选择里,Jack in the Box 是最稳定的一家。他们轮着点这家菜单上的不同东西。

金巴尔讲了一个凌晨三点的故事:他开车去 Jack in the Box,太困了,喝了一口奶昔,觉得味道不对,然后就那么睡过去了。

转机出现在 1995 年底。网景(Netscape)上市。哪怕还是没人搞懂互联网是什么,至少所有人都知道,互联网上能赚到钱,哪怕只是相信有一个更大的傻瓜会接盘。

1996 年初,他们再去见风投,气氛完全不同了。那一轮融资大概一个星期就关了,三百万美元。

讲到这里,金巴尔补了一句:那时候我们是非法移民,一辆车轮子会掉的破车。风投后来发现这件事,非但没撤资,还给了他们四万美元去买车。

埃隆花三万五买了一辆 1967 年的捷豹 E-Type。开回家的路上就抛锚了,最后是平板拖车把它拉回去的。金巴尔在台上说,应该留着那辆拖车。那辆捷豹后来也没好起来。

卖了三亿之后,一个人去纽约学做菜,一个人去俄罗斯买导弹

Zip2 做的事很具体:帮媒体公司上网。互联网出版软件,黄页,地图和路线。客户是纽约时报公司、奈特·里德报业集团,还有当时几乎所有的大媒体。

交易在 1998 年底谈定,1999 年初完成。斯科尔问他们那是什么感觉。

我像一条被关在笼子里打了四年的狗,突然有人把笼门打开,说所有的 T 骨牛排随便吃。(埃隆·马斯克)

他原本以为这家公司是要做一辈子的。突然有人给你一大笔钱,袋子很容易提,你走出去就行。整个过程非常不真实。

金巴尔去了纽约。他从小就是家里的厨子,在硅谷待够了。他进了纽约一所顶尖的烹饪学校,和世界上最出色的厨师一起做菜。

他毕业的时间点很特殊,就在 9·11 之前。他住在世贸中心后面。事件发生后,他在世贸遗址待了六个星期,给消防员做饭。

他说,他本来就喜欢做饭,但那六个星期里发生的事,让他第一次真正明白,食物可以把人和人连在一起。

后来他在科罗拉多州的博尔德开了 The Kitchen。原本的计划是每晚接待六十位客人,他当副业做,因为他还挂着特斯拉和 SpaceX 的董事。今天 The Kitchen 一周接待一万人,成了四家餐厅。

埃隆这边,卖掉 Zip2 的钱几乎全部投进了下一家公司 X.com,也就是后来的 PayPal。

斯科尔问他,把鸡蛋全放在一个篮子里,还建议其他创业者这么干吗。

埃隆的回答没有留余地:

我觉得应该把自己的钱投进去。我不相信用别人的钱做创业这回事。如果你不愿意拿自己的资产去赌,你就不该让别人来赌。(埃隆·马斯克)

2003 年帕洛阿尔托的一家咖啡馆,三件事

PayPal 卖给 eBay 之后不久,斯科尔在帕洛阿尔托的一家咖啡馆约埃隆喝咖啡,问他接下来想干什么。

埃隆给了三件事:太空,太阳能,电动车。

这三件事不是临时起意。他在大学时就列过一份清单,想清楚什么问题最有可能影响人类的未来。最后剩下三个领域:互联网;可持续能源,其中太阳能负责生产端,电动车负责消费端;人类成为多行星物种。

关于最后一条,他在台上说得很清楚,还专门做了一次澄清:

人类的未来,要么是成为太空文明,要么是被困在地球上,直到某次灭绝事件发生。我对地球上的生命相当乐观,我不认为灾难 imminent。文明在地球上延续很久的概率很高。但我仍然认为,我们应该把生命延伸到地球之外。要做的事是在火星上建立一个基地,并且尽快让它能够自给自足。(埃隆·马斯克)

他说 SpaceX 不可能单枪匹马完成这件事,但至少可以把太空运输的技术推进到某个程度:能够把一批人送上火星。这件事现在做不到。

前三次发射都炸了

斯科尔问了一个很直接的问题:SpaceX 前三次发射都失败,第四次成功了。如果第四次也失败了呢?

埃隆回答:那我们就完了。

金巴尔是 SpaceX 的早期投资人。他经常飞去夸贾林环礁看发射。那个地方在太平洋中间,离夏威夷两千英里。他形容坐直升机飞过去的感觉,像《现代启示录》里去 Dr. Evil 的岛。

我当时想,就算我投的这些钱只换来亲眼看这些火箭炸掉,每一分钱都值。(金巴尔·马斯克)

他说这话时是认真的。到今天他还是这么想。

斯科尔追问,那时候每一家公司都走到过一个临界点,往哪边走都有可能。埃隆接着讲了特斯拉的来历。

通用汽车压碎了 EV1,车主点了蜡烛

埃隆对电动车的兴趣从本科就开始了。他做物理,研究超级电容。他当初来加州,是为了在斯坦福读应用物理和材料科学的博士,方向就是超级电容和电动车。互联网把那件事搁置了几年。

PayPal 之后,他想回到这个领域。当时他并不觉得需要一家创业公司来做这件事,因为通用汽车已经推出了 EV1。按正常逻辑,通用会做 EV2、EV3,一代比一代好,创业公司没什么机会。

然后加州改了法规,不再强制要求电动车。通用召回了所有 EV1,为了确保没人能把它们弄回去,全部压碎,堆在一个废车场里。

压碎的过程中,那些不愿意交回车的车主,在废车场外面点起了蜡烛守夜。

几乎没有人会为一个产品点蜡烛守夜,尤其是一个通用汽车的产品。如果人们在这么干,你就该认真注意了。(埃隆·马斯克)

他说,这让他决定必须做一家电动车公司。

他同时承认,做这几家公司的时候,他并不觉得自己会成功。他认为最可能的结果是失败,但即使成功概率很低,这件事仍然值得做。

火星这件事,一开始只是一个温室

SpaceX 的起点并不是一家火箭公司。

埃隆最初想做的是一个很小的火星任务,一个慈善性质的项目:把一个温室送上火星,里面装种子和脱水凝胶。着陆之后给凝胶加水,种子发芽,你就能拍到一张照片,绿色的植物,红色的背景。

他的判断是,公众只对两样东西有反应:第一,和最。

这个温室会是火星上的第一个生命,是生命旅行过的最远距离。那张绿色植物配红色背景的照片,会是一张极好的"金钱镜头"。

他当时对这个项目的预期回报是零。钱花出去,事情可能成不了,就这样。

真正做这个任务的过程中,他发现自己的假设错了。

他原本以为火星上没有人的原因是意志问题:如果能把公众的热情重新点燃,让大家去呼吁、去投票、去要求增加预算,事情就能推进。所以他最初的太空计划,本质上是一场公关行动。

做下去之后他发现,卫星、航天器、温室、通信的成本都能压下来,唯独火箭的价钱压不动。

他飞了三次俄罗斯,想买洲际弹道导弹。第三次去的时候是 2001 到 2002 年之间,他谈成了一个价格。

回来之后他想明白了一件事:如果火箭运输本身还有根本性的技术障碍,那么再成功的公关也解决不了问题。

问题不在意志,在路径。

如果人们相信有一条路可以走通,并且这条路不会实质性地影响他们的生活水平,他们就会支持这件事。美国尤其如此,这个国家本身就是探险精神的蒸馏物,人们从别的地方来到这里。

那种探险精神其实非常强。但人们需要知道这件事是可能的,需要在不动摇自己生活水平的前提下是可能的。(埃隆·马斯克)

鸡肝酱和一场车祸

金巴尔在博尔德的餐厅,做本地农场到餐桌的事,那时候 farm to table 这个词还没流行起来。他一直把餐厅当成社区的一部分。

他们做的事包括把学校里的孩子带进餐厅。给孩子吃鸡肝酱,不告诉他们是什么,他们都吃得很开心。等你说出这是什么,他们立刻吐出来。金巴尔讲这件事的时候笑得很开心。

后来他出了一次很严重的车祸,脖子骨折,左半边身体瘫痪,平躺了两个月。

那两个月让他重新排了一遍优先级。他要回到对社会有实际影响的事情上。他认识很多慈善家,也很尊重他们,但他需要一个自己看得懂、能亲眼看到效果的方式。

他在学校菜园上和孩子们打了多年交道,于是有了后来的想法。

菜园不放在角落,放在游乐场正中间

这个项目叫学习菜园(Learning Garden),隶属于他创办的非营利组织 Kitchen Community。

它和传统学校菜园的区别在位置上。传统菜园在校园一角,围一圈栅栏。学习菜园建在操场上,建在孩子们每天都会经过、每天都会玩的地方,几百个孩子天天看得见。

材料用的是和游乐设施一样的材料,能用几十年,不是那种一两年就散架的东西。设计成模块化,能适配任何校园:屋顶、沥青地都行。很多城市的土壤有毒,你就算想在那里种菜也种不了。

所有材料通过 FDA 认证,专门用于种植食物。

金巴尔说自己不是园丁,这一点他说得很直接。他做的是另一件事:把在制造业、运营、甚至政治上学到的东西用上,解决规模化的问题。

数据是他最在意的东西。

学校里有学习菜园的孩子,蔬菜摄入量翻倍,从每天两份半涨到五份。同一堂科学课,在菜园里上和教室里上,考试成绩差十五分,满分一百分。

这个项目的难点从来不是"学校菜园有没有用",那已经被证明了。难点是怎么规模化,怎么在几年内铺到十万所学校。

儿童肥胖是今天的问题,不是明天的问题。贫困社区有百分之二十的孩子,进幼儿园的时候就已经肥胖。更糟的是,这些孩子同时也在挨饿。给他们的食物有热量,没有营养。金巴尔的原话是,我们在制造一批昂贵又没有生产力的人。

节奏是这样的:两年前做了 1 所,去年 50 所,今年大约 200 所,明年希望 1000 所,之后是上万所。技术能力和产能都有了,缺的是政治意愿。

他当场对着台下的学区负责人喊话:去 thekitchencommunity.org 看看。

太阳是天上那个巨大的聚变反应堆

SolarCity 是埃隆的两个表兄弟林登·里夫(Lyndon Rive)和彼得·里夫(Peter Rive)创办的。他们之前做过一家叫 EverDream 的公司,做计算机和电子资产的大规模管理,卖给了戴尔。

这家公司的起点在火人节(Burning Man)。表兄弟在聊接下来做什么,埃隆说太阳能行业需要好的创业者,如果他们愿意做,他全力支持。他们接受了。

埃隆对 SolarCity 的定位是一个分布式公用事业公司。现在规模还小,将来会很大。能源来源是天上那个巨大的聚变反应堆。

这个星球其实几乎完全是太阳能驱动的。没有太阳,我们会是一个三开尔文的冰球。太阳驱动着整个降水系统和生态系统。人类文明用的那点电,相对真正照到地球上的能量,其实非常少。(埃隆·马斯克)

SolarCity 在 2012 年 12 月上市。埃隆说那次 IPO 相当难,最后撑过去了。

南非种族隔离、互联网泡沫、9·11,和博尔德

有观众问,是什么特质、技能或者环境,让你们走到今天。

金巴尔的回答是一串地点。他在南非长大,赶上种族隔离制度崩溃,那是一段非常难的时期。他去了加州,赶上互联网兴起,兴奋但也难。他在纽约,赶上 9·11。现在他住在博尔德这个小镇上,等着下一件大事发生。

他说这些经历给他留下的东西,是一种持续性的偏执。他知道这个词听起来不太好,但那种"总觉得有很强烈的事情要发生"的状态,让他一直保持警觉,一直往前走。

埃隆的答案简单得多:坚持,以及极度专注于真相,从多个来源找反馈。

斯科尔补充了一点:两个人都极度注重细节,体验里没有任何一小块是他们不管的。

斯科尔问埃隆,人们把他比作亨利·福特、理查德·布兰森、史蒂夫·乔布斯,他自己跟谁比。

埃隆说他谁也不比。他佩服历史上的一些人,很多科学家、工程师、文学家。他特别提到本杰明·富兰克林,科学家,也是思想家,那种什么该做就去做什么的人。

金巴尔说是丘吉尔和乔布斯。他给出的理由和头衔无关:

这两个人把热情放进了工作里。工作不是关于上班,是关于创造,关于让社会变得不一样。这是我在我哥哥身上一直看到的东西。(金巴尔·马斯克)

斯科尔讲了他自己的观察:那些一开始就奔着赚钱去创业的人,几乎无一例外都失败了。真正做成的,是那些一开始就有个梦想、有件在乎的事的人,钱是顺带来的。

他引了朋友比尔·李(Bill Lee)的一句话,这句话大概是整场对谈里最值得抄下来的一句:

从零开始做一家公司,就像嚼着玻璃,同时凝视深渊。(比尔·李)

所以结论是,如果你不喜欢你的玻璃三明治,你的人生会非常痛苦。不管做什么,只要它想做出点改变,都会极其困难,那你最好是真的喜欢它。

影响力投资这件事,两个人都没有给出漂亮答案

有观众问金巴尔,影响力投资在解决全球重大问题上扮演什么角色。

金巴尔的回答是,他一周前刚跟一位重要的社会投资人聊过这件事,他自己也很挣扎。

他的逻辑是:你赚的钱越多,能拿去做慈善的钱就越多。这两件事可以分开做。一个华尔街的人可以专心赚钱,到了一定程度之后把所有精力放在慈善上,这对世界的贡献很大。但如果要求投资本身既要社会效益又要财务回报,成功会变得很难,而成功本身就是件很重要的事。

他说自己相信把问题隔离出来:专注在成功上,把事做成。放在投资上,就是在合理范围内追求最高回报。至于社会投资,他觉得这是个很难跑通的领域。

他还吐槽了非营利领域的评价体系:没有统一的尺子,你自己给自己打分。营利世界里有利润,非营利世界里这件事很怪。这是他第一次做非营利,他也在边做边学。

埃隆的回答更彻底:

如果一个问题是可以用一家赚钱的公司解决的,那就应该用公司去解决,这是最好的方式。只有在市场失灵的地方,才需要非营利组织。市场失灵确实存在,但没有大家想的那么多。(埃隆·马斯克)

金巴尔在这里插了一句,信息量不小:他是这家非营利组织最大的捐款人,埃隆。

2013 年的马斯克,和 Zip2 时期的马斯克

斯科尔问,2013 年的埃隆和 Zip2 时期的埃隆,差在哪里。

埃隆说,中间隔着很多苏格兰威士忌。然后给了一个具体的答案:

我过去做过几个招聘决定,看重脑子多过看重心。这是个错误。一个人是不是好人,这件事本身就有意义,不只是道德层面的意义。(埃隆·马斯克)

金巴尔的答案是:他现在对自己舒服多了,也更能说不。

以前只要有摆在面前的机会,钱景不错,他就会答应,然后卷进一堆自己并不真正在乎的事里。现在他知道拒绝。他说自己还有很多要学。

95 岁去火星

最后一个问题:你们会一起去火星吗?

会吧。等到我们 95 岁的时候,还能干点别的什么?(金巴尔·马斯克)

埃隆补了一句他重复过很多次的话,说完台下笑成一片:

我想死在火星上,只是不要是撞击那一刻。(埃隆·马斯克)

整场对谈里,兄弟俩讲的都是很具体的事:一本被摔在桌上的黄页,一台白天当服务器晚上用来写代码的电脑,一辆开回家路上就抛锚的捷豹,一枚本该装上种子和凝胶的温室,一所两年前才建起来的第一块菜园。这些细节加起来,比任何宏大叙事都更能说明他们是怎么走到今天的。

可以今天就用的几件事

  • 判断一个新产品有没有真实需求,别只看问卷。看有没有人愿意为旧产品点蜡烛守夜。通用的 EV1 被压碎的时候,车主在废车场外面点了蜡烛,这个信号比任何市场调研都强。
  • 创业先投自己的钱。埃隆的原话是,你不愿意押上自己的资产,就不该让别人押。这条标准可以反过来用:如果你正在评估一个创业者,看他自己投了多少。
  • 招人别只看脑子。这是埃隆自己复盘出来的错误。脑子决定这个人能不能把事做成,心决定他把事做成之后公司会变成什么样。
  • 事情推不动的时候,先分清是意志问题还是路径问题。埃隆原本以为火星计划卡在公众不够热情,飞了三趟俄罗斯之后才发现,卡在火箭太贵。搞错归因,钱和时间都会白花。
  • 如果一个社会问题能用赚钱的公司解决,就别急着办非营利。市场失灵的地方比大家想象的少,非营利的评价体系也比营利世界模糊得多。
  • 做那件你愿意嚼玻璃的事。斯科尔引的那句话值得贴在墙上:从零开始创业就像嚼着玻璃凝视深渊。既然做什么都这么难,就选一件你真的在乎的。
  • 学会说不。金巴尔说这是他这些年学到的最值钱的东西。摆在面前的机会如果钱景好但不是你想做的,拒绝它。
  • 如果你在办学区或者带孩子,去看一眼 thekitchencommunity.org 的设计方案。把菜园从校园角落搬到操场正中间,用游乐设施的材料,模块化适配屋顶和沥青地,这些是可以直接抄的做法。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:01their accomplishments are a study in opposites out of this world down to earth High-Tech high touch but while Elon and Kimble musk's means May differ their end is the same to push Humanity forward to greener pastures and Beyond they were born and raised in South Africa but Elon came to America First earning undergraduate degrees in both business and physics before briefly attending Sanford in 1995 my brother was in Canada at the time and I said look I think we should try to create an internet company so he came down and joined me Elon was more the the business Mastermind I was more the sales guy their first Venture zip 2 sold to compact in 1999 Kimble was an early investor in

0:49elon's next company which would eventually become PayPal and sell to eBay in 2002 in the Years following Kimble pursued the culinary arts eventually Landing in Colorado I'm one of the founders of the kitchen which is a restaurant in Boulder Colorado it's a nationally recognized restaurant while Kimble was pioneering local Farm totable cuisine at what would become a family of four renowned restaurants brother Elon was charting a different course when I was in in University I thought about what what are the problems that are most likely to affect the future of the world in 2002 Elon founded space exploration Technologies SpaceX continues America's

1:27mission to resupply the international Space Station from us soil I'm talking about sending ultimately tens of thousands eventually millions of people to Mars and then going out there and exploring the stars in 2003 he founded Tesla Motors to build all electric cars so we had a $100,000 sports car which was the Roadster then we've got the model S which starts at around $50,000 and our third generation car which will hopefully be at in about 3 or 4 years will be a $30,000 car the winner by unanimous decision tells a Model S in 2006 he became chairman of Solar City the largest fullservice provider of solar power in the country meanwhile Kimble while also serving on the boards

2:11of SpaceX and Tesla found another cause obesity is the epidemic of our day so I created a nonprofit called the kitchen community and what we do is we help put Learning Gardens in schools around the country to fight childhood obesity and to improve test scores when you teach kids in the garden you can increase scores by over 15 points on 100 point scale restur literally means restorers let's energize and connect our community let's do it with kids let's do it with real food with their unique forms of disruptive innovation the musk brothers are creating the future while holding fast to the ideals of family teamwork and service that got Humanity this far

2:52in the first place pretty amazing you you you think their mom's proud so leading the conversation with Alon and Jeff Alan and Kimble is is Jeff skull as you as you all know Jeff is one of the planet's true Visionary leaders in a number of fields as a business innovator he was the first full-time employee of eBay and he led the company's emergence into a transformative trading platform The democratized Economic Opportunity throughout the world in 1999 Jeff founded the skull Foundation which quickly became the world's largest foundation for social entrepreneurship and in 2004 he founded participant media with the belief that a well- told story

3:46has the power to inspire change Jeff has been the executive producer now on over 39 films which have garnered five Oscars and 35 nominations in 2009 Jeff founded the skull Global threats fund with a focus on the five issues that if unchecked could endanger the future of our planet his many awards in include Time magazine's 100 most influential people business week's 50 most generous philanthropists and the John W Gardner leadership award we're honored and delighted truly delighted to welcome Jeff skull and his conversation with Lon and Kimble Musk thanks very [Applause]

4:44much thank you very much Paul for the the very generous introduction my name is Jeff skull and I'm delighted to be here with my good friends Elon and Kimo musk in fact we're in for a treat I'm I'm not I'm usually the one that gets asked the question so this is is a chance for me to put the shoe on the other foot and it's also the first time Elon and Kimble have been on a panel together I first met Elon in

5:161995 when he was dating a classmate of mine not long after that I I dated the same girl and and I realized then that Elon always likes to be first [Laughter] I've known Kimble for about a decade Kimble runs four restaurants in Colorado and he's invested heavily in Learning Gardens which I hope he'll talk about at length tonight Elon is the CEO of both Tesla Motors and SpaceX and he's the chairman of Solar City but the first question for both of you what what do you admire about each other oh I I do it first so I I you know knows this

6:05but the the advantage of being his younger brother is is I kind of used to get what he wanted and he wanted a lot of stuff and so the one time I remember we we we he wanted motorbikes I was too young well I was he was seven I think and I was six or something like that which in this country it's not very common to get motorbikes but one of the one of the great things I admire about Elon is when he when he wants something he really wants it and he goes and gets it and it's amazing to watch him do that as his as his brother and and he's done it throughout his life interesting well I think Kimble is just one of the the the the nicest people I I know in the world i' I've

6:46never in all all my life seen Kimble intentionally do a mean thing so I admire that a great deal the the the two of you as I understand it I mean entrepreneurs are interesting because they often get started at a young age doing entrepreneurial ventures of some kind and I understand that when you were still in South Africa you had a a venture of some kind yeah the the video arcade yeah the yeah we This brilliant idea to start a video arcade because we really knew what games were popular yeah and also we were very experts at 14 and 15 and the reason we had to stop was because we went to the city to get a a code variance and you need to be 18 to

7:40sign and we had never told our parents and we already had a lease we had games coming and now when the parents found out they put a stop to it which is a real bummer because it would have been very successful [Laughter] yeah well I'm glad that wasn't the the the final barrier to success but you you that that was the first time that you worked together as brothers and eventually that led to a company called zip 2 I I I wonder if you wouldn't mind talking about zip 2 how did it come about what was the idea what was the what was the whole process like for you sure well and Kimble do you want to do you want to start off or should I well I mean I would start

8:30with the road trip the road trip yeah yeah okay so a year before this is 94 we took Elon was working at some video game company in there's a theme here what yeah I was actually working I was doing two jobs one was at a video company a video game company that was ironically called rocket science and and then working on Ultra Ultra capacitors during the day for electric cars and so we went on a road trip from Silicon Valley to Philadelphia and it was in ' 94 and we were both I'm younger than Elon but we were both finishing school at the same time because I'm much smarter than him

9:14Elon actually was doing a double major so that's why but anyway so we ended up doing that and the we went we started with a medical Network medical database remember that yeah there a bunch of iterations but I think the the the the thought in '95 was that the internet was going to be something really that fundamentally changed Humanity it was like Humanity acquiring a nervous system you know previously people would

9:47communicate information almost by osmosis relative to how the internet works you know if you wanted to have access to a lot of information like you go to like the Library of Congress but unless you're physically where the books were you you didn't have access to that information but with the internet you could be anywhere in the world and if you connected to the internet you have access to all the world's information so it was really just like the humanity was almost becoming like a super organism with a nervous system so we want to be part of you know building some elements of that and it was a funny time because it made so much sense to us but we had literally had a

10:24guy throw us throw a Yellow Pages book at us he was a very senior executive and tell us do you ever really think the internet is going to replace this yeah and literally and you're kind of looking at them going this guy's screwed yeah yeah he didn't and people didn't know what the internet was yeah including in Silicon Valley yeah yeah there was like something that universities and like the government used and nobody was really doing anything on it and you certainly couldn't make money yeah yeah did did you know that you were on to something right away or did people just think you were crazy and pursuing some bizarre

11:09dream when when did it occur to you that zip 2 might be a success well I mean when we first started out I think our Ambitions were really quite quite low it was really to make enough money to pay the rent yeah we we we got a VC give us money that was yay we thought it was all over then yeah it was pretty crazy I mean when we started out at 95 we we literally at the beginning we had one computer which would be the web server during the day and and then at night I'd program on it and and we'd sleep in the office we couldn't afford to to yeah anart it was cheaper to rent the office than to rent an apartment so we just rented the office and stepped in the office and

11:58show at the Y YMCA and for me the worst part was eating a Jack In The Box three times a yeah man this this like sleep to get food at paloalto after like 10: p.m. it's like Jack In The Box and a few other options we rotated through the Jack in the Box menu I remember the one time I was literally at Jack In The Box hopefully you guys aren't whoever's from the companies are here and it was it was one of those like 3 in the morning things and it was I took a milkshake and I was so tired and it was something in the milkshake and I Lear like this

12:32yeah that's your standard just dropped to to nothing yeah so so yeah in through through the end of 95 we that's essentially we're just sleeping in the office and Ching at the YMCA and then and around the end of 95 is when net skate went public and and then whether or not somebody knew what the internet was they knew that you could make money on the internet somehow or even if it's only on the greater fool Theory so when we went and talked to VCH capitalist in early '96 there was a much greater interest in what we were doing in fact the round closed in like maybe a week or something it crazy yeah we went from sleeping in the office to people throwing I mean again this is

13:16a financial crowd so you guys see these numbers every day but for us to hear we'll give you $3 million yeah that sound extremely we thought they were crazy like why would they do that it was literally like these people are insane they obviously do not realize we're sleeping in the office in fact when they when they did fund us they they realized that we were illegal immigrants well I mean yes we were I'd say it was a great area yes yes we were I was we were illegal immigrants we were sleeping in the office we didn't have a car we had one car with the wheel kept falling off well actually yeah the the the wheel did actually fall off the car yes exactly and the and the

13:53venture capitalist actually bought us cars yeah well they they gave us 40 Grand it was 40 Grand to go buy cars which was at the time was more money than we ever seen yeah and and I bought a a I spent 35k on a series 1 67 Jager e type which didn't drive but but he got what he wanted yeah it looked really great by the side of the road he he got it he was driving it home from the dealer and it and it broke down and he had to actually come to the house with on a flatbed truck right it didn't and it didn't improve from there I mean it was really BR should have kept the truck yeah it it it reminds me in some ways of you know eBay went public 1998 and we

14:41had kind of the scrappy startup mentality as well and the first time I ever saw Elon on on TV was when you took delivery of McLaren Supercar that's right so yeah right so so presumably somewhere between sleeping on the floor of the office and the McLaren something happened yeah yeah so at sub2 we basically created software to help bring the media companies online so we it was sort of Internet publishing software it was Yellow Pages y Pages maps and directions that kind of thing and and we helped bring some of the major media companies online or at least a portion of what their online presence was and so we had his customers and investors New York Times company night Ritter host

15:35and most of the major media companies and then in fact the guy that threw the telephone book at us eventually became an investor yeah right and then the company sold to compact for a little over 300 million yeah Circa 1999 late late 90s yeah that's right it was yeah think the deal was sort of struck late 98s and then it concluded early 99 and so so then what happens to you guys I mean at that point you're 23 24 years old give or take and you you've gone from being barely able to pay the rent to having substantial resources how how did that influence your paths in what you did next the way I I like to think about it is I was like a dog in a cage getting

16:24beaten for four years and then they let me out and he all the T-Bones you can eat so it was a very weird experience actually because you don't think I I thought I was building that company for life and then boom they you know they give you lots and lots of money and easy to carry bags and you can leave it was totally surreal and and what did you do so I went to New York so I I I was done with Silicon Valley I think technology is is my brother's thing he loves it and I I enjoy it too but but honestly for me food is what I've always been passionate since I was kid I was the cook in the family and it's ironic he's much thinner than I am you know it's true I can eat anything

17:05although I'm finding out as you get older it doesn't work out that way yeah but no so I went to New York and I learned to cook I went to the you know I was young and I I figured you know what what else do you do when you have enough financial resources to do whatever you want and I always wanted to learn to cook so I enrolled in at a cooking school is one of the top schools in the country in New York City and had this incredible experience of cooking with some of the best most talented chefs in the world and it was a unique circumstance for me personally because I was there in New York during 911 and and I graduated from cooking school just before 911 and I lived right

17:45behind the World Trade Center so I saw the everything happened it was a very big event in my life but what the rare opportunity it gave me was the opportunity to cook for the firefighters so I spent six weeks weeks at Ground Zero cooking for the firefighters and that's when I kind of my I always loved food but my passion for community and connecting people to to each other through food was just an I mean I literally couldn't even describe how incredible this experience was and so I came out of that with a very strong intention to to start a restaurant and having been part of a company that just sold for 300 million and investing in PayPal which at the time is worth

18:27millions of dollars doing a restaurant was a weird decision but for me it was the right decision so for you it unlocked a path to dreams that maybe you had beforehand or just opportunistically you just said this is what I want to do and and you you still not only run the the the restaurant you began but there's more to it yeah well you mean the nonprofit or do you mean no I mean just in terms of there are more than one restaurant oh sure so you know I I turns out I'm actually pretty good at cooking I didn't I didn't really know I was good at cooking but but when I opened the restaurant with I had two partners Hugo and Jen open the restaurant we were

19:11supposed to do 60 people a night and it was just going to be the slide project for me because I was still involved in elon's companies Tesla and SpaceX and you know today we serve 10,000 people a week you know and it's just just continues to grow Elon for you ZIP 2 happened you sold it and it and

19:37bought the McLaren yeah and if I'm not mistaken you you invested most of that money into your next your next venture x.com that's right so yeah most the most of the funds went into x.com which was later renamed PayPal and yeah and that worked out pretty well it worked out pretty well but looking looking back on it would because you put a lot of your eggs in in that basket would you would you advise entrepreneurs to roll the bones quite the way you do yeah absolutely I think so I think I think I think it's worth investing your own capital in what you do I I don't believe in the sort of other people's money thing you know I think if you not willing to put your own

20:30assets at stake then you shouldn't ask other people to do to do that so eBay comes along buys PayPal and then I I I remember 2003 give or take meeting Elon at a at a coffee shop in paloalto this was not long after the PayPal deal had closed and I said to Elon on what would you like to do next and and you had three things to say right do you remember what they were well

21:09yeah but yeah I mean there basically you know space solar and electric cars space solar and electric cars yes two points yeah wait Space Electric cross what was the middle one well so I asked Elon what he wanted to do and he he said he wanted to do something in solar power he wanted to colonize Mars

21:38eventually but to but to get there by building a rocket business a sustainable business and and building electric cars and let's talk a little bit about about Mars so where did where did this come from when when did you have that dream how' that come to be well I guess you know when I was in college that I thought about things that would most affect the future of humanity and and there were three areas that I thought would have the biggest impact and those were the internet sustainable energy of which solar power is the production side and electric cars the consumption side and then Humanity becoming a multiplet species I think our future will fundamentally

22:30bate to one where we are space spring civilization or one where we are confined to Earth until some eventual Extinction event although I'm quite optimistic about life on Earth I should point out I want to people think that that by that I expect some imminent catastrophe but I I think that the probable probable outcome for civilization is on Earth is is quite quite good for a long time but I still think that we should try to to extend life beyond Earth and have a and the thing to do is to establish a base on Mars and ultim and try to make that a self- sustaining base as soon as possible so I I don't expect that SpaceX is going to do that sort of

23:10single-handedly but I think we're we're going to try to advance the technology of space travel to the point where we can at least send some number of people to Mars which is not currently possible as I recall when followup question Jeff when when SpaceX started I think the first three rocket launches weren't successful and and and the fourth one was what would have happened if the fourth one hadn't worked we would have failed yeah but but let's talk about the one of the the failures were spectacular so I mean I so I would go out to the island quajon with and seeing giant exploding Rockets is quite an amazing site and I was one of the early investors in SpaceX and I

24:06said you know what if all I get to do is to see these rockets explode well worth every dime I put into this [Laughter] company there there's something to be said about brotherly support but it was an amazing thing to watch what Elon would had built with those rockets in I mean on a Sho string in the middle of nowhere and literally the middle of Pacific 2,000 miles from Hawaii and that exper we'd fly in these these what are they called the what are those helicopter huis you're flying the Hues you feel like you're right out of out of Apocalypse Now flying to Dr Evil's Island really amazing I mean and again with every penny still to this day I'd say so I think the failures were

25:03actually unbelievably exciting to be part of yeah yeah thank you Eli you're welcome I mean the the the the point the point being that these Ventures now seem to have a wonderful momentum and things are going well but I I remember well there was a point in time when when each of them had their their Tipping Point and could have gone either way I wonder I wonder if you could talk a little bit about the origins of Tesla sure so with the

25:41I as mentioned I was quite interested in electric cars from when I was doing my undergrad physics and in fact I originally came out to California to do PhD of Stanford and applied physics Material Science to work on Ultra capacitors and electric cars so it was a a long-standing interest of mine and and the internet kind of put that on hold for a few few years but then once after PayPal I decided I wanted to get back into electric vehicles and make something happen in that Arena particularly since GM had come out with the ev1 and and I thought okay well there's not really a need for a startup company to develop electric cars because obviously GM is going to create the ev2

26:25and the EV3 that's logical sequence and it get increasingly you get better and better with each iteration and so not really need for for for a new company in that Arena but but actually what happened was that after California changed the regulations to no longer require electric cars GM recalled all the ev1s and then just to make sure that nobody could get them back they crushed them in a in a in a lot somewhere and and in fact

26:56while they were being crushed the the the people who' been the ev1 owners who did not want those cards recalled actually held a candle at vigil as though somebody was getting executed basically and it's like that just seemed extremely crazy that GM would ignore this because you know it's quite rare for people to hold a candle at digital about a product and particularly at GM product [Applause] so so if if if people are doing that you should really pay attention but but they they they wanted to just sort of erase all that and so I thought okay well we got to try to create an electric car company but it wasn't as though in creating these companies that we thought

27:41that we would be successful I thought that the most likely outcome was failure but but it was still worth doing even though the the odds of success were low in fact even for for for SpaceX the originally what I started doing was not creating a rocket company but but actually was going to do a small Mission to Mars which was just a philanthropic mission where you would send a small green house with seeds and dehydrated gel and the would upon Landing hydrate the gel and you'd have this cool picture of green plants on a red background and the public tends to respond to precedents and superlative so this would be the first lap on Mars furthest the life have traveled and

28:21you'd have this great money shot of green plants on a red background so yeah I thought that would that would get people's attention so but but the expectation for that was was no return so I I thought we wouldn't get any you know just spend the money on that and it wouldn't wouldn't happen and it was in the process of trying to do that mission that I concluded that I'd made a mistake with respect to my assumptions about why why why why are there no people on Mars because I I started off thinking that it was because there was a lack of will and that if you could reignite the will then then it would happen so my initial thing with with even with the space side was was

29:07really to get the public excited and to to get people to essentially vote and ask her to have a bigger budget that was my goal initially and but as I try to do try to do that mission was able to compress the costs of the the satellite or the spacecraft and and the the greenhouse and everything and the communication costs but I wasn't able to compress the the rocket the rocket costs and I actually tried had some Adventures along the way trying to trying to get a good deal on Rockets I actually flew to Russia three times to try to buy a some

29:47icbms and I negotiated a deal too actually but after the third trip to to Russia which is it was very very strange because I was like there in 2001 2002 and I I thought well if if we do this well it's it's going to generate a lot of interest but if the if there's still a fundamental technology issue with rocket transport then it's not going to solve the problem so I decided that it was it was not a

30:21question of will it was a question of of way and if if people thought there was a way to do it without it fundamentally affecting their standard of living then they would support such an Endeavor particularly in the United States which United States is a is a nation of explorers I mean a distillation of the human Spirit of exploration people came here from other places and and so that I think that that that exploratory spirit is is actually very strong but people need to know that that it's possible this this can be done without materially affecting their Center of living so I mean what what you've accomplished is is amazing

30:59between linking up with the with the space station on launches and the model S winning carved the year and and and being just a phenomenon but a good yes so I mean it's it's amazing it's amazing and and we'll come back and talk about Solar City in a second but you you mentioned Gardens and I think that's a a natural segue we're surrounded by some beautiful Gardens here on stage and kimle I wonder if you might want to talk a little bit about about these sure so the restaurants that we do in Colorado are before Farm to Table was a turn we we' work with local farmers and bring local food to the tables and we really considered ourselves a community restaurant and one of the

31:47things we did as part of the community was to reach out to kids in the community in schools and get them connected to food through school Gardens and you know we'd bring them into the restaurant and we you know do everything from give them chicken liver pate without telling them what it was and they would you know thoroughly enjoy it and and then you tell them then they spit it out of their mouth and you know like fun things like that that we would we just did as a as a as a great way to connect into the community and then I I had a personal accident a very severe accident I was paralyzed my left and horizontal for two months after breaking my neck and just it really

32:25helped me focus on well let me go back to having more of an impact on society I know there's a lot of philanthropists in the crowd and I have a lot of respect for that but for me it was very much about how to can I give back but in a way that really I understood and and could could really see the see the impact and I'd been working with these School Gardens for many years and so I came up with this idea called The Learning Garden which you you see beautifully presented thank you very much Nancy for for for doing this and what we do is it's a nonprofit we go to schools around the the country and we install these Outdoor Learning environments that are School Gardens and

33:02they're very different to Traditional School Gardens the Traditional School Gardens being in the corner of the schoolyard with the fence around it these are designed to be in the schoolyard on the playground where the kids will see it every day the hundreds of kids will enjoy it and and and and play with every day and it's made out of the same material as playground equipment so it will last for decades unlike Traditional School Gardens which are very temporary we also came up with this idea to make it more modular so that you could fit it in any schoolyard rooftops asphalt there's a lot of toxic soil sadly in our cities where you literally couldn't put a

33:34garden there if you wanted to and these were all were designed to be FDA approved just for food for growing food and so what I did was really look at the problem based on the experience that I had working with Elon and working in whether it's manufacturing or operations or politics frankly which is is a very big political problem and you know what what value could I add and there are lots of great gardeners out there and I'll be first tell you I'm not a gardener but I but I really believed in the impact that these were having and and the data is amazing I mean we we see a doubling of vegetable intake when kids have a learning Garden on their schoolyard literally a doubling

34:15from Two and a half to five portions a day we see test Tesco particularly in science go up by 15 points on 100 point scale when they get taught the same science lesson in the learning G versus in the classroom this incredible impact on their lives and the challenge was not a question of school Gardens that had already been proven the challenge was how do you scale how do you get something that will reach a 100,000 schools within a few years because that's the problem we have childhood obesity is today's problem it is not tomorrow's problem 20% of underserved kids go are going into kindergarten obese it's an awful tragedy we have these poor children that that are not

34:57only obese but they're actually starving because the food we're giving them has no nutrients it has calories but no nutrients and it's just this awful awful situation a real tragedy that we' that we're creating and so for me what I wanted to do was how do I come in and say okay I know what I know I know what I think I can do well let me see what I can create that could actually go into a 100,000 schools within a few years and so so I created The Learning Garden with this idea to by the end of this decade to to reach every child that wants one or every school that wants one and we have that we have the capacity now what we need is the political will

35:33to to go do it and so we'll have about 200 installed this year and we started two years ago and we did One two years ago we did 50 last year we'll do about 200 this year hopefully a thousand next year and then many thousands after that Kim Kimble if people are interested in finding more about the Learning Gardens where would they go the kitchen community.org please go if you're a superintendent and I know there are some superintendent in this room because I had a some heated conversations with you guys earlier please go learn about it because there's no better way to teach kids about science which we all understand is a massive problem in this country getting

36:18our kids to love science is so important and childhood obesity is so important we need to fix this problem we are creating expensive unproductive people let's just stop that let's fix the problem let's fix it now absolutely I I I think we'll we'll talk a little bit about Solar City and then maybe open up to questions from the audience Solar City

36:49I mean your your family is a remarkable maybe you want to talk a little bit about how Solar City got going and your your role as chairman and and sure that so well so Sol city was founded by two cousins of ours lynon and Peter RI who were really great guys and before Sol City they did a company called everdream which did large scale management of computers and and other assets electronic assets which was sold to Dell and that did pretty well so

37:22and the Genesis of of Sol city was actually you know we Burning Man with our cousins and and and they they were thinking about what to do next and I said well I think there's a real need for for great entrepreneurs in the Solar industry and and I said if if if they were willing to start a solar power company then I would completely back them on that so they they took me up on the offer and created Solar City which I what Solar City is essentially is a giant distributed utility or it's I'd say right now it's a small distributed utility but it will be hopefully a giant distributed utility and and it's obviously one that's based on on the Sun that giant

38:12Fusion reactor in the sky so it's it's something that'll last for for a very long time I ultimately think that we will generate more energy from solar power than from any other source in fact it's worth noting that the the planet is already almost entirely solar powered in that we would be a frozen ice ball at 3 Kelvin if not for the sun and the sun Powers our whole system of precipitation and the the ecosystem so so really we're

38:46just talking about a little bit of extra power that Humanity uses for to to run civilization essentially but it's really quite a small amount relative to the amount that actually hits the Earth right and and Solar City went public a few months back yeah went public in in December it was quite a difficult IPO and were able to get

39:08it through and now it's doing doing reasonbly well well they're are amazing successes on on both your parts we're going to go to questions from the audience assuming these monitors work as as of the moment they're not and if not then I will oh I I see a monitor coming on here all right what what are the key traits skills or circumstances that have allowed you to be so successful I don't know why don't you answer for me or you what do you I'll that's a great idea so the I live in a small town in Colorado called Boulder and my my joke is I grew up in South Africa during the collapse of AP parite very very difficult time then I went to California during the rise of the

40:02internet exciting but difficult time and I was in New York City during 911 difficult time now I'm in this little small town of Boulder waiting for some serious to go down so I think those had very big impact on me and I think the the the impact personally is constant paranoia I guess maybe better I hate to say that not in a negative way but it's you're just kind of you know you're waiting for something really intense to happen all the time so I think that just keeps you on your toes and and keeps you moving forward yeah I think just a obvious being being tenacious and being well I I think just being super focused on on the truth is extremely important

40:52and looking for feedback from also sources I think those those are really key yeah yeah I I'd also add no knowing both of you is that you're very detail oriented there there's no small part of the experience that doesn't get attention from you so another question that I had you know Elon you've you've been compared to Henry Ford Richard Branson you know Steve Jobs who do you compare yourself to I I don't really compare myself to anyone I mean it's not I mean there's certain people that I admire from history that I think are you know I think are great so certainly many of the scientists and engineers and literary figures and so forth and like I'm I'm a big big

41:51fan of Ben Franklin you know who's a scientist and sort of thinker and he I mean he was kind of guys who who did did did what needed to be done you know so guys like that I right wouldn't say I compare myself in any way but I certainly admire them are are there people you you look up to I I think the the two that I look up to in my way I look the same thing as en know kind of look back I love Winston Churchill yeah he's cool he's the that guy I think is was one of the greatest gifts to mankind and I think Steve Jobs right yeah and I think the thing that that makes me like to these people is that they put their passion into their work and it's not

42:37about the job it's not about coming to work it's about creating making a difference in in your society and I think that that's what what I have always admired with my brother and with anyone else you know one one thing I've observed from my own entrepreneurial history is that people that start out

42:55bu building a company to make a lot of money almost invariably fail it's it's people that start out with with a a dream or something that they're passionate about and they care about and the money just kind of comes as as I I think if you think about it you can get money both ways but if we have a mutual friend of ours Bill Lee who has this phrase that doing starting a business from scratch is like chewing gloss and looking into the abyss it is really really hard and and if you don't like your glass sandwich you're going to have a miserable miserable life and so it's a very important lesson do what you're passionate about because no matter what

43:34you do if it's making a difference it's super hard to do it and so you better enjoy you better be passionate about it let's see if we have any other questions from from the audience yeah next next question please for Kimble what role and impact do you see impact investing in Social Ventures having and solving the world's major problems so I actually get this question asked to me a lot I was literally had this conversation with a major social investor a week ago u i really struggle with it to be honest I think the idea of obviously investing as a philanthropist I love I think that's really great but if you're looking for a financial return it is super hard to not

44:26have that as your key driver I get the idea of double bottom line or triple bottom line and I I live that life all day long but it's a personal decision of mine and I I really do struggle with the right answer because the more money you make the more difference you can make in philanthropy and you can separate the two and you can be quite impactful as a philanthropist if you're a finer on Wall Street you can choose to I me I'm sure once you reach a certain point everything you do will be for philanthropy after that and that makes a big difference in the world if you chose to invest in Social Ventures and get a smaller return I think you you struggle

45:04you actually success is very important and so I really believe in isolating the the problem focus on success getting it done and in the case of investing that means focusing on investing and getting the highest possible return within reason you know human rights and all that stuff but but social investing I think is a very difficult space to to to make work and actually

45:28maybe Jeff you should answer that question because you do that all the time yeah except I'm sitting in this chair well I I I I agree with you I I think you know so social investing has all the rigor and challenges of for-profit investing but added into that is the qualitative sometimes unmeasurable aspects of deal dealing with some sort of social change or or social good so one of the things I actually I mean on the nonprofit side I was specifically referring to for-profit social Adventures which but on the nonprofit side I get really frustrated because there is no measuring stick it's how are you doing you get to measure yourself that's you need to

46:15have you need to have some measuring some some common grounded measuring stick and in the in in the for-profit world you've got profit and in the nonprofit world it's very weird it's my first nonprofit so I'm I'm learning as I go I don't know what the answer is you Lear anything to add on that well I mean but I think

46:42generally anything that that if it's possible to solve a problem with a with a profitable Venture then it's that's the best thing to do so it's only when like the the some failure in the market and there are some but actually aren't that many but in the grand scheme things but there are some failures in the market that have to be addressed with with a with a nonprofit and but but generally I'd say or

47:06on the side of I mean I do have a small Foundation no no so as not as I against giving stuff I do elon's the biggest donor to the nonprofit yeah I mean yeah generally if there's a way to fix the market system that's the better way to do it but sometimes there isn't or the complications in doing it how how is the Elon of 2013 different from the Elon of the zip 2 days what have you learned we've learned I think well quite quite a lot a lot of scotch history between now between then and now

47:42I think you know I've mentioned this at at when I was gave my talk at sou by Southwest but I think the I I've made several hiring decisions in the past which where I valued intellect over heart and I I think that was a mistake and so try to try to adjust accordingly you know it actually matters whether somebody's a good person Beyond just you know goodness itself it right yeah Kim Kimble same question the Kimble of 2013 how are you different from the zip 2 days yeah those as I say as said that is a long time ago the I I would I

48:30would say I'm much more comfortable with myself I'm much more able to say no you know so if there's an opportunity in front of me that is very financially attractive or whatever and it's not what I want to do I just I know to say no and you know in the past I I I would always say yes and I would get involved in things that that weren't what I was passionate about so I think that's probably the most valuable thing I've learned I think I I still have a lot to learn so that's I think we have time for for one last question we got anything please

49:06wrap up in that case my last question is are are are are you are you guys going to go to Mars together we might I think we I mean when we're 95 what the hell else are we going to do yeah exactly I think that'll be fun I don't think I would want to go before that but well Elon has has a famous line

49:37about going to Mars right would you mind repeating it okay I mean so yeah I mean I think I would like to die on Mars but just not on [Laughter] impact all right I I I think on on that note I'd like to thank Elon and Kimble for a wonderful panel thank you to the [Applause] mil pretty extraordinary let's have one more time for Elana and Kimble and Jeff thank [Applause]

50:17you all right before before you all all leave we have a great late night show for you in the Beverly Hills Ballroom l Richie David Foster and Paul Anka I'm reliving my childhood and and a series of special guests so it's going to be a lot of fun Beverly Hills Ballroom right down the hall thank you so much can you put your hands in your head oh no I said Dre a Dre can you put your hands in your head oh no

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份