2019年3月2日凌晨,佛罗里达,肯尼迪航天中心39A发射台。龙飞船2号(Crew Dragon,也称Dragon 2)刚刚入轨,NASA的发布会现场,主持人把话筒递给埃隆·马斯克。他开口的第一句跟庆祝无关。
说实话,我情绪上有点疲惫,因为这次发射太紧张了。不过到目前为止,它成功了。(埃隆·马斯克)
“到目前为止”这几个字,在整场发布会里被他反复提起。飞船还没对接空间站,还没再入,还没溅落。一条完整的无人试飞航线,要等最后一个环节落地,才能叫成功。
在座的人都知道这次发射的分量。2011年航天飞机退役之后,美国宇航员去国际空间站只能买俄罗斯联盟号的座位,一张票的价格从两千万美元一路涨到八千多万美元。DM-1是商业载人计划里,美国本土制造的载人飞船第一次自己飞上轨道。
从2002年到2019年,17年。
马斯克说,公司成立那会儿,他觉得成功的概率只有10%。
所有人都说会失败,那就边失败边试
发布会快结束时,行星学会的玛丽·利·本德(Mary Lee Bender)问马斯克:17年里一直在突破质疑和怀疑,你有什么建议给那些同样被质疑的梦想家?
马斯克回答得很干脆:
我本来就觉得我们会失败,所以现在看到的都算赚的。起步的时候,我估计只有10%的概率能进入轨道。(埃隆·马斯克)
他接着讲,当年刚创办SpaceX,别人说“你肯定要失败”,他点头同意:我也这么觉得。然后又说了一句:
但这事值得一试。(埃隆·马斯克)
现场笑成一片,马斯克自己也笑。
他说,卖掉PayPal拿到的钱几乎全投进了SpaceX和特斯拉。猎鹰1号前三次发射全部失败。第四次,他们把剩下的零件拼拼凑凑,装出一枚火箭,打上去了。就这一次成功,公司才有资格继续存在。
如果那一次也失败了,我们就完了。(埃隆·马斯克)
连续三次失败还没倒闭,需要两个条件:创始人愿意押上全部身家,有人愿意继续投钱。马斯克两个条件都占上了。
他讲到自己为什么坚持做这件事:
我真心相信太空的未来。人类要成为一个航天文明,要到群星之间去。这是让人们觉得未来值得期待的事情之一。我们希望科幻小说和电影里的东西不要永远停留在科幻里,希望有一天它们是真的。(埃隆·马斯克)
这段话放在一场商业发布会里,有点像口号。放在一个曾经连续三次炸掉火箭、账上钱只够再打一次的人嘴里,分量不一样。
龙飞船2号跟1号,几乎没有一颗螺丝钉通用
有记者问:今天的发射向NASA和整个世界证明了SpaceX的什么能力?
马斯克先纠正了一点:任务才走完一小半,最后成不成还不好说。然后他解释,龙飞船2号跟龙飞船1号几乎没有通用零件,谈不上是升级。
龙飞船2号是一次彻底的重新设计,几乎没有任何零件跟龙飞船1号通用。回头看,当初我们可能不该这么干,但确实有大量新设备上了飞船。(埃隆·马斯克)
这次发射验证了好几个新系统:鼻锥打开、天龙座(Draco)推力器点火、推进剂系统工作。马斯克说,到目前为止一切看起来都正常。
他重点讲了龙飞船2号跟其他载人飞船最大的区别:集成式发射逃逸系统。
传统载人飞船(比如联盟号)的逃逸塔装在飞船头顶,像一根避雷针。发射出问题时,塔上的固体火箭点火,把飞船从运载火箭上拽走。这套设计的麻烦在于,发射正常进行时,逃逸塔必须被抛掉,而抛掉逃逸塔本身就是一个分离动作,多一个环节就多一份风险。
龙飞船2号把逃逸发动机直接装在飞船侧面:八台超级天龙座(SuperDraco)发动机。它们既是逃逸系统,也是飞船自己的动力来源。
龙飞船这里,逃逸系统集成在飞船本体上,所以一直到入轨那一刻,都具备逃逸能力。你也不用担心逃逸塔分离的问题。我认为这在原理上是安全性的一大提升。(埃隆·马斯克)
这句话背后的含义:传统逃逸塔在发射后大约两三分钟就被抛弃,抛掉之后飞船就失去了快速脱离火箭的能力。龙飞船2号从点火到入轨,全程都能自己飞走。
除了八台超级天龙座,飞船还有16台小一点的Draco推力器,负责在轨机动。马斯克专门提了它们的复杂度:
龙飞船2号有一个非常复杂的推进系统。16台在轨机动推力器加八台超级天龙座,两套系统交错在一起,设计上非常棘手。在轨机动的主推力器,喷射方向跟推进剂自然流动的方向是相反的。(埃隆·马斯克)
这是发布会里技术含量最高的一句话。推力器朝前喷,推进剂要往后走,管路就必须让燃料逆着“常识方向”输送。这种设计在纸面上能成立,在真实飞行里一旦某个阀门卡住,排查起来会非常麻烦。马斯克说,这些推力器工作正常,鼻锥下面的前向推力器也正常,鼻锥顺利打开,太阳能板展开。
一次无人试飞里,这些分系统全部按预期工作,等于把返回前的风险清单划掉了几项。
他最大的担忧在再入,不在发射
有记者问马斯克:未来五天里,有没有哪个环节让他特别紧张?
他给了两个答案。第一个是对接,第二个是再入。
对接这次是自动的。龙飞船1号送货时,飞到空间站附近后停下来,由空间站的机械臂伸出去抓住它,再安装到对接口上。龙飞船2号要自己飞过去,直接贴住对接口,完成锁定。
这次飞船要自己飞上去,贴到空间站上,把自己固定住。这是我们从来没做过的事情。(埃隆·马斯克)
第二个担忧更具体。再入时飞船靠后壳承受气动加热,而龙飞船2号的后壳没有龙飞船1号那种光滑的圆锥面。因为逃逸发动机吊舱装在侧面,后壳是不对称的。
不对称的后壳在再入时可能引起滚转不稳定。我们模拟过上千次,我觉得不太可能出问题,但确实存在这种可能。(埃隆·马斯克)
紧接着他补了另一句:
再入时还要验证降落伞,伞能不能正常打开,系统能不能把飞船引导到正确的位置安全溅落。高超音速再入可能是我最担心的问题。(埃隆·马斯克)
这里有两个技术细节需要展开。一是滚转不稳定:飞船再入时姿态由推力器调整,如果气动力矩把飞船翻过来,推力器要花更多燃料去修正,严重时可能失控。二是降落伞:龙飞船1号用过降落伞,但龙飞船2号的伞是新的,开伞时序和伞衣打开过程都要重新验证。
有记者追问:再入走廊走的是下降段,飞越美国上空,航天飞机时代飞越人口稠密区要额外评估,这次怎么处理?
NASA商业载人项目副经理史蒂夫·斯蒂奇(Steve Stitch)接过问题。他说,着陆区在佛罗里达海岸外,SpaceX划定的溅落区就在附近。NASA对再入风险有一套评估流程:先看飞船上有哪些部件,假设最坏情况会发生什么,再用独立建模系统模拟落点和碎片散布。这套流程走完,才能批准这次再入走廊。
他补了一句:这次任务的高风险时段有三个,对接口、再入、着陆。NASA想从DM-1拿到的,正是这三个阶段的真实数据。
假人没抱怨过一句
有记者问:发射时舱内摄像机拍到了什么?
马斯克说,信号优先保证数据下传,舱内视频要等飞船靠近空间站、建立宽带链路之后才能看到。但他透露了加速度:大约4.5个G。
有记者问那个坐在座椅上的假人(他们给它起名叫Ripley)状态如何,马斯克顺着开了个玩笑:
它没抱怨过一句。(埃隆·马斯克)
现场又是一阵笑声。他说假人看起来像静止的一样,其实承受了4个多G的过载。
真正引起公众兴奋的是另一件东西。马斯克说,等舱内视频传回来,大家会看到一个漂浮在失重环境里的小地球人玩偶。那颗“小地球”是SpaceX为这次任务准备的零重力指示器。马斯克说,公众可能对这个玩意儿最感兴趣。
这个细节放在整场发布会里不起眼,但它说明一件事:SpaceX很清楚公众想看什么。火箭发射的数据再漂亮,普通人能记住的往往是那个在舱里飘来飘去的小玩偶。
一把剪刀和一个小阀门
发布会里有个细节,怎么听都不像航天故事。“每日宇航员”(Everyday Astronaut)的蒂姆·多德(Tim Dodd)问:猎鹰9号已经冻结设计,之前着陆失败暴露的栅格翼液压泵问题,在冻结状态下怎么改?
马斯克先讲了一段往事。有一次,真空版梅林发动机的喷管在测试中出现了一道小裂口。喷管是铌合金做的,又薄又脆,修复方案是:
我们派了最好的技师进去,拿一把剪刀把它剪齐。(埃隆·马斯克)
他说当时自己都觉得这做法太野了,问身边人这样行不行,对方说“应该行”。后来真行了。
回到栅格翼液压泵的问题。马斯克说NASA和SpaceX在这类改动上配合得很好。龙飞船2号某种意义上是NASA和SpaceX共同设计的,双方工程团队来回反馈很多。只要改动合理,坐下来开会讨论,就能推进。
液压泵卡滞的原因查出来很偶然:一个很窄的转速区间里,泵会卡住。解决办法是加一个很小的泄压阀。
其实就是加了一个小小的泄压阀,问题就解决了,没有上冗余泵。(埃隆·马斯克)
史蒂夫·斯蒂奇补充了NASA这一侧的流程:SpaceX提出改动,NASA工程团队逐项审查,走完流程再改飞船。这次阀门改动很简单,流程走得很快。
这两件事放在一起看很有意思。一边是拿剪刀修剪火箭发动机喷管,一边是走完整审查流程换一个小阀门。前者靠现场判断,后者靠流程保证。商业航天的效率,很多时候就体现在能多快把“野路子”变成“可审查的改动”。
宇航员在看什么
鲍勃·本肯(Bob Behnken)和道格·赫尔利(Doug Hurley)坐在马斯克旁边。他们将执行DM-2,也就是龙飞船2号的首次载人飞行。
本肯说,他们过去几年多次去霍桑(Hawthorne)的工厂看飞船总装,看自己将来要坐的那艘飞船一点点成形。这次发射成功,对他们的信心帮助很大。
这件事的核心是预测飞船会做什么,然后测试它,确认预测和实际对得上。每一个里程碑对得上,信心就多一点。(鲍勃·本肯)
他提到一个细节:这次DM-1是集成操作,龙飞船团队和猎鹰9号团队第一次在发射流程里紧密配合。以前货运任务里,飞船更像一个独立载荷。这次两个团队要实时沟通,飞船告诉地面什么、地面告诉火箭什么,这些交互以后都会写进航天员训练模拟里。
赫尔利接过话。他用试飞员的逻辑解释流程:先无人试飞,再飞行中逃逸测试(in-flight abort),最后载人。飞行中逃逸测试相当于毕业考试,考过了才能上DM-2。
有记者问:马斯克说发射无人飞船已经情绪耗尽,载人发射时怎么办?
马斯克回答得很直接:
我估计会极其紧张。(埃隆·马斯克)
他说,龙飞船分离点火之后,他走过去问本肯和赫尔利,觉得这艘船怎么样。两人说感觉不错。马斯克说,那他就放心了。
39A发射台和火星上的城市
美联社的记者问马斯克:在39A发射台发射,坐在NASA用了几十年的发射控制室里,是什么感受?
马斯克的回答少见地感性:
我从来没想到这会发生在自己身上。人类登月,那可能是有史以来最伟大的事情。我不敢相信我们是从那个发射台发射的。感谢你们开放这座发射台,也感谢你们翻新了它。(埃隆·马斯克)
他说,希望人类很快重返月球。然后讲了他心里的路线图:
月球上应该有一个永久性有人基地,还要把人送上火星,在火星上建一座城市。这是我们应该做的事。(埃隆·马斯克)
有记者问:你自己愿意坐龙飞船2号吗?
马斯克说愿意。他觉得这艘船设计得不错,背后是SpaceX很多聪明人极大量的工作,加上NASA的帮助。他转头问旁边的两位宇航员:你们也觉得这是艘好船吧?两个人点头。
还有记者问:除了NASA,龙飞船2号还会不会有别的客户?马斯克说,目前没有找私人客户,全部精力放在满足NASA需求上。等飞船进入常态化运营,会考虑商业客户,包括私人公民访问空间站。他说,以前去过空间站的人都是坐联盟号去的,如果能坐美国飞船去,会是件挺酷的事。
NASA局长为什么盯着月球
发布会后半段,吉姆·布里登斯廷(Jim Bridenstine)讲了NASA的算盘。
他说,总统给NASA的第一条太空政策指令是重返月球,而且要“可持续”。可持续的意思是留下来,不光是插旗拍照。月球上要有着陆器、巡视器、机器人,也要有人,要联合国际伙伴和商业伙伴。
布里登斯廷还讲了一个更大的判断:NASA希望成为“众多客户中的一个”。
我们作为一个机构、一个国家,期待成为众多客户中的一个客户,进入一个强大的近地轨道商业市场,这样我们才能降低成本,以历史上不可能的方式增加进入太空的机会。(吉姆·布里登斯廷)
这是商业载人计划的核心逻辑:政府不再是唯一的买家,政府买的是服务。市场里长出来的运力,可以给更多人用。
为什么先去月球再去火星?他给了一个很实在的理由:地球和火星每26个月才有一次合适的发射窗口。飞船到了火星,必须在那里待很长时间等窗口返回。阿波罗13号出事时,飞船离地球三天路程,能想办法回来。去火星的路上如果出事,回程难度高出一个量级。
所以在月球上要先验证原位资源利用(ISRU),验证长期生存技术,把风险降下来,再去火星。
他提到加拿大刚刚宣布参与美国主导的月球计划,承诺周期24年。布里登斯廷说,这种长期承诺是国际合作的基石。他还说,NASA要的远超一次登月,是一整套架构:近地轨道、月球、火星三个战场,加上国际伙伴和商业伙伴,拼成一个能延续几代人的框架。
他讲了预算。总统的第一份预算案给NASA增加了约10亿美元,涨幅大约5%。在他宣誓就职之前,国会两党又追加了17亿美元。他开玩笑说,自己本来是来要钱的,结果到任时拿到的预算比他要的还多。
最后他讲了一段NASA存在的意义。NASA占联邦预算不到0.5%。从这不到0.5%里长出来的东西,包括卫星通信、电视转播、宽带互联网、导航、气象观测、农业估产。
他举了乌干达的例子:靠卫星数据提前预判灾害,减少的救灾支出以千万美元计,更重要的是救了人。
因为NASA做的事情,我们可以提高作物产量,同时减少用水量,同时保持土壤中的硝酸盐,养活世界上比以往更多的人。(吉姆·布里登斯廷)
布里登斯廷说,马斯克当年创办SpaceX的动机之一,是激励美国增加NASA预算,因为太空探索的回报太高了。
这场发布会从发射后不久开始,持续了一个多小时。马斯克在开场时说了“到目前为止”,散场时任务还在半路上。后面的对接、再入和溅落,才是真正的考验。
这场发布会真正留下的东西
把整场对话拆开看,有三条线索。
第一条是技术路线。龙飞船2号用集成式逃逸系统替代传统逃逸塔,把安全能力做进飞船本体;用自动对接替代机械臂抓取,把交会对接从“地面遥控”推进到“飞船自主”。这两项改动都指向同一个方向:减少对外部系统的依赖,让飞船自己具备更多能力。代价是复杂度上升,推进系统交错、后壳不对称,每个新设计都带来新的风险点。马斯克在发布会上花最多时间讲的,是这些风险点,很少谈成功。
第二条是组织方式。一把剪刀修喷管,一个小阀门解决液压泵卡滞。前者是现场判断,后者是流程审查。两种能力同时存在,才撑得起17年里数次濒临失败的折腾。NASA和SpaceX的关系也超出了传统的甲方乙方,用马斯克的话说,龙飞船2号“像是由NASA和SpaceX共同设计的”。
第三条是目标。马斯克讲的是月球基地和火星城市,布里登斯廷讲的是可持续重返月球、原位资源利用、26个月的地火窗口。两个人的说法不同,指向的是同一件事:把人送出近地轨道,并且留下来。
这三条线索,比发布会上的任何一句金句都更值得记住。
行动结论
关注商业航天和技术管理的人,可以从这场发布会带走几件事:
- 盯住DM-1的三个高风险节点:自动对接、高超音速再入、溅落。这三个环节的真实数据,直接决定DM-2载人飞行的时间表。
- 记住发动机这类核心部件每次迭代的公开节点。判断一家火箭公司的真实进度,看发动机试车频率比看发布会更准。
- 读马斯克讲集成式逃逸系统那一段,要抓住判断标准:一艘载人飞船的安全性,很大程度取决于它在飞行哪个阶段还能自主脱离。逃逸塔抛掉之后就没有逃逸能力,集成式设计从点火到入轨全程保留。以后看任何载人飞船的宣传材料,先问一句:逃逸能力覆盖到哪一刻。
- 把“NASA 是众多客户中的一个”当成一把尺子。评估任何一家商业航天公司,看它的客户结构。如果收入几乎全部来自政府单一订单,议价空间和迭代速度都会受限;如果它能同时服务政府、商业卫星、私人任务,成本曲线才有下降的可能。这条逻辑放到其他硬科技行业同样成立。
- 关于那把剪刀和那个泄压阀,可以提炼成一条团队管理规则:给硬件团队同时保留“现场判断权”和“流程审查”两条通道。所有改动都走流程,进度会被拖死;所有改动都靠现场拍板,隐患会静默积累。区分标准是改动能不能复现、能不能独立验证。剪刀修喷管这种一次性操作,事后必须补上原因分析和复测;小阀门这种通用件改动,就该老老实实走评审。
- 关注载人航天时间表,不要只看DM-1。真正的分水岭是飞行中逃逸测试(in-flight abort)。赫尔利在发布会上说得很清楚,那是“毕业考试”,考过了才能上DM-2。任何“今年就能载人”的说法,先看这个节点排在哪。
- 本肯那句“预测飞船会做什么,然后测试它,确认两者对得上”,是一套可以直接搬用的验收方法。不管你在做软件上线、硬件样机还是生产设备调试,核心都是先写下预期行为,再拿实际数据对照。差别只在于,航天领域把这个动作做到了每个推力器、每个阀门、每次开伞。
- 判断一个深空计划靠不靠谱,看它有没有回答“怎么在另一个世界上活下去”,而不只是“怎么到达”。月球基地的关键词是原位资源利用,是水冰、氧气、建材能不能就地取材。布里登斯廷讲的那套月球先行、验证技术、再去火星的次序,本质上是在用三天的距离给二十六个月的旅程买保险。
- 如果你需要向非技术背景的决策者解释航天投入,可以借用布里登斯廷那组数字:NASA占联邦预算不到0.5%,长出来的东西包括卫星通信、导航、气象、农业估产、灾害预警。他用乌干达提前预判灾害、减少千万美元级救灾支出的例子,比任何宏大叙事都更有说服力。这个论证结构可以直接套用到其他长周期基础研究上。
- 最后一条,留给那个漂浮在舱里的小地球玩偶。一场技术发布会,公众记住的往往是这种具体、可视、能被转发的细节,推力数据反而容易被忘掉。做技术传播的人可以记住这一点:想让外行理解你在做什么,先给他们一个能在脑子里浮起来的东西。
DM-1后来完成了对接,也完成了溅落。四个月后,飞行中逃逸测试成功。2020年5月30日,本肯和赫尔利坐进龙飞船2号,从同一座39A发射台升空。距离这场发布会,十四个月。
0:00welcome my name is batina enlan I'm the associate administrator of communications here at Nasa and thank you for joining us for the post-launch briefing of demo one just as a reminder for each of reporters please say your name and organization we also have reporters calling in on the line so and also questions from social media please be respectful of your of the other reporters and one reporter per question with that I'm going to turn it over to NASA administrator Jim brightenstein well thank you batina it's an exciting evening we've got a a great group of folks here that can share some of their experiences I'll introduce them and then and then we'll I'll say a
0:38few words and and turn it over to Elon Musk to say a few words about the about tonight's or I should say today's event whatever time it may be I'm not sure so to start the CEO and lead designer of SpaceX Elon Musk is here we have two astronauts Bob Benin and Doug Hurley who will be flying on the demo 2 mission which we're anxiously anticipating we have Steve Stitch the deputy manager of the commercial crew program and the NASA launch manager for demo one way down on my far right and Kirk shyan the manager of the International Space Station program to my immediate right so tonight was a a a big night for the United States of America a great night for NASA what
1:28to what today really represents is is a new era in space flight and an era where we are looking forward to being One customer as an agency and as a country we're looking forward to being One customer of many customers in a in a robust commercial Marketplace in low earth orbit so that we can drive down cost and increase access in ways that historically have not been possible and we have our first provider of multiple providers today that had a a su successful launch this is just the beginning we're still in the first quarter as a 5-day Mission and and we're looking forward to Future successes on this Mission and missions Beyond this one so Elon I'll turn
2:15it over to you for a few of your opening comments sure well thank you well I just like to Express a a very strong note of appreciation for the SpaceX team and that's worked it's it's been 177 years to get to this point from 2002 to now and incredible amount of hardworking Sacrifice from a lot of people that gotten to this point and yeah to be frank I'm I'm a little emotionally exhausted because that was super stressful but it worked so far we have
3:00to dock with station we have to come back but as so far it has worked some of the riskiest items have we've passed some the risk riskus items but I'd like to also Express a great appreciation for NASA SpaceX would not be here without NASA without the incredible work that was done before spaceex even started and without the support after Space X did start so thank you absolutely well it's it's great to great to have so many people here so early in the morning so we'll just open it up I'll if people have questions I'll just call on folks as as we go the gentleman right here in the gray jacket Ivanov a FR Mr
3:46MK do you have any customers for the capsule private customers other than NASA we've not sought any private customers our Focus has been on serving NASA's needs but once the once dragon is in in regular operation I think we will we will seek commercial customers and of which the NASA administrator and NASA in general has been very supportive of of that of that idea so but we've been very focused on just making sure that the the vehicle worked and maximizing safety and reliability and we've not put any any effort into yet into commercial customers we'll go to the the gentleman right behind him hi good morning Tom costell with NBC News and congratulations to all Elon
4:40can you talk about now what does what does today prove to NASA and to the world about your capabilities at SpaceX and dragon is specific specifically well the we're only Poway through the mission but the the system thus far has passed an exhaustive set of reviews and then in the launch itself the launch went as expected so so far everything is nominal the
5:15Dragon 2 or crew dragon is a fundamental redesign it's there I don't hardly a part in common with dragon one which in retrospect they probably change actually but it's there's a lot massive amount of new new equipment on the vehicle and everything appears to be working fine so yeah we opened the nose cone the
5:44the for Draco Thruster is fired the propellant system is working it's much more complex than Dragon 1 because you have the integrated launch Escape thrusters the super Draco launches gate thrusters on the side I in fact I'm not sure people so know why is the you know what say say better about Dragon than than some other vehicles is that it does have integrated Escape integrated Escape system so previously you'd have a tractor Escape system like a a solid rocket motor on mounted on the nose of the capsule as a as sort of a tractor it would sort of pull the the the the spacecraft away that's how soos works for example but in this in the
6:39case of dragon they're they're integrated so you have an abort capability all the way to orbit so and you do not have to worry about a separation event of the launch Escape system so this this is I think quite a big safety Improvement in in principle and then over the next hopefully tomorrow in about 24 hours we'll be docking with the space station so that we'll be able to dock the space station without using the the the arm yeah go
7:14ahead Picture Perfect launch maging voyage for for the dragon over the next five days has to go through a number of important steps you have a checklist that you have to go through are there any moments in particular that you are will would find especially challenging or worrisome well I think docking with the space station is going to be will be docking for the first time previously we would go close to space station and the AL would reach out and and grab in drag case dragon one and would grab Dragon one and attach it to the space station in this case the spacecraft will fly on literally fly onto the space station and attach itself so that's certainly going to be you
7:58something new that we've never done before and and then re-entry because the the back shell is is not symmetric in the way that Dragon one is and it's it's not sort of a smooth conic like Dragon one you've got the launches cave Thruster pods that could potentially could potentially cause a Roy instability on re-entry but I think it's unlikely we've Run simulations a thousand times but at the is a possibility so I think that that the rentry with the asymmetric backshell and then the the parachutes are new will the parachutes deploy correctly will it and then will it will the system guide draging
8:48to to the right location and splash down safely I see Hypersonic R entry is probably my biggest concern oh just because the asymmetric backshell yeah for a week we'll go right here yes we didn't get a chance to see the camera inside the capsule oh at liftoff in the first minute what did you see what data how did the oh sure mannequin
9:28test dumy R ly do yeah I the video we did get video from the ground station so in fact we'll hopefully be able to post some of that soon and for sure once you get close to the station we'll have a good video link from inside the spacecraft the bias was towards data getting making sure we got the data down so data is all looking really good and but I I think if for members of the public the the real fun thing would be seeing celest the little Celestial buddy little tiny Earth humanoid Earth thing floating around in zero g I think the public were probably most excited about that well it's in zero now but it would oh and it's fine yeah it's like
10:15probably probably we got to about four and a half GS or something like that it's no problem yeah the mannequin didn't complain once yeah no it looked fine you couldn't even tell it's just a it looked like a still yeah look fine we'll go right here in the front Tim do the everyday astronaut I have a question regarding when you had the the failure of of landing and you had a block freeze of the Falcon 9 you know block five you're unable to make changes according to NASA's requests how did it you know when you have non-mission critical things like gridin hydraulic pumps that seiz what were you able to do as far as you know you're in a freeze of the
10:57vehicle how did that affect certific going on were you able to make tweaks to the hydraulic systems were you able to add a redundant pump already or did it not is that not considered a freeze I guess or what's that like I guess no we've been actually able to work with NASA very well and and make changes as think it's like as I
11:20said earlier the the you know I think you can almost think of like you know D it's it's this was like kind of co-designed by you know NASA and SpaceX like in the sense that that there was so much interaction and feedback that you know this this you know this is a joint joint effort really and the
11:47NASA engineering team understands the vehicle really quite well very well and so when we want to make changes provide those changes are sound then we we meet and confer and get it done and we're able to fix the the grid for hydraulic pump stall pretty easily actually without having a redundant pump there just turned out to be like a bizarre sort of stall Zone and and with a little bit of a tiny relief valve we're able to fix this easy I would say from a massive perspective we work hand inand with SpaceX they will propose changes to us we have an engineering team that will look at every one of those changes in this particular one it was a pretty simple valve change to
12:31improve that grid fin performance SpaceX proposed it they bring it to us we kind of go through it with our process and Engineers look at it and then then we make those changes to the vehicle so it's a very methodical process I would say we have great teamwork between NASA and SpaceX yeah done some PR I mean obviously not for for for a mission like this but we done some pretty wild wild things I was just talking with B gme earlier and reflecting on that time when we had a we had to trim the nozzle of the merland vacuum engine so this the
13:06c103 nozzle which like noi half nozzle for the vacuum extension had like a little tear in it so we we we went we basically sent one of our best tchs in there to trim it with a pair of scissors and I was like this is pretty crazy but you know B and I was like well you know should work it did did did work we'll go right here in the N chirt Mary Li Bender with the planetary Society Elon you've spent 17 years pushing past adversity doubt and you must feel incredible to finally be at this stage I'm just curious what advice you have to all the dreamers out there that are dealing with the same kind of doubt that you did oh I was thought we would fail so
14:00this is all it's all upside you know I thought maybe we had a 10% chance reaching Orit starting out so then people told when we started SpaceX they said oh you're going to fail I so I agree I think we probably will fail yeah it's worth trying anyway [Laughter] yeah yeah how's that for honesty huh yeah this this let i' lose like you know lose all the money from PayPal I was like well you're probably right you know and we almost did we first three launches of Falcon one didn't work and the fourth one we scraped together some parts and and that one worked and if that one hadn't worked it would be would have been that would have been it for us so I I really believe in the future
14:46of space and and I think it's important that we become a space Fring civilization and and out be out there among the stars and I think that's one of the things that you know makes people excited about the future and it you we want the things that are in science fiction novels and movies not to be science fiction forever we want them to be real one day does anyone have questions for the astronauts or specifics on Commercial crew or the
15:17ISS you again okay gent hi I'm stepen Clark from space flight now had a question about the re-entry since Elon mentioned that one of the riskier parts of this test flight I understand the re-entry is going to be a descending node over the US is that correct and I remember during the shuttle days overflight over populated area was a concern and was always got some extra scrutiny so I'm curious if that's something you've discussed and talk about the any risk that was assessed and how you dispose of that risk to decide for a descending no re-entry thanks Kirk or Steve yeah yeah I I can take that one so yeah you're correct the the entry is we're Landing right off
16:02the coast of Florida just a little bit north of here there's an area that SpaceX is sort of designed as their landing area in terms of Entry risk there's a a process we go through to assess that risk we take a look at the components on the spacecraft and look at the worst case kind of scenarios that could happen during entry and there's a criteria we have to meet and so what we've done is we worked hand inand with SpaceX to look at the the spacecraft how it's composed how it flies they run models and simulations of how it lands we have an independent modeling system that we employed and so we went through that whole process to ensure the safety
16:41of the public relative to Landing as Elon said it is one of the areas that we're interested in for this Mission as well for crew you know if you look at the the rest of the mission in the highest risk periods it's obviously docking with station and then then the landing phase I think we'll learn a lot about the modeling of the vehicle how the a DCS works for this particular vehicle and the GNC system during entry so we're really excited about that part of the mission and getting that data for the crude missions later on we go to Reuters here in the
17:14front Kirk Steve what's the biggest takeaway you hope to learn from this Mission and based on what you've learned in the past and what you expect to learn in the coming weeks how confident are you to say that we'll see a humans launch from us soil this year or in the summer well so far it's looking quite promising yeah we're only Poway into the mission but so far it appear it seems
17:41looking very good the Dragon 2 has very complex propelling system because of the fact that it's got an on orbit maneuvering it's got 16 on orbit maneuvering thrusters the little Draco thrusters which are kind of small thrusters and it's got the eight super Draco thrusters which are very powerful thrusters and that the two are interwoven in a way that's quite tricky and the the main maneuvering thrusters on orbit actually thrust
18:08in the opposite direction that the propellant wants to flow but so those worked the the forward thrusters under the nose cone worked which is that's that's a big risk reduction the nose cone opened which is cool the solar arrays work so far everything looks good so you know docking was mentioned re-entry you know can sort of see the illustration of there on the wall what I mean by the the back shell not being sort of a smooth conic like it is on Falcon on on Dragon one it's got those Escape Thruster pods so
18:45you know should be fine but that would be you know a thing to make sure that it works on re-entry make sure the docking system works everything we know so far is looking positive and unless something goes wrong I would think that we'll be flying hopefully this year yeah I mean the summer hopefully Steve Kirk did you wanna yeah go ahead Steve yeah I would just Echo what elen said to me it's really a a bit of a dress rehearsal for the demo 2 mission we're going to fly all aspects of the mission so I think we'll learn you know a lot of subtle things about the spacecraft how it does thermally how the GNC system works getting into the Rendevous it'll be
19:33really important to check out how the sensors work as we approach station you know it's the first time we've flown to the this particular integrated docking apparatus with this vehicle there's a series of steps we'll take as we move in closer to station to make sure that the systems are performing well on the dragon obviously the crew on station will be monitoring the vehicle coming in and and then at the end of the flight you know while we're docked also we'll understand how how it works at station we're going to exchange data between dragon and the space station we exchange air flow between the two vehicles and then at the end of the flight we'll do the undock maneuver
20:13and then separate the trunk is another big big event right the before we deorbit we'll separate the trunk and then come in for the deorbited entry so lots of different pieces and each piece you know my experience is they will learn a little bit and as Elon said the flight going great so far and I would turn it over to Kirk to see yeah so the cool thing is you learn engineering things like we you talked about with operations things so docking coming close to the ISS it's a test flight but not really for us we we consider this one for score it really is flying to the ISS and we really want to protect the crew on board and the asset so it we'll
20:49learn that we actually had to learn how to to to protect spacex's proprietary data when working with our International partners and so there's this whole dimensions of of of learning and we've already done a tremendous amount of work and I'm sure we're going to have some surprises along the way that's what makes us so much fun want you to take a question from our social media participants okay Powell majack perhaps on Twitter is asking how are the dragon astronauts feeling about the spacecraft I guess I would say for us you know we've been following the the process for a few years at this point we've made a lot of trips out to Hawthorne to kind of see this spacecraft
21:31come together and the spacecraft that we fly on later this year come together as well and so seeing a success like this definitely gives us a lot of confidence in the future and you know like folks have described really this is about predicting what the vehicle's going to do and then testing it and making sure that those two things match up as you kind of go through this Mission and that's what's going to give us that confidence going forward and launch has been wonderful activation has been wonderful we still have some significant events going forward that we'll want to make sure match up as well I think the other thing I think that maybe to allude to the previous question
22:04a little bit is that I think we also have learned how to work together as a team and that that's really the reason that Doug and I came to to Florida to participate from inside the firing room we of course on launch day won't be able to do that but it's great to understand how that Team Works being a member of it that's maybe not represented during the demo1 mission we can take advantage of this experience and and take that with us when we fly on our Miss missions later this year we'll be racing across the country going to Hawthorne to see docking and then also to see the Splash Town from out there as well so we're feeling pretty good about it and it's really about each
22:39one of these Milestones getting accomplished and you know giving us more confidence in the future Doug did you wantan to yeah all I'll say is you know this is the the buildup approach that we learned very early as test pilots and you know we've worked ourselves to our first flight of the vehicle with dm1 and then as Bob said we'll work through those milestones and then next up is the inflight abort and we'll have that to go you know follow as as they go through that exercise and then that's kind of the graduation exercise for us to get on dm2 and go fly so we'll we'll work with the teams and we'll be out out in California we'll be here and we're
23:21looking forward to supporting all of those events the aqua shirt right here excuse me Dave Moor Business Insider and Insider I suppose this is for Elon you said you're emotionally drained right now having launched an uncrewed crew Dragon but you've got these two guys sitting right next to you do how are you do you think you're going to feel and and handle that experience going into demo to like any any thoughts on that how you're going to get through that launch I suspect it will be extremely stressful but I mean during during the
24:02you know this test flight I think goes a long way towards feeling good about the the flight with Bob and Doug so in fact right after dragon you know separated and fired the thrusters I went over and asked them what they they thought you know and they're like how do you feel about flying on it like seems like you feel good about flying on it I was like okay you [Laughter] now they're in the control room look watching all the data so I'm like yeah awesome when the guys told us what was going to happen and that's what happened that's how we like it to be so yeah so but I we're ask make sure they're they're feel feeling good about it and you guys were so we're well you know we
24:48definitely want launch till we've done everything we can possibly think of that's for sure and I think this plus the high altitude of ort gives a lot of lot of confidence about the the actual Mission with astronauts Aviation week thanks I ran claws with Aviation week for Bob or Doug did you
25:10see anything from your perspective in the fire room that in the countdown or in fueling anything in the calls that kind of initially you're flagging is something you'd like to take another look at and for Elon thanks for coming out here we've seen you here after the first reuse of a falcon 9 and for Falcon heavy big picture how does this flight fit into your overall objectives and satisfactions personally and professionally thanks well it's the whole goal of SpaceX was get crude space flight try
25:54improve space exp exploration technology that's actually the full name of the company is space exploration Technologies so the goal is like improve space exploration technology and that's with view towards you know helping make Humanity a space Frank civilization it's been 17 years we still haven't launched anyone yet but hopefully we will later this year and so that
26:20would definitely be the culmination of a long dream for a lot of people me and a lot of people it's face sex for sure can't wait Bob and Doug yeah I think it it was we've probably seen half a dozen maybe three4 of a dozen combination of static fires or launches either from here from Hawthorne and you know every time we participate you know it's it's just amazing to see how the team is hitting its stride getting these vehicles ready to go into space and I think you know every launch count or every static fire there are technical issues that the team has to go back and solve real time and and and I don't think this was any different and I thought everybody
27:10handled their you know their roles very well and it seemed like everything went smoothly all the way up until launch and so far so good so from our standpoint this is this is what you want to see you want to see the team hitting its stride as we get ready to put people on these things and kind of as Doug described We've we've seen several static fires or launches from various locations from McGregor from here watching along in Hawthorne and I think from our perspective is the the thing that's been different with the demo1 mission is kind of the integrated operation so seeing the dragon team work with the Falcon team you know usually it's a little bit
27:49more of a standalone payload it seems from the missions that we've seen in this case there can be you know there can be things that you need to communicate between those two teams kind of real time and to see the team kind of process that you know kind of causes us to to think a little bit about hey what is the what's the crew perspective about that what's Dragon going to tell the ground and what's it going to tell us and what does the Falcon team need to know about that that's a piece of this that we we got to see on demo one and we'll get to make sure as we go forward that that's all captured in the simulations as we as we move forward so that integration we got to see it here
28:22and and we'll continue to see that as we get closer to flight right here in the second row Mara done Associated Press for Elon I'm assuming you were in the firing room for launch if that's so and how much does it add to the satisfaction of seeing your rocket launch from the Moon pads the shuttle pads and here you are in the firing room used by NASA for so many years in Traditions I mean does that just add to the pleasure tell talk about that I would never believed that this would ever happen
29:05yeah I just think you know the humanity landing on the moon man that was maybe the greatest thing ever maybe the greatest thing ever so I can't believe we're launching from that pad thank you thank you for letting us let's do that thank you for refurbishing it yeah yeah it's it's really hard to believe it's incredible
29:42history hope we go back to the Moon soon that's the goal yeah have we should have a base on the moon like a a permanently occupied human base on the moon and send people to Mars you know and the city p a city on Mars that's what we should do the gentleman in the back put your hand up high
30:08there Mike from Fox 35 Elon after you looked at Bob and Doug and said how do you guys feel about going up in it did they say to you how do you feel Elon and I wonder under what circumstances would you get in it and take a ride yeah I'd be happy to go on the ble I think it's I think it's good design a lot of crazy amount of hard work from a lot of smart people at SpaceX and with a lot of help from NASA and I think it's a good vehicle and you guys think it's a good vehicle right yeah we we're we're going to do one more question gentlemen in the a wait until Sunday before reach any conclusions or a week when lands wait one last question here
31:06great Ken Kramer for space up close thanks for doing this Jim brightenstein you mentioned you want NASA to be one of many customers so my question Elon where do you see Dragon going Beyond NASA what would you like to do what expand on that thanks well I think like the obvious thing would be you know if there are you sort of private citizens that want go to the space station as happened before they they've always gone on on the soy before you know there been a number of people that have gone to the space station on the soy and I think it' be pretty cool if people went to the face station on an American vehicle as well you know so is a good vehicle but but it' be good
31:50if if if you know there also commercial trips on on an American vehicle as well and that's so I think that's one of the things that that we'll we'll do and and obviously NASA is very supportive of that and yeah so and and then you know maybe there's something Beyond Beyond this beyond the space station that we we'll see going to focus on the getting this this right for sure that's the priority but then after that maybe something beyond beyond lit so I'll go ahead and and close it out you know we just heard Elon say he'd he'd be interested in having a permanent presence on the moon for sure we should do it well that's that's the that's the very first
32:41space policy directive given by the president of the United States to me as the NASA administrator that we're going to go to the moon and we're going to go sustainably so what that means is when we say sustainably that means we're going to stay and of course the objective here is not just just humans but also Landers and Rovers and robots and humans and and and
33:04utilizing our International partners and utilizing our commercial partners and there's no doubt SpaceX SpaceX has some really amazing ideas about what they could help us do at the Moon and what they could help the Coalition of international Partners do as we develop this together but the president's space policy directive is clear we're going to the Moon we're going sustainably we're going with International Partners we're going with commercial Partners we're going to utilize the resources of the Moon that's a critically important part of the agenda why we have to be able to live and work on another world for long periods of time we have to be able to
33:43use those resources of another world which is of course a a great opportunity for us to prove those capabilities and Technologies on the moon because as it happens you know Mars and Earth are only aligned once every every 26 months on the same side of the sun which means when we go to Mars which I know is high on elon's agenda and it's high on NASA's agenda when we go to Mars we have to be there for a long periods of time so we have to figure out how to how to do insitu resource utilization and then ultimately we need to prove all of this out at the Moon which is a three-day Journey from Earth which means we we have a risk mitigation capability right there we've
34:23seen what happens with Apollo 13 when something goes wrong you can get home home if something goes wrong on the way to Mars it becomes a lot more difficult and so that's why the moon matters it's why the Moon is so important it's the proven ground and then at the end we want to take all those Technologies all those capabilities we want to retire the risk and and go to Mars there's great alignment between NASA and our
34:49commercial partners and as we're seeing now with our International Partners just yesterday I don't even know what day it is it's like two days ago I guess now we had a great announcement from from Canada and they announced that they're going to be with us for the next 24 years in our sustainable return to the moon and that's the kind of long-term enduring commitment that we need we need to grow the international partnership and that means the partners that are currently there we need them to help us in a bigger level the International Space Station amazing amazing development that has proven the concept we need to grow it we need every piece of the architecture between the
35:29Earth and the moon to include our International Partners it's not just about Gateway it's not just about the International Space Station but it's about the entire exploration agenda in three different theaters that includes low earth orbit that includes the moon and it includes Mars and putting together a a grand bargain if you will between our International partners and our commercial Partners in a way that can be transformative for generations to come so that we can have that permanent presence of humans on another world starting with the moon and eventually Mars and absolutely it's a it's a bright future right now and I will say this and I I say this every time I have
36:09the opportunity to talk to an audience and with all the cameras here it's more important than ever the president's first budget request increased our budget at Nasa by a billion dollars which was about a 5% increase and then even before I got sworn in as the NASA administrator a bipartisan Congress in both the house and the Senate plused us up by$ 1.7 billion doar so I thought I was coming in to advocate for a bigger budget and in fact by the time I got there it was actually smaller than what Congress had already given us which is a really good problem for NASA to have and interestingly today as as Elon and I were out on on the Launchpad
36:4839a we we had a conversation about why he got involved in this to begin with and it was to inspire America to increase Nas budget because of the return we get on those activities now it is true you know the idea that we can put humans on another world for long periods of time is great but the benefits Humanity has received from space exploration in general is immeasurable the return on investment we get from that as a nation and in fact as a world the way we communicate all of these cameras Direct TV Dish Network Internet Broadband from space I see a lot of people here they're going to put this on the internet we talk about XM radio for example but the way we
37:29communicate the way we navigate The Way We produce food was recently at the a Expo and you know we're sensing the earth in every part of the mag electromagnetic spectrum and because of that we can increase crop yields we can reduce water usage at the same time we can preserve nitrates in the soil feeding more of the world than ever before because of what NASA does that's an amazing capability and we didn't developed the satellites for that purpose but because we have that data we can share it not only with the United States Farmers but around the world we we saved tens of millions of dollars in disaster relief that would have gone to Uganda but be because we were able to
38:06predict ahead of time a disaster situation developing we could mitigate and save not only money for us in in the form of aid but also lives in Uganda but the way we produce food the way we understand weather the way we understand climate the way we do you know National Security and disaster relief all of these things were born and I understand a lot of it's commercialized and we're we love that helps save our US money at Nasa but a lot of it's commercialized a lot of it is is is done by the Department of Defense but at the end of the day it's born from this little agency that occupies less than one half of 1% of the federal budget and the return on that has been astonishing so
38:49the idea that this event today was was born from a concept of how do we how do we encourage America to increase the NASA budget friends we have that opportunity right now and and it is in fact happening with bipartisan support in Congress and support from the administration so we're we're at a great time today's event was was amazing to watch and over the next five days we're going to see a lot more Milestones be achieved and certainly as an agency and as a country and really as a world with our International Partners we're going to be able to do more than ever before so I just want to thank everybody with the TV cameras and the and the iPhones
39:30get this message to the world it's an important message and I'm so grateful for all of you being here and covering this very important achievement in American history so thank you guys so much thank you everyone for joining us if you have more information please visit nasa.gov thank you and have a great day
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版