媒体·中文精读

马斯克出席 Falcon Heavy 发射后发布会:完整采访

Elon Musk in Falcon Heavy Post Launch Press Conference - Full Interview

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2018年2月6日下午,佛罗里达肯尼迪航天中心39A发射台。一枚27台发动机的火箭升空,两分半钟后两个侧助推器脱离、掉头、点火减速,在相隔几公里的两片着陆场上几乎同时竖起支架站住。控制室里有人喊出声来。

马斯克后来说,那两个助推器同步着陆的画面,跟电脑模拟一模一样。

但真正让全球社交媒体炸锅的,是整流罩里那辆车。一辆樱桃红的特斯拉 Roadster(敞篷跑车),驾驶座上坐着一个穿白色宇航服的人偶,正以超过每小时四万公里的速度飞向火星轨道之外。

发布会现场第一个问题就是:这玩意儿是真的吗?

它看起来太荒诞、太不可能了。你能判断它是真的,恰恰因为它看起来像假的。说实话,如果我们真要做 CGI 假画面,水平会高得多。太空里没有大气散射,颜色看着都怪怪的,一切都太锐利。(马斯克)

他说到这里自己也笑了。这辆车没做过任何太空环境测试,座椅就是普通汽车的座椅,方向盘、轮胎、车漆全是量产件。马斯克说,一辆彻头彻尾的普通汽车飘在太空里,这种荒谬感正是他喜欢的部分。

一枚被取消过三次的火箭

Falcon Heavy(重型猎鹰)的方案听上去不复杂:把三枚 Falcon 9 的第一级捆在一起。马斯克在发布会上承认,最初全公司都这么想,然后就被现实教育了。

我们内部试过三次要砍掉 Falcon Heavy 项目,因为这玩意儿比想象中难太多了。(马斯克)

难在结构载荷。中心芯级(center core)要同时承受两个侧助推器传来的推力,总载荷超过一百万磅。原有的推力结构完全撑不住,整个底部得重新设计。

难在气动控制。侧助推器顶上本来要装整流罩,也就是一个锥形(ogive)的头。问题在于,锥形头会让气流贴着表面走,栅格翼(grid fins)能借到的气动力大幅下降。换成圆柱段,气流被打散、弹开,控制力矩能提升百分之五十以上。为了这个数字,团队重新设计了栅格翼,也重新算了整套控制系统的质量分布。

难在发射场。39A 要同时支持 Falcon 9 和 Falcon Heavy,管路、支撑臂、推进剂加注流程都得改。马斯克说,发射台本身的改动量比火箭还大。

他给出的总投入是:

我猜总投资超过五亿美元,可能更多。具体数字我不太想算,因为肯定比我愿意承认的多。(马斯克)

一个被取消三次的项目,最后花了五亿多美元、六年多时间才飞起来。这件事本身比火箭参数更值得记一笔:工程史上大多数“显而易见”的方案,真正的成本都藏在第一次动手之后。

两枚助推器回来了,中间那枚没有

发布会现场有人问,两个侧助推器同时着陆,是物理规律的必然,还是设计好的?

马斯克说,是偏移过的。两个助推器本来会落在几乎同一个点,但它们的导航雷达会互相干扰,一个的反射信号可能被另一个的接收机当成回波。所以团队让它们错开了一点距离,各自落在自己的着陆区。

至于中心芯级,它没回来。

它在海上驳船着陆时出了问题,落进了水里。马斯克没有详细解释故障,只说了句它在着陆的最后阶段没能站住。但他讲了一句很实在的话:

如果只能救一个,我会选侧助推器。因为上面装着钛合金栅格翼,中心芯级没装。那些栅格翼贵得离谱,生产还慢。(马斯克)

这几乎是整场发布会里最诚实的一段。火箭回收没有“成功学”,只有资源分配。哪块零件更贵、更难造、交期更长,就先救哪块。钛合金栅格翼用上了增材制造,单价高、产能紧,丢了就是几个月工期。中心芯级的发动机虽然也贵,但生产链条至少是通的。

还有个细节他没多讲:这两枚回来的侧助推器,一枚是第三代构型,一枚是第四代。它们只是“能回来”,不代表“能再用”。马斯克说得很清楚,从这个节点起,只有第五代(Block 5)的助推器才会被重复使用,第三代、第四代飞完就退役。

六千万和九千万之间的账

Falcon Heavy 的运力是全球现役火箭的两倍以上。马斯克举了个更直白的例子:它可以把探测器直接送到冥王星以外,中途不需要停靠,不需要引力助推。如果愿意做两三次轨道加注,它的载荷能力可以接近当年土星五号的水平。

但他紧接着说,不推荐这么干。

你可以用 Falcon Heavy 加轨道加注把人送回月球,但我不建议这么做。下一代架构才是正确的路。(马斯克)

价格才是这场发布会的隐性主题。Falcon 9 一次发射六千万美元,Falcon Heavy 九千万美元,运力却是三倍。

为什么差这么少?因为两种火箭真正被消耗掉的,都只有上面级。助推器回收,整流罩马上要开始回收,中心芯级迟早也能回收。一枚 Falcon Heavy 等于三枚 Falcon 9 的第一级,只有一份上面级。成本结构上,两者的差距被压到了最小。

这笔账解释了可复用性为什么值得死磕。火箭发射的成本大头是硬件,燃料只占很小的一块。一枚猎鹰九号第一级的造价,是它加注的推进剂价格的上百倍。把硬件捞回来重复用,经济模型立刻换了一个物种。

火箭升空之后,没有回滚按钮

有人问马斯克,看发射的时候脑子里在想什么。

他的回答可能是整场发布会里最接近工程师内心的一段:

任何一个参与设计的人,脑子里都在滚动清单。所有的失败模式,成千上万种出错的方式,全都得同时走对。火箭一离开发射台,就没有回滚的选项了,你没法上传一个软件补丁,没法按暂停。这就像你在盯着一个所有科目都不及格的考生。(马斯克)

他拿飞机做类比。当年波音 747 或者 DC-3 首飞的时候,总工程师大概也是同样的心情:这玩意儿真的能飞起来吗?

这句话的分量在于,它解释了为什么 SpaceX 对 Falcon Heavy 的预期压得那么低。首飞前马斯克公开说过成功率大概五成,很多人以为是在做公关,其实是真的。一枚新火箭,二十七台发动机并联,两个侧助推器要在超音速下分离、掉头、再点火,任何一个环节抖一下就是几亿美元和几年的代价。

这也是为什么成功之后他说自己到现在还没缓过来。

一套做了三年的航天服

Reddit 的 SpaceX 版块有人问 Starman 身上那套白色宇航服:是量产的,还是道具?带仪器吗?加压吗?

马斯克说,那是真的。

那是我们实际的量产设计,而且它就是资格验证件之一。真人穿的那套,跟它长得一模一样。(马斯克)

设计花了三年。他还讲了一句带点无奈的经验:

做一套好看但不能用的航天服,容易。做一套能用但不好看的,也容易。做一套又好看又能用的,真的很难。(马斯克)

这背后是航天服的真实工程约束。要能在真空环境下维持压力,要能让手部保持足够的灵活度去拨开关,要散热,要防辐射,视野还得够宽。NASA 的舱外航天服一套造价上千万美元,重量超过一百公斤。SpaceX 这套白黑配色、线条干净的版本,光是把外观和功能捏到一起,就磨了三年。

至于 Starman 那个“人”,里面是个假人模型,只是把衣服撑起来。马斯克说,这套衣服没做过真空测试,但设计上确实能工作。他补了一句:如果真要去那么危险的地方,起码得好看点。

Starman 没有返程计划

有人问,那辆车接下来怎么办?

马斯克说,没有计划。

车载电池从发射起大概能撑十二个小时,之后它就只是在深空里飘着,可能是几百万年,也可能是几十亿年。也许有一天会被某个外星文明发现,他们会很困惑:这帮人到底在干嘛?他们是不是崇拜这辆车?为什么车里还有一辆小车?(马斯克)

那个“车里的小车”,是仪表盘上放的一辆 Hot Wheels 合金模型,旁边还有个更小的宇航员。这是马斯克的一个朋友提议的,说这样会很酷。他当场就同意了。

他还解释了为什么不用传统配重:

新型火箭首飞,通常会装一块混凝土块当配重。太无聊了。这辆车的画面,能让全世界的人兴奋起来。(马斯克)

这件事常被拿来当营销案例,但它还有另一层意思。一次首飞测试的载荷选择,本身就是一种传播决策。混凝土块和一辆红色跑车,物理质量相同,信息质量天差地别。技术行业长期低估了这件事的价值:人们不会记住参数,但会记住画面。

用巨型捕手手套去接整流罩

有记者问整流罩回收的进展。马斯克说,这件事比想象中难得多,但应该能在半年内搞定。

难在哪?整流罩是两瓣巨大的复合材料罩壳,分离后要各自开降落伞落海。问题是这个罩壳太大、太怪,开伞之后会严重干扰周围气流,伞绳拧成一团,罩壳自己打转。一开始它的优先级排得很靠后,因为那时候要解决的是助推器回收,量级完全不一样。

方案最后定成这样:一艘专门的船,船上装一个巨大的网兜,像棒球捕手手套,罩壳带着伞飘下来,正好落进网里。

一艘船追着跑,一个巨大的捕手手套形状的东西去接它。挺好玩的。(马斯克)

他还顺口提了一句,同样的办法也许能用来接龙飞船(Dragon),当然得 NASA 点头才行。这话说完现场笑了一阵,但它不是玩笑。载人飞船返回时如果不用落海溅落,而是被网兜接住,回收流程、翻修周期、复用成本都会变。这个思路在几年后确实被继续推进过。

Falcon 到此封顶,接下来是 BFR

发布会上反复出现的一个词是 BFR,Big Falcon Rocket,后来的星舰(Starship)。马斯克说得很直接:Falcon 9 和 Falcon Heavy 的架构到第五代就停,不会再有第六代。

Block 5 之后,Falcon 架构就固定了。龙飞船也一样,到第二代就停,后面只有小版本迭代。我们绝大部分工程资源,会转向 BFR。(马斯克)

他说这件事的时候,语气里有一种卸货的轻松。Falcon 系列前后折腾了十几年,从一枚小火箭迭代到能把跑车送出地球轨道。到 2018 年这个节点,主线任务基本完成,剩下的活是把它变成一台稳定、可重复使用的运载工具。

BFR 的尺寸他给了具体数字:直径 9 米,大概 30 英尺;长度 110 到 120 米。他补了一句自嘲:

听起来很大,但看久了也就那样。人适应得很快。(马斯克)

真正让他兴奋的,是 Falcon Heavy 这次同步着陆给他的信心。两个十六层楼高、支架展开六十英尺的助推器,能像模拟动画一样精确落地,说明“大量飞行器反复起降”这件事在工程上是可扩展的。他由此推断,BFR 那套更大的架构,走得通。

最难的部分从大气层开始

马斯克把 BFR 拆成两半看:助推器和飞船。

助推器相对好办。可回收、能反推着陆的大家伙,SpaceX 已经做了几十次,心里有底。

飞船才是硬骨头。它要从火星转移轨道那种速度再入大气层,比从近地轨道回来难得多。他讲了一个物理细节:

再入加热的某些分量,随速度的增长接近八次方。没什么东西是按八次方增长的。所以你测这东西的时候会非常难受。(马斯克)

速度翻一倍,加热量可能涨到两百多倍。这就是为什么热防护是整艘飞船最难的一环。马斯克说,要做的是一种能反复使用、能扛住行星际再入速度的隔热材料,飞回来之后不用大修,加注燃料就能再走。

他的策略是反过来的:先把最难的部分做掉。飞船先行,助推器后补。

我们是从最难的部分开始的。助推器我们大概懂了,能反推着陆、能复用的助推器,这个我们有把握。飞船不行。(马斯克)

他还提了一个惊人的设计指标:如果加满推进剂,这艘飞船本身具备单级入轨(single-stage-to-orbit)的能力。这个说法在航天界是有争议的,因为单级入轨在历史上被当成工程上的死路,但马斯克的意思是,飞船的推进剂质量和结构系数留了足够大的余量。

时间表、短跳,以及“也许”

有记者追问:你说的“也许明年”到底指什么?

马斯克说的是短跳测试(hop test)。就像当年 Falcon 9 的 Grasshopper 项目,一枚火箭在试验场垂直起飞、悬停、垂直降落。地点可能在南德州布朗斯维尔附近的场地,也可能在海上做船对船测试,最后大概率选布朗斯维尔,因为那里有大片土地,周围没人。

所谓悬停测试,就是飞上去几英里,再落下来。飞行复杂度会逐步提高。(马斯克)

更进一步的测试是热防护验证:飞出去、掉头、全力加速冲回来,用极高的再入速度去“烤”隔热层。这一步不测,后面全是纸上推演。

完整的全系统测试飞行,他给的预期是三到四年。再往后,去月球会很快提上日程。这话他说得很轻,但在 2018 年听起来相当激进。

关于 NASA 关心的载人任务,他给了另一个时间点:载人龙飞船的目标是当年年底。他说一个月前已经把优先级调整成“全公司资源向载人龙倾斜”,因为 Falcon 9 Block 5 和 Falcon Heavy 基本定型,剩下的活可以分出去。

这几个时间点后来没有一个准时兑现。载人龙飞船实际首飞载人是 2020 年 5 月,星舰的轨道级测试拖到了 2023 年。这是马斯克时间表的常态,他自己也知道。但他给时间表的方式值得留意:他会说“aspiring to”,会说“maybe”,会承认“很多不确定性”。这种表达在发布会现场容易被当成保守,事后回看反而更接近真实。

一场私营公司发起的新竞赛

有记者提到贝索斯发推特祝贺,问他是否认为自己是在和蓝色起源(Blue Origin)赛跑。

马斯克没接这个话。他绕回去讲了整流罩回收的技术细节。

但他在另一个回答里把立场说清楚了:

Falcon Heavy 完全是 SpaceX 自己出资做的,没有拿任何人的钱。如果一家商业公司能做到这件事,其他国家和公司就会想:那我们也可以做得更大更好。这是好事,我们希望有一场新的太空竞赛。竞赛是让人兴奋的。(马斯克)

这段话里藏着一个判断:他把“竞赛”定义成了一种公共品。太空竞赛在冷战时期确实推动了技术跃迁,阿波罗计划的预算峰值占美国联邦支出超过百分之四。马斯克的意思是,竞争压力比任何补贴都有效。

关于国家安全任务的认证,他给的说法是:不需要很多次飞行,取决于具体任务。等到三四年后国家安全卫星要发射的时候,Falcon Heavy 大概已经飞了一二十次。下一次任务已经在路上,是用 Block 5 构型的 STP 测试任务。

他最后被问到发射台切换的问题。Falcon Heavy 和 Falcon 9 共用 39A,来回切换是设计时就考虑过的。侧助推器可以直接用现役 Falcon 9 的第一级改,换掉级间段、装个鼻锥、换上钛合金栅格翼。中心芯级不行,它得专门造。

发布会到这基本结束。马斯克最后说,今天对 SpaceX 来说是最好的日子之一,然后被工作人员叫走了。

那天之后发生的事,后来被反复复盘:中心芯级落海、整流罩没接住、BFR 的故事讲了很多年、星舰炸了很多次。但 2018 年 2 月 6 日那 30 分钟的发布会,仍然是一次罕见的、把工程细节讲得这么具体的公开谈话。它没有停在“我们成功了”,而是把成本、失败、取消、返工全都摊在了桌面上。

做技术的人可以从那场发布会里拿走这么几件事:

  • 估算一个新项目的预算时,先在心里乘三。Falcon Heavy 内部取消过三次,实际投入五亿多美元,比最初的乐观估计高出一个量级。凡是涉及多系统耦合的工程,第一次的成本估算基本都错,错的方向是低估。
  • 复杂系统要按“最贵零件优先”设计回收方案。哪块硬件交期长、单价高、产能紧,就先保证它能回来。资源有限时,别平均分配救援优先级。
  • 把最难的部分放在最前面做。BFR 的次序是飞船先行、助推器后补,因为热防护是那个没被验证过的环节。任何项目里,先做“一旦失败就全盘推翻”的部分,比先做容易的部分更能提前暴露风险。
  • 演示飞行的载荷选择也是工程决策的一部分。混凝土块和跑车质量相同,传播效果差了几个数量级。技术团队规划验证性项目时,可以主动设计一个能被记住的画面,这不会损伤严谨性。
  • 看技术路线图时,先看它有没有给不确定性留位置。马斯克的说法是“aspiring to”“maybe”“a lot of uncertainties”,这比给出一个确定日期更接近真实。留了不确定性的时间表,可信度反而更高。
  • 可复用性的经济账要算到“只有上面级被消耗”这一层。如果一项降本方案只省了燃料或人工,硬件仍然一次性,那它改变不了成本结构。判断可复用方案能不能成立,看它是否让最贵的那部分反复使用。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:20[Music] everyone in the room we're going to be starting momentarily I'd asked that if you have a mobile phone I'm going to get let's eat let's he seated the chef Ginsburg little short

1:03I'm gonna try to prove some three [Music] and we've got 30 minutes

1:23[Music] spirit [Music] joining us a little surreal to me I had this image [Music]

6:02to read the full 300 minutes right enough people to travel to travel for one that sees to like engines so it I think that's a center one that lead the outer to did not and that was to hit the water month now and took out to the end zone foreigner if you've got the footage some pretty fun footage if the cameras didn't get

6:38blown up as well for real but that's best baby what we're going to reuse the set but that's our craving look at you psychic system side pieces will forget something enough it since they're not blocked by the butcher client the power stations that works piece of computerized aggressive and

7:14they will see if the upper stage engine is alive quite larger spoke through that house but only there were a stage will prosper quickly two belts here it's essentially well of course first o'clock and then it's gonna do a restart simply just repellent and go to that's awesome the Raghava we'll look at the second

7:47round of the upper stage we were 20 26 which is basically right later it has like two propellant to the transpose direction that's everything that fuel doesn't freeze the else that's with my things

8:23own took a look at the side boosters they looking a really good condition so they're they're both reliable although as I said their combination of version 3 in version 4 so we will we're only gonna be reef lying really version 5 at this point that that launches shortly and that that will be on me and stable will stick to version fight for the Falcon architecture we don't expect to have a version 6 all right any

8:53questions that I haven't answered I'll do my best to answer them but not sure if I have the information yet but I'll try start in the room and the first question goes to David Kerley from ABC News he launched spectacular what did you learn what did Falcon Heavy teach you I guess taught me like crazy things can come true like because I said like I

9:19didn't really think this would work like when I see the rocket liftoff I see like a thousand things that that could not work and it's amazing when they do and I was really that seeing the to Bruce's land synchronize really just like the simulation I mean it makes you think like you there really that could be quite a scalable approach you know if you could have imagined large numbers of those just coming in and landing taking off landing doing many flights per day so it I think gives me a lot of faith for our next architecture the sort of be an interplanetary spaceship you have

10:07different names for it but BFRs the county code name and it gives me confidence that bfr is really quite workable as i should look at the side boosters and like they're pretty big you know sixteen stories tall 60-foot legs man but you really we need to be way bigger than that so so i think it's

10:34giving me a lot of confidence that we can make the VFR design work yeah it's a traumatic event so I'm SpaceX team so I think I think we can really do this a lot you know and keep advancing that the cube advancing the technology to achieve full and rapid reusability whichever whatever profound effect on the future and when there's some things about say Falcon Heavy vs Falcon 9 is that Falcon Heavy has the same level of expandability as Falcon line so if you look at say the price of oak line is sixty million dollars Felton he's 90 even though it's got three times as much capability because in both cases the only thing that's expanded is the upper stage we're gonna start recovering

11:32with the the fairings the big nose cone we're gonna recover that we recover the Boosters and so there's really the cost of us really between a Falcon 9 I felt the henries minor well the next question from marcia done at Associated Press March 10 EP what were yours what was going through your mind how how amazed were you to see your roadster up there what should our man just cruising along with the blue planet and how long will we be getting life views do you think from the car well I think it looks so ridiculous and impossible and you can

12:12tell it's real because it looks so fake honestly we'd have way better CGI infamous fake and you know the colors all look like kind of weird in space there's no atmospheric occlusion you know you know it's like everything looks too crisp and but we know we didn't really test any of those materials for you know is its space hardened or whatever you know so it just has the same seats that like normal car has it's a slickly a normal car in space which I

12:48kind of like the absurdity of that and if you look closely there's on the dashboard there's a tiny roadster with a tiny spaceman the hot wheels made a Hot Wheels roadster and a friend a friend of mine and I suggested hey why you put that wheels roadster with a tiny space man on the you know in the car - like that'd be cool sure mysteries that I mean it's kind of

13:17silly and fun but I think I think that's you know silly fun things are important and normally for a new rocket you know they'd launch like a block of concrete or something like that I mean that's so boring and I think that's just the imagery of it is something that's gonna get people excited around the world

13:46and I still tripping me out I mean out tripping balls here yeah congratulations Ilan great launch today where do you see the Falcon Heavy fitting into this launch industry is this something that is going to be for more national security you see this for interplanetary missions what's the future of Falcon Heavy yeah the great thing is like so Falcon Heavy opens up a new class of payload so it can launch more than twice as much payloads any other rocket in the world so it's kind of up to customers what they might want to launch but it can launch things direct to Pluto and beyond you know no stop needed they

14:30don't even need like a gravity assist or anything and won't join satellites it can do anything you want you go back to you could send people back to the moon with a bunch of you know if you did a bunch of motions the Falcon Heavy and did an orbital reef refilling the two or three Falcon heavies you know woody called the payload of a Saturn 5 but I

14:56wouldn't recommend doing that cuz I think the new architects should be a for architecture is the way to go but I think it's it's gonna open officers possibility I think it's gonna encourage other companies and countries to say hey if SpaceX which is a commercial company can do this and nobody paid for Falcon Heavy is paid forward and put in total funds then then

15:21they thank you Jeff - so things can encourage other countries and companies to raise their sights and say hey we can do bigger and better which is great we want a new space race face races were exciting kind of talked us through your your thought process as you were watching the launch e you said you were incredibly concerned about it just you know you just wanted to through the pad because it kind of I said expectations low so talk me through as you were watching it yeah I think this is true of anyone who's involved and didn't close in the design or something just you know all the ways they can fail and and

16:09that's like the sort of mental checklist that's scrolling through your mind it's all the things that can can can break I mean there's thousands of things that can go wrong and everything has to go right once look once the rocket lifts off there's nothing there's an opportunity to do a recall or upload a software fix or anything like that it's like you see the passenger grades on Harper sent at least really a sad face

16:37and I've seen Rockets Bluff so many different ways so you know it's a big relief when it it actually works at the first you know when they first whoever it is like it was like you know when they're like first launched like a 747 or or dc-3 or like that I bet the chief engineer was like I can't believe that thing flying how about Irene Klotz from

17:06Aviation Week hurry we need to have you on Mike first for the folks on the phone to hear ok thanks Irene Klotz with Aviation Week congratulations the can you talk to us a little bit about what needs to happen to certify Falcon Heavy for the national security missions how far along you are in that process and how many flights you might need to do and also if you're able to say anything about how much your SpaceX is investment to get to the rocket to this point thanks I think we only need I think

17:52there's there's a chance on which NASA's national security mission that we'd need to yeah you know how many flights depends on which mission but we have a number of commercial customers for Falcon Heavy and so I think I really don't think it's gonna be in any way an impediment to acceptance of national security missions we'll be doing several Falcon Heavy missions flights per year so let's say if there's a big national security satellite that's due for launch in three or four years or we probably have like a dozen or four more launches done by then so what it won't really I

18:36think there'll be a launch number that's that's an inhibitor or national security stuff and yeah so and then we've got the STP mission that that's coming up which is another test mission that'll go on full-on a where everything's on black 5 version 5 of the rocket and then we'll

18:57be launching version 5.5 single stick in a couple couple months so I think it's hopefully smooth sailing or qualification for national security missions our investment to date probably a lot more than I'd like to admit you know that we try to cancel the Falcon Heavy program three times at SpaceX because it's like man this is way harder than we thought is there shal idea was just like ah you know you stick on to give to first

19:36stages of side boosters how I canopy it's like way hard we had to redesign the center core completely we have to redesign the the grid fins because like what it's a lot long story but if you've got a nose cone on the end of it at the end of the booster instead of a cylinder you lose control Authority because if

20:02you if you got a cylinder you can kind of bounce the air off of the rocket and you get like a 50% or more increased control authority if you've got a cylindrical section instead of a an ogive section at the end of the booster so we have to redesign the grid fins reason to control the control system mass would redesign the thrust structure at the base to take way more load that Center boosters got a deal with over a

20:31million pounds of load coming in combined from the side boosters so it's as of being heavier so that the center course basically completely redesigned and and even the side boosters there's a pretty large number of parts that change and then the the launch site itself needs to change a lot I'm guessing our total investment is over half a billion probably more yeah

21:00I'd like to take some questions from the phone I think the first one up is Dan Fergana from BuzzFeed news is that right that's right dan McGann with BuzzFeed nude news could you talk a little bit about the decision to have the two side cores come down at the same time is it just the way it falls out from the physics or was that actual decision you made we did offset

21:23them slightly but but really they're pretty much just come down that that there's no we're off set slightly just to the radars didn't interfere and we actually wanted no communication between the two stages they've both going to point absolute space and we're just worried that the radar reflection of one would be seen by the radar receiver of the other but no it just that's just kind of how it happened it's actually meant to happen just like that the next

21:58question on the phone comes from Keith cowling and that's a watch congratulations you've watched a rather unconventional payload into space one that's generated a lot of buzz and there's a lot of people some of them citizen scientists some of them they're just newbies when it comes to tracking things and space are going to try and track the the test flow and understand what's happening to it you know like that movie dude where's my car and other than the live webcam today what does SpaceX going to do to interact with this community of Tesla trackers once the car leaves orbit you have a plan are you just going to kind of wait and see what bubbles up on the

22:33internet and react to it we don't have a plan no plan the battery's gonna last about 12 hours from launch roughly and after that it's just gonna be out there in deep space for maybe millions or billions of years who knows and yeah maybe discovered by some future alien race thinking what the heck what what were these guys doing did they worship with this car why do they have a little car in the car don't really confuse them I'm not sure what's

23:17gonna happen but I think you know it's kind of a fun thing and I sure hope that next burn works by the way yeah well known a few hours that's okay so phase how about Chris Davenport from the Washington Post you could wait until we get you might Thanks so now that you're focusing more on the bfr I wonder if you could talk a little bit about the timeline I know you said it's coming along faster and then what that means for your plans for Mars and the moon

23:50well I'm gonna get to off-topic but okay I think we might if we get like you will be able to do short hop our flights with the spaceship part of VFR maybe next year all right one more in the room let's see who's how about bill Harwood from CBS thanks Laura CB I saw when I took on residual Sigma which is like the key it's it's a decent decently long bone there may be a minute or so and yeah

24:29that'll be in a few hours hopefully I actually don't have the latest climate reform because I was just added actually that out of the landing zone and have been back to launch control since going to landing zone so I don't have the latest information on the status of the upper stage Tom Costello

24:50from NBC News please well congratulations again I wanted to follow up on Chris's question because Chris asked you what's your timeline potentially to go to the Moon or Mars and you said did you say as soon as next year can you quantify that by the night my real question I'm just doing Chris's water sure yeah [Laughter] well the hopper tests I mean kind of like we have to get grasshopper program for falcon 9 where we just add the rocket take take off and land in Texas I know Texas test site so that would be will either do that at our South Texas floor site near near Brownsville or or

25:38do ship-to-ship we're not sure yet whether ship-to-ship or brownsville but most likely it's gonna happen at our brownsville location because we've got a lot of land with nobody around and so if it was up it's cool but by hover test I mean it'll you know go up you know several miles and then come down the ship will the ship is capable of the single-stage-to-orbit if you fully load the tanks

26:08so that will do flights of increasing complexity we want to test the heat shield material something like you know fly out turn around accelerate back real hard and come in hot to test the heat shield because we want to have highly reusable heat shield that's capable of absorbing the heat from interplanetary entry velocities so

26:37it's really tricky potential the potential to go to the Moon or Mars what's your timeline daya so a lot of uncertainties on this program but it is gonna be our focus after now that we're almost done with with Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy we're gonna level off as I said at block 5 of

27:00version 5 best there won't be any more major versions of Falcon 9 or Falcon Heavy Dragon is also going to level off with dragon version 2 there might be like point releases you know point five point one over dragon tube or something like that but most of our engineering resources will be dedicated to VFR and and so I think that that will make things go quite quickly the ship part is by far the hardest because that's going to come in from super order books it's super super orbital velocities like interplanet yeah Mars transfer velocities both moon transfer velocities these these are way harder than coming in from low-earth orbit some others they're some of the

27:48heating things that scale to the 8th power which which doesn't think relies there's anything that scales to 8th power if it turns out reentry certain elements of reentry heating scale to the at the 8th to the 8th so or just yet testing that ship out is the real tricky part the booster I think I don't want to get you know complacent but I think we understand reasonable boosters reusable spaceships that can land propulsively that's that's harder so we're starting with the hard part first and I think it's conceivable that

28:26we do our first test flight in 3 or 4 years of a you know full up overall test flight including the booster oh no a little bit first but it would be capable of going to the moon shortly thereafter it's designed to do that you know we want to be sensitive to your time how many more questions you want a couple questions ok sure there is a gentleman I came from a retic community that I wanted to definitely call on and I don't know your riddle I don't want to say your name so you can introduce yourself with your name or your handle hi my name is Martin Avenue and I'm with reddit's our SpaceX community I'd like to congratulate it you as well as so many people have done

29:09just now I'd like to know about Starman spacesuit is it a production model is it instrumented and/or pressurized and what's holding is what's holding them up well there's a mannequin inside so it's just basically stuffed but yeah that is the actual production design so the real one looks like just like that that in fact that's one of the qualification articles so that's that's real that's the real deal yeah I figure if you're

29:37gonna go you know to I mean it's dangerous this dangerous trip you want to look good man took us three years to design that spit that's basically it was real hard and it's easier to make a spacesuit that looks good see that but doesn't work or that works but doesn't look good it's really difficult to make a spacesuit that looks good and works and you have to make it a multi-part process and it was surprisingly difficult very difficult

30:07how about that Dave musher from business insider right I take most sure from Business Insider thank you so much for doing this by the way and I want to go back to VFR for a second since you were talking about that in also Starman which is such an inspirational thing that's happening have you thought given any thought to what you might do with bfr and and that way what is the what is the payload and any thoughts of that no a no idea it's gestures are welcome I mean it's a beast so you know the VFR 9 meter diameter 30

30:47feet roughly diameter which is yeah if you put a lot in 30 feet diameter get 110 hundred 20 meters long yeah big although you know I bet it doesn't look that big after a while how about 10 holes from ports hi eman thanks again

31:25for doing this two questions for you one just about faring recovery just curious how SpaceX is coming with that and to Jeff Bezos just responded to your tweet congratulating you on your launch today you just mentioned a minute ago that we need a new space race I'm just curious if you see yourself in a race with Blue Origin what was the first part of the question

31:50yeah so the fairing you're covering is proven surprisingly difficult I think I think I'm pretty sure we're also very recovery in the next six months it turns out like you pop the parachute on the fairing you've got this giant awkward thing it tends to interfere with the air flow on the on the parachute and and miss and gets all twisty and and it obviously was a low priority to also we

32:26have varying version two which is the really that's the important one that we want to recover so even if we were faring version one that that wouldn't be we would be flying it in the future suffering too and recovery that's very important and my guess is next six months we figure out for recovery we've got a special boat to catch the bearing just like a catcher's mitt it's like a giant catcher's mitt in book form run

32:54around I can't catch the ferry yeah she's kind of fun you might be able to do the same thing with dragon so unless if NASA wants us to we could try try to catch a dragon meant for the fairing but it would work on dragon two in the room how about that James Dean from Florida today

33:26thanks so much Ilan James Dean floor today speaking of those dragons could you give us a status on Commercial Crew and and you know when we might realistically see an astronaut just getting to low-earth orbit much less the Moon or Mars yeah yeah we're making great progress on crew dragon or dragon version two that's yeah if it actually

33:51tells the company priorities the obviously mission assurance is always number one as a priority but then the number that the the priority used to be a falcon iron block five and then a month ago I said absolute priority is crew dragon so we're pretty much done with Falcon and block five over five pretty much almost done with Falcon Heavy a few tweaks that would occur with falcon heavy block five but they're minor and so it's all hands on deck for crew dragon and our goal is to we're

34:25aspiring to fly crew two over two at the end of this year that's our goal I think that's I think the harder will be ready we have time for one more question in the room and it's just looking at Falcon eyes like yeah kind of swole have to wrap it and I'd like for Chris Gephardt pleased to have the last question question from in terms of the next falcon heavy which is that arab sad are the one for the Air Force do you have any idea of how pate held up from today's launch and how quickly can it be changed and so yes and I guess my

35:11questions are how quickly can the pad be reconfigured between heavy and Falcon 9 since you need that pad for both it's it's it's so problem going back and forth this is it's designed that way and for the block five version of the Falcon 9 or Falcon Heavy are the this is the Falcon Heavy need a dedicated core built for it or the block it does ok if this was the center court needs to be dedicated yeah so that's the center core is a special build the side boosters we can reuse existing falcon eyes but we need to just replace the interstage with a with a nose cone and a nice use the the upgraded titanium grid fins which are sweet those worked out real well I'm

35:48really happy about those in fact I'm glad we got the side boosters back because they have the titanium grid fins in the center core didn't so I first to pick any one I would have picked the side boosters I picked the center court of explode if so that would be like the least yeah those friggin grid fins alright they're super expensive and and awesome but they the production air and they were slow we didn't we didn't back though that like that was those the most important thing to recover were those Griffin's series inside the spacesuit testing like its ability to vote function no it's just up there yeah no it definitely work so you can just like jump in a in a

36:23vacuum chamber with it it's fine [Laughter] [Applause] as well for real but that best day they have we're gonna reduce the set but that's everything over the to Cyprus will subside residual very handsome is one of it says they're not the conversations works - incorrect they'll see if the upper stage engine I survived quite or just use that help us

37:25only potential prospects quickly to Van Allen belts here it's essentially well before suppressor left and then it's going to do a restart completed balance and go to class boss

38:26took a look at these high boosters they looking a really good condition so they're they're both reliable although as I said they're combination of version three in version 4 so we will we're only gonna be reef lying really version 5 at this point that that launches shortly and that that will be our main stable will stick to version 5 for the Falcon architecture we don't expect to have a version 6 alright any

38:56questions that I haven't answered I'll do my best to answer them but not sure if I have the information yet but I'll try start in the room and the first question goes to David Kerley from ABC News he donned spectacular what did you learn what did Falcon Heavy teach you I guess taught me like crazy things can come true like because I said like I

39:22didn't really think this would work and like when I see the rocket liftoff I see like a thousand things that that could not work and it's amazing when they do and I was really but seeing the two boosters land synchronize really just like the simulation I mean makes me think like you they're really that could be quite a scalable approach you could imagine fudge names of those just coming in and landing taking you off landing doing many flights per day so I think

40:00gives me a lot of faith for our next architecture the Soviet if planetary spaceship cap different names for it but BFRs County code name and I it gives me confidence that bfr is really quite workable come as I should look at the side boosters and like they're pretty big you know 16 stories tall 60-foot leg span but you really we need to be way

40:32bigger than that so so I think it's giving me a lot of confidence that we can make the VFR design work yeah it's I ever have press conference at SpaceX team I think I think we can really do this a lot you know and and keep advancing that the keep advancing the technology to achieve full and rapid

41:09reusability whichever whatever profound effect on the future and when there's things about a Falcon Heavy versus Falcon 9 is that Falcon Heavy has the same level of expandability as Falcon light so if you look at say the price of oak line is sixty million dollars Felton heavies ninety even though it's got three times as much capability because in both cases the only thing that's expanded is the upper stage we're gonna start recovering the the fairings the big nose cone we're gonna recover the fat recover the Boosters and so there's really the cost difference really between a falcon 9 falcon heavy is minor

41:48of the next question from Marcia done at Associated Press March 10 EP what were yours but what was going through your mind how how amazed were you to see your roadster up there what should our man just cruising along with the blue planet and how long will we be getting life use do you think from the car well I think it looks so ridiculous than impossible and you can tell it's real because it looks so fake honestly better CGI

42:20infamous fake and you know the colors all look like kind of weird in space there's no atmospheric occlusion you know you know like everything looks too crisp and could we know we didn't really test any of those materials for you know as its space hardened or whatever you know so it just has the same seats that

42:46like normal car has its ass literally a normal car in space which I kind of like the absurdity of that any feel closely there's on the dashboard there's a tiny roadster with a tiny spaceman Hot Wheels made a Hot Wheels roadster and a friend a friend of mine suggested hey why you put that wheels roadster with a tiny spaceman on it you know in the car too like that'd be cool sure let's agree to that I mean it's kind of silly and fun but I think I think that's you know

43:25silly fun things are important and normally for a new rocket you know they've launched like a block of concrete or something like that I mean that's so boring and I think that's the imagery of it is something that's gonna get people excited around the world and still tripping me out I mean out tripping balls here congratulations on

44:03great launch today where do you see the Falcon Heavy fitting into this launch industry is this something that is going to be for more national security you see this for interplanetary missions what's the future of Falcon Heavy yeah the great thing is like so Falcon Heavy offers up a new class of payload so it can launch more than twice as much payloads any other rocket in the world so it's kind of up to customers what they might want to launch but it can launch things direct to Pluto and beyond you know no stop needed didn't even need like a gravity assist or anything and won't strain satellites but I wouldn't

44:43wreck and say hey we can do bigger and better which is great we want a new space race races were exciting how about Darrell nail from the Fox affiliate Orlando but some others kind of talk us through your your thought process as you were watching the launch e you said you were incredibly concerned about it just you know you just wanted to through the pad because it kind of I said expectations low so talk me through as you were watching it yeah I think this was true of anyone who's involved you

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份