2019年9月,得克萨斯州博卡奇卡的海滩上,Tim Dodd抬头望着一架完整的不锈钢火箭原型。一个月前他站在同一个位置,隔着一道围栏,看到的还只是“一根管子加一个尖头”。
他问马斯克:你怎么做到的?靠纯粹的意志力,还是整个团队都对目标疯狂到了这个程度?
马斯克的回答里没有通宵故事,也没有砸钱的说法。他讲了一条原则:自己在“让事情快速推进”这件事上学到了很多教训,然后把它们复制给了SpaceX团队。
如果一个设计做起来太慢,那说明这个设计错了。既然错了,就得改设计,让进度快起来。(马斯克)
紧接着这句更狠。他说先进研发里最根本的错误之一,是明明设计非常复杂,还死抱着不放,不肯删零件、不肯删流程。
这条原则直接解释了Starship身上最让人费解的一次转向:从碳纤维换成不锈钢。
碳纤维被砍掉,只因为等不起
Tim提到,2018年9月的DearMoon发布会上,SpaceX还在展示碳纤维储罐的芯模,看起来相当认真。马斯克纠正了他:那场发布会之后一个月,也就是2018年10月,他就把碳纤维方案取消了。
不锈钢在性能上并不占优。碳纤维更轻、更强,也更像“航天该用的东西”。它的问题出在速度上:太慢。
Tim称赞马斯克没有掉进沉没成本谬误,不会因为已经投了钱就沿着死路继续走。马斯克把这件事说得更干脆:
它在不在未来?如果它不在未来,那还管它干什么?(马斯克)
他衡量一条路的标准只有一条:这条路通向哪里。已经付出了多少,不在计算之内。
这也解释了为什么2019年初还只有“管子加尖头”的工地,到9月就能立起一架完整的MK1。设计一旦不再拖后腿,施工速度就变成了纯粹的执行问题。
“每个人都是首席工程师”
Tim问了一个很多人都好奇的问题:你其实就是SpaceX的首席工程师吧?
马斯克讲了个段子。他跟一个朋友吃饭,朋友问“SpaceX的首席工程师是谁”,他说“是我”。朋友不信:“不是你,到底是谁?”马斯克说,那这人要么自我极低,要么我也不知道是谁。
然后他讲了自己真正对团队说的话:
我跟团队讲,每个人都是首席工程师。(马斯克)
这句话有明确的组织含义。马斯克要求团队里每个人都大致理解整台飞行器所有系统怎么工作。理由很具体:一旦每个人只盯着自己那块,就会出现“子系统局部最优”。你把自家零件优化到极致,整台火箭反而变差了。
他把这层逻辑继续往下推:产品上的错误,本质上是组织上的错误。你画出组织架构图,部门之间的接缝,最后一定会变成产品上的接缝。
典型的坏情况长这样:A部门给B部门一组约束条件,B部门老老实实照着这组约束做设计,从不回头问一句“这约束本身对不对”。错误被完整保留下来,还被精心优化了一遍。
你拿到的约束,一定是错的
马斯克在这里讲了一段非常“工程师哲学”的话:
你应该默认,别人给你的约束一定是错的,某种程度上一定是错的。因为反过来说,就等于假设这些约束完美无缺。(马斯克)
Tim接了一句:完美无缺,从来不存在。
马斯克继续:一个零件刚好是“完美零件的柏拉图理想型”,这个概率是多少?零。所以,质疑你的约束。
他还补了一句更不留情面的:给你约束的人就算拿过诺贝尔奖,也说明不了约束是对的。连我们自己定的标准,也经常是错的。
聪明工程师最大的陷阱:优化一个不该存在的东西
马斯克说,聪明工程师最容易掉进去的坑,是把一个本不该存在的东西优化到极致。
这种场景在硬件团队里天天发生:一群人围着一个零件反复打磨,性能提升三成,成本砍掉一半,可没有人回过头问最初那句话,这东西为什么要存在?
马斯克把根源追到了教育。他说自己学的是物理,大学里你必须回答教授给你的问题,你不能站起来说“这个问题本身是错的”。
但在现实中,你有现实给你的全部自由度。所以你该说的第一句话是:这个问题问错了。(马斯克)
这句“这个问题问错了”,在Starship项目上被反复执行。团队没有去琢磨怎么把碳纤维做得更快,他们先问了另一句:为什么非要用碳纤维。
《银河系漫游指南》里藏着的方法论
Tim提到马斯克之前说过一句话:光是“把问题问对”,就花了很久。
马斯克用《银河系漫游指南》来解释。他说道格拉斯·亚当斯可能是最好的哲学家,这本书太深了,很多人没读出来。书里的设定是:地球是一台巨型计算机,专门用来计算“生命、宇宙以及一切的答案”。算了几百万年,答案出来了:42。
所有人崩溃:这什么玩意儿,完全说不通。
马斯克的解读是:
真正难的是问题。答案是容易的那部分。你需要一台强大得多的计算机,才能告诉你问题是什么。(马斯克)
一旦问题被正确地框定,答案反而会自己浮现。大部分团队把九成力气花在找答案上,却几乎不花力气检查问题本身。
为什么Starship不用气动塞式发动机
采访里有一段最硬核的内容。Tim当时正在做一期关于气动塞式发动机(aerospike)的长视频,干脆当面问了马斯克:你对这东西最大的意见是什么?
先给不熟悉的朋友补一句。普通火箭喷管只有一个固定形状,海平面和真空里的最优膨胀比不一样,喷管只能二选一。气动塞式发动机的思路是用一个塞锥加上外部气流,让“虚拟喷管”随外界气压自动调整,理论上全高度都能保持高效率。它听起来很美,历史上却一直停在试验台上。
马斯克先承认,他在公司内部问过很多次:“我们是不是该搞个气动塞式发动机?”
然后他从第一性原理拆了一遍火箭发动机。
火箭发动机要干的事只有一件:把物质尽可能快地沿直线喷出去。效率分两块。第一块是燃烧效率,实际释放的能量占理论最大值的多少。第二块是喷管效率,你把气流拉直、让分子朝一个方向跑的能力,靠的是牛顿第三定律。
传统燃烧室在燃烧效率这块很有优势。分子在燃烧室里乱撞,有足够时间结合;挤过喉部的时候又被给了一次机会。所以全流量分级燃烧能做到很高:
我们觉得能到90%,肯定能到98.5%,希望达到99%的理论燃烧效率。就算上帝亲自来把分子编织在一起,你也就再好1%,顶多1.5%。(马斯克)
能做到这一步,靠的是全流量分级燃烧(full flow staged combustion)。它的特点是气对气反应:两股热气直接混合燃烧。
马斯克顺手做了个对比。他说最简单的是氢,甲烷加液氧也足够简单,没有长链碳氢化合物。煤油就麻烦了:长链分子要先打断,再重新组合,整个过程“像一锅乱炖”,他补了一句“像一顿晚餐派对现场”。
这带来一个经常被忽略的坑:看理论值时,煤油发动机显得比实际更有吸引力。因为煤油根本达不到甲烷那样的燃烧效率。煤油拼到96%都难,95%都费劲;甲烷轻松98%,稍加努力99%。所以真正该算的是“实际可达燃烧效率 × 理论化学能”,这个数才是真的。换到这个口径,甲烷的优势立刻显出来。
回到气动塞式发动机。Tim问:所以SpaceX大概永远不会造全流量分级燃烧的气动塞式发动机?
马斯克的回答很值得抄下来:
如果有人能证明我们错了,那太好了。如果有人说“你们的设计可以更好,这里有一条路”,那是一份礼物。谢谢你这份大礼。(马斯克)
他还说,最糟的情况是“我们就是要做这个蠢设计,并且死守这个蠢设计”,那才叫疯了。
他也把条件讲清楚了。气动塞式发动机要成立,必须证明两件事:燃烧效率不受影响,气流被足够好地拉直。否则拿不到想要的膨胀比。
还有一层结构性理由。Starship是两级火箭:助推级主要在大气层里工作,上级主要在真空里工作。两级各自配专属喷管就行,海平面喷管管海平面,真空喷管管真空。
只有当你真想搞单级入轨、可重复使用,你才会去抓气动塞式发动机。(马斯克)
采访里马斯克还点出一个事实:在Starship之前,全流量分级燃烧发动机从来没有上过天,甲烷发动机也从来没有上过天。这两件事同时押在一款火箭上,风险不小。但他说自己非常确信甲烷是对的燃料。也许气动塞式发动机也是对的,只是还没人做出来,那你得先证明效率不掉。
头部储箱被当成货物绑在火箭里
采访后半段,Tim提到一张照片:马斯克钻进Starship的鼻锥里。马斯克说他在里面看到了头部储箱(header tanks)。
Tim问:那些是电池吗?几个?
马斯克说:四块特斯拉100千瓦时的电池,基本就是直接焊在头部储箱上。
然后他主动交代了一个让自己不满意的设计。头部储箱现在的做法是像货物一样被搬进火箭里。他说这很蠢。
头部储箱应该和鼻锥一体化。直接拿火箭的尖端当储箱的一半,把主储箱的做法缩小复制到鼻子里。两个穹顶,氧气和燃料都放在尖端,让储箱本身成为结构的一部分,别再把它们当货物塞进去。(马斯克)
Tim接话:这样连多出来的一层壁都省了,直接集成进结构。
马斯克用航空史做了个类比。早期火箭比如V2,燃料箱和氧箱就是“货物”,被塞在气动外壳里面。早期飞机也一样。现代火箭和现代飞机不这么干:机翼本身就是油箱,做成机翼的形状。头部储箱也该这么干。
阀门还在用液压,下一步是纯机电
Tim注意到另一点:Starship的阀门驱动,基本就是Model 3的电机。
马斯克确认了,然后说这也不是终局方案。目前的链路是:特斯拉电机加电池,先把液压油泵进蓄能器,再由液压活塞去推阀门。
他觉得这一步该删掉:
我们可能会转向纯机电执行器。直接用电机加蜗杆去拧阀门,简单得多。(马斯克)
这句话和前面那条“删除零件和流程”的原则对上了。从液压油、蓄能器到活塞,这一整套东西如果可以被一个蜗杆替代,那它就该消失。光把它优化得更高效还不够,得让它消失。
这套方法论能用在火箭以外的地方
整场采访里,具体技术只占一半,另一半是通用的做事方式。把它抽出来,可以落成几条很具体的动作。
- 先检查问题对不对,再动手做方案。开会时先花十分钟问“我们为什么要解决这个”,往往能省下后面几个月。
- 把“删除”设成默认选项。每轮评审都问一遍:这个零件、这道流程、这次会议,删掉会怎样?删不掉,再谈优化。
- 主动质疑上游给的约束。拿到需求先假设它有一处是错的,然后去找那一处。给你约束的人级别再高,也说明不了约束正确。
- 警惕局部最优。你把自己的模块做到满分,整台机器却变慢了,这种胜利就是失败。评估任何改动,看整机指标。你的模块漂亮、整机变差,这次改动就该被打回。
- 把慢当成设计错误的信号。一个方案反复延期、反复救火,先别加人加班,先怀疑设计本身走错了路。
- 公开邀请别人证明你错。把“你错了,这是更好的做法”当成礼物收下。谁能让设计变简单,谁就该被表扬。
- 比较技术路线时用真实可达的效率,别用理论峰值。把“理论最好值”换成“这个团队实际能拿到的值”,结论经常会翻转,煤油和甲烷那笔账就是现成的例子。
0:00- Hi, it's me Tim Dodd, the Everyday Astronaut. Last night, Elon Musk updated the world on SpaceX's Starship development. Let me tell ya, the event was amazing. We learned a lot of really cool details. But, I'm still a little baffled by the pace of this program, it's unheard of.
0:17If only there was someone that could answer a few more of my questions about this program and about Starship. - That's a nice shirt. - How's it going? Thank-you, you know full flow staged conduction not a bad idea Mind mic-ing yourself up there? [Tim Voiceover] After Elon complimented my shirt, we mic-ed him up and let the cameras roll.
0:33Now, for those of you new to my channel, we're gonna get into some fairly in-depth rocket science and if it's over your head don't worry. Stick around my channel, and I promise I'll make sense of all the stuff we talk about, like full flow staged combustion cycle and aerospike engines.
0:46There were parts of this interview that I wasn't really planning to release at first but, actually think the best thing I can do is just show you the entire thing, un-cut, from a single camera, so you can feel like you're right there with us. - Yeah, first off, thank-you so much for, you know, talking to me, I mean, we're underneath your beautiful beast.
1:05- Yeah it's crazy, can you believe this is even here? - I was here a month ago, literally standing right here, well not, just over the fence, and you know you got a tube and a pointy tube, and now you've got this! I mean, how do you, how do you do that? Is it just sheer will? Is everyone that driven about the goal?
1:22- I don't, I think I've learned a lot of lessons about how to make things go fast. And then I've... propagated those lessons to the SpaceX team and there's just like an incredibly talented, hard working team at SpaceX, in fact at times I think, maybe there's too many talented people at SpaceX.
1:40We have like... you know, too many talented people, that we're cornering the market, or something. You know, but there's like this very talented group that works super hard and... The, and just have taking the general approach of, if a design is taking too long, the design is wrong and therefore, the design must be modified to accelerate progress.
2:05And one of the most fundamental errors made in advanced developments is to stick to a design even when it is very complicated, and to not strive to delete parts and processes. It's incredibly important. So, this is why the switch to steel was because the advanced carbon fiber was taking too long.
2:22- Right, right, well and you're not, you're definitely not a sunk cost fallacist, you're like Mister, "This is clearly the new path forward, let's hop on it" - Yeah, is it in the future or not? If it's not in the future, who cares? - Yeah, yeah, and you did that, I mean look at last year, DearMoon, you guys were kind of in that like, awkward stage of probably figuring this out right here.
2:38You know, you had the carbon fiber mandrel... - I think we didn't even have the steel, I think we were still on the path, when was the DearMoon thing? - Almost exactly a year ago. - That was before the change to steel. - Yeah, you guys, I mean you showed the carbon mandrel and everything and you're, you know, excited about that, but then all of the sudden we see you switch- - I canceled the carbon fiber design in October last year.
2:56- Yeah, so just after that. - Yeah... - You know, what people don't understand is that you're the lead engineer, you're literally sit- - Literally, this is, I was actually at dinner with some, with a friend and he was like, "Well, who's the chief engineer at SpaceX?" Oh I go, "It's me", "No, no" he's like, "It's not you, who is it?", like okay it's either someone with a very low ego, or, I don't know, you know, but, you know that said, you know the, like, you know what I actually used to tell the team, I was like, "Everyone is a chief engineer", this is extremely important, and that everyone must understand how, the, broadly speaking,
3:34all the systems in the vehicle work. And so that, so you don't have self-system optimization, cause this is naturally what happens, you can see the organizational errors, The product errors reflect the organizational errors. So like essentially, you'll see that there's an interface at this particular, like, whatever departments you've got, that will be where your interfaces are.
4:01- Right. - Instead of like, getting rid of something, or questioning the constraints, the one department will design to the constraints that the other department has given them without calling into question those constraints and saying, "Those constraints are wrong", and you should actually take the approach that the constraints that you are given are guaranteed to be some degree wrong, guaranteed to be some degree wrong, because the counterpoint would be that they are perfect.
4:26- Right, which is never. - As you were saying like, what's the probability that this is a platonic ideal of a perfect part? Zero, okay, basically, so, question your constraints. It does not matter if the person handing you those constraints won a Nobel Prize, they are, even our own standards are wrong some of the time.
4:41So, question your constraints, this is extremely important, and, another thing that like, if you say like, "What are the mistakes that smart engineers make?", like, one of the most, one of the biggest traps for smart engineers is optimizing a thing that shouldn't exist. - Yeah, so they'll just sit there and spin on that thing that's just like, "Why do we even have this is the first place?" - Absolutely, so, When you go through college, and you're like, studying physics or engineering, I studied physics, the, you have to answer the question that the professor gives you, you don't get to say, "This is the wrong question".
5:21- Right, right, right, yeah. - But, in reality, we have far more degrees, when you're in reality, you have all the degrees of freedom of reality, and so the first thing you should say is, "This question is wrong". - Yeah, and that's what you said last year, I mean, you kinda said like, "It took us a long time to frame the question even, because we didn't necessarily know what it was".
5:39- It took ages to frame the question, I mean, it's just like The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, Douglas Adams, best philosopher ever, maybe, I think, best book in philosophy ever, Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, but his book is so deep, people don't even understand. But like, in The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, the Earth is a giant computer, and the Earth, it comes up with the answer- 42.
6:00- Right, yep. - And, to the question, so what's life, the answer to life, the universe and everything? The answer's 42, and they're like, "What the hell, that doesn't make any sense". The really, the hard part is the question, the answer is the easy part, you need a much more powerful computer to tell you what the question is, and this is true, at the point in which you can properly frame the question, the answer is comparatively easy.
6:21- Right, right. I have one more question for you, I'm working on a video about aerospikes, it's gonna be about an hour long video on aerospikes and, you know, they're like the rotary engine of rocket, you know, rockets, like the rotary was, it's been advantageous in some ways, you know, like your- - Yeah, aerospikes, man, I tell you - They're cool but, what's the biggest, what's your biggest beef on them?
6:38'Cause I'm trying to get as much insight on like, why do you think they, you know, aren't used, and obviously, I assume, you're not ever going to an aerospike for a lot of reasons... - You know, I've internally asked this question so many times, like, "Guys, don't we, shouldn't we maybe do an aerospike?", the...
7:00The challenge, so... And you're going to explain to the audience what an aerospike is? - Oh yeah, you're gonna be like the end of this thing, I've already set it all up, yeah yeah. - Otherwise you know, "What the hell are you talking about?" you know? - You gotta get your combustion efficiency, so, you know like, there's really two parts to, like, when you have a rocket engine, what're you trying to do?
7:22You're trying to shoot things out, as fast as possible, in a straight line. - Yes, yep, converting as much thermal and pressure into kinetic energy. - Yes, exactly, so you have your combustion efficiency, and so what percentage of max theoretical combustion efficiency are you, and then what's your
7:42nozzle efficiency, which is really you know, are you straightening the flow, and shooting the molecules out in a straight line, so that you go in the other direction, Newton's Third Law. - Yep. - With a traditional combustion chamber, you can get to a very high combustion efficiency,
8:03cause the molecules are all sort of bouncing around in there, they've got a time to combine and do their thing, and then when you sort of choke it through the throat, you know, it, that gives them sort of more opportunity to combine, so you can Like, we think we can probably get to 90, certainly
8:2198.5, hopefully 99 percent of theoretical combustion efficiency. This is so if, God himself came and knitted together the molecules, you're one percent better, okay maybe one and a half percent better, that's so, that's very high efficiency. - Because of full flow staged combustion.
8:36- Full flow staged combustion, exactly, you've got a gas-gas interaction, so you've got two hot gases combining - Yeah. - And with a relatively simply reaction, the only thing that would be simpler would be hydrogen. But you've got CH4 and O2, that's pretty simple, you don't have any long chain hydrocarbons, you know, with kerosene you've got the long chains, they've gotta break down, they've gotta recombine, it's a total soup, you know.
8:58Yeah, it's a part like dinner situation. It's very hard to get high combustion efficiency with kerosene, so when you look at the, say like, "What's the theoretical value of, say a Lox kerosene engine, as compared to a methane engine?" The kerosene actually looks more compelling than it really is because you can't achieve the high combustion efficiency with kerosene that you can with methane.
9:23So, you actually want to say, "What is the actual achievable combustion efficiency times the theoretical chemical energy?", that's the real number, and this is where methane starts to look really good. - Yeah, yeah. - It's like, very hard to get to like 96 percent combustion efficiency, or even 95 percent combustion efficiency with kerosene, but with methane you can get 98 easy, 99 with a little bit of difficulty.
9:44- And, so you don't think, you're just telling me now, spoiler alert, you're probably never gonna see a full flow staged combustion cycle aerospike engine produced by SpaceX? - You know, if somebody can show that we're wrong, that would be great. If somebody can explain, "Wow, you've got a, there is a way to make your design better", this is a gift.
10:04- Right, right, right. - "Thank you for this great gift, wow, this is awesome". It's definitely like, the worst thing would be like, "We wanted to do this dumb design, and stick with our dumb design", that would be insane. - Right. - I would love it if somebody could show how an aerospike is the smart move, in which case, we'll just do an aerospike.
10:24- Yeah, then just do an aerospike; there's a reason they haven't been used. (chuckles) Period. - But maybe, that reason is not valid, you know? 'Cause there's also, there hasn't been a methane orbital engine. - Right? Or a flying full flow staged combustion, yeah. - So, there's been neither a full flow staged combustion engine that's seen flight, nor has there been a methane engine that's seen flight, certainly in a rocket scenario, I think there may have been some like, little test things or whatever, but no actual rockets.
10:54So, but I'm very confident that CH4 is the right fuel. Maybe aerospike is, is right, even though it's not been done before, but you just have to show that your combustion efficiency is not affected, and that you're, and that you're straightening the flow sufficiently. - To get your expansion ratio - Yeah - Yep, awesome.
11:22- Also, if you've got a two-stage rocket, like I think like, this is the other thing like, you've got two-stage rockets where your boost stage is primarily in atmosphere, and your upper stage is primarily in vacuum, then you can specialize the, for a vacuum nozzle and a sea level nozzle, and then you're like, "Why need the aerospike?" It's only if you do want, if you want to try to do single stage, reusable, then that's when you start like having to reach for the aerospike.
11:47- Right, yep, that's awesome. Aerospikes, with Elon Musk! Thank you so much. - I would love it if somebody could show it like, "Hey, you're missing the mark, you could do this different thing, and this would be a better move", that would be, thank you, please. - Right, yeah of course, absolutely.
12:00Hey,thanks for your time again, see you soon, pleasure meeting you. (voices in background) Oh yeah, we might need to steal your mic, I mean, I don't know, I can bill you later. Thanks again for this - Absolutely. - I have to say, I've been to IEC 2016, seeing, that was like, it was almost like awkward back then cause it was like, - "You're insane", and now it's like, "Hey look, I'm not insane." (laughs) - Well, you know obviously I'm sane, but you know, I mean...
12:27(background chatter) Even when I am exposed to this all day, it's so like "Holy Smith!" you know, it's so mad, you know, to see it actually there, and I was up in the nose, and I mean I'm gonna post this later but... - Jack Buyer's photo, Beyer he got a photo of you like, I think like peeking out of it.
12:51- Well, like this is the, when I was inside there - Oh, shoot, no way! Aw and those are the header tanks? - Yeah. - And all the batteries got, what six... - They've got four Tesla 100 kilowatt hour batteries. - Yes! - And we just like, basically welded it on to the header tanks.
13:10- Right. - Oh we didn't even talk about that, you're doing model three motors basically, is that? - Yeah, for that, I mean, I don't love the, I think we should, we should just have electro-mechanically I think we are going to, probably with Mach three, move to a purely electro-mechanical actuators for the valves.
13:28Currently, it's electric motors powered, it's like Tesla motors and batteries that essentially pump hydraulic fluid into the accumulator and then the hydraulic piston moves the valve. But it would be simpler to just have the motors directly- - Just do it - Kind of worm drive the valve.
13:50- That's awesome. - And also the way the header tanks are done right now is crazy, we shouldn't be carrying the header tanks like cargo, I mean, we want the header tanks to be integral to the tip, so seriously, like just take the tip, use the tip of the rocket as the half of the header tank,
14:06and essentially mirror the main tanks, but in small form, in the nose. So, just have two domes - Yeah. - And have the oxygen and fuel in the tip of the rocket, not as, not carrying the tanks like cargo, but having the tanks- - Just integrated, right? - Yeah, just a mini version of the big tanks - Right, oh, and then you don't have an extra wall and everything too, it's just integrated into, yeah, yeah, yeah, gotcha.
14:34- Like in the early days of rocketry, like V2 or whatever you know, like the fuel and oxygen tanks were carried like cargo in the aeroshell. - Oh really? - Yeah. In the early days of aircraft and rockets, the propellant tanks were carried like cargo - Right. - now modern rockets, modern rockets and airplanes, like the wing is just a fuel tank in, in wing shape.
14:54- Yeah, yeah, yeah. - Yeah, we should do the same for the header tanks. - I love it, thanks again. - Thank you. - Thank you guys. (laughs) Sorry, I didn't mean to keep him so long I guess. - [Man] Why're you looking at me? (laughs) - [Man] Was, was I rushing you out? - (laughs) No, not at all.
15:14- [Man] With everything at the end, "Come on!" - I'm just trying to kick him outta here, you know? Wasting all my time tonight, just kidding. so that was awesome! Actually, we've still got a lot more questions to get answered, and stick around 'cause I'll have a lot of content explaining some of the topics we talk about, and sorry about the whole like, thing on aerospikes, I wasn't planning to release all that 'cause that's for a video I've been working on, but whatever, I guess you get an aerospike video spoiler today, my bad.
15:42Sorry in the interview I didn't really get much time to talk about like heat shields, or the super heavy booster, or what the interior of Starship might look like, but, maybe if we're lucky Elon will continue to update us on Twitter, or, Elon, you can always come talk to me any time about all the nerdy stuff you want, I love it, I think you did too.
16:00I owe the biggest thank you to my Patreon supporters, you guys have helped take this little passion and hobby, into a career, it wouldn't be a career without you guys, so thank you so much for your support. If you want access to more behind-the-scenes things and exclusive content and access, please consider becoming a Patreon at www.patreon.com/everydayastronaut Thank you guys.
16:19And if you want your own full flow staged combustion cycle shirt or other really cool, nerdy, aerospace stuff, I've got you covered, go over to www.everydayastronaut.com/shop, and if you work in the aerospace industry, click on the link below in the description of the apparel that you want, click on that, you can get 25 percent off as my thank you to you for inspiring me to do what I do, I wouldn't be doing any of this stuff if you weren't doing crazy things to get humans off this planet, so thank you guys.
16:45It's www.everydayastronaut.com/shop. Thanks everybody, that's gonna do it for me, I'm Tim Dodd, the Everyday Astronaut, bringing space down to Earth for everyday people. (upbeat music)
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版