2008年,底特律正在悬崖边上。通用和克莱斯勒的现金流以周为单位倒计时,国会山上吵成一团,救助方案和刺激计划轮番占据头条。
就在同一个时间窗口,一家加州小公司拿到了美国政府近5亿美元的贷款担保。这家公司叫特斯拉,当时在路上跑的车不到1700台,最贵的一款卖11万美元。《华尔街日报》的艾伦·默里把批评原封不动搬到了马斯克面前:为什么美国纳税人的钱,要去给乔治·克鲁尼和拉里·佩奇造一个11万美元的玩具?
马斯克的回答很干脆:如果这个说法成立,那这个批评完全站得住脚。问题是它不成立。
这场访谈里,他把三件事掰开讲:钱从哪来,车卖给谁,技术最后给了谁。三件事都跟当时的舆论印象有出入。
先说说这个人。默里的开场介绍是,马斯克是特斯拉的CEO,也是SpaceX的CEO,后者"在某个时点要把人送上太空"。默里还提了一句题外话:小罗伯特·唐尼在《钢铁侠》里演的托尼·斯塔克,原型是不是你?马斯克的回答是"某些方面是的"。不否认,也不认领全部,很像他的说话方式。
这个回答放在2008年看,分量不太一样。那一年特斯拉在生死线上,SpaceX的前三次发射都没成功,马斯克个人的钱快烧完了。电影里的托尼·斯塔克在山洞里用一堆废铁造出方舟反应炉,现实里的这个人正在为下一笔工资发愁。两条线之间的距离,比电影里短得多。
一台被当成高尔夫球车的车,跑出了250英里
先看产品。访谈进行时,Roadster 在路上的数量是1600到1700台。默里试乘过,用他的话说,加速"很惊人",0到60英里大约3秒。价格接近11万美元。默里当场给了判断:这不是我们能源问题的答案。
马斯克同意。他说 Roadster 最大的价值,在于打破人们对电动车的误解:你可以造一台快的、好看的、能跑长途的电动车。
续航接近250英里。马斯克说这个数字比历史上任何一台电动车都长,Roadster 在续航上破了一堆世界纪录。有一台车在一次行程里跑了超过300英里。默里追问是谁,马斯克说其实有两位客户,一位在澳大利亚的拉力赛上,赛程500公里,那是电动车第一次不充电跑完那场拉力赛;另一位在欧洲。
这里有个细节值得停一下。标称续航250英里,客户跑出300英里,这两件事不能直接划等号。一次行程里中途补电是常态,马斯克说的是"行程里程",默里问的是"一次充电能跑多远"。访谈里没有把这层说透,读者容易混。
但无论怎么算,250英里这个数字在当时是碾压级的。2008年市面上能买到的量产电动车,续航普遍在几十英里的量级,用途被锁死在社区通勤。250英里意味着从洛杉矶开到拉斯维加斯不用停。这是一次品类定义上的越级,跟省不省油没关系。
客户名单里有乔治·克鲁尼,有拉里·佩奇。马斯克补了一句更重要的信息:佩奇和谢尔盖·布林不只是早期客户,还是特斯拉的早期投资人。
默里顺着这个名单反问:1500台车,卖给很有钱的人,这算哪门子的能源解决方案?
通用没要的技术,奔驰和丰田要了
马斯克的回答藏在别人的一句话里。通用汽车的鲍勃·卢茨公开说,Volt 的灵感来自特斯拉。
这句话的分量要放在汽车工业的上下文里读。2008年的通用是全球最大的车企之一,Volt 是它押上品牌声誉的增程式电动车项目,后来被写进无数份行业报告。一个百年工业巨头承认自己的旗舰项目被一家产能不到两千台的小公司点醒,这在行业里不是常规操作。
默里接着问:他们有没有跟你学技术?你们共享技术吗?
马斯克的回答分两半。共享是真的共享。通用的那一份没成,原因是通用想走自己的路,特斯拉并没有拒绝过。另一边,戴姆勒拿到了特斯拉的动力总成,用在奔驰和 Smart 上,丰田也拿到了。
具体落地的东西,他报了三样:欧洲路上的电动奔驰 A 级,美国和欧洲的电动 Smart,还有第二年的电动丰田 RAV4。
这段信息在整场访谈里只占了不到两分钟,含金量却最高。一家 2008 年还在为现金流发愁的公司,把动力总成卖给了奔驰和丰田。这不是公关话术,是可以在车展上验证的车型。
这件事还解释了马斯克后来常讲的一个观点:技术领先不是靠藏着,是靠迭代速度。愿意把核心部件卖给全球最挑剔的两家车厂,前提是你确信下一代产品出来的时候,它们还在追你的上一代。真正怕被抄的人,才会把技术锁在保险柜里。
5万美元的 Model S,目标是路上最快的轿车
Roadster 的定位从一开始就不是走量。5万美元的 Model S 才是。
默里问下一台车,马斯克报了几个参数:价格大约是 Roadster 的一半,5万美元;全尺寸轿车,车身尺寸接近宝马5系;明年年中投产;年产能2万台。
还有一句被默里追问出来的话。默里问,加速会跟 Roadster 一样快吗?马斯克说会有一个版本可以比。他的目标是让 Model S 的性能版成为"路上最快的轿车"。
默里笑了,说大部分人听到电动车想到的是高尔夫球车。马斯克的接话是"一台相当猛的高尔夫球车",还说开着这玩意儿上球场,得给每个洞之间留足时间。
玩笑归玩笑,这句自嘲背后有一套清晰的策略。2006年马斯克写过一篇公开博客,把特斯拉的路线写得很直白:先造一台贵的小众跑车,用它的溢价和话题度去造一台便宜一半的豪华轿车,再用那台车的规模去造真正的大众车型。Roadster 是第一步,Model S 是第二步。
这套打法的核心不在车,在认知顺序。汽车工业过去几十年做过很多电动车项目,几乎都从低端切入,续航短、加速慢、造型像实验品,结果每做一次都在给"电动车不行"这句话添证据。特斯拉反过来做,先用一台跑车把最强的印象打出去,再往下走。
后来发生的事,访谈里当然没有。Model S 没有在"明年年中"交付,实际交付要等到2012年。这条时间线推迟了四年,中间特斯拉差点没撑过去。访谈只记录了他当时的计划,计划本身后来打了对折。读这段的时候把这个落差记住,会更容易理解他后来为什么反复强调造车难。
烧煤发的电,每英里碳排放仍然更低
默里的下一个问题,到今天还在被讨论:电动车的环保程度,取决于电从哪来。如果电来自燃煤电厂,它还是好事吗?
马斯克的回答有两层。
第一层是效率账。发电厂是固定式的,规模大,可以在最佳工况下持续运转,热效率远高于装在车里的小型汽油机。同样烧掉一吨煤或一桶油,用来发电再驱动车轮,跑出的里程比直接灌进油箱多。所以即使电来自煤电,电动车的每英里碳排放仍然低于燃油车。
这个结论在2008年说出来,很多人不信。默里也没有追问细节,这层账就这么过去了。
它是整场访谈里最反直觉的一段,值得展开。大型燃气轮机联合循环的效率可以做到60%左右,车用汽油机的有效热效率普遍在20%到25%,城市工况下还要更低。两者之间的差额,就是电动车在"脏电"条件下仍然占优的空间。电网越清洁,这个优势越大;电网全是煤电,优势也不会归零。
反过来说,这条账也划出了电动车的天花板。它没法靠一台车单独解决碳排放,只能随着电网一起变干净。这就是第二层。
马斯克说,等式两边都得解。发电侧要转向可持续,交通侧也要转向可持续。电动车的价值在于它把这两件事解耦了:车不挑电源,水电、地热、风、太阳能、核能都能充进去。燃油车锁死在石油上,电网可以慢慢换血。
这个逻辑在2008年不算新鲜,只是很少有人像他这样把两边分开讲。多数公共讨论把"车"和"电"混成一团,最后变成互相指责:你说电厂脏,我说油箱脏。分开之后,问题才变成两个可以分别推进的工程问题。
那笔钱出自布什签署的法案
访谈真正的主角是那笔贷款。
默里的表述是:政府从刺激资金里拿出近5亿美元,在关键时刻给特斯拉做了贷款担保。批评者的说法是,纳税人的钱不该给乔治·克鲁尼和拉里·佩奇买玩具。
马斯克的第一句话是,如果那是真的,这个批评是站得住的。
第二句话开始拆事实。这笔钱不是刺激资金。特斯拉申请的那个贷款项目,由乔治·布什签署成法,在刺激计划之前就已经存在。项目名字叫先进技术车辆制造计划(Advanced Technology Vehicle Manufacturing Program,简称 ATVM)。
默里追问:终究还是纳税人的钱。马斯克认了,但把区别摆出来。
ATVM 有一条硬性门槛:申请者必须证明,即使没有这笔贷款,公司也能活下去。这条要求决定了谁能进门。通用和克莱斯勒一分钱没拿到,原因不是它们规模不够,是它们当时正在破产,没法把这句话说出口。
默里抓住了一个逻辑缝隙:特斯拉当时也不盈利。马斯克的回答是,不盈利不等于不可行,Roadster 能证明可行性。默里接着问,没有这笔贷款,你们能活吗?马斯克说能。
这笔贷款的作用是加速特斯拉的进度,它没有用来给特斯拉续命。(马斯克)
然后是时机的部分。马斯克承认这个误会可以理解。贷款消息公布的时间,正好撞上救助方案和刺激计划占据头条的那几周,日产和福特同时拿到了比特斯拉大得多的贷款。普通人看到"政府在危机期间给车企发钱",自然会把几件事并成一件事。
他还补了几个金融细节:利息照付,是优惠利率,不是白给;如果不提前还清,政府会拿到特斯拉的认股权证;这笔钱在结构上是优先债。
这段对话值得单独看一眼方法。默里抛出的是当时最尖锐的批评,马斯克没有先辩解动机,也没有说媒体断章取义。他先承认对方的前提:如果这是真的,批评成立。然后只拆一个事实:钱的出处错了。前提一倒,后面所有的推论跟着倒。
这个顺序很关键。多数人被冤枉时的第一反应是解释自己有多努力,结果把讨论拖进了情绪。先把对方最有力的版本复述一遍,承认它的逻辑有效性,再动事实,效率高得多。
一笔指定给 Model S 的钱
"给富人玩的玩具"这半句,马斯克的回应更具体。
这笔贷款指定用于 Model S 项目,也就是那台5万美元、年产能2万台的轿车。买主不会是克鲁尼和佩奇那个圈层的人。
访谈里还有一段关于《华尔街日报》社论版的插曲。默里提到自家报纸的社论版批评过特斯拉,马斯克的回应是不回避、也不撕破脸:他和社论版的霍尔曼·詹金斯交换过几封邮件,他认为对方如果了解了完整情况,批评不会那么严厉。默里笑着说这块他不打算深挖,那是报社的另一半。
默里又追了一句:既然你们不需要这笔钱,会不会后悔拿了?
马斯克的回答没有绕。特斯拉的目标是尽快把电动车推到大众市场,5亿美元能帮上忙,为此挨骂可以接受,事实上也确实挨了很多骂。
这段回答里有个不太显眼的信息:他公开承认了公司愿意为速度付出声誉代价。创业公司通常会把政府资金说成"产业政策的胜利",把批评说成"不懂创新"。他直接把账算清楚:钱有用,骂名我接了,两件事同时成立,不冲突。
他把所有同行都算成了盟友
最后一段谈格局。
默里问,电动车进入大众市场,是靠特斯拉这样的创业公司,还是靠日产、通用、福特这些巨头扛旗?
马斯克把所有人都划进了同一个阵营:整个行业往电动化走,这件事才会发生。日产做 Leaf,通用做 Volt,戴姆勒做电动奔驰,他都觉得是好事。
默里问,你把他们当竞争对手吗?马斯克说,勉强算,但很间接。市场太大了,买 Volt 或者 Leaf 的人,本来也不一定会买特斯拉。
这句话在2008年听起来像理想主义。放到今天看,它更接近一份进度表。Leaf 卖了十几年,成了历史上最畅销的电动车之一;Volt 在2019年停产;特斯拉自己成了全球市值最高的车企之一;欧洲和中国都拿出了禁售燃油车的时间表。当年被他划进同一阵营的每一家,确实都动过。
这段对话里还有一层容易被忽略的东西。默里用了"competition"这个词,马斯克没有正面接,他说的是"从技术上算是,但不算重要"。这不是外交辞令,是他在给自己定义一个更大的对手:燃油车。
一家公司的对手定义在哪里,决定了它会做什么。把同行当对手,动作是在配置表上压过对方;把整个品类当对手,动作是先把品类的短板补上。特斯拉前几年几乎所有的资源都砸在续航、加速和充电网络上,很少在座椅缝线和内饰用料上跟人比。原因就在这里。
访谈没有说出来的部分,是这家公司当时离死有多近。2008年圣诞前夕,特斯拉的现金流只剩几天,马斯克个人借钱给公司续命,同一时期 SpaceX 的第四次发射刚刚成功。那笔被骂了几个月的政府贷款,特斯拉在2013年5月提前九年还清,连本带息。
十七年后回看这场对话
默里提出的每一个质疑,都成立。11万美元的跑车确实不解决能源问题,1500台车确实改变不了碳排放曲线,创业公司确实可能死在量产前夜。
马斯克真正回答的,是这些质疑背后的问题:一台贵车凭什么能撬动一个行业。
答案在访谈里散成了三块。第一块是认知,用一台让人闭嘴的产品,把"电动车等于高尔夫球车"这个印象从公众脑子里删掉。第二块是技术外溢,把动力总成卖给奔驰和丰田,让整个供应链跟着动起来。第三块是政策工具,用一笔有硬性门槛的贷款,把量产提前几年,而不是把公司从死亡线上拉回来。
三块拼起来,才是他说的那件事:特斯拉的总体目标是让整个行业转向电动化。
这句话在今天看来像已经兑现了。但要看清它当时的分量,得把时间拨回2008年,想象一个所有人都在讨论车企什么时候破产的下午,一个人坐在镜头前说,整个行业都会转向电动化。
视频信息:
- 英文标题:Elon Musk Interview 2008
- 中文标题:2008年马斯克访谈
- 频道:Elon Musk Editor
- 时间:2008年
- 看到"某家公司拿了政府多少钱"这类新闻,先查清资金出自哪个项目、哪一年立法、申请门槛是什么。项目名称比金额更能说明性质,ATVM 的"独立存活能力"条款,比5亿美元这个数字信息量更大。
- 判断一笔融资是加速器还是呼吸机,看它在拿钱之前有没有可验证的产品和订单。Roadster 那1700台车就是特斯拉的可行性证明,没有它,后面的话一句都说不出。
- 评估一家技术公司,不要只看发布会,看它愿意把核心部件卖给谁。敢卖给奔驰和丰田,说明它对自己的迭代速度有把握。
- 讨论电动车环不环保,把问题拆成两段再谈:每英里能耗,和电网的电源结构。混在一起谈,只会得到情绪。
- 读创始人访谈时留意他怎么定义竞争对手。把整个行业算成盟友的人,通常在打一场更大的仗,这类人的时间表往往比同行长五到十年。
- 对"明年量产"这类时间表自动打折。Model S 说的是明年年中,实际交付在2012年,四年偏差在硬件行业属于常态。
- 遇到尖锐批评时,学一下这场访谈的处理顺序:先把对方最有力的版本完整复述一遍,承认它的逻辑有效,再动那个错掉的事实。前提一倒,后面全部跟着倒。
0:00[Music] Welcome to the big interview. I'm Alan Murray with the Wall Street Journal and I'm here with Elon Musk who is the CEO of Tesla, the electric car company, also of SpaceX, which is going to colonize space at some point.
0:20Well, well, we certainly look forward to taking people to space. Absolutely.
0:24and also the inspiration for Robert Downey Jr.'s, There's a Tony Stark character in the Iron Man movie.
0:31yes, in certain respects.
0:33So, so we have a lot to talk about, but let's start with with Tesla. you now have the Tesla Roadster on the road. I don't know how many of them are there out there.
0:44I think we're around 16 or 1700.
0:46It's an all-electric car. I had the opportunity to ride in it. Amazing acceleration. It seems to go from 0 to 60 in about 3 seconds, right?
0:54But it's not cheap. It'sund $110,000. That's not the answer to our energy problems.
1:01No, no, it isn't. what what the road says greatest value is really is in breaking the the misconceptions around electric cars, showing that you can have a fast, cool, beautiful electric car, that goes long distances. and so, the next
1:16How far does the the Roadster go without a charge? Almost 250 miles.
1:20Wow. So, that's longer than any other electric car on the road.
1:23So, it's longer than any any electric car in history. in fact, the Roadster set u many world records in in terms of its range. In fact, we've had one customer take it over 300 miles on a trip.
1:33Who was that customer by the way?
1:34there were actually two customers. One one was u a rally in Australia. it's actually technically 500 kilometers. It's the first time that an electric car has finished that rally without recharging. and then another one was in in Europe.
1:48You have a lot of famous customers. George Clooney. Larry Paige, yes, has one who you probably know most of the 50 customers.
1:57Well, I know I know certainly know several of them. but Larry Paige and Sergey Brup both early customers and in fact investors in in Tesla.
2:07Yeah. So but so how how you were talking about how this is going to get us to the energy solutions? I mean how 1500 people very expensive cars is a small step.
2:20Yeah. So the the the biggest impact of the roads is really is in changing the perception of what an electric car can be and showing that you can do amazing things with electric car that in fact u are better than than than gasoline cars in in a lot of respects. The Roadster has better acceleration than almost any gasoline sports car. so the and the result of the Roadsters was in fact the the the vault. Bob Lutz at General Motors credits Tesla with the inspiration for the vault.
2:47Really? Did he work with you to learn your technology to do you share your technology?
2:52we we do share our technology. ironically not not with with General Motors. Not that we we weren't willing to do so but General Motors wanted to go their own way. U but we do provide our powertrain technology to Daimler for Mercedes and Smart and and to Toyota. and so that we have the Merced electric Mercedes Aclass now on the roads in Europe. We have the electric smart now in the US and Europe. And next year there'll be the electric Toyota RAV 4.
3:16So, your technology is spreading to to other car makers. Now, you're going to have a somewhat more affordable car out next year,
3:24correct? Next year, we will have the Model S, which is about half the price of Roadster, about $50,000. and that's a a full size sedan, about the size of a 5 series BMW. and but actually far more capable than than than other premium sedans.
3:39Will it accelerate as quickly as the Roadster does? I think we will have a version that accelerates comparable to the Roadster. Yes. Really?
3:49Yes. Which will be s our goal with the Model S is to have a a a performance version of the Model S that is the fastest sedan on the road.
3:57Yeah. Are people surprised by that? I think most people think of they think of electric cars, they think of golf carts, you know, sort of one hell of a golf cart. Yeah. Yeah. I mean,
4:08you really want you go you go on the golf course with this puppy. I mean, you really got to get some good time between the holes.
4:14And do you find people are are surprised that an electric car can do that?
4:18they are. They are. And and and that's exactly what we're trying to affect, which is to to show people, hey, you can have a how you can have a better experience with electric car than you can with a gasoline car.
4:27Yeah. So, how much does the environmental impact of of your cars depend on where the electricity is coming from? In other words, if you're if you're if you're drawing the electricity off of a coal fired plant, is it still a good thing for the environment?
4:41You know, it actually is e even if you draw electricity from from coal or natural gas or even directly from oil, because stationary power plants are so much more efficient than than small gasoline engines and cars. the an electric car actually ends up being getting more u range for a given amount of say coal or oil that's burnt than than a than than than a gasoline car gets. So in other words, the CO2 per mile is is actually less for an electric car even if it's coming from a high CO2 source like like coal. Now, of course, long-term we have to find sustainable power generation and sustainable transportation, but both sides of the equation need to be solved. and and
5:25even if electric cars weren't there, we still need to get sustainable power generation. but but but the great thing about electric cars is you can generate the electricity from a wide range of renewable sources like hydro hydro you geothermal, wind, solar and nuclear where it's safe to do so.
5:44you've gotten criticism and probably more importantly the government has gotten criticism for having made a substantial guaranteed loan to Tesla at a critical moment out of stimulus funds. It was like a a half a billion dollars. And what the critics say is why in the world should taxpayer dollars be used to fund a a $110,000 play thing for George Clooney and Larry Page?
6:10Yes. Now, if that were true, it would be a valid criticism. Okay, go ahead.
6:16So, first of all, I should say that the the loan that Tesla received did not come from stimulus funds at all. In fact, the loan program under which Tesla competed for for loans was actually created and signed into law by George Bush.
6:31So, it existed prior to stimulus. It did.
6:33but it's still taxpayer dollars. It
6:36it is taxpayer dollars. but it's it's it's very very different from the stimulus funds or the bailouts or anything. In fact, one of the requirements under the under this loan program which is called the advanced technology vehicle manufacturing program was that you had to demonstrate viability as a company independent of the loan. This is why General Motors and Chrysler didn't receive any funding under this program because it's difficult to make that argument while you're going.
7:00But you say v well so they they were in bankruptcy. They couldn't make that argument. You weren't profitable at the time you got the loan. no. But we we could demonstrate viability with the with the Roadster.
7:10Would you have had viability without the loan? Yes.
7:13You So you didn't need the loan?
7:15We did not need the loan. The loan the loan was the value of the loan is really to accelerate the progress of Tesla, not to keep Tesla alive.
7:25although unfortunately the time the timing was was was unfortunate. So, it's it's it's fair that that people would would have would have a sort of a misunderstanding about this because the the announcement of of the the loan that Tesla got, which and and also Nissan and Ford got got loans that were much larger than what Tesla got at the same time, but but but these loans were announced right around the time that that there were bailouts taking place and there was a stimulus and so people naturally confused the two, which is unfortunate, but they're really quite different. And and the other issue the other issue was that the loan was going to a very
8:02expensive play thing for the rich.
8:03Correct. And and that that is also an incorrect perception. the the loan that we received was specifically for the Model S program which is you know much higher volume, lower cost.
8:15What's the cost of a what will the cost of a Model S be? About $50,000.
8:19And how many Model S's will you be when when does it launch?
8:23we're expecting to go into production middle of next year.
8:25Middle of next year. 20,000 units a year is the
8:2820,000 a year. Okay. and a few other things that noteworthy about the the ATVM loan. of course we pay interest. It's it's a it's a reduced interest, but we still pay interest. and if we don't pay the loan loan off early, then there are actually stock warrants that the the government gets in Tesla. So
8:49So So it's it's it's not a it's a pretty good deal and a senior debt.
8:53Yeah. Given the criticism you've gotten from our editorial page, among other places, do you do you do you wish you hadn't had taken the money? If you didn't need the money, do you wish you had done it without the government loan?
9:05you know, we're really hellbent on on accelerating the advent of electric cars and and getting electric cars to the mass market as soon as possible. So,
9:16half a billion dollars helps. Well,
9:17it definitely helps and we'll take a lot of heat if if it if it's in support of the greater cause. and we did take a lot of heat. and but I I think in terms of the editorial page, the the criticism that we received, I think was was was simply we didn't have an opportunity to to correct some of the misperceptions. if say if Holman Jenkins or or others had had actually understood the the correct situation, I I don't think they would have had they would have been nearly as critical.
9:44Did you talk to Holman Jenkins?
9:46We we exchanged some emails. Okay.
9:48Okay. well, I'm not going to go there. This is the new side of the of the organization. But but let me ask you, you you you say your goal is to get electric vehicles to the mass market. Are we going to get electric vehicles to the mass market through a a startup entrepreneurial operation like Tesla or are we going to get it there through Nissan, General Motors, Ford, etc. taking up the banner? I
10:14I think it's really going to come there through the whole industry moving towards electrification. so, I'm supportive of any move by by any company to create electric vehicles. So, I think it's great what what Nissan is doing with the Leaf, what GM is doing with the with the Volt, what Daimler is doing with the the electric Mercedes. And
10:32do you consider them competition?
10:34Well, I guess they're competition in in in a sense, but pretty indirectly. It's such a huge market that that I I I we don't see people necessarily choosing to buy a vault or a Leaf rather than than a Tesla that so we I guess technically competition but but not but not in a significant way. but the
10:56overarching goal of Tesla is is to get the the the industry to move towards electrification.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版