访谈·中文精读

马斯克访谈:失败、创新速度、工作文化与爵士乐

Elon Musk Interview - Handling Failure, Speed of Innovation, Work Culture....and JAZZ!

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2021年,马斯克站在一千多名空军和太空军人员面前,扔下一句话:美国如果不搞激进创新,军事上会变成世界第二。停了一拍,他补了四个字,基本数学。

要理解这个判断,得先算一道人口算术题。

中国人口是美国的四到五倍。哪怕人均GDP只有美国的一半,总量也是美国的两倍。人均继续追上去,三倍也不是天花板。

他强调这是独立于政策的事实。中国有大量聪明、极其勤奋的人,他们会做出很多了不起的东西。

然后他把话说到根上:战争的根基是经济。你手里只有对手一半的资源,就必须在创新上大幅领先,否则结果没有悬念。

所以美国要在军事层面保持竞争力,创新必须跨过这个巨大的经济产出缺口。没有激进创新,就是第二。

说完这段,他好像觉得气氛太沉,开了个玩笑:我不确定现在是不是正有网络攻击在发生。

这场对话里真正贯穿始终的,是他对失败的定价方式,以及他对创新速度的执念。前者决定一个团队敢不敢动,后者决定一个组织能走多远。

棒球不许你等一个好球

主持人的问题很直接。Cybertruck发布会上铁球砸碎车窗,SpaceX早年那支火箭爆炸集锦,换成在场任何一个人,早就被这些场面逼疯了。你为什么看起来毫不在意?

马斯克的回答绕到了棒球。

棒球有个规矩,你不许站在那儿等一个完美的好球。裁判给你三次机会,三次没打,你下场,换人。

所以真正该关心的,是打击率。

打击率这个词很关键。在棒球里,三成打击率已经是明星打者,意思是七成时间你都在出局。一个赛季几百个打席,绝大多数以失败告终。没人因此质疑这个打者不会打球。

失败基本上无关紧要,除非它是灾难性的。(马斯克)

他把这套逻辑搬到了工程和商业上。给定一段时间,你能做的动作里,有些会成功,有些会失败。你要的是这组动作的净有用产出最大化。所以问题从来不在避免失败,而在有限的时间里怎么打出最高的总分。

这个视角一换,很多事情的性质就变了。

Cybertruck的铁球砸窗,砸碎了玻璃,但全球媒体免费报道了整整一周。SpaceX那些爆炸视频,每一帧都是真实数据,炸一次,下一次的模型就准一点。这些失败被公开、被嘲笑、被做成表情包,同时它们也是通往下一个版本的入场券。

但那个限定词很重要,除非它是灾难性的。

可承受的失败和不可承受的失败,是两回事。前者是学费,后者是退场。铁球砸窗是学费。火箭在无人状态下炸掉是学费。载人火箭炸掉就不是了。这里面有一条线,线的一边随便你折腾,另一边一次都不能碰。很多团队搞反了,在小事上反复复盘到深夜,在大事上凭直觉拍板。

特斯拉把专利全开源了

主持人问知识产权保护。在一个云端服务器天天被攻击、人人都想从你手里"解放"点东西的世界里,你怎么守住自己的技术?

马斯克的回答让提问的人愣了一下:特斯拉几年前就把专利开源了,任何人都可以用。

原因不复杂。特斯拉的使命是加速可持续能源的到来。如果建一个专利池,把别的公司挡在电动车门外,那跟使命是反的。所以反过来做,把路铺平。

那靠什么保护自己?

答案是创新速度。

如果你创新的速度足够快,你根本不用操心保护知识产权。别人抄的,是你几年前做的东西。这没关系。(马斯克)

这句话值得多停两秒。

它背后是一种完全不同的竞争观。传统思路是把技术锁进保险柜,靠法律和保密维持领先。这套思路成立的前提是,领先优势能维持很久。可如果行业变化足够快,保险柜还没上锁,里面的东西已经过时了。

护城河从来不是墙,是速度。墙会被绕过去,速度只能被追上。而只要你不减速,就永远追不上。

创新要除以时间

他提到自己经常跟团队讲一个词:单位时间创新,innovation per unit time。

把某件事改进一倍,用一年和用一百年,是完全不同的两件事。同样是一倍的进步,前者能改变一个行业,后者只是一段历史注脚。

所以真正该问的问题是,创新的速率在加快,还是在减慢?

他讲了一个观察:大多数公司变大之后,创新能力会下降。不只是人均下降,绝对总量也下降。

这一点反直觉。公司大了,人多了,钱多了,按理说总产出该往上走。可现实是,规模越大,能拿出来的新东西越少。

他给的解释是激励机制没对齐。

光用语言鼓励创新是不够的,激励机制必须和创新目标对齐。这是根本。(马斯克)

这话说得很平,但戳中的是大公司的通病。嘴上喊创新,考核看的是季度利润和零失误。员工不傻,很快就明白组织真正奖励什么。于是所有人都在做安全的优化,没人愿意碰不确定的东西。

优化有确定回报,创造没有。激励一旦偏向确定性,组织就会自动长成一个擅长优化的机器,然后慢慢失去创造的能力。这不是文化问题,是结构问题。

面试时我们找一种证据

主持人提到在飞机上遇到一位SpaceX的年轻女工程师,聊了十几分钟,被她眼里的那种投入打动。他说这种文化他只在空军见过。

马斯克讲了两个动作。

第一个是招聘。我们找卓越能力的证据,evidence of exceptional ability。多数情况下,这种证据包含创新。

这句话的分量在于,它绕开了简历上的所有常规指标。哪所学校、前一家公司叫什么、干了几年,这些都不是重点。重点是有没有做出过超出常规的事。

他补了一句,不是说每个人都需要创新,但做高级工程的人必须。

第二个是激励结构。创新会得到奖励,过程中犯错不会带来大惩罚,但完全不尝试创新会带来大惩罚。

主持人接得快:胡萝卜加大棒,你不试,大棒就下来了。

对,会被解雇。

这套设计有意思的地方,是把"尝试"和"结果"彻底分开了。结果可以坏,尝试不能没有。一个团队如果连试都不试,说明它已经失去了对未来的兴趣,比失败严重得多。

让星际舰队成真

最后五分钟,主持人把话筒交给他,说在场上千名空天领域的专业人士,你想对他们说什么。

马斯克想了想:我觉得我们得让星际舰队成真。

全场笑,然后鼓掌。

他认真地往下讲。要造真正的大飞船,能去很远的地方。

然后是最"惹麻烦"的一段:我认为太空军应该有新制服。公众听到"太空军"这三个字,脑子里出现的是酷炫的飞船和好看的制服。这就是公众想要的。

笑归笑,落点很实。

我们想让好的那种科幻未来成真,最好在我们还活着的时候看到它发生。(马斯克)

这句话把前面所有的技术讨论收拢到了一起。曲速引擎不确定,传送大概率做不到,但大飞船能去远方,这个肯定能实现。所以真正要推的,是创新速率,快到让未来在当代人的有生之年落地。

回头看,他讲的失败、专利、速度、激励、文化,指向的是同一个东西。一个组织能不能在有限的时间里,把未来的到来时间往前挪几年。挪得动,就是竞争力。挪不动,专利再多、规模再大,也只是在守一座正在缩小的城。

对话中间还有个小插曲。主持人问公司文化,背景正放着平滑爵士乐,马斯克先吐槽了一句,这音乐真是报复性地诚实,我感觉我们在一部大电梯里。全场大笑,他才开始讲招聘和激励。

这个细节其实挺像他。话题再大,也先从现场最具体的那点不适说起。

给技术从业者的几条可操作建议

  • 把手上的项目按"单位时间创新"重新算一遍。分子是进步幅度,分母是耗时。分母太大的项目,哪怕愿景再漂亮,也该拆小或砍掉。
  • 给团队的失败分两类。可承受的写进流程,鼓励快试快错。灾难性的单独列出红线,一次都不许碰。不要用同一套复盘流程对待这两类事。
  • 检查你的考核表。如果里面只有交付、质量、零缺陷,没有"是否尝试过新路径",那你的组织实际上在奖励保守。嘴上说什么不重要,表格里写什么才重要。
  • 面试时多问一句:你做过的最超出常规的一件事是什么。答案的密度,比学历和前公司更能预测这个人敢不敢动手。
  • 判断自己的护城河是不是速度。如果是靠信息差、靠资质、靠关系,早点准备第二条路。这些东西的保质期正在变短。
  • 看竞争对手时,别只看新闻标题,去看他们工程师的实际产出速度。经济总量的差距是算术,工程能力的差距是日积月累,后者更难追。
  • 给自己设一个"这辈子要看到它发生"的清单。清单上的每一项,都反推一下需要多快的创新速率才能赶上。这个反推,比任何年度规划都更能校准方向。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00let's go back to failure for a minute and and and the mindset that that you have you and your leadership team at tesla and spacex have on failure i mean the spacex blooper reel that you guys did and i think his 2017 time frame was definitely hey we embraced this learning that occurs more recently with the the tesla truck and the and the ball through the window also that might that that that mindset that embraces failure how do you personally i mean that it that those kinds of failures would drive a lot of us in this room nuts but doesn't seem to drive you nuts seems like you're very comfortable with it can you talk about the mindset that requires for you to be that accepting of

0:57that kind of failure sure should we roll the video no should we not no we should not roll the video not yet okay okay okay well i think of the these things is just there's a certain amount of time and within that time you want the the best net outcome so for you know all the set of actions that you can do there's going to be and some of which will fail some which will succeed and you want the the net useful output of your set of actions to be the highest so we have to like use like a baseball analogy like you know baseball they don't let you just sit there and wait for the perfect pitch until that you get a real easy one they didn't give you

1:56three shots and the third one they say okay and they get off the they go back to the put somebody else up there so these your three strikes on on the baseball not you know not only bad anymore so so what you're what you're really looking for is like what's the batting average you know how how are you doing on on score and just there's going to be some amount of failure but you want your net output

2:34that useful output to be maximized failure is essentially irrelevant unless it is catastrophic okay yeah okay intellectual property obviously tesla spacex solarcity have amazing capabilities that they're bringing to the to the public and to the government every day how do you protect your intellectual property in a world where it seems like the cloud and servers and things are constantly under attack from people wishing to free you of their your intellectual property yeah well actually at tesla we just opened sourced our patents some years ago so anyone can use our patents so we really have not been tried to protect intellectual property in that sense we've tried to

3:26actually smooth the path because the overarching goal of tesla is to accelerate the advent of sustainable energy and so if we created a patent portfolio that discouraged other companies from making electric cars they will be inconsistent with our mission so we open source all the patterns okay in order to help the other and anyone else who wants to make an electric car so i guess that's the opposite of protecting the ip

3:59now the real way i think you you actually achieve intellectual property protection is by innovating fast enough if your rate of innovation is high then you don't need to worry about protecting vip because other companies will be copying something that you did years ago and that's fine you know just make sure your rate of innovation is fast speed is really speed of innovation is what is what matters and i do i do say this to my teams like quite a lot that innovation per unit time as i go innovation per year if you want to say like is is what matters not innovation absent time because if you wanted to make say 100 improvement in something and that took 100 years or one year

4:52that's radically different so it's like what is your rate of innovation that that matters and is the rate of innovation is that accelerating or decelerating and a weird thing happens when companies get big is that most companies or organizations the bigger they get they tend to get less innovative not just less innovative on a per person basis but less innovative in the absolute and i think this is probably because the incentive structure is not is not there for innovation

5:35it's not enough to use words to encourage innovation the incentive structure must be aligned with that that's fundamental so so taking that from a business level to a national level in terms of obviously united states largest economy in the world china the second largest economy in the world currently and gaining fast what sort of things that could you share with the audience here that are your thoughts on the competition economic or military between the united states and china sure well i think china is a real interesting country i have to say the the thing to appreciate about china is just that there's a lot of really smart really hard-working people there

6:28and they're gonna do a lot of great things this is sort of you know independent of of chinese government policy they're just going to do a lot of interesting things the thing that will be that will feel pretty strange is that the chinese economy is going to be probably at least twice as big as the us economy maybe three times but at least twice

6:59so that assumes a gdp per capita still less than the u.s but since they have about four or five times the population then it would only require getting to a gdp per capita of half the united states for their economy to be twice the size of ours and as i'm sure people in this room know the foundation of war is economics and so if you if you have half the resources

7:35of the counterparty then you better be real innovative if you're not innovative you're gonna lose i'm not sure whether that's a cyber attack that's ongoing or not here so [Laughter] the clock says i have 11 minutes left is that not true let's get some swoosh all right it's coming through the house system we're working to get it shut off thank you

8:26yes well anyway so so yeah with with respect to china china's economy is is going to be two to three times the size of the us economy at least at least double therefore in order for the us to be competitive on military level the innovation has to overcome a gigantic gap in economic output okay so in the absence of radical innovation the us will be militarily second okay

9:09basic basic math what from the standpoint of radical innovation we already talked about workforce we talked about processes we talked about protecting intellectual property rights let's talk about overall culture that culture that you try and push into your companies that makes them successful any of us and i sat right next to one of your spacex employees on the plane here yesterday a young engineer it was motivating for me just to talk to her about what she was doing every day and how important her job was and i just felt like the only other place i've seen that kind of culture is frankly in the department of the air force with some of our young folks that are

10:02sprinkled around the back of the room how do you create that culture at spacex and tesla to to make employees like that well wow this smooth jazz is just honest with a vengeance i feel like we're in a big elevator [Laughter] [Applause] so first of all when we interview people we we do ask for some evidence of exceptional ability which in most cases includes innovation this is not said everyone needs to be innovative it's but we certainly need those that are doing advanced engineering to be innovative and ideally everyone is at least some to some degree innovative so at the interview point we select for it for people who want to create new technology

11:02and then the incentive structure is set up that such that innovation is rewarded making mistakes along the way does not come with a big penalty and but but failure to try to innovate at all comes with a big penalty you'll be fired okay yeah all right the carrot and stick that's the steak if you don't even try or or somebody doesn't even try to innovate or their innovation aspirations are are very are not not very good then yeah they will no longer be at the company okay okay all right so we got about five minutes left and what i'd like to do is just turn it over to you elon to talk about whatever you'd like to talk about if you have a message for the audience here you have

11:59you know a thousand plus air and space professionals and the greatest air and space force on the planet so what do you want to tell them think we we got to make starfleet happen [Laughter] [Applause] so so we were like real big spaceships that can go far places and well this will probably get me into the most trouble of all i think this should be a new uniform that's you know

12:36that that's like i don't know cool uniforms cool spaceships you know i think that's what when the public hears space force that's what they think it's like okay we're gonna have like some sweet spaceships and like free look good uniforms and stuff and that'll be that's what the public wants so you know we want the sci-fi futures the the the good sci-fi futures to be real and ideally to become real while we're still alive you know and we want to see it happen and so i think we really need to drive the rate of innovation to be such that we would see a big big breakthroughs big improvements in space technology in you know in the years to come so yeah so like just trying to make

13:29starfleet happen as soon as humanly possible and definitely why we're while we're still alive yeah so we're not sure about wolf drive but we can other stuff i think can be done warp driving teleportation probably not but big spaceships that can go far places definitely that can be done understood ladies and gentlemen elon [Applause] musk

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份