访谈·中文精读

马斯克 SEC“资金已到位”证词视频 第2部分

Elon Musk SEC "Funding Secured" Deposition Video Part 2

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

美国股市历史上针对单一公司规模最大的做空,不在雷曼,不在安然,在特斯拉。

这个判断出自马斯克本人,说在一场宣誓作证的质询里。对面坐着 SEC 的律师,问的是 2018 年 8 月那条推文:考虑以每股 420 美元将特斯拉私有化,资金已到位。第 2 部分的证词里,马斯克把话题拉回到他真正想说的东西上:做空者、负面的媒体机器,以及那场没做成的私有化。

他先报了一个数字。

官方登记的空头仓位是 110 亿到 120 亿美元

马斯克说,正式登记的针对特斯拉的做空头寸大约在 110 亿到 120 亿美元之间。这个数字不含合成空头,也不含他怀疑存在的违规做空。把这些算进去,他认为真实规模可能接近 150 亿美元。

按绝对金额算,针对特斯拉的做空仓位,是美国股市历史上针对任何一家公司最大的持续空头仓位。(马斯克)

他把时间线拉得很长。特斯拉上市那天起,甚至在做空在法律上还不太可行的时候,就有人想办法做空了。头一两年问题不大,真正变得极端是在 2013 年第一季度。

极端到什么程度?他说当时的"回补天数"大约是 30 天。这个指标的意思是,空头想把仓位平掉,按当时的正常成交量,需要连续买 30 天才能买回来。仓位到了这个量级,任何一点向上的价格波动都会变成踩踏。

马斯克说他在媒体上公开提醒过几次:这个做空规模不明智,为了你们自己好,别做空特斯拉。

没人听。

过去两年做空金额大幅增加,他发现一件配套的现象:负面宣传的强度和空头仓位的增长,大致同步。这个观察他在证词里说了不止一遍,措辞用的是"客观上讲"。

质询的人问他,你觉得这些做空者对你公平吗。他答得干脆:不公平,因为他们的判断是错的;而且他们经常向媒体投放信息,或者直接在推特和其他社交平台上发布他认为不实的内容。

他一条条数:这些人经常上电视说特斯拉是诈骗公司,说马斯克是骗子、是撒谎的人;说特斯拉的股价应该归零;说特斯拉多次财务造假,而那些指控并不成立。清单很长。

证词里他甚至有点自嘲地说了一句,也许我该多跟他们聊聊。

空头赌的是这家公司根本不该存在

理解这场对峙,需要先理解空头的论点。

马斯克把它总结得很清楚:他们不相信特斯拉能做成正在做的事。一家新的汽车公司,面对资源远比自己雄厚、数量远比自己多的对手,在他们看来没有任何活下来的可能。他们也不相信特斯拉的执行力能兑现。

这套观点他们持有很多年,也被证伪很多年。他觉得奇怪的地方在这里:被证明错了这么多次,判断一点不改。

他自己给过一个解释。2013 年初,做空者普遍认为特斯拉要破产。原因不复杂:那个季度只剩两周,交付量只完成了一半。收入大幅低于预期、巨额亏损,几乎是写在脸上的结局。

然后他做了一件在汽车行业听起来很荒唐的事。

2013 年第一季度,全公司改行去交车

车已经造出来了,客户也已经下了单。缺的只有一件事:把车从公司手里交到客户手里。

马斯克把整个公司重组了一遍,所有人的工作变成交车。设计工作室的人去交车,人力资源去交车,法务去交车,总法律顾问去交车。他自己也去。

整整两周,公司上下只干这一件事。

结果是那个季度的交付量翻了一倍,公司实现了小幅盈利。

这件事在证词里被反复提起,因为它同时解释了两件事:空头那套"新公司不可能赢"的模型为什么会失效,以及马斯克为什么认定这些人的判断跟数据无关。他们预期的是收入暴跌和巨额亏损,等来的是盈利。没人料到一家公司可以这样临时变形。

到作证的时候,做空特斯拉这门生意已经持续了八年。

马斯克说,他预计这个季度、大概下个季度,特斯拉会实现盈利和正向现金流。这在逻辑上应该对空头论点造成相当大的破坏,因为空头论点的核心是"特斯拉永远不可能盈利,必须不断融大笔钱,不融就必死"。

但他不认为这些人会消失。

他们每年都会回来说,这一次他们是对的。(马斯克)
我其实不太确定该怎么办。(马斯克)

这句话在整段证词里显得很突兀。一个被认为极度自信的人,在一场可能决定自己是否被禁任的质询里,说不知道该怎么办。他接下来的解释是,这些人造成的品牌伤害是实打实的。

一辆特斯拉撞上消防车,没人受伤,这成了头条

马斯克把伤害机制拆成两步:先造谣,再放大。他说第二步的杀伤力更大。哪怕信息本身是真的,只要方向是负面的,这些人就极其擅长把它放大到失真。

他举了个例子。美国每年有 4 万人在车祸中死亡。一辆特斯拉发生事故,哪怕没有人受伤,也能上头条。

他把这套流程说得很具体:事故一发生,这些人会联系公关公司,把材料发给每一家媒体,用最煽动的措辞。他强调这些说法来自媒体同行的亲口转述。之后社交媒体上再推一轮。

火灾的例子更典型。特斯拉起火的概率比汽油车低大约 10 倍。而在特斯拉的历史上,因为起火造成的伤害是零,一次都没有。

但从新闻里读到的印象完全相反。

安全数据也一样被埋掉了。美国国家公路交通安全管理局(NHTSA)的测试里,Model S 是历史上所有被测车型中乘员受伤概率最低的车,Model X 排第二。Model 3 很快会以半个百分点的优势升到第一。半个百分点是个很小的数字,但排名是真的。

他讲了一起具体事故。有人开着特斯拉撞上消防车,那是几乎不可移动的物体,撞击速度大约 70 英里每小时。车主自己走下车,只有脚踝扭伤。

马斯克的结论是,换成任何别的车,这个人活不下来。

而公众读到的版本是:特斯拉又出事故了。

觉得我痴迷空头的人,就是空头自己

质询过程中有人提到,外界有一种印象,说马斯克对做空者过度执念。

那些认为我痴迷于做空者的人,就是做空者本人。(马斯克)

关于具体的人,证词里提到一个在 Seeking Alpha 上长期写作的作者。马斯克的描述是:写了一大批精心打磨的、带有恶意的文章,定期出现在他的 Google 快讯里,社交媒体上也非常活跃。

质询者问他,你觉得这个人是邪恶的吗。

如果你让我下注,我押一千比一。(马斯克)

后面这段更值得看,因为它展示了马斯克处理这类事情的方式。

他给这个人所在机构的相关人士发了短信,问了三件事:你认识这个人吗,你同意他说的话吗,这到底是怎么回事。

对方查过之后回复:不认识,不同意,而且相当愤怒。这个人过去几年买过好几辆特斯拉,公开说过特斯拉的好话,跟那些言论完全对不上。对方要求这个人停止。

马斯克的逻辑是:一个人如果顶着某个机构的身份,说出一堆跟该机构立场完全相反的话,外界就会把那些话当成该机构的立场。这不合适。

还有一件类似的事。有人在推特上说,某位人士在博客上写各种关于特斯拉的疯狂负面言论。马斯克直接发邮件问那家公司的负责人:这个人是你的员工吗,你的员工在博客上写这些东西吗。对方查完之后说,不是。

质询的律师对这些举动显然不以为然,评价是理由相当牵强。

马斯克没有退,他说这类肮脏手段是存在的,而且不好。

什么叫空头挤压,他给了三个触发条件

证词里有一段技术性解释,讲的是 short burn,意思是空头被烧到。

定义很简单:股价突然上涨,做空者被迫平仓止损,于是亏掉很多钱。平仓本身又会推高股价,形成循环。

马斯克列了他认为会触发这件事的三个节点:特斯拉实现正向现金流;特斯拉达成每周 5000 辆 Model 3 的产能;在这之后不久实现盈利和正现金流。

质询者追问他,这些事发生了对你有帮助吗。他说会。

然后他补了一个观察,用词很讲究。他说做空者是 tenacious,这个词可以译成顽强,也可以译成死缠。他原本想说 tenuous,意思是站不住脚,当场改了口。哪怕特斯拉真的做到了每周 5000 辆,这些人仍然认为原来的论点成立。

质询者问他,现在回头看,是不是有更聪明的做法。他承认,是有。

私有化和杠杆收购的区别,是这段证词的核心

话题转到那笔没做成的交易上。

马斯克先纠正了一个概念。正常的上市公司私有化,绝大多数是杠杆收购:买方借一大笔钱,买下公司很大比例的股权,把原有股东挤出去。

他说这次不是。

他描述的方案是:给那些不愿意继续持有非上市股票的股东提供一个退出通道。买方只买这些人的份额,不买下整个公司。他明确说过,他原本希望所有股东都留下来,只是公司不再公开交易。

这个区分在法律上有分量。如果买方不打算买下全部股权,那么"资金已到位"这句话对应的资金规模、来源和确定性,就跟一次标准的杠杆收购完全不同。

他承认,那篇博客是从"买方"的立场写的,用词上带着引号。

质询者显然不打算放过这个点,反复追问他在不同场合到底以什么身份说话。

两顶帽子:CEO 和买家

马斯克的回答很直白:在这些场景里,一个人会戴好几顶帽子。有些时刻他是特斯拉的 CEO,有些时刻他是拟议中的买方。他没法变成两个人。

他试着把界限划出来:CEO 那顶帽子,回答的是公司运营层面的问题;买家那顶帽子,回答的是私有化这件事本身的问题。

董事会会议那次,他记得自己回答了两类问题。一类关于公司当前状态和进展,一类关于私有化这个想法。他这么说的时候,质询者反复确认细节,他有几次直接说"我不太确定怎么回答这个问题",也说过"我尽量说得精确一点"。

这种场面在证词里很常见。被问的人努力把话说准,问的人努力让他说漏。中间夹着大量"是的""我想是这样""我不确定"。

那篇博客是他自己写的

质询者问得很细:这篇关于私有化的博客,有没有别人参与,有没有律师参与,有没有人代笔。

马斯克的回答带着明显的不耐烦。

我一般自己写博客。这些年我写过很多,不需要别人替我写东西。(马斯克)

他的解释是:别人会提建议、做修正、补充内容,但那篇东西根本上是他的话。看到"考虑将特斯拉私有化"这种句子,那就是他写的,别人没把词塞进他嘴里。

他提到了参与审阅的人。特斯拉的总法律顾问 Todd Maron,一位叫 Steve 的人,还有一位负责英文编辑的同事 Leslie Rosenblum。这篇东西大概也过了公司律师的手。

质询者继续追问有没有专门的文件起草服务,有没有邮件往来,有没有人帮他整理措辞。他的回答是:不记得有这样的对话,可能有邮件往来,但不记得有起草服务这回事。

律师代表公司,不代表他个人

证词的后半段有一段关于律师角色的交锋,问得很技术。

质询者想知道,Todd Maron 在那段时间里到底代表谁。代表特斯拉,代表马斯克个人,还是代表作为买方的马斯克。

马斯克先说自己不确定这算不算特权问题,然后给出了他记得的事实:Maron 在整个过程里极其严格地代表公司,不代表他个人,也不代表作为买方的他。他补了一句评价,说 Maron 极其有职业道德。

这段话其实是在替自己的总法律顾问挡枪。

他还顺带发了一通牢骚。特斯拉常年处在诉讼里,被各种无聊的理由起诉。他举的例子是那个"每周 5000 辆"的荒唐案子,法官刚刚判了对方败诉。

质询者提醒他,这里在讨论的是语义问题。他说那我交给我的律师去回答。

这场质询真正在争什么

把整段证词读完,会发现 SEC 想确认的东西很具体:那条推文发出的时候,马斯克以什么身份说话;那句话里的"资金"指什么;"到位"到了哪一步。

马斯克的防线也很清楚:他谈的是一次不同寻常的私有化,买方只需要为想退出的人提供流动性,不需要买下整个公司;他在不同场合戴不同的帽子;博客是他自己写的,每个字都是他的判断。

中间穿插的大段做空者叙事,看起来像跑题,实际上在给他的动机做铺垫。一个被历史上最大的空头仓位压了八年的人,一条关于私有化的推文意味着什么,跟一个局外人发同样的推文,含义不一样。

他在证词里说过一句很轻的话:也许我该多跟他们聊聊。

这句话放在一场可能让他失去上市公司高管资格的质询里,分量不轻。它承认了一件事:有些对手,你赢了很多年,也还是没能说服。

给读者的几条可操作建议

这段证词对做技术、做公司、做投资的人都有可以直接拿走的东西。

  • 看空头数据先看两个指标:绝对金额和回补天数。回补天数到了 30 天这个量级,价格波动的性质就变了,跟基本面的关系变小,跟仓位结构的关系变大。判断一家公司的股价风险,这两个数字比市盈率有用。
  • 把"负面新闻多"和"公司有问题"分开。马斯克用的方法很实用:找一个可验证的客观指标,比如 NHTSA 的受伤概率排名、每万辆车的起火次数。舆论强度是二阶信息,监管机构的数据是一阶信息。碰到争议公司,先去查原始数据库。
  • 写公开信、发重要推文之前,把身份写清楚。你是在以 CEO 身份说公司运营,还是以交易一方说交易安排。这两种身份对应不同的信息披露义务,混着说,事后解释成本极高。哪怕在内部邮件里,也值得养成这个习惯。
  • 重要文件自己写第一稿。别人可以提建议、做修正、改英文,但核心句子必须出自你手。这样在任何被追问"这句话是谁的意思"的场合,你都能给出确定答案。
  • 公司律师代表公司,不代表你个人。这条边界在关键时刻能救命。马斯克专门在证词里替总法律顾问澄清这一点,说明它一旦模糊,会同时伤到人和公司。如果你是创始人,尽早把个人法律顾问和公司法律顾问分开。
  • 被质疑动机的时候,别急着自证清白,先把时间线摆出来。2013 年第一季度的两周交车、八年的做空历史、每周 5000 辆的产能节点,这些都是可核查的事实。事实密度高的时候,动机争论会自动降温。

最后一条最重要。马斯克在这场质询里做的事,本质上是把一场关于"他当时怎么想的"的争论,转成一场关于"发生了什么"的陈述。前者无法证明,后者可以查证。任何一个需要长期面对质疑的人,都该练熟这个转换。

YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:10No. Oh, sure. Yeah. Okay. Yes. All right, sounds good. Cool.

1:21unfairly? Yes, unfair in the sense that I think they are incorrect. And that they are frequently sending information to the press or publishing on Twitter or other social media that I feel is is false.

2:03Let's see. Well, they are frequently on television saying that Tesla is a fraudulent company that I am a fraud and a liar. I do not believe these are true. yes, they also say that our stock should be worth zero. There's a long list. Well, yes, so they've claimed that we have fraudulent accounting multiple times when that is not true.

2:50Yes, the objective numbers are very high. there's I place something on the order of 11 or 12 billion dollars of a short position officially against Tesla. This does not count synthetic shorts or possible illegal shorting which would suggest that number is higher, possibly on the order of 15 billion.

3:31Yes. Yeah, so If you From the moment that Tesla went public, even before it was really legally possible short sell the Tesla stock, they seem to have found ways to to do so. And for the first year or two, this was not too much of a problem. it became pretty extreme around the first quarter of 2013.

4:19very extreme. I to to the degree that the the days to cover I think was it on the order of 30. quote This is a essentially incredibly difficult if if almost impossible to cover your short position. And I pointed this out to them in the media a few times. Like this is really unwise to have this level of shorting. I recommend that they do not short Tesla.

4:53For their own good. This is a two-phrase. Over the past two years, I would say it has increased. Yes. Yeah. This has increased. I mean, you can see the the objective number the quote the the dollar value of the short position against Tesla has increased dramatically. and proportionate with that dollar value increase, the negative propaganda propaganda has roughly matched that increase in short position.

5:51Objectively it is. I mean the dollar value of the short position against Tesla on a sustained basis is the largest short position against any company in the history of the American stock market. [sighs]

6:17Maybe I should talk to them more. they do not believe that it is possible for Tesla to do what it is doing. they think that there is no way for a new car company to prosper when faced with competition that is far greater and has vastly more resources. They do not believe it is possible for us to execute as we have executed.

6:52And they've had this opinion for a long time. And they've been proven wrong for many years. So it does seem strange that they would not change their opinion. That was my theory. after 2013 in 2013 we had a the the the short sellers generally felt we were going to go bankrupt in that right around early 2013.

7:21and in fact we were able to achieve a small profit in the first quarter of 2013. this is contrary to all their expectations. The thing that they weren't expecting in Q1 of 2013 was that we would be actually able to rally the entire company and get about half of the quarters we we we'd only with there was two left two weeks left in the quarter and we'd only delivered half of all the vehicles we were supposed to deliver in that quarter.

7:52So they're expecting a massive revenue shortfall and a massive loss. I reorganized the company and everyone's job was delivering cars. if from the design studio, human resources, legal, the general counsel, everyone. me, too. two weeks solid of delivering cars. We we had made the cars. We had customers.

8:21We just needed to get the cars to customers. they were not expecting a reorganization of the company of that nature. and in the space of two weeks, we doubled our deliveries to customers.

8:53Fair to say historically, since they've the short sellers have been on our case for 8 years, even though I expect us to be profitable and cash flow positive this quarter, probably next, and hopefully going future, at least to some degree of positive cash flow and and minor profitability, the that that that should

9:19you know, re- really be quite destructive to the short thesis cuz the thesis is contrary to that. They say we will never make a profit and we will be have to raise massive amounts of money and and if we do not do that, we will definitely die. So that would if if we're that would break the short thesis at least in you know at least at least mostly break the short short thesis. that said, I don't think they will go away.

9:45They will just come back every year and say this time they're right.

10:01I'm not sure what to do, actually. They do cause a lot of brand damage. because independent of outright false information, they are extremely good at amplifying any real negative information. so if there's for example a car accident, even though every year in the United States 40,000 people die in car accidents,

10:32if there's an accident in a Tesla, it's front page news, even if nobody's even injured. This is crazy. and this is because when that happens, they they they they engage their PR agencies and they send they they engage their PR agencies and they send this to every media outlet in the most inflammatory way possible.

11:00I the media tells me this. This is not I'm not speculating. they amplify it on social media. and you know, if if if there's a Tesla car fire, although you're literally 10 times less like 10 times less likely to have a fire in a Tesla than in a gasoline car, they try to create the impression that Teslas have a fire risk.

11:25nobody has even burned a finger in a Tesla. Ever. Zero fire injuries, ever. But you wouldn't know that from reading the the news. You wouldn't know that our car still has the lowest probability of injury. The Model S actually technically the Model 3 is about to be the best. It's about to be slightly better. The Model 3 the Model S has lowest probability of injury of any the Model the Model S has the lowest probability of injury of any car ever tested by NHTSA.

11:59and the Model X is number two. To to me the Model 3 will soon be number one by half a percent. It's a small number. So you wouldn't know that this is the safest car one of the safest cars ever made. But because you just constantly read about Tesla accidents and there'll be some outrageous thing where you know, someone will as it happens crash into a fire truck or at 17 mph walk away with no injuries or in one case a broken ankle. A sprained ankle wasn't a broken sprained ankle.

12:38the or what's remarkable about that is they walked away from a 70 mph impact into an essentially immovable object. You could not survive in any other car. Just that's the thing. Little or no injuries. You could not survive. A little bit. Wait a bit. If I may add some color commentary there the people who think it who always think I'm obsessed about the short sellers are the short sellers.

13:20Yes. It was hard not to. It is like he wrote a series of carefully crafted pernicious articles on Seeking Alpha and on Seeking Alpha. and they would periodically show up in my Google Alerts and then he had had a very active social media presence. he is in my opinion quite an evil person.

14:04I bet he is. Do you Yes, I would say with certain I don't know, but I would I would say with certainty I'd like if you asked me to place a bet I would place that bet on a thousand to one that he is, yes.

14:27Yes. Okay. as usual he misrepresented the situation. so on on Twitter people were saying that this guy's name is and that he is for So this was like quite a surprising thing to me. I did not actually think this could be this seemed very strange because purchased several Teslas over the years and had spoken positively about Tesla.

15:11this seemed inconsistent with what we're saying. so I sent a text to saying asking to it It does Is this Is Do you Is this guy Do you know this guy? and do you agree with what he is saying? And then looked into it and he did not agree with what he was saying and he had no idea that this was going on.

15:44And he was quite outraged and asked him to stop because obviously somebody is and is espousing these views that are completely contrary to the principal, then people will think they are the views of the principal. This is not right.

16:19I sent the email to This also was like something on Twitter that was saying that there was this guy who was a who was saying all sorts of crazy negative stuff about Tesla. And so I sent a note to asking if Is this guy your employee? Is Is your employee blogging about making all these like outrageous statements about Tesla?

16:46and he looked into it and said, "No, it's his note. This seems a bit sort of you know, beyond pretty tenuous grounds. But if Things. happens when I mean, happened. You know, dirty tricks campaigns beat you know, this It's not good. Not I'm not good.

18:02Anyway, Yes. a a short burn is where Is it close to the there's a sudden rise in the stock price stock price that causes shorts to have to cover their losses and it it it cause them to lose lose lots of money.

18:53Tesla reaching cash flow positive. Tesla's reaching the goal of 5,000 Model 3s per week and then and then shortly thereafter being profitable and cash flow positive. Let's see.

19:14Yes. it's going to be helpful. Yes. reaching Tesla reaching 5,000 Model 3s per week. Tesla reaching a production rate of 5,000 Model 3s per week. Yes. Yes. The Yes. The Yes. But the shorts is very tenuous. Oh very very should say not very tenuous, very tenacious in hanging on to their thesis that Tesla is going to go bankrupt. And so amazingly despite reaching 5,000 vehicles per week, they still thought their original thesis was held water.

21:42I think in retrospect that would have been a smarter move. Yes. not in this month, but was it this month? Okay, yeah. It may have been Yes, yes, it was actually just just barely this month. Dems.

23:05as effectively a buyer, but it's I mean it is is is not in the normal sense of a take private being a a leverage buyout where where shareholders are squeezed out. So, it's it's a it's a buyer it's a buyer of those who did not wish to remain private, but not a buyer of the company as a whole.

23:41Do you mean sorry sorry sorry buyer buyer of those who did not wish to remain with the company when it says private to So, a buyer technically, but not but but a buyer only if if people really did not want to be part of the company when it was private. that

24:18Yes. I think at you know obviously one has multiple hats in in the in these situations. So, there may be moments where it was been me as Tesla CEO and most roles me as the as the as the proposed buyer. Because obviously I run the company and I'm the buyer. Well, I cannot be two people.

24:54It's very difficult to be two people explicitly. which try to do that, but it's yeah. yeah.

25:13Anyone is I guess the CEO hat would be answering questions about operationally about the company. and buyer hat would be answering questions about the take privates. I think some. Yeah, just generally about what the status of the company, where things are. I'm sorry, can you clarify the question?

25:54Yes. I'm not sure I fully understand how to answer this question. You know, there's there's generally I mean in in that board meeting I do recall answering questions about the current status and progress of the company. and I also recall answering questions about the potential idea of going going private.

27:12Essentially, yes. Sorry, I'm just it's okay, but thanks for offering.

27:59Yes. I think so. Yeah. As a wire. I don't think so. Yes. Yes. I believe so. It's a drive from here. Yeah, I mean, I'm not sure. It's quite close, yeah. Yeah. Yes. Okay. I don't think so.

31:20But, based on the blog post, I I think I Here, just to make sure that I'm So, what you're going to I've tried to be as precise as possible.

32:41Right. Yeah, so I think so this blog post was in the context of me as the buyer if you will. Although I as as mentioned I I think it's sort of an important distinction that this take private is different from the vast majority of take privates in that Sorry? Yeah, the the vast majority of take privates generally involve an attempt by the buyer to obtain a a very large percentage of the company's stock by obtaining a loan or through other means.

33:26And this was not one of those. this was simply in a desire to have This was this was and I explicitly said this. It was I to have the same shareholding base but not be publicly traded. And and so the the notion of buying in in a sense would not necessarily be the same as it would typically be in a take private.

33:52The two Yeah, I I I still wrote this from the standpoint of a buyer in quotes Sorry, I'll I'll speak louder. and I still wrote this from the standpoint of a of a buyer.

34:41Yeah, there is. My hope was that all shareholders would remain with the company even if we're not publicly traded. yes. That would be Todd Maron. There may have been others, but I don't know who they would have been. He There's a good chance he did, but I don't know what contributions he made, if any.

37:19I mean, I should be clear that Okay. I don't recall any conversations. It's possible there were some email exchanges, but I not documenting services. I don't know.

38:30Yes. Yes. Yes, it's like that's really bothered me actually. Cuz it's background. And obnoxious turn my twos and threes up rhythmically. Yes.

40:22No. I don't think I don't think so, no. counsel, yeah. I mean I generally write my own blogs. so it's not as though I think I mean what might suggest making is like I've written many blogs over the years. I don't need somebody else to write something for me. And when I see something like the taking Tesla private, I mean this is fundamentally these are my my words, you know. And somebody's not putting words in my mouth.

41:23You know, so they're getting suggestions on things corrections, additions. but this is fundamentally just a a statement of the facts. And I think it I think quite accurate ones.

42:12It would be English Leslie Rosenblum. To I think primarily Steve. I think this did did go past Todd Ricketts company council as well. I'm not sure if everyone drew a script for those. Hello.

45:48If the answer is very obvious, Tesla is in constant litigation. We are constantly sued for frivolous purposes. For example, this absurd 5,000 car per week thing. What is this? Which the judge just ruled against.

46:28Which book was it referred to? I think I think we're in sort of a semantic debate here. I would defer to my counsel to

47:55Did he have a represent me personally independent of the company? I don't believe so.

51:01Yeah, yeah. I mean, I can say like my my recollection my I It's It's I'm not with that specific to the whether this privilege or not, my recollection is that Todd Moran was extremely rigorous about representing the company and not me as an individual as buyer. if you're what you're getting at is are you concerned whether there was was was Moran representing me when he should have been representing the company, I do not think that is the case. I am He is extremely ethical and throughout this process represented the company.

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份