访谈·中文精读

DEI 的破坏性 | 马斯克《The Search》访谈

The Destructiveness of DEI | THE SEARCH With Elon Musk

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

Ben Shapiro 问马斯克,美国人要怎么才能从 DEI 里走出来。

马斯克的回答很干脆:DEI 已经走到最后阶段,原因是它本来就违法。

按种族、性别、性取向来决定录用、晋升、资源分配,这在美国的劳动法里是明文禁止的。马斯克的原话是,这么一套明摆着不合法的东西,居然被推行开了。

现在我们开始看到大量诉讼,法院在说,法律写得很清楚,你不能基于性别、性身份、种族做歧视。所以 DEI 只剩最后一口气,它会被清掉,因为它确实违法。(马斯克)

这段对话来自 2024 年 Ben Shapiro 的访谈节目《The Search》。两个多小时里,话题从 DEI 一路铺到唯才是举、财富的来源、政府是不是一家公司、东西德的生产率差距,最后落在言论自由上。

看点在于马斯克把 DEI 当成一套有内在逻辑的东西来拆。他找到了它的骨架,找到了它的心理动机,也找到了它最脆弱的地方:法律条文。

DEI 的内核,和反犹阴谋论共用一副骨架

Shapiro 先把话挑明。他说 DEI 在实际操作里就是一套阴谋论。

它假设有一小撮掌权者在最上面,控制着下面发生的一切。因为这些人握着权力,所以他们剥削其他所有人,必须把他们往下拉一格。这套叙事和反犹阴谋论贴合得非常紧。(Ben Shapiro)

马斯克接得很直接。

我认为 DEI 在核心上极其反犹。(马斯克)

这个判断放在中文语境里容易被读成情绪化的指控,但它背后有个很具体的结构问题。

反犹阴谋论的骨架是:世界被一小群人秘密操控,所有坏事都是他们干的,解决方案是把他们拉下来。DEI 里那套“权力结构”叙事,用的几乎是同一副骨架,只换了被指认的对象。它把人按身份分组,然后规定某些组天生占据结构性的优势位置,另一些组天生被压在下面。分组的标准是出生时就已经确定的属性,跟这个人的行为、选择、努力无关。

麻烦出在这种叙事没法被证伪。你越成功,越说明你从结构里获益;你越辩解,越说明你没意识到自己的特权。它解释一切,所以什么都解释不了。

后果是一层层往下传的。个体失败不再需要归因于自己的判断失误,可以归因于结构;个体成功也不再被记为能力,被记为占了位置。人的行为从解释变量里被抽走了,剩下的只有身份坐标。

马斯克后面补了一句更实在的判断。

它整体上是反唯才是举的,我觉得这非常危险。(马斯克)

反唯才是举这几个字,是整场对话的主线。后面所有话题,财富、政府、生产力差距,都在给这条主线补证据。

一个社会该按什么标准分配机会

马斯克给出了他自己的版本。

你想要的社会,是人靠技能和努力成功,仅此而已。跟你的种族、性别、信仰、宗教都没关系。只问一句:你擅长你的工作吗?你努力吗?你正直吗?问到这里就停。(马斯克)

Shapiro 顺着往下推。他说现在社会里确实有一股力量在反对这套标准,可这股反对要能站得住,只有一种可能。

它只有在你实际上承认自己赢不了唯才竞争的时候,才能维持下去。(Ben Shapiro)

马斯克同意,而且把话说得更不留情面。

它本质上是在说,我没成功,原因是谁都成功不了。这某种程度上是失败者的论证,或者是那些觉得自己应该得到更多的人的论证。(马斯克)

Shapiro 补了一句他自己的看法,这句话比表面听起来更狠。

我不确定有谁“应得”什么,除了自己的努力和创新在生活里带来的东西。(Ben Shapiro)

它针对的是补偿正义的地基。如果“应得”这件事本身没法独立定义,那“某人应该被保送到某个位置”这个主张就失去了依据。你没法证明一个人“应得”一个他没争取到的位置,只能证明他所在的那个群体历史上吃过亏。这两件事在逻辑上隔得很远。

接着 Shapiro 提了一个很少被讨论的角度。

如果一个人是靠能力和努力被提拔的,DEI 会连带损伤他晋升的可信度。旁人会想:这位置是真本事换来的,还是配额换来的?

马斯克接过这个点。

它会把这个人应得的尊重拿走。(马斯克)

这条批评的杀伤力比想象中大。政策的初衷是补偿,实际效果可能是给被补偿者的能力打上一个永久的问号。这个问号还很难被消除,因为任何成绩都可以被重新归因到身份上。你做出一个漂亮的项目,别人心里那句话是“她当然有机会做这个项目”。

这就形成了一个闭环:设计者想用身份来纠正历史,执行结果是用身份重新定义了能力。

唯才是举是唯一有正外部性的制度

Shapiro 提了一个整场对话里信息量最大的观察。

唯才是举是人类设计过的唯一一种有正外部性的制度。你创建任何其他制度,都会有负外部性,因为你实际上是在跟某个特定圈子分赃,好处归那个圈子,不在圈子里的人就被牺牲掉。唯才是举的意思是,能成功的人是那些天生有能力为所有人创造东西的人。(Ben Shapiro)

这段值得掰开看。

裙带制度的账很好算。把机会给“自己人”,收益集中归圈子,成本摊给圈子外的人。圈子越封闭,成本越高,因为你在用身份筛人,等于主动放弃了圈外所有更能干的人。一个组织里如果有一半岗位是按关系分配的,那一半岗位就自动放弃了全部候选人里最优秀的那部分。

唯才制度难算的地方在于,它的收益是分散的。你招到一个真正能干的人,好处不会全部落到你头上,会通过产品、服务、价格散到所有人手里。这个人做出一项改进,成本降下来,价格跟着降,受益的是几百万个你从没见过的人。

所以唯才制度在政治上天生吃亏。受益的人太多太散,没人会专门为它组织游说,没人会给它捐款,没人会举着牌子游行。裙带制度的受益者正好相反,集中、动机强、行动快,而且知道该找谁。

Shapiro 那段话的作用,是把这笔长期被低估的账重新摆到桌面上。

马斯克的钱,绝大部分是纸面上的股票

Shapiro 把话题引到马斯克个人身上。他提到马斯克的财富主要是持股,而那部分持股几乎全是公司股份,人并没有坐在一堆现金上。

马斯克给了一段很少完整讲过的创业资金链。

我第一家互联网公司的时候没有钱,只有 10 万美元学生贷款,那是互联网刚刚起来的时候。后面的公司我基本上是加倍下注:Zip2 的钱投进 X.com 和 PayPal,PayPal 的钱投进特斯拉和 SpaceX。我觉得自己去请投资人出钱、自己一分不出,这事不对。你得有皮肤在游戏里。(马斯克)

“皮肤在游戏里”(skin in the game)这个词用得准。他连着把三次退出的钱全押进下一家公司,结果是他持有公司大量股份,公司做得越好,股份越值钱。

这段自述把“首富”这个标签拆开了一层。他的财富形式是股权,股权的价值来自公司未来能创造的东西。公司垮了,这些数字一起归零。2008 年特斯拉和 SpaceX 同时濒临破产的时候,他账上的现金状况跟外界想象的完全是两回事。

这一点跟后面要讲的“饼”是连着的。如果饼是固定的,那一个人持有大量股份就意味着他从别人碗里挖走了东西。如果饼会变大,那股权价值上升是公司创造了新东西的结果。两种世界观,导出完全相反的道德判断。

所有反增长情绪的源头,都藏在一个假设里

Shapiro 把话题推到根子上。

很多负面情绪的来源是一个公理式的错误,它假设饼是静态的,是一场零和游戏,别人成功是因为他拿走了超过公平份额的那一块。可饼不是固定的。(Ben Shapiro)

马斯克在这里插了个玩笑,说那我现在想来块派,现场笑成一片。英文里 pie 既是“饼”也是“派”,这个谐音不太容易翻过来。

笑完之后他给了实质内容。

经济这块饼比过去大得多。商品和服务的产出、人均生产力,都远高于过去。你创建一家新公司、做出新产品新服务,你是在把饼做大,是在增加人们能拿到的商品和服务总量。你没有从任何人那里拿走任何东西,你创造了以前不存在的东西。(马斯克)

他举的例子很朴素:以前没有 iPhone,没有电脑,没有汽车,没有飞机,没有今天这些救命的药。这些全是新出现的。

这个论证在经济学教科书里不新鲜,但它在公共讨论里经常被跳过。原因是零和直觉很符合日常经验:一块地上多盖一栋楼,就少一块空地;一个岗位被占了,就少一个岗位;一个孩子进了好学校,另一个孩子就进不去。这些在微观层面全都是真的。

宏观层面的增长来自别处。iPhone 出现之前,没有任何人手里的钱被拿走。它凭空多出了一个品类,然后重新分配了人们的注意力和支出。诺基亚的衰落是竞争的结果,不是被抢。区别在于:被抢之后世界上的手机总量不变,竞争之后世界上的手机总量翻了十几倍。

零和直觉之所以顽固,还因为它在短期里常常是对的。一个行业萎缩,一个岗位消失,这些痛感直接、具体、当天就能在饭桌上感受到。而“饼变大了”这件事要过几年才在统计数据里显形,而且显形的方式是一堆没人会读的图表。

痛感是即时的,收益是延迟的。公共讨论永远偏向即时的那一边。

政客和创业者的分歧,就在这个假设上

Shapiro 把这条线拉到政治上。

创新者、生意人、自由市场派,和政治阶层之间有个根本分歧。政治阶层几乎完全建立在“饼是固定的”这个前提上。因为饼固定,你当选的办法就是承诺把饼的更大一块分给某群人,或者承诺从私营部门夺走钱,由你亲自把饼做大。判断一个政客不值得听的第一标志,就是他说“我能解决你所有问题”。这一条基本把所有人都排除了,因为政治阶层里每个人都在说这句话。(Ben Shapiro)

这段话可以拆成两层。

第一层是动机结构。饼固定的时候,政治就只剩分配,而分配不需要创造,只需要重新划界。承诺分配的人永远比承诺创造的人容易当选,因为分配的好处是即时的、点对点的、能指名道姓的。你今天说要把某笔钱给某个群体,那群人明天就记住了你的名字。而放松管制、简化审批、让新公司更容易活下来,这些政策的好处要在五年后由一群不知道你是谁的人享受。

第二层是能力边界。声称能解决所有问题的政客,在同一句话里承认了两件事:他认定所有问题都归他管,他认定自己有本事管。这两个认定任何一个出错,代价都由全体承担。

Shapiro 后面接的那句更实在:社会真正需要的是有创业精神和创新能力的人,把眼前这个具体问题解决掉,然后才有余力去面对下一个具体问题。问题是被一个个解决的,不是被一次性解决的。

马斯克顺着往下走,把政府换了个角度看。

政府就是一家公司,而且是终极公司

现实是,政府就是一家公司,极限情况下是终极公司。它跟公司没有区别,只是它是垄断的,而且除非整个国家破产,它不会破产。它还垄断暴力。(马斯克)

Shapiro 顺着问了一句,这一问很像把刀递过去。

那你会想给这家全球最大、垄断暴力的公司多少权力?大概是更少。(Ben Shapiro)

这个类比容易被当成修辞,其实它有可操作的推论。

公司有客户,客户能走。政府有公民,公民走不掉,移民的成本远高于换供应商。公司破产就清算,股东和债权人承担损失。政府破产的代价由所有纳税人承担,而且要拖几十年。公司之间有竞争,客户可以货比三家。政府在自己划定的边界内没有对手,同一片土地上只能有一套法律。

三个条件叠在一起:无退出、无破产、无竞争。任何一个商业组织同时具备这三条,都会被经济学家列为最需要警惕的结构。

马斯克给的立场其实很克制,媒体经常把这一段剪掉。

我不是那种主张废除政府的人。我只是说,让政府做最少的事。政府做得越少,经济越繁荣。(马斯克)

他给出的量化判断是:

政府做的事,效率要比私营部门低五到十倍。(马斯克)

Shapiro 插了句车管所(DMV),话说到一半自己打住了。车管所在美国是个通用梗,排队两小时,办事五分钟,柜台后面的人不急,你也不敢催。

这条效率差的说法要小心理解。它不是指政府雇员比企业雇员笨,它指的是缺少竞争和退出机制的组织,在任何地方都会慢慢变形。指标会取代目标,流程会取代结果,保住位置会取代解决问题。

同一套机制在企业里也成立,只是企业会被淘汰,政府不会。

一条任意画出来的线,五倍到十倍的差距

马斯克拿两组国家做对照:东德和西德,朝鲜和韩国。

这两组案例的共同点很干净。它们原本是同一个民族、同一套语言、同一段历史,只是被一条战后画出来的线切开,一边走一套制度,另一边走另一套。人、地、文化、气候,全部被控制住了。

这种对照组在社会科学里几乎找不到第二个。

西德的生产率是东德的五倍。而且西德并不是什么纯资本主义的样板,它有一半社会主义色彩。所以如果另一边是百分之百的社会主义或者共产主义,真正的差距大概在十倍这个量级。(马斯克)

这个数字要放在语境里看。五倍的生产率差距意味着同样一个人、同样八小时,产出的东西差五倍。差距大到很难归因于个案或者运气。

西德当年搞的是社会市场经济,国有成分、福利开支、行业管制都不少。用马斯克的话说,它算不上纯正的资本主义样本。所以这组对比给出来的是一个保守估计,真正的计划经济对照,差距会更大。

把这条线反过来看,也是在给前面那段“政府效率低五到十倍”找现实依据。那个数字不是凭感觉说的,是从两组被历史切开的国家里量出来的。

所有这些讨论能存在,前提是言论自由

访谈里马斯克还有一段话,讲的是更大的框架。他主动把话题引到这儿。

言论自由是民主的基石。言论自由让暴行能够被指认出来,让人们知道发生了什么。这就是为什么德国人当时第一件事就是想关掉媒体。我们应该尽一切努力保住言论自由,一旦失去它,我认为民主也保不住了。(马斯克)

这段话把前面所有内容串成了一根线。

DEI 能被质疑,因为“它违法”这件事能被公开讲出来。东西德的差距能被讨论,因为数据能流通。政府的效率问题能被摆上桌,因为有人敢说。任何一个环节上,只要这类话题被划成禁区,讨论就会绕着它走。

禁区是会扩张的。今天不能碰这个,明天不能碰那个,后天连“这块地方不能碰”这个事实本身都不能提。到那一步,剩下的讨论全都建立在被修剪过的事实上,得出的结论再严谨也没意义。

马斯克提到的那个历史细节值得停一下:纳粹上台之后最先动手的对象之一是新闻界。原因并不复杂。暴行需要被看见才构成暴行,如果没人能报道,它可以一直用别的名字被称呼,一直被称为“重新安置”,一直被称为“特别处理”。

语言先被改造,事实才能被抹掉。

DEI 的退场方式,可能比预想的平淡

访谈最后,Shapiro 又把问题拉回开头:如果要从 DEI 里走出来,最好的办法是什么。

马斯克的回答落在一个很朴素的地方,他没有谈文化战,没有谈人事调整,谈的是法律。

DEI 其实是非法的,因为它按种族、性别、性偏好这些东西做歧视。这本身就违法。他们居然把这套违法的事推行开了。现在我们开始看到大量诉讼,法院在说,法律写得很清楚。所以我认为它只剩最后一口气,它会被移除,因为它确实违法。(马斯克)

这个判断里有个可以迁移的思路。

面对一套看起来已经制度化、有预算、有部门、有考核指标的东西,人的第一反应是“它太坚固了,动不了”。马斯克的处理方式是从最底下找一条更硬的规则,然后看这套东西有没有踩线。

劳动法关于反歧视的条款比 DEI 早了几十年,位阶更高,而且在美国有私人诉权,个人可以直接起诉,不需要等监管部门点头。这一条一旦被激活,制度性的东西挡不住。企业法务算一笔账就明白了:一场集体诉讼的和解金额,比一整个 DEI 部门的年度预算高得多。

他给的是时间问题,方向问题他没留余地。

这套逻辑对其他领域也成立。当一个做法看起来已经不可动摇,先去找它跟更基础规则之间的冲突点。冲突点往往比正面对抗有效,因为规则不需要被说服,它只需要被引用。

可以马上做的几件事

  • 下次听到“某个群体需要被特殊对待才算公平”,先去查本地劳动法和雇佣条例里的反歧视条款。很多 DEI 操作比推动者自己以为的更接近违法边界,法律条文比会议纪要硬。
  • 在自己的团队里,把录用和晋升的评判维度写成文字,具体到“这个人交付了什么、怎么交付的”。标准要先于人选存在,事后补写的标准一定会被人选倒推回去。
  • 听到“饼就这么大”的论证时,追问一句:这件事创造了什么以前不存在的东西。答不出来,它确实只是分配;答得出来,讨论框架就该换。
  • 判断一个候选人、一个方案、一个政客,先看他承诺的是创造还是重新划界。承诺分配的人永远更容易被听见,因为好处即时、点对点、能指名道姓。
  • 在公司里保留一条能说“不”的通道,匿名的也行。禁区一旦形成,剩下的讨论全都会绕着它走,而绕着走的成本最后会以决策失误的形式回来。
  • 看到某个被提拔的人被贴上“配额”标签时,把评价拉回到具体产出上。这个标签一旦贴上就很难揭掉,唯一能对冲的是可核查的交付记录。
  • 给自己定个习惯:每年认真看一次所在行业的人均产出数据。零和直觉在短期里经常是对的,只有长期数据能把它纠正过来。
  • 读到一个让你立刻愤怒的分配类新闻时,先问一句:这件事里有没有任何一方创造了新东西。如果没有,那它确实是零和;如果有,愤怒可能被用错了地方。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00free speech is the Bedrock of democracy and free speech is what allows atrocities to be called out and for people to be aware of them that's why the Germans wanted to shut down the Press immediately so you know any a way I think we we should do everything we can to preserve free speech and when we lose free speech I think we lose democracy one of the other things we were talking about earlier to touch back on it was the Dei of it and and one of the things that you know you and I had been discussing a little bit offline is the fact that Dei effectively is a conspiracy theory in which there's a Cadre of powerful people who are at the top and they control everything else

0:41that's happening and because those powerful people are at the top they are exploiting everybody else and they have to be taken down more than one peg and you know that that conspiracy theory matches very aligns very closely with anti-semitic conspiracy theories I think the is very extremely anti-semitic in its core so yeah absolutely and it's

1:05just it's just generally anti- meritocratic so which I think is very dangerous you want to have a I think a society where you succeed based on your skills and hard work and that's it and it doesn't matter about your race gender Creed religion nothing you know just are you good at your job do you work hard are you you have high do you have high integrity nothing wrong that's it stops there and it seems it seems as though you know in our society right now there's an objection to that but that objection it seems to me can only be this crazy Su yeah it can only be sustained if you are tactically acknowledging that you will not succeed in the meritocracy the people who are

1:49pushing this the hardest ping frankly yeah I mean it's it's it's essentially making the argument I'm not succeeding the reason I'm not succeeding is because no one can succeed and so it's an argument to a certain extent of the unsuccessful or people who feel as though they are they deserve more and you know one of the one of the things that that occurs to me is that I'm not sure that anybody quote unquote deserves anything other than what your hard work and Innovation bring you in life right I think Dei also for for those who were were promoted based on their skills and Merit and hard work it undermines the the The credibility of their promotion

2:23or their status was it real or was it Dei you know and it's it it takes away the the the respect that they deserve one of the things about meritocracy that I think people forget is that it's the only system ever devised that has positive externalities any any other any other sort of system that you create is going to have negative externalities because you're literally just croning with ex group and whatever that group is that group is going to get the benefits and if you're not part of that group then you get screwed meritocracy is the idea that the people who are going to succeed are people who innately are capable of creating for everyone else I

2:57mean you mentioned earlier how many employees you have and people will talk about your level of personal wealth but that level of personal wealth is largely stockholding and that stock is in almost entirely stock yeah exactly I mean it's not you're sitting on like a giant somewhere I mean you are but not like that yeah it's just just when I created the companies I felt that it was important now in my first company I didn't have any money my first internet company I just had $100,000 student debt but for that was company in the very early days the internet CS up too but for for old companies subsequently I I basically doubled down I I took the

3:33money that from from zip2 invested it in x.com PayPal and took the PayPal money invested that in in in creating Tesla and SpaceX because I I didn't feel like I didn't feel right that I should ask investors to invest if I was not prepared to invest my own money I I think the whole other people's money thing is not right you know you want to you want to have you want to have SC in the game and put your Capital where you're of the capital of the company you're creating there with Investor's Capital and as a result of that I own a lot of shares in the company and the company as the better the company does the more valuable the shares are but that's because the p has

4:17grown and and so you have to say like what's at the root of a lot of the the negativity is is an axiomatic flow that the pi is static that it's a zero some game that if someone else succeeds it's because they took more than their fair share of this fixed P but it's not a fixed pie obviously the the the

4:40there's a lot of now I want some [Laughter] pie pie but but obviously the economic Pie has grown considerably from from what it was in the past the output of good and services the productivity per person is dramatically greater than it has been in the past so when you when you create a new company and you and you build create new products and services you you're growing the the the groups you're growing the you know the bundle has say pie again of of you're you're you're growing the amount of goods and services available to to people so it's it's

5:27not you've not taken anything away from anyone you've created something new and you've you've given people new products and services they didn't have before you know like we we didn't used to have an iPhone we didn't used to have computers we don't used to have cars or be be able to fly in airplanes wouldn't used to have many of the life-saving medicines that we have today these are all new things I'm sure you realize how good I look how well I feel well the very video you're watching right now was something that we had just shot over in Poland a few days ago most people get sick when they travel abroad but not us because we use balance of nature seriously I actually

6:04saw producers act just gobbling those things down on the plane ride on the way back balance of nature fruits and veggies are the most convenient way to get whole food ingredients every single day balance of nature uses in advanced called vacuum process that encapsulates fruits and veggies into Whole Food supplements without sacrificing those natural antioxidants the capsules are completely void of additives fillers extracts synthetics pesticides added sugar the only thing in balance of Nature's fruit and veggie capsules are you know like the fruits and veggies right now not only will my listeners get 35% off your first order you'll get a free fiber and spice supplement as well

6:35balance of Nature's fiber and spy supplement is a revolutionary fiber drink with a unique blend of 12 spices and Whole Foods there's never been an easier way to make sure that you're getting your daily dose of fruits and vegetables experience balance of nature for yourself today go to balance of nature.com use promo code search for 35% off your first order as a preferred customer plus get a free bottle of fiber and spice that's balance ofn nature.com promo code search for 35% off your first preferred order plus that Free bottle of fiber and spice this is one of the I think this is the fundamental distinction between innovators and business people and people in the free

7:04market and and the political class the political PL class operates almost solely on the basis that the pi is fixed because if the pi is fixed then the way that you get elected is by promising more of that pi to such and such a person or you promise that by seizing money from the private sector you're personally going to grow the pie and it seem it seems to me if the the the first Mark of a politician you shouldn't listen to is I can fix all of your problems and that basically rules out nearly everybody because it seems like everyone in the political class is into the I can fix all of your problems when it seems like what I actually need is people who are entrepreneurial and

7:37Innovative to solve this problem in front of me so that we can then you know move on to the next problem that's in front of them yeah basically the reality is that when that is that the government is really just a corporation in the limit government is the ultimate Corporation it's not different from a corporation it's just the ultimate Corporation and it's a corporation that is Monopoly and and and also it can't go bankrupt unless the country goes bankrupt and has a monopoly on violence so how much do you want to how much more do you want to give to the world the world's biggest corporation that have that has Monopoly on violence probably not probably less

8:18and I mean if you look at say countries like eastn West Germany or North and South Korea cases where there's just an arbitrary line that's been drawn like could used to be one country arbitrary line is drawn because of a war what is the productivity difference from one to the other

8:39you know West Germany had a productivity five times greater than East Germany that that's just and it's not like West Germany was just B the sort of Bastion of capitalism they're like half socialist so even with if you so so what that means if they have socialist and the other side is is 100% socialist or communist then you really have something like a 10 to1 difference in productivity if something is done by the government or done by the private sector that's why you but I'm not someone who says abolish the government I just say let's have the government do the least amount because the less the government does the more the economy will prosper because anything done by

9:19the government it's going to be five to time time five to 10 times less efficient but like think of the DMV I'm I'm trying not to yes what if we're going to get out of Dei what's the best way to get out of Dei well I I I think Dei is starting to fade first of all di is actually illegal because it discriminates on the basis of of race sex sexual

9:47preference and and all all sorts of other things that is actually illegal so somehow you know it's got they've managed to get this illegal thing in place but now we're starting to see a large number of lawsuits saying no actually the law says you cannot discriminate on the basis of sex you know sexual identity and race you know so I think we'll I think the is on

10:17its last legs it's going to it's going to be removed because it's illegal actually

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份