先摆一个数字。2002 年 PayPal 卖给 eBay,马斯克税后到手大约 1.8 亿美元。他把这笔钱切成三块:1 亿进 SpaceX,7000 万进特斯拉,1000 万进 SolarCity。切完,他需要向朋友借钱付房租。
这话是他自己在这场炉边谈话里说的,语气平得像在报菜单。主持人 Sarah Lacy(PandoDaily 创始人)追问了一句:这不是你的计划吧?马斯克说不是,他原本以为 SpaceX 花 5000 万就够,特斯拉 2500 到 3000 万,结果每一项都大概是估算的两倍。唯一没让他追加投入的是 SolarCity,而那家公司恰恰是他没当联合创始人的那一家。
他顺口开了个玩笑:看来我以后应该少当联合创始人。
这场对话发生在 2012 年。判断依据不在标题里,在内容里:SpaceX 刚刚连续五次发射成功并与国际空间站对接,Model S 开始交付,SolarCity 还没上市,Hyperloop 这个词是当晚第一次从他嘴里说出来。上传视频标着 2025,原片已被删除,流传下来的只有转录稿。一场十三年前的谈话还能被人翻出来读,通常因为里面的判断后来被现实验证或者推翻,很少因为它当时说得漂亮。
三个十亿美元公司,和一个他拒掉的头衔
主持人开场抛出的历史参照是 Jim Clark:硅谷历史上唯一一个做出三家十亿美元公司的人,Silicon Graphics、Netscape、Healtheon。主持人说,把还没退出的 SpaceX 也算上,马斯克是第二个,而且跨的是支付、汽车、航天三个完全不相干的行业。
聊到 SolarCity 时出现一个细节。主持人问他是不是联合创始人,他说对方确实提议把他列为联合创始人,他拒了。理由是自己只出了最初的想法,投入的"汗水股本"不够。他说这件事多少有点主观,但他认为自己做得不够。
一个被全世界认为最疯的人,在署名这件事上守的规矩比大多数人都紧。署名这件事,他讲得坦白,规矩也比大多数人都紧。
主持人随即问他:你做这些,是因为你有点疯吗?还是因为你运气好?
马斯克说他最近确实在想这个问题,结论是自己大概有点疯,但他觉得这是个健康信号。
因为当你断定自己完全不疯的时候,你多半已经疯了。(马斯克)
为什么不再做互联网
PayPal 那批人套现之后,几乎全体转身去投 Web 2.0,在所有人喊"互联网完了"的时候下注。马斯克却搬去了洛杉矶,同时开三家硬件公司。主持人问他还会不会再做互联网公司,是不是觉得互联网无聊了。
他说不太可能,理由跟无聊无关。他自称还算懂网,也不想变成"不用邮箱的老爷爷"。真正的原因在钱和人往哪儿走:互联网那头挤满了创业者和热钱,汽车、太阳能、航天这几个行业几乎没有新进入者,创业者和资本都不去。
他把这件事讲得很清楚:一个行业长期没有新玩家,就等于失去了创新的主要推力。推动创新的是新进入者,比在位者的自我改良管用得多。所以他把力气押在没人愿意去的赛道上。
另一个现实条件是资本门槛。这几个行业启动就需要很多钱,不是两个人写代码就能跑起来的。他手上的 1.8 亿,恰好是能从零敲开一扇门的量级。
一个温室、三次莫斯科、一堵软包墙
SpaceX 的源头比大多数人想的要小得多。2001 年前后,他去拜访大学室友 Adeo Ressi,被问到离开 PayPal 之后打算干什么。他说自己一直对太空感兴趣,但觉得个人在太空领域做不了什么事。
他最初的计划是往火星送一个小温室:种子加脱水营养凝胶,着陆后给凝胶加水,植物长出来,红色背景上一片绿色。他要的就是这张照片。
他解释了为什么是这张照片。人会对"第一次"和"最"有反应,而这将是生命走过的最远距离,据我们所知也是火星上的第一批生命。他判断这张照片能激起公众情绪,进而推动 NASA 的预算,然后才有可能把人送上火星。
他的原话是:你想要一个期待事情变好的未来,而不是一个期待事情变坏的未来。
再往后,他去了三趟俄罗斯,谈判买几枚俄罗斯舰队里最大的洲际弹道导弹。他自己形容这是"一段奇怪的经历"。主持人问这种谈判怎么进得去,他说认识人、找人聊,很快就聊到俄罗斯火箭部队头上了,还顺便评价俄罗斯是个挺资本主义的社会。
然后他描述了一个场景:某个看起来像疗养院的地方,墙是软包的。他想不通为什么墙要软包。会上一个缺了门牙的俄罗斯人冲他吼,唾沫飞过来。他站在软包墙中间想,这真的太诡异了。
第三趟回来,他想明白了。航天停滞的真正原因是运输成本,几十年里成本越来越高,做的事越来越少。要改变这件事,只能从运输技术下手。
所以他在启动 SpaceX 的时候,认为最可能的结果是失败。他说这并不矛盾:本来的计划是一笔财务上零回报的慈善式投入,相当于捐给这个事业。任何比"全损"更好的结果都算赢。整场谈话里他反复回到这个逻辑,这是理解他所有冒险的钥匙。
2008:三个孩子,只能救一个
2008 年是他公开承认的低点。猎鹰一号第三次发射失败,特斯拉那一轮融资因为经济要塌而瓦解,SolarCity 和摩根士丹利的交易被对方撤回,因为摩根士丹利自己也开始缺钱。三家公司的现金流同时指向零,他本人还在打离婚官司,媒体上被围剿。
他用了一个词形容那段日子:超级糟糕。
主持人问第三次发射失败是不是很意外。他说不意外,他当时判断成功率略高于五成。失败原因他讲得挺技术:一级发动机改成了再生冷却,推力瞬变期间压力衰减到低于海平面大气压,在地面试车台上看不出来;结果一级撞上了二级,二级发动机在级间段里点火,等于在室内点燃一台巨型发动机,等离子体回火把二级烧了。他说我没料到这个。
真正的难题是钱。SolarCity 需要的钱不多,问题集中在 SpaceX 和特斯拉之间:剩下的资本只能保一家,或者拆开让两家都勉强活着。
他打了个比方:你有两个孩子,你是把钱全押在一个身上提高他的存活率,还是想办法让两个都活。他说庆幸的是最后两个都活了。
第四次发射成功,特斯拉那一轮也补上了。他说从那时起,事情开始变好。
还有一个他很少主动讲的细节。他从来不想当特斯拉的 CEO,从第一天起他就有绝对控股权,随时可以坐那个位置,但他一直躲。到 2008 年底,他必须把留给特斯拉的全部储备资金投进去,才决定亲自上手。
他的原话是:这真的不好玩,超级不好玩。
后来他给了一个判断特斯拉什么时候可以交出去的标准:当大部分在造的车都是电动车,特斯拉作为催化剂的边际价值递减,那时候他就不必再管这家公司了。不是看市值,不是看产品线,是看这件事是不是已经不需要他来推。
一句"看这个"的代价
主持人现场求证一个传闻:卖掉 PayPal 之后,马斯克买了一辆迈凯伦 F1,在路上撞了,然后笑得直不起腰,说"好笑的部分是这车没上保险"。
马斯克确认了最后一句话真的,剩下部分被他改写了。
真实版本是这样的。2000 年,他开着那辆迈凯伦沿 Sand Hill Road 上行,副驾坐着 PayPal 联合创始人 Peter Thiel,两人去红杉见 Michael Moritz。他其实不太会开这辆车。Thiel 问了一句:这车能干什么?
他回了一句大概能进"遗言排行榜"的话。
看这个。(马斯克)
他把油门踩到底,在 Sand Hill 上做了一次变道。这台车 640 马力,整备质量只有一吨,没有牵引力控制,80 英里时速下后轮都能挣脱。后轮甩了出去,车开始打转。他记得自己是倒着看到迎面来车的,然后撞上路边一个 45 度的路堤,车被像铁饼一样抛起来,目击者说离地大约三英尺,转着圈砸回地面,落地方向和原方向一致。
悬挂报废,玻璃和车轮全碎,前后车身严重受损。核心底盘和发动机没事。
然后 Peter Thiel 拦了一辆车先去了红杉,马斯克留在原地等消防车和救护车,处理完自己也拦了一辆车过去,会议照开。
主持人问他当时有没有笑。他说自己不记得笑过,如果在震惊中笑了也有可能,但不记得。
主持人不放过这个故事的隐喻价值,问他造公司是不是也这样。他说希望不是。主持人接了一句:这事儿放在火箭上就有点棘手了,一吨的车和一百万吨当量的炸药不是一个量级。
宁要低估值的好 VC,不要高估值的有问号 VC
主持人问他跟风险投资打交道的经验,他说跨度很大,好的坏的都有。他给创业者的建议只有一条,但说得很重:如果你能在"估值低一点、但人你很喜欢"和"估值高一点、但你对这个人有问号"之间选,选低的。
他的比方是结婚。说完自己补了一句:可能我自己结婚这事也办得不怎么样。
他还是讲了特斯拉 C 轮的一部分。当时有两份报价,Kleiner Perkins 的 pre-money 5000 万美元,VantagePoint 的 7000 万。他直接跟 John Doerr 说:如果你进董事会,我们按 5000 万做。40% 的差价他愿意自己吃掉,条件是 Doerr 这个人。
Doerr 说自己在 Kleiner 内部有别的义务,另有一位合伙人对这个案子很有兴趣,他不能顶掉那个人。于是这笔交易没成。马斯克说这大概是个错误。
后来 Kleiner 去投了 Fisker。这句话他补得很干脆:那是他们的错误。当时 Fisker 和 A123 都出了问题。
他解释了特斯拉和 Fisker 的根本差别。特斯拉是硬核技术公司,做真正的工程,也做真正的制造:铝卷和塑料颗粒进去,整车出来,垂直整合程度很高,整车工程、动力总成、软件、造型设计全部自己做。设计负责人 Franz von Holzhausen 他评价很高。
Fisker 由设计师 Henrik Fisker 主导,而设计师的思路是这一切都关于造型。马斯克说,问题从来不是造型不够好看,我们至今没有普及电动车,原因不在造型上。
他给了一条更普适的判断:公司之所以值钱,是因为有人在啃硬问题。丰田、戴姆勒、奔驰从特斯拉买电动动力总成,这件事本身就说明问题,如果容易,他们自己就做了。
太阳能板像石膏板,戴尔不造 CPU
主持人把话题引向清洁技术,说硅谷当年一大票顶级基金押注这里,声称这是下一个互联网,结果没成。马斯克先纠正了用词,他觉得"sustainable energy"(可持续能源)比"clean tech"更准确,虽然更拗口。
然后他讲了 SolarCity 的投资逻辑。
标准效率的太阳能板,制造难度大约等于制造石膏板。真的很容易。所以他从一开始就判断,这块业务会陷入中国、日本、德国的硅片厂商之间的血战,和 DRAM 市场一模一样,价格会被压到接近原材料成本。
事实就是这么走的。当时组件价格已经跌到大约每瓦 0.9 美元。而居民光伏系统每瓦装机成本大约 4 美元,几年前还是 7 美元。
剩下那 3 美元在哪儿?在他说的"balance of system"里,也就是除了面板之外的一切:针对某个具体屋顶做系统设计、安装、布线、逆变器、售后服务、客户体验、融资方案。这才是成本主战场。
他给的类比是戴尔。戴尔不造 CPU,不造硬盘,不造内存,但戴尔设计系统、管理客户体验。SolarCity 干的是同一件事,除了那块板,别的全做。
他也把功劳分出去了:90% 到 95% 归 Lyndon Rive 和团队。
这段话是 2012 年讲的。十多年后回看,光伏组件价格继续往下走,价值果然集中到了安装、渠道、金融和运维上。他当时把产业链拆开看的方式,比结论本身更值得学。
嚼碎玻璃,凝视深渊
主持人提到他常被引用的一句话:创业就像嚼着碎玻璃凝视深渊。马斯克说这句话的原始版本来自朋友 Bill Lee,原话是"嚼着玻璃,盯着深渊",他自己把顺序调了一下。
他拆开解释:凝视深渊就是面临近在眼前的死亡,SpaceX、特斯拉、SolarCity 有很长一段时间都在那个状态。玻璃则是永远嚼不完的部分,只会越来越少,不会归零。
他说现在不盯着深渊了,深渊还在远处,但视线不在它身上。他也说自己越来越喜欢生活,希望不要再回到 2008 和 2009 年的状态。
主持人问他和 Peter Thiel 的关系,尤其是合并那段。他说两人有过分歧,但是朋友,95% 的时间里是朋友。主持人说那 5% 一定很难熬,他承认有点颠簸。
他给自己的定位是:我比 Peter 更能承受风险。他的说法是,自己是油门踩到底的那种,Peter 会说我们小心一点。
他补了一句:也许他是对的。
四个想法,一个已经说出口
主持人翻出他 2008 年说过的话,问他还想不想再开公司。他说有四件事可以做,每一件他觉得自己都有超过五成的成功率。
第一件是电动超音速飞机。触发点是协和式退役。他读到这个消息的第一反应是:我们连超音速运输都没有了,太糟了。他后来查资料,发现协和式是 60 年代设计的,今天的气动水平因为计算流体力学的进步已经大幅提升,发动机效率也提升巨大,光换发动机航程就能翻倍。
物理逻辑他讲得很清楚:大气密度随高度指数衰减,越往高处空气越稀薄,阻力越小,同样的推力就能跑得更快。燃烧式发动机在高空会缺氧,还要吸进大量不参与燃烧的氮气拖慢自己,最优高度在 3.5 万到 5.5 万英尺之间。电动风扇在高空反而表现更好,可以往 8 万英尺去。垂直起降和超音速这两件事配合得也不错。
他说这事儿不着急,但 SpaceX 和特斯拉加起来,他手里正好有做这件事的配料,所以很诱人。
第二件是交通。方案是在高速中央隔离带上架预制钢箱梁,内侧一条车道、顶上一条车道,两车道可以全部单向,让车流按早晚高峰切换方向。模块预制,像乐高一样吊装到位,施工不能阻碍现有车流。
讲这个的时候他情绪明显上来了。他刚在洛杉矶堵了一小时,3 英里的路,说自己每天都咒骂 405 公路的施工方,这是他这辈子见过最糟的工程。
第三件是聚变。他的原话是磁约束聚变,"相对标准的那种"。这句话从一个造火箭的人嘴里说出来,轻得像在说下周要修个水管。
第四件就是 Hyperloop。他当时在犹豫两件事:直接开源,把想法写清楚让能做的人去做;或者先申请专利,再开放给能证明自己真做得到的人。
他把现有的交通方式数了一遍:汽车、火车、飞机、船,再加上离开地球这一种。他想要第五种。
触发点还是加州高铁。他说这条线有个尴尬的双料纪录:最慢的子弹头列车,每英里造价最贵。旧金山到洛杉矶据说要 600 亿美元,而且现在说 600 亿,以后一定更多。
他给 Hyperloop 的属性清单是这样的:不可能撞车;不受天气影响;速度是在建高铁的三四倍;平均速度大约是飞机的两倍;从洛杉矶市中心到旧金山市中心不到 30 分钟;票价远低于机票或开车,因为基础能耗低太多;顶部铺太阳能板,发的电比系统消耗的还多;用一种不用电池的储能方式做到 24 小时运行。
主持人算了笔账:1 亿美元把你送进了太空。他说是,差不多把我送进轨道了,包括外部投资人在内总共两三亿美元,SpaceX 已经盈利几年。所以 Hyperloop 大概能做到高铁成本的 10%。
1 亿美元把他送进太空,600 亿美元修一条慢车。
氢燃料电池:成功不在可能的结果里
观众席有人问,本田和奔驰都明确说氢燃料电池是未来,为什么他们还押这条路。
马斯克的回答是全场最不留情的一段。他说他不确定,因为数学上明显站在电池这边,这就像当着事实的面说事实不成立。就算给燃料电池最好的假设,从物理极限上做到完全优化,再拿去和量产中的锂离子电池比,它还是输。
他的原话是:成功不在可能的结果之列。
然后他给了动机解释:这些公司长期有一种"必须显得在做事"的需求,而燃料电池永远是十年后的技术,永远都是,所以可以一直说自己在研发燃料电池,这就足够安抚人了。
特斯拉内部管它叫 fool's cells。
公开市场有效,双股权别做绝
有人从资本形成的角度提问,暗示像 SpaceX 这种体量的公司需要更精细的融资平台。马斯克的回答很直白:他不觉得自己现在受资本约束。公开市场对他是有效的融资渠道,特斯拉走得不错,SolarCity 那年晚些时候可能上市,SpaceX 现金流为正已经几年,随时可以上市但不需要钱。
上市公司的代价,他说自己没觉得有多糟。他管理私营公司的方式本来就接近上市公司,有相应的控制和治理机制。真正的麻烦只有一个:如果你天天在意股价波动。他的建议是别太在意日间波动。
双股权结构他也谈了,态度比想象中温和。他说双股权有它的道理,特斯拉是单一股权。但他认为有些案例走得太远,一个类别基本不算数,那就不合理了。他给的方向是:最终要有通往单一股权的路径,因为继任问题绕不过去。
他举了福特的例子。福特家族对公司的长期取向起了稳定作用,福特也是当年唯一没破产的美国车企。所以他不否认双股权的价值,只是反对做到极端。
另外几句话
PayPal 的状况,主持人是从 Stripe 切进去的。她说这是唯一一个她比马斯克更懂的话题,前几天刚跟 Stripe 的人聊过。马斯克先承认自己是 Stripe 非常小的投资人,小到不知道他们在干什么,然后被问到 PayPal 是不是终于要完了。
他说如果 PayPal 不做点什么,就会被干掉。2000 年他写的产品计划,到今天几乎没变化,某些地方还更差了。他的判断是:PayPal 本该是所有钱所在的地方,但它不是。
教育这块,他点了 Sebastian Thrun 和 Salman Khan 的在线学习,认为这是真正有破坏力的方向。核心方法是游戏化:让学习不像苦差事,让人像被电子游戏吸引那样被学习吸引。至于上大学,他觉得完全可选,有想法就退学去试,随时可以回去,大学一直在那儿。
搬去洛杉矶的原因,他说得很实在。南加州有全世界最密集的航空航天工程师。他在湾区住了十年,住在 Palo Alto,离 PayPal 办公室三个街区,University Avenue 那个地址就是因为他住在 Forest 街。但造火箭这件事成功率本来就低,如果还要求有经验的航天工程师离开南加州、卖掉房子搬去房价昂贵的湾区,成功率会再低一截。所以他搬了过去。
火星的时间表,他说大概 12 到 15 年后可能到。他特别强调了一点:直到大约一年半以前,他才确信在火星上建立自给自足的文明是可能的。此前他觉得这件事"就在不可能的这一侧",现在的判断是"可能,只是极难"。
生于地球,死于火星
主持人问他有没有想过退休,毕竟有五个孩子。
他说想多陪孩子,但不想退休。他的目标是赶在衰老之前退休,大概 80 岁左右。他说这事有点像判断自己是不是疯了,也像缺氧,你意识不到自己的判断已经不太行了,直到来不及。
然后他说了那句话。
生于地球,死于火星,这件事挺酷的。(马斯克)
主持人拿 Peter Thiel 做对比,说 Thiel 想去一个没有法律的离岸岛屿,马斯克想去火星,火星是更冒险、更疯的那个版本。马斯克说 Thiel 只是喜欢玩味各种有趣的想法,未必真想住在离岸岛上,上次见他他就在旧金山。
最后一个问题照例是"你想要什么平庸超能力"。前面几个答案风格各异,有人说希望自己永远处在刚刚好的咖啡因摄入状态,有人说希望能在和姑娘抱着睡觉时临时卸下自己的胳膊,主持人的保姆说她想要给敌人施加痛经的能力。
马斯克说,最厉害的超能力是运气。
主持人说,大家都觉得你已经有了。于是他重新回答:
那就永远不堵车吧。
整场谈话到这里结束。那句"永远不堵车"听起来像玩笑,但把前面所有内容串起来看,它其实是这个人的方法论:他看到一件让他恼火的具体的事,一辆打滑的车、一条修不完的公路、一枚买不到的导弹、一块贵在安装费上的太阳能板,然后开始算,算完就去干。宏大的愿景是结果,起点永远是那件让他不舒服的小事。
十三年后再读这场对话,有几件事被验证了:可回收火箭把发射成本砸了下来,电动车从边缘产品变成了主流,光伏的价值果然沉到了系统集成和金融那一段。也有几件还没发生:Hyperloop 至今只有几条试验线,磁约束聚变还在等,火星上的那个温室还没有出现。
真正值得抄走的不是他的判断,是他做判断的那套动作。
可以立刻用上的几条
- 挑赛道时看的是资本和人才的流向,不是热度。所有人往一个方向涌的时候,反方向的进入成本最低,机会密度最高。这条适用于选行业,也适用于选岗位。
- 融资时把投资人当婚姻对象评估。同样的条款,选那个你愿意在董事会上吵三年架的人,别为了 40% 的估值差价忍受一个你心里打问号的人。这个建议对合伙人的选择同样成立。
- 算成本时把产业链拆开,找出真正贵的那一段。太阳能板便宜得像石膏板,贵的是安装和融资。你的行业里,那个看起来最不起眼的环节,往往藏着全部毛利。
- 给项目做预算时,默认乘二。马斯克三次创业的初始估算全部翻倍。如果你的计划里没有"成本翻倍还能活"的余量,这个计划就是纸上的。
- 用"这件事还需不需要我推"来判断什么时候退出。市值和职位都不算数,唯一的标准是当初要撬动的那件事有没有自己转起来。
- 启动一件极难的事之前,先想清楚最坏结果是不是可接受。他的 SpaceX 原本就是一笔当捐款准备的投入,全损也在预期之内,所以任何结果都算赢。这个心理账户的设立方式,决定了你能扛住多少次失败。
- 把"不知道自己在发疯"当成一种需要定期校准的状态。定期找几个不顺着你说话的人,听他们讲你的计划哪里荒谬。没有这一步,缺氧式的自我说服会一直到死才被发现。
0:00We have a lot to talk about and we only have you for an hour, so I want to get to it. I think the main thing that I want to get out of you tonight is you seem to play this game differently than everybody else. you know, there's in the history of Silicon Valley, there's only one guy who's created three companies that were worth more than a billion dollars each and that's Jim Clark. And he did it with Silicon Graphics, legitimate company, Netscape, legitimate company, and Healthion, which never would have been a billion-dollar company without a bubble. But all sort of in the same industry. You've done it if we count, if we count SpaceX even though it hasn't exited, but it has a
0:39multi-billion-dollar contract, so I think we can count it as more than a billion, right?
0:42Yes, SpaceX is a private Yeah, I mean it's it's private market valuation sort of a couple billion dollars.
0:50Right. So, so you're the only other guy who's done it and you've done it with payments, probably one of the hardest industries to disrupt on the web, cars, and going to space. Right. Yeah.
1:04So, what do you do differently?
1:07later this year, by the way.
1:09What? So, oh, yeah. But do you have a as a co-founder for that one?
1:12no, actually they offered to have me be listed as a co-founder, but I I thought that although I had suggested the initial idea, I did not put enough sort of sweat equity into it to be considered such.
1:25have been cuz then you could have been the first guy with four.
1:27yeah. I It's I I think there's sort of a certain threshold of of idea contribution and you know, initial effort that's that's required for that. That's sort of, you know, I mean it's sort of sort of subjective, but I think I don't think I did enough. Right.
1:44They did offer it to me, but I I said no.
1:46So, it is part of the reason you've done this that you are sort of crazy? Are you lucky?
1:52I You know, I've I've been thinking about that lately. And and I I sort of wonder, you know, I think I probably am a bit crazy. but I think but maybe that's that's sort of a healthy sign because at the point at which you conclude you're not crazy at all, then you probably are.
2:14So, the fact that you you realized that you're thing, yeah.
2:19There's one story that I've heard about you. Do I seem crazy?
2:22Yes. I've heard a lot of people say that about you. Here's the story that made me think Here's the story that made me think you were crazy. Okay.
2:27and you can tell me if this is
2:28Does this involve the New York Times? No. Okay.
2:33Elon got me in so much trouble several years ago and Yeah.
2:37he called someone a douchebag and a liar and I started laughing and never looked back. douchebag and an idiot.
2:43We actually said a liar. We cut out the liar. did I really?
2:46Yeah, cuz it would have been liable if that part we cut.
2:48Okay. Well, I think that that may Well, I guess that's probably true, too. But but I I think it's more more the first two, yeah.
2:56More the first two, yeah. So, no, this is the story that made me think you were crazy. Yeah.
3:00I heard right after you sold PayPal, before the other two companies, you went and bought a McLaren S1 F1, yeah.
3:08F1, yeah. Sorry. The that No, that's the that's the same part. Oh, right. It's
3:13Partially cuz you were going to race cars with Jim Clark and Larry Ellison.
3:16no. Well, not really, no. Actually, and I never did. although that was one of the things that was sort of talked about at one point, but I never did. In fact, I've I've never raced anyone with my car. I I had I had several years I put 11,000 mi on it and I drove it from LA to San Francisco. It was my daily driver, which is a crazy car to have as a daily driver, particularly on the 405.
3:34So, But I understand when you got it, Yeah.
3:37you're driving down 280 and you wrecked it. No, well,
3:42And you Let me just tell the story and then you can correct it.
3:45I mean, yeah, let's see if the story that you tell is actually How does that How that compares to the the reality? Cuz the reality is pretty messed up.
3:52So, hopefully the reality's better. So, you wrecked the car, you get out of the car, you're doubling over with laughter. And the person with you said, "Why are you laughing that you just wrecked this car?" And you said, "No, you don't know the funny part. IT WASN'T INSURED."
4:09WELL, THE PUNCHLINE'S CORRECT. yeah, so I was actually I was driving up Sand Hill Road with with Peter Thiel, my co-founder of PayPal. We actually driving to see Mike Moritz. this is in in 2000. And so we're driving up Sand Hill Road. I didn't really know how to drive the McLaren. And Peter says, "So, so what can this do?" And then like I'm probably number one on the list of famous last words, I said, "Watch this."
4:46so I so I floored it. I floored it and did a lane change on on Sand Hill. And so the McLaren has no attraction control or anything. It's just it's massive power to to the wheels. So, 600 640 brake horsepower and it it only weighs a ton. So, it has massive power to weight. It can break wheels free at 80 mph. so it broke the the rear end free and started spinning. and I I sort of let's see, I think it was sort of I was I was going straight and then turned and I remember seeing the the cars coming towards me while I was going backwards. And then we hit the hit an embankment sort of a 45° embankment on Sand Hill, which tossed the car into the air like a discus. And it kept it
5:32kept rotating with about 3 ft of air air clearance, according to witnesses. and then slammed down on on on the ground going the original direction. and we blew the suspension out and now it actually wreck the car the core chassis and the engine were okay. Thank god.
5:52But but all all the glass and the wheels and everything was was shredded and and there was massive body damage in the front and rear. and yeah. Did you start laughing?
6:05I don't recall laughing. I I mean I I I could have been laughing in shock but I don't recall laughing. and and then and then Peter caught a hitched a ride to to Mike. I I waited while the the fire truck and the ambulance arrived and then finally the
6:25Did Peter Thiel literally hitch a ride? to to Like
6:28to yeah over to to to Sequoia to yeah and then and then I I once once the car was taken care of then I I I hitched a ride too. and so and we we continued the meeting.
6:39I'm picturing you and Peter Thiel like that scene in Tommy Boy where you're like the deer and you're both like Yeah really. Oh wow. Yeah. Is there a parallel be alive really.
6:52I I should say so. Is there a parallel with how you build companies in that story? I hope not.
6:59Let's see what this thing can do.
7:02yeah watch this. That that could be awkward with a rocket launch. You know yeah it's it's it's one thing if you've got a one ton car versus a million pounds of TNT equivalent. That is a little dicey. Yeah.
7:19now what I think is so I mean one of the things I find so interesting about you the rest of the PayPal guys they get done with PayPal they start starting and investing in web 2.0 companies at a point in time when everyone said that's insane. That's insane the internet will never come back. They were considered the crazy ones. Meanwhile you move to LA and start working on Solar City SpaceX Tesla's a glint in your eye. Yeah.
7:45Why didn't you Would you ever do an internet company again? Do you find the internet boring?
7:50I think it's unlikely that I'll do an internet company again because not that I find the internet boring. I mean I'm still sort of I think I'm relatively sort of net savvy and interested in the internet and what's what's going on. You know, I I I don't ever want to be the the like like grandpa who doesn't do email or something like that, you know.
8:10So I I think But I think I'm trying to allocate my efforts to that which I think would most affect the future of humanity in in in in a positive way and the I think there's there's lots of entrepreneurial energy and and and financing headed towards the internet whereas in certain sectors like automotive and solar and space, you don't see new entrants. You don't There's not a lot of capital going to startups and not a lot of entrepreneurs going to that into those arenas. And the the and the problem is that in the absence of some new entrants into an industry, you you you you don't you don't have that that force for innovation. It's really new
8:59entrants that that drive innovation more than anything. So that's why I have devoted my efforts to those those industries and and they are industries that require as that you know quite a quite a bit of capital to get going. And even with SpaceX, I mean I I invest I mean I had My proceeds from PayPal after tax were about $180 million.
9:22100 of that went into into SpaceX, 70 into Tesla, and 10 into SolarCity. and and I literally had to borrow money for rent. so that was a close call. Or
9:35No. That was not the plan.
9:36So what was the What was the plan? You thought I'll just put 10 in each of these or?
9:41Well, actually I thought with SpaceX I thought it would be about Well, I guess it was probably about double. I thought it could cost it ended up being double in in in most cases. So, with SpaceX I thought it'd be 50. With Tesla I thought it'd be I thought I'd be putting in 25, maybe 30. with SolarCity for Well, SolarCity actually went really well. and that's that's the one where I wasn't a co-founder, so maybe that's a good sign.
10:08I mean I should I should co-found less stuff. so, that's
10:14So, what happened? Why did you have to put more money in the other two? What Did investors flake? Did you have
10:19Well, I didn't actually seek investor funding for the first three rounds of of SpaceX because you know, the first thing that investors want to ask you is sort of well, what's tell us about prior successes in this field. and and you know, what could we compare this to? and and there's you know, the one when you've got kind of the donut in the success category and a lot of you know, a cemetery full of failures, then they're they're not that keen. And rockets are just pretty far out of the comfort zone of most venture capitalists.
10:54and and now, we were able to to get venture funding after we made some progress and demonstrated that we were able to al- al- almost get to orbit. Mhm.
11:06and yeah, credit goes to sort of to to Founders Fund and which was obviously some of my compatriots from from PayPal, Peter and Peter Thiel and Luke Nosek and and Mhm.
11:17Ken Howery and another guys. Mhm.
11:19So, and and they they invested before we got to orbit, so so credit to them for that. But but I did have to show that I could actually make stuff. Like I I never actually made physical stuff before you know, before SpaceX. So, let learn rockets. started with a rocket?
11:34Yeah. I mean, it's that's a that's a hard one. and it's the the probability of success was low. In fact, when I started space X, I thought that the most likely outcome was failure. but and and I think to have any other expectation would have been irrational. So,
11:53So, why did you want to do it? I know for Tesla, it seems more obvious like, oh, save the planet, big auto makers aren't doing this. I I mean, I think it's sort of fairly obvious that's good for humanity. Why did you feel like space X needed to be done?
12:05Well, I I I guess the if you if you look at the the trajectory of space technology and and and and progress, the the pinnacle of of that progress was was around maybe 1969, 1970. you know, with with the with the moon missions. And so, we we made incredible incredible progress in the '60s.
12:31And and then we were able to land on the moon. And then with the space shuttle, we could only get people to lower orbit. Now, the space shuttle is retired and that's just a There's no trajectory of improvement. It's a trajectory to nothing. Mhm.
12:45So, and I kept thinking that there'd be some plan to send people to Mars because that's the obvious next step. And the actual origin of space X is is is when I was I think it was around 2000 one or so and I was visiting a friend of mine, Adeo Ressi, who actually you you may have met. but he he lives in Palo Alto now.
13:09we we we were we were college housemates. And he asked me what I was going to do after PayPal and I said, well, I've always been interested in space. And but I didn't think there was anything I could do in space as an individual. So, my initial plan in space was actually to send to do a small mission to Mars with with a greenhouse essentially seeds and dehydrated nutrient gel in a little greenhouse that would land and you'd hydrate the gel and then you'd grow the plants and you'd have this great shot of of green plants on a red background.
13:38And that would be the money shot essentially. and and and the people tend to respond to precedents and superlatives and this would be the furthest that life's ever traveled, the the first life on Mars as far as we know. And and that that would get people excited and I thought well that would result in an increased NASA budget and then we could send people to Mars cuz that's you know, I think you want to have a future where you're expecting things to be better, not one where you're expecting things to be worse. Mhm.
14:06so that was how I think it started out and then as I learned more and I I went to speaking of crazy things, went went to Russia three times to negotiate a deal to buy a couple of the largest ICBMs in the Russian fleet. a strange experience.
14:23How do you even get into that negotiation?
14:26well, you talk to people and know people and and pretty soon you're talking to the Russian rocket forces and you know, they it turns out Russia's quite quite a capitalist society and and so I but I but I definitely had had some some weird meetings in in in places like that I swear they looked like a sanita- sanitarium or something, I don't know. It's very odd.
14:54We keep coming back to the theme of crazy.
14:56Yeah. seriously, this place had padded walls. you're like, "Who Why do you have padded walls?" That was weird. and yeah, and then I had some some sort of Russian guy who was missing a front tooth started yelling at me because his friend one of his front teeth was missing, it was like spit flying at me in a place with padded walls. I'm like, this is really bizarre.
15:23What's happened to my life? Right.
15:25And that was the moment when you thought, I'm going to build my own rocket.
15:27Yeah. That was probably the when I got back from that third trip, I was like, well, I realized that the the real issue, the reason we haven't advanced in space is because the cost of of space transportation is is become unaffordable. You know, it's got it's become more and more expensive to do to do less and less in space. And we really need to improve the technology of space transportation. So, that's why I started SpaceX. Mhm.
15:52But, it it it may seem odd that I would start SpaceX with with the expectation of failure, but bear in mind that my initial thing was to do essentially a philanthropic mission with a 0% chance of success from a financial standpoint. So, it was it would have effectively been a donation to the cause.
16:10And so, anything better than that is win.
16:12Right. Right. So, you know, I know people think of you as someone who's had a lot of success, but you had several failures within SpaceX before the recent launch. Can you Can you tell us a little bit about what it's like to put that much work into something and and and be doing something that really no one else is doing? And at least trying something and putting that much of your own money in it that you're having to borrow money from friends to pay your rent. And there are launches and it's failing.
16:41Yeah, that that well, it super sucks, I can tell you. Yeah, that that that that was 2008 in particular was was was was awful because we had the third launch failure in a row of of our Falcon 1 vehicle at SpaceX. And we the Tesla financing round that we were raising fell apart cuz the economy was going to tailspin and it's pretty hard to raise money for a startup car company you know, late 2008 when GM and Chrysler are busy going bankrupt. Mhm.
17:18that that was that was tough and then SolarCity had to deal with Morgan Stanley and Morgan Stanley had to renege on the deal cuz they themselves were running out of money. so all three looked like all three companies were going to die and I was also going through a divorce. So that was definitely a low point.
17:35and but fortunately the fourth launch worked and and then
17:40Did you think the third launch was going to work? Was it a shock that it didn't?
17:45well I I I thought it would most likely I think I thought the odds of it working were were better than 50%. but yeah there was just a little little change in the thrust transient of the first stage engine that resulted in that we didn't we couldn't see it on the ground because of the thrust transient well to get slightly technical for a second the the pressure decay on the thrust transient dropped below sea level pressure. So when you when you look at it on the test stand at with you know at sea level you don't see it. It doesn't it doesn't look like it's there's a thrust transient and because we changed the architecture of the engine to one
18:24that was regeneratively cooled instead of ablatively cooled it had this little tiny transient which caused the first stage to ram the upper stage and and the the upper stage engine started started inside the interstage section. Like it's like sort of firing up this giant this engine indoors with with a big plasma blowback that fried the fried the upper stage. Wow.
18:47Yeah. I wasn't expecting that.
18:49So So it's 2008. You're going through a divorce which like some to borrow your word douchebag bloggers are writing about to make even worse.
18:58Right. yes that's true. In addition to to all this stuff happening I was getting dumped on massively in the press. Right. Yeah.
19:05You're you know it looks like all three companies Yeah.
19:07are going to get fail. I mean why do you keep going with all three? Like I feel like even a lot of great entrepreneurs in that situation would have been like, I've already sunk everything I have in these companies and I got to pick one. But, you didn't. I mean, you kept doing all three. Why?
19:24yeah, that was a that was a very tough call. at at the end of 2008, that was that was probably the tough you know, one of the toughest calls I've had to make. because I could either reserve capital for one company or the other. I mean, fortunately, SolarCity didn't need a ton of capital, so they were they were okay. but between SpaceX and and and Tesla,
19:48you know, it's sort of like like you got two kids and what do you do? Do you spend all your money to to to maximize the probability of success of of one or do you you try to keep both alive? Fortunately, it worked.
20:02you also had to step back in as the CEO of Tesla.
20:05Yeah, my goal was never to be the CEO of Tesla. from the beginning, I mean, I had an interest in electric cars that goes back 20 years to, you know, when I was in college. In fact, I used to talk to my dates about electric cars. Probably not the best strategy. Close those dates.
20:20No, no. I I used to have to stop talking about that. but yeah, so I I I had a long long-standing interest in electric cars. but just since I was doing SpaceX, I knew that if if if I did try to start an electric car company and run it, that it would be extremely painful to run two companies. So, I didn't I tried really tried my hardest not to be the CEO of of Tesla. I mean, I could any at any point from day one, I could have been the CEO cuz I had majority control of the company. Right. but
20:57I really tried not to and in the end, it was at the end of 2008, it's I had to commit all of my reserve capital to to Tesla. All that and that wasn't allocated to SpaceX and so I felt I had to sort of steer the ship directly, but it was it was not it was not out of it was most it was really not fun. Like super not fun.
21:22Yeah, I remember when we talked I I guess maybe the next year after that you said, you know, this is not at the fun level running these two companies.
21:31No, I mean it's definitely gotten a lot better. with with SpaceX, you know, we we so since we've now had five successful launches in a row and we're able to dock with the space station and with Tesla we're able to raise enough capital to get the company to be able to produce the Model S and and do the IPO and you know, so I've got a much strong I've got a much stronger a much stronger team with a lot of bench strength at both companies.
22:00so you know, I can go from essentially almost every waking hour being being spent on the companies to 90% which is a big difference actually.
22:12is the ambition still to find another CEO for one or the other?
22:16well, I I I expect to run both companies for the foreseeable future because I've I've made a commitment to people at both companies to do that. Will I be running both companies forever? I I think that's that's unlikely, but certainly for the foreseeable future I will be.
22:37Is there one that has your heart more than the other one?
22:41well, you know, they both they both they both do have my heart, but I think that there there may come a point, you know, several years in the future where the the fundamental good that Tesla is trying to accomplish, which is to serve as a catalyst for the acceleration of sustainable transport been accomplished. In other words, that I mean that's really what what what has the If you look at from an historical standpoint, or or or what what's important here in affecting the world, it's it's to what degree is Tesla serving as a catalyst for the advent of electric vehicles.
23:20and at some point, you know, when when say most cars being manufactured are electric, then te- that will have been accomplished, and or the the catalytic value of Tesla will will have been realized. and the diminishing returns have gone. I think at that point, I I would not need to run the company. yeah.
23:46Can we talk a little bit about across the companies, your experience with venture capitalists, because it's been pretty varied, right? Yes.
23:57So, you've had good experiences, you've had not so good experiences. Is that fair to say? wide range. Yes.
24:03What have you What What would you advise entrepreneurs watching this or in the audience to make sure they don't they don't live through what you did in the bad experiences? And can you tell us about the bad experience?
24:17well, I think I think one thing that's important is if if you have a choice of a lower valuation with with someone you really like, or a higher valuation with someone you have a question mark about, take the lower valuation. it's it's better to have a a higher quality venture capitalist who you think is like would be great to work with, than to ha- you know, get a get a higher valuation with someone where there's even a question mark, really. You know, I think that's that's important. It's sort of like getting married, you know.
24:51I don't know. Well, maybe I haven't been that good at that. But You probably learned
24:57years is okay. mean, it's not too bad. It's
25:00Did you do that wrong? Did you maximize for evaluation?
25:06the I suppose in in the case of the Tesla Series C I I don't know I I mean, at some point I think I'll I'll tell the the full story, but Not tonight. But, not tonight. the They did wait an hour.
25:23Right. No, I know. Well, I'll tell part I'll tell I'll tell part of the story. So, the There There was There were There were two There were multiple competing bids, but there were two competing bids. one was from Kleiner Perkins, the other one was from VantagePoint. Kleiner offered 50 a $50 million pre-money. VantagePoint offered 70.
25:54I actually said to John Doerr that if if John joins the board Mhm.
26:00we'll do it at 50. but John felt that there was that that he he had too many obligations and that there was another partner at Kleiner who who really wanted the deal and so he could not supplant that person. and I I I I thought, well we could do I I would I would be okay if if John Doerr joined the I I I I mean, there's a 40% difference. That difference is pretty significant. So, if if John would would be willing to join the board, then we could do that, but not if it was somebody else. Mhm.
26:32Yeah, that that was probably a mistake.
26:34Mhm. And so, then they did Fisker instead, which
26:38And that was their mistake.
26:39Yeah. Yes. I I I hope they live past the election.
26:50Fisker and A123 are both having a lot of issues. Yeah.
26:55What has Tesla done that it hasn't fallen in that bucket? What was I mean looking back, was there a crossroads where you made a right choice that has put you guys so far I mean you're not profitable yet, but in a different category?
27:08well the Tesla's a a really different company to to Fisker. I mean we're Tesla's a hardcore technology company and and we we do really serious engineering and and I think you only build value in a company if you if you're doing hard work to solve tough problems. That that's that's why companies are valuable or it's why they should be valuable and and largely is why they're valuable. So and and and we do we we do our we do real manufacturing as well. I mean the the Model S coils of aluminum and plastic pellets come in and cars come out. I mean we're we do real hardcore manufacturing quite vertically integrated.
27:48and the we did all the vehicle engineering, all the powertrain engineering, all the software and whereas and and we also we also of course do the the the styling and design of the car. We've got a great design studio. Our head of design Franz von Holzhausen is awesome. in the case of Fisker it's it's headed by always headed by you know Henrik Fisker and and he's he's a designer so he's he's good at sort of the styling of the cars but he thinks it's all about styling. Mhm.
28:20and it and and it's not. you know it's it's really this is you know the the the the reason we don't have electric cars is not for lack of styling.
28:30Right. at the time when you were getting started with Tesla the Valley was trying to take a turn back towards science and towards saving the world. you had Kleiner Perkins, Khosla Ventures, a lot of these big firms really getting aggressive about clean tech and saying that was going to be the next internet. That has not been the case. Right.
28:54why did clean tech not work for the Valley?
28:58Well, I think the jury's out on clean tech. I think as far as Tesla and Tesla and SolarCity are certainly clean tech or I'd say I I think it would more like sustainable energy stuff. I think sustainable energy is a better more of a more of a but but more of a mouthful but it's more accurate than than than than clean tech.
29:20and I mean I think the I think I think Tesla's going to be an extremely valuable company in the long term. and
29:28done differently? Because a lot of VCs have said well, the problem with clean tech is you have to rely on subsidies and if you have to rely on subsidies, it's never going to work. I mean, people buying a Tesla in part get a subsidy, it takes down the price. I assume with SolarCity. So, it's like like that hasn't been a knock against you guys. Like why have these two companies worked when when so many other ones haven't?
29:49I I think it's you know, in in any industry there are only a few companies that that kind of get big and and succeed. and I I don't know. I think I it just seems that in in the case of Tesla we we were focused on making great products and and doing solving hard engineering problems. I mean, as evidence in Tesla forward, the fact that we solve hard hard engineering problems is a fact that Toyota and Daimler and Mercedes you know, buy electric power trains from us. I mean, they if this was easy, they would just do it. Right.
30:25so so we focused on solving really hard engineering problems at at Tesla. that's like I said, that contrasts with Fisker to some degree. And and then at at SolarCity the so SolarCity does everything except the panel. So, what a lot of people don't realize is that the solar panel, if it's a standard efficiency solar panel, the difficulty of manufacturing that is about as hard as manufacturing drywall. It's really easy. -huh.
30:56And so, I mean it seemed to me pretty obvious that in the long term we'd see cutthroat competition between silicon PV manufacturers in China, Japan, Germany, and other places much as you see this competition in the DRAM market. I think the PV market and the DRAM market are very similar. And so, you that that cost would be driven down to to very low number approaching the raw material cost really.
31:28and that that's that's pretty much what happened. And and so, the real the real cost of solar and and real challenge for solar is what's called balance of system. It's everything except the panel. And and so, the the cost per installed watt for a residential system might be around $4 now. Which is a big drop from where it was a few years ago. It used to be sort of $7, now it's it's sort of kind of half that.
31:50But the optimization really has to be at the everything except the panel cuz the panels are are dropping now to like 90 cents a watt. Mhm.
31:58So, you know over three you know, $3 of the $4 is balance of system which you which includes the you know, that it it includes the customer ownership experience, the designing the system particularly to a particular rooftop, installing it, the wiring, the inverter, after sales service, figuring out the financing the final financing of it all. Mhm.
32:19you know, it's in the same way that say say Dell. Dell doesn't make the CPU or the hard drive or the the RAM or anything, but they kind of design the system and they manage the customer experience and that's that's kind of how SolarCity is. So, when I looked at the problem of solar power, that that that's what looked like to me.
32:39Mhm. So, that's why SolarCity is working on the problems that it's working on and it's doing super well with you know, 90% of the credit, 95% of the credit due to Lyndon Rive and the rest of the team at SolarCity.
32:58you've said I think this is the first time I've interviewed you and you haven't said it, that being an entrepreneur is like standing on the edge of an looking into abyss chewing broken glass.
33:09yeah, actually that's a a phrase from a friend of mine, Bill Lee, who he he's early internet entrepreneurs and done a number of things since and and he he the the phrase that he uses is like starting a company is like it's like chewing glass and staring into the abyss. Right. So, I flipped it.
33:29Yeah, it's just a So, if it's it's I mean there's a point which obviously it's not that that not that way.
33:35do you still feel like that or I know easy now?
33:42I you know, the staring at the abyss part is just you know, are you are you facing imminent death? And we certainly were at SpaceX and Tesla and SolarCity for a long time. I think I don't we're no longer staring into the abyss, which is great. There's always going to be some amount of glass that's got to be chewed.
33:58it's never zero. but it's less and less as as time goes by.
34:04So, less glass and no more abyss.
34:06No, yeah, the abyss is kind of there in the distance, but I'm not staring right at it. vision. Yeah. Yeah.
34:13I mean, you know, you guys did PayPal, which was, you know, obviously started at a time when that there was a lot of money and there were advantages, but you know, compared to other dot coms was a very hard company to build. And then you go on to do Tesla. keep alive. Yeah. Right.
34:26as as you point out, I mean, PayPal got started in like late '99, late '98 to early '99. Mhm.
34:33and yeah, it was a sort of merger of two companies, X.com that I started and Confinity that Max Levchin started. And and we started to come sort of pull our resources and and tackle problem together. Mhm.
34:47and but but we went from starting the company to less than 18 months later, maybe it was 14 months later or something, having a valuation of $500 million. and you know, those these days, you know, after seeing some of the you know, things like the recent acquisition by Facebook, they go, "Well, maybe that's not that great." but but at the time it was certainly it was like this is this is completely ridiculous, that we
35:22Did you feel that way though? Cuz I know there were some people inside the company who thought, "Why are we only Why are we only worth $500 million?"
35:28I thought it was completely ridiculous. but but the Nasdaq peaked I think in March or thereabouts of 2000. Right.
35:39And that's around when we when we did the valuation for $500 million. But the the challenge was really keeping the company alive for the next 2 years roughly until well, until it was sold to eBay.
35:51What What is you and Peter's relationship like and what was it like then? There's There's a lot of stories that the two of you guys did not get along in that merger.
35:59you know, we've had our disagreements, but we're friends, and I would say for 95% of our the time we were around each other, we've been friends.
36:12I bet that 5% was rough though, knowing both of you.
36:15a little It was a little rough, yeah. Things were a little bumpy at one at one point. and I think I'm I'm not I'm I have more tolerance for risk than Peter does. So I was sort of maybe more kind of pedal to the metal and Peter was like, "Well, let's a little bit let's be a little cautious here." He may be right actually, so.
36:37Mhm. Which is ironic since he encouraged you to gun your car that
36:40Well, I don't think that was what he had in mind. But yeah, he I'm pro- I'm probably slightly more risk risk tolerant than Peter is. but I think what But between all of us we've managed to make PayPal work, which is the what was what that was the important thing.
37:02But back to the back to the abyss and the the broken glass. I mean, do you only enjoy this if you're just the odds of failure?
37:11No. No, I'm I'm I'm liking life more and more actually. as as this less staring into the abyss and less glass chewing, I'm finding that to be a good thing. so I I hope never to return to the experiences I had in 2008 and 2009.
37:31So I know back in I think it was 2008 you talked about if you were to start other companies, one that you had an idea for was a electric plane that could take off and land vertically. Yeah.
37:41Does that seem Are Are you now like, "Fuck no, I am not starting another company?" Are you still thinking that?
37:48how I feel. That is. Yeah, I've actually I mean there are three things that that I think well, arguably four that I think could be done. I think I could probably do it. Maybe, you know, have a better than even chance of success. one is the an electric jet sort of it's this would be kind of something cool cuz I one of the things that I guess where the idea where these things tend to come from is like I'll read something that seems like like a sad thing in technology and then like, "Well, how could we make it not a sad thing?" So, when I read about the Concorde being retired, I was like, "Oh, jeez, you know, we don't even have supersonic transport. That's terrible." Mhm.
38:34and I did actually never get a chance to to to fly in the Concorde, so you know, that just seemed like a terrible thing. So, initially I thought, "Well, I started reading up about it and I read that that the Concorde was it was really designed in the '60s and and so the aerodynamics have have improved a great deal with computational fluid dynamics, engine efficiencies have improved massively, and even if you just change the engines on the Concorde, you could double the range. Mhm.
39:00or or thereabouts. And so, then I thought, "Well, okay, what what if what if you we could figure out a a really efficient design that could make it economically competitive to have a supersonic aircraft?" And and then and then I started looking at it more and more and then I started doing the math on on on all of it. It seemed like, "Well, you just really want to go higher and higher. you know, that the lower you are in the atmosphere, the more drag you have. atmospheric density decays exponentially.
39:33so, as as as you go up, you you you your your air density just drops drops dramatically and it's it's really easy to go fast. And I mean, and your speed is just a force balance. It's whatever you you the output thrust of the engine is you know, balanced against the the drag that you're experiencing. Mhm.
39:50So, as you go higher, you just go faster for the same force. Mhm.
39:55and and and then there's there's there's a slight outward acceleration you experience, which is also slightly helpful. like like a satellite, you know, when a satellite's going Mach 25, it it just goes on forever once it's out of the atmosphere. So, anyway, this is maybe slightly the worst, but the an an electric fan gets better electric aircraft gets better at the higher you go.
40:20whereas, a combustion aircraft does not. You have you you start starving it starving it from from from oxygen. and and only in fact the air is mostly nitrogen. So, what when you when as you're going through the air, you you're sort of sucking in all this all this nitrogen, which is just kind of slowing you down and and you're trying to combust oxygen. Anyway, so with with aircraft with combustion aircraft you you hit a an optimal altitude that's in the sort of 35 to maybe 55 max altitude. whereas
40:57in electric aircraft you could you'd want to go at like maybe 80,000 ft. and anyway, it's a long long way of saying you can get super efficient and super fast with electric aircraft and and vertical takeoff landing works well with being supersonic and anyway, so I I think I think you could you could make a really breakthrough aircraft that's several generations beyond what currently exists.
41:21But are you going to do that?
41:23Not anytime soon. It's possible that I may do it at some point in the future because between SpaceX and Tesla, I kind of have the ingredients. so it's very tempting. Easy after those.
41:37Yeah. but I I the the the the I think may maybe it's worth something worth considering in a few years. that's so that's one idea. Then there's I think we could really improve transport by having a prefabricated kind of double-decker or actually what what would really make sense is a a steel box beam over the center divider with a a lane on the inside and lane on top. that's made in prefabricated sections and installed down the center divider and you can get two lanes and you can have the the traffic be, you know, all one way or all the other and massively improve life in places like Los Angeles where I was just stuck in traffic going Right.
42:19for like an hour to go 3 miles. So I don't know who's in charge of the damn 405 construction but they're a bloody idiot. And I hate them. It is it is the worst construction project I've ever witnessed in my life. I curse them daily.
42:41Okay, so that's two. What are the other two you would do?
42:43well the other one well one of the the third one would be I think you could make fusion work. And and I mean and and I mean by that I mean magnetic confinement fusion. you know relatively standard fusion if you will. And And then the fourth one
43:05Photo sharing app. Right. Subscription commerce in a box.
43:11Absolutely. The fourth one I'm considering just open sourcing. You know basically just describing the idea, saying that this is what would be done and and if somebody wants to do it then they can do it. But I I think like maybe I should patent it and then offer to open source the patent to anyone that can make a credible case that they could actually do it.
43:33So I'm sort of debating it but it would be for for a fifth mode of transport. So right now we've got off terrestrial transport, we've got planes, trains, automobiles, and boats. Mhm.
43:42for getting around Earth. And but what if there was a fifth mode? Mhm.
43:49And I I have a name for it name for it which is called the Hyperloop. The Hyperloop? Hyperloop, yeah.
43:55Is it like a Jetsons tunnel? What?
43:57It's something like that, yeah.
44:00Like you just get in it whisks you?
44:02yeah. Well I'll I'll and I'll I'll I'll tell you the characteristics. So this partly prompted by the California train thing. Like we know we've got like a bullet train that that's like this it's the has a dubious distinction of being the slowest bullet train and the most expensive per mile. Go California.
44:23We got some superlatives there. so we're setting records at both you know both ends of the the wrong the wrong end of the of the spectrum. And you know we're apparently it's going to be like $60 billion or something to go from San Francisco to LA and if it's if they're saying 60 now it's going to be more later. Right.
44:44And of course it's a really slow slow train.
44:46this in perspective, a $100 million got you into space.
44:49Well, it got me started. I mean it got it got me to Yeah, it certainly got me to space and probably get get me into orbit very close. Yes, yes, something like that. Yeah. In terms of cap of of cap of venture capital investment it's been a couple hundred million total including outside investors. So, and SpaceX has been profitable for the last few years. So, I think we can do do something that's probably 10% of the cost and and and I I try to think of what are the attributes that you'd want in a new mode of transport. in fact, what is the theoretically fastest way that you could get from LA to San Francisco? Mhm.
45:26and and so so the system I have in mind which is you've you've sort of you're guessing in the right direction. so how how do you like something that can never crash? Mhm.
45:38it is immune to weather. it goes three or four times faster than the the the sort of bullet train that's being built. jet?
45:48Well, it it would it goes about let's say the an average speed of twice what what what aircraft would would do. So, you go from downtown LA to downtown San Francisco in under 30 minutes. Mhm.
46:04and it would cost you much less than than an air ticket or car much less than any other mode of transport which is fundamental energy cost is is so much lower. And I think we could actually make it self-power it self-powering if you just if you put solar panels on it. you you you generate power of back the envelope is you generate more power than you than you would consume in the system.
46:33and there's a way to store the power so that it would run 24/7. Mhm.
46:39without using batteries. so you there's you can you know there's different ways to store energy. Anyway, so that's
46:48think this is possible? This is not just
46:50Yes, absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah.
46:53Wow. Is there ever a time you retire? You have five children. You ever just want to hang out with the kids?
47:02Yes, I do. I do want to hang out with the kids. I don't want to retire, but I do want to hang out with the kids. my goal is to retire right before senility. it's tough, you know, tough you know
47:16It's it's like being crazy. Like how do you know you're crazy?
47:18it's like getting hypoxia. You don't like you don't realize your your your your decisions suck until you're dead. so so I don't intend to retire. Maybe at like 80 or something. and it would be cool to be born on Earth and die on Mars. Yeah, so.
47:36Yeah, you've said before you want to retire on Mars. Is this more or less feasible?
47:40well, actually I was asked do I it's more like if I were to retire, I just like I want to retire, but if I were to to retire on the verge of senility, I'd like it to be on Mars. That would be cool.
47:53It's funny cuz you're saying earlier that you're slightly more risk-taking than Peter. Peter wants to be on a boat that's like an island out somewhere that has no laws. You want to be on Mars. It is the slightly riskier, crazy version.
48:07Yeah. I think Peter entertains a lot of interesting ideas. I'm not sure he necessarily wants to be on an island offshore. I mean last time I saw him he was in San Francisco. So But but I think he likes to he sort of entertains interesting ideas and he's not bound by convention, certainly.
48:27That's for sure. All right, we want to get some questions from the audience. So we've got a couple microphones. If anyone wants to line up. While we're waiting on people, you're an investor in Stripe and
48:37A very tiny investor. Very tiny investor and I've no idea what they're doing.
48:42Well, I know this is the only subject where I know more than you. I talked to them the other day. But which leads me to the question, do you think PayPal is finally screwed?
48:51Well, if if PayPal doesn't do something, it will be screwed. Yes.
48:55There has not been a lot of innovation.
48:56No, in fact, if if you look at the product plan that I wrote in 2000 there's hardly any difference. In fact, it's it's slightly worse than that. It's gone backwards.
49:10Yeah. I mean PayPal should be where all the money is. Yeah. And it's not. It's definitely not. All right. Go ahead.
49:20I I first want to thank you, Sarah, for believing in LA. I I was actually up at one of the events in San Francisco and I think we have two to three times as many people here. So thank you.
49:31It is It is the same It's actually 100 people fewer than we fit in our in our San Francisco venue, but it sold out the fastest.
49:39So Ben Horowitz sold out in about 4 hours and you sold out in 3.
49:42All right. And you have a a writer here, Michael, so thank you for believing in LA.
49:47I think we are the only blog with a full-time writer here.
49:50There you go. my question is for you, Elon. First of all, thank you for doing these big things to, you know, improve humanity. I work for Space Adventures when I was in college and I really believe in the space frontier, the abyss, so to speak. But indeed, but just thinking about LA for a moment, what do you think we can do to improve the the ecosystem here in LA?
50:11Well, I think better freeways would be huge. Honestly, I I don't I I wish there was like Who do I complain to about the the freeways? Yeah, yeah, so some somebody's got to be responsible for it. Yeah,
50:28Don't do that. I'd rather you build jets and hyperloops than be the mayor of LA.
50:32but I I I think if if somebody could Seriously, it's like if improving the transport system of if that's got to be for anyone who lives in LA, what's going to be the number one gripe? It's it's the damn highways.
50:42I tried to run a startup and to do that, but no one would fund me. Yeah. endinggridlock.org
50:51I'm open to funding someone if they if they want to do the bucks beam thing over the center divider, which would be I mean a regulatory challenge, but I mean I think people you can get people to vote for it. I'd vote for it in like 3 seconds. And it's just you got to do it in a way that it doesn't impede the existing traffic flow. And so it's got to be prefabricated sections that just get dropped in place like Lego.
51:10Mhm. Why did you move to LA?
51:13because the Southern California has the biggest concentration of aerospace engineers in the world. Oh.
51:18and it was a choice I had. My I mean I lived in in the Bay Area for 10 years and lived in Palo Alto. I lived like three three blocks away from the PayPal office. That's why PayPal is on University Avenue cuz I lived on Forest. Mhm.
51:32It's just really convenient. So, I moved down to LA just because the the odds of success with a rocket company were pretty low to begin with and if I insisted that experienced aerospace engineers move from Southern California to the Bay Area and can leave their job and buy and buy a house in the Bay Area, which is really expensive.
51:52Then then the odds of success would would go would be decreased even further. So, that that that's why I moved to to LA is is All right. Yeah.
52:02I want to try to get through as many of these questions as possible, but cuz we do not have Elon for much longer. So, let's ask him real quick and answer real quick. Okay? All right. Okay.
52:10Hey Elon, huge fan of yours. So, thank you so much for inspiring young entrepreneurs all over the world. quick question. One of the area of innovation is in the area of education, right? So, I'd love to hear your thoughts on what are some of the ways that we can disrupt or to in the area of education.
52:28Right. well, what Sebastian Thrun is doing and Salman Khan I mean, I think that's really those that stuff is really disruptive. sorry. And yeah, so so what Sebastian Thrun and and so and and Khan are doing is that that's great stuff. Sort of online learning. And I think there's a if to the to the degree that you can gamify learning, I think that's really helpful.
52:57most you want to make learning not a chore. if if people are drawn to it like they're drawn to video games, then then I think that would really help.
53:09What do you think about Peter's whole getting people to drop out of college thing?
53:13yeah, I think I think go go going to college is, you know, entirely optional. I mean, it's if you've got a if you've got a good idea, I I'd say drop out and try it out, you know. you can always go back to college. Nobody's It's always there. Yeah. All right.
53:29Honda, Mercedes have both sort of said to me very clearly they feel hydrogen fuel cells are the future, but I believe strongly in batteries. I know. Why do you think they're so behind? Why do you think they're so committed to hydrogen as like the next step, where as batteries I really feel like we can make this happen.
53:45I don't really know because the the math is so super obviously in favor of batteries that it's like it's like staring facts in the face and saying they're not true. if you take the best case scenario for a fuel cell and you say you know forget about it's like assume it's fully optimized so you're you're you you're going to envelope it from a physics standpoint and say and give it the best case situation. How does that compare to state of the art lithium ion or or current current lithium ion in production and it loses. So so it's like success is not one of the possible outcomes.
54:19What why embark upon that? it's crazy. I I think part of it is like there's there's they felt for a long time that there was this need to be doing something and since fuel cells were 10 years in the future and always would be then they could always say they're working on fuel cells and that and that would satisfy people. You got to just deliver.
54:37Yeah. It's so Tesla called it fool's cells.
54:43All right, great. Go ahead.
54:45Hey there. my name's Richard Cooperstein. I was an early executive at Facebook where I headed up all of the international business development, corporate development, and strategy. And so, you know, thinking big was something that, you know, has been a part of my DNA from those days and before and so as I look at all the things that you've been building obviously it resonates very much. So in order to build the things that you're building obviously you need sources of capital and you have, you know, a sort of network of people around you.
55:09I recently partnered with a group called Liquidnet and they think about providing liquidity on a nine-figure and up kind of basis and they've created this really dynamic platform where they have 700 partners who all have an average of $20 billion under management which equals about $14 trillion and what they're trying to do is identify really tremendous technology companies, biotech, pharma, and that kind of thing.
55:34And space being sort of the next frontier my question to you is where do you think, you know, the next big buckets of efficiency are for you in your capital formation efforts vis-a-vis, you know, really finding that way to Mars and finding that way to kind of create the next, the next, wave of humanity out in the in the in the wider universe. And, you know, we have a platform that provides for that. My question is is where do you find, you know, efficient sources of capital or is a platform like what we have something that would serve your needs?
56:05Well, well, in my case, I I I find the public markets to be a a pretty effective source of capital. it's it's worked out well for for Tesla. and SolarCity will probably go public later this year. and so generally, you know, so so all and and and and SpaceX it could go public at any point. It's doesn't need SpaceX has been cash flow positive for a few years, so it doesn't really need doesn't really need additional capital.
56:31so actually as far as I'm concerned, I I at this point I do not feel myself to be capital constrained.
56:39But but going public is is more efficient for you than than sort of staying private, you know, thinking about what's been happening in the in the public markets and sort of the the gyrations and the need for public disclosure and all that kind of stuff. You think that's more efficient?
56:52yeah, I actually don't find it to be too much of a problem, to be to be a public company. I'm not kind of run the the private companies like they're public companies. in terms of you know, having the you know, the the proper controls in place and and mechanisms for effective governance.
57:14I don't I think I don't think it's actually that bad to be a public company. And and unless, if if unless you're going to sort of get really, concerned about the day-to-day fluctuations in the stock price. But so as long as you you just say, "Look, if the stock price is going to fluctuate day-to-day and I don't care." then, you know, that that that's the only time it's an issue. Just you just shouldn't worry about the day-to-day fluctuations too much.
57:37What do you think about the trend of the dual class shares and this whole idea like being pushed by Andreessen Horowitz and others of basically you need a fortress to go public?
57:47I think the there can be some merit to a dual class. I mean Tesla has a single class. and and there's there's some merit to a dual class. I think it can be taken to a bit of an extreme in some cases where it's a dual class where one class basically doesn't count. I think that's that's probably a bit unreasonable.
58:08we we we you know, you need there needs to be some path towards ultimately I think having a single class because you you you just get the succession problem. Right.
58:19and it's just it's just rare that say somebody's successor particularly if that's their kid is is is the right person. It is it does happen but it's unusual. Mhm.
58:29and so but I mean there there are cases where it's been well managed say like with the with Ford like Ford was the only company not to go not to go bankrupt and one could argue that the Ford family was a stabilizing influence on the company and had more long-term thinking and and so like I said, I think there's merits to to having a dual class of ownership as long as it's not taken to an extreme. Right. Yeah.
58:57I'm I'm getting a sign that we can only take one more question. So
59:01Yeah, and I I I apologize. I'm actually supposed to be at a at a at a screening for a film at about Haiti and that's actually where I inadvertently went first and why I was so late. so but I I I absolutely have to show up there
59:15So, I apologize you guys. but you're getting the last one.
59:19All right. so I I work in the space industry out here as well. So, I appreciate the things you're doing with SpaceX. you tweeted yesterday that you thought we're going to be in at Mars in 40 years and we haven't been to the moon in 40 years. So, I was wondering what SpaceX's plan is for that.
59:35Yeah, actually I was I was saying that I thought we we could conceivably be at Mars around 12 to 15 years from now. and what what SpaceX is is is continuing to develop the technology beyond Falcon 9, Falcon Heavy, and on you know, on paper at least I think we've got a system that could achieve Mars colonization.
1:00:03there's a long way from having such a system on paper or electronically really. I don't really have it on paper. and and actually making it real. but it was only maybe a year or two ago that less than two years ago that that I concluded that it was possible to just to have to create a self-sustaining civilization on Mars. That's yeah.
1:00:29So, I I read earlier a quote from you that said that that Mars was just this side of impossible. Is it further than this side of impossible?
1:00:36I believe it's possible, just extremely difficult. Okay.
1:00:39Yeah. But I I I wasn't sure it was possible until about a year and a half ago.
1:00:43-huh. So, last thing we we always ask everybody a series of questions and the the crowd favorite is always what would be your mediocre superpower? Now, this is absurd to ask you because Tony Stark is partially modeled after you. So, you actually are sort of have real So, we have asked you to downgrade from that.
1:01:03have a superpower. He I guess except inventing technology or something.
1:01:07Right. So, we're sort of asking you to downgrade from that a bit. So, an example of a medio- mediocre superpower would be the one of the best ones we've ever gotten is this guy who wished to temporarily detach his arm while spooning with a girl. sometimes it set it's sometimes it's staying
1:01:24That's what he wants to do with a girl?
1:01:29That's awesome. Sometimes it's like staying perfectly caffeinated. That's some people's the other day my nanny had a great one which was to inflict menstrual cramps on her enemies. Wow. Okay.
1:01:42So what what would yours be? A mediocre superpower. Mhm. So it can't
1:01:46Cuz I think the most awesome superpower would just be able to be lucky. and
1:01:52One would say you have been. Yeah.
1:01:55So if you could dial that back slightly.
1:02:01what what would be a good a mediocre superpower? I I think it it you're talking mediocre superpowers here. I think to just to always beat the traffic.
1:02:19I think that's an appropriate way to end tonight. so just a couple housekeeping things we're we're not going to do LA monthly but we are going to do it regularly. So we'll do two or three more of these before the end of the year and we will try to have as impressive guests as Elon. we have a couple in mind already that I think will be surprising. if anyone would like to sponsor these events, we are a for-profit company and we are trying to make money. you can email me at sarah@pandodaily.com and I will get you to the right people. As you can see it's an amazing event. You should absolutely give us money so we can keep doing it and pay people like Michael who cover LA
1:02:53companies. next week if you're in San Francisco, we have Mark Pincus. we would love to see you there. And other than that, let's just give a huge round of applause to Elon. Thank you so much.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版