安德鲁·索金(Andrew Ross Sorkin)的手机里有个文件,名字就叫「Elon」。
每次刷到马斯克的相关新闻、听到一句播客、脑子里冒出一个念头,他就往里记一笔。这个文件攒了两三个月,最后变成 Dealbook 峰会上那场将近一小时的直播采访。
准备远不止这点。他粗算过,每位嘉宾的前期投入超过三十个小时:读书、翻旧访谈、找对方身边的人聊天,把一个人尽量拼完整。
可他说,采访真正开始前的两三分钟,比台上发生的几乎任何事都重要。
索金是《纽约时报》Dealbook 的创始人。那场年度峰会请来十二位全世界最有分量的人,从早上九点天还亮着,一个接一个聊到傍晚六点半天黑,全程直播,没有重来的机会。
他和同事卢卢·加西亚-纳瓦罗(Lulu Garcia-Navarro)复盘了这场马拉松。里面讲的东西,对任何一个要跟人深谈一次的人都有用。
聊孩子聊天气,唯独不碰待会儿要问的事
他管这叫暖场,但用词很谨慎。
目的很朴素:让对方放松到愿意说话、愿意流露情绪的状态。人一紧绷就只会背稿子,松弛下来才会真的思考。
但他有一条铁律,绝不碰待会儿要问的话题,沾边都不行。
理由是人脑太爱排练。你随口问一句跟中国有关的,对方脑子里立刻开始播放「等会儿他要问中国了,我该怎么答」。等真上台,你听到的是一份背好的稿,一个人的想法被提前过滤掉了。
所以他聊孩子,聊天气,聊昨天那场球。听起来浪费时间,实际上是在保护后面那一个小时的原始度。
他要的不是金句,是人脑子里那列逻辑火车
索金对这批采访的定义很清楚:让公众看到这些人怎么想事情,为什么这么想。
同不同意另说。看懂对方脑子里那列逻辑火车往哪儿开,才是目的。
他提到印刷媒体做不到的一件事。写文章的时候,一个人可以说「不予置评」。这四个字落在纸上,你什么也看不出来。
但在台上,你能看见那是哪一种不予置评。
紧张的不予置评,恼怒的不予置评,话到嘴边又咽回去的不予置评,笑着把问题挡回去的不予置评,每一种都是一个答案。
有时嘉宾的回答让人不满意。那份不满意本身就是信息:他不喜欢这个问题,他不想谈这件事,他还没想清楚。观众看见的是完整的人,而不是整理过的句子。
峰会还有个特殊设计。很多演讲嘉宾讲完不走,坐到台下去听别人讲。索金正要采访迪士尼的鲍勃·艾格(Bob Iger)谈中国,而艾格当时就坐在台下,听副总统哈里斯谈中国。
这群人彼此看着对方怎么回答同一类问题,场面本身就有张力。
一个人三十小时准备,一百个问题,最后可能一个都用不上
索金说他试着算过账,每位嘉宾的前期投入超过三十个小时。
他打了个比方:有点像律师,你想在问出问题之前就知道答案。
自私一点的动机也有。好奇心重的人总想问那些从来没被回答过的问题。而要问出这种问题,前提是你知道哪些问题已经被问烂了。
问题清单也不是十条。他坦白说,可能是五十条,也可能是一百条。
有人注意到他在台上翻一沓厚厚的纸。他解释,理想状态是不带笔记,完全活在当下。可这是十二个人、九个多小时的马拉松,脑子不可能一直满电。
他带笔记,用法很特别:用一段原话、一个数字、一条旧闻当提示物,把话头递过去,让对方接。一段好的引语,往往比一个概括性的问题更容易逼出情绪。
他说得很直白,上场前你不可能预测对话会走到哪里,你能做的是准备好足够多的入口。
这些人没有义务来
台上坐着其他同样有权势的人,台下是几百双眼睛,说什么都会被放大。他们完全可以不来。
索金总结了几种动机。
一部分人来过,坐过观众席,知道这是什么场合,也享受这种能公开、认真谈点难事的机会。
一部分人认可准备工作。平时他们接受的电视采访只有五到十分钟,四五个问题,全是事实型的:明天会怎样,你打算怎么办,这个流程怎么走。在 Dealbook 的台上,谈的是你怎么想。
还有一部分,动机非常个人。
萨姆·班克曼-弗里德(Sam Bankman-Fried)在崩盘之前来过一次。他当时跟索金说过一段话,大意是:如果全世界九成的人恨我、认定我有罪,我出来讲一场,这个比例掉到八成七,那也是进步。
索金说,他当时就是这么算的,不是在打趣。
这个细节说明一件事:这些人上台,往往不是来做公关的,是来按自己的方式算一笔账的。
麦卡锡说「他就是老」,几小时后哈里斯回了句「恕我直言」
政治人物是最难采访的一类。他们受过训练,专门练过怎么不给答案。哈里斯(Kamala Harris)就以这个出名,采访过她的人常常带着挫败感下台。
索金把凯文·麦卡锡(Kevin McCarthy)排在哈里斯前面。麦卡锡谈到拜登的年龄,索金顺着说了句,你好像在暗示总统的年龄问题。
麦卡锡当场顶回来:「我没有暗示,他就是老。」
接着他讲债务上限谈判,说拜登念卡片,卡片上没有的内容就不谈。
「我跟拜登谈债务上限的时候没法谈,因为他照着卡片念。卡片上没有的,就不谈。」(凯文·麦卡锡)
几个小时后,哈里斯坐到同一把椅子上,被问到同样的事,先说了四个字:恕我直言。
「恕我直言,以他最近那段经历,我不认为他是评判谈判的那个人。」(卡玛拉·哈里斯)
两个人没有同台,却在同一块舞台上隔空对了一次话。
索金说,这种安排能让人看见观点之外的东西:皱眉、停顿、抢话、笑一下带过。这些反应在纸面上永远看不到。
一个存在主义时刻,两个人的刻度完全不同
那天用的标题里有个词:existential,存在主义式的。
乌克兰在打,以色列在打,台海悬着,国内要选举,AI 在改写商业的地基。索金说,感觉所有东西同时悬在半空,这种状态很久没出现过了。
哈里斯显然这么看。她是真的相信民主本身站在悬崖边上。
麦卡锡不这么看。他觉得这次选举极其重要,关系到国家往哪走,但他不认为那是文明存亡的关头。
同一年份,同一种焦虑,两种完全不同的刻度。看一场采访的价值,有时候就在于发现「他们连焦虑的单位都不一样」。
台湾地区领导人罕见地把话说直了
蔡英文很少接受国际媒体采访。那次她坐下来,说了一段让研究中国的人意外的话。
「我认为中国领导层在这个节点上被内部挑战压得喘不过气。我的想法是,考虑到经济上的代价,现在也许不是他们考虑大规模犯台的时候。」(蔡英文)
索金说,采访结束后很多中国观察者找他,说他们也吓了一跳。
按惯例,这种场合最适合对着西方观众喊话:请你们尽可能地帮我们。她没有。她给的是一个冷静的判断。
观察者们的解读是,这可能是她能给出的最诚实的答案。
时间点也要放进来。那是她第二个任期的尾声,本人不再参选,她的党大概率会赢下接下来的选举。这番话有风险,问题在于风险落到谁头上,是让选情变好还是变坏,索金说他也不知道。她同时在对着国际受众说话。
一个即将卸任的人,说话反而最不带包袱。这个规律在政界和商界都成立。
好莱坞三个人坐在台上,谁也给不出答案
鲍勃·艾格、大卫·扎斯拉夫(David Zaslav)、珊达·莱姆斯(Shonda Rhimes)。一个迪士尼,一个华纳兄弟探索,一个最会做剧的制片人。
索金说,这一组让他想到报纸行业最早的崩塌期。所有人都知道变了,没人知道变成什么样。
好莱坞的旧经济学被三件事拆掉了:流媒体、有线电视套餐的解绑、社交媒体。年轻人的时间流去了 TikTok,整门生意模型的地基没了。
他问得很直接,你们知道怎么办吗。三个人给出的答案,翻译过来是:不知道。
他顺带承认了自己这行的处境:内容生产过剩,内容支出过剩。他问对方,也在问自己,接下来几年还能不能一直这样烧钱。打开任何一个流媒体平台,片单长到不知道该看什么。
资产好的公司位置更靠前。可真正的问题在后面:它们还能不能作为独立公司活下去,还是最终被大科技公司一家家买走。因为钱在那些公司手里。
他借用了超市小报那个栏目名,「明星也和我们一样」,配图是名人拎着垃圾袋出门。台上这些人也差不多,坐拥惊人的资源,面对的还是没有答案的难题。难题之所以是难题,就是因为没有现成解法,谁坐上去都一样。
他还留了一句判断:内容过剩这件事,接下来几年一定会调整,不然整个行业撑不住。
马斯克上台前很愉快,上台后脑子里在刮风暴
索金说他没有预感到。
马斯克进来的时候状态不错,带着儿子,聊了些不痛不痒的话,没有生气,也没有烦躁,看起来还挺期待这场对话。
索金反而担心另一件事:他刚从以色列飞到奥斯汀,又飞回纽约,会不会累到没精神。结果是彻底反过来,能量高得吓人。
后来那个流传很广的说法来自沃尔特·艾萨克森(Walter Isaacson)写的那本传记:demon mode,恶魔模式。马斯克会周期性地滑进某种状态里。
索金说他采访过马斯克很多年,见过他掉进情绪暗处的时候。所以那天他不至于震惊,只是没料到会撞在那个节点上。
他给这场采访定的目标,就是让人看见马斯克的所有版本。
为了这个目标,他准备了几个月。手机里那个叫 Elon 的文件,每次遇到什么就记一笔。一个问题在心里放了很久:你到底是怎么运转的。
上台后他问了那个问题。
一个月前马斯克在一个播客里说过,我的头脑是一场风暴。索金把这句话原样端了出来。
「我的头脑经常感觉像一场非常狂野的风暴。我有一大堆想法,多到我根本执行不完。我有一整套电动超音速垂直起降飞机的设计,已经放了十年,可我就是做不了。」(埃隆·马斯克)
他追问,是快乐的风暴吗。
「不,不是快乐的风暴。」(埃隆·马斯克)
索金说,他手上有好几个版本的问法,本来打算从别的角度切进去。可那一刻他看见对方脑子里在打转,就换了。
他给自己定的规矩是:到人所在的地方去见他,去他此刻站着的地方,而不是他应该站的地方,也不是你希望他站的地方。
他真的相信自己是那座光明的堡垒
马斯克为什么会在那个时刻脑子里刮风暴,索金给了一个解释。
他深深觉得这个世界充满虚伪,而自己站在另一边,是某种光明的堡垒。艾萨克森说过,马斯克看自己像看一个超人式的角色。
他把 X 当成言论自由的载体。企业界一批批撤广告,在他的理解里,那是在杀他,杀这家公司,杀他想做的事。
索金强调,很多人不同意这个判断,他自己也未必同意。但马斯克是真的这么相信。
他想让人看见这一点。
这场采访的目标在这里变得很清楚:不是让人出丑,也不是让人背书,是让人把自己脑子里的东西原样摊开,哪怕那堆东西是乱的。
对着鲍勃·艾格骂脏话,两边的反应完全相反
那场采访里最出圈的一段,是他对着迪士尼的鲍勃·艾格连说了几次 f 开头的那个词。
索金问他,你觉得艾格在房间里吗。马斯克说着还举了下手,问,Bob,你在吗。
艾格那时候大概已经离场了。马斯克显然以为他可能还在。
舆论裂成两半。
一边说,这人疯了,这样搞下去哪个广告主还敢来。
另一边,索金的邮箱被塞满了。写信的人说,太痛快了,传奇,这才是向权力说真话。
同一段视频,两种完全相反的解读。那道裂缝就摆在那儿,谁也没有说服谁。
索金说,他不觉得马斯克事后会后悔。他相信马斯克到今天依然认为自己说得对。
飞行计划随时要改
索金用飞行员打比方。
你从肯尼迪机场起飞,计划降落洛杉矶,中途可能经停芝加哥、丹佛、亚特兰大。可天上的天气会变,你得愿意改航线。
看到一片云,你决定先绕开。看见他儿子在旁边,你就先聊两句孩子。
计划一定要有,不然你在台上就是个提问机器。计划一定要能改,不然你追不上现场发生的事。
他的做法是准备一百个问题,只带十个提示物上场,剩下的靠判断。哪一刻该往哪拐,靠的是你事先对这个人了解得够不够深。
X 只是他那盘棋里很小的一块
很多人不理解,一个靠广告吃饭的平台,老板为什么要把广告主往外推。
索金的解释是,X 在他心里的位置跟外界想的不一样。
他手上有 SpaceX,里面有星链(Starlink)。有特斯拉。有 Neuralink,最终想做的是植入大脑的东西。有 Boring Company。有 xAI,未来要用 X 上产生的数据去喂。
X 只是其中一块,甚至可能是最小的一块。
他希望人们理解他整盘棋的运转方式,而不只是盯着一个平台的广告收入。他相信的那个「真相」,是这盘棋的底座。
这个解释也顺带回答了一个问题:一个人为什么会在明知道有代价的情况下,仍然选择把话说到底。因为在他自己的账本里,那笔代价记在另一个科目下。
没有人真的不在乎别人恨自己
马斯克在台上说,我不在乎你是爱我还是恨我。
索金说,恰恰相反,你看得出他在乎得很。
这就是现场和影像的价值。一句话可以骗人,说这句话时的表情骗不了。
他当时追了一个问题过去:你可能不想被爱,也不想被恨,可你有多在乎被信任。
因为手上这些生意,最后都建立在信任上。人们信你,才会上你的平台;信你,才会买你的车;政府信你,才会把合同给 SpaceX。
马斯克没有正面回答。索金说,答案写在脸上:他不仅想要被信任,还想要被爱。
后面那句才是这场对话真正的落点:我们所有人都一样。
一个把火箭送上天、把车卖到全世界、随手就能买下一家社交平台的人,坐在这儿,被人追问「你希望被信任吗」,沉默了一下。这个画面比任何一段金句都更有说服力。
看完这一整套复盘,会发现索金做的事情其实很朴素。他把采访当成一次认知的交换:我给你三十个小时的准备,你给我一个真实运转的脑子。
那场马斯克采访之后,很多人讨论他是不是失控了。索金给出的视角更有意思:一场好的采访,目标不在让人出丑,也不在让人背书,而在让人露出思考的痕迹,哪怕那个痕迹是一团乱麻。
真正稀缺的从来不是观点。观点到处都是。稀缺的是一个人在想一件难事时,那几秒钟犹疑的样子。
- 重要对话前留出两三分钟纯闲聊,聊孩子、天气、球赛,一个字都别碰正题,防止对方提前排练。
- 把每个问题先自己回答一遍,猜到答案再去问。这样能省下对方的时间,也逼自己问得更深一层。
- 准备五十到一百个问题,上场只带十个提示物。一段原话、一个具体数字,比一个概括性的问题更容易撬开情绪。
- 对方开始绕、开始背稿、开始激动的时候,先判断他在哪儿,去他此刻站着的地方见他,别急着把他拉回你的提纲。
- 想问一个人是否在意名声,把问题换成「你有多在乎被信任」,得到的答案会真实得多。
- 看这类长访谈时,别只截金句。留意停顿、抢话、笑场、突然沉默,那些才是没被整理过的信息。
- 行业剧变类的访谈里,如果台上的人说不知道,先信这句话。承认没有答案,本身就是当天最有价值的信息。
- 轮到你自己开口时,记住那三分钟:真正的对话质量,往往在正式开口之前就已经决定了。
0:00[Music] hi everyone I'm Andrew O sorin columnist and founder of dealbook a daily business and policy report from The New York Times after the Whirlwind of news from the dealbook summit event the other week I sat down to talk with my colleague Lulu Garcia Navaro audio host with the New York Times magazine about what stood out for me here's our [Music] conversation when you you are starting these interviews there were 12 interviews with some of the most important people in the world live on stage and you're waiting in the wings do you have chitchat I mean what are you doing to warm up the guest so in many cases I get to talk to the guests prior
0:50I mean in the in the moments prior in a couple of cases I don't just because of the sort of structure of the day but I always think actually that the two or 3 minutes prior to an interview are more important than almost anything else that happens in an interview in truth and so I do I don't want to say warm them up but I think trying to get the guest comfortable to a place where they are going to feel able to emote able to
1:16engage in the conversation is very important so I do try to talk to them as much as I can you know in between and before the interviews begin having said that I try desperately to avoid talking about anything that we might be talking about because I always fear that people start to rehearse in their head even if you ask them even like a question that's even tangentially related to something you're going to ask later so I like to talk about people's kids and the weather and sports and just almost anything else
1:51which brings me I think to what you're trying to achieve when you're doing these interviews and how you craft the entire event what is it that you are trying to get these incredibly powerful people to do when they sit down with a live conversation I always think that the goal of these interviews is to try to let the public see the way these people think and to understand how they think about these different issues why they think what they think you don't have to agree with what they're saying but try to understand the sort of logic train in their head head is sort of the goal and to do it in an environment where often times they're talking to some of the
2:37same people that are involved in some of these very consequential decisions on the other side so people in the audience many of our speakers many many of the people who are sitting on the stage with me often times then go and sit in the audience you'll see Bob Iger sitting there watching the vice president as we're talking about China you know I was actually about to talk to Bob Iger about China so and they're all seeing how each other are talking about things and thinking about things but I think the underlying goal is is so you can see it and I think one of the things that's so interesting about live journalism is you get to see it in a way that's often
3:11times different than in words in print you know often times when I'm writing an article you can talk to somebody and maybe they'll say no comment or they don't they're not really giving you the answer there's many ways to say no comment there's many ways to say no comment but when you are seeing them answer the question sometimes people don't like the answer or they find the answer unsatisfying but in many ways that is the answer and you get to see that answer and you get to see the equivalent of the no Comon but is the no common and anxious no Comon is the no common and angry no com what is that you're and so being able to sort of see all of those
3:47different sides of it I think are really what makes it special I want to talk about this idea of trying to get people to reveal themselves because that's what you're saying essentially that you want to show this side of these people that we read about all the time that we hang on their every word because they shape the world that we live in and how do you as an interviewer get those moments to happen I mean part of it is the craft I mean it can't just be that they're going to sit down in front of a live audience and decide to impart personal details intimate details about their life there's a couple of things that I'm trying to do some of it is planned and
4:29some of it's unplanned part of it's making them feel comfortable that they're going to get a fair shot that they're going to have an opportunity to engage in a conversation that is intended to illuminate how they think and the other thing is hopefully lots and lots and lots of preparation both I spend inor amount of time I mean trying to do the math on it it may very well be 30 plus hours a person really where I end up
4:58both in terms of reading talking to other people around them you know really trying to get a full piece of it and it's a little bit like I don't know I imagine it may be like a lawyer in some cases you want to know the answer before you ask the question and selfishly if you're just a curious person you also want to ask questions where the answer is not has never been available before and so I think it's that and then hopefully having the ability to to navigate and move the questions the conversation to different places when the opportunity arises because you can plan out an interview you know you could plan out the 10 questions you want to ask or
5:38whatever it is but that's sort of not really the way first of all I don't usually have 10 questions I might have frankly like 50 or 100 questions I did notice watching you that there's like a thick pile of paper that you're sort of flipping through sometimes so I yeah so in a perfect world to be totally Frank with you I don't really like to have notes m at all if possible I like to be so in the moment that you're not really looking at the notes because there's in this case a dozen people and it really is a sort of8 or 9h hour marathon we begin when it's very light outside at 9:00 a.m. and we end it I think at 6:30 when it was dark I do bring lots of
6:18notes I also use quotes and other kinds of facts as prompts I often find that a great quote or a great little tidbit or or note that often times I need to almost read can create a great prompt for the interviewee to emote or react to why do you think these people come on to dealbook because I'm thinking about your interview with Elon and the headlines that came out of that and I'm also thinking about last year's interview with Sam pman freed which didn't do him any favors either right and they don't need to come there's no there's no requirement for them to come on this very public stage with these very other powerful people in the audience with a lot of scrutiny what
7:05do you think is the motivating factor I think there's two or three things that happen one is I think that a number of them have been there before they've sat in the audience they've seen it and some of them relish the opportunity to to to be able to speak out publicly in this kind of format in this kind of way and hopefully have an intelligent conversation and get engaged in some often times thorny and difficult stuff but in a respectful way hopefully I think they respect the preparation that goes into it oftentimes to the extent they do interviews they're doing five or 10minute interviews on TV there's four or five questions that most people are
7:53being asked questions that are very factual tell me this what's happening tomorrow what are you going to do Tom what's this how's this going to work that we're not I don't want to say we're not interested in those questions but going back to this sort of opportunity to talk about how you think and I think people want want to do that and then everybody has their own idiosyncratic reason a year ago s bankman Freed's view was if 90% of the world hates me and thinks that I'm guilty if I can speak to people and that goes from 90% to
8:2287% that's an improvement he that's how he really thinks and that's how he really thought so I think everybody has their own reason for for wanting to engage in these conversations and these interviews we'll be right back I want to talk about politics because political interviews I think are some of the hardest interviews to do because politicians are very practiced at not revealing themselves and you had vice president KLA Harris who is known as a frustrating interview she often gives a lot of non- answers and I thought it was interesting that you had before that Republican speaker Kevin McCarthy how did you set that up because it ended up that they were in
9:17conversation with each other in a way and specifically when Kevin McCarthy was talking about President Biden's age you just said something which I think is on the the minds of all Americans which is the I think you're alluding to the age of the president I'm not alluding he is old with Biden I could not negotiate the debt scene with Biden what you explain that it was certain decisions he talked from cards if it's not on the card we're not talking about it and then of course you had kamla Harris clapping back in her own interview with all due respect when anyone who has had the experience that he has most recently had I don't think he's a judge of
10:04negotiations that's the other thing that I think makes the day so interesting because you do have people who in a way are talking to each other I think you get to see sort of how these different individuals react to these types of things and I think that when they're challenged on issues or policy or just how they react to certain things you then get to really sort of see how they react in the moment in a way that oftentimes you can't necessarily see physically when you when you read an article or or what have you what sense did it give you of the state of the world right now because one of the things when you look at sort of the totality but specifically
10:45those two interviews I mean we are going into an election season we are about to face what I think is going to be a very grueling difficult moment to have these two very important people sitting down with you what what Insight did it give you about what we're facing and how they view this moment so it's interesting I think they both view it somewhat differently and it's actually the headline we used that we are at this sort of existential moment part of that is the fact that we are in the midst of wars in Ukraine and Israel and hopefully not in Taiwan but we can talk about that piece of it in a moment but then here at home with our election and then obviously within the
11:26world of business and given AI and some of the transformative disruptive changes that are happening so I think it does feel existential I think for the vice president it clearly feels that way I mean she she demonstrably believes that democracy is at stake I don't think that Kevin McCarthy believes that democracy is at stake in the next election I think he thinks it's super important and super important for the direction of the country but I don't know if he thinks it's it's existential in that way but I think clearly we're at this sort of pivot point where it almost feels like everything is sort of up in the air in a way that it hasn't been in
12:01a very long time yeah in that same vein what was so interesting to me is when you talked to the president of Taiwan tywan who doesn't give a lot of interviews to the international media and again there's this overriding concern about the status of her country but also what it means because of the war in Ukraine the relationship with China and she was surprisingly sanguin well I I think the Chinese leadership at this juncture is overwhelmed by its internal challenges and my thought is that perhaps this is not a time for them to consider a major invasion of Taiwan because of the economic I I was so happy that she just she was willing to engage
12:45at all I was surprised you know at one point she wasn't saying about what she thinks is manipulation happening in the election in Taiwan I thought actually how direct she was about that was fascinating but her her willingness I don't know if it's will or allowance that she believes that China's economy is so damaged right now and so challenged that because of that that they won't try to invade Taiwan I never heard her say that so directly and so publicly now remember this is the end of her second term she's not up for reelection but it does seem that her party is likely to win if she said that there was a remarkable risk would that make her party's situation better or
13:33worse come next year when the election take place I don't know but she's also speaking to the international audience and so that is what struck me because you see a President Vladimir zalinski of Ukraine really always making the case I mean obviously he's in an active War but how much the International Community needs to Rally around Ukraine and this seemed to be slightly a different message well is so I heard from a lot of sort of China Watchers after this and people who who watch her and that they were surprised too by the way and they believe that she was genuine just for for what it's worth the view was that you normally would have taken this opportunity to speak to
14:14the Western audience and say folks please please please help us as much as humanly possible but they felt like this was the most honest kind of answer that she could ever give because of how sanguin she was before we get to Elon we're almost there I do want to ask you about Hollywood because that was another big bucket I mean you had as we've mentioned Disney's Bob Iger you had Warner Brothers David zoff CEO David zasloff and you had shaa Rimes of course and and so all
14:48these buckets are really interesting the media the Hollywood the politics the economy but for me of course in the world of media this group felt very very indicative of where the media is at right now and where Hollywood's at which is just an enormous upheaval and real a real sense that things are are very unclear what did you take away from from those three I think I took away that this is an industry that is in true disruption in a way that they didn't expect or knew was coming but maybe it's come sooner this feels very much to me like newspapers frankly circle circle the early a when the real sort of transformation began and it was a tough
15:43period and it was it was a very challenging period it still is for for lots of parts of the country local newspapers and the like but I think that the economics of the way Hollywood worked have been so upended by streaming and the unbundled of cable and social media you younger people going on Tik Tok and want just their time being spent elsewhere that the whole sort of model if you will is broken and I think that they now know that they've realized that and the question of course is what do they do about it and did you get an answer that satisfied you do you think they know I guess that's the truth is I think the truth is they don't know I think the better assets you have and I
16:25think Disney and Warner Brothers discovery of the media companies out there that have fabulous assets are probably better positioned but the question is do they remain independent companies you know do the big Tech players ultimately own them all because they're the ones who have the money it is clear unfortunately as as content creators we're both content creators of sorts that there's been an abundance of content creation probably too much content creation and too much spending on content and so that over at least the next several years I can't imagine we're going to be able to go on to a any of these streaming services I mean I don't know how often you go on a streaming
17:01service now and there's almost there's too much to watch you're not even sure what you're supposed to watch anymore I think that'll change we're always looking to these people though to have the answers and I think again it struck me with the Hollywood section that they don't have the answers they don't have the answers do you ever read and that's scary it's totally scary and in a way though I think that the whole day in these interviews if they do what they're supposed to do there's a I don't know if I'm supposed to admit this or not so if you ever occasionally read Us magazine maybe you pick it up at supermarket or at a gym or somewhere anyway there's
17:37always that page where they have pictures of these celebrities you know taking out the garbage or things and they say they're just like us yes I don't want to say all these people are just like us but in a way they are in so far as they don't know the answers but I think you really see that often times these are intractable challenging problems they're problems because they don't have obvious answers and they're just like us and that they're trying to sort through them and I think that what you're trying to see in these interviews is hopefully back to the sort of like how do they think do you think that they are capable of figuring out the answer
18:11there are certain people by the way they may not have the answer but you can sort of see the way they think in so far and go you know what they're better position than than maybe somebody else would be to able to figure this out and there's other people who don't have the answer and you can see that maybe they will never have the answer which brings us to Elon you described the moment before you
18:33get on stage with Elon Musk and I've held off on discussing this because it by far made the biggest news I mean it was sort of overshadowed all the other wonderful interviews that you did because he was in a particular State of Mind y did you know going onto that stage that he was in a particular State of Mind what exactly did you feel
18:59was going to happen when he was coming on I did not think that he was in that state of mind I did not he was on the way in relatively jovial had a a nice energy about him we talked about a couple sort of generic things he was with his son and didn't seem angry or upset or anything like that he was seemed to be excited about doing the interview he didn't say he was tired I worried he might be tired because he had just flown from Israel to Austin and then back to New York and I thought oh goodness that you know that's that's he might be low energy that's that's a lot this was the opposite it was not low energy it was it was totally high energy
19:44so you know when when he went down that that road I was I was surprised I've you know I've covered him for a long time so I've seen moments where you know he can get to a place that's a emotionally sort of dark and so I wasn't I don't want to say I was surprised in the moment but I wasn't shocked as in oh my God I cannot believe this is happening also by the way Walter isacon who's written a brilliant book about him talks about this thing called you know demon mode where he will sort of go into these these these these moments and there are multiple Elon I mean I think you do see and I my goal with the interview in many ways by the way was to show you all of
20:22those different El you were on a podcast about a month ago and you said my mom mind is a storm what did you mean by that I mean I have known you for quite some time I think it is a bit of a storm yes yeah I mean I in as much as a a weather metaphor makes sense my mind is often feels like a like a like a very Wild Storm I mean I have I have a fountain of ideas I mean I have more ideas than I can possibly execute I mean I've got an entire designed for an electric supersonic vertical takeoff jet but I I mean I just if I I just can't do that as well I've had that for 10 years I there a million things is your storm a Happy
21:17Storm no it's not a Happy Storm no were you trying to elicit that this this idea of like what it's like to be in the mind of Elon oh 100% I think I spent weeks making notes weeks months maybe the last three two or three months before this interview I was making notes about I had a file on my phone that was called Elon and every time i' see something I quote a thought that I had I'd write it down how we going you know how do we get here why did you decide to do it in that moment in that moment I you know my plan was to actually go to something like that and I sort of had a different handful of sort of versions of different prompts related to a qu to that kind of question
22:03but in that moment I think I saw him him spiraling in his head his mind was a storm in that moment and I think that you know I was see my role is I would say my job is to meet people where they are it's not necessarily where they should be or where I want them to be but to meet them where they are in that moment and so I think I saw him in that moment and I thought okay you're there let me meet you there and let's talk about it why do you think his mind was a storm in that moment I mean you said you could see him spiraling yeah what do you think was going on I think that he feels so deeply that there is this hypocrisy in the world and that he is this Bastion
22:50of light that's the way he thinks of himself almost I think Walter isson once described the way he thinks that Elon thinks of himself almost as like a a like a Superman kind of character and he thinks with X formerly Twitter that he is trying to create this service that embodies sort of free speech and the like and he thinks that Corporate America by dropping them from the sponsors is trying to kill him and to kill this company and to try to kill what he's trying to do that's what he demonstr believes I know there's lots of people who disagree with him about that but that's what he believes and I think that he wanted people to see that interestingly I will say and this to me
23:39was surprising there were a lot of people who said oh my God elon's crazy this is absurd how could he you know you're never going to get an advert you're you're never going to get advertisers to want to advertise on your platform if you tell everybody if if you start cursing at them right but on the flip side I can't tell you how many emails I get and I don't know if they're Elon Musk Fanboys or what they are but who say that was epic you're a legend Elon that was remarkable you're speaking truth to power and so you could see this sort of Chasm and divide and you can also see where some of this comes from because of course we're talking about when he told Bob Iger head
24:16of Disney to f off yes multiple times multiple times did he think Bob Iger was in the room was Bob Iger in the room I think Bob actually had left at that point but I think I mean there was one point he he actually said put his hand up and said hey Bob if you're in the room so I think he must have thought that Bob could have still been there so you're sitting with Elon Musk he's spiraling he's saying pretty provocative things but he seems open totally keeping the conversation going I mean what are you what are you thinking as an interviewer at that point and so when do you choose like okay we need to Pivot from this and go somewhere else well I
24:58think that in that moment it was in the meet you where you are let's let's pivot and look I'm sure he wouldn't describe it as spiraling I think he was actually very I think to this day he's very happy with what he said I I I believe that but that's so interesting it's a little bit like you know where you want to begin every conversation I say it's like being a pilot I imagine you sort of say you're going to start at JFK and you're going to end at LAX and you're probably going to stop along the way in O'Hare and maybe Denver and maybe you'll you'll stop in Atlanta but the weather's going to change up there and and you got to be willing to sort of change the flight
25:30plan and so you sort of see the cloud and you decide okay I'm going to go the other way for now or you see their son I'm going to go there why do you think he didn't see it as a disastrous interview if the point is that he runs this company and he does need advertisers and he's clearly grieved by the fact that these advertisers are no longer putting their money towards the platform so why does he then think think this is fine that I did this because I think and again I don't want to speak for him I think that X is one component part of this larger ecosystem that he controls in SpaceX in Tesla by the way
26:17SpaceX has starlink as part of it in neuralink which is you know what he eventually thinks will be you know an implant in your brain the boring company the boring company xai which is now going to be the sort of artificial intelligence engine powered in part by some of the things that go on in X and I think he wanted people to understand the way he thinks about all of these things and that Twitter or X is just one as I said component part it might even be a miniature part of the sort of larger larger thing and he does believe in this idea of Truth what he thinks is truth do you think Elon actually truly doesn't care that people hate him does anyone really not care that
26:58people hate them no I think actually that was but I think that's one of the great things about live and visual journalism when he said I don't care if you love or hate me I think you could very much tell that he cared deeply about that I mean one of the things I tried to do in that moment I don't know if you remember was I said you may not want to be loved or hated but how much do you care about being trusted because given all these things that you're running you ultimately have to be trusted if people are going to be on your platform if they going to buy your cars if the government's going to give SpaceX money do they trust you ultimately and I don't know if you
27:34actually answered that question directly but it was clear as day at least in my mind that not only does he desperately want to be trusted but he desperately wants to be loved we all do we all do Andrew rossin thank you so much thank [Music] you thanks for listening to this year's dealbook Summit podcast this episode was produced by Evan Roberts and edited by Lane Chen original music by Daniel Powell mixed by Kelly Pico the rest of the dealbook events team includes Julie Zan Carolyn Brunell Haley Duffy Angela Austin Haley hes Dana Paskowski Matt Kaiser Yen we Liu special thanks to Sam dolnick Nina laom Robie matu Beth Weinstein and Kate [Music] Carrington
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版