马斯克自己给星舰那次试飞估的成功率,只有20%到25%。
他说的是两个目标要同时达成:超重型助推器和飞船都得在海上完成软着陆。他心里盘算,两样全中的概率两成出头。结果两样全中。
用他的原话说,团队完成了他认为不太可能完成的任务,SpaceX 里那批火箭工程师,是他见过最有天赋的一群人。
这条消息本身是工程新闻,算不上稀奇。值得多想一层的是他紧接着的那套思路:爆炸不算失败,爆炸是快速把真实问题逼出来的手段。炸一次,暴露一批地面测试模拟不出来的工况,改掉,再炸,再改。
他把这套东西用在了火箭上,也用在了公司管理上,还顺手拿去评价监管、政府和文明本身。
45亿年的地球,文明只占了最后那一丁点
有人问 SpaceX 的终极目标是什么。马斯克没直接答,先绕去了费米悖论(Fermi Paradox)。
恩里科·费米(Enrico Fermi)当年问的那个问题很朴素:如果宇宙里到处都可能存在智慧生命,为什么我们一个信号都没收到?
马斯克说他经常被问到地球上有没有外星人。他的回答是,他没看到任何外星人存在的证据,一旦看到,他会第一时间发到 X 上,那会是史上传播最广的一条帖子。现场笑了。
玩笑之后是推论,这才是他真正想说的。
地球大约45亿岁。人类有文字记载的文明,按最早的文字算,只有大约5000年,把前文字阶段也算上,5500年左右。他把这个数字当成文明的起点。
5500除以45亿,得出的结论是:文明只占地球历史的百万分之一。
这个比例的含义在于,它提示文明可能是短暂的、脆弱的,而不是一件理所当然会一直延续下去的事。宇宙给了地球45亿年,人类文明只占了最后那一丁点时间,前面99.9999%的时间里,什么都没有发生。
想通这一层,“多行星物种”这个听起来像科幻小说的目标就不显得中二了。
它是在给文明买保险。地球出一次大问题,人类不至于一次性清零。马斯克说,让意识延伸到其他行星,最终延伸到其他恒星系,能大幅提高人类和意识的预期寿命。
他还把话说得很直白:造这么巨大的火箭,运力远远超过把卫星送上近地轨道的需要,因为它压根就是一台行星殖民机器。目标是尽可能快地在火星上建成一座自给自足的城市。
然后他说了那次对话里最冷的一句:这件事在跟全球热核战争或者某种大灾变赛跑。
如果在自给自足的火星城市建成之前,我们就遇上某种终结文明的灾难,那就完了。也许未来某个外星文明会发现我们的遗迹,然后说,他们差一点就到了。(马斯克)
“差一点就到了”。这五个字把整套论证的分量压出来了。
答案是最容易的部分,难的是问题
这个目标背后还有另一层动机,和一本小说有关。
马斯克说他小时候有过一段存在主义危机,反复琢磨人生意义是什么,翻了很多哲学书和宗教书。最后让他觉得最通透的,是道格拉斯·亚当斯(Douglas Adams)的《银河系漫游指南》(The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy)。
书里的设定是,地球其实是一台巨型计算机,专门用来算出“生命、宇宙以及一切终极问题的答案”。算了很久,最后算出来的数字是42。
麻烦在于,没人知道最初的问题是什么。
马斯克从这个设定里读出的东西是:答案往往是最容易的部分,难的是提出正确的问题。我们连该问什么都不知道。
如果我们扩大意识的规模和范围,我们就更有能力搞清楚,面对“宇宙”这个答案,我们究竟该问什么问题。(马斯克)
所以他给出的终极目标落在概率上,没落在某个具体产品上:把所有能提高“未来会变好”这个概率的动作,按优先级排出来,一件件做。
这句话单看很空,把它拆开就具体了:让生命多行星化,搞清楚宇宙是怎么回事,顺带在路上赚够做这些事的钱。
星链(Starlink)在他眼里就属于第三类。它是一套建在太空里的互联网系统,是给“扩展意识”这个目标供血的现金流。他把话说得很清楚:任何跟太空相关的业务,都是为了筹钱,把意识送出地球。
他真正在管的公司,其实只有两家
主持人问他手里到底有几家公司。他的回答是六家上下,真正吃掉他绝大部分时间的只有两家:特斯拉(Tesla)和 SpaceX。
规模差得很远。特斯拉大约14万人,SpaceX 大约1.5万人,其余几家都只有几百人或更少。
X 平台他不负责日常运营,那是琳达·亚卡里诺(Linda Yaccarino)在做。他自己抓的是产品开发和功能迭代这一类事。
这个澄清有意义。外界习惯把他看成一个同时在六条战线上作战的人,实际上他的注意力高度集中在两处,其余的要么是规模很小的实验,要么是已经交给别人管的资产。
主持人接着抛出一个更刁钻的角度:除了这几家公司,他还在对付第七个东西,监管和官僚体系。把人送上火星难,那是字面意义上的火箭科学;可火箭科学好歹有物理规律可循,审批流程没有。
一百万根细绳子,把格列佛捆在地上
聊到监管,他的语气变了。
他的基本观察是,长期繁荣会自然带来法规堆积。因为长期没有大战,日子过得顺,法规就一层一层往上加。人是有寿命的,法规没有。
他用了一个比喻:每一条法规单独看都不致命,它们像一根根细绳子,一百万根细绳子把格列佛捆在地上。每根绳子都很轻,捆到一定数量,巨人就动不了了。
在西方,我们制造出了一种监管僵局,几乎什么事都变得不合法。(马斯克)
他举的例子是加州高铁。
项目花了70亿美元,最后拿得出手的成果是一段1600英尺长的路段,上面连轨道都还没铺。他说这事已经荒诞到连讽刺剧都写不出来了。
他的判断是,在加州,大型项目的实质状态就是“不合法”。法律没有明文禁止,真正发生的是审批、诉讼、听证、环保评估这一整套流程叠加起来,让事情在物理上做不成。欧洲和不少国家也有类似的病灶。
要改这个状态,他提了两条机制。
第一条是设立专门删法规的部门。要的动作是删除,审查解决不了问题,定期把过期、冗余、没人敢碰的旧规定清出去。
第二条是给新法律加日落条款。新法规通过时设定有效期,到期自动失效,需要重新表决才能续命。
这两条为什么推不动,他自己也给了答案:法规一旦立起来,围绕它会长出一个咨询行业的生态,这个生态靠法规吃饭,天然有动力让它永远不变。环保领域的法规尤其如此,这是他原话里的判断。
把“事先许可”换成“事后罚款”
他把矛头具体指向了环保监管。
他先强调自己支持环保,然后说现行的环保监管运作方式很糟糕。问题出在形态上:这套制度是“事先许可制”,你要动工,得先花三到四年走完审批,拿到许可才能开始。
他提的替代方案是“事后追责制”:你先干,出了问题再罚。
这两种制度的激励结构完全不同。
事先许可制下,审批方的最优策略是拖和否。批错了要担责,拖着不批几乎没有成本。于是所有项目都卡在审批这一环,三四年时间就这么没了。
事后追责制下,动手的人有动力把风险控住,因为出了事要自己掏钱。同时,审批环节的拖延成本消失,项目节奏回到了做事的人手里。
把制度从“事先必须拿到许可”改成“做错事必须付罚款”,对推动大型项目会非常有效。(马斯克)
他还顺带表扬了阿根廷总统米莱(Javier Milei)。米莱在阿根廷干的事,就是拿电锯对着政府部门一路砍下去,砍掉整个部门,砍掉整批审批。马斯克说,米莱这件事干得非常漂亮,砍掉整个部门,太棒了。
然后他补了一句很关键的逻辑:
如果你删掉一个部门和一批法规,事后发现有些其实很重要,你随时可以加回来。(马斯克)
这句话是给所有不敢删的人准备的。删除可逆,不删不可逆。删错了加回来,成本无非是折腾一次;不删,成本是长期被绑住,动弹不得。
他把法规体系比作一个没有垃圾回收机制的系统。所有文明都需要一个定期清运的流程,否则血管会硬化,硬化到最后什么都做不了。
删完没被迫装回去10%,说明你删得还不够
聊到公司里怎么做减法,他讲了一套自己反复用的流程。他说这是犯过太多次同样的错之后总结出来的,现在还得反复对自己念,才能少犯错。
顺序是这样的:
- 先把需求本身改得不那么蠢。需求错了,后面做得再对也是白费,最好的结果无非是把错的问题答对了。
- 能删的零件、能删的流程,先删掉。
- 然后才是简化和优化。
- 再往后是加快循环速度。
- 最后才是自动化。
他强调顺序不能乱。很多团队的通病是一上来就搞自动化,把一个本来就不该存在的流程自动化了,等于把错误固化成一堵墙,撞上去还得重修。
关于删,他给了一个很具体的判断标准:
如果你删完之后,没有被迫把至少10%的东西装回去,说明你删得还太保守。(马斯克)
这句话反过来听更有意思。删过头是正常状态,删得刚刚好反而说明你压根没敢下手。人在删东西时天生偏向保守,删到刚好合适的概率很低,删不够的概率很高。所以他给的门槛是:删到必须往回装一点,才算删够了。
还有一条更细的要求:每个需求都得挂上提出它的人名。
挂了名字,你才能去问那个人当初为什么提这个要求。绝大多数要求都是多年前某个部门某个人随口定的,定的时候有当时的理由,那个理由今天早就不成立了,要求还在,没人敢碰。挂上名字,就是给这个要求装一个可以追溯的把手。
他的底层信念是:真正不可协商的只有自然规律,其余的规定都是人的建议,建议就可以被质疑、被修改、被删掉。
政府是一家永远不会破产的垄断公司
有人问政府在经济里该扮演什么角色。
他的回答是,政府像一场足球联赛的组织方,负责定规则、当裁判,确保场上公平,球该由市场来踢。
问题出在政府的规模会一直长。长到某个点,场上的裁判比球员还多,这场球就难看了。
裁判是需要的,我没说不需要裁判。但你不希望裁判比球员还多,那太荒唐了。可现实经常就是这样。(马斯克)
他把政府比作公司,而且是终极形态的那种:体量最大的公司,同时是垄断的。
普通公司做不出好产品会破产,这是外部强制的纠错机制。政府不会。除非整个国家破产,否则它不会因为服务差而消失。
他拿车管所(DMV)举例:效率低得离谱,但你不会想让车管所来造车。你也没得选,服务再差也得去,投诉也没地方投诉。
竞争催生卓越,因为至少有两家组织在抢着让同一个消费者满意。谁做得更好,谁就拿到更大的市场份额。(马斯克)
这是他全部论证里最基础的一块砖。他习惯用反馈回路来看待一切:一个系统能不能自我改良,取决于它有没有真实、及时、无法回避的反馈。市场有,因为用户会走、收入会掉、对手会追上来。政府缺少,因为用户走不了。
没有反馈,就没有改进的压力。改进的压力一消失,服务质量只会随时间往下走。所以他的结论是,政府应该尽量少做事,原因在于它自带一个坏掉的反馈回路。
这套逻辑还能反过来用:判断任何一个组织有没有自我改良的能力,就看它有没有真实的反馈回路。有没有用户流失,有没有收入下降,有没有竞争者。三样都没有的组织,不会自己变好,只会自己变胖。
言论自由的核心是一台公开运转的纠错机器
谈到买下推特,他的切入点和别人不太一样。他很少停在“言论自由是天赋权利”这个抽象层面,他谈的是机制。
他说一个平台上一定会有人说错话,这不可避免。真正要看的,是说错之后会发生什么。
在 X 上,有人说错,下面有人回复,有人引用,有人补上缺失的背景。读者翻完整个帖子,能看到原话、反驳、再反驳。这个过程本身就是一台公开运转的纠错机器。
传统媒体的结构不一样。一篇报道发出去,你只看到记者的判断,看不到反驳,看不到评论区里更懂行的人指出的硬伤。
很多时候报纸上印的东西完全是假的,但读者不知道。(马斯克)
他还专门讲了社群笔记(Community Notes)的设计。这个功能的核心机制是:一条笔记要挂到帖子下面,必须由平时立场对立的两拨人同时认可。
这个设计巧妙的地方在于,它利用了人的对立本身。
立场对立的双方,只有在某个说法足够明显、足够硬的时候,才会同时点头。任何一方觉得有争议,笔记就挂不上去。所以最后能挂上去的笔记,准确率相当高。他说这是社群笔记全部的秘密。
有人抬出那句老话:脑子敞得太开,垃圾也会往里飞。他没有否认平台上会有难听的东西甚至有害的东西出现,他的回答还是那套机制:让错误暴露在公开的对话里,让纠错过程可查,让读者看到全过程,而不是只看到经过筛选的结论。
他认为最被低估的风险,是出生率
最后主持人问他对人类进步是否乐观。
他先说技术层面确实在往上走,势头还不错。然后话锋一转,说他真正担心的是另一件事。
出生率。
他觉得这是被严重低估的问题,而且在几乎所有的国家都在加速下滑。
如果没有人类,就没有人类文明。你得想办法把人造出来。(马斯克)
他的逻辑很朴素:所有关于政策、制度、价值观的讨论,都建立在“还有人类”这个前提上。前提没了,后面全是空谈。除非我们打算把这一切都留给机器人。
他承认自己也没有好办法。但他提了一个方向:
给人希望,让人相信未来会变好,他们才会愿意让更多新的人来看看这个未来。(马斯克)
主持人顺着这个往下推:乐观本身就是一种生产力。人对未来有信心,才愿意投资长期的、回报在几十年后的事情,才愿意生孩子。
扩张主义与灭绝主义的底层对撞
顺着这个话题,他讲了一个更底层的对立。
他说极端环保主义里有一种倾向,把人类看成地球表面的一层瘟疫,暗示人类消失之后地球会更好。他把这叫做“灭绝主义”。
在他看来,真正的分野不落在左和右,落在“扩张主义”和“灭绝主义”的对撞上。
如果人类灭绝了,或者文明崩溃了,我们有什么政策都无关紧要。(马斯克)
这句话把前面所有话题串成了一条线。
为什么要把文明送上火星,因为要给文明买保险。为什么要删法规,因为细绳子捆住了巨人。为什么要保住言论自由,因为需要一台纠错机器。为什么担心出生率,因为所有讨论都建立在人还存在这个前提上。
这条线再往下推,就是他给整场对话收的那个尾:先有扩张主义,先有文明的延续,其他的争论才有意义。
主持人最后用一句话总结:那就去繁衍吧,在一个自由的文明里繁衍。
马斯克说,对。
这九条可以直接搬走
这场对话的价值不在惊人之语。他讲的东西大多不新,很多是他重复过多次的老观点。
有价值的是那几条可以拿去就用的思考工具。它们不依赖你有几家公司、有多少钱,也不依赖你在哪个行业。
下面几条可以挑着用:
- 任何项目启动前,先把需求本身审一遍。每个需求都要能追溯到提出它的人,追不到人的需求,默认可以删。
- 改造流程时先删,别先优化。优化一个不该存在的流程,是在给错误装上轮子,跑得越快,错得越远。
- 删完看结果。如果你一次都没被迫把删掉的东西装回去,说明下手太轻,还能再删一轮。
- 进监管密集的行业之前,把审批周期算进成本。三到四年的许可流程是实打实的现金和时间支出,必须写进商业模型,不能当背景噪音。
- 判断一个组织能不能自我改良,看它有没有真实的反馈回路。没有用户流失、没有收入下降、没有竞争者的组织,不会自己变好,只会自己变胖。
- 看信息时别只读单方陈述。看有没有反驳,有没有补充背景,有没有立场对立的人同时认可同一个事实。社群笔记那套“对立双方同时点头”的机制,可以直接当成日常阅读的检验标准。
- 做重大决定前先问一句:这个要求是谁提的,当初的理由今天还成立吗。多数时候你会发现,理由已经不成立了,要求还在。
- 评估长期风险时,先把人口结构放进第一批变量。其他讨论都建立在人口还在这个前提上,前提破了,剩下的都是细节。
- 给自己留一条可逆的删除通道。想拿掉一个流程、一份周报、一个会议,先停一个月,真需要再加回来。停掉不可逆的东西要慎重,停掉可逆的东西要果断。
0:00[Applause] I'm going to be quick because our moderator doesn't need an introduction to this group and our guest doesn't really need an introduction to any group at Ko we advocate for individual Liberty limited government free markets and peace as part of this we Champion free enterprise markets Innovation and creativity human accomplishment progress
0:33voluntary exchange for Mutual benefit job and wealth creation and economic dynamism and vitality in his role as senior fellow at Ko there are few if any better communicators of these ideas and values than yoan Norberg as his most recent book The capitalist Manifesto aply demonstrates and as one of the most consequential entrepreneurs of our lifetimes there are few if any better exemplars of these things than Elon Musk I'm not going to sit here and recite the list of Enterprises Elon has founded and built most of you know about these rather let's think about the future I'm looking forward with great anticipation to see the things Elon creates and builds in the decades ahead
1:21I'm excited for this conversation where I think we'll hear what Elon thinks about numerous topics and perhaps we'll Identify some areas of both agreement and perhaps disagreement I thank both yoan and Elon for taking the time to be with us and I gladly yield the floor to my colleague Yan [Applause]
1:48Norbert thank you so much Peter thank you all for coming back and thanks to all of you joining us on X live right now but most of all welcome Elon Musk thank you thank you so much for taking the time to speak to us today I know you've got many things on your plate and speaking of that congratulations on the Starship rocket last week and the first soft Landing in the ocean for the world's most powerful rocket vehicle it's a remarkable achievement you are taking the fiction out of Science Fiction can you share with us what your thoughts what thoughts were running through your head when you saw that happening and what's next well I would say I was incredibly excited
2:50that we achieved those Milestones I I thought perhaps we had maybe a 20 or 25% chance of achieving both Milestones where the booster and the ship both both did a soft propulsive Landing in the ocean and so it really was we achieved all the objectives which I thought was unlikely and that's thanks to an incredible team at SpaceX I think we've got the most talented team of rocket Engineers that has ever been assembled and that's that's how we're able to accomplish these things so it's always an honor to work with great people to accomplish great things so what's next in in the final frontier what do you see ahead for
3:35space well the the founding purpose of SpaceX is to develop the Technologies necessary to extend Consciousness beyond Earth so and and and this is sort of a little cerebral but perhaps appropriate for a KO event they're quite cereal but if you think about the sort of FY filters of you know enrio F was always wondered where are the aliens why do we not see signs of them and I frequently get asked are there aliens on Earth and I I I haven't seen any signs of aliens and and I promise you the the minute I see any evidence of aliens I'll immediately post it on the xplatform most popular post of all time so but that but that we haven't actually seen any evidence I'm not aware
4:30of any suggest that Consciousness is extremely rare you know if we believe the archaeological record and the standard model of physics Earth is about 4 and A2 billion years old civilization as measured by the first writing is only about 5,000 years old so archaic pre uniform in roughly 5,500 roughly 5500 years ago was the first writing I think that's a good date for the start of civilization which which means that civilization has only been around for 1 millionth of Earth's existence almost nothing I think this potentially
5:12argues for civilization being fleeting and fragile and so the thing that we can do to increase the probable lifespan of civilization is to be a multiplet species to extend Consciousness to other planets ultimately to other star systems and and this would massively improve the probable lifespan of La of of humanity and Consciousness as we know it so that's it's it's really trying to get past the single planet bomy filter that that's the goal of SpaceX that's why we're building such a big rocket it's far in excess of anything that's needed to put satellites into Earth orbit and and it's really it's a planet colonizer it's intended to build as quickly as possible a self-sustaining
6:07City on Mars and I I think the you know there's it's somewhat of a race between making a self-sustaining City on Mars and global thermonuclear war or some Calamity whichever if if we have some civilization ending ending Calamity before that happens then you know that's that's all they wrote you know that's that's some perhaps some future aliens will discover our civilization and say well they they they almost got there you know so so that that that's
6:43that's the goal I think that's kind of an important thing to convey to people in the in the audience who who think about the future and you know care about the you know the the not just the preservation but the extension of civilization the extent the the growth of of the scope and scale of of Consciousness so yeah so that that's that's that's the goal make life multiplanetary is the goal of SpaceX and you know along the way we'll seek to generate revenue from any space-based activity such as providing you know building an interet internet system in space anything that's sort of space related in order to fund the the extension of Consciousness
7:32Consciousness beyond Earth that makes a lot of sense to me we shouldn't keep all our eggs in one basket we should try to diversify risk so thank you for doing Mankind's work but that's not the only thing you're doing if anyone has missed it you're also revolutionizing electric cars and it's neuralink it's AI the boring company and if you missed that he recently bought Twitter and renamed it X as well where we're live streaming as right now yeah see that's popular with the
8:06audience to to me it's exhausting just to read the list of these things I think what's Al Alex Ferguson the football coach the soccer coach who said that hard work is a talent but it's also hard and it's actually quite exhausting so the question is what's what's the big plan what's the overarching goal is it just that you can't help yourself from getting involved in every technological field or is there an overarching
8:35goal yeah the overarching goal is to take the set of actions that are most likely to improve the probability the future is good and that lead to the the the the the expansion of consciousness and our understanding of the the Universe you know this is somewhat prompted by a you know trying to figure out what's the meaning of life you know
9:06so you know I had this existential crisis when I was a kid trying to figure out like what's the meaning of life is it just pointless like and I read a lot of books on on philosophy and religious books and whatnot and and and ultimately the thing that I felt was most enlightening was dougas Adams hitra sky to the Galaxy where you know Earth basically this giant computer to answer the question of what is the meaning of life and comes up with the answer 42 but but it turns out that actually the answer is the easy part and the hard part is the question but we don't actually know what the right questions to ask so I thought well if we expand the scope and scale of
9:46Consciousness then we're better able to understand what questions to ask about the answer that is the universe the hitchhike is Guide to the Galaxy great book and I advise everyone to read it h maybe you can become the next Elon Musk if you do thank you also Elon for putting the role of the moderator and the interviewer and and on a in the spotlight coming up with the right questions that's that's the most important thing so let me ask you the next question then and try to probe a little bit deeper into what you're really doing because as I understand you you have six companies that you're running but you also have a seven or you
10:24just come up with another one well I really the companies that take up the vast majority of my time are TS than SpaceX so yeah so that and then the other companies are much smaller and I you know I don't run sort of the xplatform day to-day that's Lind acarino I do Drive the product development and the sort of feature Improvement that kind of thing and you know so
11:00that that's really it's it's not like it's a these companies are very different in scale like Tesla's I don't know about 100 40,000 people and SpaceX is about 15,000 people and all the other companies are less a few hundred people or less yeah so very different scales yeah but but apart from that you also have if it's six companies give or take you also have a seventh or what it might be and that's to navigate bureaucracy and regulations while you're doing this and this has been a conference about Innovation and Entrepreneurship and how do we do that that when there's so many obstacles in the way and it I mean it's difficult enough to get to Mars it's
11:46it's rocket science literally but you also have to navigate regulation and precautionary mindset So and I've understood that your style of management is to question every requirement to create Clarity by never accept accepting that it just came from some Department someplace every requirement should come with the name of the person who made it because this makes it possible to question whether it makes sense on the conviction that only nature makes the real laws everything else is a recommendation and that sounds great but I think many politicians and bureaucrats would beg to differ right yeah well with respect to laws and regulation we do have have a fundamental
12:29issue which is a natural outcome of an extended period of prosperity where there's there really hasn't been sort of a global war or you know this when things have been prosperous for a long time you you just get you get an accumulation of laws and regulations naturally and these laws and regulations are Immortal whereas humans are obviously mortal so the longer you
12:56you have this generation of this this this creation of rules and regulations the but you sort of get to this point where you know each law and regulation is not perhaps crippling in and of itself but they're they're all like little strings that that like a million little strings that that that tie Gula down so like each little string and eventually the giant can't move
13:24so in in you know in the west I think we we' have created a regulatory gridlock where just almost everything is illegal this is why they can't build a high-speed rail in California they spent $7 billion and there's a600t section is all they have to show for it and doesn't even have rails on it it's it's really you know too absurd for parody because large projects are
13:54essentially illegal in California so and and and much of Europe and and and other countries so there has to be some garbage collection process for removing rules and regulations in order for society to function and not to you know get a hardening of the arteries just to to the point where you can't do anything and this relates to our risk aversion I think in the classical liberal tradition one important starting point is that we just don't know everything we nobody does so the world is a game of learning and of Discovery and therefore it takes trial and error and experiments to get to the right place and I've realized that when I'm looking at your businesses that you're
14:44not really the risk averse type on the contrary you shouldn't avoid problems but test things fast to find out what the problem is fast and then fix it fast so a rocket blowing up might not be a mistake it might be an important step of leveling up to the next stage of knowledge and of Discovery but that's the total opposite of much of the risk averse culture in many businesses and certainly in in governments so and many are so conservative that they wouldn't allow anyone to do anything for the first time so the question is how do you deal with that kind of risk averse culture what changes
15:28in culture and in regulation would you make to make the world world safe for experiments well like I said at a government level I think that there should be a regulation removal Department and and probably some when when we pass new laws they should have some kind of sunset perhaps that they they need to be reaffirmed before they are or or they just they expire now the thing that tends to happen is that once regulations are passed that an ecosystem of Consultants forms around those regulations that wants to keep them going environmental regulations are particularly bad in this regard so you know and I I I'm very much Pro environment but but the the the
16:27environmental regulations are are are in might view largely terrible and they're they're very much sort of permission based as opposed to you have to get permission in advance as opposed to say paying a penalty if you do something wrong which I think would be much more effective to say like look we're going to do this project if something goes wrong then we'll be forced to pay a penalty but we do not need to go through a three or four year environment environmental approval process so just changing things from
16:59you know you have to get a permission in advance to you have to pay a penalty if you do something bad I think would be profoundly effective for the advancement of of large projects but just in general I think governments around the world should be actively deleting regulations questioning whether departments exist obviously president mle is I think seems to be doing a fantastic job on this front just deleting thing deleting deleting entire departments fantastic
17:31yes you know I mean I mean here here's the thing about like if if you delete departments and regulations you can always put them back it turns out that those were very important you can always put them back and and and really this is like tra taking the breaks of of a an economy and and of a civilization it's it's it's we need to snap those strings that are holding galiva down and preventing us from making progress as a civilization yeah we've been discussing Argentina here over the past few days and the new classical liberal reform agenda and the next speaker here on stage is President mle and of course he's up against Decades of U of of not just
18:19obstacles in general but stagnation but he's coming there with his chainsaw it was a very famous clip of him on social media was when he's looking at bureaucracy and spending and government departments and just removing them one by one a a which I guess means sort of get just get rid of it sure doesn't that remind you of something your own idea about the value of subtraction when it comes to Innovation and business delete any part of the process you can and apparently if you don't end up putting 10% back in you did not delete enough so sorry yeah
18:59there's I I sort of I always I like to use sort of the tools of physics like a first principles approach to things and so the the sort of a a simple algorithm that I developed after making the same mistake over and over gain was and I need to repeat it to myself U so I hopefully make these mistakes less less often is that you start off first by making the requirements less dumb so so you you delete the requirements
19:31as to you know delete and simplify the requirements because if if you don't delete and simplify the requirements you are simply going to get in a in a the best case outcome is the the right answer to the wrong question and then you also now a lot of this involves like sort of technology companies but you want to delete first then then once you've addressed the attempt to delete the part or process step and if you haven't deleted at if you're not forced to put back in at least 10% of what you delete you're obviously being far too conservative in your deletion so but people often afraid to delete things and and I'm like well it's just just just go ahead and do it
20:19and and and if you're not putting a little bit back in you you're just not deleting enough obviously so I really would I think this is a very big deal if if is over over overd delation of rules and regulations and you'll end up putting a few back and that's fine yeah I told you he's not risk averse right you follow think it's pretty sensible it's just sensible really I I think it stands the test of logical examination and to me that seems to be what president mle is trying to do in Argentina as well to delete what's not absolutely essential to leave space for creativity and and Entrepreneurship you've met him repeatedly you've seen what's going on in Argentina do you have
21:09any thoughts about that his Ambitions how important it is for Argentina and possibly for the rest of the world with a case right here right now well I I think it is very important that Argentina succeed and that we give president M for support and I I think this yeah and and my prediction is that unless president mle is is stopped in some way from taking the actions that he wants to take that that Argentina will have a massive growth in the economy and there will be formal
21:52prosperity and an optimism about the future than there ever there has been perhaps in 100 years [Applause] and in in just 10 minutes mle will we'll talk about those things from this stage would you be able to give him some advice if he wants to turn Argentina into an innovation and Entrepreneurship Nation again what how should he go about it well I from everything I've read he's he's making the Right Moves I would just encourage the people of Argentina to give him their full support run this experiment because clearly the things the policies of the past have have not succeeded we know that for a fact so let us let us I think go boldly into the
22:44future you know I hope people of AUD to give him their full support and and I think it'll be a very exciting adventure and I think it's going to work out really well [Applause] could I just then broaden that question about Innovation and the future of economies because right now it seems like active industrial policies all the rage not just in the old left but sometimes in the populist right as well the idea that governments should get heavily involved and pick certain winners in business and in technology they all often talk about trying to come up with government Moon shots to create the the future which I find a little bit ironic because the
23:35landing a man on the moon was great but it didn't give us any kind of industry we didn't see internet from the space no Moonbase no asteroid mining no solar power in space because it was political and not commercial so and because it was political it was okay to spend tons of money but it also made it unsustainable in the future it only became a commercially viable final frontier when SpaceX got into the race so it it could you tell us about how you see government's role in Innovation generally I mean you were the guy who had to sue NASA to get them to open up as space to to private providers as well what is the government's role in building the future of
24:23technology I I think the government's role is is is really the it it's to ensure that the playing field is a good playing field that the rules that that there are good rules the government is essentially the you know the football league like the the the referee the you know making sure that that there's fair play that
24:46like I said that the rules are sensible and allowing the players on the field to play the game and what happens over time though is government keeps growing and and at a certain point you have more referees players on the field and and then the game is not good yeah you do need referees I'm not saying you don't need referees but but you don't want the referees to outnumber the players that would be silly but that's often what happens so it's just make sure that that that that the player that the fair games are being played that the that are sensible rules and I think and don't get on the way of the players and the results will be excellent when we met in Austin recently
25:32you talked about socialism as a concept and the problem that when the government gets too heavily involved you lose the feedback mechanisms that really force them to continue to learn improve and do things better all over again would you be willing to share those thoughts with the audience yeah you know like another way you think the government is like a corporation in the limit it is the most it is the biggest corporation and it is a monopoly and and one that can really can only go bankrupt if the country goes bankrupt so it doesn't have the the sort of you know commercial corporations if the if they make bad products fail to compete then they will
26:16go bankrupt and and they should if they make bad products so government is essentially Corporation in the limit and and since it is Monopoly and and there's there's no there's just you can think of like like I think one way you think of economy is just in terms of feedback loops and the feedback loop for government provided services to be excellent is weak because if like if you have if you have a a Government monopoly or anything what do your you as a consumer have no Alternatives you have no means of like you know I would sort of say
26:55like you say think of the Department of Mo Motor Vehicles like the DMV you know and and and it's it's very inefficient you wouldn't want the DMV to make cars you know yeah and and if if you don't get good service from the government what do you do who do you complain to what and you just you know
27:15competition breeds Excellence because two organizations or more organizations are fighting to make the end consumer happy and one will gain market share if they do a better job than the other so that's why we really want government to do the least because it because it's just got the broken feedback loop for
27:39improvement right AA so we only have four minutes left so but I'd like to pick your brains on a couple of topics one of them being free speech you bought Twitter partly to as you've said described it to save an open platform to save free speech and that's very laudable but of course there are also tradeoffs the old saying goes if you keep your mind sufficiently open people will throw a lot of rubbish into it so obviously when we have free speech we'll get some ugly stuff as well even toxic can you talk about why to you it's so important to save freedom of speech for to you and for society and the progress of society yeah well for a platform like
28:27the platform forly known as Twitter there will be things that are said that are that are incorrect but it provides an immediate feedback loop for correcting that things that are wrong so somebody says something well then another person can reply and reut what that person's saying there can be just an ongoing sort of dialogue or argument to and and someone can read the whole thread and see okay this person said something but somebody counteracted that there was further rebuttals there was more Contex added and and that will give them the best understanding of the situation as compared to say a legacy news media article where it's you just have the opinion of the reporter no
29:08rebuttal no comments no no no counterargument and very often what's what printed in the Press is completely false and people don't know but on a on a real-time interactive platform like X like they can see the like I said they can see the not just what somebody said but what are the rebuttals what the counter arguments and we've got things like Community notes which I think is very helpful where if something somebody says something false or or sort of inacurate or misleading then the the the sort of the core secret to community notes is that for a note to be attached to a post people who normally disagree about a subject must agree on that on that Community note for
29:51it to be shown so the probability of it being accurate is is very high because people who historically disagree are are only going to agree on something that is quite accurate so it's all down to feedback loops basically so yes you've been remarkably generous with your time so I'll just give you a last question possibility for some last thoughts it seems to me that your Take On The World Is that progress doesn't happen by itself it's not automatic after the moon landing we went back from the final frontier for half a century and Argentina has been stagnating for almost a a century by now it takes human agency someone's got to do it and in the light
30:35of that are you optimistic about human progress and if so what are you optimistic about and what do you think that people are listening today and and think tanks like the Kato Institute can do to speed progress up well it it does seem as though like Civilization is reaching New Heights in technology and and and I think we've got quite a bit bit of momentum I I do worry about certain existential risks like the low birth rate which is accelerating in in most countries you know and really this is one of those things that I think is underrated as an issue is that if there no no no humans there's no Humanity they you have to make them somehow and I think we should
31:27should be very concerned about the the U accelerating implosion of of U of the birth rate this is a super big deal like basically nothing else matters if there are no humans like as a first as a initial premise you must have humans for for there to be civilization unless we're going to leave it all to the robots so this I think is is massively massively underweighted and I don't have a great solution to it but it must be solved somehow or Humanity will dwindle to nothing perhaps if we give people a hope and a belief in the future and that it'll get better that they want more people to see it yeah I I agree I think we should we should have an optimistic view of the
32:17future and like like I do think that one sort of bad like bad thing about the environmentalist movement is that the in in the in in the sort of extreme form of the environmentalist movement it you people start to view humans as a plague on the surface of the Earth as a fundamentally bad thing and with the implication that if all humans disappeared somehow Earth would be would be better off this is the extinctionist movement and I think you can you can really at a I think at a a fundamental level you you can think of things as as a a fight between expansionist and extinctionist philosophy and the that that's what really matters like everything else is like
33:05if if if humans if humans go extinct or or civilization collapses whatever policies we may have are irrelevant so first first and foremost we must have an expansionist Philosophy for for civilization and for Consciousness we must seek to you know go go beyond what we've done in the past to increase
33:28the I think increase the number of humans and this is this is incredibly fundamental so one way or another this this must happen yeah so the final message is go forth and procreate yes and go forth and multiply in a free civilization yeah yes well you know time flies and opportunity cost is a concept that's very viable when you're talking to Elon Musk so thank you so much for your time here today and I'm sure you've got other important things to attend to now good luck all right thanks p
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版