Code Conference 2021 的台上,主持人卡拉·斯威舍(Kara Swisher)问马斯克,美国政府对加密货币应该做点什么。他的回答是三个字:什么都别做(do nothing),让它飞。
四十分钟后,同一个台上,他说 AI 安全必须要有监管机构,而且要尽快。
这两句话摆在一起,看着像自相矛盾。把整场对话听完会发现,他判断一件事该不该管的尺子相当稳定:这项技术会不会让人受害。加密货币被政府掐死,受损的是普通人;AI 失控,受害的也是普通人。
这场访谈信息密度很高,从中国的电力短缺一直聊到模拟假说。挑几条最有价值的展开。
政府摧毁不了比特币,但能让它慢下来
话题从中国开始。2021 年 5 月,中国监管部门对加密货币挖矿和交易出手,比特币算力一度腰斩。
马斯克给出的解释分两层。表层是电。他说中国南方当时确实出现了随机停电,电力需求超出预期,加密货币挖矿可能在其中扮演了某种角色。
但他认为这只是表层。真正的原因在下面这层。
加密货币从根本上就是要削弱中心化政府的权力。他们不喜欢这一点。这是我的猜测。(马斯克)
主持人追问,那政府能不能把它彻底干掉。马斯克的回答很精确:
我觉得摧毁加密货币是不可能的,但政府可以让它的发展速度慢下来。(马斯克)
摧毁和延缓,是两个量级的动词。他没有说加密货币不可战胜,他说的是分布式的账本没法被一个中心关掉,但可以让你挖不了矿、换不了法币、上不了交易所。
那美国该怎么做。此前不久,SEC 主席加里·根斯勒(Gary Gensler)在同一场活动上把加密金融称作“狂野西部的金融”。马斯克的建议是别管。他承认这个回答听起来不像一个负责任的企业家,但他坚持这个判断。
货币的本质是信息,而且是一堆不联网的老旧数据库
马斯克说过一句被很多人忽略的话:他不太懂经济学家怎么想,但他知道支付系统在物理层面是怎么跑的。
他把货币当成信息系统来看。评价一个货币体系,可以套用信息论的四个指标:带宽、延迟、丢包率、安全性。欺诈相当于网络里的丢包,结算时间就是延迟。
按这个框架看,现有金融体系的表现相当难看。
货币体系基本上是一堆异构的数据库,彼此不同步、非实时,只能靠批量对账。对账时间从 24 小时到好几天不等。ACH 系统基本上没有安全性可言。1999 年 PayPal 成立时是这样,22 年之后还是这样。(马斯克)
他形容政府在“编辑货币数据库”,像一台藏在弗吉尼亚某处的古老大型机。这个说法带着调侃,但指向一个真实的问题:货币的发行和记账权集中在少数机构手里,修改规则的成本极低。
所以他对加密货币的期待并不高,也没把它当成救世主。原话是:
我不认为它是某些人以为的弥赛亚再临。它有望降低传统货币体系的误差和延迟,这就够了。(马斯克)
这个定位很克制。加密货币的价值在于它提供了一个无法被单方面修改的账本,至于这个账本上的资产值多少钱,是另一回事。
马云去哪了,马斯克的回答比问题更有意思
主持人问,中国对科技企业家的态度在收紧,马云现在在哪。
马斯克说,我不知道,我也很好奇。
接下来他给了一个很少听到的解释。他认为中国这套体系的运行,很大程度上依赖面对面的会议。过去 18 个月疫情阻断了这种会议,很多事没法当面谈,于是问题被放大了。
我觉得随着疫情缓解、面对面会议恢复,信任水平会提升,事情会朝更积极的方向走。(马斯克)
主持人追问,所以这些反垄断动作是因为没法当面打招呼?马斯克承认不是所有事都能这么解释,但有一部分可以。
他补充,特斯拉上海工厂运转良好,中国团队做得很好,车既供中国市场也出口欧洲。被问到是否担心中美关系,他说目前不太担心。
这段回答真诚度不低,也暴露了他的思维习惯:遇到复杂的政治问题,他倾向于找一个物理层面的、可量化的解释,比如“人们没法见面”。这个习惯解释了他后面讲的几乎所有话题。
亚轨道和轨道之间,差着一百倍的能量
2021 年 7 月,布兰森和贝佐斯先后完成亚轨道飞行。9 月,SpaceX 把四个普通人送上轨道,绕地球飞了三天。
马斯克没上去。他说自己的目标不是亲自上天,是把太空对全人类打开,让文明走上多行星物种的路。
他对亚轨道飞行的评价不高不低。方向上是对的,难度上差得远。
进入轨道需要的能量大约是亚轨道的 100 倍。返回时你还得把这些能量烧掉,所以需要重型隔热罩,因为你是以流星的速度冲进来的。轨道比亚轨道难大概两个数量级。(马斯克)
这句话解释了为什么蓝色起源和维珍银河的飞行只有几分钟,而 SpaceX 的龙飞船要在轨飞行三天。前者是抛物线上去再掉下来,后者是横向速度足够快,快到掉不下来。
他对两位竞争对手花钱做这件事的评价是正面的:人类应该成为跨行星文明,科幻小说里的东西有一天该变成真的。
星链不是 5G 的对手,它是给没网的人兜底的
当时星链在轨约一千五百颗卫星,长期目标是三万颗。这个数字常被拿来批评太空垃圾问题。
马斯克先讲了物理。地球同步轨道在 36000 公里高度,星链在 550 公里。差 65 倍的距离,延迟差出一个量级。550 公里的延迟足够玩竞技类网络游戏,体验接近地面宽带。
然后是定位。这一点他讲得清楚:
星链不是 5G 或地面光纤的威胁。它适合低到中等人口密度的地区,那些铺光纤、建 5G 基站不划算的地方。城市里一个波束覆盖范围很大,可能服务不到 5% 的人。(马斯克)
换句话说,星链服务的是那批被现有网络遗忘的人:网速太慢的、太贵的、干脆没有的。全球大概 5% 的人口。
为什么值得做,他给了一笔账。发射业务,也就是帮别人发卫星、给空间站送货,收入上限大概在每年三四十亿美元。如果星链能拿下全球互联网流量的 3%,那是一个每年约一万亿美元的市场,SpaceX 的收入能涨一个数量级,到三百亿美元左右。
这笔钱不是为了让他更有钱。是为了造去火星的火箭。
猎鹰 9 的边际成本是一千五百万美元,星舰要做到一百万以下
马斯克在这里讲了一段火箭经济学,值得细看。
猎鹰 9 是两级火箭。助推级可以回收,上面级是一次性的。他打了个比方:助推级像一架大飞机,上面级像一架小飞机,现在每次发射都要扔掉一架小飞机。
即便如此,猎鹰 9 已经是全球最有竞争力的火箭。助推器有的已经飞到第 10 次。不算 overhead 分摊,单次发射的边际成本约 1500 万美元,载荷 15 吨。这个价格是竞争对手的一半到三分之一。
过去一年,SpaceX 运送了全球约三分之二的入轨载荷,剩下三分之一大部分来自中国。
星舰要做的,是把“大部分可复用”变成“完全可复用”。
星舰的边际发射成本有可能低于一百万美元,载荷 100 吨,优化后大概 150 吨。也就是说,载荷是猎鹰 9 的 10 倍,成本是它的十五分之一。相当于一次性系统的 1%。(马斯克)
成本降两个数量级,性质就变了。不是“发射变便宜了”,是“火星城市的账算得过来了”。他讲得很直白:星舰让自给自足的火星城市在经济上成为可能,也让月球基地成为可能。
这也是他当时把大部分时间花在星舰上的原因。
贝佐斯的火箭形状,和一场关于登月合同的官司
NASA 的载人着陆系统合同给了 SpaceX,金额 29 亿美元。蓝色起源抗议,后来起诉,合同一度冻结。
马斯克的评价很不客气:
我觉得他应该把更多精力放在进入轨道上,而不是打官司。不管你的律师多厉害,你没法靠这个到月球。(马斯克)
他提到自己劝过贝佐斯,让对方把重心放到入轨上。两人之间“不算友好”。
主持人问他怎么看待蓝色起源火箭的外形。马斯克笑了一下,说如果只做亚轨道,火箭确实可以做得短一点。
玩笑归玩笑,星舰的设计逻辑他在后面讲清楚了。它是一个通用运输系统,推进式着陆,只要有固体表面就能降落。支持轨道加注:先把星舰送上去,再发几艘加油船补满推进剂,Delta-v 就非常充裕,可以去地球轨道以外的任何地方。
为什么先去月球。因为近。月球基地的价值,他拿南极科考站做类比:阿波罗登月时全人类都跟着去了,那种激励作用没法用钱衡量。
死在火星上,但不是摔死在火星上
马斯克说过很多次想死在火星。这次主持人追问了一句,是着陆时摔死吗。
他说不是。“出生在地球,死在火星”,只是从两个选项里挑一个更酷的。
关于火星生存的细节,他讲得比想象中具体。有人担心辐射,他说不用挖几百英尺深。一半时间火星本体就帮你挡住了一半辐射,剩下的一半,屋顶铺三英尺左右的土就够了。
重力是地球的 40%。他说在火星上人可能会变高一点。
大过滤器:火星城市的维生素 C 是什么
这场访谈里马斯克讲得最深的一段,是关于“大过滤器”的。
这个概念来自费米悖论:宇宙这么大,如果生命常见,为什么我们没看到任何外星文明。可能的解释是,文明在发展到某个阶段之前,会撞上一道过不去的坎。那些坎就是大过滤器。
马斯克认为,能不能成为多行星物种,就是其中一道。
火星城市的关键门槛是:如果来自地球的补给船因为任何原因停止,火星是会繁荣还是消亡。这个原因可能是平淡无奇的,也可能是第三次世界大战。如果火星缺了任何一样东西,相当于文明层面的维生素 C,它最终会死掉。(马斯克)
自给自足不是道德口号,是生存条件。一个依赖地球补给的火星前哨站,在地球出事的第二天就变成墓园。
他说这道坎应该在本世纪内跨过去。主持人说你那时候会很老了,他说自己大概率已经死了,也许老了会过去一趟。
ProPublica 的报道,和 53% 的边际税率
2021 年 6 月,ProPublica 发布了一份基于国税局内部数据的报道,标题是《机密国税局文件显示,最富有的美国人如何避税》。里面提到马斯克某几年缴纳的联邦所得税为零。
主持人在台上直接问他,你怎么回应。
马斯克先讲了政府合同。他说 SpaceX 赢的每一份合同,都是因为价格更好、服务更好,不是白给的。月球着陆器那个标的,SpaceX 报价是蓝色起源和洛克希德联合体的一半,载荷是对方的 8 到 10 倍,为纳税人省了大概 30 亿美元。
然后讲他个人的税。
我不拿工资,现金报酬基本为零。收入对大多数人来说是个问题,因为他们要对收入缴税。我有的是股票期权。(马斯克)
他解释为什么过去很多年没缴多少税:他从来不套现。绝大多数创业者会卖掉一部分股票,把钱拿到手,落袋为安。他没有。特斯拉和 SpaceX 多次濒临破产,他一股没卖。
现在这件事被倒过来,说成了一件坏事。这很离谱。(马斯克)
真正缴税发生在期权到期时。必须行权,行权即纳税。他的最高边际税率是 53%,也就是一半以上的收益要交出去,第二年可能涨到 57%。
他说有一大批期权在 2022 年初到期,所以 2021 年第四季度会卖出一大笔股票,因为不卖就作废了。大部分卖出都会被课税。
至于 ProPublica 说的“借贷炒股避税”,他的回应是:借钱加杠杆在牛市里像游戏,到了衰退期就是追加保证金,然后归零。每次衰退都这样。
有一年他的税确实接近零,原因是他前一年多缴了。这个细节 ProPublica 没提。
推特瘾君子,和“做空者致富委员会”
主持人问他,你跟推特到底什么关系。
我是个推特瘾君子。有些人用发型表达自己,我用推特。(马斯克)
问他发之前会不会想。他说会想几个小时,还会咨询策略团队。然后自己补了一句:
或者我可能喝多了,心想让我朝自己脚上开一枪,砰。再来一枪,砰。(马斯克)
他说这确实描述了他的一部分推文。
被问到 SEC 会不会介入,他把 SEC 的全称改了:不是证券交易委员会,是“做空者致富委员会”(Short seller enrichment commission)。这个梗在特斯拉被做空最凶的那几年流传很广。
“时间就是货币”那条推文他很喜欢,说时间是终极货币,不管你多有钱,都没法把时钟拨回去。
拜登那条推文的背景是这样的:白宫办了一场电动车峰会,邀请了通用、福特、克莱斯勒和全美汽车工人联合会,特斯拉没收到邀请,会上一次都没提到特斯拉,还夸了福特引领电动车革命。
马斯克说,这个政府看起来不太友好,似乎被工会控制。
被问到想不想当总统。他答得干脆:一点也不想,当总统听起来毫无乐趣。
他认为美国需要一个温和的中间派总统,不要太左,不要太右,一个能力强的管理者就够了。
民主有点让人担心,人口崩溃更让人担心
主持人问他对民主的看法。他说有点担心,用了个词是“a smidge”,一丝。
他担心的是舆论环境。他研究过宣传是怎么运作的,觉得很多对话正在变得不对劲。有人说“这种事不可能发生在美国”,他的回答是:完全可能。
然后他抛出了一个和主流叙事相反的判断。很多人都觉得地球人太多了,他的看法相反:
人口增长率的快速下滑,可能是人类文明面临的单一最大风险。数据摆在那里,任何人都能查。但很多人还停留在保罗·埃利希《人口爆炸》那本书的结论里,那是很久以前的事了,今天不是那样。(马斯克)
他说 2020 年和 2021 年的出生率出现了一个大缺口。没有婴儿就没有人类。
这个判断在他那里不是修辞。要理解他的整套逻辑,得把人口崩溃和 AI 风险放在一起看:一个是文明的自我萎缩,一个是文明的失控膨胀,两边都是悬崖。
AI 安全是第二大威胁,而监管机构还不存在
有观众问 AI 和机器人。马斯克说,他讲了很多年 AI 安全是件大事,应该有监管机构来管。
目前还没有这样的东西。而政府要设立一个监管机构,通常要花好几年。人口崩溃之后,AI 安全大概是文明未来的第二大威胁。我也不太确定该怎么处理。(马斯克)
特斯拉在这件事上的位置有点微妙。他说特斯拉可能是世界最大的机器人制造商,因为路上跑的半自动驾驶汽车最终会变成完全自动驾驶,同时他们还造人形机器人。
他承认自己拖延了很久才决定做人形机器人。理由是不想加速 AI 末日。但看到波士顿动力的进展,他意识到这件事无论如何都会发生。既然会发生,不如让一家相对更在意安全的公司来做。
这是一种很典型的马斯克式论证:如果一件事必然发生,就由我来做,至少我能控制方向。这个逻辑支撑了他做特斯拉、做星链、做脑机接口,也支撑了他做人形机器人。
自动驾驶的过渡期,和两吨重的死亡机器
有人问,人类驾驶和机器驾驶混行的过渡期,怎么看待这种“人机混合”的风险。谷歌那边的观点是,这是最糟糕的阶段,人会走神,车会犯错。
马斯克承认过渡期会颠簸。然后他给了数据:
我们公布过安全统计,自动驾驶状态下的里程和手动驾驶的里程,差了十倍。你可以说我们在玩弄统计口径,但十倍不是细微差别,这不叫微调数据。(马斯克)
他的核心论点是:人类本来就不擅长开车。
人们不擅长驾驶两吨重的死亡机器。人会累,会喝酒,会分心,会发短信,会做各种不该做的事,然后车就撞了。(马斯克)
他还讲了一个残酷的现实。哪怕自动驾驶把死亡人数降低 90%,剩下 10% 的死者家属照样会起诉你,而活下来的那 90% 根本不知道自己为什么还活着。
他跟 FSD 团队说过一句话,大概是这场访谈里最能代表他管理哲学的一句:
做正确的事本身,比做正确的事的观感更重要。只要我们确信自己在做正确的事,就算被批评、被起诉,也不该停。(马斯克)
电动车普及之后,电从哪来
一位来自电力行业的观众问了个很实际的问题:交通全面电动化之后,电网撑得住吗。
马斯克说这是好问题,然后给了长答案的短版本。
交通电动化之后,电力需求大约翻倍,可能还多一点。真正难的不是发电,是配电。你需要新的高压线、中压线,需要大幅扩建变电站。而扩建变电站意味着要拆房子。(马斯克)
这就是他做太阳能屋顶的原因。如果只靠公用事业公司扩大集中式发电,配电这一关过不去。必须有一部分电在本地发、本地用,屋顶太阳能是必要解决方案的一部分,不是可选项。
大规模发电这块,他的判断是风能和太阳能配电池。他给了一个数字:太阳能过去几年的复合年增长率大约 40%。
然后他说了句不太符合环保主义者刻板印象的话:他支持核能。他惊讶于公众对核能的强烈反对。德国关掉核电站之后又建了一批煤电厂,他认为这个决策是错的。
关于模拟假说,心和脑子吵了一架
最后一位提问者提到了几年前同一场活动上他说过的话:我们可能生活在模拟里。过去两年世界这么魔幻,是不是更像了。
马斯克的回答很简短:
我的心说不是,我的脑子说是。(马斯克)
这是他在这类终极问题上的一贯姿态。他不假装知道答案,但也不回避。理性推演指向一个结论,直觉指向另一个,两边就这么放着。
这场访谈里,能带走的东西
两个小时的对话,讲的都是很远的未来:火星、星舰、AI、人口。但里面有几条东西,今天就能用。
- 判断一项新技术该不该管,别问“它危险吗”,问“谁会被它伤到”。加密货币被掐死,普通人受损;AI 失控,普通人也受损。马斯克对这两件事态度相反,尺子是同一把。
- 看一个货币或系统,可以用信息论的四件事去量:带宽、延迟、丢包、安全性。传统跨境汇款要几天,就是高延迟;欺诈多,就是丢包。这个框架比“它有没有价值”好用得多。
- 降成本降两个数量级,性质会变。星舰把发射成本从 1500 万美元压到 100 万美元以下,变的不是发射生意,是火星城市能不能成立。评估一项技术突破时,先算清楚它跨过了哪道阈值。
- 任何新技术一开始都很贵,而且不好用。早期手机像鞋盒,早期电动车是富人的玩具。如果没人先付这个溢价,就没有后来人人买得起的版本。看到“这东西只有有钱人用得起”的批评时,多想一层。
- 如果你在一家公司里负责一件有争议的正确的事,记住马斯克对 FSD 团队说的话:做对的事,比看起来在做对的事重要。这句话的代价是,你得准备好被起诉。
- 评估长期风险时,别只看热闹的那一个。AI 失控天天上头条,人口崩溃几乎没人讨论,而马斯克把后者排在前面。热点和风险常常不重合。
- 如果你在能源行业或者打算装光伏,记住那个结论:真正的瓶颈是配电,不是发电。变电站扩建要拆房子,所以分布式发电不是补充,是必选项。
回到开头那个问题。政府该不该管加密货币,该不该管 AI,马斯克的答案看起来矛盾,其实指向同一件事:技术本身没有立场,能不能让大多数人过上更好的日子,才是唯一值得问的问题。
他在这场访谈里反复说的一句话是“我也不太确定”。对 AI 不确定,对模拟假说不确定,对中国的政策不确定。一个把火箭送上轨道的人,公开承认自己不知道的事情很多。这大概是这场对话里最不像表演的部分。
0:00[Music] we were bond is opening today it's my favorite movie so I felt like I had to do something like that anyway how you doing good how are you good what's the mood of Elon today the the mood it could be anything I feel good hear you yeah all right we have a lot to talk about right where do you want to start anywhere all right China
0:29cryptocurrency what they're doing that's my safe word by the way okay good good what they're doing cryptocurrency yeah cryptocurrency yeah for later for us go ahead cryptocurrency in China yes what they're doing around Bitcoin Etc and then I'd like to Pivot to what the us is going to do around regulation well it it would appear that they don't love cryptocurrency yeah it's subtle but yeah [Laughter] you're hinting in that direction yeah so I can't speak to exactly why they don't like it that much but people can speculate for various reasons China by the way is having some significant electricity generation issues yeah so actually I think part of
1:28it may actually be due to electricity shortages in many parts of China so a lot of South South China right now is having random power outages because the power demand is higher than expected so yeah crypto mining might be playing a role in that I'm not sure this is further than that it's more than that well I suppose cryptocurrency is fundamentally aimed at reducing the power of centralized government yes it is and that they they don't like that that's my guess okay so what do you think is going to happen I mean maybe the audience has otherwise went up it didn't matter after they announced this they went down and they went up you can change the shares of cryptocurrency more
2:19than China can yeah is that a good thing [Music] if it goes up I suppose it is but I mean I think there's an obvious long-term role for for crypto and you know really people should think of any kind of money system whether it's historic value or currency as as really a form of information if you apply information Theory to money whether it's cryptocurrency or some other form and view it in terms of you know how good is it at you're sort of bandwidth latency General dropping packets which was you could say like fraud is like losing packets or something on the network and you know it's overall security then I think a lot of these things just seem
3:21s make make a lot of sense in that share in that regard like any form of money has no power in and of itself except as an exchange of value between people for goods or services or to translate things in time like alone so is this the right thing for governments to do to take control of it is it possible I I it is not possible to I think destroy crypto but it is possible for governments to slow down its advancement so what should the U.S government do we had Gary Gensler on earlier SEC chairman he was calling it the wild west of Finance what should they do if anything
4:04I would say do nothing okay they're not saying that yeah I mean I wouldn't I've seriously just let Let it Fly because well what what do you think governments can do I think they can like you said anything they can ruin it I don't think they can just slow it down I think they can stop it I don't think they can control it and therefore they may want to stop it yeah I mean I I I'm I wouldn't say I was some you know massive cryptocurrency expert you know I think the there's some value to cryptocurrency I don't think it's like the step the second coming of the Messiah which some people think you know it's a it will hopefully reduce the error
4:56and latency in the money system the Legacy money systems and reduce the yeah I mean just you know governments have a habit of editing the money database which is like probably some ancient Mainframe somewhere in Virginia rankobo FY it's kind of bleep to think about that but so you know when governments can't keep the hand out of the cookie jar and edit the money database there's probably some values to that okay so what are you you're saying you're not an expert but you spend a lot of time tweeting about it now you tweet about a lot of things we'll get to that in a minute but why is that why that's true why is that of interest to you crypto because you become
5:42say the crypto Messiah that's going to be oh no well I mean I mostly don't tweet about crypto this is a minority of small number of tweets Okay so I do know a lot about the money system and payments and how it actually works as opposed to say how economists think it works on a practical basis just how money money's just a basically the monetary system is a series of heterogeneous databases that are not real time with
6:18the exception of PayPal and a few others and engage and to reconcile on a batch basis you know that that may take anywhere from 24 hours to several days and so it's just it's low that's just a lot of latency in Jitter and the ACH system is has basically no security so and this has just been in the it was that way when PayPal started in 99 and it's still that way 22 years later yeah yeah all right so I want to move on to when China I want to stick with China for a second you're operating there selling there what do you make of what they're doing to the tech entrepreneurs there the tech mobiles well hmm
7:11where is Jack ma where is Japan I know do you know no I was curious unless the means to find out I'm guessing I well maybe I don't know I think there's there there are there are some changes of foot in China I think part of this may be actually covered related in the sense that it's been quite difficult to have in-person meetings in China and trying to really run a whole system is set up to run on the basis of in-person meetings and the absence of of these meetings for the past 18 months I think has probably led to things being worse than they would be if they were more in-person meetings so I think as covert lifts and the in-person meetings return I think the
8:16but I think probably there will be an increase in the in the sort of trust level and I think things will probably start heading in a more positive direction trust level backend the government yeah both internally within China and with respect to fuel from the US and other countries going and visiting and meeting with the officials in the Chinese government now it's just it it is very much set up to work with in-person meetings and so covered I think has impeded that so I think I think things will improve most likely as the imperson meeting should resume so they do these Anti-Trust actions because they couldn't say hello I think and not all of it can be
8:59described that but it's a some of it can be yeah well we'll see I I I suspect things will improve next year because of just better more interaction are you nervous about what you're doing there a big market for you it's a you've operate there yeah we've got a big Factory in Shanghai which is doing very well at Tesla tell the Tesla China team is doing great work and we we do well with selling in the Chinese market as well as producing cars for China and for export to Europe so overall things are going pretty well frankly you're not worried about U.S China relations don't it's not no not not especially right now especially all right so let's start space
9:59you had a recent space you would send up a bunch of civilians into space you did not send yourself up no I'm not set myself up I suppose I will at some point but my goal is not to set myself up my goal is to open up space for Humanity and ultimately set us on a path to becoming a space-spring civilization and a multi-planet species yes so you don't want to go up yourself it's neither here nor there I will go at some point what do you think of the other efforts to go with suborbital
10:34is a step in the direction of orbit but so but just to put things in perspective you need about 100 times more energy to get to orbit versus Sub orbit and then to get back from what you need to burn off that energy so you need to like heavy duty heat shield because you're coming in like a meteor yes so like orbit is roughly towards magnitude more difficult than than subord but it's still you know good to do something in space what do you think watching those both Richard Branson and Jeff Bezos doing that I thought it was cool that they're spending money on the advancement of space so I think we ultimately want to be Humanity wants to be should want to
11:29be a space-bearing civilization and out there among the stars and we want I think we really want you know I mean all these things that we see in science fiction movies and books like you know we want those to be like real one day not always fiction right so I think it's good that people are spending their money advancing space technology so last time we talked we didn't talk a lot about space we talked about a whole month we talked about meat flaps which was elon's word for speaking Yeah or flapping arm yeah slow tonal wheezing yes that's right when I sound like it right now this always sound like to a computer like whale sound slow down yeah
12:12space so we think you've been you're doing because I think you're probably the most fast forward yeah so with respect to SpaceX let's see there's two besides overlooking the space flight and providing transport for NASA of astronauts and cargo to and from the space station which we've been doing for a while now over a decade we are we have something called starlink which is a global internet system and this was I think going to have some profound positive effects on the world because starlink is really designed to serve the the least served we have 1300 satellites up right now is that correct 50 1500 and you want to put 30 000.
13:07yeah we'll get to space pollution in a minute but explain the reasons for yeah so in order to provide high bandwidth low latency connectivity to a large number of people you need you need a lot of satellites and there needs to be at low of orbit so that latency is is low the problem with satellites that are at geostationary orbit is that they are you know around 36 000 kilometers whereas we are at 550 kilometers so
13:40gigantic difference in latency [Music] for the selling system you could play like a competitive video game that's latency dependent and still be able to play it with Sterling it's like browsing a terrestrial system essentially and but starlink is really just to be clear not a threat to 5G or terrestrial fiber or anything like that it's but it's very well suited to low to medium density regions of the earth places that where it is too expensive to trench fiber or put cells you know 5G cellular base stations and so it's really a good it kind of
14:30takes care of the the people that that just didn't get internet either internet is too too slow or too expensive what they just don't have it at all it's very well suited a space-based system for serving like the least served maybe five percent or something like that how big a part of your space business is it from your perspective I mean I think it's quite significant in that the launch side of things just just launching other people's satellites and serving the space station probably tops out around you know three or four million dollars a year of Revenue whereas if we can get to say three percent of global internet traffic then that that's and
15:10that's roughly a trillion dollar a year business then we can increase our Revenue by order magnitude more like the 30 billion or something like that and and then we can use the proceeds from that to develop the rocket technology necessary to get Humanity to Mars and to the moon and elsewhere in the solar system so that's something that you know so so I think Sonic is is good in and of itself for providing like I said providing internet access to the the least served in the world it's a fundamentally good thing in that respect and also offering a little bit of competition in the cities although the you know Estonia can really maybe serve less than five percent of people in a
15:57city it's just because of the way the the the spot beams from space are very big so anyways it's a very nice compliment and a necessary compliment to 5G and fiber so and like I said we'll provide a revenue stream for us to develop our next Generation rocket which is Starship with Starship but we're trying to achieve the a fundamental breakthrough that is the Holy Grail of rock tree that
16:31is to have a fully reusable oval rocket this is this is extremely fundamental with Falcon 9 we have a mostly reusable rocket she recently proved it landed correct we've been Landing for quite a while now but so we in fact a number of our boosters are on their 10th reflight so we've shown that we're using the the
17:00Boost stage it is can be done and that it is economically sensible to do so what's the difference in price between our Falcon 9 competitors I'm using a reusable rocket oh yeah sure sure so it's it's really gigantic was built with Falcon 9 we still have to lose the upper stage and you can think of each stage being like the equivalent of a jet airplane so the Boost age is like the big jet airplane upper stage is the small jet airplane we still throw away the small jet airplane every time so [Music] Falcon 9 is able to be the most competitive rocket in the world because we recover the blue stage in the fairing but that but still our best case marginal cost of launch not taking into
17:49account overhead allocation is about 15 million dollars per Lodge yeah for 15 Tons two of it which is quite big like a SpaceX over the last year or so has delivered about I think roughly two-thirds of all payload to orbit of Earth and most of the remaining third is China and then everyone else's kind of either in a miscellaneous so [Music] so anyway so but we still have a it's still 15 million dollars because of the most because what's the cost differential between that and what you're aiming for yeah so basically Falcon 9 is effectively about half to a third of the cost of Alternatives because of the ReUse of the Boost age with Starship we should be able to get to the point
18:47where it's maybe one percent the the cost of an Expendable system so that would just be a million bucks right or yeah the marginal cost of launch that we think can be it could be potentially under a million dollars so is anybody for over 100 tons to orbit 100 more though than 15 he said 15. yes it was a hundred times likely and with refinement of the design probably 150 tons so essentially it's it would be you know 10 times the payload of Falcon 9 for
19:2915 times lower cost what's been happening 100-fold better you know it's really but profound essentially with Starship it is possible to make the economics close for creating a self-sustaining City on Mars and a base on the moon for those who want to go there [Music] and so it's really you very very profound development and that's what I'm spending most of my time on is driving the development of Starship so you can go to Mars or however you want civilization on Mars civilization or Mars so what's first the moon base or moon base first correct I mean it's closed so we might as well okay yeah you might as well it's practically right there you know excuse me will you
20:21you got a contract with the defense department to do a lunar lander it's from NASA from NASA which is being disputed by Jeff Bezos yes how do you feel about that well I think I've expressed my thoughts on that front you know if I I think you should put more of his energy into getting to orbit than lawsuits you can't you cannot see your way to the Moon okay there's no matter how good your lawyers are yeah so why isn't he doing that I don't know I also like to make fun of his rock head we all make fun of each other's Rockets I mean I think it does have I mean it could be a different shape potentially
21:18you know [Laughter] could you explain from a technological point of view why it's that shape well if you are only going to doing suborbital then your rocket can be sort of shorter yes [Laughter] so have you called and said cut that [ __ ] get bigger or what I mean I haven't I've encouraged him to emphasize getting to orbit yes you talk to him not bubbly what is it just you know look at him yeah
22:07so what are you going to do with the lunar lander and how do you get the moon base there yeah so Starship is designed essentially as a general purpose transport system to anywhere in the solar system because it is a propulsive Lander and with a proposal blender you can land anywhere that's got a solid surface so and it's also designed for orbital refilling so you can get the Starship to
22:43orbit and then send tanker flights to refill it so that it has a tremendous Delta velocity basically it can go very far from Earth orbit because you can refill propellant the moon base is important because well I think the moon base I mean certainly is like a lot we could learn scientifically if we had a proper laboratory on the moon about the nature of the universe and you know where we all came from and the early history of Earth and that kind of thing yeah we have a science station in Antarctica and we're still learning a lot from you know our activities in Antarctica and I think we could learn even more on the moon so there's a lot of a lot of value I
23:29think to having I think it'd be just freaking cool I mean come on it's like we got a you know Humanity let's we've got to represent here for Humanity just have a base on the moon but I think everyone would be like yeah hell yeah we got a base in the moon that's cool yeah you know
23:49I think like the a lot of a lot can be learned if you've got a sort of a science station on the moon like we've got a science station in Antarctica and many other places and I think there's I think there is value that shouldn't be denigrated for people who want to experience going to orbit or going to the moon and you know when they do so and I think some degree vicariously we all go with them you know and and when in the polar program when they landed on the moon yeah it was just a handful of individuals on the moon but we all went with them vicariously humanity went with them like if you if you asked Peter DePaul of people on Earth and said sorry what do you think
24:39is Humanity's greatest achievement of the maybe ever I was like landing on the moon you know and that's inspiring I think to kids everywhere so you just brought Santa for civilians is that space tourism you're doing and by the way you have to be kind of Rich to do it like from what I understand I cannot afford to go to the moon for example yeah I mean I think it's very interesting I think it's got a bit more gravitas than you know metaphorically figuratively and literally more gravitas than you know simply tourism it's not like going to Disneyland you know it's like it's more profound than that so sometimes people use tourism in a sort of a negative way but
25:28I think you know especially with the inspiration light I think they they really I mean they but you know they filmed the whole thing in real time you know they shared their experiences with the world it's a really cool group of people I recommend watching the Netflix show countdown Mark pennyoff talked about it it's awesome I I didn't have anything to do with it and and the production value on the Netflix countdown documentary is amazing and you learn about the backstory of the people and it's it's actually super you know like this is for Science and for saving Humanity presumably yeah I think what tourism
26:13I think that there was an element of Tourism to it but I think you know it there's also you know the technology is expensive at first you you can't just when you're trying to develop brand new technology it doesn't instantly become cheap and affordable you think of like cell phones and the early cell phones were were really expensive and sucked you know frankly like you know usually like Wall Street one where you know he's walking down the beach with the shoebox size cell phone on a you know talking to and so it's like really expensive and the tech wasn't that great but but if if some number of people didn't pay for the expense of cell phones they would not be
26:53the inexpensive cell phones that everyone can afford so thank billionaires for going into space I mean you know it doesn't have to be top of your thank you list but I mean it's not I'm just saying that there is a nest when there's new technology it is necessarily expensive until you can refine the design and you can scale things up and then you can make it more affordable it's a common misconception that there's some with some new technology especially if it's a physical object that you can just suddenly make it cheap and available and and but you have to have many design iterations and you go to scale off the production and get economies of
27:34scale like we had this argument against Tesla for a long time because people would say like well why are you building this Tesla Roadster back in the day it's it's basically you know it's an expensive toy sports car for its people we're like yes it is but there's no way we could build an affordable electric car as off of this car any you know we just didn't have the capital we didn't have the experience and we needed to go through several technology iterations in order to get to Something Like the Model 3.
28:06right and I actually wrote A Blog about this because I knew people would be like why are you making Sports costs ritual rich people as though we thought there was somehow a shortage of sports class rich people or obviously not but but you just gotta you gotta figure out the technology you got to go through multiple design like how do you make something Mass market and affordable many many design iterations many many different versions of the technology a lot of hard work and then you've got to scale up the production rate so you get economies of scale and those two things are What Make Any Given technology available to the public and basically every technology that we take
28:46for granted today has gone through that Evolution I think to Mars will be affordable someday yes absolutely it has to be in order for it in order for Mars to be a self-sustaining civilization it has to be affordable can you say that well enough people need to go you know why do you want people to go when you just keep saying that because you're worried about this planet are you just betting the odds are to blow it up or no it'll be the day after tomorrow moving you know I think it's really you know if you sort of look you know just sort of stand back just if we just step away from us sort of intimacy and squabbles and say let's look at the big picture here
29:29what what set of actions can we take that maximize the probability that the future is going to be good for civilization and for Consciousness and I think we should regard Consciousness on Earth as delicate not you know just fragile and you know what sort of actions can we do to ensure that it continues and that the scope and scale of Consciousness expands and and I'm I'm in favor of
29:59of expansion because like you know if we want to understand what the universe is about and and what's the meaning of life and we need to get out there and find out and the more we expand the scope and scale of Consciousness the better we will be able to understand what questions to ask about the answer that is the universe so when you get a lot of criticism say about Starling space pollution you see a lot of stories about space pollution why is Elon putting so many astronomers get mad at you or with the Rockets so you have these big expense contracts that you're doing correct first time someone's broken into the area how do you meet those criticisms here's
30:43this is just small potatoes well first of all with respect to the astronomers we are in a constant dialogue with the leading astronomers of the world and taking great pains to ensure that our satellites do not interfere with their telescopes and we're I believe at this point they are satisfied that they will not so yeah like I said we're taking great pains to ensure that the satellites do not reflect or you know otherwise interfere with the the telescopes including the most sensitive telescopes so you know maybe a few sort of amateur astronomers who aren't happy but the professional ones are are satisfied that we're taking reasonable steps to ensure
31:30that we are not standing in the way of science so no would we ever want to and we're also looking at launching some new telescopes using Starship because starship's much bigger vehicle we can launch satellites that have 10 times the resolution of the Hubble which would be great for science and in fact we're at there's an exciting program working with Seoul Pearl Motor at Berkeley on a big new space satellite
32:01A Space Telescope I should say and I think we'll do we'll do more of those so I think at the end of the day Starship and SpaceX are going to do a lot to advance our understanding of astrophysics and strong you still want it you said to me last a couple times ago we talked you wanna die on Mars you still want to die on Mars well just not on Landing right yes yeah it's not an impact right well that would be spectacular yes but you wouldn't get to enjoy it much of you know just a second or so not a narrative for the rest yeah no I was just asked
32:40do you want to die on wise and I was like well I suppose if you're going to pick both homeowners I'm like it'd be cool to like be born on Earth and die on Mars I'm not I'm not like trying to make a beeline to promise and just you know dive or something it's just that yeah I gotta pick one you're gonna die somewhere and throw up Mars I'm interviewed a lot of Astro I guess they're biologists they're worried about essentially they said you have to be under the Earth couple hundred feet no no you get short definitely not comfortable it's a couple hundred yeah you know what you see first of all half the time you're shielded by this by Mars itself
33:24that's half the radiation is just the planet shielding you and then you want to make maybe have like I don't know three feet of dirt ish on the roof or just a kind of a thick roof I think it'll be fine so so you're not worried about becoming shorter and stupider by moving to Mars no I think we might become taller actually on Mars a little bit a little bit taller yeah because the gravity is roughly 40 out of Earth okay that would be good for me when you think about but I think I do think there's like an important thing for if you think of the various great filters if you feel familiar with the sort of great grateful sort of thought yeah one of the filters is do we become a
34:06spacecraft a multi-planet species or not so that is at least one of the one of the great cultures and we would I think it would be great to pass that and have be a multi-pilot species where the the critical threshold is on a for a Mars City if if the resupply ships from Earth stop coming for for any reason whether that is civilization on Earth it could be a mundane reason or could be world war three but does Mars Prosper or die out and if Mars is missing anything at all like the civilizational equivalent of vitamin C then it will eventually die out so you need to get to the point where Mars city is self-sustaining even if the ships from Earth stop coming then you have
34:59passed the great filter OD stack particularly Breakwater I think we should Endeavor to pass that great culture as soon as possible [Music] he said pretty soon last time we talked yeah I mean I think we should really try hard to make it happen this century before the end of the century you'll be pretty old I'll probably be dead yeah not on Mars well I mean I'll you know pop over there when I'm old or something okay so
35:31there's a lot of government deals in Orlando he did the rocket one you're getting billions from 2.9 billion dollars is that right well right now we're not getting anything because we're being sued right that's right I'm sorry okay but you're getting a lot of money hopefully we'll get it right right when it's over yeah I mean most of our launchers are commercial to be clearance yes I understand that but you're doing a lot of government work so what is what is that like working with the government is that important your business yeah I mean it's it's an important part of it's an important part of the business I mean it's just I mean bear in mind if
36:09like if you're in any industry like let's say you were a pencil manufacturer okay about 40 of your pencils are going to go to the government the government's about 40 of the economy you know if you're a shoe manufacturer you're about 40 of your business is going to be with the government so you know it's to be expected that any any company is going to have a most companies are going to have a percentage of business with the government state federal and local that is proportionate to the GDP of the government so one of the criticisms of you is you don't pay enough taxes if any can you address that because here you are getting money from the government
36:48you obviously want a function in government to be able to build all kinds of things and services how do you look at that trade-off well I mean there was a bunch of very misleading stuff that was published by propublica and really that was some sort of trickery and really that they did themselves no good service by by doing that so first of all with respect to the government contracts that that SpaceX wins our aspiration is to do the most for the least and if you look at all the contracts we've won we've won them because we are the best price we have a better service at a lower price they weren't just handed to us I don't think they were am I that's what I'm saying
37:32the fact you called me and said we finally got in after years of this backslapping I think it's a great thing that is great absolutely I mean in the for the moon lander just taking that as one example our bed was half the price of the blue origin Lockheed bed half so for a vehicle that does basically 10 times more or eight times more baths our price was half and NASA has a mandate to get back to the moon so we save taxpayers like three billion dollars relative to that contract so I think that's that's a good thing with respect to my personal taxes the I don't actually draw a salary or anything my cash compensation is basically zero which is a good thing because income
38:25is a problem for most people I think they pay taxes on income that was the whole point of the story I think yeah yeah so I do have sock options that best and so in the years that the but but I don't I basically with Tesla's Basics I just have not really bothered to sort of take money off the table which is a common most people do they sell some of this stock and they take money off the table and for me I just like I said I you know my mind will be the sort of it was it was the first thing and it'll be the last out and success of SpaceX and Tesla was far from assured and there are many times when it looked like the companies would and they did they squirted bankruptcy many times
39:10but I never tried to take money off the table and now this has been trying to be turned around and made into a bad thing and I this is that's messed up so but when my stock options just before I saw options expire then I am forced to exercise and my top marginal tax rate is 53 percent so I don't think that's particularly low and it's going to go up next year it's like probably 57 or something and you sell yes and and I I I have a
39:44bunch of options that are expiring early next year so I'm that a huge block of options will sell in Q4 because I have to they'll expire and my top marginal tax rate is 53 percent eventually will pay a lot of taxes massive yeah I mean basically majority of what I sell will be taxed I don't think it was alleging legality it's that wealthy people got to borrow against their stock yes they were they were saying that like somehow barring is a trick to get away from paying taxes but it's more important to bear in mind that we've had a very long expansion in the economy maybe the longest ever and borrowing against stock is all is all sort of fun of games until you have
40:31a recession and you get the margin calls and then you'd go to zero which is which happens basically every time there's a recession stocks don't always go up they go down yours seems to most stocks have gone up including some questionable stocks frankly are you talking about yourself I'm sorry [Music] I think are you surprised by how much it's gone up and yeah I mean I have literally gone on record and said I think pasta price is too high in my opinion and this did nothing to stop the rise in the stock price no so I don't know what am I supposed to do you know all right I'm not doing anything to go up so but I think it's important to bear in mind like my actual tax rate is 53 they
41:21try to make it sound like basically it was a big increase in the value of the Tesla stock and then they added up they're just very selectively poked the numbers to make it sound like I was paying very low taxes but in fact my taxes are very high they're like over half and you pay them yes and a huge amount will be paid in the next three months because of expiring options and there was like one year where I think my taxes were basically zero and the reason for that was because I had overpaid taxes the year before I forgot to mention that yeah call them back I gotta call him back I have no interest in the truth oh okay all right let me ask you a question
42:04Twitter let's finish Twitter and then let's get to questions from the audience what's going on with you and Twitter I am a Twitter addict I say the wrong things all the time what is someone explained it to me it's very close to you saying it's your release valve this is where you feel better some people use their hair to express themselves I use Twitter do you regret anything or not you are kind of prominent not I mean sure walk us through when you decide to do it to eat you go no no no well I think about it for hours and I consult with my strategy team you just literally go yeah yeah
42:51or maybe I'm wasted enough it's gone let me shoot myself in the foot bam now let me shoot myself another bam yeah that describes some of my tweets yeah yeah worried about any sec involvement in your tweets going forward what does that stand for again I mean I know the middle word is elon's but I can't remember the other two words
43:28you talk about the short seller enrichment commission yeah yeah that's the new name is it yeah about he did one great weight about time time is the currency which I thought was beautiful time is the ultimate currency yes no matter what resources you have you can't wind back the clock true yeah how rich you are yeah but then you did the Biden tweet can you explain that one oh when well yeah I mean
44:05so you know like Biden held this EV Summit didn't invite Tesla invited GM Ford Chrysler and UAW Navy Summit on the White House didn't mention Tesla once and praised German Ford for leading the EP resident Revolution so you were pissed so Sean does this sound maybe a little biased or something so and then you know just not the friendliest Administration yeah seems to be controlled by the unions before they can tell hey we need to get Trump back no would you like to be president besides yourself I would not want to be present at all and it sounds like no fun being president
45:11what do you think is going to bring our country together if at all moving to Mars what well I think if there was some moderate you know sort of sort of Centrist president and I think that would help [Music] I mean that I think everyone just once I think most people most people want a president who is just a very competent you know executive you know not too far left not too far right and another one will be like I think most people would prefer that you know some when it comes down to the election you've got two choices you're like you know maybe you don't love you the choice but you gotta pick one it will happen do I think that would be what interest I
46:06hope so I hope so how's everything about democracy I'm not super worried about democracy are you worried about democracy oh smidge what concerns you a lot of the dialogue is getting a little I study propaganda well yeah it's worrisome the fact that it can't happen here it certainly can I'm A Philip Roth kind of person yeah but we're both having a lot of children so we must believe in the future yes children we have 10 children between us correct at least yes you're slightly ahead but you've got a rocket anyway I I I I I do I do think we there is you know I think a lot of people think that there's too many people on the planet but I think there's in fact
47:04too few and that the the possibly the single greatest risk to human civilization is the rapidly diminishing growth rate and the facts are out there for anyone to look at but a lot of people are still stuck with you know Pearl LX book population bomb it's like ah that was a long time ago that is not the case today and the there's a there was a massive Notch in demographics last year because the birth rate plummeted and also this year so I mean if you know no babies no Humanity but you got to come from somewhere okay okay we're gonna have any questions from audience because there's a lot of great questions hey Lana I'm Ronan Levy from a field trip we spent a lot of time talking
47:52about outer space we want to ask you about Inner Space and the question specifically is do you spend time thinking about Humanity's somewhat destructive Tendencies before sending people to Mars and specifically you've talked about the subject of DMT and curious to know what role you think psychedelics may have in addressing some of the more destructive Tendencies of humanity we're going to talk about this tomorrow okay well I think generally people should be open to psychedelics
48:29yeah [Applause] so yeah clearly it's a I mean you know yeah a lot of people making laws are kind of from a different era so I think as you know as as a new generation gets into political power I think we'll see great receptivity to the benefits of psychedelics concerning like about before we go to Mars I mean Humanity's Tendencies I mean we are at a very peaceful moment in history
49:08so you've got to separate the sort of news headlines from the reality I think like Stephen Pinker at Hobbit has really pointed us out like we're actually at the lowest violence per capita in his in human history it may not seem like that but objectively those are the statistics that's not to say there's no violence or there aren't things to be approved but it's you know it's actually quite good and so
49:38but you know just like I said big picture-wise we I think we want to take this set of actions that maximize the probability that the future is good That civilization continues and that the sort of this small candle of Consciousness in the void that is humanity continues and there's not it's not the candle does not go out okay next I'll be here hello my name is Lena I'm a student at the University of Chicago and I also have a podcast called kind of soda Brown so my question centers a little bit what you talked about concerning that you know you're building this world for not enough people yet but the people that now are here but concerning young people how do
50:31you actually build infrastructure to make sure that you're not just building resources for people to be in Mars but actually putting them in positions of power politically or educating people who don't have access to learn about space technology Etc how do you actually teach young people and bring them and do you feel like that's your role or does it your role to just build the spaceship to Mars well our primary goal is is to
51:02create the technology necessary to get people to Mars in the absence of which not you know it's some academic so we don't want to get too distracted from our primary mission of we we got to make it at least possible to get them to go to Mars and we want to do so as soon as possible and make access to Mars as
51:26widely available as possible as affordable as possible so that if somebody wants to go they can so that's that's our primary Mission I mean there are many good causes in the world but we've got to be careful that we do not try to take on too many I mean there are many noble missions but we we have to pick our battles and say okay let's just make sure we we get this done and because nobody else is doing it and I I mean if SpaceX doesn't do it I'm not sure how it will happen I think this this is the at least right now SpaceX is the only hope so we 've got to get this done it was far from done I mean it's got a lot long way to go yeah I installing in terms of
52:19providing internet connectivity to people that really don't have it or it's very expensive I think will be helpful in empowering a lot of people who are disempowered today so I think that's a good thing too right next hi techno king how do you respond to allegations yeah okay that is my formal title I'm about that with you gotta be respectful Cara yeah how do you respond to allegations that you're a living cyber genetic organism sent from the future to save us and secondly I can either confirm nor deny that it's good he's good and secondly what do you think the probability is the general purpose blockchains that have greater utility will eclipse the value
53:07of like a fish finished product in Bitcoin I actually I'm not sure how to answer that last one I think just generally a public Ledger stuff is good because out of Open Source and just and just you know sunlight being a great disinfectant and the the more the less things occur in the dark the better and you know sort of a crypto basically I mean block chances of just a cryptographic ledger but an open you know so I think that there's probably a lot of things good things I could be done with that the first question I said I could be able to confirm no denial okay right here hey Elon Alex Heath with the Verge the questions on the self-driving beta you guys are rolling
54:00out curious why you're encouraging people to not share videos and making them sign ndas just be careful no I mean there's there's a lot of videos being shared but the ndas in front of me the ndas for for the full self-driving beta I don't know people don't seem to listen to them I mean I'm not sure there's
54:27yeah I don't know why this is an NDA we probably don't need it and people just are ignoring it anyway so I don't sure it matters all right I'm gonna ignore this I'm gonna keep getting questions let's do tomb hi hi Elan Zia Yusuf from BCG could you talk a little bit about Ai and Robotics and you've expressed concerns in the past but you know building some as well what do you see as the issues that we do have to solve on that front well I've said for a long time I think AI safety is a really big deal and we should have some regulatory agency that is overseeing AI safety
55:10but there's not yet currently any such thing and and just generally any kind of regulatory agency done by the government will usually takes years to put in place so you know after the population collapse issue I think AI safety is probably the second biggest threat to the future of civilization and yeah like I said I'm not quite sure what to do with it I mean Tesla is arguably the world's biggest robot maker because like we have basically semi semi-autonomous cars that will ultimately be fully autonomous and we are building a humanoid robot that will be basically like like like the carpet with legs [Music] so and I kind of held open doing that
56:10for a while because you know I I certainly don't want to hasten the AI apocalypse but clearly it was either looking at Boston Dynamics and like this humanoid robots are going to happen so the reason can happen with or without Tesla so it's like Tesla I've got a little bit more I mean a lot more ability to ensure robotics safety and
56:31AI and I will try my best to do that what what would you do oh no we can't do more sorry we got a quick go ahead first thanks for making the first car I ever loved my wife insisted I asked this question if I got here we also have way too many children no that's probably great if there's any chance that you could put a roof rack on the X that's what she's looking for we need a roof rack on the X if you can figure that out that's almost more important than going to Mars we have not figured that out I mean It's tricky because we have the fancy doors they're awesome yeah the doors are awesome but you know if you have a roof rack like how do you stop the doors from
57:11smashing on them you were smart yeah thank you now the model y has a roof rack though it's not big enough for all the kids really it's seat seven yeah not not normal kids okay okay what do you have separate cars for your children it does have a tow hitch you can tell you some stuff I have two questions Elon thanks for the Plaid it's a great car as we're all you know waiting for full self that's awesome really it's awesome we like we might have to argue a bit about the yolk but we're getting accustomed to it's great car yeah it's like something different in a it's different and people sometimes don't like the different things but how much did pretty dance
57:59so that works for them anyway really really quick look we're living in this in between time between we drive our cars ourselves and the cars drive themselves they're semi-autonomous for those of us in the industry those of us who understand something about technology about machine learning I actually like it it's pretty easy it fixes my mistakes I fix its mistakes a lot in the Press though about and Google's position certainly is this is like the worst place to be right because people are going to get checked out and the cars are going to drive themselves into what do you think about the ml human hybrids that were kind of you know embracing right now how long are we
58:34going to have these crossover periods I know you believe FSD is around the corner do you think this is really a problem are we going to teach people to deal with ML well I mean the the transition period to a new technology is always a little bumpy and but I think we published the the safety
58:58stats like basically miles driven on autopilot and miles driven manually and this I mean it's an order of magnitude different so like if people say oh well you're playing with the statistics I'm like listen we're just saying miles driven autopilot miles not driven Automotive there's a 10 or back to 10 difference so I mean even if we were like we're not fiddling with Statistics that's just it this is not subtle that's what I'm saying it's not subtle the truth is that people are actually not great at driving these two-ton death machines you know and people get tired and they get drunk and they get distracted and they text and they do all sorts of
59:43things they shouldn't do and then the cars that you know crash basically and now that now when we're embarking on the autonomy front someone told me I think that's quite true which is even if you for argument's sake reduce fatalities by 90 with autonomy the 10 that do die with autonomy are still going to sue you right the 90 that are living don't even know that that's the reason they're alive nonetheless I've had many conversations with the Tesla autopilot full-time driving team who are just an outstanding group of people and saying like listen guys it is better to pursue like the reality of doing the right thing matters more than the perception
1:00:42of doing the right thing and as long as we are confident that we're doing the right thing even if we are criticized and sued and all that we should not unless do the right thing and not care about the perception of the right thing Rick cutter the cloud for utilities thank you so much for the card work you've done with with Tesla driving the EV Market as we move towards more green energy utilities are getting rid of their fossil plants coal plants investing in in Renewables there's a difference in economic output they can deliver are you concerned at all as the growth of EVS continue do you think we could have a supply chain problem with energy down the road
1:01:24yeah I think that's a that's a very good question the full answer is is lengthy I'll try to give this the short version the electricity demand roughly if if we go if we shift we'll transport to Electric then electricity demand approximately doubles maybe a little more than doubles and this is going to create a lot of challenges with the the grid especially for distribution to neighborhoods and
1:01:56this is why Tesla has the product the solar roof and the solar retrofit is because even if you increase sustainable power generation at the utility level you're still going to have a distribution problem where you need new high power lines new medium power lines you need to dramatically increase the size of the substations which means you're gonna have to start knocking down houses to increase the substation size is really unworkable unless you have a significant local power generation at houses and this is why I think it's actually very important that that a necessary part of the solution is local power generation on on rooms on the houses of homes very
1:02:39important and then of course we need large sustainable power generation developments primarily winds in solar but it needs to be paired with battery packs or steady state so you can provide continuous power and a lot of good things are happening in this regard the growth of solar in the last several years has been incredible I think it's like a 40 percent compound annual growth rate in in solar and also a big growth in Wind
1:03:13I'm also kind of a pro-nuclear a nuclear nuclear Pro nuclear and you know I'm sort of surprised by a lot of the public sentiment against nuclear and you know I'm not saying we should go build a whole bunch of new nuclear plants but I don't think we should shut down ones that are operating safely and what they did that they did this in Germany for example and I think that was and then I had to create a whole bunch of coal power plants and I I don't think that was the right decision frankly so
1:03:53yeah anyway so we're one way or another though we're gonna have to have a lot more electricity Generation and this is this is primarily going to come down to solar and wind paired with batteries will be our next conversation okay so Tesla boring solar sounds good okay we're gonna ask you one more question one time we talked a couple years ago code you said we were in a simulation this past couple years has seemed truly [ __ ] up yeah it feels like a bunch of teenagers from the future we're just really smoking a lot of dope and [ __ ] with us are we are we in a simulation I mean my heart says no and my brain says yes Elon Musk
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 视频在 B 站收看UP 主「SpaceX小工」搬运,标题注明带中文字幕
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版