2020年5月30日,佛罗里达州肯尼迪航天中心。鲍勃·本肯(Bob Behnken)和道格·赫尔利(Doug Hurley)被绑在一枚猎鹰9号火箭顶端的龙飞船里,等待点火。距上一次美国宇航员从本土飞向太空,已经过去九年。航天飞机2011年退役之后,美国只能花大价钱买俄罗斯联盟号的船票。
发射成功那一刻,控制大厅里有人在哭,有人在笑。几个小时后,NASA局长吉姆·布里登斯廷(Jim Bridenstine)、SpaceX总裁格温·肖特维尔(Gwynne Shotwell)、NASA商业乘员项目经理凯西·卢德斯(Kathy Lueders)和埃隆·马斯克坐在发布会现场,面对记者。
这场发布会里,马斯克两次被问到差点说不出话。一次是回答“你答应过两个小男孩把他们爸爸带回家”,一次是回答“你想对当年怀疑你的人说什么”。
把整段问答拆开来看,信息量比“发射成功”四个字大得多。它讲清楚了四件事:一家私营公司怎么被逼到悬崖边上又爬回来;NASA和承包商的关系发生了什么样的结构性变化;把人送上去和把人接回来,风险完全不在一个量级;以及马斯克对星舰和火星的真实时间表。
“蹦床在正常工作”:一句嘲讽等了六年
发布会进行到一半,有记者问布里登斯廷,俄罗斯同行有没有联系你。
他说俄罗斯航天集团总裁德米特里·罗戈津(Dmitry Rogozin)没有直接通话,但公开发表了祝贺,还说了一句“这就像开着一台iPhone”。布里登斯廷补了一句,他自己以前也说过类似的话。
然后现场有人接了一句:“蹦床在正常工作。”(the trampoline is working)
这句话背后有一段旧账。2014年克里米亚事件之后,美国对俄罗斯实施制裁,罗戈津在推特上嘲讽:既然美国制裁俄罗斯航天工业,那美国宇航员以后恐怕得“用蹦床”去国际空间站了。当时美国确实没有自己的载人飞船,只能继续买联盟号的座位。这个嘲讽被美国航天圈记了很多年。
六年之后,一台私人公司造的飞船从卡纳维拉尔角升空。蹦床这个梗,是从SpaceX自己嘴里说出来的。
马斯克后来在推特上把这句话原样发了出去。这种回击方式很有意思:没有愤怒,也没有长篇反驳,他把对方当年的刻薄话当成笑话讲回来。嘲讽本身没变,说话的人换了位置。
被问到宇航员的孩子,他卡住了
《泰晤士报》的记者问马斯克:你上周说,你告诉鲍勃和道格的两个小儿子,你会尽一切努力把他们的爸爸安全带回家。现在发射成功了,任务还没完。记者追问的是,抛开SpaceX老板这个身份,作为一个父亲,这份责任感是什么滋味。
马斯克的回答是断的。
“当你见到别人的孩子,然后你意识到,他们负责的那台飞行器上,人命关天。这个真的很扎心。我们还得对接空间站,还得把飞船带回来。某种意义上,返回比上升更危险。所以现在还不能宣布胜利。我们会尽一切努力把风险降到最低……抱歉,我有点说不下去了。”
他确实停了几秒。原话是“I'm getting choked up here,sorry”。
这段之所以重要,是因为它给出了一个判断:最危险的环节在返回,上升阶段还没有到最凶险的那一步。他已经用Demo-1无人飞行验证过再入,退掉了一部分风险,但载人返回是第一次。所以整个发布会,包括布里登斯廷在内,反复强调同一句话:现在还不能庆祝,等他们落地再说。
这个态度贯穿全场。局长说了两遍“我们还没有在庆祝”。
十八年里两次差点死掉
《商业内幕》的记者问得直接:你为这一刻干了18年,一路上遇到的阻力不少,甚至一开始NASA内部也有人怀疑你。你想对当年那些怀疑者说什么?
马斯克说了一句很坦率的话:“我当年也怀疑我们自己。”
“我一开始觉得,SpaceX能进轨道的机会大概只有百分之十。所以那些怀疑我们的人,我当时的想法是:你们大概是对的。”
他讲了2008年。那一年他把PayPal赚到的钱全部投进SpaceX和特斯拉,两家公司都到了破产边缘。猎鹰1号前三次发射全部失败,第四次是最后的钱。
“那四次发射的钱,就只够第四次。而且就算第四次成功,也不足以救公司。我们还必须拿下NASA的国际空间站商业货运合同。那两件事,是2008年底救活SpaceX的关键。”
他还讲了一个行业笑话:怎么在火箭行业发小财?答案是先发大财。他说这笑话他听了不下一万两千遍,结果差点变成现实。
这段话的价值不在励志。它说明了一个结构性问题:航天这种行业,几乎没有给试错留出容错空间。一家公司如果只有一次发射的钱,那它的“技术路线”其实就是“不许出错”。SpaceX后来能反复迭代,前提是先把商业货运合同拿到手,有了稳定现金流,才有资格谈失败多少次。
八个月前那条推特:“该交付了”
Ars Technica的记者把话头转向布里登斯廷:八个多月前你发推特说,SpaceX该交付了。现在你觉得他们交付了吗?
这里需要补一点背景。2019年,SpaceX的载人龙飞船在地面静态点火测试中发生爆炸,飞船全毁。同一时期,降落伞测试也一再出问题。NASA内部对进度非常不满,布里登斯廷公开施压。
八个月后,布里登斯廷在发布会上说:
“埃隆·马斯克和SpaceX交付了NASA要求他们交付的一切,而且是以我们完全没想到的速度。我的工程团队当时说,这个时间表不可能实现。要完成那么多次降落伞测试,光测试本身要花多久?结果我们全做完了。”
他还提到一项具体工作:更换爆炸事故中出问题的钛合金止回阀(check valve),换完之后再做一轮完整测试。这些都是消耗时间的硬活,没有捷径。
格温·肖特维尔补充的角度更实在:
“我们遇到过不少问题。我们一个一个解决。SpaceX团队和NASA团队是一起把问题啃下来的。如果没有SpaceX的人这么快把东西做出来,今天我们不会站在这里。”
这段话透露的是协作方式的变化。传统模式下,NASA写需求,承包商交付,出问题走流程。这次是两个团队混在一起排查,分享数据,共同判断。
发射当天唯一的异常:一个传感器
有记者问,直播里听说某个部件温度比预期低,今天有没有意外。
凯西·卢德斯的回答很具体。她说整个倒计时“安静得有点不寻常”,唯一值得说的事,是一个传感器读数不正常。而且这个现象在周三第一次尝试发射、卸载推进剂的时候就已经出现过。
关键是处理方式。他们去搞清楚这个传感器为什么这么读数、它的位置在哪、如果真的失效会发生什么。最后确认它位于加注/排放阀的下游,数据可以解释,于是判定可以继续发射。
卢德斯说,这次任务真正的收获之一,是学会了怎么“读懂飞行器想告诉你什么”:拿到一个异常数据,理解它、验证它、然后放行,整个过程在很短时间内完成。这需要两个团队长期磨合,才能做到。
这件事听起来技术细节很重,但它其实回答了“为什么这次能按时发射”。当天确实出了异常,区别在于团队能快速判断这个异常要不要紧,然后放手发射。
烧掉一艘飞船换来的信心
有记者问卢德斯:8月30日或者9月初的首次正式任务(Crew-1),你有信心吗?
她给了一个具体的进度证据:前一天晚上收到邮件,“Crew-1的飞船已经进入推进系统检查阶段”,正在验证管路密封性和关键操作。也就是说,下一艘船已经在流水线上了。
然后她讲了这次Demo-2要验证的东西,按顺序排:
- 飞船和宇航员作为一个整体系统,怎么协同工作
- 接近空间站时的导航和对接
- 对接之后长时间停靠、和空间站联合运行(这是SpaceX第一次做长周期任务)
- 返回时的再入和溅落
她特别提到2020年3月那次无人Demo-1的价值:对接系统的大部分环节已经在无人状态下验证过。但“太空飞行总会教你点新东西”,尤其是这次船上有人,人和机器构成一个系统,变量完全不同。
柯克(Kirk,NASA飞行任务负责人)补充了对接当天的具体流程:道格会手动驾驶飞船做一次近场演示,鲍勃在旁边监控;空间站上的克里斯·卡西迪(Chris Cassidy)同时监控;然后自动对接、均压、查漏、开舱。他说他跟卢德斯保证了明天天气好,虽然有太阳耀斑,但预计不影响操作。
有个细节需要单独说:手动飞行是任务清单上必须打勾的科目,它本身就属于测试内容,后备手段只是附带作用。记者问,宇航员能不能选择手动对接?马斯克的回答是,计划是自动交会对接,但如果需要,他们可以手动接管。手动飞行的目的,是采集人在回路里的操作数据,为后续任务积累经验。
“我们叫他们Dads”
《大西洋月刊》的记者问了一个技术问题:鲍勃和道格是想手动对接,还是允许他们只有在紧急情况下才接管?
马斯克先答了自动对接的安排。布里登斯廷接着把话题引到了别处,讲了一段这场发布会里最有温度的话。
“鲍勃和道格一直挂在埃隆心上,整个SpaceX都在操心这件事,他把这种文化贯穿了全公司。我们做过一次SpaceX安全文化评估,结论非常强。从流水线工人到最高层,每个人都知道这里押着什么。”
然后他说了一句现场所有人都笑的话:
“在SpaceX,你们不叫他们鲍勃和道格,你们叫他们Dads(爸爸们)。因为他们的确是爸爸。把他们的安全放在你们心里最重要的位置。”
卢德斯接过话,讲了一件更能说明问题的事:过去一年里,鲍勃和道格有连续32周待在霍桑的SpaceX工厂,和工程团队一起工作。看对方的时候,眼神和笑容都不一样。她还透露一个细节:他们座椅和宇航服的零件编号里,印着他们自己的名字。
这件事看起来很小,但它解释了前面那个问题:一家商业公司怎么在送货之余,始终盯着载人这个目标不放。答案是请宇航员真的坐进设计流程里,请工程师每天见到要坐进去的那两个人。
马斯克回应这段时把功劳推给了NASA:
“没有NASA和你们团队的大力支持,我们不可能达到这个安全水平。是NASA推着我们变得比本来好得多。当然,没有NASA我们根本开始不了。”
这句话可以当真。SpaceX的载人飞船从设计评审、安全评估到降落伞测试标准,大量规范来自NASA的商业乘员项目。这也是为什么布里登斯廷反复强调“商业模式验证成功”:NASA出钱、出标准、出人,但不拥有硬件,也不当唯一客户。
NASA不想当唯一客户
布里登斯廷在回答关于星舰的提问时,把NASA这套逻辑讲得最清楚:
“NASA不想当硬件的拥有者和运营者,也不想当唯一的客户。我们希望SpaceX和其他公司去找不属于我们的客户。”
他列了一条时间线来证明这套模式在扩张:
- 商业货运(Commercial Resupply):给国际空间站送货
- 商业乘员(Commercial Crew):送人
- 商业月球载荷服务(CLPS):把载荷送到月面
- 人类着陆系统(Human Landing System):1972年以来NASA第一次出资研制载人登月器,SpaceX是承接方之一
注意最后一条的措辞。他说“不只是投了钱,我们已经和承包商签了合同,在研”。
从“NASA拥有并运营一切”,到“NASA买服务、多家供应商竞争”,这个转变的核心动机是成本。布里登斯廷的原话是“我们在压低成本,在扩大准入”。而扩大准入的前提是有别的客户进来分摊,否则只是把政府独营换成了政府独买。
星舰、月球、火星:他自己也不确定的时间表
法新社的记者问马斯克:能不能谈谈星舰(Starship)的进展,你预计什么时候能绕月飞行?
马斯克的回答很符合他一贯的风格,也很诚实:
“我对时间表一向偏乐观,大概总体上就是乐观的人。我希望两年内能做到,但两年可能意味着四年。我觉得两年不是不可能,如果超过四年我会感到意外。”
这句话要拆开看。“希望两年”是目标,“可能意味着四年”是往历史上他的预测偏差上打的折扣,“超过四年会意外”是他给的上限。三个数字层层后退,等于承认自己也不知道。
但他在另一段里给出了这件事的意义框架,讲得比时间表重要得多:
“这是通往火星文明之路的第一步。促使生命成为多行星物种。在地球45亿年历史上,这是第一次。这需要巨量的创新和技术开发,才能把进入轨道、乃至飞出轨道变成一件常规的事,使成千上万、最终可能数百万人能够前往其他星球。”
他特意澄清了一件事:把生命延伸到地球之外,并不意味着放弃地球。他的表述是,地球上所有生物,动物、植物、人类,都可以被带到其他星球上去,一颗星球不必排斥另一颗。
然后他加了一句罕见的呼吁:“我呼吁公众支持这个目标,思考这个目标有多重要、多根本。我们必须把它做成。”
发射卫星赚钱这件事,他的定位很清楚:“当然很好,能带来收入,我们必须赚得比花得多,这很重要。但归根结底,一切是为了地球之外的生命。”
这场发布会没说但值得注意的三件事
第一,“9年”这个数字的分量。布里登斯廷在结尾说,距美国拥有本土载人发射能力已经过去九年。这九年里,美国宇航员往返空间站全部依赖俄罗斯,单座价格从最初的约2000万美元涨到后来的8000多万美元。商业乘员项目的直接目的,就是终结这种依赖。
第二,“10万人”这个数字。有记者问这项任务涉及多少人,马斯克先说“可能10万”,后来补充算上供应商“接近10万”。这个数字背后是一条极长的供应链,任何一个环节掉链子,发射就得推迟。前面提到的钛合金阀门、降落伞、传感器,都是这条链上的具体环节。
第三,“Crew-1是国际任务”。布里登斯廷在结尾特意提了一句:第一次正式商业乘员任务上会有一名日本宇航员。这句话的意思是,商业乘员头一次就接进了国际空间站的既有框架里。而国际空间站的合作伙伴关系,恰恰是罗戈津那句祝贺背后真正的底色。
飞船有了名字:奋进号
发布会进行到中途,布里登斯廷收到一张纸条,当场念了出来:道格·赫尔利宣布,这艘龙飞船命名为“奋进号”(Endeavour)。
这个名字有来历。赫尔利和本肯都是航天飞机时代的宇航员,而美国最后一艘航天飞机、也就是2011年执行最后一次飞行的那艘,就叫奋进号。用同一艘船的名字,给九年后接续它的新飞船命名,这个选择本身就是一份宣言。
现场还聊到一件轻松的事:飞船入轨之后,两名宇航员把自动驾驶关掉,手动驾驶飞船在轨道上飞了一圈。马斯克说,这大概是每个人童年的梦想。
布里登斯廷补了一个段子:赫尔利上一次航天飞机任务,发射前被取消五次,第六次才飞成。本肯拿这个开玩笑,说赫尔利是个“扫把星”,所以今天大概也发不出去。结果当天天气一度只有50%的发射概率,最后还是飞了。
还有一个小插曲。柯克说,难的部分不在手动飞行,在飞完之后要把控制权交还给计算机。因为两个人都是试飞员,骨子里就想自己开。他原话是“他们明天最难的事,是别把自己开进沟里”。
怎么理解这场发布会的真正信息
如果只看标题,这是一次“发射成功”的庆祝。但把整段问答串起来,能读出的东西更硬。
一家公司可以靠一次发射改变行业格局,前提是它先活过那些没有第二次机会的时刻。SpaceX的第四次猎鹰1号发射,本质上是一次“全押”。押中了,才有后面的17年。
政府和承包商的关系可以重构,但重构的前提是政府愿意放弃“拥有并运营”,接受“购买服务、引入多家供应商”。这个转变在货运上验证过一次,在载人上又验证了一次,现在正在往月球着陆器上推。
把人送上去,和把人安全带回来,是两种完全不同难度的工程。整场发布会里,从马斯克到局长,没有人说“成功”,只说“第一步”。这种克制属于工程判断,再入这一段,Demo-2才第一次真正验证。
最后,马斯克对星舰的时间表,两到四年,仍然是乐观估计。但他给出的意义框架比时间表更值得记住:促使生命成为多行星物种,在地球45亿年历史上是第一次。
发布会结束时,局长说了句“去SpaceX,去NASA,去鲍勃和道格,去美国”。对接预定在美东时间上午10点29分。
那时候,两个被SpaceX全员叫作“Dads”的人,还在轨道上,离家还有一段路。
- 看航天新闻,先分清“发射成功”和“任务成功”。载人任务的真正风险点在再入和回收,任何在轨阶段就宣布胜利的报道,都值得打问号。
- 判断一家硬科技公司的技术路线,去看它在最缺钱的时候做了什么选择。SpaceX在2008年选择把最后的钱押在第四次发射上,这个决策比任何PPT都能说明它的技术判断。
- 想理解商业航天的成本逻辑,去查NASA的商业货运、商业乘员、CLPS三份合同的定价方式。固定价格合同和政府成本加成合同的差别,是这套模式能不能成立的关键。
- 对马斯克给出的任何时间表,做一个心理换算。他自己在这段访谈里给了公式:说两年,实际可能四年,超过四年他会意外。用这个区间去估他的其他项目,准确率会高一些。
- 如果你在带团队做长周期项目,可以从这场发布会学一件事:请最终用户(这里是宇航员)长期坐进设计流程,连续32周和工程师待在一起,比任何需求文档都更能保住项目的方向。
0:00thank you our next question comes from Jackie waddles of CNN thanks so much for doing this I was curious this question is for Yvonne if you had heard from president Trump yet and what she might have told you and what you might have said to him about this thanks so much well I've not spoken
0:23one-on-one with with him I just essentially heard the the press conference along with everybody else so we've not exchanged any direct comments it's in the firing room thereafter after the launch and I'll tell you that yeah the president is excited of course he congratulated Elon and the SpaceX team and I thought it was I thought it was a good moment yes it was it was a with a group of people but yeah sure yeah but yes he certainly congratulated
0:55the SpaceX team at NASA and everyone involved and yeah I think this just to echo the NASA minister's comments I think this is this is a day that is but I think everyone can be proud of that it's it's a good day to be that this event is something that any all all of humanity can get excited about it's just a fundamentally positive good thing and you know I think we need we need more positive good things as well our next
1:29question is from Joey roulette of Reuters doing that one question two-part question first is for Jim bridenstine have you heard from your Russian counterparts I know Kirk chairman mentioned that international partners reached out to NASA with the success and the others for Elon Musk with SpaceX as you know success today have you heard from your Boeing counterparts and what would you say to them Thanks so Dmitry
1:58Rogozin is the head of Rose cosmos in Russia and I haven't talked to him but I have seen his public comments and of course he was overwhelmingly congratulate congratulate Ori towards NASA and SpaceX and and he made some comment about how it's it's it's like flying an iPhone or something and I know I've made similar comments as well but but he does he did express that this is an exciting day not just for us but also for them they're they believe in the partnership and so I think it's going to remain strong the trampoline is working inside
2:43okay our next question comes from Marcia done for you your company president said right before liftoff that she was super nervous stomach and throat could you talk about how you were your emotions your feelings leading up to liftoff and especially seeing them make it to orbit safely thank you very much
3:10was that for me or kneel on sure he goes for you our free monthly heal on Marshall if your ass on the line can you repeat your question yes Elon Gwynne Shotwell said right before a liftoff that she had her stomach and her throat she was super nervous I'd like to know how you were feeling in the minutes leading up to liftoff today your emotions your feelings of having to stand there and watch all this unfold thank you well I mean just being
3:51straight from the heart on Wednesday during the first first countdown I'd say that my adrenaline was railed at 100% and when the launch was called off it went does 0% it was like I just basically collapsed and slept though the longest time I'd slept in probably a year they're gnarly enough today I don't know I feel like just the fates were aligned and I didn't feel didn't feel nervous didn't feel just but if I like if I like it was gonna work and I felt like the right thing was gonna happen so for whatever reason I did not I know if you're nervous sure say something real quick I just got a note moments ago Doug Hurley announced that the crew dragon is named endeavour
4:41and we are going to look forward to hearing a few words from them shortly thank you yeah they've been flying it around actually it's cool it they they they they took it off automatic and and just wouldn't manually flying the craft around it's gotta be pretty fun just zipping around space and yeah space craft everyone's childhood dream yeah next we'll go to Emory Kelly a floor today hey thanks for doing this I
5:12appreciate it I'm just wondering with this being the first time humans have had a chance to experience flying on a falcon 9 and in a crew dragon after all these years of them flying have you gotten any input from Bob and Doug is it you know smooth ride what was it like thank you I've not heard specifically as to
5:36how it flies I do know that we are gonna hear from them soon I don't know at what point that's going to take place patina I don't know if you have that specific information no I don't was very smooth ride you can see yeah I think in the webcast it looked quite smooth in fact I was a friend of mine who's a filmmaker said you need to put some shake into the camera to make it look more realistic our next question will be
6:08from Paul Brinkman of UPI yes I'd like to ask you on I realised mission isn't over but it's a significant achievement at this point what's the impact of success for this program on SpaceX as a whole including development of starship well I think this was obviously a trance compliment for SpaceX in
6:38partnership with NASA and a number of critical spires in fact if I think about the total number of people involved in making this mission successful probably adds up to a hundred thousand so I just like to just express a word of appreciation and congratulations again for to everyone involved making this successful and actually and just a
7:01special special word to administrator and Cathy and you know it's just a everyone involved it's just wow anyway it is a little hard to process like I think at this point I am somewhat of a come by emotion to try to come up with cohesive you know sentences that make any sense is quite difficult all right but I think the this is
7:30hopefully the first step on a journey towards civilization on on Mars because of life echoing multiplanetary you know base on the moon and expand expanding beyond earth and life becoming a multi-planet species live becoming multiplanetary for the first time in the four-and-a-half billion year history of Earth I think this is hopefully the first step on that journey it will require a tremendous amount of innovation and technology development to
8:04make going to orbit and ultimately beyond orbit a routine matter where thousands and perhaps ultimately millions of people can travel to other planets that's that's what we really need to achieve over time we're and that that's that's obviously a very difficult goal but that's it's that seeming increasingly real with what happened today but getting people to overt finally after 18 years if we if we are
8:36able to increase out the rate of innovation then life can become multiplanetary this is the goal we should strive for I think from from a NASA perspective I think what this did for starship and a lot of others is kind of established that this is a successful business model and if we look at how we did commercial resupply of the International Space Station and now Commercial Crew of the International Space Station and of course the commercial lunar payload services program to deliver payloads to the surface of the Moon and now for the first time since 1972 we have funded a human landing system and of course we're very proud that SpaceX is going to be a
9:17partner in that development program as well so so not only do we haven't funded we actually have contractors under contract developing that human landing system so I think as far as how how this relates to the Artemis program and and the moon to Mars program I think I think the business model has has proven itself very successful we're bringing down costs we're increasing access that's going to continue to happen as we on ramp more partners and of course as SpaceX and others to go get more customers NASA doesn't want to be the owner and operator of the hardware we also don't want to be the only customer we want we want SpaceX and others to go get customers that are not
10:00us and when all that materializes I think what Ellen's talking about here this vision for Humanity being able to live on the surface of the Moon for long periods of time and eventually on Mars for long periods of time that that's the eventualities of the business model that we are currently developing thank you our next question is from Chris Davenport of The Washington Post oh thanks guys for taking my call I
10:30really appreciate it and thanks Elon for the trampoline quote that was classic Elon if I could ask you you put the window in the car go dragon as a symbol of your ambition of flying people I wonder if you can talk a little bit about how over these very long years you kept your team focused on human spaceflight as the ultimate goal even though obviously they've been working on so many other things along the way Thanks and Congrats yeah human
11:04spaceflight was was always the goal but the fundamental goal of SpaceX well it like said to create the technologies or help create the technologies necessary to make life sustainably multiplanetary I can't emphasize I cannot emphasize this enough this is the thing that we need to do we must make life sustainably multiplet multiplanetary it's not one planet to the exclusion of another but to extend life beyond Earth we our life's agent in this regard all the creatures that none of the plants and everyone that that exists here on earth we can bring them to other planets and it's very important that we do so as soon as possible I think well while the window of
11:46opportunity is open I call upon I call upon the public to support this goal and to think about this goal and think about how important it is and how fundamental it is to the future we got to get it done the launching satellites is it's nice of course and it keeps the coat you know we've got to bring in more money than we spend this is important but it's ultimately all about life beyond Earth we'll go to our
12:25next question it's Eric Berger of Ars Technica good afternoon that was a hell of a thing to watch question for Jim today it's been a little more than eight months since you tweeted about SpaceX and it was time to deliver just wondering if you would say that they have delivered or not and and maybe do you have a message for other contractors for NASA yeah no I leave it to you to
12:53bring this up we're celebrating here a little bit I want to be careful we're not celebrating too much until Bob and Doug get home safely but but no that's that's right you know there was a there was a time eight months ago as you mentioned where we were having challenges with parachutes you know we had a crew dragon that had a static fire
13:15test that ultimately resulted in its catastrophic loss and you know if you would have told me then that we would be right here today I don't know that I would have believed it and and yes I sent a tweet and asked to you on to deliver and I'll tell you and I'll tell you the same thing I told the president I told the vice president and of course I've said it in a number of interviews since that day Elon Musk and SpaceX have
13:42delivered on everything nASA has asked them to deliver on and and and and at a speed that we never would have guessed my engineering team was saying that this is not going to be able to be achieved in this amount of time the amount of parachute tests that we had to get done and how long it takes to get those parachute tests done look we got we got all the parachute tests done and and we are just overwhelmingly grateful not just for SpaceX and-and-and Elon Musk but also airborne and the NASA team that really went to on getting all these tests done and of course all of the you know getting changing out the titanium the hole that took time and then doing all the tests
14:27after that my goodness SpaceX really delivered something that is magnificent and that is speed without question I don't think anybody would have believed the speed with which SpaceX delivered and they did in fact deliver had anything to that oh no I mean I think Jim said it really well I mean we went through it wasn't like we didn't have issues we had things we had to go solve right and we've learned a ton and that team the SpaceX
15:00team and the NASA team together working hand in glove you know together solve these problems together right we tackled them and we solved them and figured out how we're gonna go fly together but without the SpaceX folks making it happen like Jim said so quickly we wouldn't be here today thank you next is Lauren crush with the verge hi
15:26thank you so much for taking my question I guess is for anyone who can answer it I'm wondering if there was anything unexpected during the launch today I think I heard something on the livestream about some component being lower in temperature than expected just wondering if everything went as planned or if you had any any hiccups along the way Thanks
15:52so the only you know really the count was I would say spectacularly quiet I mean I mean everybody said you know and then probably within as we were loading the prop the only thing we saw was we saw it was it was actually something we had seen as we were unloading on Wednesday we had a sensor that was that
16:16was reading in a way that we had to go understand why was it reading in that particular manner and we also had understand what can happen if it and it was in an area where actually we it's downstream of our fill and drain valve and so it was you know chem talked before about where do the teams how do they work together and one of the things that we've learned on this mission is how to go take a piece of data like a sensor data and go understand what is that data telling us and then be able to clear it which is really why we were able to fly through our understanding of what the issue was and then turn that around in a very short period of time
17:02and what that takes is two groups of folks that have been working with each other for a while and understand what the vehicle is trying to tell them but you know I thought oh my goodness we're gonna have this issue after going to all the weather stuff now we're gonna have this issue and and I was very impressed
17:20with how the joint teams together looked at the sensor understood it understood the phenomena and then cleared it and continued on the count next we'll go to Irene Klotz of Aviation Week thanks everybody that was super impressive to see my question I think it's for Kathy and maybe for you on what what has happened from this point on for you although feel confident that in August 30th or early September or launch of the first post certification mission shouldn't happen thanks well you know
18:02I'm very proud of the SpaceX team for another reason you know we had really won it our crew on vehicle to get into prop checkouts which is really where the spacecrafts assembled and we're kind of in one of the final acceptance testing modes and last night I got an email it said crew one vehicle is in prop checkouts they're going through so and making sure that the propulsion systems leak tight and operating in a critical manner so I tell you that's the first thing the vehicles got to be ready the other things that we've got to do is make sure one week and we dock our demo to vehicle because like we said this is a test flight and make sure that we're taking all that
18:48learning that we are going to have from the docking and rolling it into our readiness for crew one and then and then we also have to make sure that we are understanding that we get through landing and make sure that we're taking that understanding and any issues that we have with the landing and then rolling that into crew one so our team's
19:13getting the vehicle ready and we're also watching this demonstration mission and making sure that our learning out of this test flight is then rolled into how we're going to be flying crew one so keep watching along the way it's gonna be like a we're like a I'd say like a cereal net your your cereal and what are we following along as we learn along the way but these test flights are very important for that next mission next
19:43question comes from Jeff's house all right this Jeff house with space news are there anything any issues you're particularly watching on the crew dragon as approaches the space station anything that you'll be particularly keeping your fingers across over the rainy hours up through Aki
20:06so you know the big thing the nice thing about us having the uncrewed mission was we were able to check out a lot of the systems on the uncrewed mission that had to do with Docky and i think everybody saw last spring how successful our crew our demo1 mission was went through the docking bays but you always learn
20:31something when spaceflight and now having the crew on board and and understanding how the spacecraft and the crew operate as a system and then how that total system then obviously works with us approaching station will be another big thing that we're learning right and then obviously you know people
20:53forget and Kirk alluded to it us understanding how to be docked with station and operate within station is a big part of our learning for this crew we're going to be this is also our first long-duration mission where we're going to be doing integrated operations with the space station for a long period of time which is which is also going to be a huge learning opportunity for us so these test flights are very very important for us to not only learn how the vehicle works but learn how we're operating it and we've learned a lot about how to try to fly with weather and how to operate with these systems it's going to be really important for us now
21:37to go learn how to obviously do the docking piece but then learn how to be part of this integrated you know enterprise that's the International Space Station and Kirk you I could add there it's a very complicated you know system first of all I promise good weather tomorrow Cathy rain showers I did have a solar flare but I don't think that'll impact our operations but there's a series of tests along the way just like on demo one there's some additional tests of course Doug's gonna take over and fly manually and the crew the the crew on board the Dragon Bob & Doug monitoring how the vehicle comes in and Chris Cassidy on board the ISS will also be monitoring
22:19so it really is how does the vehicle perform how does the integrated crew both the crew on the Dragon and the Khurana International Space Station handle all that and then of course equalizing the pressure is making sure the the there's no leaks when it's made it to the ISS and then finally just training the crew to come across the hatch and how how the ISS works and be part of that bigger integrated team so I think there's a tremendous amount of things to learn along the way and we have very very experienced crew onboard the ISS and a very very experienced crew on on Dragon and I think it'll go really well but but I'm sure we'll learn a few things along the way thank you our next
23:00question is going to come from Jackie Goddard of Times of London hello thank you and congratulations my question is for Elon you said last week that you had told Bob and Doug's two little boys that you would do everything you can to bring them home safely even with a safe launch out of the way that must still weigh on you throughout the mission there and I wondered if you can share some personal insight into what it's like to have that responsibility not just with your SpaceX hat on but as a dad thank you
23:37well it really hit home you know when you meet somebody's kids and and the the vehicle that they responsible for you know that their life's at stake it's it's I really hits home so you know this stole so we still got a duck with Space Station we still got a cigar returned I think there's an argument that the return is we're more dangerous in some ways than the ascent so we don't were to declare a victory yet we need to bring them home safely make sure that we're doing everything we can to minimize that risk of reentry and and return of the we
24:29were able to do that with the demo1 vehicle so we were able to retire a lot of risk with the reentry there that that's a big deal but yeah that and I get a chalked up here so it it's it really this yeah I'm getting choked up sorry I yeah I'm not sure I can answer the question and more than that except yeah we're gonna do everything we can so make sure it gets home safely our next question comes from marina Curran hi everyone marina corn with the Atlantic congratulations on the launch this is for Ilan or Jim do Bob and Doug want to dock manually to the ISS instead of letting dragon do it are they allowed to do that or can they only take over if
25:22there is a problem or some kind of emergency the the plan is for automatic rendezvous and docking that's that's the plan of course if they needed to do something manually they they could but but but we're planning to to test automatic rendezvous and docking I just want to reiterate something that that Ilan talked about there is no doubt that
25:49Bob and Doug are on Ilan's mind all the time but that is not just on his mind he has made that throughout the culture at SpaceX and we did we did an assessment of the culture at SpaceX and it came back extremely strong and it is it is on the my Bob and Doug are on the minds of everybody all the way down to the line worker and all the way to the top everybody at SpaceX knows what what is at stake here and I will tell you I was very impressed with what I saw in that in that safety assessment that we conducted and I think all of our NASA team was was impressed with it as well it's not just Elon it's his whole team and he's made that go all the way down
26:36to the to every person that works at SpaceX dad's which may have something to do with their age but I won't I can say that because they're on orbit so there's and it'll be a few months before maybe they come back and kick me now but but yes but they're called the DM to Dad's we should have a dad joke I would like
27:02to add to that because it plays back to an earlier question about how did SpaceX stay focused on human spaceflight coming out of cargo and I think part of that is that relationship that was built I I know recently over this past year I think it was 32 straight weeks that Bob and Doug were out there at Hawthorne with the SpaceX team and they have really built a very close relationship you can see it in the eyes and and the smiles when they see each other and that goes a long way I think in this and so I
27:38think what's really really cool is that the part number for their seats and their suits has their names in it so you know I think Elon you guys have done a great job to personalize that you're they're flying our crews that culture is not easy to achieve and it's not easy to get it throughout the whole organization and the safety assessment that we did indicated that that was the case well I just want to say that I think we would not have achieved this level of safety without the tremendous support from NASA and your team this is this it that there's it that NASA made us way better than we would otherwise have been and obviously you couldn't even have got
28:16started without NASA so thank you very much for your support let's let's celebrate safety when we get them home our next question is from Ivan Crone from AFP thank you very much a question for you Lana could you expand on the starship development about when you expect you if you will go around the moon well I tend to be a little optimistic about schedules so so I mean
28:55optimistic in general so I guess that extends to schedules too I don't know I mean I I guess I would I would wish that we could do it in two years I don't know that might mean for but I think I don't know what I think it's not out of the question that it could be two years I would be surprised if it took more than four okay
29:26our next question is from Dave Mosher of Business Insider thank you for taking my question and congratulations on an amazing launch this is for you on you've been working toward this moment for 18 years and have certainly encountered some resistance along the way I think even in NASA at one point what would you say to those who doubted SpaceX could do this do you have a message for them and then your last conversation with Bob and Doug can you can you tell us what you what you talked about what you said thank you my plugs I didn't hear the first question properly
30:07Dave yes I'm sorry you couldn't hear the question yeah can you repeat it please yeah sorry about that so this was for you I said you've been working toward this moment for 18 years and you've certainly encountered a lot of resistance along the way even I think from NASA at the very beginning what would you say to those who doubted SpaceX could do this do you have a message for them and then what was your last conversation with Bob and Doug like what did you what do you talk about where was it thank you so much it's do I have a message for those who owed out it okay I was like okay maybe I
30:43just blank out the word doubt so no I mean I treat totally Frank I doubted us too so I thought we you know had maybe went starting SpaceX maybe had a temps and chance of reaching orbit so so you know to those who who doubted us I was like well I think you probably right you know I mean the number of times that I
31:12was told like because he was taking the money I earned from from PayPal and and rolling into to create SpaceX and Tesla and MSN are spending it all wasn't the intention but and and and we're almost both companies went bankrupt frankly 2008 was a tough year you know took us took us four attempts just to get to orbit with Falcon one and so but a lot
31:41of times I was you know I feel will tell me this joke like how do you make a small fortune in the rocket industry you start with large one is the punchline and I was like okay I already heard that joke twelve thousand times you know so anyway and it was it almost came true you know we just barely made it there that fourth launch of Falcon one that's all the money we had for that fourth launch and then it and that wasn't even enough to save the company we also then had to win the National cargo resupply contract so that that came a little after you know a little bit later all right towards the end 2008 those are the two key things that that save SpaceX otherwise we would have
32:24we would have you know not made it so so hey I think those doubters were there probably the assessment was correct but fortunately Vader smiled upon us and brought us to this day impact anything else you get out about Bob and Doug right before they launched well I mentioned earlier that that they were calm and focused I think that this was
32:55for both of them a chance to get back to space they felt like it was a privilege to represent NASA and the astronaut corps and in this endeavor and they I guarantee you are going to enjoy their time on the International Space Station Chris joke with them when they didn't get up the first time I think the administrator heard this that they were trying to get out of the weekend cleaning that we do on the ISS but they'll be glad to get they're glad to come back we're going to take our last question from space com hi this is
33:31Annika waitering with space.com thank you so much for taking my question and congratulations on an amazing launch today I'm just wondering if you could talk about what else Bob and Doug will be doing now that they've completed their manual flight test I've heard that they're going to be taking a nap at some point but what else is on the to-do list for Bob and Doug between now and docking well you know they they did their far-field demo so like Ilan already mentioned they got to manually fly the vehicle they'll be doing another demonstration a little bit closer to the space station you know people forget that you know the reason we picked or
34:12the fod picked the Bob and duck to fly this is because of their experience as test pilots and and actually had developed this the concept of the cadre to have an experience set a pilot of crew members working with the companies to make sure that that they were able to help them they're working through their designs and developing their systems so this is kind of cool because this is Bob and Doug get to actually fly the work that they've been helping work and develop and say figure out how is it really working on orbit and so the other thing they get to do is just to be able to be you know the ecosystems working they're getting to see things cooling is the
35:02houses seat feels house the suits feel can you get in and out of the suits you know when you're on orbit how easy are those kind of functions going to be I'm not going to talk about the the waists functions but that's kind of part of it and and then obviously how approach feels with I know that Jim was able to use a simulator but now they got this big simulator with that's the International Space Station that they're gonna get to be able to actually you know come up to and be able to dock and see how that really works and how it matches because one of the things that's really important we all know it and anybody I've you know is how does the
35:46real thing really approximate what you've been practicing on for you know the last few years and so there now we're going to be able to come back and for these next crews that are going up they'll be able to share with them hey this is really how it felt this is how these systems worked and be able to share that experience with the crew one crew that right now is doing their training so they're doing a very very
36:15very important function for upcoming crews that will really be the long-duration crew members and we'll be flying to the space station and I can promise you that the hardest thing they'll do tomorrow is when they're done flying their manual near-field klein is to hand it back over to the computers and not daka themselves because they are test pilots and answer an earlier question that is exactly what they would enjoy doing so to give it back will be a little bit hard for them I didn't notice you know Doug was really good at teaching Jim how to fly it so yes he helped you dock right well I might have helped a lot well that was
37:00our last question some closing remarks from the administrator sure so again this is a great day for the United States of America it does represent many years of work I want to say you know a question came up earlier about you know doubters and people that didn't believe that this could have ever happened there was a day when Charlie Bolden my predecessor at NASA as the administrator was trying to get this program off the ground in a significant way and he had members of Congress on both sides of the aisle that were in opposition to it and wouldn't adequately fund it and ultimately gave him a hard time about it and general Marine Corps general Charlie
37:44Bolden persevered and he pushed through and that was the beginning of what we all get to experience today and so I want to I want to emphasize that I also want to emphasize you know Pat was talking about how the the Bob and Doug we're joking with each other earlier today when when I had the opportunity to be with them and they were joking you know Doug Doug Hurley's last space shuttle mission got scrubbed five times before they finally launched on the sixth time and of course Bob Behnken is saying that Doug Hurley is the jinx here and therefore you know they're not gonna launch today either and and to see them loose like that Pat you mentioned that
38:23they were loose and joking and and in fact seemingly having fun on the day of launch even though what they're doing is very serious and nerves of steel just I mean these were these are just American American heroes yeah so I just want to make sure that we're keeping them in mind and of course Elon SpaceX in your team you know going back to what we talked about just a few minutes ago the fact that at SpaceX you don't call them Bob and Doug you call them the dads because that's what they are they are in fact dads and keeping their safety at the foremost of your minds so really this is really a great day for all of America it's a great day for our country
39:09it's been a long time it's been nine years since we've had the opportunity and of course where we are here now and there's that there's you know as Ilan said earlier there's a 10,000 people behind this that that have made it happen you might have said I hired that when you add up suppliers and yeah and everyone it's it's I think is probably closer to a hundred thousand that's right this really is a it's a great day for the United States of America it's a great day for our international partners remember crew one is going to be an international mission on the first on the first crew we're going to have a Japanese astronaut with us so so we're
39:50very excited about this I want to say congratulations to everybody we're not celebrating yet we will celebrate when they're home safely but certainly we can we can breathe sighs of relief every step along the way and that's what we're doing today so congratulations to SpaceX and Elon Musk congratulations to Kathy leaders and your NASA team that got us to this position and we look forward to so many things ahead great so that's
40:17gonna wrap it up for us here at the Kennedy Space Center you can continue watching our live coverage until the astronauts reach the International Space Station and docking and hatch opening and the arrival of Bob and Doug at the ISS docking is scheduled for 1029 Eastern Time and right after this broadcast we'll turn it over to JSC we're gonna hear from Bob and Doug during a downlink from the crew dragon from as they orbit the Earth so we'll have more information please stay go-to nasa.gov for more specific information on Commercial Crew you go to nasa.gov slash Commercial Crew and go spacex
40:53go NASA go Bob and Doug and go America thank you
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版