媒体·中文精读

2014年SpaceX 3发射后电话会议:马斯克发言

Elon Musk at SpaceX 3 Post Launch Teleconference 2014

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

海况很差,浪高 15 到 20 英尺,回收船连靠都靠不上去。马斯克在电话会议里直说,他不认为这枚助推器能完好溅落。可紧接着他又说,今天是“快乐的一天”。

矛盾就摆在这儿。花那么多功夫去测试回收技术,结果硬件大概率沉海里了,凭什么高兴?

答案在于他们拿到了什么。这场 2014 年 4 月 18 日的 SpaceX 第三次商业补给任务(CRS-3)后电话会议,信息密度很高,谈到的东西远不止“又往空间站送了一船货”。马斯克、NASA 负责载人探索与运营的副署长 Bill Gerstenmaier、SpaceX 任务保证副总裁 Hans Koenigsmann 三个人,把当天发射的细节、回收技术的进展、可复用性的真正门槛、生产瓶颈、后续排期,全摊开聊了一遍。下面挑重点说。

火箭飞得近乎完美,龙飞船先出了个小状况

先看发射本身。

马斯克的说法是,上升段一切正常,“火箭飞行就我们所能判断的而言是完美的”。级间分离、龙飞船分离、太阳翼展开,都顺利。

龙飞船这边有点小插曲。飞船上有几组姿态控制推力器,通向其中两组的隔离阀没有响应,团队切到了备份阀,备份阀工作正常。马斯克说,他离开控制室的时候,飞船上所有推力器都已经正常使能,后续轨道机动在按计划走。

有人追问,这个阀门问题跟去年 CRS-2 任务那次阀门故障有没有关联。马斯克的回答很谨慎:他不认为是一回事,但也不想在拿到全部信息之前做草率判断。当时手里还没有足够数据下结论。

还有记者问发射时火箭侧面那股深色烟柱是怎么回事。Koenigsmann 回答得很实在:发射台周围喷了大量水,结果把脏水溅到了自己身上,看起来像黑烟。“有点尴尬,但没什么问题。”

顺带说一句,这次发射前那几周的天气确实折腾。Gerstenmaier 回忆,整晚闪电预警反复出现,团队提前把推进剂晚加注(late load)的操作做掉了,等于把选择权留在了自己手里,什么时候天气窗口打开什么时候就走。他用了“sporty”形容当时的状况,说这是团队“能行”态度的一次展示。空间站上的航天员甚至看到了这次发射,对从佛州起飞的航班来说,这不太常见。

助推器没捞回来,滚转控制归零才是这次的真收获

回收这段是整场电话会议里信息量最大的部分。

猎鹰 9 号的一级助推器在分离后做了返场点火,尝试受控再入并溅落。马斯克说,他们拿到了从再入段一直到马赫 1.1 左右的数据,数据看着不错。但海况太糟糕,浪高 15 到 20 英尺,船根本靠不近,所以他对“完好溅落”这件事不抱高期望。

他紧跟着解释了为什么这依然算成功。

过去几次尝试里,摧毁助推器的头号问题出在滚转上。箭体再入时气动特性会让它越转越快,箭上那套氮气推力器压不住,最后转散架。这次换了推力更强的推力器,带了更多氮气推进剂,把助推器的滚转速率压到了零。马斯克的原话是“这是好消息”。

另外两件事也顺带验证了:着陆腿在上升段没有任何负面影响;助推器以高超音速再入时撑住了,而且拿到了通过最大动压(max Q)区间的数据。跨音速段的数据还没到手,那正是马斯克最急着想看的一段。

“我们真的开始把该连的点连起来了。结合昨天飞行设计里着陆腿的表现,加上今天助推器取得的进展,只剩几个点还需要补上,整套东西就能跑通。我觉得今年有相当大的机会把一级拿回来。”(马斯克)

他还提到一个细节:这枚助推器其实是朝着预定溅落点飞的,落点精度相当高,只不过那一片海实在没法作业。回收船当天能不能出海去找,取决于安全评估,浪太大就只能在港里等。负责观测的飞机带回数据还要几个小时。

“今年把一级拿回来”这句话在当时听起来有点像画饼,但对照后来的事实,2015 年 12 月猎鹰 9 号首次陆上回收成功,这个时间表说得相当准。

上面级多滑行 35 分钟,为的是摸清推进剂余量的底

这部分容易被忽略,但对任务经济性很关键。

当天的发射还做了一个额外测试:上面级在关机后滑行了大约 35 分钟,然后重新点火几秒钟,一直烧到液氧接近耗尽,最后剩余推进剂的质量约为总质量的 0.15%,非常接近预设目标。

为什么要这么干?因为每次发射都要在推进剂里留余量,应对各种不确定性。余量留多了,运力就浪费了;留少了,风险就上去了。把余量的真实边界摸清楚,等于给未来的任务性能余量计算挤出更多空间,说白了就是同样的火箭能多送货,或者送更重的货。

马斯克把这次测试称为“有点像可选动作”,纯粹为了拿数据。这种思路贯穿整场会议:能顺手验证的,就顺手验证掉,别浪费一次飞行机会。

复用的门槛:快,而且完整

有记者问了一个很到位的问题:航天飞机的部分部件也是可复用的,航天飞机很了不起,但没人会说它便宜。那 SpaceX 的复用凭什么不一样?

马斯克的回答把问题拆得很清楚。

“复用的效果要大,必须同时满足两个条件:快速,且完整。就像飞机或者汽车那样。如果你的车每开一次就得拆开、重装、换发动机零件,那开车会贵得离谱。”(马斯克)

所以 SpaceX 的目标不止是把一级收回来,还要证明它能快速且容易地重新飞,两次飞行之间唯一要换的就是推进剂。马斯克说,火箭从设计之初就是按这个思路做的。

关于航天飞机为什么没做到,他的解释是:航天飞机最初的设计其实相当适合复用,后来需求变了,改来改去,变得很难高效复用。原始设计要求被一路追加的指标挤到墙角,最后剩下的只是“零件可以再用”这个表面特征。这段历史对做产品的人有参考价值,项目早期定下的核心约束,得有机制守住。

时间表上,他的判断是:今年至少能把助推器收回来,复飞可能要到明年。只要今年回收成功,明年再飞一次是大概率事件,那时候一级火箭这条线就算闭环。

全年 10 次发射,卡在一个喷注器铸件上

记者问,前面几周连续推迟,会不会影响全年发射数量。马斯克说,全年 10 次的目标应该还能保住,“或者非常接近 10 次”。

真正的约束不在发射台,在产线。他明确讲,主要瓶颈是火箭生产速度,具体卡在一个部件上:喷注器铸件。这个问题他们认为已经解决,解决之后产能可以拉到一个相当高的水平。

关于连续推迟本身,马斯克的表态挺坦诚。这次火箭和龙飞船的航电都做了大幅修改,龙飞船换了新软件,火箭加了着陆腿、改进了氮气推力器,所以推迟有客观原因。但他也说得很直白:

“未来我们希望做到分秒不差地准时发射,彻底摆脱推迟。这不是我们想要的状态。”(马斯克)

Koenigsmann 补充了另一层原因:这次任务的窗口约束特别多。空间站要避开推进剂补加、舱外活动、联盟号发射和返回的档期,龙飞船的再入轨迹还要对上加利福尼亚海岸的位置。火箭、天气、硬件加上这些轨道相位约束叠在一起,能把一次发射凑出来本身就很难。

会议里还提到,奥博康(OrBcomm)的那次发射预计在四到六周内进行。马斯克强调,虽然这次一切顺利,但还是要仔细复盘数据,看有没有接近事故的“擦边”情况需要纠正,目前没发现什么,但不能跳过这一步。

下次还是往水里落,陆上着陆场还在挑

有记者问,下一次会不会直接尝试陆上着陆。Koenigsmann 的回答是:下一次还是水上溅落。现阶段真正想要的是数据,数据才能告诉他们要改什么,才能把技术一步步推下去。他也承认,团队当然希望助推器能完整回来,但数据的优先级更高。

陆上着陆场已经在看了,方向是佛罗里达海岸一带,卡纳维拉尔角附近,但还没有定论。有记者追问,猎鹰重型一次要回来三个助推器,场地怎么安排。Koenigsmann 承认这是个挑战,目前还在评估最佳着陆点。

同一场会议里还确认了另一件事:猎鹰重型首飞的地点从范登堡改到了肯尼迪航天中心的 39A 发射台,计划 2015 年第一季度首飞。

空域和地面安全的问题也有人盯。SpaceX 的思路是给靶场安全部门提供数据,由他们划定需要的空域和地面范围。Koenigsmann 的判断是,需要的范围跟火箭发射时差不多;返回的助推器里基本是空的,本身是个相对安全的状态。

F9R 测试分两地:低空在德州,高空在新墨西哥

关于 F9R 开发飞行器(Falcon 9 Reusable Development Vehicle),马斯克讲了测试分工。

他们有两台开发飞行器,dev1 和 dev2。一台放在德州麦格雷戈的测试场,一台放在新墨西哥州的美国太空港(Spaceport America)。

  • 1 万英尺以下的低空测试,继续在麦格雷戈做
  • 高空测试要飞出稠密大气层,冲到 30 万英尺以上,放在新墨西哥做,因为那里需要大得多的净空区域

这套安排背后的逻辑还是那句话:复用只有在快速且完整的前提下才有经济意义,否则省下来的钱抵不上翻修成本。技术要一点一点磨,磨一次飞一次的账,得算得过来才行。

NASA 的账本:补给窗口、备件和轨道科学公司

Gerstenmaier 在这场会议里提供了 NASA 视角的信息,几条值得记下来。

空间站已经为龙飞船的到来做好了准备。下周有一次舱外活动,要更换一个外部数据中继设备(MDM),备件已经就位。龙飞船的货舱里装了两个载荷,包括一个高清晰度地球观测装置和一个光通信包,在轨状态正常,团队已经拍到了它们在货舱里的画面。等它们装到站上开始回传数据,才是真正好玩的部分。

补给节奏方面,Gerstenmaier 用了一个很好懂的比喻。如果一段时间内没有任何消耗品补给,空间站会进入所谓的“跳过周期”(skip cycle),大约 45 天后关键消耗品就会见底。他说这就像汽车的低油量警告灯:灯亮了还能开很远,但那是在提醒你该做准备了。这次龙飞船送到之后,警告线推到秋天;等轨道科学公司的飞船再上去,还能继续往后推。

关于轨道科学公司的下一次发射,NASA 的态度是:在龙飞船周日安全对接之前,仍然要求轨道科学公司按 5 月 6 日的窗口做准备。Gerstenmaier 说自己有点迷信,不想在龙飞船还没靠上空间站的时候就松掉另一条线。等龙飞船对接完成,轨道科学公司再转向 6 月的窗口。

还有个细节值得单独说:NASA 原本打算派一架 P-3 飞机去观测助推器跨音速段的推力器点火,这些数据对火星进入、下降和着陆有用。但当天结冰条件不允许起飞,最后是 SpaceX 自己的飞机抓到了遥测数据。也就是说,火星着陆技术的验证机会,被一场冰给耽误了一次。

这些信息拼起来看

这场电话会议发生在 2014 年,回头看,它几乎是一份路线图的提前披露。

马斯克当时说今年有可能收回一级,2015 年 12 月做到了。他说复飞可能要到明年,猎鹰 9 号首次复用飞行发生在 2017 年 3 月,比预期晚了些,方向没变。他说全年 10 次发射,2014 年实际完成 6 次,目标没达成,卡住的确实是产能。

比预测准不准更值得琢磨的,是 SpaceX 对待失败的方式。助推器沉了,但只要拿到了滚转控制的数据、拿到了 max Q 的数据、验证了着陆腿不影响上升段,这次尝试就算成功。每一次发射都在为下一个版本积累确定性的信息,这跟传统航天“一次成功、失败即灾难”的逻辑完全是两套打法。

另一个容易被忽略的点是上面级那 35 分钟滑行。它不酷,不上头条,但它直接决定了未来每次任务能多带多少货。这种顺手把边界摸清楚的习惯,才是运载效率一年一年往上走的底层原因。

还有那句“快速且完整”。这四个字解释了 SpaceX 后来十年的动作逻辑:为什么不惜代价搞回收,为什么坚持不拆解翻修,为什么星舰要追求像飞机一样的周转。所有关于成本的故事,最后都落在周转时间上。

对做产品、做工程的人来说,这场会议里有几条能直接拿走用的东西:

  • 把“回收”和“复用”拆成两件事看。拿到资产不等于拿到经济价值,中间隔着翻修成本和时间。设计复用方案时先问一句:重新投入使用要多少人、多少天?
  • 发射前就写清楚失败时的成功标准。硬件可能回不来,那就明确哪些数据必须拿到,让每次尝试都有保底收益。
  • 守住项目早期的核心约束。航天飞机的原始设计是可复用的,被追加需求一路改成了半一次性。核心约束要有守护机制,别让它在指标迭代里悄悄消失。
  • 找瓶颈要找到零件级别。产能上不去,问题可能就在一个喷注器铸件上。笼统说“提升产能”没用,把那个具体零件解决掉才有用。
  • 对外沟通时给概率,别给情绪。“我不给高期望”比“我们非常有信心”更让人信服,也给自己留了余地。
  • 顺手做实验。主任务之外能验证的东西,就在同一次飞行里验证掉,边际成本接近零,边际收益可能改变整个产品路线。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:06good afternoon and welcome to today's special space x3 post-launch news conference after the launch of Falcon 9 and Dragon we wanted to get together and and talk about how well the day went we are pleased today to be joined first by elon musk the chief executive officer and founder of SpaceX NASA's associate administrator for the human exploration and operations mission directorate bill Gerstenmaier and hans xmen the

0:37spacex vice president of mission assurance and we'll begin with opening remarks first we'll start in california with mr. musk go ahead please sure so it looks like the everything looks great as far as the ascent phase of the mission and the rocket flight was as perfect as far as we could tell and drag and deploy went well the we had some some slight

1:08initial challenges with with dragon but with respect to enabling some of the thruster quads but those have been resolved so looks like everything's good on on the Dragon front for the rocket boost age reentry we have good data down to a pretty low level to roughly around Mach 1 point 1 everything looks fine and we're waiting additional data to see how the potential landing Boone went but we have a it was a very heavy sea state condition so i would give I wouldn't give high odds but the rocket was able to splashdown successfully ok mr.

1:51Gerstenmaier thanks Mike again I'd like to congratulate the specs SpaceX team on a tremendous launch today they did a lot of great work last night getting ready to to get the rocket ready to go fly with the weather conditions it was kind of sporty for them to figure out exactly when the right time to load the vehicle and get it ready and keep options open and and they just did a tremendous job I would say the entire NASA payloads team as well as the SpaceX team did a tremendous job of getting ready to do the late load they did it early so then that allowed them the option of picking the right time to roll out with all the phase 2 Lightning warnings that were

2:27coming and going throughout the night so thanks to their efforts we got a launch attempt today and the weather happen to be good at lunchtime and we got a good launch so again congratulations to the SpaceX team for showing that can-do attitude and going that extra mile to really work hard to get things ready on board space station we're ready for the dragon arrival that the crew actually reported and talked to Mike a little bit and said they actually got to see the launch so that's pretty exciting when our crew gets to see the launch out it out of Florida so that was encouraging the multiplexer on board space station the repairs of that spare device are

2:58ready so we're ready for the EV a next or deviate next week to go change that external MDM so we're looking forward to all the research coming up on Dragon tremendous things we got to see nice video of the two payloads in the trunk got to see the H stove and the and the optical communication package in the trunk it's pretty cool seeing those on orbit see and there them in the trunk and be really exciting to see them one station and actually operating and bringing data back to us so I look forward to all this research is going on in station the crews are doing a great job things are going well and I really want to congratulate to SpaceX team for

3:30just a wonderful day to day getting ready and keeping up she opened options open they did really really great so thank you Hans yeah that both teams both he and at the cape and back in hawthorne worked very hard over the last couple days to get the vehicle ready and then last night of course we had a we had to do got weather mostly today but there was our primary concern everything worked very beautiful in the end if you got a you got a beautiful launch and we got some some really pretty video from from orbit it's a it's really good day okay thank you we'll take questions now and because we have mr. Moscow on the phone we want to make sure that you make

4:14sure that you addressed to whom your question goes please state your name and affiliation and wait for the microphone and let's start with Marcia Dunn Marcia Dunn Associated Press probably from mr. musk sort of a light question i'm wondering i know-- spacex has the tradition of putting surprises and gifts on board i'm wondering if there's anything in the way of chocolate easter eggs bunnies anything like that given that you'll be arriving on Easter morning I I you

4:44know I don't know of anything to Hunts do we have anything on the I mean it's obviously it's it's you know that NASA is a customer here so I mean we defer to tenacity you know as to what cargo is manifested so yeah and I don't think we put anything on board ourselves but yeah and I don't know of anything it's a surprise and it'll be a surprise for all of us when they open ass but we're a

5:18little delayed in the launch third way I have not yet briefed of anything uniquely that's flying it but I wouldn't be surprised if there isn't something there but I don't know the details of what the teams may have loaded yeah we I know the scientific cargo I don't know the other person nothing from SpaceX that you know of Hans okay fine all right thanks Irene Klotz with Reuters for me lon when you said that you give high odds that the rocket was able to splashdown successfully do you mean in one piece I know sorry I wasn't speaking clearly i said i wouldn't give high odds so the I mean I the sea state is quite

5:56heavy and I heard reports of 15 to 20-foot wave height so it's really pretty pretty crazy out there in fact that the boats weren't even able to get particularly close because of the heavy seas so I think it's going to be it's unlikely that the rocket was able to splashdown successfully but I think

6:21we'll supposed to get good data from the plane telemetry and we should get that pretty soon as soon as we are able to look at that data will be able to provide some more information but I would consider it a success in the sense that we were able to control the blue stage to a 0-0 roll rate which is previously what has destroyed the stages is an uncontrolled a role where the onboard nitrogen thrusters weren't able to overcome the aerodynamic talk and such sort of spun up and this time with more powerful thrusters and more nitrogen propellant we were able to tune all the roll rate so that's that's a good bit of good news there and of course we were able to show that on a

7:13scent that the legs don't have any negative impact and that were able to come back through through hyper sonic velocity not we don't have yet to have the data through transonic but we have it through the d-max dynamic you know max dynamic force coming through the Mac what's called max Q if we have the information of the rocket making it through max Q okay yeah but I'm quite anxious obviously to to find that out and be awesome if as far as it gets that that they will be able to use and flow

7:49back into into the next flight with an increased probability of a successful recovery so we're going to have to probably iterate our way there i think i should mention whether one of the suicide point is that we did we did a longer coast and restart of the upper stage this is a very sort of optional thing just to see what our propound

8:15residuals were and what the environments would be on the stage you know during a it's a depletion shut down and the upper stage coast is for about 35 minutes and then restarted for a few seconds and went to to essentially zero liquid oxygen level with about point one five percent propellant mass of fuel remaining which is very close to our target so that that's helpful for us to

8:47essentially to reduce the uncertainty associated with propellant residuals and thus improve the mission performance margin calculation on future missions Rob Robert Perlman with collectspace.com I guess for Ilan you mentioned having some challenges with the quads can you go into a little more detail and I think you have a burn coming up pretty soon will you be doing that burn well I mean

9:17right now I'm on the phone so I when I left about 15 minutes ago everything was looking good and there was a an isolation valve that leads to of the thruster quads and that that valve was was not responding so we went to the backup valve and that one worked fine so when I after everything was looking good for you know all thrusters enabled on on the vehicle so as far as i know the we're on track to make up on high Ellen

10:01this is stephen clark with spaceflight now mr. question looking ahead for the rest of the year with the trouble getting this rocket off over the last few weeks does this affect how many launches you plan for the rest of the year i believe it was 10 total before this and and also the the thruster pod

10:23issue is it related it all to the issues on crs to last year thanks so I mean I think we think we can probably still do 10 but it's probably if it's particularly telephone town will occur this year the main constraint is actually on vehicle production which and then two and then it will add sort of both down to this one particular part which is a injector casting and we think

10:57we've resolved a particular issue should unlock the enterprise quite a high rate of reproduction and yes a bottom line is that i think we will do 10 or something very close to 10 this year your search obviously it's a launch month slightly better than the launch month and then that we don't get know

11:26enough to say whether there's any commonality between this I that this particular valve and the valve issue and the one that occurred previously I don't think it's the same but you know it's always I want to be careful about making snap judgments until one has all the information so I don't think it's the same but group we don't it yet no we're going to take one more question here before we go to the telephone bridge and then we'll come back for follow-up questions bill bill are with CBS News for mr. musk technical stuff aside I'm just wondering how you're feeling this is the third CRS mission it's off the ground to a good start you've got a

12:07pretty good string going what are your what are your personal thoughts is how are all his mission is not over but I mean at this point anyway thanks I'm feeling pretty excited to him and this is a happy day I mean most important will it is that you know that we did a good job for NASA I mean the you know I always like that's number one thing to do we do a job for our customer so you know that's you know everything else is like secondary to that so this guy were able to do to you know do the job of a contract for or at least as far or doing it seismograph it hasn't get docked with the space station but number 1 i'm super happy that we have made good progress so

12:51far and you know for for our NASA customer so and then on top of that i'm also excited that we got good data through max dynamic pressure the of the re-entry of the boost page and even though we probably won't get the stage back i think we're really starting to put the connect the dots of what's needed when you combine the takeover lining yesterday of the flight design landing legs and the

13:25greater progress of the boot stage on this flight today I mean there's just only a few more dots that needs to be there to have it all all work and I think that that I think it's I think we've got a decent chance of bringing a stage back this year which is which would be wonderful because I think what we've done thus far as it is evolutionary evolutionary improvements but that holds the potential for something more significant all right let's go to the telephone bridge and start off with alan Boyle Alan hi I guess this would be for Ilan or Hans that some people had remarked about a dark plume that that rose up along the side of the rocket and during launch was

14:15that any concern what was going on with that thank you he's on you one I may not know what happened but aren't you aren't you I actually don't know you know I think I heard people say that but I don't know about the root causes at this point in time and collecting water yeah that's so I thought that question might be asked so I looked into it and and we

14:41we sprayed a bunch of water around the pad and we essentially what happened is we splashed dirty water on ourselves so a little embarrassing but no home had done okay still on the phone dan leone from space news dan hi everybody thanks for having the conference call I guess one for NASA and one for SpaceX can we just get a sanity check about when rendezvous and proximity operations are supposed to start from NASA and sort of a big picture question on reusability how far down the road as far as you know doing some back of the napkin calculations have you gotten to see whether the cheapest way to increase long traits and have inexpensive launches is really to fly of stages back

15:36refurb them refuel them and send them back up versus you know maybe just trying to make a dent in the manufacturing side or something like this well start off with the rendezvous question basically the burn got delayed a little bit to burn actually wasn't required but it won't affect the overall rendezvous sequence it'll still be on Sunday pretty much as it's planned there may be a couple minutes of movement but not very much it's really set on lighting conditions so all the rendezvous stuff that we had planned will be pretty much as it's been published pre-flight this is some minor changes and you'll see those through the press kits inserts George asked the

16:17question but what is reef reef I'd likely to do that would just to give it context for example parts of the shuttle were reusable and the shuttle was impressive although I don't think anyone would argue that it was particularly inexpensive true so if there is a step beyond simply reusing something that is important what source of some conditions on reuse in order to make the reuse have a big effect on the space industry which is that the reuse must be both rapid and complete like an aircraft or a car or something like that if you have to disassemble and reassemble a car and change motor parts in between driving it would be make it quite expensive so we

17:09winner is it's true that we don't just have to recover it we have to show that it can be refloated quickly and easily with it will be allocated with the only thing changing being reloading propellant and another extent you know it is basically the coil of refueling so now the vehicle is is sort of designed for that you know the unfortunate thing with the shuttle was that the the original design for the shuttle was but I well well sort of fairly well suited for a good reuse but then the requirements changed and made it very difficult to to reuse efficiently and

17:57you know so as long as we were able to hold to our requirements I think we will be able to achieve the Rapidan and essentially complete reuse and so what I'm hoping what it will occur is and I'm feeling a little bit more optimistic about it is that this year at least we will recover the rocket booster I'm not sure we'll be able to reply it this year but I i think we flying it next year is it is is likely if we recover at this year and and then you know that that will complete the picture at least as far as the blue stage is concerned okay our next question is from Michael Belfiore either question for you on i'm

18:43wondering how far down range the deal was made on how far down range from the cape on reentry sorry but it was been hard to hear i think she said how far down range it's actually not the exact number i think it's it's about four or five hundred kilometres downrange it away from the cape essentially and then the nearest shore is I think two or three hundred kilometres and that's that

19:21main engine cutoff or re-entry or both that's where that's sort of the normal nominal splashdown point which I was headed why I should mention that it was headed quite precisely for the detox by some point so that's a yeah ok the next question is from land simberg random street in head back to

19:55the control room too because hopefully we'll have the aircraft telemetry that I'd like to look at so I'll just be on for another two minutes or so ok let's try miriam kramer Miriam yep miriam kramer space.com so I have one question for SpaceX men another for NASA and I'm wondering you on I think we're the multiple delays challenging i mean was this kind of a test for the team just having to push it back and push it back and push it back and then I'm for for NASA I'm curious does this mean that the orbital launch is officially put off until June Thanks well I was from the

20:41SpaceX enter we yeah there was there were favorite of new things with this rocket and with the dragon avionics this was actually quite a substantial revision of drag navionics for example a new software that accompanied it and across the rock and have the landing legs and improved nitrogen thrusters and a few other things so it was the only just exactly not our you know in the future we want to try to get to what you're launching exactly on time without any delays and and definitely get away

21:16from having delays that's not our aspiration but I think the team did did do a great job of responding to the various issues and I'm certainly very proud of what they've done yeah I think another thing to consider is space station is a pretty tough thing to do the rendezvous with when we look at all the constraints because we had no progress lights coming up we've got some evaa activities coming up pretty quickly we've got the Soyuz landing and Soyuz launch cycle coming up so and then we have to watch the dragon landing and dragon landing has to be against that by orbital mechanics and where space station is and when you undock and where you put the dragon with respect

21:55to the coast of California that's another constraint so you put all those together and that makes space station flights even tougher from a manifesting standpoint so it's not only the hardware and the weather and the normal things with a rocket but then you've got all these unique phasing things that play in and that makes it a pretty tough scenario to get a good launch together and make it work so the team again working last night to protect today's option was tremendously important to us that really worked out well to your question about orbital because I'm superstitious will probably continue to ask orbital keep preparing for May sixth until we get dragon safely attached

22:32station in birth but once Dragon becomes safely attached and birthed on Sunday then we'll release the orbital team but I think until then we'll ask orbital still protect till May and then after that that birthing occurs will then release the orbital team and let them move into the June timeframe our next question on the phone is from Joseph Abbott Joseph Abbott Waco tribune-herald

22:57first I was going to ask if you have a date set now for the orb com launch coming up and I was going to all I was also wanting to know if you could tell me how many more tests on the f Niner development vehicle at macgregor before it moves on to spaceport america new mexico for real on I sure i'll ask my

23:21question then I'm going up to jump with a call so let's see so for the Ofcom launch is expected to happen in the next four to six weeks and you know we want to obviously make sure we review carefully the data from this launch because although I mean everything went fine but we'll review the data to see if there were any near miss near miss issues that need to be looked into and corrected we don't know of anything yet but we want to make sure of that and then regarding the f9r we're going to

23:55have really we're going to keep doing tests Adam aggregate test site near Waco I with the Deaf 9 art stage this is so what we have at in McGregor is the f9 art that it was called up in our dev one which is developing unit one there's dev too and so one of those will be at macgregor one of them will be at Spaceport America in New Mexico and so anything we can test

24:30at a relatively low altitude so below around 10,000 feet will continue to do in in McGregor and and then the high-altitude stuff where it's going except atmospheric and you know going going to sort of 300,000 feet plus and like I think we'll what we're doing in New Mexico's we just need a much bigger clear area but i would expect those those tests to be will continue refining the technology over time because we had posed a question that was asked earlier you know reusability only matters to the degree that to agree that it's a rabbit and complete otherwise it's sort of

25:14reusability but you don't you don't get the equivalent economic benefit that that has a you know huge huge potential to to open up space flight alright thanks the question all right mr. boss thank you for being with us I will try one more time for rand simberg on the telephone r & r you there yes go ahead

25:37with your question please ya feelin still available as it is to him just wondering I'm assuming you're going to try another water landing you're not going to attempt land on any on the next one Duncan's question did you get an update a to give you confidence that you can fly back to land or you're going to try it in the water again and how much of a setback is it that you still haven't actually recovered a stage to see how much where you're actually getting on it unfortunately he had to

26:08hang on I don't know Hans if you would be able to address the question or not I can yeah i think that the next vehicle is going to try a water landing again and honestly I think the data are at this point in time really what we are after and that gives us the clues to to make the any changes or which allows us

26:34to continue this development so I would say we didn't as I said earlier you know we didn't really expect the stages to come back you know or we had you know some hope of course but overall I think the data is much more important to him okay we're back in the room Jason Jason Ryan for Space Flight insider.com this question goes to Hans and I have another one well it's true you didn't get the landing you might have wanted did you see anything in the telemetry data that said okay we were on the right track here or perhaps maybe something made you want to rethink something else online could you talk a bit about that from what I saw basically in the in the

27:15control room and another video it looked it looked great it looked like it's doing what it's supposed to do however that's data on top of that that I haven't seen yet there they eat on the boat or on the airplane and we need to we need those data to come back first and then put them together and see if you can get the full picture basically from lift off to to reentry and and possibly as far as possible into lending so and this was kind of off topic from the day but the other day Gwen shot was here and the announcement was made that LC 39a will be used for falcon heavy and that we expect to see the first launched in the first quarter of 2015 my question

27:54goes that perhaps this is already been answered but up until then I believe the understanding was the first launch will occur out of Vandenberg is that now changed to where the first launch will take place in Kennedy instead of Vandenberg I think so yes okay James James Dean Florida today handsome so I just want to clarify a couple details the the boats I understand weren't able to get close so far today but you are still trying to get out there and and find a booster or is there no point doing that anymore depends on the sea state and and I heard that the sea state is really it's really pretty rough right now I'm sure they think it's safe then they will

28:33you know move towards the stage and take a look also I don't know what the airplane saw those those those data and news basically come back in a couple hours and the source of the telemetry that you're talking about getting back is that the NASA aircraft or where is that coming from no this is basic so a plane just curious of the detail what

28:59was fine if I cuz NASA was also tracking it cursed as well just curious what was up there tracking we're going to have a p3 go fly and our intent was to take a look at the supersonic thruster firings that would occur and we wanted the data because that's applicable to Mars entry descent and landing we were unable to fly the aircraft because of icing conditions so we did not fly our p3 aircraft so it was a SpaceX aircraft that captured telemetry that that Hans is talking about so we didn't get a chance to fly our aircraft ok and and data so far did it show would it have

29:32shown if the landing legs did deploy or is that something that would come later and that that's typically so the data we have right now at this hour basically is the data that we got here from Tel for from from the range and and the range loses it goes over the horizon basically for the range that before that bill I

29:52feel hard for mr. Gerstenmaier just can you clarify for me the the provisioning situation on station in the Skip cycle and how that plays out I was confused today when mr. suffered a knee was talking to us about where your marks are out there for getting stuff up yeah I think the way we if we take no consumables resupply for a period of time it i think we run into a skip cycle

30:17number which is like 45 days before we run out of critical consumables and i think food is one of the things that comes in it's important in july timeframe july august of this summer when we get spacex on board that will push that data into the fall when we get orbital on board or even push it further to the left yeah it starts so then that's kind of the way we do that is we want to prepare if we have to bring the crew room because we're running out of supplies right that's the beginning of the clock that says we start preparing so we actually draw a line it's like the low low fuel light on your car right you still got quite a voice to drive but

30:54it's a warning that you are an S&S digital ID hi Jared Hayworth I'm a guest of NASA social and I'm a photographer with we had today calm this is a question for Hans looking down the road a little bit to the reusable first stage once the landing legs have been proven you're ready to start landing on the non land again where are you gonna actually set these stages down this particularly thinking about something like a falcon heavy reusable where you have you know up to three stages coming back home it's going to be a particular challenge that's to be looking right now at landing sites we had a couple but we

31:29need you need to still evaluate exactly what's the best landing site here at the cape or yeah at the Cape basically sorry you are still thinking somewhere here along the east coast somewhere on the Florida coastline perhaps okay I think we'll take one more question and wrap it up go ahead please imean cleft from the NASA social group and airline reporter com the question for SpaceX actually related to Jared's question when you're bringing stages back have plans been started on how much air space and ground area will have to be cleared for these tests and then how much will that to come down when it gets to operational so that that's basically a question to to

32:05arrange safety we basically providing data for the analysis and then Range Safety will tell us how much space you need we believe it's about the same as what you need for a rocket going out coming back is a particular challenge but at the same time the stage is pretty empty so it's a it's a safe state safe stage to come back basically okay yeah

32:30do you have any closing remarks again I would just say again congratulations to SpaceX on just a wonderful day to day and tremendous preparation it's also fun for me to be down here in Florida I got to go over and see Orion get in testing over neo and see building they did their first sine waves weep of the multi vibration tests of the Orion capsule and it just completed all their avionics testing and power up so it's pretty exciting to see that vehicle come together that first beyond low-earth orbit vehicle over neo and see building and if you get a chance you need to go over and see the vehicle as it goes through these next couple stages over the next couple months getting

33:06ready for the December launch so heat shield addition and putting it on top of the service module and looking at a launch abort system it's a pretty amazing spacecraft and it's fun for me as an engineer to get a chance to go see hardware again and get out of Washington so this is an ultimately great visit for me down here I got to see our hardware beyond low-earth orbit and then I got to see a launch so it's a double wind and a great weekend and a great start to the Easter holiday so thanks to the KSC team again in this face eckstein thank you yeah and then for me I'm really happy that dragoness is safe and orbit and on its way to the station I'm really

33:42looking forward to a bro thing at the station and and again also a great easter weekend all right Thank You Hans the next planned televised event for SpaceX 3 is the grapple on sunday morning at about 7-14 am with nasa television coverage beginning at 5 45 a.m. between now and then you can keep track of all the activities that are happening by going to the NASA website at WWDC gov / SpaceX and will conclude

34:14with a replay of today's Falcon 9 and Dragon launch thank you all very much

34:37and liftoff of the Falcon 9 rocket and dragon space x3 is underway an American commercial spacecraft launching from US soil makes special delivery of new science and technology to the International Space Station first is propulsion is nominal you

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份