访谈·中文精读

马斯克 Clubhouse 访谈

Elon Musk Clubhouse Interview

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2021 年 2 月的一个周日晚上,Clubhouse 的一个语音房间里挤进了 6000 多人。他们在等一个从没在这个 App 上说过话的人。房间里有人在赌他会不会抽大麻,有人在猜他会不会当场宣布什么大消息。等到马斯克(Elon Musk)开口,他先讲的不是特斯拉,不是狗狗币,是火星。

他给出的时间表是:大概 5 年半。

不是“未来某一天”,不是“我们这一代人的有生之年”,是一个可以用日历圈出来的年份。这场访谈里他讲了两个多小时,从行星际运输讲到脑机接口,从怎么教五岁小孩讲到清算所为什么要收 30 亿美元保证金。把这些话拆开来看,能拼出一套相当完整的世界观。

火星:26 个月一班的船票,和 5 年半的赌注

为什么是 5 年半?因为地球和火星每 26 个月才会走到太阳的同一侧,只有这个窗口适合做霍曼转移。马斯克说,他们大约 6 个月前刚有过一个窗口,一年半后还有一个,再往后数,差不多就落到 5 年半这个位置上。

这个算术很朴素。困难的是它背后要凑齐的四项条件,他在访谈里一条一条列了出来:

  • 一枚大型、完全可重复使用的火箭
  • 轨道加注(orbital refilling),在近地轨道上给飞船重新加满燃料
  • 高效率、低成本的推进剂
  • 火星本地生产推进剂

最后一条最容易被跳过。火星上没有加油站,飞船返程的燃料必须在当地造出来。马斯克的方案是用水冰(H2O)合成甲烷(CH4)和氧气。没有这套化工厂,人去得成,回不来。

这四项凑齐,火星就不再是一个象征符号,而是一个有物料清单、有工期、有失败模式的工程项目。他反复强调的是“完全可重复使用”这几个字,因为一次性火箭的成本结构决定了这件事在经济上永远不成立。只有火箭像飞机一样反复飞,票价才可能降到有人愿意买单的水平。

古埃及人忘了怎么建金字塔

访谈里有人问了一个很大的问题:这一切有什么意义。

马斯克的回答是一段少年往事。他十几岁时读道格拉斯·亚当斯(Douglas Adams)的《银河系漫游指南》,书里那台超级计算机算了几百万年,算出宇宙终极答案是 42,然后所有人发现没人知道问题是什么。

42 是答案,真正难的是搞清楚该对宇宙这个答案问出什么问题。(马斯克)

他把宇宙理解成那个已经存在的答案,人类的工作是找出对应的问题。这个说法听着玄,但它解释了他后来所有的急迫感。

他的论证链条是这样的。地球有 45 亿年历史,宇宙有 138 亿年。如果宇宙里曾经出现过别的文明,那它们要么已经消亡,要么还在路上。看地球自己的记录就够了,文明不是一条一直向上的线。古埃及人在 5000 年前建起吉萨大金字塔,几百年后住在那里的人已经忘了怎么建,再过很久连象形文字都读不懂了。巴比伦、苏美尔,都走过同一条曲线:复杂化、成熟、然后遗忘。

所以他推论,人类大概率也会走一遍。而且这一次更麻烦,因为全球化让各个文明互相咬合,任何一处崩塌都会牵连全体,恢复难度比古代高得多。一个自给自足的农业文明被摧毁,几百年后还能重新长出来;一个依赖全球供应链的文明被摧毁,可能连螺丝都造不出来。

结论是他反复说的那句话:在 45 亿年的历史里,把生命送出地球这件事,只在一个极窄的时间段里变得可能。这个窗口可能开很久,也可能很快就关。他选择假设它很快会关。

这不是乐观主义,是风险对冲的逻辑。如果窗口真的很长,早点出发没有额外代价;如果窗口很短,晚一步就再也没机会。两种情况下,答案都是现在就走。

火星城市能不能活,看它缺不缺维生素 C

有人追问:到了火星,法律、货币、互联网、政府,这些东西怎么设计?

马斯克的回答出乎意料地退让。他说他不会去规定火星社会该长成什么样子,那不是他该干的事。他关心的只有一件事:这座城市能不能在断供之后活下去。

他给了一个特别具体的判断标准。如果从地球出发的飞船某天不再来了,这座城还能不能撑住。如果它只缺几样小东西,比如相当于维生素 C 那样的少数补给,那它还能撑一阵,然后慢慢死掉。真正跨过门槛,意味着除了极少数无法替代的物资,其余全部本地化:粮食、空气、水、零件、冶炼、机械加工、药品。

他把这条线看作大过滤器(great filter)的通过条件。过了这条线,人类才真正有了第二个备份;过不了,火星就只是一个昂贵的前哨站,一次太阳风暴或者一次经济衰退就能把它清空。

时间压力也在这里。他担心的是,在地球文明发生某种剧烈中断之前,火星还没跨过这条线。两个进程在赛跑,一个是对外扩张,一个是对内衰退。

那不是逃生舱

很多人把火星想成一张逃生船票。马斯克直接否定了这个想象。

他说早期基地会非常小,就是一个小前哨站,而且非常危险。

在火星上,能让你死掉的方式比地球上多得多。(马斯克)

工作强度大,生活条件差,很长时间内和舒适无关。他又补了一句:这会是很好玩、很伟大的冒险。这两句话放在一起并不矛盾, frontier 的吸引力从来不在舒适。

访谈者接了一句,说这个画面让人想起古希腊的斯巴达人:环境越严酷,长出来的文明越硬。马斯克没有反对。按他的说法,去火星的人在出发前就已经接受这套条件,他们的后代会在这种压力下长成另一种人,对风险、对资源、对互相依赖的理解都会不同。

再往远看是地球化(terraforming):把火星改造成接近地球的样子。他没给时间表,只说这会花很长时间。这句话的分量在于,它把火星计划的时间尺度从“一代人”拉到了“几十代人”。

你的大脑和手机之间,只有几十比特每秒

Neuralink 那一段是整场访谈信息密度最高的部分。

马斯克先讲动机。他的原话大意是:即便 AI 是善意的,人也得能跟上这趟车。如果智能差距拉到某个程度,人类就等于坐在副驾驶上看风景。Neuralink 的长期目标,是让人和 AI 之间的耦合足够紧,紧到最终结果里还留着人的意志。

然后他讲了一个三层结构。

最底层是边缘系统,管的是原始欲望、恐惧、本能反应。上面一层是皮层,管长期规划和思考。再上面还有一层,是数字层,也就是你的手机、电脑、所有 App。

第三层已经存在了。带着手机的人,认知能力远超不带手机的人。问题在于,皮层和数字层之间的接口太窄。

窄到什么程度?他用拇指打字举例。人的视觉系统每秒能接收的信息量是天文数字,而两根拇指敲字,输出速度只有每秒几十比特。更荒谬的是接收端:你说出来的话,是先把一整套复杂的思想结构压缩成词,对方听到后再解压成他自己的版本。中间还隔着语言本身的偏差。

所以在他眼里,人类今天的高效沟通是一种错觉。你脑子里有一整套完整模型,压缩成句子后剩下百分之几,对方收到的还要再打一次折。两次有损压缩,中间隔着一根极细的管子。

直接神经接口的意义就是绕开这条窄管。他的估算是带宽能提升至少一千倍,也许一万倍以上,而且可以传输未经压缩的原始概念,不用先转成词。

有人问得更远:那能不能把自己的状态上传。马斯克的回答带着他惯有的半开玩笑的认真。他说上传的副本不会和你完全一样,会丢一些记忆,但大部分还是你。紧接着他补了一句更狠的:其实你每天早上醒来,也不是昨天那个人。所谓连续的自我,本来就是一段不断重建的记忆。

先让瘫痪的人用念头打游戏

长期听着像科幻,短期目标非常具体,而且有一个四年左右的时间刻度。

第一个产品是一枚无线植入芯片,服务对象是四肢瘫痪的人。他们能靠想的来操作电脑、鼠标、手机或者任何设备。对这群人,这不是炫技,是把被切断的那条通路重新接上。

他提到进度:已经有一只猴子在头骨里植入了无线装置,通过那些比头发还细的线,它可以用意念玩电子游戏。相关视频大概会在一个月左右放出来。

植入设备的外形参照了 Fitbit、Apple Watch 这类产品。他在访谈里强调,早期植入一定伴随不可忽视的风险,所以必须让人看到收益和代价的全貌。技术上的一个重点是可逆:他们测试过植入、取出、再植入,功能正常。这意味着第一代设备出问题时,患者还有更换的机会。

他还讲了一个细节。Neuralink 的人去看过实验猴的饲养设施,评价是“我整个职业生涯里见过最好的猴子设施”。这话放在访谈里显得琐碎,但它说明这个项目绕不开伦理审视,而伦理审视的第一步就是把实验动物的处境做扎实。

教五岁小孩拆一台发动机

话题转到教育,起因是有人问:在今天这个世界,你会怎么教一个五岁的孩子。

马斯克先给了一个很实在的答案。他的孩子大部分知识来自 YouTube 和维基百科,再加上同学和课程。按他们花在线上的时间算,线上就是主要的教育来源。这个回答听上去像自嘲,其实很诚实。

然后他讲方法论。核心只有一条:把“为什么”讲清楚。

他的逻辑是,大脑天生会丢掉与生存无关的信息。如果一门课不说明它为什么重要,学的人记不住是正常的,不是笨。反过来,一旦相关性建立起来,记忆会自己发生。

他举的例子是拆发动机。与其先上一门“扳手课”、一门“螺丝刀课”,不如把一台发动机拆开再装回去。拆的过程中你会遇到具体障碍,然后自然需要知道:这里要什么工具,为什么这个螺栓要用这种力矩,汽油机的转速和压缩比之间是什么关系。工具应该从问题里长出来,课程表不该是起点。

他还提到一个好游戏为什么让人上瘾:它一直在制造“下一步该做什么”。玩家不会先去读一本关于游戏机制的手册,他先玩,遇到墙,再去找解法。教育如果能做到同样的吸引力,效果会完全不同。

更妙的是,这套方法可以一站式覆盖大量学科。一台发动机拆下去,涉及材料、热力学、流体、几何、力学,甚至可以顺手算一下功率和油耗。项目足够大,知识点就自己聚合过来了。

“如果你需要鼓励,就不要创业”

有人问:你对想创业的人有什么鼓励的话?

马斯克的回答后来被截成了图:

如果你需要鼓励才去创业,那就别创业。(马斯克)

这话听着刻薄,但它其实是一道筛选题。创业的默认状态是连续几年面对不确定性、被人拒绝、产品做不出来、钱快烧完。如果一个人需要外部打气才能撑过第一年,那他在第十年肯定撑不过去。真正能走下来的人,靠的是对问题本身的执念,不是掌声。

同一个问题还有一个更早的版本:为什么世界上没有更多马斯克。他的回答是自己也不知道,可能是运气好。这句不像谦辞,更像实话。他的路径里有太多不可复制的偶然:出生在南非、少年时读到那几本书、赶上互联网泡沫、卖掉 PayPal 拿到本钱、2008 年两家公司同时濒临破产时挺了过来。

一块比特币蛋糕,和狗狗币的讽刺结局

访谈里有人问他,为什么把推特简介改成了 bitcoin。

他的回答先绕了一下。他说这种话题得小心,一句话就能推动市场。然后讲了个故事:2013 年有人送他一块做成比特币形状的蛋糕,还切了一片给他。

所以我那时候明显至少应该买一点比特币的。(马斯克)

接着他说了那句后来被反复引用的话:

最有趣、也最讽刺的结果,是狗狗币成为未来的货币。(马斯克)

两句话放在一起看,能理解他对加密货币的态度。他不把它当成一套严谨的货币理论,更像把它当成一场大型的、带有反讽意味的社会实验。一个起于玩笑的币种,如果最终成了主流,那说明人类给价值定价的方式本身就带着玩笑的成分。

这段话的时机也值得注意。他说这些话的时候,房间里 6000 多个听众正在实时下单。

特斯拉真正卡住的地方是电芯

谈到特斯拉,马斯克给了一个很容易被误读的数字。

他说长期目标是每年生产 2000 万辆。理由是:全球路上跑着的汽车和卡车大约有 20 亿辆,一家车厂如果一年只造几十万辆,对存量结构的影响不到百分之一,等于没动。要真正推动能源转型,产能必须量级性地上去。

然后是瓶颈。不是设计,不是工厂,是电芯。能从供应商那里拿到的量已经拉到极限,还是不够,所以特斯拉要自己造电芯。

他专门强调了一句:这不代表要把供应商挤垮。正相反,他希望松下这类伙伴也拼命扩产。整个市场的池子太小,先把池子做大,再谈份额。这个态度和很多人对马斯克的印象相反,但他讲得很清楚:电池短缺是行业级约束,不是竞争问题。

再往上一层是储能。车用电池之外,固定式电池组和太阳能也在推进,这部分是他所说的“加速可持续能源”里不可或缺的一半。

一辆车每周只开 12 小时

自动驾驶那一段,马斯克给了一个不常被讨论的角度:资产利用率。

一辆私家车平均每天开一个半小时左右,一周大约 12 小时。剩下 150 多个小时它停在车位上,占着一块地,不产生任何价值。

如果车能自己开,情况就变了。同一辆车一周可以跑到 60 小时,是原来的五倍。这意味着完成同样的出行量,需要的车更少,需要的停车场和车库也更少。这笔账里的环境收益,不比省下来的汽油少:少造车意味着少挖矿、少炼钢、少浇混凝土。

他还算了另一笔账,是命的账。全球每年大约 100 万人死于交通事故,1000 万人受重伤。自动驾驶每提前一年落地,就少死一批人。这也是他对进度如此执着的原因。在他看来,拖延不是保守,是用人命换时间。

技术路线上,他讲得很明确:特斯拉走纯视觉,靠八个摄像头同步采集,正在转向视频训练。他承认纯视觉会出错,会漏,但他认为在穿透遮挡这件事上,真正该用的是主动发射光子,比如波长更长的雷达。这句话在 2021 年说出来显得微妙,因为特斯拉当时正在把车上的毫米波雷达拆掉。

我的周一:开会、写邮件、写支票

有人问他的周一是什么样。

他的回答里没有“战略思考”这种词。他说大部分时间在处理杂务,而且他一直在试图逃避这些杂务,但只要不做,公司就会出问题。

具体下来是一串会议、一堆邮件、一堆签字。他特别提到一种邮件:发给全组的,说明方向要改、接下来做这几件事、如果你不同意那我们还是这么做。这种邮件写完,一个组织内部的争论就结束了,代价是写的人要承担全部后果。

然后是那句听起来很疲惫的话:

在不同事务之间切换上下文,非常痛苦。我不推荐这种生活方式。(马斯克)

访谈里还有一段关于睡眠的对话。他说自己常常凌晨四点才睡,四小时后起来。同事说他如果不在办公室,别人会以为他消失了,所以他会特意让人看到他在。有人开玩笑问他是不是有一张高层专属的沙发。这段对话的调子很轻松,但内容不太好笑。

这段最值得记下来的地方,是他对“切换”的描述。深度工作需要连续的注意力块,而他的日程被切成了 15 分钟一段。这种生活能撑住的唯一理由,是他认为自己正在做的事值得。

细胞是生物计算机

访谈后段聊到 mRNA,马斯克的表述方式很特别。他不从生物学讲,从信息讲。

他的说法是:mRNA 药物的本质是医学的数字化。你像写一段计算机程序那样写出一段 RNA 序列,然后用脂质外壳把它包起来,送进细胞。细胞读到这段代码,就按指令生产蛋白质。

他把细胞称为生物计算机。这个比喻不是修辞,是字面意思:输入是核酸序列,输出是蛋白质,中间的执行者是核糖体。人类第一次可以用编程的方式给这台计算机下指令,而且改一行代码的成本极低。

他提到这套工艺分三段:DNA 扩增、RNA 扩增、脂质包裹。他当时手头正在做一个速度相当快的 RNA 微型工厂,思路和造车一样,把流程拆成工位,压缩每一段的节拍。他的判断很直接:一旦医学变成软件,迭代速度就会变成软件的速度,从几年一个版本变成几周一个版本。

这段最反直觉的地方在于,它把药物研发从“发现”变成了“编译”。传统药物的筛选是在海量分子里碰运气,mRNA 是在写代码然后跑一遍。

先给所有人打第一针

聊到疫苗分发,马斯克给了几条非常具体、也非常有争议的建议。

第一,放松接种资格的限制。他的类比是流感疫苗:每年 CVS 和 Walgreens 都在打,流程早就跑通了,新冠疫苗没必要设那么多门槛。让人直接走进去打。

第二,先给所有人打第一针,暂时不要留第二针。他的判断是第一针带来的保护已经很有价值,把有限的产能摊开覆盖更多人,总体收益大于按部就班。

第三,不用太担心打错剂量。

他还解释了为什么 mRNA 疫苗必须超低温保存。RNA 序列本身不稳定,会自发回到能量更低的状态,温度不够低就会降解。这是物理层面的约束,不是物流管理没做好。也正因为如此,疫苗一旦解冻就必须尽快用掉,否则效价会掉。

他补了一句:自然感染后康复的人,抗体反应比接种疫苗更强。这句话在 2021 年初说出来,引发了不小的争论。他的整体判断是,疫苗产能会指数级上升,叠加感染后获得的免疫,群体免疫的门槛不会太远。

那个凌晨 3 点半的文件

访谈快结束时,Robinhood 的 CEO 弗拉德·特涅夫(Vlad Tenev)被拉上了台。那一周 GameStop 的逼空行情正打到最激烈的时候,无数人想知道为什么自己的账户突然只能卖不能买。

他讲得很细。Robinhood 有两个法人实体:面向用户的 Robinhood Financial 是介绍经纪商,负责处理订单;真正和清算所打交道的是 Robinhood Securities,负责清算和交收。

2021 年 2 月那个周四凌晨 3 点 30 分,运营团队收到 NSCC(美国证券存托与清算公司)发来的文件,要求追加保证金,金额大约 30 亿美元。

这个数字是什么概念?Robinhood 成立以来累计融资大约 20 亿美元。一次追加保证金就要 30 亿,超过公司全部历史融资额。

保证金的算法里有一个叫 VaR(风险价值)的部分,基于波动率、持仓集中度等量化指标,但公式不完全透明。还有一部分是自由裁量的,相当于一个乘数。清算所不解释乘数为什么是这个数,你只能接受或者谈。

他们打电话沟通,把数字从 30 亿谈到了 14 亿。仍然拿不出来。最后能做的只有一件事:对那几只最疯的股票设限,只允许平仓,不允许开新仓。

为什么不禁卖出?特涅夫的回答很干脆:用户手里有股票,想卖却卖不掉,那比不能买严重得多。这个逻辑在当时的舆论里几乎没人听,因为被限制的那一方叫得最响。

24 小时内,团队融到了超过 10 亿美元。周五开门时限制能放松一些,但不可能取消。资本没有无限这一说。

至于 Citadel 这类做市商有没有施压,他说没有理由相信。他也承认,模因股带来的波动确实让系统风险变高,清算所提高保证金要求不算完全不合理。整个对话里最有价值的一句,是他把清算所描述成一个“财团”而不是政府机构,也就是说,规则由参与者共同制定,而参与者各有各的账本。

这套世界观里,有几件事现在就能用

这场访谈横跨火星、脑机接口、教育、制造、医学和金融市场,看起来散,其实共用一套判断方法。他把每个问题都拆成“约束条件是什么”和“窗口有多长”,然后倒推现在该做什么。这套方法比任何一个具体预测都更值得拿走。

  • 评估任何长期项目,先问断供测试。如果外部输入突然停了,这个东西还能活多久?能活的,是资产;不能活的,是项目。
  • 学新东西先找问题,再找工具。不要从目录开始读,从一台要拆的发动机开始。遇到障碍时学到的知识,留存率完全不是一个量级。
  • 衡量技术时看利用率,不只看性能。把某个资源的占用时间从 12 小时提到 60 小时,价值可能大于把参数提高 10%。
  • 沟通前先想压缩损耗。你脑子里的模型和对方听到的句子之间,隔着两次有损压缩。重要的事多花时间写清楚,比多说几遍有用。
  • 找瓶颈,不要找目标。特斯拉的目标是 2000 万辆,真问题是电芯。把资源压在瓶颈上,目标会自己实现。
  • 新技术优先看可逆性。Neuralink 强调能取出再植入,这个属性决定了早期失败可以被承受。评估任何高风险决策时,先问退路还在不在。
  • 假设窗口比你想的短。如果早晚要做,早做的成本更低;如果窗口很短,晚做就是零。这条对职业选择、对项目启动时间都成立。
  • 创业前先自查动机。如果你需要别人鼓励才动手,那这件事大概不是你真正想做的。真正想做的事,别人拦都拦不住。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00welcome everyone we are six minutes away six minutes away from elon musk's debut on clubhouse i do want to get like a supreme draw before for rapid fire i'm gonna i'm really gonna call out your name we're gonna do rapid fire and then we're just gonna move on to the next person for the next five minutes and then we're just gonna set ourselves up to join this room so we got we got we got i was at you know what i'm curious i'm here elisa rapid fire are you ready

0:33i think so wrap it i literally just walked in what are we rapid fire i'm always ready i've been i've been putting people on the hot seat all day long for the last nine hours so that's great all right is elon musk going to make a major announcement or clubhouse tonight yes no always okay so you're part of the 64 not in a public spot i think it depends how high he is and how reckless he is on the mic but i think he's going to spill all the tea i love it so actually one of the questions was do you think ilama is going to be smoking weed tonight on clubhouse minimally minimally okay so now another question is oh wow the are room the room is open the

1:12room is open open there i got in open the room's open hey come in i got in perfect can someone ping me i don't see it [Music]

1:53everybody i want ben up here can you try please yeah they're not talking it's really quiet right now so i'm in the room the room is done there are 3 000 people in the room right now everybody everybody there's 3 000 people in this room i want you all to know that ben up here and a few people have been yeah it's full already

2:22i got some insider information who's got the insider who is this this is anthony the smartplay guy so where are you he may be making an announcement already hey they're talking right now pharrell can you hear me i'm in the room also can ben can everybody mute but ben please dude they're not talking right now they're just waiting okay so justin they said that the room was full already so yeah i got it it's only six thousand hey who got in i'm in i'm i'm broadcasting it through my phone then frenzy and techie to the best

3:16isn't getting into the room so they're trying to get him on hey elon might join this room seriously honestly i think that's the only logical solution yeah it looks like the room is already full my app is

3:41hey this room is blowing up right now blowing up guys ben ben will be coordinating the mirror and we're at 3800 right now and techie you will be there don't accept too many people so we can let elon in if we need to okay elon's in guys let's listen are you wearing your short shorts yeah

4:28are you celebrating anything in particular with your short shirts no i'm just trying to look sexy in these in these tight pants with the fabulous red and gold

5:08moment the good times room has almost 6 000 people in it right now all right

5:50oh [Music] okay first of all everyone thank you for joining us for what is really a historic episode i will come to our very very special guest in a second but just to quickly introduce

6:43the founder of tesla spacex the boring company neuralink paypal and 2.4 thank you glad to be here thank you okay i think you're a friend yeah yeah so you know again welcome this is really fun you know we've been waiting all day this is the longest way to 10 p.m because we just couldn't wait to get this going i hope this is as much fun by the end of it for you as it is for us first question from you is

7:25i think we have a decent shot of doing that in about i said like five years something like that so mars earth and i think we're just think of every 26 months as we're in this kind of the it's roughly the same quadrant of the solar system and we can do explanatory transfer and so we have one about six months ago about a year and a half there'll be another one so figure you know i don't know five and a half years five and a half years so what does it take from here to that point like what are the milestones you think for us to like get to you know five years out via landing on mars

8:37between flames and then go to mars and if if you've got a large fully eventfully reusable rocket with orbital refilling that uses high efficiency low cost propellants then you can go to mars and then and then one one last thing is on mars here you need a local propellant production

9:35it with water ice h2o to create ch4 methane and oxygen and if you have those elements life can become multi-planetary and we can have a self-sustaining city on mars which i think is one of the most important things we could possibly do for ensuring the long-term existence of consciousness

10:14sure is it all meaningless i got quite depressed actually about it and and then the thing that kind of broke me out of it was reading douglas adams was the galaxy out that the is the answer and really the hard part is figuring out what questions to ask about the answer that is the universe yeah exactly exactly easy part

11:18at the same time [Music] for a while they might have prospered for millions of and years gradually the civilization collapsed for reasons external or internal and and that was that all civilizations go through go through an arc where they they grow up and technology complexity but then they they don't keep good enough they over time they they decline their fool and this has happened obviously with true student history with many civilizations in the past you can look at ancient egypt you know five thousand years ago there was the great part of my giza but then the people living there have forgotten how to build pyramids after a while then they figured out how to read

12:32hieroglyphics you know ancients mary's babylonians all these things that they've all gone through a similar arc which suggests that most likely we will go through ourselves and we'll be probably less resilient to recovery because of globalization so i think for the first time the four and a half billion year history of earth has been possible to accept life beyond earth and make life possible and this window of opportunity may be open for a long time i hope it is or it may be open for a short time i think it would be wise for us to assume that it's open for a short time

13:41transport life to make life multi-planetary and and of life humanity this process and i think we almost have an obligation to ensure that the creatures of earth continue even if there's a collaboration on like natural earth yes if you look at the fossil record there's there are many many mass extinctions yeah i think yeah i think you know all of that makes sense and i think we've heard you've talked about this before i think one other question i have is you know when we get there you know we have to set up the whole society we have to set up civilization here how does the whole thing work in your mind you know everything from what does it mean to have internet connection

14:28in mars all the way to like garments and rules and laws and everything yeah all those things i would not presume to prescribe what should happen there i think the important part is just that we get people there and we get the equipment necessary to establish a self-sustaining civilization at least one city and i think the key threshold of when we would pass the great culture of this this particular great filter is is sufficiently self-sustaining such that if the ship stop coming from earth for any reason be

15:25it must only have to be missing ones little ingredients like the equivalence of vitamin c and if it was fine for a while there will not but it will eventually die out so it's kind of getting getting experience to pass that critical threshold where it is self-sustaining and are we able to do that before some calamity or a gradual decline civilization occurs that prevents those trends from going there

16:06if you if you kind of let yourself dream out over the next few decades like what would you what would you consider success like let's say they get through the first you know five years even the first ten years like what do you think is possible to build on mars 10 years in 20 years then 30 years in after first arrival

16:27well i think i think most of it are very tiny just like a tiny little outpost and by the way it's going to be very dangerous sometimes people think oh is this like some escape hatch people are like no it will be dangerous hard work it's gonna be you're out there on the frontier there's a way far more ways to die there than there are deaths but hard work but it will be a fun and a great adventure but it will not be a luxurious thing for sure quite some time ago [Music]

17:17you know the food production going creating the necessities i you know i am in the iron refinery all of the sort of fundamentals of industry in order to make sure that mars is a self-sustaining planet over time like this would take a while but you could terraform the planet and make it earth like

17:48so you know as you talk about this i mean honestly what comes to mind is sort of the idea that a martian civilization you know although obviously imported to earth it will quickly evolve to be quite a bit tougher by necessity and and just the mental image is leaping up my mind is the spartans in ancient greece do you think that you think do you think this sort of vector of civilization will unfold differently as a consequence of how difficult it's going to be to get it going

18:23yeah we actually have an alternative [Music] a group of people arriving roughly every two years

19:22events of consciousness as we know it because as far as we can tell we're the only

20:04and i'm pretty sure how do you think we should so that doesn't mean there aren't aliens i'm just literally saying i've seen nothing that could not be explained by other means and whereas explanation by other means is much more likely than alien technology the resolution of the picture needs to be at least like 7 11 atm good okay

21:42is [Music] i really how do things become interesting to people and it means like actually kind of a complex form of communication that's

23:48so you know i don't know i love names in has powerfully affected people so yeah how did you get so good at them i mean many years going from that to your c7 or

24:49[Music] in [Music] deleted my [Music] five or three of cats from the grain yeah so it's sort of yeah

26:21yeah i mean ask you what are the new means that you're like following or creating right now what are the ones that are interesting to you right now and then some of are sent to me i have some pretty kick-ass beam dealers yeah

27:16very interesting news [Music] and why people should be working there for folks who don't know about it i thought it was really cool like you know just the possibility of it is really fantastic tell us more about it you know there are a lot of engineers listening on this this clubhouse you know what is neural link why should we care what is possible with it sure sue the the long-term okay so new link steps from the consent i had where i was trying to figure out even in a benign ai scenario how do we at least go along for the ride so i mean if elizabeth ain't closely it's almost improving dramatically you know should be like look let's say gp1 versus gft2 versus gp3

28:18[Music] so just really solving vision perception and control with ai

29:08human will to the outcome of artificial intelligence and what's developed that way i think that will probably be a better scenario for unable to effectively couple collective human world through that outcome so

29:38digital layer you've got your sort of limiting system which is your primitive drives and desires and responses and then you've got your cortex which is like long-term planning and thinking and then there's a layer third layer which is digital and you already have that in the form of your phones and computers and all your applications you're far more powerful than a human would be without those cognitive enhancements but the bandwidth between your cortex and your digital cheshire layer is very slow and in fact with the adventure phones it got even slower so if you're

30:35trillions of bits per second so it's you know at a certain point smart enough it's like the computer's just like trying to talk to a tree you know crazy sort of talk but they've talked so slow that you're gonna notice so so we need to improve the bandwidth and with a direct neural interface we can improve the bandwidth

31:03between your cortex and your digital territory layer by many orders of magnitude at least a thousand or maybe 10 000 or more and we could also spend a lot more time thinking about interesting things as opposed to taking complex thought structures compressing them down into words which is which also gain a very low cut rate and then having someone else receive those words decompress them and then and then send words back to you so huge round about brain power and compression decompression and we could be incentive

31:59and you can just transfer them directly uncompressed to the other the first this would massively improve the quality of communication and the speed of it so there are other sort of pretty wild things that can be done like you could

32:26here and you wouldn't be exactly the same so you you know get a little less than transfer but you can also say it's also arguably true that when you wake up in the morning you're not exactly the same as yesterday or the you of a month ago is not the same as the

33:09where you are able to resume yeah upload your last state yeah kinda like ultra carbon maybe lose a few memories but i'll mostly be you so now that's the launch of stuff in the short term four year old length the idea would really just be to address brain injuries or spinal injuries and you know make up for whatever lost capacity somebody has with with an implanted shoe

33:45so the first thing that we're going after is a wireless compliant chip that would enable someone who's a quantum cleaning or cardiological tetraplegic to control a computer or mouse or their phone or really any device just use just by thinking and this

34:18so just is good at designing like fitbits apple watches phones computers various kinds then actually they would be a great fit for we'll probably be releasing some some new videos showing progress maybe in a month or so and because we've already got like a monkey with with a wireless implant in their skull and the tiny wires who can play video games using his mind

35:43facilities she said it was like the nicest monkey facilities she's ever seen in her entire career

35:59[Music] [Music] implant is just would be enormous because obviously the early implants will come with some non-trivial risk and so it's going to be like okay this is the good far out with the bad and then you know that that will be accounted for some of the initial surgeries with full

37:06it out and then we can re-implant another one so we've tested implantation removal and re-implantation safe and it works great

37:26[Music] who is crawling all over everything and trying to figure everything out and learning as much as he can as fast as he can like what you know with everything that we know now and kind of all the modern tools we have like what's the best way to think about educating a five-year-old in today's

37:48world educate a five-year-old and then think about kind of his education over the course of the next you know five or ten years like what what kind of program ideally should you think a kid should be on my kids were mostly educated by youtube and writers and then you know and i guess classmates and i guess their lessons as well but judging by the amount of time they spent online it seemed like most of their education online i mean i think generally with education you want to make it as interesting exciting as possible like what is going to be like if you feel like one of the things like saying a good video game does to keep someone engaged you know if kids can be super engaged

38:50in education as well like one of the things i think very fundamental is to explain the why of things like so we're teaching this we're going to explain why we're teaching you this and why it is relevant i mean we were involved to forget things that are irrelevant low low relevance probability it makes sense like otherwise we remember all sorts of nonsense things that are very important to our future so unless relevance is established clearly then people will have a hard time remembering remembering advice nature because

39:40some sort of engaging narrative for the problem solving like it's like better to say okay orientation works by taking apart an engine and they're putting it back together and then what tools are needed for you know for in order to take extension apart put it back together like okay screwdrivers branches and allen keys and we need a winch and a bunch of other things and then you understand the relevance and especially interesting problems this is much better than having say a course on wrenches or a course on screwdrivers just like start with a problem and say what titles i need to solve this problem and that establishes real relevance and gives a compelling hour of threat

40:28yeah it seems like you could kind of if you have sort of elaborate enough projects you know you could you could rule a huge number of topics into and ultimately kind of combine a musical [Music]

41:04engine better what do we need to do okay well let's calculate if the gasoline engine you know what's the how do you get to a higher rpm or you know better compression ratio you know i'm using like that [Music]

41:43yeah one is but why doesn't the world have more elon musk well i don't know i might be getting so much better here so i mean for me these things

43:10most what encouraging words do you have for entrepreneurs who want to do a startup and my response is if you need encouraging words don't do a start-up

43:48[Music] [Music] you just sent your twitter bio to just bitcoin logo and the word bitcoin this week what do you think of cryptocurrency what do you think of bitcoin what do you think of other well yeah i gotta watch what i say here because so many things can really move the market

45:02he actually had a bitcoin cake a cake that was like a bitcoin and he fed me a slice of white corn cake in 2013. so i mean clearly i should have at least fight for some bitcoins

46:40and arguably the most entertaining outcome the most ironic outcome would be that dogecoin becomes the currency of oath in the future

47:50[Music] itself well yeah i mean i think that the goal with tesla is [Music] and our rough target is we want to be able to eventually make 20 billion cars a year the reason for that is two billion active cars and trucks in the road and you're not really moving the needle unless you're changing one percent of the existing fleet and as those are roughly how we came up between your car's trucks per year that's very important to accelerate the sustainable energy and of course the stationary battery packs and solar which makes a lot of progress in that front [Music] so yeah we're gonna try to grow car

49:30production as fast as possible and the primary limiting factor there is battery cell production so we're getting as much as possible from suppliers and then but even that is not enough so we are actually going to be building battery cells ourselves important to emphasize that suppliers

49:54who are great suppliers that we're not we're not trying to put them out of business we want them to increase their rate as well so panasonic and then you know to increase the accelerate stable energy further we're making our own cells and i'm pretty pretty excited about that and then anyways i think you expect possibly an acceleration of

50:38once depending on the situation you're where you look an hour and a half a day or something like that most likely cars that are autonomous could maybe do a third of the hours a week or something like that so maybe they do 60 hours a week of usage instead of 12. basically increase in asset utilization there and far less need for parking less garages that kind of thing so in itself is good for the environment because you need fewer cars to get the same thing done and we're gonna need fewer parking garages and places just to just keep cars

51:58i think is at the heart of why a lot of investors think tesla is

52:46[Music] sooner is translates directly to live space and live saved and injuries about a million people die every year in car accidents and about 10 million per year have serious injuries so that's the sooner the better and a lot of lives will be saved in people's lives

53:35[Music] no yeah so first of all i'm not like farming like a flight or you know because you know for the spacex space station

54:2210 years ago [Music] for driving on real world roads you have to solve vision you have some ambition to basically understanding on objects with passive optical photons and and then making sense of those objects so like division perception what does this object mean what are they going to do what is the likely path of travel and in control and and all of that really is you know is ai we're doing it is

55:18the same thing way we do it right now is we have all the cameras synchronized with so you've got eight frames collected and we're moving towards mostly move towards video training so you've got you've got eight surround cameras it's like it's like kind of a surreal thing to see because people look you know really you don't have two eyes but kind of like really more like

56:11[Music] it's there's all sorts of things that go wrong there's no question that you can't be serving here but it was just cameras i think if one is going to go with sort of active photon generation in the occlusion penetrating wavelengths you know like radar you know roughly four millimeter or something like that would be better if you could really delve into the arena of actual photon generation

57:24a lot of people are very interested in how you work as an engineer so walk us through it's monday morning you wake up what is it a difficult

57:58is not actually fun or interesting it's like chores so i've tried really hard not to do my chores but then if i don't do my chores help so yeah man you have to do it for us [Music] just hearing you say that yeah

58:50[Music] so so anyway i'll have a bunch of meetings i'll write email write checks especially if it's like an email to the group like saying hey we need to i think we need to change direction do the following things and you know if you think otherwise we're going to do these things back together in this area or that area

59:57switching is a real pair it's really hard to context switch between

1:00:40is [Music] it's insane i don't recommend it i i mean yeah it's

1:02:32you know some advice for others that might be helpful [Music] and you know you know going to sleep at four in the morning like waking up like four hours later and like they literally see me they won't pass me

1:03:39i figured you know there must be like an executive floor or something you must have like the couch

1:04:07[Music] room so they can see that i was there even more advanced level yeah i always wake up and smell like oil and iron violence

1:05:03i'm not doing the same super interesting because thing people think you know

1:05:43[Music] or another effort thank you [Music] massively improve people's quality of life by making it easy to travel from one place to another in a city and then that can be further expanded to long distance travel where if you just throw a vacuum on the tunnel then you can go extremely fast a plane and faster than a plane or a high speed rail so i really still recommend someone else if he's not a styling company that'll be great then there's rna or mrna basically synthetic viruses which is we've seen quite secret effect with bio intake and moderna but i think people don't quite appreciate that what's actually going on is the digitization of medicine

1:07:28so it's where you can just literally you know create an r new dna sequence like a computer program and then encapsulate that

1:07:54future of medicine i mean i mean you could probably figure out how to expense money to a literal butterfly okay that's it it's just your cells are biological computers

1:08:36and then just super randomly tells actually is making a fairly fast rna sort of micro fab or something where

1:09:04so studied and at that time position they said look we're willing to be acquired but there's like just a couple of projects that we think even though they're not related to automotive we really like to continue

1:09:59there's three parts to it there's a dna multiplier an rna multiplier and something which puts them the lipid shell on the rna sequence like version three of it now and then keep going so if you keep it under 10 resources

1:10:29[Music] the distribution effort right now what would you do [Music] good insight into the as it stands but i think relaxing the requirements on it's like there are too many requirements of looking at the vaccine the next thing really

1:11:20i think really just saying like you know first come first show up show up here like use cvs and walgreens which would give out the flu vaccine every year and say okay just just show up here and

1:11:47deep deep freeze briefly and then they must be used or they they lose their is because effectiveness my understanding is is the rna because the rna sequences they use are not stable those sequences want to reverse to something else because they're not stable they must be frozen at a very low temperature or they will simply want to revert to a lower energy state rna sequence that's my understanding so just like

1:12:34here let's just get into as many people as possible as quickly as possible and for sure we should not worry about the second dose yet just give everyone the first dose i suspect that the community grounded by the first dose is very significant

1:13:00and don't worry about like accidentally give them the dancing

1:13:24and the combination of because this is going to be if we were gonna have so many so much

1:13:58i know the tesla machine that you can make your brazilian doses super fast so you know i think this is definitely you should expect an exponential increase in vaccine availability and then combined with that we we are i think starting to approach some degree of code immunity with you know people who contract the virus and and recovered so which is actually better than getting vaccine the antibody right reaction is better than nitrogen so

1:14:55so you know speaking of vaccines you know california has you know has been sort of bouncing between kind of 40th and 45th and 50th country you know by states in terms of the speed of the roll out of it you know it re-raises those questions by coming up more and more which is you and i and a lot of people you know here listening is like you know bills are companies primarily in california up until now what's your view in the future california from here well first of all i should say i love california i've been i've lived half my life more than half my life in california just like i am you know californian you know like so much of my

1:15:47technology for electric vehicles way back in like 92 i think it was 92 or 93 there's a little company called clinical research [Music]

1:16:43[Music] vehicles which may or may not be successful like the phd but would

1:17:21[Music] yellow pages and white pages i wrote it personally it was just me and my computer and when we started our first company we only had one computer so the website only worked during the day because i was coding at night and the server and during the day

1:18:24well we what are you what are you watching on tv what are you reading right now well i just finished watching the last kingdom which i think is a great piece of mostly accurate historical drama

1:19:33[Music] the sort of most accurate representation of what you know actual space actual like interplanetary travel would be like you know what's the sort of face routine the politics that flow right so it sort of sets up a three-way battle between you know basically earth and mars and then the asteroid belt

1:20:39[Music] did you see the ravens banquet the most recent one yeah that's right [Music] have you seen it yet wow okay well i think you can i think if you think too hard about tennis complete sense but i enjoyed the work that's kind of what nolan said in one of the interviews he said just don't like go deep into it just enjoy it for the movie and the four hours like later i emerged from bread and bean like i still don't like entirely get it so i should have just you know just skim through it and just watch it for the fun of it yeah yeah exactly

1:22:07do you want to hear the real story from vlad from robin hood about what happened this week with cave style click on a button so you can talk

1:22:49disguised as a silly humor the answer is easy once you probably can probably formulate the question infinite it's called the heart of gold yeah yeah earth gets destroyed by is a sort of clerical error or whatever they basically

1:24:28hey guys thanks for thanks for inviting me up it's good to hang with all of you all right what really happened give us the insight all right well i was actually hoping that you would invite me up for the fermi paradox part because this has been a very surreal weekend and week for me one of the really great things is all the people coming to coming out of the woodwork to offer support

1:25:07a couple days ago just to see what it was all about so this is my first time literally using the app but yeah i i got introduced to your friend antonio elon who had some good advice for me and then introduced me to you you have some great advice and then i figured you know i heard about this clubhouse and this has got to be part of the simulation so i just thought why not so here i am so i'm actually i'm actually an adherent to the simulation hypothesis all right well it's philippines man what happened last week why do you still people why can't people buy their gamestop shares the people demand an answer and they want to know the

1:26:10it's actually a couple of companies so there's a an introducing broker dealer called robin financial and that basically is the app that you know and love it processes trades you're a customer of robinhood financial then there's a clearing broker dealer robin the securities that clears and settles the trades [Music]

1:26:45so basically wednesday of last week we just had you know unprecedented volume unprecedented load on the system a lot of these you know so-called mean stocks were going viral on social media and people were people were joining robin hood and there was a lot of net buy activity on them as you guys all know and robin at this time i think was number one on the ios app store and pretty close to my number one on on google play as well so just unprecedented and so thursday morning right

1:27:31so i'm i'm sleeping but at 3 30 a.m pacific our operations team receives a file from the nscc which is the national securities clearing corporation so basically as a broker as a clearing broker as where robinson securities comes in we have to put up money to the nscc based on some factors including things like the volatility of the of the trading activity concentration into certain securities

1:28:11this is the equities business so it's based on stock trading and not options trading or anything else so they gave us a file with the deposit and the request was around three billion dollars which is you know about an order of magnitude more than what it typically it sounds like this is an unprecedented increase in demand for capital what formula did they use to calculate that well yeah and just to give context you know robinhood up until that point has raised you know a little bit around two billion dollars in total venture capital up until now so it's a big number like three billion dollars is a large number right so basically

1:29:12you know the details are we don't have the full details it's a little bit of an opaque formula but there's a component called the bar of it which is value at risk and that's based on kind of some fairly quantitative things although it's not it's not fully transparent so there are ways to reverse engineer it but it's not kind of publicly shared and then there's a special component which is discretionary so that's that kind of acts as a multiplier and their yeah they're it's it's a little bit i mean i'm sure there's there's definitely more more than just their opinion but

1:30:47have the full about you know what was what was going on in what's going on in the nscc to make these calculations but yeah essentially [Music] and i actually was asleep at this point you know the operation scheme was was fielding this at three o'clock and then you know we got back we put our heads together chief operating officer basically said look let's call up the higher ups at the nscc and kind of figure out what's going on maybe there's some way we can work with them and basically there was another call and they lowered it to something like 1.4 billion dollars from three okay we're making some progress right and then that's still a high number

1:31:56and then we basically proposed well let's let's explain how we plan to let's explain how you know we'll manage risk in these symbols throughout the day we propose marking these volatile stocks that were kind of driving driving the activity physician closing only and then at about an hour before market closed market open

1:32:49[Music] outcome for customers you know part of what's been really difficult is robbing the stands for you know democratizing access to stocks and yeah we want to give people access so that's been very very challenging but we had no choice in this case we had to conform to our regulatory capital requirements and so the team did did what they could to make sure we were available for customers

1:33:29you know it's a consortium it's not it's not quite a government agency you know i don't really know the details of of all that okay but you know and to be fair we were we were i think there was legitimate sort of turmoil in the markets like these are unprecedented events with these mean stocks and you know there was a lot of activity so there probably is some amount of extra risk in the system that warrants higher higher requirements so it's not entirely unreasonable but we did operational processes to make sure that customers that had positions could sell their open positions because obviously restricting someone we got a lot of questions about okay

1:34:23you have to restrict buying why didn't you also restrict selling and the fact of the matter stock and they want is sell it and they can't read so that's that's categorically worse so and lots of other brokers i think were in the same situation robinhood was in the news but you sort of heard this industry-wide right other brokers basically restricted the same exact activity all right so it sounds like this visualization should it pulls you up when they basically

1:35:09[Music] financial institutions have [Music] better around that you know but to be fair we were able to open and serve our customers and you know 24 24 hours later our team raised over a billion dollars in capital so that when we when we did open well when we do open tomorrow morning we'll be able to kind of relax the stringent position limits that we put on these securities on friday will there be any limits

1:36:13well i think there's always going to be some theoretical limit like we don't have infinite capital right and on friday there were limits so there's always there's always going to have to be some limit i think the question is you know will the limits be high enough to the point where you know some it won't impact you know 99.9 plus percent of customers

1:36:47you know all right [Music] and you know then that's understandable but then who put that gun to your head you know people against the public yeah listen and and to be fair those guys have been reasonable so we are i think the one thing that is maybe not clear to people is a participant in the financial system so we have to work with all of these counterparties so we do get a lot of questions about you know when you work with market makers when you work with clearing houses vertically integrating and getting

1:37:59is sort of a complex web of multiple parties and you know it's hard to everyone says [Music] it's just the necessity of trading equities in the u.s

1:38:33[Music] so from our perspective you know citadel and other market makers weren't involved in that but wouldn't they have a strong saying and who could put in charge of that organization since not a government consortium or not a governmental agency i i don't have any reason to believe that i think that's just like you know then you're getting into kind of the conspiracy theories a little bit so i just have no reason to believe that that's the case you know okay

1:39:32all right much thank you so much

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份