访谈·中文精读

马斯克 Clubhouse 完整访谈

Elon Musk Full Interview - Clubhouse

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2021 年初,马斯克出现在 Clubhouse 的一个语音房间里。原定晚上 10 点开始,结果房间人数爆掉,服务器被压垮,无数人被挤到溢出房间。这场对话从火星一路聊到狗狗币,从 Neuralink 聊到特斯拉为什么不用激光雷达,中间还临时把 Robinhood 的 CEO 拉进来,追问 GameStop 事件的真相。

两个多小时里,马斯克说了很多后来被反复引用的话,也透露了不少他很少公开谈的细节:他为什么睡在工厂会议室外的地板上,他最近为什么一看到邮件就产生生理性的负面反应,以及他为什么相信有生之年可能真的会看到一座能独立存活的火星城市。

这篇精读把整场对话拆开来看,重点放在他的判断依据,而非结论本身。结论很快就过时,判断方式能管更久。

第一批人去火星,他给的数字是五年半

主持人阿尔蒂第一个问题就是老问题:什么时候能到火星?

马斯克的回答比很多人印象中更具体。他说第一批人登陆火星,有不错的机会在五年半左右实现。这个数字有出处,来自两个硬约束:星舰必须能飞,而且必须一次次飞;地球和火星的窗口每 26 个月才对上一次,只有那时两颗行星才处在太阳的同一侧象限,才能做行星际转移。

上一次窗口就在半年前,下一次还有一年半。五年半,意味着中间大概能碰上两三次窗口。

他更愿意谈的是那几项必须成立的技术条件,日期只是结果:

  • 一枚完全可重复使用、而且能快速复用的轨道级火箭。这是火箭领域的圣杯,至今没人做成。要害在“快速”两个字,飞完不能花几个月翻修,得像飞机一样,燃料占成本的大头。
  • 轨道加注。先发一艘船上轨道,再发一艘上去对接,把推进剂转移过去,让去火星的那艘几乎加满。
  • 火星本地生产推进剂。从大气里取二氧化碳,配合水冰,造出甲烷和氧气。

第三条最容易被忽略,它却决定整个计划的生死。推进剂只能从地球运,成本永远压不下来,火星就永远是一个昂贵的考察站,成不了一座城市。

他还补了一句容易被跳过的判断:火星城市能不能活下来,看规模意义不大,真正要看的是当来自地球的飞船停下来,它会不会死掉。哪怕只缺一样东西,比如相当于维生素 C 的那种东西,它能撑一阵,然后慢慢死掉。

说得更精炼一点就是:火星上的城市先实现自给自足,还是第三次世界大战先来?

这句话听着像玩笑,其实是整场访谈里最严肃的一句。

他小时候有过一场存在主义危机,被一本书捞了出来

主持人问他,为什么那么执着于扩大意识的边界,这件事为什么对他重要。

马斯克的回答回到了少年时代。他说自己小时候陷入过相当严重的存在主义危机,一直在想人生的意义是什么,我们为什么在这里,这一切有没有意义。想不通,他一度非常消沉,甚至抑郁。

把他捞出来的,是道格拉斯·亚当斯的《银河系漫游指南》。

那本书给他的启发是:宇宙本身就是那个答案,真正难的是想出该问什么问题。答案一直摆在那里,人类连问题都没问对。

顺着这个逻辑,他推出一条完整的链条:要问出更好的问题,就需要更大范围、更大规模的意识;要扩大意识的范围和规模,就不能把所有的鸡蛋放在地球这一个篮子里。

他用了支蜡烛的比喻,说意识是黑暗里的一支小蜡烛,脆弱、微小,目前我们只在这一点上看到它亮着,别处没有任何迹象。

这也是他对“大过滤器”(Great Filter)的理解。银河系里可能布满了曾经繁荣过的单行星文明,它们可能繁荣了数百万年,然后因为外部或内部的原因慢慢垮掉,然后就没了。他举的例子很具体:五千年前吉萨金字塔就在那里,后来住在那里的人忘了怎么造金字塔,也忘了怎么读象形文字;罗马人有道路、输水道、下水道,后来也基本忘了。

文明会走一条弧线,起来,繁荣,然后落下。这件事在历史上反复发生过很多次。

他由此得出一个有点冷的推论:人类很可能也会走这条弧线,而且因为全球化,我们恢复的能力可能比古代文明更差,大家彼此绑得太紧,一个地方出问题,全都受影响。

他不认为自己是个悲观的人,原话是“我是个乐观主义者,不是悲观主义者”。只是地球四十五亿年历史上,生命第一次有可能延伸到地球之外,这个窗口可能会开很久,也可能只开很短一段时间。理性的做法是假设它只开一小段时间,然后赶紧用上。

人类在这个过程中扮演的角色,是生命的载体。他把这称为一种近乎义务的东西。

火星不会是一个高端社区,它会先是一个很危险的前哨

主持人设想了一个画面:火星文明虽然由地球带过去,但它会很快变得更强悍,像古希腊的斯巴达人。

马斯克同意了,并且补充了一层更具体的现实。

他说火星一开始就是个小前哨站,而且会非常危险。很多人以为火星是某种逃生舱,他的回应是:想错了,那地方非常辛苦,是边疆,在那里死掉的方式比在地球上多得多,还要干大量体力活。

他也说,这会是一场了不起的冒险,只是很长时间内都谈不上舒适。

他列了要在火星上做的事情清单:建推进剂工厂、铺太阳能、搞粮食生产、建铁矿石精炼厂。工业基础得一层一层搭起来,火星才有可能自给自足。再往后,可以靠升温来改造火星,让它变得像地球。

还有个物理条件决定了火星社会的形态:每 26 个月才能去一次,单程六个月。他说随着技术进步,这个时间可能压缩到一个月,但地球和火星分处太阳两侧的时候,你无论如何都过不去。

这意味着火星会按批次形成人群。每两年左右到一批新人,人们可能会追溯自己是跟着哪一次“地球母亲同步事件”来的。

至于火星上的法律、规则、互联网,他的态度很明确:这些都需要建立,就像每个国家建立自己的制度一样,但他不会去规定火星应该怎么运作。他认为重要的只有两件事,把人送上去,把建立自给自足文明所需的设备送上去。

关于外星人,他只看像素够不够

主持人提到过去一年有不少 UFO 目击报告,还有那个掠过太阳系的神秘天体,问他怎么看“黑暗森林”理论。

马斯克的回答很符合他的说话方式。他说自己在科学意义上可以很严格地讲:他没有看到任何一条确凿证据。这不等于没有外星人,只是他看到的每件事都有其他解释,而那些解释的可能性远高于外星技术。

接着他拐到了像素上。他说,如果你们说拍到了外星人,那至少得像 7-Eleven 便利店里的 ATM 摄像头那种分辨率。别拿尼斯湖水怪那种糊成一片的东西来,那是什么,五亿像素的相机?你在哪儿找的那种设备?至少得是 iPhone 6 的水平。

这段话听着像段子,底下藏着一条方法论:证据的质量得跟结论的重量匹配。 越是惊人的结论,越需要干净的证据。

“谁控制梗,谁就控制宇宙”

话题转到梗图(meme)上。马斯克那句“Who controls the memes, controls the universe”改写自《沙丘》里的“Who controls the spice, controls the universe”。

他解释说这句话里有几分真实。他关心的议题是怎么影响时代精神,一件事是怎么变得让人感兴趣的。

在他看来,梗是一种复杂的交流形式。一张图能说一千个字,一个梗可能能说一万个字,它是一张承载了很多含义的复杂图像,目标还得好笑。

他承认自己很喜欢梗,认为它们常常很有洞察力,也补了一句:纵观历史,象征符号对人的影响力一直很大。

主持人问他怎么变得这么擅长玩梗。他讲了一段很少被提到的 Twitter 早期经历。他其实很早就注册了账号,那时候用户还不到一万人,但当时大家在上面发的都是“我在大学街的星巴克喝了什么拿铁”这类内容,他觉得没必要知道这些,就把账号删了。

后来有个冒充他的人拿到了这个账号,发了好几年。再后来朋友劝他重新注册,好直接跟人对话,家人也劝,他才把账号拿回来。

他说自己早期的推文相当“够辣”,因为那段时间他正在读叶卡捷琳娜大帝的传记。主持人接了一句很妙的话:很多人觉得他在 Twitter 上是疯了,其实他一开始就在 Twitter 上疯。

他还提到自己认识几位“梗图供应商”,会源源不断地给他发很有意思的梗。主持人问火星上会不会有梗图供应商,他说得先有好的供应商才行。

Neuralink 的起点不是炫技,是怕被落下

这一段信息密度最高。

马斯克说,Neuralink 最早来自一个担忧:即使 AI 的发展完全良性,人类怎么至少还能“搭上车”?

他拿 GPT-1 到 GPT-2 再到 GPT-3 的进步幅度举例,也提到 DeepMind 基本上把能赢的游戏都赢完了。他特意强调,特斯拉拥有世界上最强的 AI 团队之一,方向放在真实世界的可用性上:视觉感知和控制。

然后是那个他反复讲过的三层结构。人有两套生物层:边缘系统负责原始驱动力、欲望和反应;大脑皮层负责长期规划和思考。在这之上,人类已经长出了第三层,数字层,就是手机、电脑和所有应用。

带上这些设备的人,比不带的人强大得多。问题出在带宽:大脑皮层和数字层之间的通道太窄了,手机普及之后,这条通道反而更窄。

他算了一笔账:两个大拇指在手机上打字的比特率非常低,慷慨点算每秒 100 比特。计算机之间的通信在每秒万亿比特的量级。总有一天,计算机会觉得自己在跟一棵树说话。树确实也交流,只是慢到我们根本注意不到。

Neuralink 的目标是把这条带宽提高几个数量级,至少一千倍,可能一万倍以上。

他还提到一个常被忽略的成本:人思考时要把复杂的思想结构压缩成语言,压缩过程本身消耗巨大;对方收到语言之后还要解压。如果两个人都装了 Neuralink,就能做“概念层面的心灵感应”,把一整组复杂概念不经压缩直接传过去。

再往远看,他说理论上可以保存大脑的状态。人死了以后,状态可以被还原到另一具人体或一具机器人身体里。他承认这听着像《副本》(Altered Carbon)里的情节,也承认还原之后不会百分之百一样,会有损耗。他补了一个很有意思的角度:你每天早上醒来,也不是昨天的那个你,脑细胞一直在死,记忆有的淡了有的强了,你本来就在不断变化。

短期目标朴素得多:一个无线植入芯片,让四肢瘫痪的人能用意念控制电脑、鼠标、手机或者任何设备。他的说法是,本质上就是个装在头骨里的 Fitbit,带着一些细小的线连到大脑。

他还提到进展:已经有一只猴子在头骨里植入了无线装置和细线,能靠意念玩电子游戏。从外面看,除了头顶有一小块深色的“莫西干”,看不出植入痕迹,猴子看起来也不痛苦。他说 USDA 的人来检查时,说这是她职业生涯里见过的最好的猴子设施。

风险控制也谈了。早期植入物一定带有不可忽视的风险,所以最初的适应症会落在脑部或脊髓严重受损的人身上,在这些人身上,收益远远大过风险。团队非常在意能不能把植入物取出来,已经测试过植入、取出、再植入,效果很好。

怎么教一个五岁的孩子

有位主持人问了一个很实际的问题:现在这个时代,该怎么教育一个五岁的小孩?

马斯克的回答先从自己的孩子说起:他的孩子主要是被 YouTube 和 Reddit 教育的,加上同学和学校课程。从他们花在网上的时间看,大部分教育其实来自线上。

然后他说了核心观点:教育应该尽可能有趣、尽可能让人兴奋。他反问,好的电子游戏为了让玩家保持投入,做了那么多设计,为什么教育做不到同样的事?

他给出的第一个原则是解释“为什么”。要教一样东西,就要说明为什么要教它,它和什么相关。他的解释带一点进化论视角:人类演化出了忘掉无关信息的倾向,不这样的话,脑子里会塞满没用的东西。所以只要相关性没有被清楚地建立起来,人就会很难记住,这跟聪明与否无关,大脑判定它不重要。

第二个原则是用一个问题串起所有知识。他举了个特别具体的例子:要教发动机怎么工作,就直接把发动机拆开,再装回去。拆装过程中自然需要螺丝刀、扳手、内六角、吊具,于是你就明白了工具的用途。

这比单独开一门“扳手课”或者“螺丝刀课”强得多。从一个问题出发,问需要什么工具来解决它,相关性就建立起来了,叙事线也有了。

顺着这个逻辑往下推,项目足够大的话,就能把大量科目卷进来。比如造一辆车,或者造一台电动机,想知道怎么提高扭矩、怎么输出更大功率,麦克斯韦方程组就成了必需品,它不再凭空出现在课本某一章里。

这套方法里,项目本身没那么重要,重要的是顺序:先有真实的问题,知识作为答案被需要。顺序反过来,学习就变成了记忆负担。

为什么世界上只有一个马斯克,以及为什么你不该想成为他

有人问,为什么世界上没有更多像他这样的人。

马斯克的回答不适合当励志鸡汤来读。他说自己做的事情,是因为有一种强烈的内在驱动力,没有人推着他做,是他自己非做不可。

他也不觉得这值得羡慕。他说自己人生中有相当长的阶段非常痛苦、非常艰难,不确定别人会愿意过那种生活。如果有人想成为他,或者做他做过的事,他的判断是:你多半搞错了,你不会想那样的。你得在头骨里养一只愤怒的恶魔,非把事做成不可。

然后他讲了那句后来被引用了无数次的话。有人问他,对想创业的人有什么鼓励的话。他的回答是:如果你需要鼓励的话,就别创业了。

他引用朋友的话形容创业:吃玻璃,并且长久地盯着深渊。

这话听着像劝退,实际效果是校准预期。创业的难度由这件事的性质决定,环境顺不顺都能遇上。抱着“熬过这一段就好了”的心态进场,通常熬不过去。

比特币、狗狗币,和一个迟到八年的人

那几天他刚把 Twitter 简介改成比特币的标志和“bitcoin”这个词,市场立刻有反应。他先开了个玩笑,说自己说话得小心,这种东西真的能推动市场。

然后他讲了段自嘲。他说很多朋友很早就劝他买比特币,2013 年的时候,那位朋友还做了个印着比特币标志的蛋糕,切了一块给他吃。所以八年前他就有机会至少买一点。“还能怎样,难道要耶稣亲自来说吗。”

他承认自己入场太晚,还道了个歉。态度倒是明确的:他现在认为比特币是件好事,他是比特币的支持者,比特币正处在被传统金融界广泛接受的边缘。

对其他加密货币,他说自己没有强烈看法,偶尔开狗狗币的玩笑,但那些真的只是玩笑。狗狗币当初就是作为一个玩笑被创造出来的,用来嘲讽加密货币。

不过他接着说了句很有意思的话:命运喜欢讽刺。费米说过,最讽刺的结果往往最可能发生;换成另一种说法,最好玩的结果往往最可能发生。而最好玩、最讽刺的结果,就是狗狗币未来成为地球的货币。

这段话可以当段子听,背后有一个他反复使用的思维工具:用“什么结果最有趣”来反推概率。它谈不上严格的科学方法,却经常能捕捉到严格方法漏掉的东西。

特斯拉的 2000 万辆,卡在电池上

谈到特斯拉,马斯克先把目标讲清楚。特斯拉成立之初的目标就是加速可持续能源的到来。要达成这个目标,就得造很多车,而且得让车越来越便宜。

他们的粗略目标是最终做到每年生产 2000 万辆。这个数字是算出来的:全球在路上的汽车和卡车大约有 20 亿辆,如果你一年卖的车不到存量车辆的 1%,根本谈不上改变什么。

制约这个目标的最大因素是电芯产量。他们从供应商那里尽可能多地拿货,松下、LG、宁德时代,还是不够,所以特斯拉自己要造电芯。他特意说明,这样做无意挤垮供应商,希望他们一起扩产。

接着他讲了自动驾驶对这件事的意义。一辆普通车一周大概只开 12 个小时,而一周有 168 个小时。车能自动驾驶的话,使用率可能提高到一周 60 小时,资产利用率提升约 5 倍。同样的出行需求,需要的车更少,需要的停车场和停车楼也更少。这对环境本身就是好事。

他认为这也是很多投资者给特斯拉高估值的原因:他们买的不是现在的车,是未来的执行力。

他还顺便招人:如果你对实用 AI 感兴趣,特斯拉的 Autopilot 和 AI 团队在做真正落地的东西。硬件上有自研的推理芯片,软件上正在建 Dojo 训练计算机,因为要处理海量的视频训练数据。

他给了一个很硬的理由:自动驾驶早一天到来,就能救更多命。全球每年大约有 100 万人死于车祸,约 1000 万人受重伤。

他为什么对激光雷达有意见,却自己造过激光雷达

主持人提到他之前公开批评激光雷达。马斯克先澄清了一件事:他对这项技术本身没有敌意。SpaceX 的龙飞船对接国际空间站时用的激光雷达,就是他们自己研发和制造的,那是十年前的事。

他的反对意见只落在真实道路上的驾驶。

论证是这样:要在现实道路上开车,你必须解决视觉问题,也就是用被动光学光子去理解物体,判断这些物体是什么、要做什么、可能的运动轨迹,然后做控制。这一整套本质上是 AI,人类靠脑子里的一堆神经网络完成,车上也得跑一堆神经网络做同样的事。

一旦你解决了视觉,你就已经比人强了。车上装了八个摄像头,三个朝正前,两个斜前,两个斜后,一个正后,八个摄像头同步采集,而且是视频级别的训练和推理。

相比之下,人类的感知条件很差:只有两只眼睛,两只眼睛高度协同,实际效果接近一台慢速云台上的单摄像头,还经常分心,可能在调收音机,可能睡着了,可能各种状况。只用摄像头做到超越人类,没有任何疑问。

他还给了句技术上的建议:真要采用主动发射光子的方案,他会选择能穿透遮挡的波长,比如四毫米左右的雷达,激光雷达不在这个范围里。

他的一天:一堆杂活,和对邮件的生理性厌恶

有人问他典型的一天什么样。

他的回答没有修饰。醒来先看短信和邮件,看看有没有紧急情况,往往真的有。他说自己处理的很大一部分事情既不有趣也不好玩,就是杂活。他试过很努力地不做杂活,只要不做,事情就会烂掉。

然后他讲了一个很少见的细节:他现在对邮件有一种轻微的、生理层面的负面反应,用他的说法是“邮件在杀我”。相比之下短信好处理得多,面对面会议更好,Zoom 会议也比邮件强,什么都比邮件强。

他的会议大部分是工程和设计会,也得处理财务、销售这些公司运转必需的事。

最大的问题不在工作量,在上下文切换。他说有人发给他一张梗图,“恐惧是思维杀手”被改成了“上下文切换是思维杀手”,他完全同意。在 SpaceX、特斯拉、Neuralink、Boring Company 之间来回切换非常难。他试过的方法是尽量少切换,一个小时专注一件事,下一个小时再换另一件。

Boring Company 和 Neuralink 相对占用少一些,公司规模小,他形容为“CPU 负载不高”。当然还有梗图,那也得跟上。

有人问他日程表里有没有大块空白。他说没有,基本上背靠背的会议,密集得像信息洪流。他说不推荐任何人这么过,自己有时候也在想还能撑多久,脑子会不会炸掉。他甚至想过是不是该休一周假清空一下,或者写本书,把自己犯过的蠢错误和一些可能有用的建议写下来。

他还解释了当年睡工厂地板的事。他确实这么干过,只在危机时刻。逻辑很简单:当团队被要求拼命干活的时候,他必须在场,而且必须让人看见。看见才会相信。 他凌晨四点睡,四个小时后起来,工人路过就能看到他,没有藏起来。CEO 愿意吃这种苦,别人才会跟着吃。

主持人提到去参观时看到会议室就在工厂正中间,十五英尺外就是轰隆作响的巨型机器人。马斯克纠正了一个细节:他大多数时候没睡在会议室里,因为那里别人看不见他。他睡在会议室外面的地板上,就为了让人看见他在那儿。他还说,醒来时身上全是机油和铁屑的味道。

如果凭空多出五个小时

有人问他,如果一天多出五个小时,会再创办一家公司吗,做什么方向。

他先说自己完全没有再开公司的计划,头会炸掉。被追问之后,他给了两个方向。

第一个是隧道。有五年时间,别人问他哪里有创业机会,他都回答隧道,结果没人动手。他后来半开玩笑成立了 Boring Company,在洛杉矶挖了一条测试隧道,还是没人相信,于是他们在拉斯维加斯挖了第一条运营隧道。他的判断是:所有大城市都有交通问题,隧道能大幅改善人们的生活质量。把隧道抽成真空,就能跑得比飞机和高铁还快。

第二个方向更出人意料:RNA 或者 mRNA,本质上就是合成病毒。BioNTech 和 Moderna 的疫苗已经证明了它的效果,他觉得人们还没意识到正在发生什么。这是医学的数字化。

他的解释是:你可以像写计算机程序一样写出一段 RNA 或 DNA 序列,然后把它扩增几百万倍、几十亿倍,包裹在一层脂质外壳里,让身体以为它是好东西。你的细胞就是生物计算机,像老式计算机读取打孔卡那样,你给它一张卡,它就照着执行。

他说这可能是 2020 年最让他开眼的一件事。顺着这个话题,他讲了一段听起来毫不相干的事:特斯拉在德国收购了一家公司,主要看中它的自动化能力。收购时对方说有两个跟汽车无关的项目想继续做,一个是给英特尔做芯片分析的微小探针,另一个就是这个生物技术项目,包含 DNA 扩增、RNA 扩增和脂质包裹三个部分。他们现在做到第三代了,目前为 CureVac 做,也愿意接其他公司的单。

这个细节挺说明问题:一家车企手里有个 RNA 微型工厂,纯属收购时的意外附带。

疫苗分发的关键是别追求完美

主持人问他,如果明天让他来负责疫苗分发,会怎么做。

他说自己对现状了解不够深,建议倒是很明确:放松接种资格的限制,改成先到先得,让 CVS 和 Walgreens 这些每年发流感疫苗的门店直接开放,人来了就打。

理由是,Moderna 和辉瑞的疫苗对温度极其敏感,从深冷环境拿出来解冻后必须马上用掉,否则失效。他解释说,RNA 序列本身不稳定,倾向于回退到能量更低的状态,所以必须超低温保存。

在这种情况下,如果还纠结“是不是绝对正确的人打到了疫苗”,就会浪费大量本来可以打出去的剂量。他的态度是:接受一小部分不该打的人打到了,换来更多人及时打上。

还有个具体建议:暂时别考虑第二针。先把第一针铺开,第二针要三四周之后,那时候供应会上来,有时间再想。

他对供应量的判断很乐观。美国可能已经订了大约九亿剂,多到今年晚些时候一定会有疫苗被扔掉,超过任何可能的需求。强生的疫苗刚获批,更传统的技术路线,只打一针,常温保存。CureVac 的疫苗可能很快获批,而他知道特斯拉那台设备能飞快地做出海量剂量。再加上大量人已经感染并康复,群体免疫也在接近。

他特意声明了一句:他不是反疫苗的人,他是支持疫苗的人。

他去 Netscape 找过工作,因为太害羞没敢说话

聊到加州,马斯克说自己爱加州,一半以上的生命都在那里度过。1992 年或 1993 年,他作为暑期实习生去硅谷做电动车储能技术,之后去斯坦福读研,方向是电动车用的先进电容器。

然后他讲了个很好笑的往事。他当时判断互联网会是未来,人类在此之前靠某种渗透方式交流,有了互联网,就像人类长出了神经系统,变成一个超级有机体。于是他面临选择:读博研究先进电容器,不确定有没有用;或者参与建设互联网。

他决定去 Netscape 找工作,发了简历,没有回音。然后他去 Netscape 大堂里晃,想碰碰运气,但他太害羞,不敢跟任何人说话。他就那样在大堂里坐着。

最后他决定自己写软件。他写了互联网上最早的黄页和白页地图导航,一个人、一台电脑做出来的。他说第一家公司刚创立时只有一个电脑,所以他晚上写代码,白天服务器才开着,网站只有白天能用。

主持人接了一句很到位的话:下次你再来我公司大堂晃,实习 offer 一定有,我们提供两台电脑。

他在看什么,以及《银河系漫游指南》为什么是本哲学书

被问到最近在看什么,他提到《最后的王国》,认为是一部不错的、大体符合史实的历史剧。然后是《眼镜蛇》(Cobra Kai),他说如果你在这个年代长大,这剧太狠了,一直在往伤口上撒盐。

有人说《苍穹浩瀚》(The Expanse)。他说自己没看下去,因为开头似乎有个设定是缺水,他觉得这在科学上讲不通,就没再看了。主持人说这其实是目前对行星际旅行最贴近现实的呈现,还涉及地球、火星和小行星带三方的政治博弈。马斯克说他会接着看,因为他得让自己在跑步机上待着,不然他根本不想运动。

他还推荐了《开发者》(Devs)和《神话任务》(Mythic Quest),也聊了诺兰的《信条》,说自己也觉得太较真就讲不通,当成电影看就好。

后面他专门讲了《银河系漫游指南》。他说这是一本伪装成搞笑书的哲学书。从哲学的角度去读,会发现它相当有洞察力。核心那句他重复了一遍:答案本身是容易的,难的是把问题正确地提出来。

他喜欢那艘船叫“黄金之心”,动力来自“无限不可能引擎”。他也喜欢书里对官僚系统的讽刺:地球被毁灭,起因几乎是个文书错误,要修一条星际高速公路,地球挡了路,通知被贴在一个地球人根本访问不到的外星公告板上,管理者还奇怪为什么地球人不高兴,明明通知贴出来了。

他还提到书里的巴别鱼,把鱼放进耳朵就能自动翻译。他说这东西我们基本上已经有了。

GameStop 那一夜的完整版本

访谈快结束时,马斯克把 Robinhood 的 CEO 弗拉德·特内夫拉进房间,让他讲清楚 GameStop 事件那一周到底发生了什么。

特内夫的解释很具体。Robinhood 实际上是几家公司:一家是介绍经纪商,就是用户用的那个 App;一家是清算经纪商,负责清算和交收;还有一家做加密业务。上周三交易量空前,那些所谓的“meme 股”在社交媒体上疯传,大量净买入涌入,Robinhood 当时在 iOS 应用商店排第一。

周四凌晨三点半,太平洋时间,运营团队收到清算公司 NSCC 的一份文件,要求缴纳一笔保证金,金额大约30 亿美元,比通常水平高出一个数量级。而 Robinhood 到那时为止总共融到的风险投资大约是 20 亿美元。

他解释说,这个公式里有一部分是 VaR(在险价值),基于一些定量因素,不完全透明;还有一部分是自由裁量的,相当于一个乘数。他们没有完整的公式细节。

后来他们和 NSCC 沟通,金额降到大约 14 亿美元,再然后他们提出在这些波动剧烈的股票上采取“只允许平仓”的风控方案,开盘前一小时,也就是早上五点,金额降到 7 亿美元,他们立刻缴纳了。

这解释了当时为什么只能卖不能买。他承认这个结果对客户很糟,但公司必须满足监管资本要求。他们也讨论了为什么不连卖出也限制,答案是:人持有股票、想卖却卖不掉,那才真正会激怒人,明显更糟。他还说,很多其他券商当时也做了同样的限制,只是 Robinhood 上了新闻。

马斯克追问,是不是有人拿枪指着你的头,是不是 Citadel 施压。特内夫说,这属于清算所基于资本要求做出的决定,做市商负责执行交易,没有参与。至于清算所这个行业联盟里谁说了算,他说自己没有任何理由相信存在那种情况,那属于阴谋论的范畴。他也承认,公式能更透明一些的话,他们会更好地做计划。

他还提到,事件之后公司融了超过十亿美元,所以下次开盘时可以放宽那些严格的持仓限制。他同时说,限制永远会有某种理论上限,资本不是无限的,目标是把上限设在不会影响 99.9% 以上客户的位置。

这场对话里真正值得带走的东西

两个多小时,听到了很多预测和段子,留下长期价值的,是他做判断的那几种方式:先找到物理约束,再倒推需要什么;用“什么结果最讽刺”校准直觉;在建立相关性之前不谈知识点;把最难的问题换成“谁在什么时候必须做什么”。

下面这些可以直接拿去用:

  • 评估任何宏大计划时,先问物理窗口。火星每 26 个月才有一次机会,这个约束决定了所有节奏。你自己的项目也有类似的窗口,找到它,再排时间表。
  • 判断一个系统能不能长期存活,别看它现在的规模,看外部输入断掉之后它能撑多久。火星城市如此,一家公司、一个团队也如此。找出那个“维生素 C”是什么。
  • 学任何新东西之前,先给自己造一个真实的问题,让知识成为答案。拆一台发动机需要的工具,比一门“工具学”课程有用得多。
  • 用“什么结果最有趣、最讽刺”做一次反向推演,当成直觉校准工具,别当成决策依据。真正的决策还得回到数据和约束上。
  • 减少上下文切换。把一天切成整块的专注区间,别让不同项目互相打断。这一条对所有同时推进多件事的人都成立。
  • 要求证据的分辨率匹配结论的权重。看到惊人说法时,先问一句:这相当于 7-Eleven 的 ATM 摄像头,还是 iPhone 6?
  • 带团队打硬仗时,别只发指令,让自己被看见。睡在会议室外面听起来极端,作用机制很简单:看见才会相信。
  • 如果你需要别人不断鼓励才想创业,那可能不是你要走的路。先把预期调到“吃玻璃、盯着深渊”的水平,再决定要不要进场。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:02hey you aren't here can you hear me yes i can yes i can okay hey hello there [Laughter] are you wearing your short shorts yeah that's me are you celebrating anything in particular with your short shorts no i'm just trying to look sexy in these in these tight pants with the you know fabulous red and the gold

0:49are the are the shorts are the shirts still available to be purchased sorry i got a small [ __ ] dog elon i think you are you might have broken i'm not sure about the internet but definitely clubhouse this room is easily the biggest room the app has had and you just putting all sorts of pressure on it this is amazing this is a true historic moment all right i mean is it working absolutely absolutely

1:25all right all right we're gonna just give it a minute because we promised we'd start at 10 p.m and i think few more people are going to try and trickle in and then we're going to be get we'll get going for what should be probably a historic first ever time for you on clubhouse it's gonna be amazing just do 30 seconds if you're doing it okay by the way can you let in vlad from robin hood

2:03my phone just blew up with when we started the room with people trying to get in so we're gonna try and get as many as possible okay why don't we why don't we get started okay first of all everyone thank you for joining us for what is really a historic episode i will come to our very very special guest in a second but just to quickly introduce the rest of the room we have gary tan you know of initialized capital we have my significantly better other half arti ravi whom elon you've met when you took us on a tour of spacex we have steven synovsky of xmicrosoft fame and we have the one and only mark andreessen but to introduce our special guest and this person clearly

2:49needs no introduction the founder of tesla spacex the boring company neural link paypal and there's a bunch more elon musk welcome to clubhouse thank you glad to be here thank you okay arty i think you're first this is awesome yeah yeah so you know again welcome this is really fun you know we've been waiting all day this is the longest way to 10 p.m because we just couldn't wait to get this going i hope this is as much fun by the end of it for you as it is for us first question from you is is when are we going to get to mars well i think we'll get to you know when will we get the first people to mars i think we have a decent shot of doing that in

3:35about i'd say like well i i call it five years something like that so mars that's earthenware sync up every 26 months that's when we're in this kind of the it's roughly the same quadrant of the solar system and where we can do interplanetary transfer and so we had one about six months ago so about a year and a half there'll be another one so figure you know i don't know five and a half years five and a half years so what does it take from here to that point like what are the milestones you think for us to like get to you know five years out we are we are landing on mars

4:18well we've got to make a starship fly get gets go to over and back repeatedly i mean the essential elements are you need a a fully reusable like you need a fully and rapidly reusable rock orbital rocket this is the the holy grail of rocketry so no one has ever succeeded in creating a fully reusable rocket and it can't just be fully useful it needs to be rapidly reusable so it doesn't take like several months of refurbishment between flights it needs to be much like aircraft where the cost of an air flight is the biggest component of that is fuel and you know you can't just be throwing rockets away every time and then you need to have orbital

5:02refilling so where you can send the ship up to orbit then send another ship up dock with a transfer propellant so that you can load up to being almost full with propellant and then go to mars and if you if but if you've got a large fully rapidly reusable rocket with orbital refilling that uses a high efficiency low cost propellant then you can go to mars and then and then one other one last thing is on mars to you you need a local propellant production so you take co2 out of the atmosphere combine it with water ice h2o to create ch4 methane and oxygen and if you have those elements life can become multi-planetary and we can have a self-sustaining city on mars

5:53which i think is one of the most important things we could possibly do for ensuring the long-term existence of conscious consciousness yeah i think yeah that makes sense sorry sure i'm good for that yeah elon you've spoken about this often which is you know expanding the scope of consciousness and how it is tied to multi-planetary life could you explain what that means for you and why that matters to you i'm sure well so the

6:29originally i i had sort of actually quite become an existential crisis when i was a kid trying to figure out what's the meaning of life why are we here what's the point of it all is it all meaningless i got quite depressed actually and sad about it and and and then the thing that kind of broke me out of it was reading douglas adams's hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy yeah where he essentially pointed out that the universe is the answer and really the hard part is figuring out what questions to ask about the answer that is the universe okay so yeah exactly it's huge exactly trying to make fun of the fact that the answer is the easy easy part but the questions

7:07are the hard part so in order for us to gain a a better understanding of what questions to ask or to understand what it's all about we have to increase the scope and scale consciousness so that we're better able to figure out which questions to ask and answer them so the longer the the broader

7:29in scope larger in scale that consciousness is the more likely we are to ask these questions and figure out what things going on why are we here to answer the fundamental questions and i think there's arguably a great filter that we face with you know will we become a multi-planet species or not you know we'll be surprised that out there in our galaxy and others that there are a whole bunch of dead one planet civilizations that prospered prospered for a while they might have prospered for millions of years but then gradually the civilization collapsed for reasons external or internal and and that was that all civilizations go through go through an arc where they

8:14they build they grow up in technology complexity but then they they don't keep going up they over time they they decline they fall this has happened obviously with if if you're a student of history with many civilizations in the past you can look at ancient egypt you know five thousand years ago there was the great part of megiza but then the the people living there forgot how to build pyramids after a while and then they forgot how to read hieroglyphics there's obviously you know kevin's famous book about the decline and fall of the roman empire and how they they had advanced technology in terms of roads aqueducts plumbing and so forth and and and

8:55then they basically forgot about it the ancient sumerians babylonians all these things have been we've all gone through a similar arc which suggests that most likely we will go through such an ourselves and we'll be arguably less resilient to recovery because of globalization so i think

9:19for the first time in the four and a half billion year history of earth it has been possible to extend life beyond earth and make life multi-planetary and this window of opportunity may be open for a long time i hope it is or it may be open for a short time and i think it would be wise for us to assume that it's open for a short time i'm an optimist not a pessimist but i you know you have to say like there's some chance of selling it open for a short time and we should take advantage of this this brief window of opening where we can trans transfer life transport life to make life multi-planetary and and humanity is essentially the agent of life in this process

9:56and i think we almost have an obligation to ensure that the creatures of earth continue even if there was a calamity on earth which as i said could be man-made or it could be some natural calamity as if you look at the fossil record there's there are many many mass extinctions yeah i think yeah i think you know all of that makes sense and i think we've heard you've talked about this before i think one other question i have is you know when we get there you know we have to set up the whole society we have to set up civilization there how will the whole thing work in your mind like you know everything from what does it mean to have internet connection in mars

10:36all the way to like garments and rules and laws and everything yeah i think all those things need to happen just as they happen in you know in the u.s and happen in every country and i i would not presume to prescribe what should happen there i think the important part is just that we get people there and we get the equipment necessary to establish a self-sustaining civilization at least one self-sustaining city and i think the key threshold of when we would pass the great filter or this this particular great filter is is mars sufficiently self sustaining such that if the ship stop coming from earth for any reason it could be you know something massive or something

11:22banal i mean civilization on earth could end with a bang or a whimper and but by the way if the ship stopped coming from mars does mars die out or or not and it only has to be missing one little ingredient like the equivalent of vitamin c and it will survive for a while but it will not but it will eventually die out so it's kind of getting getting state on was to pass that that critical threshold where it is self-sustaining and are we able to do that before some calamity or or a gradual decline in civilization occurs that prevents the ships from going there that's that's that's the key threshold i mean in a more pithy way is like does does the city of on mars become

12:06self-sustaining which comes first a celta's sustaining studio in march or world war three if if you if you kind of let yourself dream out over the next few decades like what would you what would you consider success like let's say they get through the first you know five years even the first 10 years like what do you think is possible to build on mars 10 years in 20 years in 30 years in after first arrival

12:34well i think i think mars will go let's start off being very tiny just like a tiny little outpost and by the way it's going to be very dangerous sometimes people think oh is this like some escape hatch for people i'm like no it will be dangerous hard work it's going to be you're out there on the frontier there are way far more ways to die there than there are on earth and an experienced amount of hard work but it will be i think fun and advent and a great adventure but it will not be a luxurious thing that is for sure not for quite some time to go but we yeah we've got a bull

13:18propellant plant we've got to build you know get solar power going get the you know the food production going start creating the necessities i you know iron we need an iron ore refinery we need you know all of the the sort of fundamentals of industry in order to make ensure that mars is a self-sustaining planet i mean over time like this would take a while but you could terraform the planet and make it earth-like mostly by just by warming it up so yeah

13:56so you know as you talk about this i mean honestly what comes to mind is sort of the idea that a martian civilization you know although obviously imported from earth it will quickly evolve to be quite a bit tougher by necessity and and just the mental image just leaving my mind as the the spartans in ancient greece like do you think that do you think do you think the sort of vector of civilization will unfold differently as a consequence of of how difficult it's going to be to get it going yeah probably will

14:27i think so then maybe maybe we don't we don't just have a backup right maybe we actually have an alternative like a and a and the ability to actually see two different two like fundamentally different civilizations flourish yeah absolutely the the the fact that it's you can only go to mars every two years and that is six months six month journey although i think we can over time get that potentially as low as one month but still you can't go to mars when earth is on the on the other side of the the sun from mars like the you know times where you know mars is literally the other side of the sun you can't get no matter what you do so that that that time gap would mean that

15:08you know that there'd be essentially a new group of people arriving roughly every two years i don't know i think interesting people probably trace their like yeah i came on you know this this you know this particular you know earth mother synchronization event i don't know but like like i said the important thing is is like that we have established mars as a self-sustaining civilization and and that we've done whatever we can to ensure the long-term continuance of of consciousness as we know it because that so as far as we can tell we're the only

15:59the light of consciousness which is a delicate little candle in the dark it's only here on earth i mean it might be else place other places and there's arguments that it's likely to be other places but honestly we have seen no sign of it and and i'm pretty sure that i would have known about it and i am i've seen nothing to indicate that there's any alien civilization whatsoever i would i i'd be the first to jump on that in a second but i see i've seen there's such evidence elon that's actually you know that's actually something we wanted to ask you about because in the last year there has been multiple reported ufo sightings there was the mysterious

16:36object that flew past our solar system i think you just described that you haven't seen any evidence of aliens but a do you think we'll ever run into them and b if we if we do have you heard of dark forest theory from three body problems how do you think we should think about aliens yeah i'm trying to be strict in the

16:57scientific sense the word of saying i've seen no no not a single piece of conclusive evidence so that doesn't mean there aren't aliens i'm just literally saying i've seen nothing that could not be explained by other means and where the probable explanation by other means is much more likely than its alien technology

17:22so and and for people to say like their sightings of aliens i'm like listen man the resolution of the picture needs to be at least like 7-eleven atm good okay we can't have that fuzzy loch ness monster [ __ ] you know it's like come on was that like a 500 megapixel camera what what are you talking about where do you find that thing it's going to be it's going to be at least like iphone 6 level or something i don't know can i ask one more mars question

18:00so you know elon you you famously have a pile of you know really beautiful kids you know i know you care about them a great deal as all parents do what would your response be if they start coming to you when they turn 18 or you know 22 and they say you know dad you know you know now that you've landed us on mars and there's a colony for me like i really want to go yeah i think if we're talking about say this third or fourth set of landings on mars i think that'd probably be i'd be okay with that although i've pulled them so far and none of them say they want to go so they may change their minds but currently they're they're not chomping at the foot to go to mars

18:43okay interesting elon okay so i think for folks you may know this i think we originally met over twitter and it's just safe to say and i want to move on from mars to memes it is safe to say that you might be the master of the memes and in fact you had a quote who controls the memes controls the universe could you just explain what you meant by that and how you became well i mean it's a i mean it's a play on words from from dune who controls the spice controls the universe and then if memes are spice then it's memes i mean there's a little bit of truth to it in that like like how do you you know what is it that influences the zeitgeist like how

19:33how do things become interesting to people and a meme's like actually kind of a complex form of communication that's that like a picture says a thousand words and maybe a mean says ten thousand words you know it's a complex picture with it with a bunch of meaning in it and it can be it's you know aspirationally funny so you know it's i don't know i love memes but they i mean i think they can be very insightful and you know throughout history i think the symbolism in general has powerfully affected people so yeah

20:19how did you get so good at them i mean i remember following you many years ago going from that to your sea shanties meme or any one of the memes and some of it might may not be safe for work here you know how did you told it why do we have to be safe for work [Laughter] it doesn't work yeah yeah i know yeah i don't know i i guess probably [Music] i mean you know i if you go back to my early very early tweets or technically i was on twitter it i like i think very in the very early days when there were only like maybe ten thousand less than ten thousand users but then like people were just like tweeting like what kind of latte they had at the university street starbucks and i was

21:18like i don't need to know this so then i deleted my twitter account and then and then a then a fake person who got my twitter account and tweeted for a few years and then my friend volley said hey you really should be on twitter so you can speak directly to people and so i was like okay i'll do my family convince me to just you know regain my twitter account and and my early tweets are pretty racy you know like pretty like you know because i was reading this biography of catherine the great you know so

21:55it's sort of what if yeah things went crazy from there by the way i like this i like how you say that your early tweets were racy and not right now look at your profile some people think like oh he he's gone crazy on twitter i'm like no i started crazy on twitter set up new memes elon like what are the new things that you're following now with respect to memes or creating

22:27sorry what was that again yeah i mean i was just going to ask you what what are the new means that you're like following or creating right now what are the ones that are interesting to you right now i don't really follow memes did you just make them i made some of them and then some of them were sent to me i have some pretty kick-ass meme dealers yes [Laughter]

23:02are there main killers on mars wait wait you gotta you gotta have a good meme dealer there will be my friend mike is a good main dealer and claire as well and jake now and a few quite a few others actually i get i unfortunately am the lucky recipients of very interesting memes slightly changing subjects a bit just twitter today you posted about neuralink and why people should be working there for folks who don't know about it i thought it was really cool like you know just the possibility of it it's just really fantastic tell us more about it you know there are a lot of engineers listening on this in this clubhouse you know what is neural link why should we

23:50care what is possible with it sure so the the long term okay so neural link stems from a concern i had where i was trying to figure out even in a benign ai scenario how do we at least go along for the ride so i mean if for those that are following ai closely it's it's obviously improving dramatically you know if you see like look let's say gpt-1 versus gft 2 vs gp3 super t3 and just how radically that's improved and and just as like you know a deep mindset i mean i think they've run out of games to win at basically and there's just and look i say look at tesla it's an important thing that note i should make is like tesla actually has i think one of the the strongest ai teams

24:40in the world but it's ai team focused on real world usability so just really solving vision perception and control with ai but but even in a benign scenario for ai where let's say like the the eyes like just really wants to be super nice to us and make us happy it will happen how do we stay relevant and still ha and have meaning and at least go along for the ride that's in the good scenario and then in terms of avoiding the bad scenario to the to the degree we can couple collective human will to the outcome of artificial intelligence and and what's developed in that way i think that'll probably be a better scenario than if we're unable to effectively couple

25:25collective human will to that outcome so so the the final net now i'm sorry this is getting kind of esoteric but oh we love it i would keep going yeah yeah okay so people are already a cyborg and then in that you already have a tertiary digital layer you know you've got your sort of limbic system which is your primitive drives and desires and responses and then you've got your cortex which is like long-term planning and thinking it allows your two biological layers and then there's a tertiary layer third layer which is digital and you already have that in the form of your phones and computers and all your applications you're far more powerful than a human

26:13would be without those cognitive enhancements but the the bandwidth between your cortex and your digital tertiary layer is very slow and in fact with the advent of phones it got even slower so if you're if you're thumbing like you know say what's the bit rate of a thumb of a pair of thumbs on a phone it's very low i mean let's be super generous and say it's 100 bits per second well computers can communicate at trillions of bits per second so it's you know at a certain point computer gets smart enough it's like the computer's just like trying to talk to a tree you know trees do sort of talk but they've talked so slow that we're gonna notice so so we need to improve the bandwidth

27:03and with a direct neural interface we can improve the bandwidth between your cortex and your digital tertiary layer by many orders of magnitude i'd say probably at least a thousand or maybe 10 000 or more and we could also spend a lot more time thinking about interesting things as opposed to taking complex thought structures compressing them down into words which is which also gain a very low but rate and then having someone else receive those words decompress them and then and then send words back at you so a huge amount about brain power spent in compression decompression and we could be instead sending it on deeper concepts and so if you had a

27:57neural link if two people had a neural link you could do conceptual telepathy where you have a conflict series a complex series of concepts and you could just transfer them directly uncompressed to the other first this would massively improve the quality of communication and the speed of it so and there are other sort of pretty wild things that can be done like you could you could probably save state in the brain and so if so if you were to die you could your state could be returned it you then form of another human body or a robot body okay this is getting like really you know it's weird sci-fi stuff here carbon right like this basically from

28:37altered carbon go on love it yeah yeah it's kind of like altered carbon yeah exactly and but i think you could decide you want to be a robot or a person or whatever and you wouldn't be exactly the same so you you know there'd be a little lust in transfer but you could also say it's also arguably true that when you wake up in the morning you're not exactly the same as yesterday or the you of a month ago is not the same as you of today i mean a bunch of brain cells have died and memories some memories have faded some have strengthened their new memories so anyway the point is like you wouldn't be you could there could be something analogous to a video game like a saved

29:16game situation where you are able to resume upload your last state yeah kind of like ultra carbon maybe lose a few memories but but mostly be you so now that's the long-term stuff in the short term for neural link the idea would really just be to address brain injuries or spinal injuries and you know make up for whatever lost capacity somebody has with whether when implanted chip

29:52so the first thing that we're going after is a a wireless implanted chip that would enable someone who is a quadriplegic or quadriplegic or tetraplegic to control a computer or mouse or or their phone or really any device just use just by thinking and this obviously would be a massive enabler you know make life way way easier for them they have been sort of primitive versions of this device one done with like a wire sticking out of your head but it doesn't work all the time and and you can't take it home with you so just having basically you think like in simplistic terms i'd say it's sort of like a fitbit in your skull with tiny wires that go to your brain

30:34so fitbit inner skull with tiny wires so if somebody who's listening is is good at designing like fitbits apple watches phones computers various kinds then actually they would be a great fit for your lake so yeah we're i mean we'll probably be releasing some some new videos showing progress maybe in a month or so and because we've already got like a a monkey with with with a wireless implant in their skull and the tiny wires who can play video games using his mind

31:21so it's not look like an unhappy monkey and you can't even see where the neural implant was put in except that he's got like a slight like dark mohawk he's not uncomfortable and he doesn't look weird so so that so we're you know oh and i was like when when the usda person came through and inspected our facilities our monkey facilities she said it was like the the nicest monkey facilities she's ever seen in her entire career just fyi we went the extra mile for the monkeys

32:01they're as long as long as you didn't make them play cyberpunk that that would be a well that would be out of trouble for monkey but you know one of the things we're trying to figure out is like can we have the monkeys play mind pong with each other you know that would be pretty cool you know i have to say the pig demo was really fantastic that was that was really cool thanks yeah well it's it's a great team at north lincoln making good progress and like i said but it i want to feel like the early applications will really just be for you know people who've had a serious brain injury like where it's like the the value of the implant is just would be enormous because

32:49obviously the early implants will come with some non-tropical risk and so it's going to be like okay does the good far outweigh the bad and then you know that that would be a candidate for some of the initial surgeries with full disclosure of like these little risks and everything and one of the things we're all we're really paying close attention to is the ability to remove the implant so it's like it's not like you know for it if somebody doesn't want it or it's not working we can take it out and then we can re-implant another one so we've tested implantation removal and re-implantation say and it works great

33:32i mentioned kids earlier as it turns out i have a very bright and inquisitive five-year-old who is crawling all over everything and trying to figure everything out and learning as much as he can as fast as he can like what you know with everything that we know now and kind of all the modern tools that we have like what's the best way to think about educating a five-year-old in today's world

33:53sorry the the best way to ex yeah educate a five-year-old and then think about kind of his education over the course of the next you know five or ten years like what what what kind of program ideally should you think a kid should be on well my observation is my kids were mostly educated by youtube and reddit and and then you know and their i guess classmates and and they're i guess they were lessons as well but judging by the amount of time they spent online it seemed like most of their education is actually coming from online i mean i think generally with education you want to make it as interesting and exciting as possible the you know like what are some of the like

34:43if you see like like what are all the things like say a good video game does to keep keep someone engaged and interested you know if they're get if kids can be super engaged in video games like this is weird for them to be super engaged in education as well like one of the things that's i think very fundamental is to explain the why of of things like so we're teaching this but we need we're going to explain why we're teaching you this and why it is relevant i mean we've evolved to to forget things that are irrelevant or have low low relevance probability it makes sense like otherwise we'd remember all sorts of nonsense things that are what weren't very important to our

35:24future so unless unless relevance is established clearly then people will have a hard time remember remembering advice nature but it's because it's it appears to be irrelevant it might be relevant but if it's not explained to them they won't know and then there's if you want to have some sort of engage if you're trying to say problem solving some sort of engaging narrative for for the problem solving like it's like it's far better to say okay if we're gonna teach you how an engine works by taking apart an engine and and then putting it back together and then let's find out what tools are needed for you know in order to take this engine apart and put it back together it's like

36:07okay we need screwdrivers and wrenches and allen keys and we need a winch and you know a bunch of other things and and then you understand the relevance and and it's much more interesting problem this is much better than having say a course on wrenches or a course on screwdrivers you just like start with a problem and say what tools i need to solve this problem that establishes relevance and it gives a compelling narrative thread yeah it seems like you could kind of if you had sort of elaborate enough projects you know you could you could roll a huge number of topics into into that ultimately kind of combine into a single project with you know some

36:45really actually you know interesting form of output you know like you know for example you know building a you know literally building a vehicle or something like that yeah exactly it's the business it you just you if you have that narrative thread or that well like why is it all established relevant to that and there's a story to it and and and then and then you say like well if you can't you can't you can't turn without the wrench and then like let's let's let's see how can we make this engine better what do we need to do okay well let's calculate you know if it's a gasoline engine you know what what's the how do you get to a higher rpm or

37:20you know a better compression ratio you know i'm using like an outdated analogy of engines but you could say for electric motor you know what what steps would you need to take to get higher torque you know and pull higher power out of this electric motor you know and and and then you should you can explain it's obvious why you know things like maxwell's equations become necessary in that situation yeah yeah yeah that would be amazing yeah elon you would not believe the number of parents and people with kids have asked us about tonight and i think that two questions are connected one is you know how do kids if you're having a kid and you want pizza to become a

38:09polymath like you have become what advice you have for parents and the next one is here you are with you know so many companies that have created it i can't even list them at the top of my head why doesn't the world have and this doesn't mean to sound you know psychopathic but why doesn't the world have more elon musk well i don't know i might be getting too much credit here so i mean for me these things the things i've done have been because i felt a strong compulsion to do them so it's not like nobody was pushing me to do it but they're just like i felt strong compulsive through them

38:50i mean i i wouldn't say you know there are pretty long sections of my life that have been very painful and difficult and i'm not sure i would i'm not sure people would want to do that you know that this yeah if somebody wants to be me or do the things i've done they should i i would say most probably you're mistaken you do not want to do that you'd have to have some kind of like rage demon in your skull that you just got to get it done there's no it's like when people ask me like what encouraging words do you have for entrepreneurs who want to do a startup my response is if you need encouraging words don't do a startup

39:45you know my friend bully during a startup was like eating glass and staring into the abyss for a long time yep yep okay we're going to switch up just a bit but i think for everyone in the audience who just caught up and managed to squeeze in just a quick reset slash recap this is the one only elon musk for his first time on clubhouse and there's a show that we do every single day i know a lot of you are trying to get in the room there are a bunch of overflow room see if we can get in there but we're just having an amazing conversant elon elon okay this is something you joked about but i'm kind of curious to get your you know maybe serious answer to this

40:25which is all things cryptocurrency and bitcoin you famously just change your twitter bio to just the bitcoin logo and the word bitcoin this week what do you think of cryptocurrency what do you think of bitcoin what do you think of other you know currencies would love to get your take on the entire thing well yeah i gotta watch what i say here because some of these things can really move them move the market so i first of all i should say like many friends of mine have tried to convince me to get involved in bitcoin for a long time like from where it first just popped you know he popped out there

41:09you know i heard my bully he he actually had bitcoin cake a cake that was like had a big bitcoin symbol on it and he fed me a slice of bitcoin cake in 2013. so i mean clearly i should have at least bite bought some bitcoin eight years ago like what what more do people need to do you know like jesus talk about being late i thought about being late to the party so i was a little slow on the uptake there my apologies but i i and i think about a fair bit but i i do at this point think bitcoin is a good thing and

41:48so i am a supporter of bitcoin you know like i said i'm late to the party but i'm a supporter of bitcoin and i think bitcoin is really on the verge of getting broad acceptance by sort of the conventional finance people you know so yeah i think so yeah you know i i don't have a strong opinion on other cryptocurrencies i mean occasionally i make jokes about dogecoin but but they are they are really just meant to be jokes but you know dogecoin was made as a as a made as a joke to make fun of cryptocurrencies obviously but but fate loves irony

42:37and often as a fermi says that the most ironic outcome is most likely or as like like say the most entertaining outcome is is often most likely and arguably the most entertaining outcome and the most ironic outcome would be that dogecoin becomes the currency of earth in the future

43:00oh my god elon when you tweeted me this afternoon i will say my tweet replies have been overwhelmed by probably like a zillion different like cryptocurrency coins and but yeah and by the way you might remember the infamous time when your replies were filled with cryptocurrency bots on twitter oh my god that was insane [Laughter] yeah that's how elon and i actually want a meeting because that was a very painful painful time okay yeah in fact and then i made a joke about bitcoin and my account got locked [Laughter]

43:38yeah i i had to actually try and convince some folks that that was actually the real elon musk yeah okay so i wanna ah you know you know bring us bring us back to one of your companies we actually have a tesla model s sitting outside our house right now it carries us in our two-year-old baby around and we love it would love to just get your take on you know where you see you know you just have a refresh of the model s coming out i just saw the review for it where do you just see you know the future for tesla and especially when it comes to all things battery technology and self-driving those two type of things a lot of people are very interested in

44:23okay so so you're asking me about the future of batteries and self-driving more like actually where do you see tesla over the next few years well yeah i mean i think that i mean our the goal with tesla is to and had you know has been from the beginning is to accelerate the advent of sustainable energy so in order to do that we've got to make a lot of cars we've got to make them increasingly affordable and our rough target is we want to be able to eventually make 20 million cars a year and the reason for that is the two billion active cars and trucks on the road and figure if you're not really moving the needle unless you're changing one percent of the existing

45:10fleet and so that's roughly how we came up with 20 million cars you know cars and trucks per year that that's that's very important to expect you know accelerate the advantage of sustainable energy and then of course we've got stationary battery packs and solar which was making a lot of progress in that front so so yeah we're going to try to grow car production as fast as possible and and that the the primary living limiting factor there is battery cell production so we're getting as much you know as much as possible from suppliers and then but but even that is not enough so we're actually going to be building battery cells ourselves but it's important important important

45:58to emphasize that you know to our suppliers who are great we've got great suppliers that we're we're not we're not trying to put them out of business we want them to increase their rate as well so panasonic lg and catl and then but it to to add you know to increase the to accelerate sustainable energy further we're making our own cells and we're pretty excited about that and then anyway so i think you expect you know possibly an acceleration of of compound annual growth at least aspirationally that's our goal and and then that combined that with autonomy and it's a very powerful story because if once you have autonomy of self-driving cars you massively increase

46:49the utility of of any given car you know a typical car is driven about 12 miles sorry 12 12 hours a week you think like you know maybe depending on the situation you're where you live it's like maybe an hour and a half a day or something like that or in la it might be two hours a day so roughly 12 hours a week and there's 168 hours in a week in a seven day week so most likely cars that are autonomous could maybe do a third of the hours in the week or something like that so maybe they do i don't know 60 hours a week of of usage instead of 12. so basically a 5x increase in in asset utilization there and far less need for parking less parking garages and that kind of thing

47:40so but this is in itself is good for the environment you need because you need fewer cars to get the same thing done and we would need fewer parking garages and places just to keep cars when they were not in use because that [ __ ] being in use a lot more so but then the net of the net of like having a lot of cars times automation or time self-driving i think is at the heart of why a lot of investors think tesla is worth what it is they're giving us a lot of credit for future execution but i think the trend is there it's quite positive and i'd like to once again say if anyone is interested in in practical ai iii that that where the rubber hit the road please

48:27tesla's autopilot slash ai team i think people are quite appreciate that that tesla has some of the most advanced ai in the world both on the software side and on the hardware side and on the on the software on you know on the hardware side we've obviously got our inference computer which i think is still the best inference computer out there even though it's been going for a couple years and and then we're building dojo which is will be the most most powerful training computer because it's got to process vast amounts of video training data and and bringing the day of self-driving sooner is translates directly to live saves and lives saved and injuries avoided because

49:13about a million people die every year in car accidents and about 10 million per year have serious injuries so that's the sooner the better and a lot of lives will be saved in lives people's lives made better if it becomes happens here on self-driving you know you made headlines i think a while back when you basically you know to put it mildly criticize lidar as a key technology for self-driving could you talk more about that and why you know you're not such a huge fan of lidar yeah i mean you know sometimes i'm just talking smack you know no we didn't know that yep it's it's tiny it's tiny new outside we took the street seriously

49:59i confess so yeah so first of all i'm not like fundamentally against lidar you know on all things because you know for the spacex dragon at doxworth space station we we we actually developed and and built our own lidar for docking with the space station so obviously if i hated lidar we would not have done that and this is well before this was like 10 years ago we started doing that so i'm not i'm not like i don't have some sort of weird like you know antagonism to later the the however for the for driving on real world roads

50:48you you have to solve vision you have to sell a vision basically understanding objects with passive optical passive optical photons and and and then making sense of those objects so like vision perception what what do those objects mean what are they going to do what is their likely path of travel and then control and and so and all of that really is you know it's ai it's or i mean the way we're doing it is by running a bunch of neural nets in our head so we've got to run a bunch of neurons do the same thing in the car and the point of which you've sold passive optical and and this is better passive optical than a human has because you've got eight cameras three of which

51:33point directly forward two that are diagonally forward and and two that are diagonally rear and one rear so the way we do it right now is we have all eight cameras synchronized with so you've got eight frames collected simultaneously and we're moving towards and have in fact mostly moved towards video training so you've got you've got eight eight surround cameras it's like it's like kind of a surreal thing to see because people look you know really people have two eyes but kind of like really more like one eye because the the two eyes kind of combine but anyway the neural net is it basically it needs to move to full video training video inference

52:19surround video training surrounding inference and then it will be superhuman no question about it like it just because people don't have eyes in the back of their head like they can't you gotta you basically have effectively a human for all intense purposes has it's like having one camera on a slow gimbal and and that is often distracted and maybe sort of drunk or you know change the radio or they fall asleep or you know there's all sorts of things that go wrong there's no question that you can be superhuman with just cameras i think if one is going to go with sort of active photon generation i would recommend something in the occlusion penetrating

53:06wavelengths you know so like radar you know it's a roughly four millimeter radar or something like that would be better if you're gonna really delve into the arena of actual photon generation wow okay that's amazing okay also i love how dp gardner that was super super fun all right i'm going to switch topic just a bit i would say it's safe to say a lot of people are very interested in how you work and you often for example describe yourself as an engineer so walk us through it's monday morning you wake up what is the day a typical work day in the life of elon look like i guess i wake up and and see if there are any emergencies by on text or email

53:56and often they are so i mean the a ton of what i deal with is not actually fun or interesting it's like chores so i've tried really hard not to do my chores but then if i don't do my chores things go to hell so oh man you have to do your chores so you know basically i'm a bit relieved that elon musk basically has the same schedule as the rest of us you know we all and you do too and it's kind of there's something just really relieving just hearing you say that yeah i mean that's pretty much how it goes these days i i do enjoy the in-person meetings more than email in fact i haven't i think i'm getting like a slight like negative like limbic reaction to email

54:52it's killing me texts are way better to deal with and and then in post meetings are are much better even zoom meetings or whatever you know they're still better than email anything's about an email frankly so so anyway i'll have a bunch of meetings i'll write email write texts especially if it's like an email to the group like saying hey we need to i think we need to change direction and do the following things and let me know if you think otherwise but otherwise we've got to do these follow these things and and get our act together in this area or that area and then yeah a bunch of meetings most of my meetings are engineering and design but of course you have to deal

55:39with finance and you know sales and and other things and yeah the things that are necessary for a company to function and and then then there's this quite a lot of context switching and so he sent me the meme of like fear is not the mind killer context switching is the mind killer which i totally agree with context switching is a real bear so just try to try basically try to do less context switching so maybe focus on one thing for an hour and then another thing for another hour it's really hard to context switch between spacex and tesla and all the things that are going on in space next tesla and then and then neural link boring company which was fortunately pretty low low

56:31bandwidth they don't take a high level cpu load because they're smaller and there's their personal stuff and and of course memes you know gotta get good

56:56earlier last year i spoke to mark about how he spends his time and mark talked about you know you know you know when he was younger he used to have large blocks of open time on his calendar and i think a lot of you know well-known founders have large blocks of open time with schedule time now you are unique because you have multiple companies you're running you're also much more of an engineer than traditional ceos what does your calendar look like you have this yeah you allocated 30 minutes back to back you want to open space how do you handle it i don't have a lot of open space it's generally back-to-back meetings and it's insane i i mean my my my days are like insane

57:32torrents torrents of information i mean sometimes people if you want to like audit what i do for a day it's it's insane i don't recommend it i i i mean yeah i was thinking like man how long can i keep this up because i i don't want my brain to explode and it's like the meetings that are scheduled are not like nice to have meetings they're like this meeting is essential like okay it's it's pretty intense i was thinking like maybe i should like at some point like take a week off or something you know clear my mind or like i know there's like a bunch of people like writing books on tesla and spacex for example like it's very pretty hard for them to

58:27get it right because that you know they just weren't there and maybe i should like write some like book of my experiences that has like you know all the foolish mistakes i've done and like you know some advice for others that might be helpful i think so a book a documentary i think you know i mean i remember once hearing about how do you still sleep on the floor of your factory i really used to at one point in time i did i haven't i only if there's like a crisis situation and you know i actually it's like basically when when the team is being asked to do to to really work super hard i i i gotta be right there with them and they us they got to see it

59:18you know seeing is believing and so if i'm just sleeping in the middle of the factory floor and you know you know i sort of go to sleep at four in the morning like you know waking up like four hours later and like they literally see me they walk past me it's not like hidden or anything and it's like okay ceo's willing to [ __ ] take that level of pain then then they'll do it too i was going to say when you first said you slept in the factory i figured you know there must be like an executive floor or something and you must have like a couch and it must be like a nice setup and then you know when i when i came over when i came over to see you that one time

59:55you know it's like you have your conference room is literally literally in the middle of the factory and like the the giant sure i'm pardon my my my swearing but i have to the giant [ __ ] robots are like 15 feet away yeah and they're they're pounding metal and it's like ear splitting and your factory is like literally your your room is like literally right in the middle of them and then at least i saw your your like sleeping bag in the conference room so i assume that's where you're sleeping and i didn't see any of the rooms like yeah so it's not just in the middle of the factory it's like that's intense most of the time i did i did not sleep in the conference room because

1:00:28people could not see me in the conference room so i slept on the floor outside the conference room because otherwise how do people know you know they don't know if they sing is believing so i i mostly just sleep on the floor outside the congress room so they could see that i was there yep that's that's an even even even more advanced level yeah that's less less will to hurt and i always wake up and smell like like oil and iron filings it was it was rough

1:01:05yeah but i was i was i was asking people to really go all out you know and i can't expect them to go out if i'm not doing the same thing that's super interesting because when people think you know and you know again i'm not saying this is a plateau when people think that how does the richest person in the world live they don't think uncomfortably sleeping outside a conference room with like a lot of loud banging going on right next door they probably don't but people the people of the factory do they saw it themselves all right that's what and that's what's important you know okay i love it okay switching topic just a little bit i think a lot of people you know okay

1:01:44you have your hands full with spacex and tesla you know and the boring company and neurolink if you had to start if you somehow magically found an extra five hours in a day and you had to start another company or another effort what would you start well i'm definitely have no plans to start yet another thing

1:02:09yeah my head will definitely explode it's like that gladiator meme are you not entertained enough have you not created enough companies indeed i i think there are still tremendous opportunities in tunneling you know for for five years i people ask me what would i see opportunities and i'd say tunneling and then nobody did anything so then actually initially as a joke created the boring company just and and did it we did like a test tunnel in l.a and then still people don't believe us and then so we just did our first operational tunnel in vegas but the world really needs tunnels in it because all major cities have traffic and tunnels can massively improve people's quality of

1:02:55life by making it easy to travel from one place to another in a city and then that can be further expanded to long distance travel where if you just draw a vacuum on the tunnel then you can go extremely fast faster than a plane and faster than a plane or a high speed rail so i'd really still recommend can someone else say please start a styling company that'll be great then there's rna or mrna basically synthetic viruses which is we've seen puts a good effect with bioin tech and moderna but i think people don't quite quite appreciate that that what's actually going on is the digitization of medicine so it's where you can just literally you know create an rna or dna sequence

1:03:43like a computer program and then it caps encapsulate that in a you have to multiply it many many millions of times billions of times and encapsulate that in a lipid shell so it looks like a tasty treat for yourselves and you can literally do anything this is absolutely the future of medicine i mean when i say it i mean you could you could probably figure out how to turn someone into a literal butterfly okay that's it's comp it's it's yours your cells are biological computers they're they execute just like like a sort of an old-school computer where you feed it like a you know if you'd feel a tape you know or a punch card that's that's just feed that that your

1:04:30sales which are tiny tiny biological computers this punch card and they will do whatever that punch card says so that that was probably a big eye opener last for 2020 of like just the understanding the potential of rna and then just super randomly tesla actually is making a fairly advanced rna sort of micro fab or something where for currently for cure back but we're open to making it for other companies as well wait a minute i i don't think i i'm not sure i understand this why is tesla making an rna fad

1:05:10it's super random so like about a little over four years ago we required a company in germany primarily for they're very good at automation it's called they're called groman and they're they're in southern germany near basically a city of chrome and the at that time the acquisition they they said like look we're willing to be acquired but there's like just a couple of projects that we think even though they're not related to automotive we'd really like to continue if you don't mind as like and the two projects one is one is this like tiny chip analyzer or i think with tiny wires for analyzing chips that intel needs from for making cpus and then another one was

1:05:57this biotech thing for it it's basically a a well there's this there's three parts to it there's a dna multiplier an rna multiplier and something which puts them the lipid shell on the rna sequence we're on like version three of it now and they said could they keep going so if you keep it under 10 percent of resources no problem you can keep going and then i know it turned out like it turns out it may actually be useful i just love that you accidentally found yourself with an rna fab by the way yeah you've been talking a lot about how mrna obviously has been key to the modern vaccines and all the covet 19 vaccines which brings me to covid let us

1:06:41say somehow magically tomorrow you were running the vaccine effort the distribution effort right now what would you do to get the vaccines out yeah specifically around the delivery of the logistics side which we just don't seem to be doing a really good job across the world so what would you do differently there

1:07:02well i i don't have good insight into the situation as it stands but i think relaxing the requirements on this like seems to be there are too many requirements of who can get the vaccine the the vaccine really is important for anyone with that that is elderly or has a compromised immune system or is otherwise at risk for the virus and i i would i think really just saying like you know first come first serve show up here like use cvs and walgreens which which give out the flu vaccine every year and say okay just just show up here and you know especially for the modern and violent tech vaccines which are quite temperature sensitive they can only be

1:07:52sort of defrosted from from the deep deep freeze briefly and then they must be used or they they lose their effectiveness this is because the my understanding is is the is the rna because the the rna sequences they use are not stable those those sequences want to revert to something else because they are not stable they must be frozen at a very low temperature or they will simply want to revert to a lower energy state rna sequence that's my understanding of it so just like instead of worrying about like this it is the exact right person going to get the the vaccine like just accept that maybe some people who shouldn't get the vaccine will get it but we will

1:08:36still get a whole lot more vaccines out there and and and and let's not worry about the details here let's just get it to as many people as as possible as quickly as possible and for sure we should not worry about the second dose quite yet just give everyone the first dose i suspect that the the community grounded by the first dose is very significant and we've got you know that that third the second dose is like three or four weeks later so we'll have that we've got plenty of time to think about the second dose just just worry about the first dose and first come first served and and don't worry about like accidentally giving them doing the damn thing to

1:09:11someone who maybe doesn't deserve it that will happen a little bit so that's my recommendation on that front we are going to be there's there is going to be a an avalanche of vaccine coming i think the u.s may have ordered on the order they may have ordered something like at 900 million doses said by and and the combination of there's going to be we were going to have so many so much covert vaccine i guarantee you it will be thrown away later this year more than we could possibly ever need or want and then the johnson johnson vaccine just got approved which is that that's good because that's a it's more conventional vaccine but it's a single shot room temperature

1:09:59and then there are more vaccines that are going to get approved hopefully the cure back one will be approved soon and i know because i know the tesla machine it can make a bazillion doses super fast so you know i think there's there's definitely for those who are concerned about the vaccine you should expect an exponential increase in vaccine availability and then combined with that we we are i think starting to approach some degree of herd immunity with you know people have contracted the virus and and and recovered so which is actually better than getting a vaccine the antibody reaction is better than if you've got the vaccine so yeah could go

1:10:46on and on about it but overall i think you know optimistic message that there will be lots of vaccines and i would really encourage people to take the vaccine i am not an anti-vaxxer i want to be clear i'm a pro-vaxxer so you know speaking of vaccine you know california is you know has been sort of bouncing between kind of 40th 45th and 50th in the country you know by states in terms of the the speed of the rollout and it for me it sort of you know it re-raises this question that's been coming up more and more which is you know you and i and a lot of people you know here listening of like you know builds our companies you know primarily in california up until now

1:11:24what's your view on the future california from here well i mean first of all i should say i love california and i've been i've lived half my life more than half my life in california just yeah like i am you know californian you know like so much of my i mean i built my companies here you know i came here as a summit came silicon valley as a summer intern to work on on energy storage technology for electric vehicles way back in like 92 i think it was 92 or 93 there's a little company called pinnacle research and plus goddess i mean i got silicon valley as soon as i could and and then a stanford i was gonna be working on sort of advanced capacitors for using

1:12:15electric vehicles as grad studies and ended up putting that on hold for the internet and yeah try to get a job at netscape by the way so i have what i have i have heard that story indirectly i i would actually i would actually like for you to tell it so that i can i can learn what what mistake i made okay well first of all i wouldn't say i did a very good job of trying to get a job in escape but i was like i was convinced that that the internet would be the future you know essentially the humanity communicated by osmosis until until then but with the internet it would be like humanity acquiring a nervous system and becoming much more of a super organism

1:12:55and so i was like okay well i could do a phd at stanford on sort of advanced capacitors for use in electric vehicles which may or may not be successful like i could get the phd but would it be useful or not uncertain or i could be part of building the internet which was associated like do the phd and watch the internet get both right in front of me or study grad studies on hold and and and try to help you know build their internet in some way and like you know i mean you're basically the only internet company so yeah so i said i sent my send my resume and i was like didn't get any feedback and and then i and then then i tried hanging out in the lobby but i was too shy to speak to

1:13:40anyone and i was like what if charlotte and i am sitting in this lobby wow and then i just started writing software myself because i was like okay well you know i'll just write software myself and i actually wrote the first maps and directions on the internet i'm not sure how many people are aware of that but first directions yellow pages and white pages i wrote it personally it was just me and my computer and when we started our first company we only had one computer so the website only worked during the day because i was coding at night and then the server ran during the day that was quite an adventure that's for sure yeah so i i just want to let you know that the

1:14:27next time you show up at one of my companies and hang out in the lobby for an internship you're going to get an internship well thanks man yeah but but only if you get the stuff running 24 7 like you can't slack off at night yeah yeah no sleeping outside the conference that's not okay yeah we will we will provide you with not just one but two computers nice okay i i want to you know you know wrap up with some light questions for you which i think a lot of people curious in what are you what are you watching on tv what are you reading right now

1:15:04well i just finished watching the last kingdom which i think is a great piece of you know mostly accurate historical drama there's cobra kai which is if you grew up in it's so good it's so it's so good it's such a sick burn that that show my goodness that i mean they just like turn the knife constantly and

1:15:30yeah let's see what else i've been watching what are you what are you if i can break what do you think of the expanse i you know yeah maybe i should start watching that i think there were like some sort of like things about like having a shortage of water or something is there something like that didn't make any scientific sense at first so i was like come on this is dumb so then i stopped watching it but i it sounds like maybe i should work you know keep watching it i i need to make myself on the treadmill otherwise i won't work out cause i hate working out yeah i think you'll find i mean i think season four now i think you'll find it's it's apparently i think you'll know more

1:16:09than i will but the sort of most accurate representation of what you know actual space actual like interplanetary travel would be like you know once it's sort of made routine and by the way the politics that flow right and so it sort of sets up a three-way battle between you know basically earth and mars and then the asteroid belt and kind of gets into all that in the future i would say that that's a that would be a good outcome because it means that you know humanity's actually made it out there as long as they're not and don't mallead each other besides the expanse i mean what do you recommend oh have you seen it i've got one free oh i just got to bring one up

1:16:45devs spelled d e b yes if you have not seen devs dev is definitely the show for you and i i will not say any more but you you will you will enjoy it all right devs oh you know a game that's pretty good is mythicquest yes yeah amazing favorite after tv show yeah that's a good one did you see the ravens banquet the most recent one yeah it's great so good have you seen tenet yet the new christopher nolan movie yes it's pretty good wow okay and did you understand tenet well i think if you i think if you think too hard about tenet it's not going to make maybe complete sense but i enjoyed the it's movie because that's kind of what nolan said too in one of the interviews

1:17:32he said just don't like go deep into it just enjoy it for the movie and the four hours like later i emerged from reddit being like i still don't like entirely get it so i should have just paid you know just skim through it and just watched it for the fun of it yeah yeah exactly okay elon you know i think you know i don't you don't take up too much of your time this has been amazing you're pretty much broken clubhouse there are probably about like over a dozen maybe more overflow rooms and i see so many twitter friends right now you've been so generous for all your listeners here and on twitter you've been asking for people to join neural link you've been

1:18:09asking people to join tesla do you have any final thoughts for everybody who's listening to you right now well do you want to hear the real story from vlad from robin hood about what happened this week with gamestop sure go for it okay you need to like let him somehow click on a button so he can talk all right let me figure this out

1:18:40while we're figuring it out elon why don't you talk to us about hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy since you mentioned that right at the beginning yeah hitchhikes hit the hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy by douglas adams is is in fact a book of philosophy disguised as a silly humor book and if you read it from the standpoint of wow this is an interesting book philosophy this is quite insightful you know as i mentioned he really goes hits on the point of the answer is easy once you properly can properly formulate the question

1:19:20and yeah i mean i like the fact that the ship is powered by infinite improbability it's called the heart of gold yeah yeah it's a he makes fun of of bureaucracy in fact earth essentially gets destroyed by is a sort of clerical error or they basically decide that they need to have an interstellar highway and the earth's in the way and so they they they post the fact that the earth needs to get destroyed for this interstellar highway but of course this posted on alien bullet board bulletin board that no one earth can access and and so then they're surprised when people on earth aren't happy about this it's like it was posted on the board what do you mean like what board

1:20:17so some of the things in doug sanders were like the babble fish where you put the fish in your ear that automatically translates we kind of have that already so yeah i mean the future is coming fast elon okay blood can you hear us glad the stock impaler hey guys thanks for thanks for inviting me up it's good to hang with all of you all right vlad what really happened give us the inside scoop all right well i was actually hoping that you would invite me up for the fermi paradox part because this has been a very surreal weekend and week for me one of the really great things is all the people coming to coming out of the woodwork to offer support for the company offer you

1:21:07know advice so i got introduced today and actually i should say i just randomly downloaded clubhouse a couple of days ago just to see what it was all about so this is my first time literally using the app but yeah i i got introduced to your friend antonio elon who had some good advice for me and then introduced me to you you had some great advice and then i figured you know i heard about this clubhouse and this has got to be part of the simulation so i just thought why not so here i am so i'm actually i'm actually an adherent to the simulation hypothesis all right well it's full of beans man what happened last week why do you stop here why can people buy the

1:21:56gamestop shares the people demand an answer and they want to know the details and the truth yep yep okay so let me let me start by giving a little bit of background so i'm the chief executive of robin hood right now actually i'll go through this quickly don't worry this is this is this is important it's actually a couple of companies so there's a an introducing broker dealer called robinhood financial and that basically is the app that you know and love it processes trades you're a customer of robinhood financial then there's a clearing broker dealer robinhood securities that clears and settles the trades and then we have robin hood crypto which is our crypto business

1:22:47all of which all these are kind of different entities that are differently operated so basically wednesday of last week we just had you know unprecedented volume unprecedented load on the system a lot of these you know so-called meme stocks were you know going viral on social media and people were people were joining robin hood and there was a lot of net buy activity on them as you guys all know and robinhood at this time i think was number one on the ios app store and pretty close if not number one on on google play as well so just unprecedented activity and so thursday morning right so i'm i'm sleeping but at 3 30 a.m pacific our operations team receives a file

1:23:48from the nscc which is the national securities clearing corporation so basically as a broker as a clearing broker and this is where robinhood securities comes in we have to put up money to the nscc based on some factors including things like the volatility of the of the trading activity concentration into certain securities and this is this is the equities business so it's based on stock trading and not options trading or anything else so they gave us a file with the deposit and the the request was around three billion dollars which is you know about an order of magnitude more than what it typically is right so no no why was that so high like this seems

1:24:47like like it sounds like this is an unprecedented increase in demand for capital what formula did they use to calculate that well yeah and just to give context you know robin hood up until that point has raised you know a little bit around two billion dollars in total venture capital up until now so it's a big number like three billion dollars is is a large number right so basically the and you know i

1:25:21the details are we don't have the full details it's a little bit of an opaque formula but there's a component called the var of it which is value at risk and that's based on kind of some fairly quantitative things although it's not it's not fully transparent so there are ways to reverse engineer it but it's not kind of publicly shared and then there's a special component which is discretionary so that's that kind of acts as a multiplier and basically discretionary discretionary meaning like it's just their opinion yeah they're it's it's a little bit i mean i'm sure there's there's definitely more more than just their opinion but basically i mean i i guess it's based

1:26:10on growth everyone wants to know what everyone wants to know is like did something maybe shady go down here like like it's like it seems weird that you'd get a sudden 10 billion dollar demand you know three billion in the morning sorry how much yeah it was three billion u.s dollars okay three billion around you know just suddenly out of nowhere and what i wouldn't i wouldn't impute shadiness to it or anything like that and actually you know the nstc was reasonable subsequent to this and you know they've been they've been they worked with us to to actually lower it so it was unprecedented activity you know we don't i don't have the full context about

1:26:57you know what was what was going on in what's going on in the in the nscc to make these calculations but yeah essentially is anyone with a large i'm holding you hostage right now no no i'm okay yeah thanks for asking but anyway so this was this was obviously nerve wracking and i actually was asleep at this point you know the operations team was was fielding this at at three o'clock and then you know we got back we put our heads together you know our chief operating officer basically said look let's call up the higher ups at the nscc and kind of figure out what's going on maybe there's some way we can work with them and basically there was another call

1:27:51and they lowered it to something like 1.4 billion dollars from three so okay we're making some progress right and then but it's still a high number and then we basically proposed well let's let's explain how we plan to let's explain how you know we'll manage risk in these symbols throughout the day we proposed marking these volatile stocks that were kind of driving driving the activity position closing only and then at about an hour before market clo market open so 5 30 or 5 in the morning they came back and they said okay the charge is or the deposit 700 million which we then deposited and paid promptly and then everything was fine so that that essentially explains why

1:28:51we had to we had to mark these symbols position closing only and also why you know we didn't wanna we knew this was a bad outcome for customers you know part of what's been really difficult is robinhood stands for you know democratizing access to stocks and yeah we want we want to give people the access so that's been very very challenging but we had no choice in this case we had to conform to our regulatory capital requirements and so the team did did what they could to make sure we were available for customers

1:29:30who controls this this organization this clearinghouse you know it's a it's a consortium it's not it's not quite a government agency you know i i don't really know the details of of of all of that okay but you know and to be fair like we were we were i think there was legitimate sort of turmoil in the markets like these are unprecedented events with these meme stocks and you know there was a lot of activity so there probably is some amount of extra risk in the system that warrants higher higher requirements so it's not entirely unreasonable but we did operational processes to make sure that customers that had positions could sell their open positions because

1:30:28obviously restricting someone we got a lot of questions about okay you had to restrict buying why didn't you also restrict selling and the fact of the matter is people get really pissed off if they're holding stock and they want to sell it and they can't read so i think that's that's categorically worse so and lots of other brokers i think were in the same situation robinhood was in the news but you you sort of heard this industry-wide right other brokers basically restricted the same exact activity all right so so it sounds like this this organization should you know calls you up and they basically have a gun to your head either either hand over this money or or else

1:31:10and so because i mean like basically what people are wondering is like did you sell your clients down the river or do you have no choice if you had no choice that's understandable but then you know we got to find out why you had no choice and who are these people that are saying you have no choice yeah i think that's fair you know we have to comply with these requirements financial institutions have requirements you know the the the formula behind these requirements i think it would obviously be ideal if there was a little bit more transparency so we could plan better around that you know but to be fair we were able to open and serve our customers

1:31:54and you know 24 24 hours later our team raised over a billion dollars in capital so that when we when we did open well when we do open tomorrow morning we'll be able to kind of relax the stringent position limits that we put on these securities on friday will it be any limits well i think there's always going to be some theoretical limit like we don't have infinite capital right and on friday there were limits so there's always there's always going to have to be some limit i think the question is you know will the limits be high enough to the point where you know some they won't impact you know 99.9 plus percent of customers so you know someone were to deposit

1:32:50a hundred billion dollars and and decide to trade in one stock like that that wouldn't be possible you know all right all right well i guess people really just want to know you know if you had no choice then then you had no choice gun for that situation and you know then that's understandable but then we'll put that gun to your head should you know be willing to answer to the public yeah listen and you know i know there's there's processes this is unprecedented times and to be fair to those guys they've been reasonable so we are i think the the one thing that is maybe not clear to people is robin is a participant in the financial system so we have to work with

1:33:43all of these counterparties so we do get a lot of questions about you know why do you work with market makers why do you work with clearing houses vertically integrating and getting i mean it's hard enough to build a introducing and a clearing broker dealer not too many people have done that but the financial system that allows customers to trade shares is sort of a complex web of multiple parties and you know it's it's hard to

1:34:16everyone says though it could be better it could be improved it's it's just the necessity of of trading equities in the us that you have to do all these things all right to what degree are you beholden to citadel i mean like basically if citadel's unhappy then then what happened yeah so that you know there was a rumor that citadel or other market makers kind of pressured us into doing this and now that's just false right market makers execute our trades they execute trades of of every broker dealer no this was this was a clearing house this was a clearinghouse decision and it was just based on the capital requirements so from our perspective you know citadel

1:35:06and other market makers weren't involved in that but wouldn't they have a strong say in in who got put in charge of that organization since it's an industry consortium not a government consortium or not a government regulatory agency i i don't have any reason to believe that i think that's just like you know then you're getting into kind of the conspiracy theories a little bit so i just have no no reason to believe that that's the case you know okay

1:35:40all right well i guess so we'll see what happens with future actions hopefully that was insightful or at least a little bit entertaining are you not entertaining yeah okay well i i don't know what to say first of all vlad thank you so much for jumping on i know it's pretty late and thank you so much you know deep you know i deeply appreciate it and i'm sure everyone in the audience here and watching elsewhere deeply episodes so thank you so much we appreciate this i'm gonna wrap this up elon what can i say you know thank you so much i'm i hope you had a fun time for your first time on clubhouse did you have fun yeah it's great this is awesome i didn't

1:36:28even know existed a week ago so it seems cool awesome so would you come back yeah all right okay well you know thank you so much and also thank you everyone for listening and i know we went way over elon elon we every time we do this show we try and pick a song that fits the person we're interviewing so i'm gonna place out of the show with a song that i think you might like gary hit it

1:36:56[Music] there we go elon great song thank you so much this was a true break the internet movement thank you everyone thanks guys good night everybody everybody thank you then you

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份