一千个人共用的二十二个厕所
本·夏皮罗(Ben Shapiro)坐在波兰一间临时演播室里,开口没讲感受,先报了一串数字。
他刚从奥斯维辛-比克瑙(Auschwitz-Birkenau)营区回来,同行的是埃隆·马斯克(Elon Musk)。两人周六夜里飞抵波兰,周日进的营区。这趟行程由欧洲犹太人协会(European Jewish Association)安排。每年一月,他们都在这里办一场活动,纪念奥斯维辛被解放的日子。1945 年 1 月,苏军进入那片营地。
比克瑙留下来的砖砌营房已经站了八十年。当年设计时,一格铺位装三个人。后来装六个、七个。整片营区最初按容纳一两百人的规模规划,实际关进去一千人。一千个人共用二十二个厕所。在毒气室建成、这里还没变成纯粹的死亡工厂之前,死亡率已经到了百分之二十五。整个二战期间,九十六万犹太人在比克瑙被杀害。
奥斯维辛集中营区其实是一张网,四十来个营地摊在周边,有劳动营,有灭绝营。比克瑙是其中规模最大的那一块,占了数百英亩。纳粹撤离前炸掉、推平了大部分建筑,想抹掉痕迹。留下来的这批砖房,是没来得及毁掉的部分。
夏皮罗说他从没来过,马斯克也没来过。两人跟着导览走过那道铁门,门楣上挂着那句标语:劳动带来自由。那是谎话。这里通向的自由,是死亡。
夏皮罗年轻时帮一位大屠杀幸存者整理过回忆录,那位老人真的在奥斯维辛-比克瑙待过。他说,书上读到的和脚下踩到的完全是两件事。营区是空的,砖房是空的,人早就不在了,但走在里面,那个东西还在。
一间堆满行李箱的房间
奥斯维辛有一间房,里面堆满了行李箱。夏皮罗在节目里专门讲了这间房。
每一个提着行李箱走进这里的人,都以为自己最终会打开它。欧洲的犹太人一步一步退,每一步都以为下一步不会发生,一直退到毒气室门口。
所以当有人批评当年的人为什么不反抗,问题该换一个问法:他们该在哪一步相信,不可想象的事情已经成真了?
“不可想象”这个词本身就藏着问题。在它成真之前,它就是不可想象的。
夏皮罗在飞往波兰的飞机上读德国犹太人维克多·克莱普勒(Victor Klemperer)的日记。克莱普勒住在德累斯顿,靠写日记熬过了整个二战,一直活到战后东欧被苏联控制。日记里,他一路都以为事情可能会好转,会逆转。哪怕最绝望的时候,他也想不到结局会是这样。
人心能生出的恶没有上限。恶需要意识形态来遮住脸。这是夏皮罗想说的第一件事。
营区里还有另一处地方,是把齐克隆 B(Zyklon B)第一次投入使用的地下室。这种毒剂最初用在苏军战俘身上做试验,后来才成了针对犹太人的大规模灭绝工具。技术手段的演进是有台阶的,每一级台阶都不高,加起来就是一套工业化的杀人流程。
反犹主义的内核,是一套权力阴谋论
要读懂奥斯维辛-比克瑙,得先读懂欧洲的反犹传统。夏皮罗给的解释很直接。
反犹主义的内核,是一套关于权力的阴谋论。翻希特勒写的东西,翻比他早五六十年那些反犹小册子,看到的是同一个模板:每个行业的顶层都是犹太人,他们串成一个阴谋集团,他们的权力来路不正,是用某种扭曲手段偷来的,所以必须被清除。
这里有个细节要说清楚。反犹分子很快发现,拿宗教当理由站不住脚。战前欧洲很多行业的领头人根本不是虔诚的犹太教徒,他们按血统算犹太人,可很多人已经改信新教,甚至天主教。
于是说法转向了种族。犹太人在柏林、华沙这些大城市的主要行业里占比偏高,这被解释成一套权力理论:他们是剥削者,他们为自己改过规则,所以他们必须被消灭。
这套意识形态最阴暗的地方,在于它能自我辩护。你要杀的人,恰恰是真正的加害者,于是屠杀成了替天行道。
夏皮罗说,这种意识形态的诱惑力极强,也很容易复制。这不等于明天会再来一次大屠杀,没人这么认为。可把犹太人指认成加害者的那套叙事,今天活得好好的。
他还提醒了一件事:把奥斯维辛当成一个统计学意义上的异常值,是最舒服的处理方式,也是最危险的处理方式。它看起来是孤立的、疯狂的、脱离人类关系常轨的。实际上它只是一条几千年连续谱系的终点,一路可以追到《出埃及记》。法老说的话,希特勒 1935 年说的话,以及今天某些人说的话,结构完全一样:他们人数在增长,他们在攫取权力,他们对我们是威胁。
意识形态有分量。想弄明白奥斯维辛发生了什么,就得先弄明白那套意识形态怎么一步步长出来的。
买下 X,他就动了守门人的位置
夏皮罗在节目里花了不少篇幅讲一件事:三年前,媒体对马斯克是什么态度。
那时候他是宠儿,理由充分。他参与创建了 PayPal,此前自己做的 X.com 并了进去。他创办 SpaceX,把一家火箭公司做成承运全球九成载荷的企业,目标是让人类殖民火星,给文明留一条后路。他接手特斯拉,做成人类历史上利润率最高的车厂之一,靠的是自动驾驶背后那套 AI。他深度介入工程细节,连火箭用什么材料都要过问。
然后他买下了 X。
买下 X,他就动了守门人的位置。马斯克自己的解释只有一句:去看激励在哪里。
现实是,X 是传统媒体的竞争对手。人们现在去 X 上看最新消息、了解世界发生了什么。传统媒体是我们的直接竞争对手,他们会找各种角度去取消 X。你想弄明白一件事为什么发生,就去看激励在哪里。去年传统纸质媒体和有线电视的收视率下降了两三成,X 上升了差不多的幅度。这是对用户注意力的直接争夺。
夏皮罗补了一句:那些针对马斯克的攻击,无论包装成什么议题,骨子里跟议题无关。一个把三家公司做到世界级的人,突然被系统性描述成人类公敌,这个转折本身需要解释,而解释不藏在那些议题里。
多元化、公平与包容,和反犹主义几乎完全重叠
访谈正式开场,夏皮罗先问的是 DEI(diversity, equity, inclusion)。
他给这套意识形态的描述是:整个社会是一座巨大的身份金字塔,站在顶端的是成功者,成功者在剥削其他所有人。判断谁在顶端靠群体身份,个人成就在这套框架里被排除在外。
他说,这套东西和反犹主义几乎是韦恩图上两个完全重合的圆圈。
马斯克的回答很干脆:
任何听起来像是从乔治·奥威尔小说里蹦出来的名字,你都该警惕,这从来不是什么好兆头。多元化、公平、包容,每个词单拿出来都好听。可它真正的含义是按种族、按性别、按性取向搞歧视,是反精英的。所以我认为它从根本上就是反犹的。
他接着说,那几年发生在主要城市和大学校园里的骚乱,任何还有一点文明意识的人看了,都该被敲一下。
夏皮罗把逻辑链条铺得更完整。任何理论,只要声称原则只是权力的面具,声称有一小撮精英躲在系统背后,那么这套理论用在自由市场上,结论必然是:成功者都是加害者,加害者就该付出代价。用在言论自由上,结论是:说话的自由只是权力在说话。用在一个自由社会本身上,结论是:这个社会本身就是压迫机器。
这也解释了那些看起来奇怪的联盟。黑人平权组织为“巴勒斯坦”游行,社会主义者替地球上最不负社会责任的一群人站台,LGBT 群体声援一个一旦有机会就会把他们处死的地方。逻辑是通的,只要你接受那套权力框架:凡是被判定为被压迫的一方,就自动站在正确的一边。
夏皮罗强调,这种“权力藏在所有系统背后”的思路不独属于左派。右派也有它的变种,比如把资本主义说成全球主义富人的工具。DEI 只是这套思路目前最完整、也最有攻击性的版本。
顺着这条线往下走,还有一个更彻底的说法:市场不重要,言论不重要,程序不重要,唯一真实的东西是权力分配。这套说法一旦被接受,讨论就结束了。剩下的问题只剩一个:谁该被清算。
弱者不等于正确
马斯克在访谈里讲了一段话,夏皮罗后来反复引用。
我们真的需要停掉“弱的一方永远正确”这条原则。你被压迫,你是弱的一方,不代表你就是对的。如果有些更弱的群体想把你消灭掉,那也不能说明他们是好的。我们得去掉这条规则:只要你更弱,你就自动是善的。这显然说不通。通常来说,别去打比你弱小的人,这话有道理。可如果那个更小的群体想杀了你,那他们就是坏的。
我是个道德绝对主义者,不是道德相对主义者。有绝对的善,也有绝对的恶。你拿绝对道德标准去衡量任何群体和个人,别看他自称是被压迫者还是压迫者。就看他做的事,是不是想谋杀无辜的人。想谋杀无辜的人就是坏的,跟他属于哪个群体没有关系。
夏皮罗从这里接到了《圣经》。他说《圣经》里明确写着,如果你是法官,不能偏袒穷人,也不能偏袒富人。为什么连穷人都不能偏袒?因为品德和财富之间没有必然联系。他认识品德很好的穷人,也认识品德很好的富人,同样认识两边都不怎么样的人。
左派的前提是:穷人永远值得偏袒。这个前提一旦成立,整条推论就锁死了。如果弱者天然有德,那么是这套系统让他们变弱的,系统必须被推倒,维护系统的人必须被清除。
这条逻辑一路推到底,终点就是奥斯维辛。
把这一段和营区里那些砖房放在一起看,会发现一个残酷的对称。纳粹那套理论里,犹太人被定义为隐藏的强者,是一切的幕后黑手;今天某些理论里,犹太人被定义为压迫者阶级,是必须被清算的一方。位置换了,句式没换。
他至今戴着那条项链
2023 年 10 月 7 日之后,马斯克去了以色列。他去了那些被哈马斯烧毁的村庄。那天一千二百人被杀害,二百四十人被掳走,至今仍有近百人在押。
他到现在还戴着那条项链,纪念被绑架的人质。
同一时间,西方街头有人在游行支持哈马斯。夏皮罗问马斯克怎么看“Queers for Palestine”,也就是 LGBT 群体声援一个一旦掌权就会把他们从楼上扔下去的地方。
答案还是回到 DEI。只要你相信存在一套必须被推倒的权力体系,那么和这套体系里的任何“被压迫者”站在一起,就自动正确,哪怕对方的纲领是杀光你。这套思路和反犹主义交汇得极快,因为反犹主义的全部内容就是:有一群人,按血缘、按族群、按宗教被判定拥有不成比例的权力,因此他们就是压迫者。
夏皮罗提了一个数字。哈佛-哈里斯(Harvard-Harris)去年的一项民调里,十八到二十四岁这个年龄段,百分之六十七的人把犹太人归为“压迫者阶级”。
意识形态是有后果的,而且后果是致命的。
社区笔记是言论自由的配套设施
夏皮罗问的另一个问题很直接:把话说开,是不是等于把仇恨言论也放开了?
平台整体的偏向是支持言论自由的,我认为最终言论自由会赢。如果有人说了假话,尤其是在我们的平台上,你可以直接回复去纠正他。我是社区笔记极其坚定的支持者,我们把最多的资源和注意力放在这上面。如果有人试图散布像否认大屠杀这样的谎言,他可以立刻被纠正。
X 最初被设计成一个城镇广场,后来变成一小撮自封的道德警察的属地,他们不允许你说真话。把奥弗顿窗口(Overton window)重新拉开,代价是坏话也会多起来,同时纠错机制也被建了起来。
这一点放在奥斯维辛的语境下格外重。夏皮罗说,信息流通被切断,恶就会成倍繁殖。切断信息来源,等于给虚假信息腾地方。虚假信息既会误导公众对世界上正在发生的坏事的判断,也会让真正有权势的人随意操纵叙事。
他用了一个更形象的说法:把奥斯维辛当成例外,是因为它的规模太不可想象,所以我们习惯把它从人类关系的连续性里摘出去。摘出去之后,它就不再是警示,只剩一段历史。可它本来是警示。
那个行李箱房间里有几百个箱子,每一个上面都写着名字和地址。它们的主人以为战争结束后还能凭这些信息找回自己的东西。这些箱子今天还在原地,主人一个都没回来。
加沙的孩子,从会说话起就被教了什么
访谈里有一段专门讲加沙的教育。夏皮罗说那边没有信息流通,灌输和错误教育会把世界带向更糟的地方。
加沙孩子的教育,把仇恨灌输给加沙孩子这件事必须停下来。我在以色列的时候,这是我给出的首要建议。我理解进入加沙的必要性,很不幸会有无辜的人死去,这没办法避免。最重要的事情是确保之后,那种从孩子刚能听懂话就教他们目标是杀死以色列人的灌输不再继续。如果一个人从蹒跚学步起就被这样告知,他就会相信。这件事必须停下来。
这段话和前面那条线接上了。先把一套关于权力的阴谋论装进孩子脑子里,再把加害者和受害者的位置倒过来,然后用教育系统把仇恨固化进下一代。奥斯维辛是这条谱系某一端的终点,起点在别处,在很平常的地方。
夏皮罗说,理解奥斯维辛需要懂德国史、懂欧洲史、懂欧洲的反犹传统。核心只有一条:意识形态是实在的东西,坏的意识形态会杀人。理解西方当前面临的威胁,同样需要先理解那些有害的、错误的、确实邪恶的意识形态。
他家里还留着那些信
夏皮罗在节目结尾讲了一段私人的事。
他的大家族里,很多人在大屠杀期间死在这片土地上。家里还留着当年东欧亲戚写给他祖母的信,写在大屠杀前夜。他父亲这边的祖母,失去了大家族里很大一部分人。
他说,光是飞进这片区域,情绪上就已经很难扛。走进奥斯维辛更难,也更让人恐惧。做完这一切,再和马斯克坐下来对话,那种感觉很复杂。
他对马斯克的评价是:一个天生的解决问题的工程师,看事情有非常分析性的框架。这个框架让他既敢冒险,也能一眼判断出什么时候一个问题真的是问题,然后知道怎么解。所以他的道德判断往往出奇地清楚。这和媒体塑造出来的那个人完全是两回事。
夏皮罗今年四十岁。他说,他这一辈子,西方面临的意识形态威胁从没有像现在这么大。
他成长的环境里,美国是一个极宽容、极开放的地方,人们有成功的自由,精英主义是默认规则。现在有人在系统性地反对这套东西,编造左右两翼各种奇怪的阴谋论:把自由市场里的成功者说成靠操纵政府获利的人,把自由市场本身说成问题,把精英主义说成问题,把某些群体指认成对大众的威胁。
他说,这种事情在他活着的时间里没有发生过。来奥斯维辛,是想提醒自己,恶的意识形态最终要付什么账。
五条能直接拿来用的判断
整期节目看下来,最值得带走的东西在后面那几条判断上。
第一,判断一套说法,别只看它的名字。名字越好听,越要去看它的实际操作。多元化、公平、包容,三个词都无害,可它真正推行的样子是按族群分配奖惩,是把个人成就替换成身份标签。马斯克那句话值得记下来:任何听起来像从奥威尔小说里蹦出来的名字,你都该警惕。
第二,警惕任何把“弱者”和“正确”划等号的论证。强弱是事实判断,对错是道德判断,两件事之间没有必然通路。一旦把它们捆在一起,接下来的每一步都是滑坡:因为他弱,所以他被系统压制;因为系统压制他,所以系统有罪;因为系统有罪,所以维护系统的人该被清除。
第三,判断一件事为什么发生,去看激励。这是马斯克解释传统媒体攻击 X 时用的方法,也是他自己做决策的方法。一个组织说什么不重要,它靠什么活着才重要。传统媒体去年收视下降两三成,X 上升两三成,这个数字放到一起,后面所有关于“反犹”“危害言论环境”的指控,都要重新掂量一遍。
第四,信息封闭的地方,恶会长得特别快。这是夏皮罗在奥斯维辛和加沙之间画的那条线。一个地方如果只有一种说法流通,这种说法无论多荒谬,都会变成常识。反过来,允许说话、允许纠错的地方,坏东西传播得慢一些。
第五,意识形态可以杀掉几十万人到几百万人。这句话听起来像修辞,可它是字面意思。九十六万人在比克瑙被杀,杀他们的人里面,很多在战前是普通文员、工人、父亲。让他们变成刽子手的,是一套先让他们相信自己站在正义一边的理论。
营区里最让人后背发凉的从来都是这一点:这件事的参与者是普通人,规模大到需要铁路时刻表、需要建筑图纸、需要化学工业配合。所有这些环节,都由正常人完成。他们下班回家,吃饭,听音乐,陪孩子。第二天接着上班。
可以立刻做的事
- 如果有机会去波兰,把奥斯维辛-比克瑙排进行程。留半天时间,走完比克瑙那批砖房,看一眼那间堆满行李箱的房间。有些东西必须亲眼看一次才成立。
- 读一本大屠杀亲历者的日记。夏皮罗提到维克多·克莱普勒的战时日记,读的时候别盯着惨状,要盯住一个人如何在每一步都以为“还不会到那一步”。这种心态比惨状更值得研究。
- 下次看到任何一套“谁在压迫谁”的叙事,先做一道替换题:把里面的族群名字换掉,看这套逻辑是否还成立。如果换掉之后依然成立,它讲的其实是权力结构,不是事实。
- 在社交媒体上遇到明显造假的内容,写一条纠错回复,或者给一条社区笔记投一票。纠错机制自己不会转,它靠人喂。
- 对任何名字听起来很好的政策或项目,去查它的具体执行条款,别只看宣传语。名字和内容对不上的时候,内容才是真的。
- 跟孩子讲历史的时候,别只讲结果,讲过程。讲每一步的退让是怎么发生的,讲当时的人怎么说服自己“不会的”。理解过程的人,才不会在下一个过程里当旁观者。
0:00we are broadcasting today here from CRA out Poland flew in here on Saturday night arrived on Sunday night so we could visit alitz with Elon Musk we were invited by the European Jewish Association every year they do an event here at aitz around the liberation of aitz is the time of year that aitz was liberated in 1945 and I have to say aitz is an insane experience I've never been there before I know that Elon hasn't been there before either and we were walking the grounds together obviously being given a tour by a tour guide and you know for those who have seen images of the Holocaust which I would assume is pretty much everyone although by poll numbers
0:39apparently not for for those who have seen movies about the Holocaust seeing the actual structures where Mass death was brought upon the Jewish people as well as Roma homosexuals Russian soldiers it's an astonishing demonstration of the darkness that is present and possible inside the human soul and just first general impressions of what it's like there and you know for those who have not visited it it is worth to visit because I think that we tend to live very easy lives thank God in the West in the modern era we we we tend to you know look around us and see people who are generally good people who who generally believe in non-evil things and then you go to a place like ashit
1:25and you realize that it actually is not all that Unthinkable for the unthinkable to happen so first we visited ASW which is a much smaller area of the actual death camps than than the death camp footprint actually is the death camp footprint includes the aitz complex includes some 40 different camps around work camps death camps the ashz complex the center of it where you see that famous fence the arbit fry the work will make free which of course was a lie the freedom was murder you see that when you walk in and then you walk into various building buildings brick structures that had originally been built as actual barracks and that were then turned into these
2:06hell holes where they would hold a thousand people in a space that was maybe meant to hold a 100 couple hundred at best 22 toilets for a thousand people where the death rate in the early days before they were turned into fullscale death camps was already 25% you walk into the areas where prisoners were executed you see the the basement structures where zeyon B was first tried against Russian PS before it was then turned into a tool of mass extermination against predominantly the Jews 960,000 Jews killed at ashz birkenau during World War II you're walking all this and it is the lowest of what Humanity has to offer obviously then you go over to burkau
2:46which is even more astonishing because burkau is the actual Camp complex that was meant to hold tens of thousands of human beings and it expands for well must be hundreds of Acres it's it's an extraordinarily large complex they've preserved many of the structures most of the death camps were blown up by the Nazis destroyed by the Nazis and plowed under by the Nazis in an attempt to hide up what they had done as broken now obviously survived when it was liberated and so these structures are now 80 years old and they are basically brick HS in
3:18which you see bunks stacked one on top of another that are incredibly small were originally designed by the evil architects of the Holocaust to hold three people at a time and then were eventually expanded to hold six seven people at a time I had the privilege when I was younger of helping to write the Memoirs of a holocaust Survivor who'd actually gone through ashit burkan now and the stories obviously are horrifying now you walk it and it's empty obviously and you know you can you can feel the darkness of the place pretty clearly and I think that you know I think that Elon obviously saw it well as well because I I don't think that you can walk through that place and and not
3:57see the the darkness inherent there and I think I think that there there are a bunch of important things to be gained from doing something like walking aitz burken now I think the first is to realize that people can be made to believe nearly anything and this holds true on the side of both the evil people and and the people who are victimized by by those who were evil one of the things that you see when you walk through asit itself the the actual complex is you see a room that's just filled with suitcases and every person who brought a suitcase to ashit thought they were going to end up unpacking that suit case step by step by step European jury thought that
4:34whatever was next couldn't be this all the way until the final step into the gas Chambers and so when we criticize people for not having fought back at what point were they supposed to believe that the unthinkable was now thinkable because the unthinkable is Unthinkable until precisely the moment that it becomes real and it's a cautionary note to to people who don't take the world seriously don't take politics seriously that we all ought to be at a certain level attempting to read tea leaves now it can read too deeply can be too catastrophic about politics and I think it's very easy to fall into that when you doom scroll on various social media
5:07services but it is also important to recognize that as we're flying to Poland I was reading the Memoirs of of Victor cler who's a German Jew who lived in Dresden actually and he kept these Memoirs all the way through World War II he ended up living past World War II and into the Soviet domination of Eastern Europe and every step of the way in his
5:28memoirs he seems to think well maybe things are going to be okay maybe maybe this will reverse itself and even when he becomes despairing he never thinks that it's going to turn to this and there is very little limit to the evil that can be created in the human heart that evil can only be masked by ideology ideology absolutely matters it absolutely matters to truly understand what happened in Ash berken now you have to understand German history and European history you have to understand European anti-Semitism and and the first and most fundamental thing to understand about anti semitism in the modern era which again if you're at Ash Burk now
6:02that's what you have to talk about the the first and most fundamental thing to understand about anti-Semitism is that at root it is a conspiracy theory about power when you read the writings of Hitler when you read writings that precede Hitler by 50 60 70 years anti-semitic writings when you read these writings what you see is that there's a conspiracy theory about Jews this conspiracy theory is that the powerful in every industry are Jewish that they are part of an evil conspiracy and that the only reason that they have gained power is through some sort of perverse machination and that therefore they must be extrap they must be destroyed now there's a recognition that
6:34it can't be religious jewry because it turns out that the people at the head of many Industries in pre-war Europe are not religious Jews they're Jewish by ethnicity but they're not practicing many of them were converts to protestantism or even Catholicism but because Jews were disproportionately represented at the top of so many major industries particularly in major cities around Europe they represent a heavy percentage of places like Berlin like Warsaw because of that there's a theory of power and the the the of power suggested they were the exploiters that they had rigged the system on their own behalf and that therefore they had to be destroyed and that ideology a
7:08self-justifying ideology whereby the people you're about to kill are actually the true victimizers which is why of course they have to be killed and that particular ideology is so seductive and it's so easy to replicate doesn't mean the Holocaust is going to be replicated tomorrow I don't think anybody thinks that the Holocaust is going to be replicated tomorrow God forbid but the ideology that bre reads the victimization of Jews among other subgroups that ideology is very much alive well and with us and I think one of the things that we tend to see when we see places like Al burken now is the the extent of the horror is so Unthinkable and so unimaginable that it
7:46means that we tend to cut it off from the rest of sort of human relations we tend to think okay this is an outlier it's just this crazy statistical outlier when in reality it is just the culmination of a Continuum of theory that has been present on Earth for literally thousands of years going all the way back to the Book of Exodus the same things that Pharaoh is saying about the Jews that they're rising in numbers and power that they're a threat to us that same stuff is being repeated by Hitler in 1935 and it's being repeated by some people today ideology absolutely matters and to understand what happened in Ash bur now you have to understand the
8:19ideology to understand the threats to the West you have to understand ideologies that are pernicious wrong and yes evil so Elon and I visit asid we visit berkin now and then we end up going over to the local Double Tree hotel which is where the eja actual event is taking place and I had the the privilege of interviewing Elon on stage now first of all I should tell you I think that Elon is an incredibly good-hearted person you know having met him this is the first time I met him in person but we've we've spoken before obviously having having dealt with him Elon is by nature a problem solving engineer it's the thing that he does it's what's made him world famous he's a
8:57person who solves problems so he sees things through a very analytic frame and that analytic frame means that he's both a risk taker and also somebody who I think is pretty cleare eyed about when a problem is a problem and how to solve that problem that leads him to a shocking level of moral Clarity like TR truly I think that that elon's understanding of of morality is instinctively very it's it's
9:25instinctively quite good which is obviously very different than the media is telling you what the media are telling you about Elon the Legacy Media they they have a stake in degrading Elon as as a human being largely because Elon threatens their frame Elon is obviously both a product and a creator of the free market Elon is Rich which according to many of the media makes him inherently bad Elon is somebody who's a free speech Advocate which according to the media again makes him bad because he doesn't gatekeep the way they would like for him to gatekeep or the way that they gatekeep and so they've been targeting him on a wide variety of issues nearly
10:00all of which I think are are fully specious I'm going to get to the discussion that I had with Elon in just one second first let's talk about something lighter how you hire so obviously we have a company here at Daily wire we are very concerned with finding the best people on planet Earth to work at our company to meritocracy here well one of the best ways that we have found to actually fill all of our employment positions is through zip recruiter according to Forbes January is the hottest month for hiring business owners and hiring managers are on the hunt for top talent which is no easy task if you're currently hiring you can probably relate it's challenging to find
10:31qualified candidates that's why you need zip recruiter zip recruiter's powerful matching technology finds the right people for your roles fast and right now you can try it for free at ziprecruiter.com dailywire immediately after you post your job ZipRecruiter smart technology will start showing you candidates whose skills and experience match it to encourage top candidates to respond to your job post even sooner zi recruit will let you send them a personal invite to apply as you rate candidates zip recruiter sends you more of the ones you like from the thousands of new job Seekers who join the site this month find the talent you need to fill all of
10:59your roles with zip recruiter see for yourself why four out of five employers who post on zip recruiter get a quality candidate within the first day just go to this exclusive web address right now try zip recruiter for free that's ziprecruiter.com dailywire again ziprecruiter.com dailywire ZipRecruiter is the smartest way to hire he so back to this visit we sat down together and we had a wide- ranging conversation about various topics including some of the ideologies that lead to evil action one of the things that we discussed at Fair length was diversity equity and inclusion and Dei which of course sounds very happy face Dei is the basic thesis that
11:36again the world is driven by power dynamics that virtually every system is a power dynamic system that free speech is actually just a standin for power that free markets are stands in for power that those who are successful in these systems are actually perpetuators of the system for their own exploitative power that is a dangerous Theory by the way that that theory not diversity Equity inclusion but the idea that power lies behind all systems EX exist on the right as well it's not unique to the left it it materializes in racial ways on the left it materializes in sort of bizarre populist class ways on the right the idea that for example capitalism is
12:09a tool of the globalist rich right that sort of nonsense exists on all sides of the political aisle but Dei which is the most threatening version of this form particularly on the political left it helps explain why for example you see a giant Coalition of people who are pramas and one of the things that I asked Elon about was the fact that in the aftermath of October 7th and Elon of course visited Israel after October 7th he visited the areas in which Mass Slaughter of Jews leftwing Jews by the way took place in Israel by Hamas he still wears the necklace in honor of the people who were kidnapped by Hamas and who are still being held in captivity and and you see people in
12:47the west marching on behalf of members of Kamas and so I asked him about that because obviously the only rationale for queers for Palestine for example LGBT people who are suggesting that they have solidarity with people who would literally murder them first chance they got in the Gaza Strip is this Dei theory that there's a system of power that must be torn to the ground and that crosses streams very strongly with anti-Semitism because after all if you're making the case that there's a group of people with disproportionate power along racial lines ethnic lines religious lines and that they are therefore the the oppressors and the exploiters that
13:23crosses streams very quickly with anti-Semitism which is why by the way a Harvard Harris poll that we discussed last year found that 67% of those aged between 18 and 24 called Jews an oppressor class and ideology matters folks and it has deadly consequences we'll get to the actual discussion with Elon in just one second first if you're like me there's not a day that goes by that you don't call or text somebody that you actually care about my friends at P talk are making it easier and more affordable to connect with the most important people in your life P talk gives you phenomenal coverage on America's Most Dependable 5G Network it's the same coverage you know
13:53and love but for half the price of the other guys with unlimited plans starting just 20 bucks a month the average family will save almost $1,000 a year as a veteran-owned company P talk raises $10 million toward veterans debt last year alone what's more P Talk's customer service team it's located right here in the United States it can help you make the switch in as little as 10 minutes I made the switch years ago at this point and I got to tell you my coverage is excellent Pure Talk makes sure that I'm getting it at the best possible price and not only that they actually don't hate my guts in terms of values I challenge you to stand with a company
14:21that actually likes you and champions your values go to Pur talk.com Shapiro right now you'll save an additional 50% off your very first month of coverage that's Pur talk.com Shapiro save on wireless the company you can be proud to spend your money with again that's Pur talk.com Shapiro P talk.com switch over that phone coverage to a company that actually likes you okay so we sat down together and we started by discussing Dei here's what it sounded like the diversity equity and inclusion ideology that basically suggests that all of society is a vast pyramid of group identity and that at the very top are the people who are successful and that those people are
14:57exploiting every everybody else and we can tell who's Successful by their group identity not by their level of success by their group identity that matches up incredibly it syns up almost a v diagram ccle with anti-Semitism absolutely the diversity ex inclusion I you should always be always be wary of any name that sounds like it could come out of a George Orwell book okay that's never a good sign and because it sounds like sure diversity Equity inclusion these all sound like nice words but but there what what it really means is discrimination on the basis of race sex and sexual orientation and and
15:34and it's against Merit and and thus I think is fundamentally anti-semitic so yeah you know the I I I think the the the whole all of the sort of the the all all of the riots that were in the major cities and college campuses I think was a shocking wakeup call to I think any any any sort of civilization or civil minded person really now obviously I think elon's take on Dei is exactly right and it is dangerous because again any theory that suggests that principal is really just a mask for guyses of power and there is a Cod of elite people who are standing behind that system when you're talking about a free market system when you're talking about a free system for example
16:31or a free speech system when you make that suggestion what you're really suggesting is that anyone who is successful is a victimizer and as a victimizer they therefore ought to pay some sort of price this is why you see all these streams Crossing in the de left this is why you see black lives matter protesting for quote unquote Palestine this is why you see people who are socialists who are protesting on behalf of some of the least socially responsible people on planet Earth now Elon talked in those terms more broadly with regard to for example this sort of reversal of morality when it comes to weakness versus strength one of the things that we've been seeing in the
17:07modern world is this attempt to read strength as evil and weakness as virtue that is a that is a Despicable morality because it's not moral at all in fact it's directly anti-biblical the Bible specifically says that if you're a judge you are not allowed to favor either the poor or the rich why does the bible suggest that you're not allowed to favor the poor when the suggestion by the left is that you'll never favor the poor after Poor and Powerless the answer is because virtue and wealth are not necessarily connected I know very virtuous people who are poor I know very virtuous people who are rich and I know many people who are not virtuous who are
17:41both poor and and rich as well and that makes a difference when it comes to World politics and it makes a difference when it comes to the sorts of things that you stand if you believe that the weak are inherently virtuous then what that means is that the system itself has made them weak and the system must be torn down and the people who purport to uphold the system must be destroyed that's how all of this connects to visiting places like ashid bken now that conspiracy theory is very much alive and well here was Elon talking about weakness versus strength and morality well I I think we really need to to stop this principle that the the weaker no normally weaker party is
18:15always right this is simply not true if you are in qutes oppressed or or the weaker party it doesn't mean you're right because if some of those you know we weaker groups want to annihilate you that does not make them good we just we have to get rid of the rule that that if you're weaker you're automatically good that's that's obviously makes no sense you know you know it often makes sense where it's like okay you don't want to beat up on someone smaller and weaker than you but if that if that smaller group wants to kill you that they're they're bad okay I mean I'm a big believer in moral absolutism not moral relativism there is there's good and bad in the
19:07absolute and you judge any group or individual against absolute moral standards not whether they they're the so-called oppressed or oppressor just on absolute moral terms are they doing good things do they want to motor inent people that's bad it doesn't matter who they are in just a second I want to get to elon's perspective when it comes to free speech and X which of course has been used as a as a rationale by the media to attack Elon among others first I've been talking about Helix mattress for years I got to be honest with you I am missing my Helix Sleep mattress right now because I'm abroad I'm on the road I need the Helix Sleep mattress to get a
19:47good night's sleep it's just that simple I've had my Helix Sleep mattress for I don't know a decade at this point it is excellent It's the gift that keeps on giving because it was made just for me I took that two-minute Helix sleep quiz and it matched me with a mattress that was firm but breathable which is exactly what I need and it's exactly what I'm missing when I'm on the road well Helix Elite is their newest most high-end collection and harnesses years of extensive mattress expertise to offer a truly elevated sleep experience that Helix collection includes six different mattress models each tailored for specific sleep positions and firmness
20:15preferences head on over to helixsleep.com men check out the new collection today if you're nervous about buying a mattress online well you don't have to be because Helix has a sleep quiz that matches your body type and sleep preferences to the perfect mattress because why would you buy a mattress made for somebody else go to Helix sleep.com Ben you should take that 2 minutes Sleep p and get a mattress made for you Helix is offering 25% off all mattress orders two free pillows for our listeners start the year off right upgrade your sleep at helixsleep.com it's their best offer yet it's not going to last long that's helixsleep.com benen with Helix better sleep starts
20:45right now okay so then Elon and I discuss freedom of speech so one of the critiques of Elon and X is that when Elon bought X he opened it up he broadened the so-called Overton window the the the window of acceptable speech and Elon has tried to pursue the broadest possible speech that he believes is is legal right which makes sense because Twitter was originally founded to be a sort of town square and then it became Instead The Preserve of a select group of self-appointed moral police officers who would not allow you to say true things and so I asked him one of the critiques of that has been well aren't you going to allow more bad speech as well as good
21:24speech on X and that includes theoretically more anti-Semitic commentary on X and so I asked Elon about this and here's what he had to say how do you balance the necessity for free speech with with all these critiques about you know what is hate speech what is anti-Semitism and how do you balance that well the general bias
21:45of the platform is in favor of free speech and I think at the end of the day free speech wins and in that if somebody says something that's false it especially on our platform you can then reply to it with the correction and then I'm a huge fan of community notes I've put we've put maximum resources and attention behind Community notes so if somebody tries to push a falsehood like Holocaust denial or something like that they can immediately be corrected again it's elon's perspective on free speech that has made him a Persona nrata in many of the halls of of Power with regard to for example government and Legacy Media if you look back back forth three even years at
22:30elon's public profile elon's public profile was very much beloved of the media and for insanely good reason this is a person who has not built one or two but three of the biggest companies in world history he helped build PayPal he actually created a company called x.com that end up merging with PayPal which was time run by Peter theel so that was a huge company and then he founded on the back of that he invested his money into SpaceX and Tesla a rocket company with the goal of creating human colonization on Mars in order to broaden the scope of human survival and to make provision for the possibility of something bad happening on this planet
23:10which is just an amazingly audacious concept obviously and he actually has materialized that in the form of a profitable company that now carries 90% of global payload into space which is just amazing and insane and that that's that's crazy of course that's genius level stuff and Elon if you know anything about him has been deeply involved in every aspect of the Engineering Process I mean down to like what materials ought to be used in the rockets and all the rest so he builds that and then he builds Tesla right he works with somebody to to start Tesla and then he ends up taking it over and turning it into the most profitable car company in the history of man
23:49actually because it is largely based on the tech not just based on the sales of the car right the AI That's being generated in order to do things like self-driving is just insane makes life better and easy iier for tons and tons of people and so the media loved him right he was this entrepreneurial figure who had come out of basically nowhere and then he buys x and by buying X he threatens the the structures he he threatens the people who were The Gatekeepers in a second I'm going to bring you elon's answers to questions about what was going on with the Legacy Media why they've reversed course on him and why he's now the villain in their little morality play in just one second
24:21first think about your favorite childhood memory that you caught on film or videotape there's really not a great way to share that you've got that in the garage somewhere you got a bunch of film reels from your grandparents do you have like a film projector in your house and forget that when I was growing up we used to take everything on camcorder so you have like a VHS tape you had the little tapes you put it in like the the bigger tape block and then you had to like mess around with it and put in the VHS you don't have any of those things anymore why not get all those memories preserved in a form you can actually use this is why you should go check out
24:48Legacy box right now simply send Legacy box filled with camcorder tapes film reels and pictures you'll get back digital copies that can be easily enjoyed shared and organized it's like magic I've done it myself for my family several times at this point did it for my parents did it for my in-laws and it's amazing I mean it just brings the past to life again Legacy box is the world's largest digitizer they've helped over 1 million families relive their wedding days chaotic childhood Christmases even road trips to Yellowstone by going to legacybox.com Shapiro you can enjoy 50% off when you get started with Legacy box today kick off the Year by rescuing your family's
25:17most cherished memories that haven't been watched or enjoyed in years head on over to legacybox.com Shapiro save 50% buy today send it in when you're ready go to legacybox.com Shapiro that's legacybox.com Shapiro hey so I asked Elon yesterday about the Legacy Media and the gatekeeping function that they've performed and here's what he had to say about what he's trying to do over at X Legacy Media has spent an awful lot of Ink on you there's been a lot of attempts to paint you as anti-semitic or paint X as anti-semitic where do you think that's coming from why why why does the Legacy Media seem to have you particularly in the last year and a half
25:53in in the crosshairs so much well I mean the reality is that X is competition for the Legacy Media so you know X is a is where people go to get the most current news and learn about the world so leg you know the the Legacy Media is our direct competitors so they're really going to find try to every angle to try to cancel xan that's I mean if you want to know why things happening look at the incentives you know so and and Legacy Media had a tough time with respect to usage the numbers I saw was that the sort of traditional print
26:36cable television viewership went down something like 20 30% last year on the other hand X went up roughly the same roughly 20 30% so it's a direct competition for people's attention now a flow of information matters and one thing that that Elon I think is very clear on and was focused in I know specifically yesterday when we visited ashz was how free flow of information when cut off actually leads to the multiplication of evil that when you actually cut off the sources of information you can make room for misinformation that both misleads the public as far as the bad things that are happening in the world and also allows truly powerful people to manipulate the
27:20narrative and that's incredibly dangerous I asked him about this in the context of what's going on right now in the Gaza Strip because as I say Elon I think in in morally righteous fashion visited the villages that had been burned out by Kamas where 12200 people were killed 240 people were taken prisoner still almost 100 people being kept in captivity that is an ongoing war and and I asked Elon about the the fact that there is no informational flow in places like the Gaza Strip that in fact indoctrination and miseducation of young people can lead to a significantly worse World here's what he had to say about education in the Gaza Strip the education of kids in Gaza the the
28:02indoctrination of hate into kids in Gaza has to has to stop so I you know when I was in Israel I was like that was my top recommendation is like you got to make sure you know I understand the need for this to to invade Gaza and unfortunately some innocent people will die there's no way around it but the the the most important thing is to ensure that afterwards that the indoctrination where kids are taught from as soon as they can understand language that their goal is to kill Israelis and and if you're told that from when you were a toddler well you're going to believe it and that needs to stop overall it was just I'm still processing the day to be honest with you
28:52it's it was Heavy going in you know I I again I've never been to this particular part of the world I've spent years reading about it a lot of my extended like every Jew a lot of my extended family lost their lives in this part of the world during the Holocaust we have letters to my grandmother my my dad's mom from members of her family from Eastern Europe in the leadup to to the Holocaust and you know she lost large segments of her extended family over here and so even flying into the area is you emotional and difficult visiting Alit obviously is emotional and difficult and terrifying and all the things I mean it's it's all the things and then doing that with Elon Musk
29:37you know again in in a modern era looking at a world that sometimes can seem unbelievably dark I think I think it was an inspirational thing for for Elon go aitz I think that the conversation that we had was was important I think again that when we talk about the true dangers to the world particularly in the west right now the ideological dangers to the West are greater than they have been at any time in my lifetime I'm I'm relatively young I just turned 40 and in my lifetime I've been privileged to live in the free of society in world history America is an unbelievable place it's an unbelievable tolerant open place where people have the freedom to succeed where
30:16meritocracy is the rule of the day and as that is quashed and as people oppose that as people try to craft weird and bizarre left and right conspiracy theories about the inability of people to get ahead to blame the people who are successful in the free market not not by manipulating the levers of government successful in the free market to blame the free market itself to blame the meritocracy to suggest that there's there there exploitative groups that that are a threat to the the population that's something that I haven't experienced in my lifetime and so coming here being reminded of the wages of of evil ideologies and and coming here again with Elon I think good for Elon
30:55and it was an honor to be to be asked to to come and and do this event okay just one second I want to get to the New Hampshire primaries those of course are happening today I think the end of this road is a foregone conclusion I'll explain in just one second first the bench SP show is supported by Grand Canyon University an affordable private Christian University with a vibrant campus in beautiful Phoenix Arizona ranked top 20 in the country by niche.com GCU is a missional Christ centered University that strives to foster a culture of community giving and impact gcu's goal is to help you develop into a servant leader who makes a difference finding your purpose with
31:28330 academic programs over 270 online as of June 2023 GCU integrates the free market system with a welcoming chrisan worldview into your bachelor's MERS or doctoral degree find your purpose at Grand Canyon University private Christian affordable visit gcu.edu today also it's the signature razor from Jeremy's razors the Precision 5 you can get one handle plus one blade cartridge kit just 14.99 it's a magical razor it's crafted with a luxurious hungen handle five welded steel blades a Precision trimmer for a close smooth shave around hairlines and hards to reach places but remember that Precision five is not just a razor it's also a sword in the battle
32:05for beliefs it's a banner to wave into a new economy and also it's a razor that you can shave with the position five starts at $1499 with a price so low it has never been easier to stop giving your money to woke corporations that hate your guts join over 200,000 customers who've ditched those woke razors and switched to Jeremy head on over to Jeremy risers doc today meanwhile today marks the New Hampshire primary and this is basically Nikki Haley's last shot Nikki Haley has to win this outright if Nikki Haley finishes second to Donald Trump in New Hampshire then the race is over for her because they're going to head down to South Carolina and she's probably going to
32:34lose her home state to Trump by all available polling data Trump is well ahead of her in north in South Carolina but he also happens to be ahead of her in New Hampshire right there are some polls usually badly rated polls that that have Nikki Haley competitive in New Hampshire the latest polls that I've seen the ones that that real clear politics take seriously enough to put in their average all of those have Trump up pretty well ahead of Nikki Haley the latest traar poll has Trump up 5836 over Nikki Haley the Boston Globe suff poll has him up 5738 over Nikki Haley Insider Advantage has him at 6235 over Nikki Haley and again let's just be clear
33:13about this the Republican party wants Trump I mean it's just that simple now I may wish that things had gone differently I supported Ronda santis as as a voter if I had had a vote in the primaries I would have voted for governor Dan santis as I said he is the best governor in America I moved to Florida at least in part because Ronda santz had kept the state open because Ronda Sanz helped make Florida awesome and so having that level of governance extended to the federal government I think would have been great I think he would have been the best president of anybody in the pack the Republican voters did not agree and do not agree by polling data Republican voters want
33:45season n9ine of the Trump show they want to see Trump run again they want to see Trump beat Joe Biden they're looking at the polling data and what they are currently seeing is that Donald Trump is actually leading Joe Biden in a statistically significant way way the latest Harvard Harris poll has Donald Trump up 5347 over Joe Biden which is mostly fascinating because it means that Trump is actually breaking 50% in more than one poll at this point and by the way in their General sort of Republican primary polls and those ones are the ones that are you know being released after Dan sanis dropped out of the race we'll get to that in a second th those
34:16polls had Trump up in the Republican National primary by 60 plus points over Dan sanis in second and Haley in third the national polling numbers for Trump continue to be durable that is the reason why Trump is the nominee if Donald Trump were trailing Joe Biden by 10 points in all the polls and if Ronda Sans were beating Joe Biden by three points in all the polls I think this race looks totally different but basically since March the Republican base has been brought into line on Trump because of the unjust cases that are being brought against him in a wide variety of jurisdictions it feels like legal Espionage against the Trump campaign and Republicans get that and
34:50the way that they are fighting back against that is by saying let's give him the nomination I get that and you can see that in the polling data Beyond beyond that the fact that Trump has been durable against Biden takes away the chief baton that fellow Republicans could use against him for a brief moment in time November 2022 it seemed as though the Republican party was finally declaring that Donald Trump was likely to make them lose that he had lost in 2020 he had lost in 2021 in Georgia Senate races 2022 went really poorly and so 2024 why why do this thing again and then as Joe Biden began to sink slowly into the Meer it became clear to Republicans that actually Trump could
35:26win and if Trump can win there's no reason to nominate somebody else not only that a wide swath of Republicans believe that for good reasons and Ill that the 2020 election was not was not correctly decided that in fact Trump won or should have won or that the rules were changed in order to make Joe Biden win which actually is somewhat true some people believe what I think is not true proposition that it was just pure electoral fraud whatever it is Republicans are basically treating Donald Trump as an incumbent in this race and because he's incumbent in this race he's getting incumbent type numbers in this race well that that was made clear by the fact that Ronda Sanz
36:02dropped out of the race over the weekend here was governor D santis dropping out by the way this is the right move he did not have a path forward he did not have a path in New Hampshire he did not have a path in South Carolina getting out now makes sense now he's getting a lot of flak which we'll get to in a second for his campaign in the first place I think a lot of that flak is entirely misguided meaning that the theory of The Campaign which is that Republicans had basically gotten tired of all the Antics from Trump and ready to move to the next thing that wasn't false in January February it became false as Democrats targeted Trump for Destruction and Republicans rallied
36:34around Trump and so the fact that he ran against Trump I don't think that there's anything wrong with running against Donald Trump in the primaries and all all the kind of trump fans who were angry at other people for running against Trump why why especially because again it was a referendum Trump won the referendum that's the end of the story but the fact that that danis would have made I think a better president and more effective president than Trump was in his first term or would be in his second term again you can reject that that's fine but that doesn't mean that that Dan sance is anything wrong by running I also there mistakes that that Dan's
37:08campaign made for sure you can say about literally every non- Victorious campaign but were those mistakes the telling factor or was it just that by polling data 70% of Republicans really love Trump period end of story in any case here was D santis dropping out in doing so he endorsed Donald Trump for the presidency over Nikki K who has sort of become the because she's the only non-trump candidate left in the race she has become sort of the quote unquote candidate of the establishment which again is a little strange only in the sense that Nikki Haley was Donald Trump's un Ambassador it's like she's some sort of stranger to trumpism and she she may be more in line
37:45with I would say Bush era conservatism and she's softer in affect so much so much of Republican politics by the way is affect and Nikki Haley is actually to Donald Trump's right when it comes to economics matters right she she tends to be a little bit more free trade she tends to be more interested in reforming entitlements for example she's to his left maybe on social issues although unclear because Donald Trump himself has not made himself clear on social issues when it comes to say abortion or samex marriage she just is more Squishy in affect because she's more Squishy in affect that means that she's been tagged with the establishment label but
38:20DeSantis I think endorses Trump for good reason here and that is Trump is going to be the nominee so why would you endorse the candidate who's not going to be the nominee in the face of that here is here was governor Dan sis now following our second place finish in Iowa we've prayed and deliberated on the way forward if there was anything I could do to produce a favorable outcome more campaign stops more interviews I would do it but I can't ask our supporters to volunteer their time and donate their resources if we don't have a clear path to Victory accordingly I am today suspending my campaign I'm proud to have delivered on 100% of my my promises and I will not stop now it's
38:59clear to me that a majority of Republican primary voters want to give Donald Trump another chance they watch his presidency get styed by Relentless resistance and they see Democrats using law fair this day to attack him wife had disagreements with Donald Trump such as on the Corona virus pandemic and his elevation of Anthony fouchy Trump is superior to the current incumbent Joe Biden that is clear I signed a pledge to support the Republican nominee and I honor that pledge my endorsement because we can't go back to the old Republican guard of yester year now again the sort of old Republican guard talk is something I don't know who this old Republican guard is per se like some
39:40names would be useful whenever people talk about the old Republican Guard versus the new Republican guard I I'm just I mean Donald Trump was the president so he is the current Republican guard I mean period it's not as though Donald Trump is the wave of of the future Donald Trump is the Pres and also the past a little bit because he was the president just a few years ago and that was like 2016 it's now 2024 so for at least almost last decade Republican politics has been dominated by Trump in any case here was Donald Trump congratulating to Sanz before we begin I'd like to take time to congratulate Ronda santis and of
40:14course a really terrific person who had gotten to know his wife Casey for having run a great campaign for president he did he ran a a really good campaign I will I'll tell you it's not easy they think it's easy doing this stuff right it's not easy but as you know he left the campaign Trail today at 3pm and in so doing he was very gracious and he endorsed me so I appreciate it again it is amazing how Trump again what Trump thinks in the moment is what Trump thinks in the moment but he switches from Casey D sance is terrible and Ronda sance is terrible everybody's terrible Ronda sanctimonious and all to he r a great campaign in like this fast but
40:53that's what Trump has to do so Trump does need to consolidate the party behind him I think the party is consolidating behind him I think that's what's likely to happen in the New Hampshire primary today again the polling shows that he is well out ahead and if he were not to be the nominee that would be an act of God frankly at this point if there there there would have to be an act of God from not to be the nominee so the Republican party is going to consolidate as they should behind Donald Trump to be the person against Joe Biden we're going to run this thing back and we're going to do it all over again now there's one thing that's worth noting here in the media
41:22coverage of D santis dropping out there's a lot of scornful media coverage that's being dropped on STIs today for example I'm in meldon just a terrible commentator over on MSNBC but I repeat myself because again MSNBC is filled with terrible commentators it's like a giant Bread Basket filled with terrible commentators here's Imon meldon ripping on Ronda santis in his campaign Florida Governor Ron de santis the man once heralded as the future of the Republican Party the so-called era parent to the Maga movement bowing out of the race for president he suspends his campaign a short suspended his campaign a short time ago bringing an end to one of
41:59the most embarrassing and disastrous GOP Primary showings in modern American political history the move comes just two days before New Hampshire's primary contest where he was projected to Finish Well behind both former president Donald Trump and former un Ambassador Nikki Haley I mean they couldn't be happier so on the one hand I think this is a cautionary note for Republicans we'll see in a second Democrats are prepared to roll out their anti-trump strategy it's been their entire strategy for the past several years get Trump to be the nominee again then run against Trump and again be careful what you wish for politics is the monkeyy Paw what you
42:30wish for very often ends up being the curse against you but the amount of scorn they're pay they're pouring on to santis is demonstrative of the fact that they actually don't believe all the crap that they say about Trump when they say that Trump is the most threatening political figure in American history when they say that he's a hitlerian muselin ass figure when they say this sort of stuff they don't believe that thing if they believe that thing then presumably they would have been a lot more supportive of the chief Rivals to Donald Trump but they weren't they're more than happy to watch those people go down in flames for fun profit and political
43:02motivation and because to them all Republicans are the same and this is this is this is the thing that's so funny about Trump with all of the talk about how Donald Trump is out of the box and crazy and does wild stuff and and he does he does wild crazy stuff particularly on Twitter when when he does those things he is treated in the polling like generic R he is treated like generic Republican which is why his polling is nonii from the in terms of like against Jo Biden he runs kind of the same as Des santis haen runs a little bit ahead because I think the American public isn't as familiar with Haley and again she has that softer affect than Trump or dis Anis but if you
43:37look at Donald Trump's poll numbers in for example 2016 when you ran ran against Hillary they look almost exactly the same as Mitt Romney's poll numbers in 2012 when you look at his poll numbers in 2020 he performs like generic Republican maybe a little better in the rural areas and that is because the left treats him as generic Republican or to put it another way whoever the Republican nominee was he was going to be treated or she as the ultimate form of the Destroyer as the evil Destroyer because that's every election cycle with regards to the Legacy Media and with the Democrats okay so speaking of the the strategy that is going to be rolled out
44:11here by the Democrats one of the things they're going to try to do is jiujitsu a lot of critiques of Joe Biden into critiques of Donald Trump so the number one obvious critique of there really two critiques of Joe Biden one is that he's barely alive and the other is that he's a bad president it's very hard to argue with he's a bad president because he really is a very bad president he has been terrible domestically he has been pretty awful in terms of foreign policy I think worse in terms of foreign policy than he has domestically and so what the Democrats are going to focus on is try to defang the other prong of the attack right the scile and bad at the job they
44:46can't really argue bad at the job because he's not good at the job they can argue scile so you say to yourself wait how can they argue that Joe Biden is clearly non compos menes he's not functional anymore he just isn't I mean you watch him in public it's it's sad as an American I would like for our president to at least be able to speak full sentences without running the risk of of having a full-on physical collapse so what so Democrats have their response their response is yeah Trump is too that's going to be the response the response is that Trump is also somebody who is non- compos menus so they're basing this this week on a on an event that Trump was doing and Trump at least
45:23is doing events I mean Joe Biden's schedule looks like this wake up at 9:00 in the morning meeting at 10: security briefing at 10 noon one pre-planned event two lid for the day that that's what a day looks like for Joe Biden and then presumably it's back to the old age home for a little bit of of water aerobics and then some mat lock before they put him to sleep Trump's doing events but the other day Trump was doing a speech and he mixed up Nikki Haley and Nancy Pelosi for whatever reason here's what it sounded like by the way they never report the the crowd on January 6 you know Nikki Haley Nikki Haley Nikki Haley you know they do you know they destroyed
46:02all of the information all of the evidence everything deleted and destroyed all of it all of it because of lots of things like Nikki Haley is in charge of security we offered to 10,000 people okay so this is what we call a brain fart gu it doesn't mean he's insane it doesn't mean he doesn't know the difference he nany Pelosi and Nikki Haley and it that that's that's a brain fart and it happens all the time I mean again like you want to say that Donald Trump is in a state of decline you'd have to show me a market difference between Donald Trump 2016 and Donald Trump 2024 I don't actually see a giant market difference if I played you backtack tape of trump 2016 and Trump
46:392024 they look very similar if I played you back to back tape of of Joe Biden 2016 and Joe Biden 2024 they are radically different as much as I am not a Joe Biden fan Joe Biden at least used to be a person who was fluent with human verbiage he did not look as frail and and as tenuous as he does right now that's just a brain fart but the media decide that this is evidence that he's just as he's just as off his rocker and losing it just as in a state of decline as as Joe Biden is here was John Carl trying to make that case that moment which by the way the Biden campaign is already cut into an ad is really something Donald Trump is truly confused about who Nikki Haley is
47:19thinks somehow that she was in charge of security at the capital on January 6 clearly confusing her with Nancy closy but we've seen him confuse Joe Biden with Barack Obama he thinks that he beat Obama we saw at one point he talked about how Biden was going to get us into World War II so there there has been you know there there have been moments there have been moments and there have been several moments on the campaign Trail where where he has seemed quite frankly out of it again this attempt now to reverse polarity with regard to who's seen all and who's not I don't think that's going to play but this is what they have to do they're going to have to attack Trump on that
47:54and presumably they're going going to attack him on the criminal front now again I think that's baked into the cake so CNN's man Raju spend spends his day very often tracking down Republicans to comment on other Republicans it's a game that doesn't seem to be replicated with Democrats very often so when ilhan Omar says something deeply anti-semitic you don't see Manar Raju or members of the media tracking down every Democrat Senator and asking for their opinion when when Joe Biden does something truly a inspiring a inspiringly stupid you don't see a rush to Capitol Hill to get comment from every Democratic senator but menar Raju decided to go ask a bunch
48:30of Republican Senators if they would still vote for Trump if you were convicted criminally and there's sort of various answers to this the most obvious answer is well yes he's the Republican nominee against Joe Biden a criminal conviction would not change the underlying opinion as to what he did or did not do like I I can think all the things I think about Donald Trump and his shortcomings in terms of character and still recognize for example that the fanny Willis Case is crap that it doesn't make any sense that the Jack Smith January 6th case is a legal stretch Beyond nearly all imagination but in any case this is you know this this is the the campaign the
49:06campaign is going to be for the Democrats about how Trump is really kind of losing it and also is a criminal I mean good luck with this pitch I don't think it's going to work all that well if he could be convicted before November would you still support him then well is his opponent still Joe Biden yes I I would absolutely support him before then kevinr even if he's convicted it's a convicted felon you'd support listen though yeah on totally trumped up charges I will support the nominee yes in including president Trump what if he gets and convicted when you so support him we'll we'll cross that bridge when we come to it facts matter I mean I think you need to look at what
49:40are the charges you know what if he's convicted what was he convicted of I think these things matter okay now all of those are the right answer but Democrats seem to believe that if they can grab a criminal conviction I mean that that's going to be their deex mackina is is if there is a hand of God coming down into the story it's going to be Trump being criminally convicted first of all I'm not sure the timeline allows for that it's not clear that any of these cases are going to come to a conclusion before the actual election takes place the the only real possibility is the Jacks Smith case Jack Smith is trying to accelerate that Trump is trying to slow that down post the
50:14election it looks like those Georgia charges are going to last too long for them to materialize it before the election it looks like the Florida case is going to be delayed beyond the election so really the only shot they have is that Jack Smith case and that one is really legally tenuous not only is it legally tenuous it does raise the January 6th questions all over again which I think is what Democrats want they'd love to discuss January 6th endlessly but I mean let's be real about this there are still some unanswered questions about January 6th so for example the there is now tape outside the DNC that is at least somewhat strange I mean it raises questions let's
50:52put it that way one of the big things that happened on January 6 apparently is that there were a couple of pipe bombs that were put outside the DNC and the RNC and we haven't heard a lot about that since January 6 and not not quite as spectacular on video as those giant scenes of of riots outside the Capitol Building or people breaking windows or whatever but more dangerous by the way like pipe bombs are meant to kill people and the story on the pipe bombs seems to be getting weirder and Weir weirder so representative Thomas Massie of Kentucky he's accusing the government of a coverup he says if there were indeed two operable pipe bombs that would be the
51:25biggest threat that existed on January 6 it doesn't make any sense why they wouldn't be promoting that threat to advance The Narrative unless they had something to do with the pipe bombs and they're trying to memory hold the whole thing to avoid embarrassment so apparently there's video that's been identified by Massie showing officers reacting nonchalantly after being notified of the pipe bomb Milling slowly around the area even letting kids walk in the area vice president kamla Harris was in the building at the time the doj didn't really let that be known at the time Massie says you would think they'd be focused on these pipe bombs but they
51:57are not and I mean they really aren't I mean the last time you heard about the pipe bombs is from Massie you're not hearing about about it from Democrats like at all not only that the bomb planter apparently is using a cell phone but data from a cell phone company was deemed corrupted the FBI wasn't able to find any records for the suspect I mean they they've locked down like who every person was who was in the capital building they're arresting them and putting them in jail for years on end but like you plant a pipe bomb outside the DNC or RNC that's like actual deadly threat of violence and we still can't find who exactly did that like that's
52:30weird again those sorts of questions are are going to to be asked during this campaign because this will be at the center of the campaign yet again now is that good for Trump I don't think it's an amazing thing if this campaign is held over January 6 I I think that that probably damages Trump politically does it damage him enough to overcome the fact that Joe Biden is bad at the president thing I have serious serious doubts all righty in just one second we are going to jump into a Supreme Court ruling on the border pretty wild ruling by the Supreme Court if you're not a member become member use coach Shapiro check out for 2 months free on all annual plans click
53:03that link in the description and join [Music] us
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版