访谈·中文精读

马斯克拷问 Robinhood CEO:GameStop 争议全记录(Clubhouse 完整访谈)

Robinhood CEO GRILLED by Elon Musk Over Gamestop Controversy (Full ClubHouse Interview)

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2021年1月28日,太平洋时间凌晨3点30分。Vlad Tenev 在睡觉。他的运营团队收到一份文件,发件方是美国国家证券清算公司(NSCC)。文件里写着一个数字:30亿美元。距离美股开盘还有六个半小时。

Robinhood 成立八年,累计融资大约20亿美元。这份文件要的钱,比这家公司历史上拿到的所有风险投资加起来还多。

十几个小时后,Robinhood 用户发现 GameStop 的买入按钮变成了灰色。能卖,不能买。

当天晚上,马斯克在 Clubhouse 的一个语音房间里把 Vlad 拉了进来。第一句话是:"这事儿太离谱了,上周到底发生了什么?"

2021年1月底的 Clubhouse 还是个新鲜东西。语音房间,几千人旁听,没有剪辑,没有提词器,说话的人随时可能被拉上台。马斯克那几天在平台上开了好几个房间,聊火星、聊比特币、聊脑机接口。把 Robinhood 的 CEO 拉进来问 GameStop,是其中传播最广的一次。

这个场景对访谈质量有实际影响。没有摄像机,没有被剪成三十秒片段的压力,被问的人不需要表演。Vlad 后来说,他是在朋友介绍下认识马斯克的,拿到了一些建议,又听说有这么个房间,就来了。他还说自己几天前才刚下载 Clubhouse,第一次用,并且信奉模拟假说,"这一定是模拟的一部分"。

马斯克回了一句"这事儿太离谱了",两个人笑了一下,然后进入正题。

先把三家公司分清楚

Vlad 开口先做了一个区分,这个区分在后续所有讨论里都重要。Robinhood 不是一家公司,至少在法律意义上不是。

用户手机里那个 App 属于 Robinhood Financial,一家介绍经纪商(introducing broker-dealer),负责接单、开户、显示界面。真正把交易送去清算的是 Robinhood Securities,一家清算经纪商(clearing broker-dealer)。另外还有 Robinhood Crypto,做加密货币业务。三块业务,三套牌照,三套监管要求。

这个结构解释了为什么一个"App 出问题"的事件,最后会变成"公司要在一夜之间拿出30亿美元"的事件。

Vlad 提到一件事:Robinhood 自己建了清算经纪商。他说"没有多少公司做过这件事"。多数券商把清算外包给第三方,Robinhood 选择自己做,好处是省掉中间费用,坏处是自己直接面对清算所的保证金要求。1月28日凌晨那张账单,某种程度上是垂直整合的代价。

逼空是怎么走到这一步的

GameStop 在2020年还是一只被遗忘的股票。主营线下游戏零售,电商冲击之下连年亏损,股价长期在个位数到二十美元之间。华尔街不少机构做空它,理由充分:基本面差,转型无望。

做空的机制是借股票卖出,等价格跌了再买回来还回去,赚差价。问题在于借来的股票要还。如果价格不跌反涨,做空方要么追加保证金,要么在市场上买回股票平仓。买回的动作本身会推高价格,价格越高,越多的空头被迫平仓,形成正反馈。这就是逼空。

2021年1月,Reddit 的 WallStreetBets 板块把 GameStop 选成了目标。买入的理由混杂,有认真分析基本面的,有纯粹想对抗机构的,也有跟风进来赌一把的。结果是股价从20美元附近涨到483美元的盘中高点,做空机构亏损以十亿美元计。

Robinhood 在这条链条里的位置很特殊。用户基数大,操作简单,大量新入场的散户通过它买入。当买入集中在同一只股票上,Robinhood 的清算风险就集中了。NSCC 的保证金要求按波动率和持仓集中度计算,这是理解30亿美元账单的前提。

一张比公司全部身家还大的账单

美股实行 T+2 结算。今天点下"买入",钱和股票要两个交易日之后才真正交割。中间这两天,如果买方违约或者卖方违约,需要有人兜底。这个兜底的角色由清算所承担。NSCC 是美股股票和公司债的主要清算机构。

清算所不白干。它要求券商按持仓风险缴纳保证金。这笔钱是券商的自有资金,不是客户的。

可以把它理解成担保金。你替朋友担保一笔借款,银行会看这笔钱的风险有多大,要求你先押一笔钱在银行。押的钱越多,银行越安心。区别在于,银行的要求通常写在合同里,而 NSCC 的要求,按 Vlad 的说法,有一部分没有公开公式。

Vlad 的运营团队在凌晨3点30分收到文件,要求的保证金大约是30亿美元。平常这个数字在3亿左右。整整十倍。

马斯克听到这里插了一句,问这个数字是怎么算出来的。他后来说了一句更直接的话:

所有人都想要一个答案,他们想知道细节和真相。(马斯克)

一个公式,加一个自由裁量

Vlad 的回答很坦白:他也没有完全掌握。

细节我们并不完全掌握,公式有一点不透明。里面有一个成分叫 VaR,也就是风险价值,基于一些相当量化的指标。但它不是完全透明的,可以反推,只是不公开。然后还有一个特殊成分,是自由裁量的,它起一个乘数的作用。(Vlad Tenev)

马斯克追问:自由裁量,意思就是"他们的意见"?

我觉得肯定不只是他们的意见,但,呃,我猜是基于增长之类的判断。(Vlad Tenev)

VaR 是个统计学概念。给定置信区间和持有期,估算一个投资组合在正常市场条件下最多可能亏多少。举例,95%置信度、一天持有期、VaR 为1000万,意思是过去的数据显示,有95%的概率当天亏损不超过1000万。

这个数字可以算。问题在于 GameStop 那种走势,历史数据里没有。波动率模型在极端行情下会失灵。NSCC 把 VaR 调高,逻辑上说得通。

让马斯克皱眉的是另一样东西:自由裁量。这部分不是公式算出来的,是人拍的。Vlad 说它像乘数,也就是说,它能把 VaR 算出来的数字成倍放大。

马斯克的态度很明确。他不接受"我们也没搞懂"这种回答的完整性,但也没有直接指控。他问的是机制,不是道德。

每个人都想知道的是,这里面有没有什么见不得光的事。突然冒出来一个30亿美元的要求,看起来很奇怪。(马斯克)

Vlad 的回应:

我不会把这归因于有什么猫腻。NSCC 后来其实很讲道理,他们跟我们合作,把数字降了下来。这是前所未有的市场活动,我手上没有完整背景,不知道 NSCC 内部在按什么计算。(Vlad Tenev)

30亿、14亿、7亿:一夜之间的讨价还价

Vlad 被运营团队的电话叫醒之后,Robinhood 的首席运营官提议直接联系 NSCC 的高层,问清楚到底怎么回事,能不能有商量的空间。

第一轮沟通,30亿降到14亿。还是很高,但已经砍掉一半多。

第二轮,Robinhood 提出一个方案:把这些波动剧烈的股票设为"只可平仓",并说明当天会怎么管理这些标的的风险敞口。凌晨4点半到5点之间,NSCC 回话:保证金7000万美元。

Robinhood 当天缴了这笔钱。开盘后,GameStop 等一批股票只能卖不能买。

从30亿到7亿,中间隔了不到两个小时和三轮沟通。这个变化幅度本身就是马斯克追问的原因。同一个清算所,同一批持仓,同一个早晨,要求可以差四倍多。

注意一个细节:只可平仓不是 NSCC 下的命令。是 Robinhood 自己在第二轮沟通里提出来的方案,用来换取更低的保证金要求。Vlad 的原话是"我们提议把这些驱动交易的波动股票设为只可平仓"。

这个区别很关键。清算所要的是钱,Robinhood 给不出那么多钱,于是拿"限制用户买入"当作谈判筹码。从风险管理角度,这个操作有道理:只可平仓意味着持仓只会减少不会增加,风险敞口单向收缩,清算所要的保证金自然下降。从用户角度,这个筹码是拿他们的交易权限换的。

只可平仓是一种技术性的风控状态。持有股票的人可以卖出,没有持仓的人不能买入。对券商来说,这个标的的总敞口只会缩小,不会扩大。对用户来说,含义取决于你在哪一边。已经持仓的人理论上可以卖出离场,但卖出价格由市场决定,所有人都在卖的时候,价格会崩。没有持仓的人被挡在门外,看着股价涨或者跌,什么都做不了。

1月28日那天,两种人都愤怒。持仓的人觉得被锁在了过山车上,空仓的人觉得被剥夺了机会。

为什么禁买不禁卖

马斯克问了一个很多人问过的问题:既然要限制,为什么不干脆连卖出也限制?

Vlad 的回答是从用户情绪出发的:持仓的人想卖却卖不掉,愤怒程度会更高。

人们手里拿着股票想卖却卖不了,会非常愤怒。我认为那种情况绝对更糟。(Vlad Tenev)

这个逻辑站得住。限制买入只是挡住了新进场的人,限制卖出则把已经进场的人锁在里面。前者是机会损失,后者是实际损失。

Vlad 还提到,那一周不止 Robinhood 一家这么做,很多券商都对同样的标的做了类似限制,只是 Robinhood 上了新闻。

马斯克没有在这个点上纠缠。他关心的是另一层:你没得选,这可以理解,但拿枪指着你的人,应该出来向公众解释。

如果你们没得选,那没得选,可以理解。但那个把枪指在你头上的人,应该愿意向公众作答。(马斯克)

他在访谈里还反复回到一个问题:谁控制这个组织?这个能决定几百万人能不能买一只股票的组织,到底归谁管?

Citadel 那条线,Vlad 只否认了一半

访谈里最敏感的一段,是马斯克直接问:你多大程度上受制于 Citadel?如果 Citadel 不高兴,会发生什么?

Vlad 的回答用了"完全错误"这个词:

有传言说 Citadel 或其他做市商向我们施压,这是完全错误的。做市商执行我们的交易,他们执行每一家券商的交易。这是清算所的决定,基于资本要求。从我们的角度看,Citadel 和其他做市商没有参与其中。(Vlad Tenev)

视频作者在访谈前后补了一段背景,值得放在这里。Citadel 这个名字在2021年1月同时指向两件事。一件是 Citadel Securities,全球最大的做市商之一,Robinhood 把散户订单卖给这类机构执行,这叫订单流付费(payment for order flow,PFOF),是 Robinhood 的主要收入来源。另一件是 Citadel 对冲基金,它做空了 GameStop,并且在2021年1月和其他机构一起向做空机构 Melvin Capital 注资二十多亿美元,帮它扛过逼空。

这两件事在公众讨论里经常被合并成一个"Citadel 操纵一切"的故事。Vlad 的否认,严格来说只覆盖了第一件:做市商没有施压。他没有直接回应第二件,也就是 Citadel 对冲基金作为清算会员和 Robinhood 收入来源的双重身份,是否在保证金计算里产生了影响。

这个区分不代表 Vlad 在撒谎。它只说明,他回答的是被问到的那部分。

订单流付费这件事值得多说两句,因为它是理解 Citadel 传闻的关键。Robinhood 不收用户佣金,2019年底率先打出零佣金,逼得整个行业跟进降价。收入从哪来?把订单卖给做市商。做市商拿到订单,在买卖价差里赚钱,分一部分给 Robinhood。Citadel Securities 是这门生意里最大的买家之一。

这套模式合法,SEC 允许,但它制造了一个结构性疑问:给 Robinhood 钱的公司,同时也是市场上的一方参与者。当这家公司同时在别处持有与散户相反的头寸时,公众有理由追问。追问不等于指控,但否认也不能替代披露。

马斯克也没在这个点上继续追。他换了个角度问:Citadel 这样的大机构在 NSCC 里难道没有很大话语权?谁决定谁进入那个组织的管理层?

Vlad 说不知道细节,并再次把这类推测归为阴谋论。

我没有任何理由相信这一点。这已经开始进入阴谋论的范畴了。(Vlad Tenev)

到这里,能确定的事实和不能确定的部分需要分开。

能确定的是:NSCC 在1月28日凌晨要求了远超常规的保证金,Robinhood 在开盘前通过限制买入把要求降了下来,当天缴了7000万美元,第二天融资之后放宽了限制。

不能确定的是:自由裁量那部分是怎么拍的,谁拍的,有没有受到清算会员构成的影响。Vlad 说他也不知道,这个说法可以是真的,因为券商确实拿不到清算所的完整模型。

NSCC 到底归谁管

马斯克在访谈里反复回到这个问题。Vlad 的回答是:它是一个联合体(consortium),不完全是政府机构,具体细节他不清楚。

补充一点背景。NSCC 是美国存管信托与清算公司(DTCC)的子公司。DTCC 由它的清算会员共同持有,这些会员包括大型银行、券商、做市商。它受美国证券交易委员会(SEC)监管,规则变更需要 SEC 批准,但它不是政府机关,日常运营和风险管理由行业自己主导。

这个结构本身不神秘,美国的金融基础设施大多这么组织。问题出在透明度。一家私人联合体在凌晨给券商发一张30亿美元的账单,账单里有一部分是"自由裁量",券商没有申诉渠道,只能打电话求情。这套安排在过去几十年没出过大问题,因为市场没出现过 GameStop。

马斯克的不满在这里变得具体。他不在乎 NSCC 是不是政府机构,他在乎的是一件事:如果有人能决定散户能不能买股票,这个人得能向公众解释。

马斯克的问法

视频作者在片头说了一句观察:如果马斯克不当 SpaceX 和特斯拉的 CEO,他完全可以去当调查记者。这场访谈里他挖到的东西,比主流媒体过去几天拿到的都多。

原因不在问题本身。问题很直接:发生了什么,公式是什么,谁控制这个组织,Citadel 有没有施压。主流媒体问的是同样的问题。

区别在语气。媒体进直播间的时候是攻击姿态,预设了一个"你在害用户"的立场,被问的人立刻进入防御,回答变成律师审过的稿子。马斯克上来先说"这事儿太离谱了",然后用玩笑把气氛松下来,中间插一句"我现在是不是在把你当人质",再突然问"那谁在管那个组织"。

被问的人放松了,话就多了。Vlad 在这场访谈里说出了很多他在正式声明里没说的细节:3点30分收到文件,30亿降到14亿再降到7亿,自由裁量的乘数,只可平仓的具体时间点,以及"24小时内融了超过10亿美元"这个数字。

访谈里有一段很能说明他的问法。Vlad 说完 NSCC 的公式不透明,马斯克没有说"这太不透明了,你应该抗议",他问:"自由裁量,意思就是他们的意见?"

这个问题把抽象的制度问题压缩成一个具体的主语。Vlad 只能回答"我觉得不只是他们的意见",然后自己补了一句"但我也说不准"。一个追问,把"不透明的公式"变成了"有人在拍板",后面所有关于治理结构的问题才立得住。

还有一个背景值得提。马斯克问"你多大程度上受制于 Citadel"的时候,带着自己的经验。特斯拉被做空最惨的那几年,他公开抱怨过做空机制,也抱怨过媒体和华尔街的共生关系。他问这个问题的方式,不像法官,像一个同样被市场结构折腾过的人。

99.9%的用户感受不到限制

访谈后半段,Vlad 说了一句很关键的话。他说未来总会有某种理论上的限制,因为公司没有无限资本,但目标是让99.9%以上的用户感受不到这个限制。

马斯克没有反驳这句话,但这句话本身值得拆开看。

"感受不到限制"和"没有限制"是两回事。前者是产品体验问题,后者是市场结构问题。一个用户账户里放几千美元,买卖几十股 GameStop,确实碰不到那条线。但如果限制的设计目标就是"让绝大多数人碰不到",那么这条线画在哪里,就变成了一个可以调节的参数,而不是一个客观事实。

Vlad 还提到一个极端例子:如果有人想存100亿美元全部买一只股票,那不可能。这个例子很安全,因为几乎不存在这样的用户。真正的问题是中间地带:多少资金量、多少仓位集中度,会开始触发限制,触发之后用户能不能提前知道。

这场访谈没有回答这个问题。

这一夜暴露的问题

把时间线摆在一起看:

  1. 1月27日周三,GameStop 相关交易量创纪录,Robinhood 净买入激增,冲到苹果 App Store 免费榜第一。
  2. 1月28日凌晨3点30分,NSCC 要求约30亿美元保证金。
  3. 凌晨4点半到5点,经过两轮沟通,保证金降到7000万美元,条件是相关股票只可平仓。
  4. 开盘后,用户只能卖出,不能买入。
  5. 1月28日到29日,Robinhood 在24小时内融资超过10亿美元。
  6. 1月29日周五,限制放宽。

这串时间线说明一件事:整个系统的风险控制,是在开盘前六个小时里靠电话谈判完成的。没有预案,没有自动化的压力测试流程,没有提前告知用户的机制。清算所按模型算出数字,券商打电话砍价,砍下来的代价是限制用户交易。

马斯克在访谈里问了一句很朴素的话:为什么这个数字能在一个早上变四次?

Vlad 没有直接回答。他说 NSCC 后来很讲道理,说这是前所未有的市场环境。这些都对,但它们解释的是"为什么要求高",没法解释"为什么要求可以谈判"。

如果保证金要求是风险模型算出来的客观结果,它不该在两个小时内缩水四倍。如果它可以谈,那谈判的筹码是什么,谈判的记录在哪里,谁有权决定用限制用户交易来换取更低的保证金。这些问题,2021年1月的这场访谈没有答案,后来的国会听证和 SEC 报告也只回答了一部分。

还有一个容易被忽略的数字:限制交易之后不到24小时,Robinhood 融了超过10亿美元。这笔钱来自可转债和信贷额度,用来充实资本。有了这笔钱,周五的限制才能放宽。

这个时间顺序说明,1月28日的限制不是终点。它是一个资本不足的公司在极端行情下的应急动作。应急动作本身可以理解,问题在于应急的代价由谁承担。那一天,承担代价的是想在开盘时买入 GameStop 的散户。

回头再看这场对话

Vlad Tenev 在这场访谈里的表现,比他在同期电视采访里松弛得多。他承认自己刚下载 Clubhouse,第一次用,说"这一定是模拟的一部分",还说自己信奉模拟假说。这种松弛让他说出了具体数字。而具体数字是判断一件事的基础。

没有3点30分、30亿、14亿、7亿这几个数字,公众只能停留在"Robinhood 掐断了散户"这个情绪判断上。有了这些数字,讨论才能推进到"清算所的自由裁量权该不该公开"这个层面。

马斯克在访谈里没有给结论。他问完 Citadel,问完 NSCC 的治理结构,说了一句"那我们就看后续行动吧",就把话题带过去了。这场对话的价值不在结论,在于它把一条原本模糊的链条拆成了可以追问的环节。

清算所要钱,券商没钱,于是拿用户的交易权限去换。这条链条上每一环都有它的道理,每一环也都可以被追问。追问的人不需要先认定谁在作恶,只需要把数字和时间摆出来,让看得懂的人自己判断。

  • 看到"券商限制交易"的新闻,先分清是清算所保证金要求触发的被动限制,还是券商自己的商业决定。前者去查清算所的保证金通知和券商的资本状况,后者去查券商公告和持仓变化。
  • 听到"Citadel"这个名字,先分清说的是 Citadel Securities(做市商,执行订单)还是 Citadel 对冲基金(做空方,注资 Melvin)。2021年1月这两件事被大量混在一起说,分清之后判断会清晰很多。
  • 判断一场访谈有没有信息量,看被访者有没有说出具体数字和时间点。"我们遵守监管要求"是废话,"凌晨3点30分收到文件,要求30亿,后来降到7亿"才是信息。
  • 想从受访者嘴里拿到细节,学马斯克的做法:先松后紧。用玩笑降低防御,用具体问题逼出数字,不在道德判断上纠缠。
  • 关注 DTCC 和 NSCC 的规则公示。SEC 在2021年之后推动过清算所风险模型的透明度改革,这类技术细节比任何阴谋论都更能解释下一次类似事件。
  • 自己复盘这件事时,把"能确定的事实"和"不能确定的部分"分两栏写。前者是时间线和数字,后者是自由裁量怎么拍的、谁拍的。分清楚之后,你会发现自己能判断的东西比想象的多。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00all right well it's full of beans man what happened last week why do you stop here why can't people buy the gamestop shares the people demand an answer and they want to know the details and the truth yep yep [Music] hey guys welcome back so the saga continues guess what elon musk of all people yesterday was able to sit down and talk with the ceo of robin hood vlad whatever his name is and it was really interesting i tell you what if elon wasn't the ceo of spacex and tesla he could very well be an investigative journalist because he actually got much more out of vlad than the media outlets have gotten over the past few days so this is quite a long i'm basically just

0:51going to shut up during this this interview i'll add a little bit of thoughts and opinions here and there but really i'm just going to let the interview play out so without further ado let's have a listen and hear vlad's explanation of why robin hood decided to halt trading or hope buying of gamestop when was it last thursday and from there onwards so let's have a listen elon okay blood can you hear us glad to stop impaler hey guys thanks for thanks for inviting me up it's good to hang with all of you all right vlad what really happened give us the inside scoop all right well i was actually hoping that you would invite me up for the fermi paradox part because this has

1:40been a very surreal weekend and week for me one of the really great things is all the people coming to coming out of the woodwork to offer support for the company offer you know advice so i got introduced today and actually i should say i just randomly downloaded clubhouse a couple of days ago just to see what it was all about so this is my first time literally using the app but yeah i i got introduced to your friend antonio elon who had some good advice for me and then introduced me to you you had some great advice and then i figured you know i heard about this clubhouse and this has got to be part of the simulation so i just thought why not so here i am so i'm i'm

2:28actually i'm actually an adherent to the simulation hypothesis all right well it's full of beans man what happened last week why do you stop here why can't people buy the gamestop shares the people demand an answer and they want to know the details and the truth yep yep okay so let me let me start by giving a little bit of background so i'm the chief executive of robin hood we know actually i'll go through this quickly don't worry this is this is this is important it's actually a couple of companies so there's a an introducing broker-dealer called robinhood financial and that basically is the app that you know and love it processes trades you're a customer of robinhood financial

3:20then there's a clearing broker dealer robinhood securities that clears and settles the trades and then we have robin hood crypto which is our crypto business all of which all of these are kind of different entities that are differently operated so basically wednesday of last week

3:42we just had you know unprecedented volume unprecedented load on the system a lot of these you know so-called meme stocks were you know going viral on social media and people were people were joining robin hood and there was a lot of net buy activity on them as you guys all know and robinhood at this time i think was number one on the ios app store and pretty close if not number one on on google play as well so just unprecedented activity and so thursday morning right so i'm i'm sleeping but at 3 30 a.m pacific our operations team receives a file from the nscc which is the national securities clearing corporation so basically as a broker as a clearing broker and this is where

4:44robinhood securities comes in we have to put up money to the nscc based on some factors including things like the volatility of the of the trading activity concentration into certain securities and this is this is the equities business so it's based on stock trading and not options trading or anything else so they gave us a file with a deposit

5:16and the the request was around three billion dollars which is you know about an order of magnitude more than what it typically is right so three billion dollars almost an order of magnitude more than normal so for those that don't know an order of magnitude i had to look this up is 10x so normally the deposit would be about 300 million today or this this day they're asking three billion dollars which is just insane and this is money that robin hood has to hand over and as vlad's about to talk about this is actually more money so in robin hood's life the total amount of money that they've raised is about two billion dollars so it's more money than robin hood has ever

6:00raised in the history of their company which is pretty insane anyway let's continue so no no why is that so high like this seems like like it sounds like this is an unprecedented increase in demand for capital what formula did they use to calculate that well yeah and just to give context you know robin hood up until that point has raised you know a little bit around two billion dollars in total venture capital up until now so it's a big number like three billion dollars is is a large number right so basically the and you know i

6:43the details are we don't have the full details it's a little bit of an opaque formula but there's a component called the var of it which is value at risk and that's based on kind of some fairly quantitative things although it's not it's not fully transparent so there are ways to reverse engineer it but it's not kind of publicly shared and then there's a special component which is discretionary so that's that kind of acts as a multiplier and basically discretionary discretionary meaning like it's just their opinion yeah they're it's it's a little bit i mean i'm sure there's there's definitely more more than just their opinion but basically i mean i i guess like it's

7:33based on growth everyone wants to know what everyone wants to know is like did something maybe shady go down here like like it's like it seems weird that you'd get a sudden 10 billion dollar demand you know three billion in the morning sorry how much yeah it was three billion us dollars okay three billion around you know just suddenly out of nowhere and

7:56what i wouldn't impute shadiness to it or anything like that and actually you know the nstc was reasonable subsequent to this and you know they've been they've been they worked with us to to actually lower it so it was unprecedented activity you know we don't i don't have the full context about you know what was what was going on in what's going on in the in the nscc to make these calculations but yeah essentially is anyone with a large i'm holding you hostage right now no no i'm okay yeah thanks for asking but anyway so this was this was obviously nerve-wracking and i actually was asleep at this point you know the operations team was was fielding this at three o'clock and

8:53then you know we got back we put our heads together you know our chief operating officer basically said look let's call up the higher-ups at the nscc and kind of figure out what's going on maybe there's some way we can work with them and basically there was another call and they lowered it to something like 1.4 billion dollars from three so okay we're making some progress right and then but it's still a high number so essentially vlad here is saying that there's kind of room to move and it's not just a hard formulaic number that gets spat out at them which i find is really strange i would have thought it would be a little bit more you know this is the amount based on

9:41this this this and this it seems like there's a lot of subjectivity behind it so i don't quite understand how it all works i'll be the first to put my hand up and admit that but pretty insane it went from three billion dollars to almost half of that so that seems pretty wild but anyway let's continue and then we basically proposed well let's let's explain how we plan to let's explain how you know we'll manage risk in these symbols throughout the day we proposed marking these volatile stocks that were kind of driving driving the activity position closing only and then at about an hour before market clo market open so 30 or 5 in the morning they came back

10:33and they said okay the charge is or the deposit 700 million which we then deposited and paid promptly and then everything was fine so that that essentially explains why we had to we had to mark these symbols position closing only and also why you know we didn't want to we knew this was a bad outcome for customers you know part of what's been really difficult is robinhood stands for you know democratizing access to stocks and yeah we want we want to give people the access so that's been very very challenging but we had no choice in this case we had to conform to our regulatory capital requirements and so the team did did what they could to make sure we were

11:23available for customers so once they told the clearinghouse that they were only going to let users sell gme and not buy the deposit requirement went from well first of all 3 billion and then it went down to 1.4 billion and then down to 700 million this is insane i wish i knew exactly how they come up with these numbers and if you do know if you know this area in depth please explain it to me let me know down in the comment section below how do the clearinghouses actually come up with the deposit requirements but i'd be really interested to know anyway pretty insane that it went from 3 billion and eventually by all the steps that robin has said what if we do this

12:01what if we do this it got down to 1.4 and then 700 million so wow anyway back at it who controls this this organization this clearinghouse you know it's a it's a consortium it's not it's not quite a government agency you know i i don't really know the details of of of all of that okay but

12:30you know and to be fair like we were we were i think there was legitimate sort of turmoil in the markets like these are unprecedented events with these meme stocks and you know there was a lot of activity so there probably is some amount of extra risk in the system that warrants higher higher requirements so it's not entirely unreasonable but we did operational processes to make sure that customers that had positions could sell their open positions because obviously restricting someone we got a lot of questions about okay you had to restrict buying why didn't you also restrict selling and the fact of the matter is people get really pissed off if they're holding

13:16stock and they want to sell it and they can't right so i think that's that's categorically worse so and lots of other brokers i think were in the same situation robinhood was in the news but you you sort of heard this industry-wide right other brokers basically restricted the same exact activity all right so it sounds like this this organization should you know calls you up and they basically have a gun to your head either either hand over this money or or else and so because i mean like basically what people are wondering is like did you sell your clients down the river or do you have no choice if you had no choice that's understandable but then you know we got to find out why

14:00you had no choice and who are these people that are saying you have no choice yeah i think that's fair you know we have to comply with these requirements financial institutions have requirements you know the the the formula behind these requirements i think it would obviously be ideal if there was a little bit more transparency so we could plan better around that you know but to be fair we were able to open and serve our customers and you know 24 24 hours later our team raised over a billion dollars in capital so that when we when we did open well when we do open tomorrow morning we'll be able to kind of relax the stringent position limits that we

14:53put on these securities on friday will it be any limits well i think there's always going to be some theoretical limit like we don't have infinite capital right and on friday there were limits so there's always there's always going to have to be some limit i think the question is you know will the limits be high enough to the point where you know some they won't impact you know 99.9 plus percent of customers so if you know someone were to deposit a hundred billion dollars and and decide to trade in one stock like that that wouldn't be possible you know so this makes sense obviously there is going to be some limit to how much one or users just in

15:42general can trade a particular stock based on these deposit requirements and how much money robin hood has to hand over as you know for these deposits but i think vlad he recognizes the important issue here is to try and make sure that although there is a limit you know 99.9 of robin hood users just don't feel that limit right so it almost feels as though there is no limit to most users most users their experience is not interrupted by any sort of limit that's going to be the balance that robinhood is going to have to make they're going to have to meet these clearinghouse deposits without putting their business at risk okay so obviously robin hood

16:25itself doesn't want to put their you know their business at risk of bankruptcy but they also have to try and find the right line where you know users don't feel like they're being restricted in what they can do because you know reality is with robin hood the platform itself mostly retail users are using it obviously so generally speaking you wouldn't expect me people to be trading millions of dollars on robin hood at once usually for most users i would imagine it would be like perhaps just say for example it's like a maximum most users there's a maximum of ten thousand dollars that they've put into their trading accounts so for robinhood if you can set that

17:01limit to trading at you know ten thousand dollars for you know gme stock for example then you know 99.9 of your you know your users aren't going to feel that limit and that's really important that's the line that they're going to have to find so the user experience is not limited and people don't feel like they're limited where when in reality there is always some limit anyway that was pretty long for me let's get back into the action all right well i guess people really just want to know you know if you had no choice then then you had no choice gun for that situation and you know then that's understandable but then whoever put that gun to your

17:41head should you know be willing to answer to the public yeah listen and you know i know there's there's processes this is unprecedented times and to be fair to those guys they've been reasonable so we are i think the the one thing that is maybe not clear to people is robin is a participant in the financial system so we have to work with all of these counterparties so we do get a lot of questions about you know why do you work with market makers why do you work with clearing houses vertically integrating and getting i mean it's hard enough to build a introducing a clearing broker dealer not too many people have done that but the financial system that

18:27allows customers to trade shares is sort of a complex web of multiple parties and you know it's it's hard to everyone says it could be better it could be improved it's it's just the necessity of of trading equities in the us that you have to do all these things i mean to what degree are you beholden to citadel i mean like basically if citadel's unhappy then i but then what happened yeah so that you know there was a rumor that citadel or other market makers kind of pressured us into doing this and now that's just false right market makers execute our trades they execute trades of of every broker dealer you know this was this was a clearing house

19:20this was a clearing house decision and it was just based on the capital requirements so from our perspective you know citadel and other market makers weren't involved in that so that's the meat right there that's your job now is to go back over that little bit about citadel and you come to your own conclusion as to whether you think vlad is telling the truth because for those that don't know the backstory so citadel is a hedge fund that was short game stop and they also are big investors in melvin capital in fact they're one of the two entities that just bailed out melvin capital to the tune of like 2.75 billion dollars i think it was so they have an interest their

20:07investments they have an interest in making sure that gamestop stock doesn't go through the roof because otherwise the shorts get squeezed and it's just a terrible situation for them now here's the thing is that citadel is a hedge fund that buys order flow from robinhood so citadel provides revenue to robinhood so it is rumored and i put that in bold and underlined it is rumored that citadel has flexed their muscle or you know put robin hood under pressure to not allow people to buy gamestop stock because by buying gamestop stock that spikes the share price up people that are short lose even more money that would be citadel and melvin capitals so

20:52that is a rumor that's been floating around so your job i think is now to listen to this section of this talk about citadel and come to your own conclusion of whether you think vlad is actually telling the truth i before today i'll be honest i thought that he was not telling the truth having heard him explain it in much more detail in literally this interview by elon musk i actually think that they're i actually i'm starting to believe that story that vlad tells a little bit more but i'd be really interested to hear your opinions on it definitely leave your opinion down in the comment section below what do you think do you think vlad's telling the truth or do you think he's

21:33telling little fibs here and there let me know anyway back to it but wouldn't they have a strong say and and who got put in charge of that organization since it's an industry consortium not a government consortium or not a government regulatory agency i i don't have any reason to believe that i think that's just like you know then you're getting into kind of the conspiracy theories a little bit so i just have no no reason to believe that that's the case you know okay

22:05all right well i guess so we'll see what happens with future actions hopefully that works insecure and at least a little bit entertaining are you not entertaining so there you go that is the situation and as i was saying before let me know what you think do you think that vlad and robin hood are actually telling the whole truth and nothing but the truth or do you think there's some little half-truths maybe blended into the mix i'd be interested to hear what do you think the truth behind the situation with citadel is vlad was obviously very quick to shoot down that idea and to say nah they're just rumors it's just straight up false what do you think let me know know down

22:48in the comment section below it is going to be some time before we actually know the full truth behind this situation but yeah i'd also be interested to hear your thoughts on what do you think about the explanation behind having to limit the trading of gamestop because of the various clearinghouse deposit requirements let me know that stuff down in the comment section below and give this video a thumbs up if you thought that elon musk did actually a really good job at getting information out of vlad he got much much more information out of lad than any media outlet has done over the past few days and i think the reason behind that is that the media companies they

23:24want to try and you know they want to try and expose right so they almost come into the interview as an attack on vlad whereas i think elon and i agree i watched stephen's video from solving the money problem he brought up this topic as well at the end of his video where he was saying that that elon really came at that interview yes he asked the hard questions but he came at it in kind of a joking kind of informal way which i think actually really helped get more information out of lad and by the way if you haven't watched steven's video then definitely go over to his channel and watch it i'm going to leave it linked up top over here i think it was over

24:04here i can't remember it's coming up on the screen right now go and check out his video if you haven't done so already but that is my take that is my opinion so let me know what you think down in the comment section below leave a like on the video if you did enjoy it or if you found it useful check out profitful down in the description below if you're interested in how i go about my investing but that is it from me for today guys thank you very much for watching and i'll see you guys in the next video

24:32[Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] you

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份