把政治光谱最左边算成 1 分、最右边算成 10 分,《巴比伦蜜蜂》(The Babylon Bee)该打几分?马斯克给出的答案是 6 到 6.5 分。
他的原话是,一个人完全站在左翼是 1 分,完全右翼是 10 分,那么《蜜蜂》大概落在 6 分到 6.5 分之间。紧接着他补了一句:《蜜蜂》偏右的程度,比《洋葱报》(The Onion)偏左的程度要小。
这个打分跟《纽约时报》的判定差得很远。纽时给这家网站的定性是“伪装成讽刺的极右翼虚假信息”。同一家媒体,一边被主流大报钉在极右的坐标上,一边被当时的世界首富用刻度尺量成“中等偏右一点点”。
这场对话发生在 2022 年,地点是《巴比伦蜜蜂》自己的播客。坐在马斯克对面的是主编凯尔(Kyle)、创意总监伊桑(Ethan)和 CEO 塞斯(Seth)。两个多小时里,话题从一家花 50 美元买域名起家的讽刺网站,一路滑到出生率、太阳能算术、觉醒文化、史上最高的个人税单、糖果实验、元宇宙、火箭的最大动压、AI 监管和脑机接口,最后停在一个没人预料到的地方:他们请马斯克当场接受耶稣作为个人的主和救主。
五十美元的域名,和一份备用方案
《巴比伦蜜蜂》2016 年上线,最初只是一个基督教幽默小站。域名花了 50 美元,几个人开始写笑话往外扔,两年前在保守派圈子里火了起来。CEO 塞斯后来从原创始人亚当·福特(Adam Ford)手里买下了这个网站。
现在的规模是十几个全职,加上外围参与的大概 25 人。一年前只有三个人。
马斯克对这门生意的产能结构很感兴趣,他自己补了一段观察:讽刺不需要一屋子写手轮班倒,一天也就消化得了那么多笑话。这家网站一天发 6 到 8 篇,而福克斯新闻那一类机构是三分钟一篇。所以团队里有大量兼职,比如住在奥斯汀的弗兰克·弗莱明(Frank Fleming),他有全职工作,业余给他们写稿。
他们还有一份“备用方案”,叫 Not the Bee。当世界荒诞到讽刺无法成立的时候,就转过去如实报道荒诞本身。凯尔的总结很到位:现实就是虚构。
马斯克是怎么发现他们的?推特上刷到的,觉得有些文章挺好笑。就这么简单,没有公关,没有推荐人。
加州从机会之地变成了罚单之地
话题转到搬家。蜜蜂的总部在南佛罗里达,他们一直想把人从加州挖出来,结果发现比想象中难得多。
马斯克对加州的态度很复杂。他大部分朋友还在那儿,风景漂亮,好玩的东西很多。但越来越难把事情做成。他的原话大意是,加州曾经是机会之地,现在正越来越成为过度监管、过度诉讼、过度收税之地,外加人行道上的粪便,以及一种轻蔑。
“你交了税,他们回你一句‘谢了’,然后朝你脸上踹一脚。”(马斯克)
他们聊到《蜜蜂》写过的一篇文章,标题大概是《加文·纽森(Gavin Newsom)当选年度最佳推销员》。马斯克说,那篇文章其实是真的。加州政府在尽一切努力鼓励人们离开。
《洋葱报》和 SNL 得了同一种病
马斯克以前是《洋葱报》的忠实读者,后来它变得非常政治正确,一路往 SNL 的方向滑。他的判断是,这家媒体现在基本不会拿左翼开任何玩笑,而早年它要均衡得多。
他用了那个后来被反复引用的词:woke mind virus,觉醒心智病毒。
SNL 也在名单上。他曾经是铁粉,现在觉得大部分剧集更像一场道德训话,主题是告诉你为什么你是个坏人,而不是逗你笑。至于泰德·克鲁兹(Ted Cruz),他们能揍一万七千次。而且经常的情况是,克鲁兹先嘲笑了左翼某个人,然后所有人一起扑上去,这更像一种防御性反应。
他给出的判断标准相当清晰:
“喜剧是在接近一个有趣的本质真相,还是在做宣传、把你往某个方向推?当它不再试图接近那个有趣的本质真相,它就不那么好笑了。”(马斯克)
这套标准套回《蜜蜂》身上,就出现了开头那个有趣的错位。左翼骂他们是“用笑话包装叙事的宣传机器”,《纽约时报》直接定性为极右翼虚假信息。而马斯克的观察是,同一段笑话,你怎么看它,几乎完全取决于你站在哪儿。
traceroute woke_mind_virus:一条给非程序员解释的命令
马斯克发过一条推文,内容是 traceroute woke_mind_virus。凯尔说自己不是程序员,请他解释这是什么意思。
traceroute 是一条网络命令,Windows 里叫 tracert。想看数据包到某台服务器或某个域名走的是什么路径,就用它。它会列出途经的每一跳,以及每一跳之间的延迟。
所以这条命令的意思很直白:这个病毒从哪儿来?源头在哪儿?
凯尔的反应是:我认识其中几个词。
马斯克没有给出追踪结果,只留下了一句判断:
“它是一种流行性很强的心智病毒,可以说是对文明最大的威胁之一。”(马斯克)
数一数今年的婴儿,就知道二十年后的成年人
聊到人口,马斯克的论证方式跟他做工程时一样,把复杂问题压缩成一个几乎不需要统计学的观察。
看去年出生了多少孩子,就知道二十年后有多少成年人。人只能从婴儿长成大人,没有别的路径,这条因果链没有任何弹性。出生率的趋势是在往下走,几乎在所有地方都往下走,很多国家已经长期低于更替水平。
不需要是统计学大师,只需要看这条曲线朝哪个方向。
凯尔抛出了一个带着讽刺的问题:左翼的担忧是,如果生孩子,他们会加剧气候变化,然后杀死地球。所以生更多孩子,是为了占领火星吗?
马斯克的回答只有一句:地球离人口过剩还差得远。
可持续能源的三根柱子,和一道心算题
既然聊到了气候,他把整套逻辑摊开讲了一遍。
第一根柱子是可持续的能源生产,主力是太阳能,其次是风能,还有一部分地热、水电和核能。他在这里插了一句批评:核电站正在被关掉,这件事不该发生,核电站应该继续运行。核能非常安全,除非建在重大自然灾害频发的地方。德国、法国没有那种问题。把核能从清单上划掉,是个错误。
第二根柱子是电池储能。太阳不会一直照,风不会一直吹,间歇性必须靠储能来抹平,才能有连续的电力。
第三根柱子是可持续交通,电动车、电动船、电动飞机。
唯一讽刺的地方是火箭没法电动化。不过长期看,可以用太阳能发电,从大气中抽取二氧化碳,配上水,合成甲烷和氧气。火箭按质量算大部分是氧气。所以从原理上讲,一切最终都能靠太阳能跑起来。
然后是他招牌式的量级估算:
太阳辐照度大约是每平方公里 1 吉瓦,也就是每平方米 1 千瓦。一平方公里有一百万平方米。光伏转换效率算 20%,净发电大约每平方公里 200 兆瓦。满足整个美国的用电,需要大约 100 英里见方的一块地铺满太阳能板。犹他州或者德州的一个小角落就够了。
他顺手又加了一刀。大多数核电站周围有一大片无人区,因为没人愿意住在核电站旁边。那片空地如果铺满太阳能板,发电量会超过核电站本身。
觉醒文化给刻薄的人发了一件盔甲
回到那个核心问题:觉醒文化为什么有破坏性?
马斯克的出发点很朴素:社会应该朝积极的方向走,幽默应该是被允许的。觉醒文化基本上是想让喜剧变成非法,这不酷。查普尔(Dave Chappelle)被抵制,太离谱了。
他描述的是一幅没有幽默感的图景:一个充斥着谴责和仇恨的社会,没有宽恕。
“觉醒文化本质上是对立的、排他的、充满恨意的。它给了那些刻薄的人一个理由,一件盔甲,让他们可以刻薄和残忍,还披着虚假美德的外衣。”(马斯克)
蜜蜂这边的对应观察是:左翼现在几乎成了一种宗教。他们如此严肃,如此强烈地相信,以至于你拿他们开玩笑,对他们而言等同于嘲笑上帝或救赎。在他们的视角里,左翼成了新的宗教右派。
“参议员凯伦”和他那张史上最高的个人税单
伊桑提到了马斯克在推特上对沃伦参议员(Elizabeth Warren)的刻薄话。
马斯克的回应是那句著名的“请别叫经理来,参议员凯伦”(please don't call the manager on me, Senator Karen)。他强调,是沃伦先开火的。她称他为搭便车的人,一个不交税的骗子。
他的反驳很硬:那一年他交的税,是历史上任何个人交过的最高金额。而沃伦基本不交税,她的工资还是纳税人付的。付她工资的纳税人里就包括他。
他接着把自己的税务结构完整说了一遍。资产基本就是特斯拉和 SpaceX 的股票。特斯拉是上市公司,信息全部公开。SpaceX 是 C 类公司,有外部审计,有外部投资人,极其透明。没有离岸账户,没有税务庇护结构,也不从公司拿任何现金工资或奖金。他当年觉得不拿工资在道德上是更好的选择。
所以 H&R Block 完全能处理他的报税,他自己几个小时就能弄完。
2018 年他一分钱税都没交,原因是那年没有收入。他还解释了一个细节,2017 年他不小心多交了税,2018 年就把这笔净额抵掉了。
至于卖出特斯拉股票跟推特投票的关系:一部分是明年到期的期权,无论如何都必须行权;在这之上,他又卖了一部分增量股票,把总卖出比例做到大约 10%。他在推特上问要不要卖,多数人说要。
“我尽量做到字面意义上的精确,你不需要读字里行间,读字面就行。”(马斯克)
所谓财富,是持股比例乘以估值
被问到个人财务问题时,他先把一个常见的误解拆了:他的现金余额非常低。股票是质押出去做了贷款,如果特斯拉和 SpaceX 破产,他本人会立刻破产。
为什么不在公司有风险的时候套现分散?他的回答是一个船长式的比喻:船长应该跟船一起沉。如果提前把钱拿出来,公司失败了,投资人受损,自己却更富了,这不对。所以哪怕破产只剩几周,他也没卖股票。
后来公司值钱了,那是投资人的判断,不是他能决定的。他持有 20%,一万亿美元估值对应两千亿美元。他还多次公开说股价太高,投资人直接无视。他开玩笑说,我字面上说了太高,他们还是往上抬。
“我的净资产就是我在 SpaceX 和特斯拉的持股比例,乘以估值。就这么简单。”(马斯克)
他真的让人从网上给他寄糖
关于糖果公司的传闻,源头是调侃巴菲特(Warren Buffett)和喜诗糖果(See's Candies)。蜜蜂翻出了他的原话:“我超级超级认真。”
马斯克的回应是一个写作技巧:如果有人在一个词前面加两个“超级”,那他大概并不认真。这算是给讽刺作者的一条免费建议。
不过他确实动过手。他在推特上征集好吃的糖果,让陌生人寄过来。他也承认这不太安全,万一有毒呢。试下来的结论是,有些花生脆糖配着别的东西挺好吃,有些巧克力也不错,但没有一款让他惊艳。
所以这件事停了。不会为了推出一款“还不错”的糖果而开一家公司。
然后是关于公司本质的那段话,值得完整抄下来:
“如果有一个非常打动人的产品或服务,那才是重要的,公司本身不重要。公司只是一群人的集合,用来创造那个产品或服务。如果一家公司不能提供伟大的产品和服务,它就不应该存在。为了一家公司的存在而存在一家公司,毫无意义。”(马斯克)
他还补了一句:市面上有很多公司大概应该直接解散,那些人去做别的事会更好。
元宇宙:把电视绑在鼻子上
谈到元宇宙,马斯克的反应是:“Web 3,当然,你可以把电视绑在鼻子上。”
他小时候被教育别坐得离电视太近,会毁眼睛。现在电视就贴在你脸上。
VR 眼镜戴久了不舒服,需要更轻。想在里面走路会晕,只能靠传送式移动。他承认这可能只是他个人的体感,但确实不觉得有人愿意一整天待在里面。
现在推销元宇宙的方式太弱了。他描述的场景是:就是 Zoom 会议,只不过旁边那个人有个虚拟形象,也许你还能设计自己的形象。就这。
他也留了个余地,说自己不想变成 1995 年那种说“互联网只是一阵风”的老头。当年他说的恰恰相反:互联网会改造人类,在此之前,绝大多数信息是靠人和人当面传递、或者靠人物理送信送过去的。所以这种可能性他承认存在。
但到目前为止,他看不到一个令人信服的元宇宙场景。Web 3 听起来更像营销,而现实还没跟上。
长期看,Neuralink 有可能把人完全放进虚拟现实里。他顺口提了这么一句,没有展开。
为什么不去岛上喝鸡尾酒
伊桑问了一个几乎所有人都会问的问题:钱早就够了,为什么还在工作?
马斯克先否认了前提。他不生活在炫耀性消费里,工作时间极长,做这些公司跟让自己变富没什么关系。
特斯拉的价值该怎么衡量?他的答案是一个可以量化的指标:这家公司把可持续能源的转型提前了多少年。10 年还是 20 年,这才是它的根本善。
他最初对电动车产生兴趣,跟环保关系不大。高中、大学早期,他担心的是石油终会枯竭或昂贵到文明无法运转:车开不了,电厂转不动。后来才加上了气候风险的考量。但他自称不属于最激进的全球变暖阵营。他不认为当前大气和海洋里的二氧化碳浓度本身已经到了灾难级别。
他的论证绕过了争论,直接指向一个更硬的逻辑:既然煤炭和石油迟早要烧完,既然无论如何都要过渡到可持续能源,那为什么还要拿真实世界做一次高浓度二氧化碳的实验?这个实验没有额外收益。
他还提到一个很直观的角度:人类喜欢住在海边。文明天生对海平面变化极度敏感,哪怕水位变化很小,也会让大量房屋沉到水下。所以气候变化的后果未必是文明的终结,但会是剧烈的扰动。
对油气行业,他也没有敌意。他的说法是,如果现在就断掉油气,文明会崩溃,很多人会饿死。当下的油气是必需品,但应该加速走向可持续能源,放慢才是问题。
SpaceX 的价值在另一条线上:让人类成为航天文明、成为多行星物种。一个让人早上醒来会兴奋的未来。他举的例子是阿波罗计划,1969 年送人上月球,那是全人类最伟大的成就之一。
关于登月真伪,他直接说自己被问过这个问题。他的回答是,我们去了,不止一次。如果造假,苏联人会当场揭穿,他们当时正拿着望远镜看着,而且绝不会放过这种机会。
多行星的意义,他给了一个很温柔的定义:给生命本身买的保险,不只是人类,还包括地球上所有生物。因为它们造不出飞船,人类实际上是生命的管家。像诺亚方舟,只不过每种生物带的远不止两个,因为两个太近亲繁殖了。
他给了一个时间尺度。地球大约 45 亿岁,再过 5 亿年左右,太阳膨胀会让地球大概变得不宜居,10 亿年后则确定不宜居。如果地球上智能生命的演化慢了 10%,人类根本不会出现,海洋会沸腾,一切来不及发生。
但这套论证有个显而易见的反驳:宇宙最终热寂,那一切不还是徒劳?
“他们说旅程本身就是一半的乐趣。如果热寂是宇宙的结局,那旅程就是全部的乐趣。”(马斯克)
然后是费米悖论。宇宙 138 亿岁,外星人应该早就到处都是了。他没有任何证据,还说了一句很马斯克的话:如果真有人知道外星人的证据,那应该是我。
他引用卡尔·萨根:要么我们在银河系是孤独的,要么有很多外星人,两个答案同样可怕。如果是后者,那可能意味着入侵舰队正在路上。
他把人类意识比作黑暗里一点微弱闪烁的烛光,说我们不该让它熄灭。
最大动压:给一位波音火箭工程师的回答
伊桑的爸爸是波音的火箭工程师,托儿子带了一个技术问题:星舰在什么数上承受最大动压?那个压力有多大?
马斯克当场认真作答。最大动压(max Q)是一个速度与大气密度的组合点,在这个点上,火箭受到的风力达到峰值。高度越高,大气密度指数级衰减,所以峰值会出现在某个特定的速度与密度交叉处。
它主要取决于推重比。推重比低,最大动压通常低;推重比高又不节流,最大动压就高。还跟弹道有关:低地球轨道单次点火入轨是一回事,带低近地点的地球同步转移轨道是另一回事,后者更高,因为横向飞行的时间更长。
“入轨靠的是平行于地球表面的速度。大约 23 到 25 马赫,也就是每小时 17000 英里左右,才叫入轨。你只需要高度来脱离大气稠密层,免得减速。”(马斯克)
具体数字:大多数火箭在 1.4 到 1.8 马赫之间达到最大动压,量级在每平方英尺 400 到 800 磅。
星舰不一样。完全复用的火箭,推进剂成本在总成本里的占比会变得显著,而一次性或部分复用的火箭,推进剂成本相对火箭本身微不足道。所以为了压低每吨入轨成本,星舰的推重比要更高,1.3 甚至接近 1.5。如果不节流,最大动压可能达到每平方英尺 1000 甚至 1200 磅,速度在 1.4 到 1.5 马赫左右。
聊完空气动力学,伊桑作为“男性女权主义者”,问能不能造一些阴道形状的火箭,为了平等。马斯克的回答是:空气动力学和水动力学,无论生物还是机械,共享相似的性质。
真正该怕的东西不在机器人身上
谈到特斯拉机器人,马斯克把恐惧的对象换了个位置:机器人本身没什么可怕的。
可怕的是 AGI,人工通用智能,一种智能远超人类的数字超级智能。如果它比最聪明的人类聪明出一个量级,人类可能失去控制,它可能做出糟糕的事。他强调,这里讲的是概率,谈不上必然。
他主张设立一个监管机构,监管先进 AI。理由跟他支持 FAA 的理由一样:政府的正当角色之一是监管行业,确保公司不走危害公众的捷径。
FAA 干得不错。他给了一组让人印象深刻的对比:坐一架受 FAA 监管的航空公司班机,比待在自己家里还安全。
在家里,你可能被配偶谋杀,可能被烤面包机或烘干机引发的火灾烧死。在飞机上,你带不上枪,甚至带不上一把刀或者一瓶乳液;空乘受过急救训练,有除颤器,一旦有人出现医疗问题会立刻降落,救护车在机场等着;而且飞机上随时可能有医生。
监管机构的通病是不对称:出事了重罚,做对了没有奖励,所以天生偏保守。FDA 就有这个问题,一个能救很多人的东西,因为可能伤到少数人而迟迟不批。
他举了安全带的例子。安全带缺失在全球造成的死亡可能上千万,汽车行业抗争了很多年,前后花了 15 到 20 年才强制安装。儿童安全座椅也是一样,很多孩子因为直接坐在光秃秃的座椅上死掉。他自己小时候就坐在没有安全带的座位上,还坐在皮卡的车斗里跑过好几个小时。活下来了,那是幸存者偏差。
对政府,他自认是温和派,谈不上极端自由意志主义。私人军队、私人警察,他觉得不合适。但他也把话说得很直:政府是一个垄断体,是终极的垄断公司,还垄断着暴力。所以政府做任何事都会低效。
他给了个粗略的比例:经济产出里政府占三分之一或许可以接受,超过 50% 就有问题。东西德、南北朝鲜,一条人为画出的线,西德的人均 GDP 是东德的五倍。私营部门的效率大概是政府的十倍。私人公司会破产,政府不会破产,除非把民众榨干。
“你想要场上有裁判。没有裁判,比赛会更糟。你只是不希望政府既当裁判又当球员。”(马斯克)
他还提了一个很有意思的概念,法规的垃圾回收。新法规有强推力,每年都在增加;废除旧法规几乎没有推力。文明变老的过程,就是约束越来越多的过程。最后像《格列佛游记》里那样,被几千根小绳子绑住,没有一根是致命的,但所有加在一起,你什么也做不了。
猴子用意念打乒乓,人类明年植入
Neuralink 的初衷,他自己讲得很清楚:长期对冲数字超级智能的风险。
如果人类能与数字智能形成有效共生,那么集体的意志更有可能把方向拨到我们想要的地方。哪怕对面是善意的超级智能,如果它快到无法与我们有效沟通,那跟它说话就像跟一棵树说话。树在跟环境交流,只是非常慢,根在找水,枝在找阳光。
他顺手给了一个判断:人类已经是半机械人了。手机和电脑是数字延伸,忘带手机的人会有一种缺了一条肢体的感觉。
问题在带宽。用两个拇指跟手机交流,大概每秒 10 比特。而计算机之间是每秒几十亿比特。他把人分成三层:负责本能和情绪的边缘系统,负责思考和规划的大脑皮层,然后是手机电脑构成的第三层数字层。瓶颈就卡在第二层和第三层之间的接口上。
Neuralink 要把这个带宽提升几个数量级,可能一千倍以上。主要是输出方向,也做双向。输入因为视觉,本来就比输出高好几个数量级,一张图胜过千言万语,一段视频大概是十万句。
近期用途更实际,也更打动普通人。第一位人类受试者的目标,是让四肢瘫痪、甚至面部都无法活动的人操作手机或电脑,速度超过有手的人。
猴子已经证明了原理。先训练它用摇杆打乒乓,读取它大脑发出的信号,再把摇杆拿走,它靠意念继续打。而且不只乒乓,它还会好几个游戏。目前的纪录是接近每秒 10 个有效比特,是同类神经设备里最高的,虽然这个数字听着不大。
他还相信可以植入第二个装置。第一个接运动皮层和体感皮层,第二个放在损伤位置下方,两个装置互相通信,把信号跨过断点。不需要知道信号内容,就像网线不需要知道里面传的是什么,Wi-Fi 中继也不需要知道数据包的内容。
长期目标,是让完全没有身体功能的人恢复全身功能。他说自己确信这在原理上可行,但不愿给出承诺,以免造成不合理的预期。
每月 9999 美元的马斯克订阅等级
蜜蜂这边爆了个料。他们曾经在网站上做了一个“马斯克订阅等级”。
起因是马斯克跟他们互动过几次,团队想把他发展成订户,就专门为他做了一个等级,价格大概是每月 9999 美元,这是支付处理商允许的上限。
结果真有人订阅。每次他们去后台看,都在猜是不是本人,结果全是随机路人,以为那是个玩笑,结果信用卡真被扣了钱。愤怒的邮件涌进来,大意是老婆会杀了我,你们必须退款。于是这个等级在马斯克发现之前就被下架了。
马斯克听完说了一句:这算是一种恭维。
十个固定问题
播客有个传统,每期最后问嘉宾同样的十个问题。这个传统从凯尔的车库开始,他们从没想过有一天会拿这十个问题去问马斯克。
第一个:你见过基督教说唱歌手卡门(Carmen)吗?
马斯克只知道一个卡门,卡门·米兰达(Carmen Miranda),头上顶着一堆水果跳舞的那位。而且她已经去世了。
第二个:你更偏加尔文主义还是阿米尼乌斯主义?预定论还是自由意志?
马斯克说,他的理智选择决定论,他的心选择自由意志。
他顺带讲了自己的宗教背景。小时候上英国圣公会的周日学校,同时又被送去希伯来语幼儿园。他本人并非犹太教徒。他的说法是,今天唱“我们的主耶稣”,第二天唱另一套,一个小孩哪管这些。
第三个:如果可以在《圣经》里加一本书,你加哪本?
他选《银河系漫游指南》(The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy)。
他解释了一段童年经历。小时候有过一次存在主义危机,想搞清楚生命的意义,一度觉得一切都没有意义。他读了一堆宗教书籍,包括《圣经》,发现里面有很多周日学校没教过的东西。所多玛和蛾摩拉,很黑暗。上帝从旧约到新约好像完全改变了态度,旧约里那个报复心极强的形象让他吃惊。
第四个:雪茄还是烟斗?
他基本没抽过烟斗,但祖父抽。看着挺酷。雪茄抽过,庆祝的场合配威士忌是很不错的组合。
第五个:可以跟任何三个人共进晚餐,活着或已故,选谁?
他先说这个问题很难,然后开玩笑指了在场三人:伊桑、凯尔、塞斯。接着提到杰夫·贝索斯(Jeff Bezos),又收回来。最后给了一个随口的名单:莎士比亚、本·富兰克林,也许牛顿或者爱因斯坦。有人吐槽全是白人男性,他自己补了一个:克利奥帕特拉听起来挺有意思。
喝的什么?威士忌,百分之百。
第六个:如果当总统,第一件事做什么?
他先讲了美国总统一职的设计。开国元勋不想造出一个君主,所以这个位置被刻意设计得相对弱势,比议会制里兼任多数党领袖的首相要弱。没有国会支持,你连法律都改不了。
那么能做什么?他会倾向于缩减政府规模,然后清理监管。他要给法规做一次垃圾回收。
新法规有强推力,每年都在产生;废除旧法规几乎没有推力。这是文明变老的通病,约束越来越多,拆除的努力极少。时间长了,就像血管硬化,最后被几千根小绳子绑住,每一根都不致命,但加在一起就动弹不得。他搬到德州,一部分原因就是不想被那么多绳子绑着。
他还说了一件常被低估的事:总统一职对“执行力”的估值太低。总统相当于国家的 CEO,你擅长不擅长把事做成、有没有效率,这个能力被严重低估了。
聊到这儿他插了一段关于 CEO 头衔的看法。CEO 算不上法律头衔。你去看注册公司要填的表格,只需要三个角色:总裁(president)、秘书(secretary)、财务主管(treasurer),跟组建一个象棋俱乐部没什么区别,而且法律上这三个人可以是同一个人。其他诸如总法律顾问、CFO、CEO,全是编出来的,某种程度上是简历膨胀器。首席营销官、首席信息官、首席各种官,都可以有。他们顺势开玩笑说,那应该设一个首席魔法官,高级副总裁级的魔法。
第七个:你打过人吗,或者被人打过吗?有什么精彩的故事?
他说自己没有精彩的故事,但成长的地方极其暴力。除了跟弟弟打过一架,他基本没卷入过斗殴。在南非长大,那是个本身就很暴力的地方。他被人往脸上揍过很多次,有一次差点被打死。
“如果你没被拳头打在脸上过,你根本不知道那是什么感觉。那种冲击感。然后你会开始明白,那些对词语如此敏感的人有多好笑。你要是被拳头打过脸,词语就不算什么了。”(马斯克)
第八个:可以去任何一场演唱会,历史上任何乐队,你去听谁?
他选了巅峰期的滚石乐队。
第九个问题开始之前,蜜蜂的人先承认了一件事:今天是周日,而《蜜蜂》是一家基督教机构,算个事工。他们质问马斯克为什么不去教堂。马斯克反问,你们为什么不去?今天是休息日。有人说我们做线上教会了。
然后他们提了一个请求:为了把这场录制变成教会,你能不能做一个简短的决志,接受耶稣作为你个人的主和救主?
马斯克的回答值得原文保留:
“这么说吧,我认同耶稣所倡导的那些原则。耶稣的教诲里有极大的智慧,我认同那些教诲。像‘转过另一边脸’这种事非常重要,相对于‘以眼还眼’。以眼还眼会让所有人都瞎掉。所以宽恕是重要的,你希望别人怎样对待你,你就怎样对待别人。爱人如己,非常重要。”(马斯克)
然后他补了爱因斯坦那句:我相信斯宾诺莎的上帝。至于耶稣救人这件事,他说自己不会挡路,如果能被拯救,为什么不呢。
蜜蜂的人当场宣布:他答应了,我们搞定了。
关于洗礼,他说自己已经受过了,圣公会的,还是婴儿的时候被浸在水里。他还讲了一段童年困惑:领圣餐的时候,那到底是血还是身体?这是不是食人族的奇怪隐喻?给未成年人喝酒合适吗?蜜蜂那边说他们用葡萄汁,更规范。马斯克说自己五岁就想不通这些问题,在周日学校提问,老师明显被问得很不高兴。
比如五饼二鱼。他会追问:人群有多大?鱼和面包从哪儿来的?是从袍子里掏出来的吗?是凭空变出来的吗?咬一口会不会又长回一整块?
他对耶稣的关注点还有一个:耶稣显然是支持喝酒的,他第一个神迹就是把水变成酒,而且是在婚宴上酒喝光了的时候。
最后他们提到《洋葱报》。马斯克重申自己觉得它历史上做过极其好笑的东西,只是近几年被觉醒心智病毒污染了,一切都变得没那么好笑。他的总结是:觉醒心智病毒,等于一个没有幽默的世界。
他还半开玩笑说,希望 Neuralink 能解决这个问题。
这场对话里真正值得带走的几条判断
整场看下来,马斯克的观点散落在大量玩笑里,背后有一套相当一致的方法。
他习惯把宏大议题压缩成一个可以心算的量级问题。出生率用“去年生了多少孩子”来推算,太阳能用“100 英里见方够全美国”来回答,火箭入轨用“23 马赫的横向速度”来解释,脑机接口用“每秒 10 比特对每秒几十亿比特”来定位瓶颈。这种表达方式有一个副作用:它让复杂争论变得难以含糊其辞。你要么同意这个数,要么给出另一个数。
他对政府的态度,很难用“反监管”概括。他支持 FAA,支持 FDA 的食品安全职能,支持给 AI 设监管机构,理由是场上需要裁判。他反对的是裁判下场打球,以及只增不减的法规堆积。
至于那套“给生命买保险”的叙事,它跟“人类应该去火星”的口号差别很大。他承认自己大概率活不到火星自给自足的那天,也承认宇宙终将热寂。这两件事都没有削弱他的行动理由,反而让理由变得更清楚:去火星的用处落在文明的概率寿命上,跟个人能不能逃出去没什么关系。
如果你只记一件事,记这个:他衡量特斯拉的尺子是“把可持续能源转型提前了多少年”,跟市值无关。一个创始人这样定义自己公司的价值,这个视角比任何财务数字都更能说明他在做什么。
- 下次看到“某公司估值多少亿”的新闻,换成“它把某件事提前了多少年”再问一遍,判断会清楚很多。
- 遇到宏大的争论,先找一个可以心算的量级。太阳能够不够用、出生率会带来多少成年人、带宽差多少个数量级,能算的就不用吵。
- 分辨一段内容是在接近本质真相,还是在做宣传,用马斯克那个标准:它好笑吗,它敢不敢拿自己人开玩笑。
- 评估一家公司该不该存在,只看它有没有提供足够好的产品或服务。这个标准对你自己所在的公司同样适用。
- 如果你关心 AI 风险,把注意力从“机器人”移到“远超人类的数字智能”。前者只是硬件,失控的来源在后者。
- 看监管议题时,同时问两个问题:这条规则防止了什么,以及它挡住了什么。只问前一个,规则只会越来越多。
- 读到任何“某人说了什么”的转述,去找原话。这场对话里被误读最多次的几句话,恰恰都是加了一两个形容词之后变味的。
0:39So, these are the guys that run the show. This is Kyle, our editor in chief. This is creative director Ethan Nicole. Okay. So, I mean well, I guess before we get started like maybe you guys could tell me like what's the you know how how did the Bee get started and and and yeah. What's your deal? And why why are you in California?
1:04We're very good That's way easier actually. I'm much better at being interviewed. So, no problem. Yeah, the the Bee was just this little like Christian humor site that we launched in 2016 and it was just like we spent 50 bucks on the domain name, started writing jokes and throwing them out there and it started to go big in conservative circles a couple years ago and and that's just kind of where we got to where we are. Seth is our CEO. He bought the site a few years ago from the original founder. Yeah.
1:29Who was the original his name was Adam Ford. Is he not with the company anymore? he owns he owns a piece of it. He does not the Bee now. If you've seen that the you know the yeah. They were just unaffiliated? No, they're they're kind of affiliated. Yeah. Yeah, they're kind of affiliated.
1:42them? Yeah. Okay. they do like real news, but crazy real news. Real news. It's like the backup plan. It's like when satire is impossible because the world's too absurd, then we just report on the absurdity over on Not the Bee. So, you know plan B. Yeah. Real reality is we're we're living in fiction.
1:58Yeah, exactly. often is. So, many people at the Bee now? Yeah, we've got probably a dozen full-timers now. It's grown pretty fast. A year ago it was it was three of us. Okay. We have over we have like 25 people involved. It's not all full-time staff. So many you'd be surprised like with satire you don't have to have a writing staff like filling a room churning out articles all day long. You can only handle so much satire every day. You know like we don't we don't need to publish an article every three minutes like Fox News or Daily Wire or something like that. So we have a lot of part-time. One of our writers here Frank Fleming is one of our writers and he's he's got a
2:30full-time job. He just writes for us on the side. We'd love to have him full-time. I'm the local guy. Yeah, he lives in Austin. Yeah, you live in Austin. Okay. Texas over California. Got it. Yeah. And I'm a Florida guy. I have my head the headquarters are technically in South Florida. I'm in in Southeast Florida. Yeah. And Florida man.
2:45I'd love to get these guys to Florida but it's hard to get people out of California. It really is. yeah. It's more challenging than you think. despite like California is the state of California doing everything it can to encourage people to leave. Yes, yeah. I think you had one article about how Gavin Newsom is such you whole salesman of the year.
3:04Yeah. Actually true. That was true. Actually true. So you don't miss it then? no the I mean there's certainly many aspects of California that I do like. most of my friends are still in California. There's some of my best friends are California. So yeah. I do I do miss many aspects of California especially my friends. and it's beautiful and lots of cool things. but increasingly difficult to get things done.
3:32and California used to be the land of opportunity and now it is the has become and is becoming more so the land of regu sort of over regulation, over litigation, over taxation. Poop on the sidewalk. And and scorn. It's just so it's it's like it's not like thanks for the taxes. It's like take thanks for the taxes and Paxa.
3:58kick you in the teeth. Yeah. Sucks. Exactly. Very exactly got a thank you note. Yeah. So the bee Okay, let me flip the question though. So that's kind of the story of the bee. The bee started out as you know this little blog. It took off. It's kind of blown up into something like now we have a following including you. Like how how do we get on your radar?
4:20People sharing our articles and you just saw them coming across your feed? Yeah, I'm not sure. I saw you on Twitter at one point. I thought some of the articles were quite quite funny. I wrote those. Okay. Yeah, I mean I I I used to be a much bigger fan of the of the Onion, but then the Onion just seems to have gotten really politically correct.
4:45You know, it's sort of gone in the SNL direction. Somewhat leftist as you know it's it's basically it will it will not really make fun of anything on the left. And it used to be much more even-handed than the Onion. And and then they just they just got the woke mind virus. Yeah.
5:02So to the point where the Onion just was it used to be very funny and and then it was not that funny. You know, SNL I I used to be a huge fan of SNL, but you know, I still think they have some some occasional good stuff, but it's just become I I think you've written some some articles about this.
5:21You know, SNL many many many if not most of the SNL episodes are kind of a a moral lecture on why we're bad human beings Right. instead of comedy. Yeah. So and and again won't make fun of anything on the left really. Like you know, they'll beat up on Ted Cruz 17,000 times. Right.
5:44You're like okay, we get it. And often because he's made fun of someone on the left, he'll make fun of someone on the left and then they jump on him for that. It's like a defensive thing. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. So it's it's just there are just a lot of no-fly zones with a lot of comedy and and then and then you realize it's like wait a second is is is comedy Is Is the comedy getting in a at an essential truth or or trying to or is there Is there a propaganda element or is is it trying to push you in a particular direction or or or getting getting to an essential truth that is humorous?
6:19Mhm. And And when it stops trying to get to an essential truth that that is that is humorous, then you you know, it's it's just not that funny. Right. Now see, that's exactly the criticism we get from the left. The criticism from the left is that that's what we're doing with our humor is that we're trying to push a narrative neglecting the truth literally what the New York Times says, which is that we are far right misinformation disguised as satire.
6:41Right. You know, so there's a It's almost where you're standing. too. Yeah. It's almost based on where you're standing that how you see it. on where you're standing. Yeah. I I mean, I'd say the Bee is probably is moderately right. it's not it 's not but it's not certainly not far right.
6:55That my my impression is not that I would say that the Bee is not probably wouldn't It wouldn't be accurate to say the Bee is fully centrist. but but it is it is certainly not far right. if if one is fully left and 10 is fully right, the Bee seems to be at 6 6.5 towards right that ish. But Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, Babylon Bee, Hitler somewhere on that scale.
7:23Yeah. It It It It's not But you know, it's it's a But I mean, the the the Bee is I I think less right than than say the Onion is is left, for example. You know, so the the the Onion I think would be more left than the the Bee is right. Right Rightist or whatever. Rightist. I don't know.
7:41We'll have to put that on our Wikipedia page. is a leftist. Rightist propaganda. You know, you talked about the woke mind virus and I was wondering if you could decipher this tweet of yours for me because I I'm not a programmer. You wrote trace route woke _ mind _ virus. What does that mean?
7:58okay, so trace route is a networking command to So if you if you want to figure out a path to a particular server or or domain, you'd say traceroute or in Windows, tracert. that would show you the path to a particular source server either an IP address or domain name. And and it it would show you basically all the hops that that it goes through.
8:30and the latency between each each hop. And so I know some of those words. Yeah. so traceroute would be yeah would be like where did it come from? Yeah. Where did the virus come from? What is its origin? So did this work? Did this command work or did you find figure that out? Read the comments and see and see.
8:52All right. It it is a prevalent mind virus and arguably one of the biggest threats to one civilization. Also not having enough kids, right? yeah I think most people if if you just simply look at the birth rate statistics you can tell what the future's going to be like because you can see how many children were born last year.
9:14and and then you can say like is this is the birth rate trending down or up? and it's been trending down basically almost everywhere. So so if you look at the birth rate last year, you know you know how many adults there will be in 20 years because that's how many babies were born. The the the trend is like like you don't have to be some master statistician or something like that.
9:36you can just look look at kids born last year trending too well below replacement rate. and and a lot of countries have been well below replacement rate for a long time. Well the concern is that if you have kids, then they'll contribute to climate change and then they'll kill the earth, right? That's the leftist concern is that we're overpopulating the earth and that we're going to kill it. Are you trying to overpopulate the earth so that we can go to Mars and take over and take over Mars?
9:58The earth is the earth is far from overpopulated. strategy? The earth the earth is far from overpopulated. yeah far far from overpopulated. so the you know the the the thing that's necessary to minimize the chemical change to the atmosphere and oceans is to move to sustainable energy generation and consumption.
10:22So the the three elements of a sustainable energy future are sustainably energy generation primarily through solar, wind, some geothermal, hydro, and nuclear. although they're shutting down all the nuclear power stations, so you can sort of cross that one off the list, which they shouldn't be doing. They should just keep this should keep moving.
10:42they're they're they're really unless a nuclear power plant is in a region of a major natural disaster is then or something, yeah. Yeah, you don't want to be like, you know, subject to massive natural disasters cuz obviously that could be a problem. But if you're you know, like say Germany or France or whatever they they don't have those, so the the nuclear power is very safe.
11:02but but anyway, the the the the long-term the the heavy lifting on energy generation will be solar followed by wind. And and you really don't need a a very large land area to generate enough power to power for example the United States. So it's on the order of you know, roughly a little over 100 miles by 100 miles section of land with solar solar panels would power the entire United States.
11:30So like a little corner of Utah or Texas, like it can power the whole country. So anyway, so it's really not that hard. The solar incidence is a gigawatt per square kilometer. for most nuclear just going to do some calculations while Most nuclear power plants most nuclear most mo it's it's it's it's a kilowatt per square per square per square meter and and there's a million square you know, million square meters in a in in a square kilometer. So it's very simple math. So and then you'll get you'll get like maybe 20% efficiency on that. So call it like net power generation of 200 megawatts per square kilometer. Now if if you take most nuclear power plants,
12:13there's usually a pretty big clear area around a nuclear power plant because people don't usually want to live right next to a nuclear power plant. So the area of most nuclear power plants that is uninhabited if if if covered in solar panels would generate more power than the nuclear power plant.
12:31And then you also then the second element that's needed are batteries to store solar and wind because it the sun doesn't shine all the time and the wind doesn't blow all the time. So the the intermittency of solar and wind requires battery storage for continuous power. So that's the second part of the of the sort of second the second pillar of sustainable energy. And the third is sustainable transport. So that means electric cars, boats, planes.
12:59And then ironically the one thing that you can't really make electric is rockets. And I was even involved in that but but although you can over time use solar power to generate fuel by pulling CO2 out of the atmosphere, combining it with H2O, creating CH4 which is methane and O2 oxygen.
13:18Rockets are mostly oxygen by mass. So over time you can make everything basically solar power. So you're working on some of those problems, but the problem of wokeness specifically you mentioned that's like a mind virus and it's destructive. And why why do you think wokeness is so destructive?
13:33I was interested in your your opinions too. But you know like I mean generally I think we should be aiming for like a positive society and you know it should be okay to you know be humorous like you know like we should we should like like wokeness basically wants to make comedy illegal which is not cool.
14:02We've experienced a bit of that. I mean Chappelle like what the Flower bed. I mean try to shut down Chappelle. Come on man. That's crazy. So you know so do do we want a humorless society that is is simply rife with condemnation and hate basically. And no forgiveness, right? Yeah.
14:28At at its heart wokeness is divisive exclusionary and hateful. It's it's it basically gives mean people a reason it gives them a shield to be to be mean and cruel. Armored in false virtue. What do you think? I'd agree with that. Yeah. Yeah, I mean we've we've obviously seen that from the left, you know, just ourselves, you know, the left is almost this religion now where they're so serious and they believe what they believe with such intensity that for us to make fun of them, you know, for them it's like you're making fun of God or salvation, you know. So they're almost the new religious right in our view.
15:13Yeah. He agreed with him. Well, you were pretty mean to Senator Warren though on Twitter recently. You slammed her, man. please don't call the manager on me, Senator Karen. She struck first obviously. Right. Yes, she did. She called me a freeloader Yeah. and a grifter who doesn't pay taxes basically.
15:39And I'm literally paying the most tax that any individual in history has ever paid this year ever. And she doesn't pay taxes. Basically at all. And her tax and her salary is paid for by the taxpayer like me. Could you even use could you use turbo tax? Would that even work? If you could die by irony she would be she would be dead.
16:05If irony could kill. What would happen if you walked into an H&R Block to file your taxes? Like could they handle your case? My taxes are actually not that complicated. I do not have any offshore accounts. I don't have any sort of tax shelters. I have a I have basically a Tesla and SpaceX stock.
16:32and Tesla is publicly traded, so all information is public and SpaceX is you know, a a C corp that is audited you know, has outside auditors. So it these it's it'll with that outside investors. So it is they're also it's everything is extremely transparent. there are there is no there there are no elaborate sort of tax avoidance schemes or or anything like that. So so H&R Block could could easily do my taxes.
17:01You know, I don't need H&R Block. I could do it. You know, if like I don't probably take me a few hours to do my taxes. It's very basic. Did you sell that stock in Tesla because of the Twitter poll? in part. you make up your mind that you were already going to do that before the Twitter poll?
17:16they they're I I have some Tesla options that are expiring next year that so I needed to exercise those options no matter what. and and I was like, okay, I'll I'll move forward and exercise those options. so that that that only would be part of it no matter what. but then over and above that, I sold incremental stock to try to get up to the 10% level. So just the option exercise alone would not get to 10%.
17:47So I sold stock that should be roughly make my total Tesla share sale roughly 10%. Is the most annoying thing in the world people asking you questions like this about your personal finances? Hey, no one ever asks me what stock I'm selling or or why I made so much money last year.
18:06I mean, I'm the third richest man on my street, which is which is pretty good. Pretty good. I mean, I'm not sure it's it's all that productive or interesting. You know, essentially all of my net worth is is just in SpaceX and Tesla stock. These two companies that that I helped create and and I've run for now almost 20 years have done a lot of useful things.
18:33SpaceX is the launches more payload to orbit than the rest of the world combined and has a global internet system called Starlink and and is the primary the the only US provider of astronaut transport to the space station. We publish six to eight satire articles a day. Yeah. Some of them are funny. So that's I mean pretty good.
19:00So so so SpaceX yeah transports US and as well as non-US astronauts to the space station that was previously the US was dependent on on Russia who's doing a good job but charging kind of crazy money per seat. So as with with SpaceX the the cost per astronaut dropped dramatically and and the money was you know went to jobs in the US.
19:26So that's what why why people you know think SpaceX is valuable. Tesla I mean the annoyance though of like people holding it against you that you've had success, holding it against you that you have wealth, you know viewing billionaires as evil and you know you're not doing enough to give back, you know you have like the Elizabeth Warren thing that you haven't paid your fair share. I mean that's you know it's that's got to be kind of aggravating.
19:54Yeah, I think it's just important to understand like like what is this wealth. It's not like some it's not like I've got like some some mashup massive cash balance. I've my cash balances are are very very low and at least until I sold stock which is really the first time I've actually sold stock in a meaningful way was this quarter.
20:17I I simply had loans against my my stock so I I I if if Tesla and SpaceX went bankrupt, I would go bankrupt too immediately. So, It's not realized is what you're saying. Yeah, it's not. No, it's it's just like people it's just like it's like you know, I built these two companies and it was extremely difficult to build them.
20:42like massively painful and difficult. rewarding too, but also but but massively painful difficult. and and and I didn't I didn't sell the stock in the companies. you know, I I I you know, my my sort of impression was that you know, you you shouldn't take money off the table or you shouldn't you shouldn't take stock off the table and de-risk things that a captain should go down you know, with their ship. So, so it's like okay, like you know, I don't want to take money off the table and then then if the companies fail, then I will be I will be sort of enriched while investors suffer and that does not seem right.
21:26So anyway, so I that's the reason I didn't sell is is I could easily have diversified and and protected myself financially if if SpaceX or Tesla went bankrupt, but I I did not. and SpaceX and Tesla came very close to bankruptcy many times. Even when bankruptcy was literally weeks away, I did not sell stock. and then the companies became valuable. Not Tesla's value is and SpaceX's value is not it's not up to me. It's up to investors.
21:53and they decided it was worth Tesla was worth a trillion dollars in the public market. So, and I own 20% of the company. So, So, you're not apologizing right now? You're not going to look into the camera and say I'm so sorry. the camera right now. I was just trying to explain like I don't think people necessarily understand They don't. Yeah, yeah.
22:12that that this is this is not you know, that some function of of sort of hoarding or something. It's it's simply that you know, I own 20% of the company that became very valuable as decided external investors. And so 20 percent of a trillion dollar valuation is 200 billion dollars.
22:31Mhm. and I you know I've said at various times that I think the stock price is too high but investors just ignored that. I'm like okay I literally said it's too high. and they just kept making that price higher. So I'm like Tell them our value is too high. So anyway so just that's but like I said this is not like my so-called wealth is is not some is is not some deep mystery it's simply what is my ownership percentage of SpaceX and Tesla multiply that by the valuation that's my net worth. That's super simple and my taxes are super simple and I have no like I said no offshore accounts no sort of clever tax evasion or anything like that and I don't I don't draw a salary or any
23:14cash salary or bonus from the companies at all. So again I thought that was like morally good to to not do that and so there were there were like there's one year I think 2018 where where I I didn't pay any tax but but that's because I didn't have any income and and and but I did have a little bit of income but I'd actually overpaid taxes I think in 2017 so I paid too much tax and so I got like I basically netted that out in in 2018 because I paid too much tax in 2017 Right.
23:46by accidentally. unless you sell stock there are no realized gains so so then I was like well should I sell like I I like what am I supposed to do wire and shares to the government somehow I don't know if you can even do that. Yeah. so then I was like well like unless I sell shares there's not there's no there's no actual mechanism to pay tax.
24:08Mhm. So then I was like well should I sell 10 percent you know to in order to pay tax and and I sort of asked Twitter and they're like on balance they said yes and so so I I sold enough stock to get to around 10 percent plus the option exercise stuff. And I very I tried to be extremely literal, so that you don't generally need to read between the lines. You can just read the lines.
24:37Mhm. So, that's it. As the as the fattest guy here, I I want to know what's when are you going to make the candy company? Cuz you said on Twitter that you're making a candy company. And you're the closest thing to Willy Wonka that this culture has. could be Willy Wonka. I didn't say it. When did he say that?
24:56He said I'm starting a candy company. It's going to be amazing. of Warren Buffett. No. But you did say I am super super serious. We've got the receipt. I think if if you put two supers before serious, then that's like you're probably not serious, you know? just FYI for satire writers out there.
25:14Yeah. I thought that locked it in as like definitely serious. He's explaining jokes to it. Yeah. Yeah yeah. It's just guys say let me tell you how jokes satire works. No, I was I was just obviously I was just like making fun of Warren Buffett who's like really he's got this like candy company and stuff. So, and That was my one question.
25:35That's that's what you got. No no I I did actually I did actually experiment with trying to find some compelling candy that would be like I don't know maybe much better than other candy. We we tried various candy options, but I didn't find any I couldn't figure out a candy that was like just way better than another candy.
26:00Like a little bit better, but not a lot better. And so it was like unless it's like really a a great product then You looked into this. You looked really into this. Yeah yeah. Yeah. Yeah, we tried tried a whole bunch of different candies and and it was like there's not anything like that's obviously just way better.
26:20So, I don't want to just have like a pretty good candy. There's like a great candy. Yeah, some aces some candy that's aces. But we we don't need another sort of like pretty good candy. Yeah. There's plenty of those out there. Yeah. What does that look like when you like suddenly get an idea like we should make candy? Do you like you just call somebody and like how does what what are the steps that suddenly take place when you're like cuz you do so many things?
26:46I'm just fascinated by the what that process looks like. Rockets. Tell me. got a guy you call? Jim, I want to make candy. Make it out. I think I I did ask for you know people on Twitter to send me candy that they thought was good. Just employed and I was like well what if some of this candy is like you know is poisonous or something but whatever like you know candy for strangers on the internet.
27:15Yeah. It it could go wrong. It's it's not 100% safe. but I did try a whole bunch of candy sent from strangers. What what's your favorite candy then? Well there was like a a pretty good like peanut like some pretty good peanut brittle ones or like that peanut brittle with a bunch of other stuff in it.
27:36Mhm. And some pretty good chocolates but but nothing that was like blew me away. So and and then there are people at SpaceX and Tesla that that send me some candy options but n- nothing that was it's not that I care about starting companies like if there's like there are if there's a a very compelling product or service then that's the thing that is important not the company. You know company is just an assemblage of people to create a compelling product or service. And if a company does not provide great products and services it should not exist.
28:08There's no point in a company for the sake of being a company. That's pointless. Companies should only exist to provide great products and services. A company's just just literally a group of people. So do we have to close down or can we stay open? I I think there's a lot of there's a lot of companies out there that probably should just be disbanded because they they don't make compelling products and services. It's pointless. And those people better that those people do something else.
28:35I think on that topic, I mean, the the question that I just like really I mean, I feel so unqualified to be interviewing you right now. I think we all do. Why are we here? Like what what drew you to like actually sit down with us? for it. I'm not the one who asked for it. I'm not the one who asked for the podcast.
28:50You guys did. Just to be clear. I'm not pushing the podcast on you. You guys came here. We just We were like, I will stop by, you know, Texas. Yeah, just to be clear who is asking who. Like, yeah. I'm not I'm not like, you know, didn't exactly hold a gun to your head for this podcast.
29:11Anytime you ask him right now. Sorry, I don't You could be on CNN right now. You know. A real news organization. You know. I'm just throwing it out there. I don't know. No, I unfortunately I just, you know, haven't you know, I guess you know, what what was it you said the the requirement for being a CNN drive at CNN is or what was it?
29:36are you a pervert? you know, I I have not perverted enough, I guess. I don't know. pedophile fan or what? You know Babylon Bee headlines better than I do, so I think you know, a lot of us fantasize about if we had lots and lots and lots of money, what we would do. And you've done a lot of the things that like a lot of us fantasize about. Build cool robots, going to go to Mars, we're going to fix traffic.
30:01But most of us also think we'd become Batman. Have you ever thought about like what would that really look like to become Or would you go Batman or Iron Man route? What kind of fruit kind of bat? A fruit bat or an insect bat? I like the dragon bat. Big, scary. Yeah, because most bats are either fruit or They carry a lot of diseases. Yeah.
30:21You know, they eat fruit and bugs like fruit Batman, insect Batman. Fruit bat. You need to read that spin-off comic now. It's a strange choice of creature to you know. that's true. You can pick a different animal? Like maybe monkeys that play pong with their brains? Man. Batman would be man.
30:49Monkey man, yeah, exactly. Just very agile. They're the smartest animal, right? It can just swing m- monkey man. Bat- Batman is more is more like monkey man really, you know, because he's like he's swinging around and very agile climbing up things and Yeah, throwing a batarang is more like throwing poop.
31:07for for a Batman like why can't he fly if he's Batman? Bats can fly. Yeah, that's true. He just glides. he glides very effectively though. So he's really more like a flying It's more like flying squirrel man. Squirrel man. It's says less It's less intimidating I guess. Oh no, squirrel man. We're we're It's going to get us, you know.
31:29not squirrel man again. Yeah. Have you ever thought about making the the grappling hook he has? That thing's sweet. We need those. You can make probably make that. Yeah. Yeah, sure you can make a grappling hook. I I mean the thing is like like like when you It's It's It's like they they sort of skip the parts where like Batman always in the top of a building, but like once you get to the ground floor, how do you get back to the top of the building? It's like you're going to huffing and puffing, you know.
31:53Climb You know. I mean how do you get to the top of a skyscraper even if you got a grappling hook? I mean how big is your grappling hook? Like 50 stories? Like What is How big is that cable, you know? It's not really feasible. so do you just got to like run up the stairs or take the elevator?
32:11So it's like how do you How do you get back up to the top of the skyscraper in Gotham City? It's always at like top of some tall building, so So Iron Man then. He'd be Iron Man. be Iron Man? Yeah. Iron Man just doesn't have that problem. the costs of things and stuff like that, so like would it be cheaper to become Batman or Iron Man or just pay every criminal that you encounter a salary to just stop being a criminal?
32:30I think they're trying that so. Irony Man. Irony Man? I just defeat villains using the power of irony. There you go. It's like oh too much irony. I can't stand it. Please, no, stop the irony. I can't handle it anymore. I give up. I give up. Too much irony. That would be That would be awesome.
32:49That'd be totally awesome. It would be awesome. That would be Don't make me use irony again. Cheaper, too. And What are your thoughts on the metaverse which like takes technology to the next level and puts us in like a virtual world? Like do you see that as being dangerous, hopeful for humanity? Like what's your view on that?
33:11Maybe we're in the metaverse right now. It's just metaverse is all the way down. I don't know if I necessarily buy into this metaverse stuff. although people talk to me a lot about it. It's Web 3, you know. I'm like, sure, you you can put a TV on your nose. Yeah. not sure that makes you in the metaverse, you know.
33:36it's like weird like, you know, when I grew up it was like don't sit too close to TV. It's going to ruin your eyesight. Right. And now I got like TV is like literally right here on us. I'm like, what? Is that good for you? I mean have you tried these games or you know The VR Oculus stuff? Yeah.
33:54they're okay, you know, but like it gives you motion sickness if you try to walk around. Like Like you can do a video game on your sort of computer console or whatever and and and you can you can be in a like a first person game and and and move rapidly and not get motion sickness. But if you try to do that in with VR goggles, you get motion sickness. It's like weird. So you have to like teleport around with It's okay.
34:20So it doesn't It doesn't feel like like that's the answer necessarily. Could you team up a Neuralink into the brain so that you don't have to have the glasses? There you go. Yeah. A Neuralink long term, supposed to get a Neuralink, could put you fully fully in a virtual reality thing.
34:40so I guess what I'm getting at is yeah, exactly what could go wrong, like the the negative implications, the kind of dystopian implications that some are drawing out. Like, I think it was I think Jack Dorsey was really critical of the whole metaverse idea. And you see problems with people living in a virtual world and leaving the physical world for for that and I don't see if someone's strapping a freaking you know, screen to their face all day and not wanting to to ever leave. I that seems no way. I mean, if you does it feel like that to you? It doesn't seem like that to me.
35:12Yeah. It's like it it gets uncomfortable to have this thing strapped to your head the whole time. It definitely needs to be lighter. Yeah, I mean, if it was I mean, if it was like super light, it still still be like I don't know. It's not so like you want to be there all day. So, you know, I think we're far from disappearing into the metaverse.
35:30this sounds just kind of buzzwordy and you know, I I don't want to feel like like like hey, is this you know, if I just got too old and like am I like one of those people who was like dismissing the internet whatever 95 as being like some fad or something that's never going to amount to anything.
35:49Although I didn't. I was like saying like 95 was literally the internet is going to be transformed humanity and and it going to be like you know, prior information basically just went by osmosis. Like unless a person called another person or carried a letter physically to another person like how did you get information around?
36:06The vast majority of information was literally person to person. Then then you had like the fax machine and stuff, but it's just like The way the metaverse is being sold right now is so underwhelming. It's like you're going to be in it's like Zoom meetings, but there's an avatar of for the person next to you, you know, and you maybe you get to maybe you get to design your avatar.
36:23Like said, I don't I don't want to be like you know, some old some old codger sort of dismissing the internet in 95 is not amounting to anything. So, there's some danger with that if that's the case, but I I currently am unable to see a compelling metaverse situation or Web 3 sounds
36:42like more marketing than reality. I don't get it. You know, and maybe I will. But I don't get it yet. Let me put it that way. It's definitely not monkeys playing pong. Let's just put it that way. Yeah. I just like to advertise for White Claw. Those are good. Yeah. White Claw, real men drink White Claw.
37:08Can we get our guys on the phone with White Claw to get Sponsor after the fact. If you want us to be that in, then you will pay us. Well, this is you know, this is the first White Claw the first White Claw ever drunk on the Babylon B podcast. So that's great. You had a point in your life where you you know, you made plenty of money and you could do whatever. What drives you to just keep it could be surfing Mai Tais on on a tropical island and like you know, windsurfing with naked models.
37:38Yeah. You know, some people do that. Like what drives you to be How do you see you you working normally working second. White Why am I not What to White? I just realized what the I I've I've been wrong all this time. Why am I working 90 hours a week? This is crazy. Cuz I'm always fascinated by the idea of like I have made it. People always want to say be able to say I've made it.
37:57I've arrived. Yeah. And like how do you you know, you you hit those little islands in your life and you actually have to break yourself of that mindset. And what are ways that you break yourself of that mindset and keep on going? I just put all this effort into building SpaceX and and Tesla because I thought they were easy ways to make money. I mean anyone who starts a car company thinking it's an easy way to make money is a fool.
38:22there are only two car companies that have not gone bankrupt in the history of the United States and that's Ford and Tesla. And Tesla came within in inches of going bankrupt multiple times as did SpaceX. So right and like who starts a rocket company thinking it's going to be successful? I I started a I mean I both both those companies I I thought had less than a 10% chance of success.
38:45And I thought it was overwhelmingly likely that I would lose the money that I made from PayPal. You know, I I came to North America when I was 17 just by myself. and I had like like a a few thousand dollars in in travelers checks back when travelers checks were a thing, you know.
39:02in Canadian dollars. Yeah, and I landed in Montreal. I have some family in Canada. and my mom's uncle lived in Montreal, but like we didn't we didn't know his phone number, so I I landed in Montreal and my mom says, oh, I just got a letter back from my uncle. He's in Minnesota or something.
39:21So I'm like, okay, I don't know what to do now. So I just stayed in a youth hostel and like bought a bus ticket across Canada. I worked in various like odd jobs and stuff. Worked on my on my mom's cousin's farm wheat farm in Saskatchewan for 6 weeks. That's where I had my 18th birthday actually.
39:37And worked in a lumber mill. chainsawed logs and did various odd jobs. and and then went to college in in Canada for a couple years. I paid my own way through college by the way, so but in Canada it's like easier cuz the college is more subsidized and I was a Canadian citizen through my mom.
39:56So and I got some scholarships and loans and stuff and and then I applied to the University of Pennsylvania and didn't think I'd be able to go because tuition's really high, but they they gave me a scholarship and loans and stuff, so I was able to go there. I graduated with about $100,000 in student debt.
40:18And I was going to do grad studies at at Stanford and decided to put that on hold to try start starting an internet company. I actually I tried to get a job at Netscape but they didn't I had sent my resume and didn't get a response. So I was like, okay, I guess I I can't get a job at at they're only a few internet companies and can get a job at any of them, so I was like, I guess I want to do something on the internet. I got to start my own company.
40:49but I ended up writing the first maps and directions on the internet. I wrote it personally, maps, directions, yellow pages, white pages, on a puny computer, like with hardly any So it had you had to be like the code had to be super tight. I even have some patents on like maps and directions and yellow pages and white pages and stuff from from ages ago. They're they're lapsed now, but that that company ended up up getting bought by by Compact for about $300 million and I owned 7% of the company, so I got like $20 million from that. Put most of it into
41:24x.com which merged with Confinity to create PayPal. And then I got about $180 million from that. And I put all of that into SpaceX, Tesla, and and SolarCity. I just basically kept, you know, kept all the chips on the table and just like let's play another round. When most people take the chips off the table or or at least some of their chips. And and then SpaceX and Tesla ended up being valuable and that's where I am. But but the the the reason for SpaceX and Tesla is, you know, Tesla Let's say like what is what is the how would you assess the historical good of Tesla?
41:58I'd say it's the degree to which Tesla accelerated sustainable energy. And I I've been interested in in in electric cars for a long time since maybe high school, certainly early college. My original interest in electric vehicles was not so much due to environmental concerns, but rather from the concern that we'd run out of oil eventually and or it become extremely scarce and expensive and then civilization would collapse because we couldn't drive cars or, you know, run power plants and stuff. So so we need some form of sustainable energy generation and consumption or or civilization's going to collapse. So that was my original interest in electric vehicles and solar energy.
42:42And and then I I do think there's some risk of negatively affecting the climate. you as you increase the CO2 concentration in the oceans and atmosphere, this you increase the risk of something going wrong. I I I am I am not like in the camp of of of the super alarmist global warming.
43:11I you know like I think like I don't think we're like screwed because of like the the current parts per million of CO2 in the oceans atmosphere. I I think like this is actually it's not not a terrible level. However, the there's so much inertia in the direction of mining and burning hydrocarbons that at the you know that the the the world is still overwhelmingly dependent on mining and burning hydrocarbons. so you know if if this continues and you start really driving up the the CO2 in the oceans atmosphere, then there's there's there's increased risk of accelerating climate change, basically warming up the oceans and and raising the sea level. So so I
44:09think that's that's like it's just I think that's probably just not a wise risk to take since we will in in any case have to transition to sustainable energy long term because we will eventually run out of oil and coal to mine and burn. then why run the experiment to see if you know to see if something bad will happen with a a high CO2 concentration in the oceans atmosphere. Like it's a pointless experiment. Like we know we have to get to some sustainable energy economy.
44:41It's tautological. Like so I think there's we should try to get there sooner so as not to run the risk of climate change. It would not climate change would not be catastrophic to self of civilization, but it would be very disruptive. Humans love living right on the ocean. So it's like we're almost like a like a thermometer.
45:01It's like it's like if we we're living right on the beach. Okay, so this is like so even small changes in the sea level in sea level will put a lot of houses underwater. Even little little changes, not they don't have to be big. We just we just inherently created civilization that is highly sensitive to changes in temperature.
45:19A lot of politicians who are alarmist about this stuff buy homes right on the water though, don't they? True. Yeah, I I mean I I'm I'm not sort of into like vilifying the oil and gas industry because I think I think the the reality is like if if we don't have oil and gas right now, civilization would collapse and and everyone would be starving. So we obviously need oil and gas right now.
45:45It would be absurd to just stop it. Like it's not not feasible. but but I do think we should be trying to accelerate progress towards a sustainable energy future not slow it down. You know, I think it's just a sensible thing to do to to try to move faster to a sustainable energy economy rather than slower because that reduces the risk of of the climate experiment. Like I said, since we know we have to get to a sustainable energy economy anyway, why run this experiment? It's it's just not smart.
46:21Anyway, so so the fundamental good of Tesla I think is by you know, should be measured by how by how many years did Tesla accelerate the transition to a sustainable energy economy? 10 years, 20 years you know, that's like the fundamental good of the company. But to Ethan's point, he's asking like why not like is is that is that your is that your answer for why you keep going is because these are these things make a difference. They make a difference ultimately for the flourishing of humanity, for the longevity of humanity.
46:50Is that why you're not on a beach somewhere sipping Mai Tais or White Claws? Yeah. I I actually drink a lot of White Claw. This is not about like trying to enrich myself. I do not live a life of conspicuous consumption. I work, you know, very long hours and but I think I think what Tesla is doing is important to the future.
47:19and that's that's why I keep doing it. and I think it you know it's it's something that I think is it Tesla increases the probability that the future will be good for humanity. And and then for SpaceX I think I think it's important that we take the actions like like that we become a spacefaring civilization and a multi-planet species.
47:43This is an exciting inspiring future. You know you need to have things that when you wake up in the morning you like you're excited about the future. Why live if if it's all about solving problems or being miserable? But why live? so there got to be things that are that are inspiring that like you know get you in the heart.
48:03And I think space is one of those things. So you know look at the Apollo program and you know sending sending people to the moon in '69 and wasn't that a great thing for all of humanity? Great thing. And if you ask people like what are some what are some of the greatest things that humanity's ever done that would be one of them.
48:24And I think you know around the world people would agree with that you know. you believe it really happened. Yes, I do get that question. This is yeah. We we we went to the moon not just once but several times and I think the Russians would have called us out on that one if it wasn't true you know.
48:49to say the least. Among among this is like the yeah it's we went to the we went to the moon okay. The Russians didn't like us at the time. Yeah the Russians certainly was not a huge fan of America. They wouldn't congratulate like they were looking at us in the through telescopes and like is this real or what, you know?
49:06they would have Bubble gum. If it wasn't, that's for sure. it was a huge you know victory you know ideological victory for the United States and Western civilization. So but anyway the the point is like we we want to have an exciting inspiring future and and one where we are spacefaring civilization and a multi-planet species I think it is much more exciting and inspiring future than one where we are forever confined to Earth and never go back to the moon. And and the moon was our high water mark and that's all we ever did.
49:36That's depressing. and and there's also from a long-term basis if we're a multi-planet species it's like life insurance for life itself, not just for humans but for for all the creatures on Earth. because we bring them with us and and they can't build spaceships. So you know we are we are in effect the steward of life.
49:54and you know we we can make a we can make Mars like a you know another planet with life on it. you know it is you know it's probably a dangerous analogy to use but it it it's a bit like Noah's Ark but you know we we we bring more than two two of every creature because it's a little incestuous frankly.
50:17I mean they're still you know like how does this work, you know? Second generation. And and did he hate the dinosaurs? Like what's the why why why is it like F U to the dinosaurs? You got to get answers from the dinosaurs. it's like pro incest bad on dinosaurs. I don't get it anyway.
50:39and it would have to be a very big vote. So but but there's you know it's a metaphor perhaps. I don't know. you know so anyway so like there's there's some some risk especially over a long period of time that some would happen to Earth and if we're just on one planet that would be the end of life itself. And certainly the the the sun the sun is slowly expanding so you know the Earth's roughly four and a half billion years old. Some people might disagree with that, but it appears to be that way.
51:10and roughly half a billion years the sun will expand to make earth probably uninhabitable. In a billion years definitely uninhabitable. So basically if intelligent life had taken 10% longer to evolve on earth then we would never have evolved at all because it would be destroyed because the oceans would boil and they would we wouldn't be able to exist.
51:39So I mean no matter what the universal end in heat death though, right? Eventually. So it's all futile to some extent if you go far enough. yeah I mean I think the if heat death is the outcome of the universe it really all is all about the journey. Like you know they say it like you know the journey is is is half half the fun is the journey or whatever. Well if heat death is the end of the universe the journey is all the fun.
52:05You know Can we just evolve heat resistance become like lava beings? It's not it's cold. It cools eventually. Entropy and it I'm not a scientist. The death of heat basically. Can we just evolve to that? It's like entropy entropy no escaping that for me. Entropy the ultimate enemy.
52:31You thought the devil was bad try entropy. Yeah. Okay. Try getting away from that. But yeah I mean the yes I mean technically the being a multi-planet species would increase the probable lifespan of of civilization and and life as we know it. So I mean humans don't live forever. So but just because we don't live forever does not mean that civilization cannot live much longer than than we do.
52:59Civilization lives much longer than any individual human. So this is not about like escaping to Mars. This is simply I mean I I will die probably long before Mars is a self-sustaining civilization. it's just I think something we should we should do in order to have a much longer probable lifespan of civilization.
53:22And it's interesting and exciting and and Mars is is like a it is like an essential next step to like there there are these like you know filters they're called the like the great filters. And because you have to say like where are the aliens, you know? It's like the Fermi paradox.
53:42Where are the aliens? If the universe is 13.8 billion years old, shouldn't they be everywhere by now? And I'm not aware of any evidence for aliens. People ask me about that too. where are the aliens? I'm like man, if anyone would know about evidence of aliens it would be me. And I I've seen nothing.
54:02So nothing I may have been Carl Sagan who said you know there's like we're either alone in in the galaxy or there are a lot of aliens and and each answer is arguably equally terrifying. it's like it's like hey we found it aliens are on their way too bad it's the invasion fleet. you know so I I don't know. It's like where are the where are the aliens? Like maybe there aren't any in this galaxy and maybe the what we have here is a very very rare situation.
54:43you know a brief a brief flickering of consciousness in the dark like a little candle in in in a vast darkness. And we should not let that little candle go out. So my dad's a rocket scientist at at Boeing and he had a question engineer. That well whatever. I'm going to ask when people say rocket scientist they they really mean rocket engineer.
55:03Okay yeah so he's a rocket engineer and he says at what number does Starship endure max Q? Maximum dynamic pressure. How much pressure is that? Does that make any sense to you? yeah so yeah max max Q maximum dynamic pressure is is when you're at a combination of speed and atmospheric density such that the the wind force on the rocket is is the highest.
55:34and so as you climb higher and higher the atmospheric density decays exponentially. and so you hit this point of of combination of velocity and and air density which is maximum dynamic pressure or maximum Q. and this this is mostly a function of thrust to weight. So if you have a a low thrust to weight rocket you will have typically a a lower max Q.
56:04and if you have a high thrust to weight rocket you will have a higher max Q if you do not throttle down. And so and and it also kind of depends on on on what trajectory you're flying. Are you flying a low Earth orbit trajectory? single burn insertion or or a a say a geosynchronous transfer orbit with a low perigee then you'll have a higher a higher max Q because you will spend you'll you'll spend more time going sort of horizontal instead of vertical. getting to orbit is mostly about your getting to orbit is is about your your velocity parallel to the Earth's surface.
56:41So around mach 23 mach to mach 25 you're you know so roughly 23 ish times the speed of sound is when you reach orbit orbital velocity roughly 17,000 mph. So and and and that's that's what it means to go up and stay up. You only need height in order to get out of the the high density portion of the atmosphere so that you don't slow down.
57:04None of that was correct. I disagree. I disagree. Yeah agree to disagree. I I totally different answer. I don't have time to get into it right now. It all checks out. Yeah, so I mean, typically a rocket is going to hit max Q somewhere between Mach 1.4 and 1.8 and and and that Q level is going to be maybe 400 to 800 lbs per square foot.
57:33now the Starship is intended to have a high a higher thrust-to-weight because with a fully reusable rocket the the cost of propellant starts to become significant, whereas if you have an expendable rocket or a partially reusable rocket, the cost of propellant is is tiny compared to the cost of the rocket.
57:56so so you actually want a higher thrust-to-weight to minimize cost per ton to orbit with a fully reusable rocket than you would for an expendable. so so probably Starship will have at least 1.3 if not closer to a 1.5 thrust-to-weight which would if if with without throttling down, which aspirationally we would not throttle down, would would have a quite a high Q.
58:23maybe as high as 1,000 or even 1,200 lbs per square foot. so that's and and and probably probably you know yeah at at at what velocity? I mean, I'd guess Mach 1.4 to 1.5, something like that. Okay. Well, my dad very much enjoyed that answer, I'm sure. I think as a male feminist though, one thing that about the rockets is the phallic symbology.
58:55What would it take to get some more vaginal-shaped rocket? Just, you know, for well, equality. can we make that happen? Aerodynamics and hydro dynamics. He's going to me a serious answer. share share similar properties, whether biological or mechanical. Okay. Good answer. That's all I got on a rocket science.
59:30robots. Yeah, Tesla Bot. So you're creating robots. Have you ever seen a sci-fi movie in your life? Never. Okay. I thought maybe not. You know, like because things can go wrong. What's the worst that could happen? Yeah. I I thought the I thought the robots are not are not the the scary part. The scary part is AGI or artificial general intelligence, digital super intelligence that far exceeds human intelligence.
1:00:01and you know, if if if if if there's a digital super intelligence that is just vastly smarter than the smartest human, we could lose control of it and then it it it could it could just it could do something bad potentially. these things are just probabilities. They're not certainties.
1:00:23so it's it's not the actually it's not the robots. It's the digital super intelligence to be concerned about. I I think this is definitely one of the issues that we need to be concerned about as an existential risk. I think we should have a regulatory agency that oversees advanced AI.
1:00:45because you know, generally like I I do think there are important roles for the government and and one of those roles is in regulation of of industry to make sure that any any that the companies are not making shortcuts that endanger the public. So you know, the FAA does has done done generally a great great job of ensuring that aircraft are safe.
1:01:09you know, it it it's literally safer to fly on an American airline or any any any sort of airline overseen by the FAA than it is to live in your house. Just to give people a sense of you're more likely to die. Your probable lifespan is less if you live your entire life in your house or than if you live on a plane.
1:01:33cuz in your house you can get murdered by a spouse get bitten by a louse. But if you're living a plane in Afghanistan, that's not maybe this the case. if if if it's not if if the if if it's not overseen by a a regulator that like the FAA then then then it's not necessarily going to meet the same safety standards.
1:01:59What if your spouse is on the plane? Well, I think it's the planes have you know they have means of stuffing like you can't it's hard to bring a gun on a plane Yeah. and even a knife or even a bottle of lotion at this point, you know. So Your spouse couldn't bring any of those things on the plane.
1:02:17I mean they'd have to just punch you with it or stab you with a fork you know plastic fork and it's like hard to kill someone with a fork. so and and then planes also have like the flight attendants are trained in first aid. They've got like they can do CPR. They've got defibrillators. if if somebody's you know having medical issues, they'll immediately land the plane and an ambulance will meet you at the airport.
1:02:44So and you're not going to like you know drown in the bathtub or get electrocuted by a toaster or you know have your house burned down or because of the toaster. By the way, toasters cause a lot of houses to burn down. So one of the one of the the main causes of house burning down like toasters and dryers.
1:03:02There's also a decent chance there's a doctor on the plane at any given time, right? That happens all the time like a doctor is like treating somebody on a plane and in your house, you know. Yeah. So so planes are very safe and and I mean generally speaking the the does a good job of overseeing food and and drugs.
1:03:20you know this might might be a bit of a a conservative bias on you know where at times there's an asymmetry with the FDA where so something that that could help a lot of people is not approved because it it it might hurt a small number of people. So that there's a sort of like a a bit of a a bit of an asymmetry.
1:03:41like so regulators they're in in general can have a bit of an asymmetry where they are they're punished a lot for something going wrong but not rewarded enough for going something going right. so that that's just a general you know challenge with the the punishment and reward of of regulators.
1:04:02They can be a little conservative. So but but but I think there should be a regulatory agency to oversee you know anything that is a danger to the public. so and I think AGI could be an injury to the public so therefore should should have some oversight. and and normally great regulatory agencies are very reactive. so like for seat belts for example which like of seat belts caused I don't know 10 million deaths worldwide I mean a massive number.
1:04:31And the car industry fought seat belts for a very long time. And and eventually after many deaths the Department Department of Transport NTSA which oversees as a regulatory body for cars said all cars have to have seat belts that you can't just not have a seat belt. but but that I don't know took it 15 years or something or maybe longer maybe 20 years before seat belts were mandated so and then you know baby seats are a lot of a lot of kids and babies died because they're just like sitting on this you know on a a seat with nothing. I mean I I kind of grew up sitting on a seat with nothing.
1:05:11And we'd ride in the bed of the truck Yeah seriously I rode rode in the bed of the pickup truck for hours survivor bias or something. I was fine but Yeah I mean I was fine but if if if there an accident, it was game over, you know? Yeah. so So you do see some good in government with when it comes to regulation and stuff like that. But you don't generally think the government can spend your money more effectively than you can.
1:05:32Yeah, I mean I would say like generally I'm I'm like I think pretty moderate. I'm not like an sort of an extreme libertarian. I think there are roles for the government that make sense. Like I don't think we necessarily want like a private army or private police force or private Yeah, I I think there's, you know, certain things that that are probably the the right role for the government. But but anything done by the government is going to be inefficient because the government is a monopoly.
1:06:04it like people that don't like corporations should not somehow think that the government is is much is much better because the government is a a corporation in the limit. It is the ultimate corporation with a monopoly on violence. So so so like I think you know the right role of the government is is like to be acting in a regulatory capacity.
1:06:29and but but we we should aspire to have the government be be a a limited actor in the economy. so you know you could say like what percentage of economic output should be government? You know and maybe maybe a third or something like that. You know once you start getting above 50% government, I think that's problematic. Oh, so you can look at at countries like East and West Germany, North and South Korea, and there's you know there's just essentially an arbitrary line drawn out to divide the countries. And East Germany was like kind of 100% government. West Germany was I don't know probably at least 40% government. They're like you know relatively socialist.
1:07:16and yet the GDP per capita of that you know of of West Germany was I think it five times higher than East Germany. So that just shows you just how big of a difference it is if if you have like something that's close to half government versus 100% government. private sector is probably a factor of 10 more efficient than the government.
1:07:36and and this like this is sort of this is also true of just just generally if you have like a monopolistic private corporation then the forcing function for serving the customer is weak. but at least private corporations can go bankrupt and the government cannot go bankrupt unless the people will go bankrupt like basically unless it exhausts extracting money from the population. So Well they're trying their best so.
1:08:04Yeah. It's just you know so so it's just you want to just knowing that the government is is inefficient as any large monopolistic corporation would be and it is the ultimate large monopolistic corporation we should minimize the how much the government does. you know keep it to what is essential and and not go beyond that.
1:08:28Yeah I mean I guess you know the conservative concern with that is you start to give them you know you give them a foothold and then they're just going to keep going like you give them a regulatory capacity over something like AGI and then they're just going to start to you know overreach more and more cuz that's what we've seen in the past you you know you give them an inch and they take a mile.
1:08:48Yeah but I I mean does anyone realistically want to delete the FA or the FDA? Probably somebody. I I mean we got an anarchist in the corner already. I mean it used to be if like you go to the store like you you you buy some whatever a steak or or or some some from the store and ask like is like poisonous you know and and or or you know the like we take for granted that the food we buy is is at the store is it it is not going to kill us you know actually you know because some company cut costs and decided that you having E. coli and salmonella is you know who cares type of thing.
1:09:30so so I think you know like we like we take for granted that the food we we buy at the stores is is is not poisonous and that the drugs we buy like that is the extremely unlikely like the drugs will be consistent and and they will do what they say they're going to do. which except for the the sort of vitamin supplements industry which can basically is is unregulated.
1:09:57And so they can say things that are not true and still still buy it. anyway so it's it's like I think you know do you really want like you can think of like the you want some kind of referee on the field. So like you know for you know like it's like a if you're watching say a football game or or something like basketball there's referees.
1:10:21Okay so would would the games be better or worse without a referee? They'd be worse. You know so the think like the role of a referee in in games is important and so the the government's role as a referee I think is also important. you just don't want to have the government be kind of on the field as a player.
1:10:40It would be weird if the referees just suddenly started playing ball you know. Probably not the game would not be as good. Well another things that make me think you've never seen a sci-fi movie before you have neural link so you can like put things in people's brain or something what's that like?
1:11:02What's that like is it What it is it cool? You like it? Well try it you might like it. Okay. Yeah with with neural link neural link is in part well in fact the the the the sort of the reason I created neural link was long term as a risk mitigation for digital super intelligence in if we are able to effectively achieve symbiosis with digital intelligence then we're we're sort of the collective human will is better able to steer things in a direction that we'd like or or even with benign AI at least go along for the ride.
1:11:52So because even with a benign benign superintelligence if it's so much smarter than us that you that it really can't even communicate effectively because it's so fast and and then like talking to us is like talking to a tree. You know because if you if you do a stop motion on like a tree a tree is communicating with its environment just very slowly.
1:12:12You know it looks for the it looks it's looking for water the tree roots looking for water the the the branches are looking for sun and and the tree has movement it's just very slow. and so and we we are already at this point partially a cyborg we're de de facto sort of a cyborg in in that our phones and computers and applications are a digital extension of ourselves at this point like if somebody leaves their phone behind it's like missing limb syndrome.
1:12:46You know like the the phone is almost like a part of you. and but but but the the issue with that symbiosis is that the the data rate is extremely slow. So like how fast can you can you can you communicate with your your phone using two thumbs? You know 10 bits per second it's it's very low the data rate.
1:13:09And if if computers can and which they can communicate at a you know a a billion bits per second or more and and we're communicating with them at 10 bits per second then that's just an extremely slow communication link. and it inhibits symbiosis without sort of tertiary digital layer. Like so we've got sort of basically like a a primal layer, which is like our limbic system. Basically it's our our instincts and love our emotions and it's kind of like the reptile brain situation. And then you've got the cortex, which is like the the thinking part of the brain, planning and what not.
1:13:51and so it's like the second layer and then then our phones and computers are our tertiary layer, but there's a just a a bandwidth limitation. I would very slow to communicate. So with with with a a neural link you can increase the the communication bandwidth by many orders of magnitude, maybe by a thousand or more.
1:14:13So you're talking about output from the brain to other devices. Yeah. Primarily. Yeah. Not input to the brain. it would be both ways. our input is much less constrained than our output because of vision. So you know I don't know like rough approximation is like our input because of vision is like maybe a million times roughly. Yeah.
1:14:38Some people online are going to argue with this, but it's it's the input to input is many orders of magnitude higher than output because of vision. you know a picture picture says a thousand words and a video says I don't know a hundred thousand words. Like there's just you know there's that's why like a meme can communicate so much more than a few words. Now this is obviously very esoteric and like I'm not sure this will resonate you know with a lot of people like oh we need to increase the the bandwidth between our cortex and our digital tertiary layer by many orders of magnitude in order to not lose symbiosis with digital intelligence.
1:15:22So this is quite esoteric, but but that's the long-term existential risk mitigation of neural link which we may or may not achieve. I'm not saying will achieve this, but it's at least an attempt to solve that. Then along the way, Neuralink can solve a lot of brain issues. Like if you got and so if you got if you got like a a severed spine or something. So like one of like the first application we're looking to solve is implanting Neuralink in someone who has is a quadriplegic or tetraplegic.
1:16:07So like they have no they can't move their arms and legs or maybe not even really move most of their face. They can like maybe blink or something like that, you know, like Stephen Hawking. Or or they didn't have to have severed spine, but like there are various there are various mechanical and other like mechanical breakages or diseases that break the link between your brain and body.
1:16:31And Neuralink can solve that. It can certainly we're confident Neuralink can can enable someone who is a tetraplegic to operate a phone or a computer faster than someone who has hands, working hands. And we've shown this for example with the monkey being able to play video games.
1:16:55They can play a bunch of games, not just Pong. Pong is currently its favorite game. I didn't even know monkeys could play Pong. Yeah, monkeys can play Pong with their hand. Yeah, they're monkeys have good reflexes. So and that that's how that's how the monkey we train the monkey to play Pong with a joystick.
1:17:18And then we we look at the signals that the monkey's brain is sending. And then we read those signals and and then we we transfer the signals directly to the game. And you know, so and then then we take the joystick away. And the just playing basically tele- telepathic mind pong.
1:17:39Wow. That's wild. Yeah. So, I we we we recently got what we think is a world record in bits per second from from any neural neural device. Like we're start we're starting to approach 10 bits per second, which is not actually well not that big, but it's more than anyone else has achieved in a in a useful way. 10 10 like close to 10 useful bits per second is where where we are.
1:18:06And we'll we'll increase that dramatically over time. So, so anyway, so the we're we're we also want to make sure the device is extremely safe and and extremely well tested. our standards go far beyond what is required from a regulatory stand standpoint. And but we're hoping to do our first Neuralink into a human next year.
1:18:32and and like I said enable someone who you know has has almost no no movement capability to operate a phone as faster or or I think we think faster over time than someone who has has working hands. So, I think that that would be quite a significant thing and would help a lot of people.
1:18:58And and there are many such applications. and I'm increasingly confident that we we can implant a second Neuralink device. So, one one that accesses the the motor cortex, the somatosensory cortex, and then a a second one that is passed where the injury is. so if you got severed you know we we basically where where are the neurons still functional?
1:19:25and implant a second Neuralink device and act have the two devices talk to each other and just transfer the signals across the wherever wherever it broke. Yeah, because it's like a broken circuit. So, if you got a broken circuit, you just you you basically just do a signal transfer between the two. And necessarily even need to to know what all those signals are. you just need to transfer the signals.
1:19:53so just like if you have like a an ethernet cable, you don't need to know what's on the ethernet cable for the cable to work. Or or a wireless from one wireless ethernet you know Wi-Fi box to another wireless ethernet Wi-Fi box. You don't need need to know what the contents of the signal are in order to transfer the signal.
1:20:11so I I'm confident that that such a thing is possible. not saying we will do it. otherwise I said unreasonable expectations, but I'm I would say I'm certain that it is possible. and we will try to make it happen, which would then enable people to walk again and use their hands and I think long term probably restore full body functionality to somebody who has none.
1:20:39Did you know that we created an Elon Musk subscription tier at one point on the B? Did you ever see that? No. You didn't know that we did that? We were cuz you had you had pay a lot of money or something? Yeah, you had interacted with us a couple of times and so we were like wooing you as a subscriber, come subscribe. We created our own tier for you. What was the fee on the tier? I don't remember what it was.
1:20:57I think it was like it was the highest our payment processor $9,999 a month or something. But people were signing up for it. People were actually signing up for it though. Every time I would check it would be like is it him? Is it him? It was random people who picked it thinking it was a joke and it was actually charging their credit cards. We had like we had all these angry people like my wife is going to kill me if you don't refund this charge. So, we had to take the Elon Musk tier down. So, we took it down I guess before you could before you could find it.
1:21:22But it was there. We had it there for you. So, yeah. that's a compliment I think. All right. Very eloquently put. Well, shall we land the plane here with the 10 questions? So, we Well, this is podcast started in Kyle's garage. We asked every guest the same ten questions at the end of the interview.
1:21:47We never anticipated we would be asking Elon Musk these ten questions. These are rapid fire so you can answer them as quick as you want. Yeah. Or you can go on forever. Yeah. Your call. have you ever have you ever met Christian rap artist Carmen? I I mean the only Carmen musician I'm aware of is Carmen Miranda.
1:22:15you know she she would like dance with like a like a fruit ball on her head. Yeah. Fruit head. Yeah. And you never met her? No she she died a while ago. All right. Cool. We'll come up. Are you more of a Calvinist or Armenian? Or Armenian? Yeah. Like predestination or free will? like Or you could say determinism versus free will.
1:22:43dichotomy. Yeah The assumption is that he Or or or you're an Armenian? It's The only people that know what an Armenian is are Calvinists. So free will or predestination is the or right no determinism versus free will is kind of the more secular version of that. I guess what my mind would say determinism and my heart says free will.
1:23:14All right. Yeah when I grew up I was funny enough I went to Anglican Sunday School you know Church of England basically and and but but I was also sent to Hebrew preschool although I'm not I'm not Jewish but unless I was singing one day and and Jesus our Lord the next. And you know took that's fine if you're a kid you know and and and Claus and like know
1:23:47So yeah. Yeah, that answers the question. Yeah. So you get to add one book to the Bible. What is it? He never he was never updated these questions to like apply broadly No. at any point. They're unchangeable. Yeah. They're like the Ten Commandments at this point. I mean a little bit lower.
1:24:13I remember we can have a chapter past Revelations. But I like it's sort of a happy ending here like the Revelations part two, the happy ending. Well, you know if there's like a really good book you think everyone should read because it would be in the back of the Bible. Everyone should read this book. Yeah.
1:24:34Okay, how many people have actually read the Bible? Fewer than probably say they have, but Oh yeah. I mean Do you have a favorite book? I I mean at one point I you know when I was a kid I was like I had this existential crisis and I was trying to figure out what's the meaning of life.
1:24:48And I was like oh it all means nothing. It's all and and I and I you know read like a whole bunch of religious books including the Bible and I'm like there's a bunch of things in there that didn't teach me in Sunday school. Sodom and Gomorrah dark. yikes. you know God truly changed his mind from the Old Testament to the New Testament. I'm like whoa.
1:25:12That was pretty vengeful in the Old Testament. What was the question? You get to pick a book to add to the Bible. Yeah. A book The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. Okay. Yeah. Good pick. a great book. Yeah, great book. book. cigars or pipes? you know I'm not sure I've ever really smoked a pipe. my grandfather did.
1:25:34it kind of looks cool. but I have smoked cigars. And I think like you know for a celebratory occasion like cigars and whiskey is a pretty good combo. you get to hang out with any three people, living or dead, who are they? It's always hard to think of like three Yeah. people. Ethan, Kyle, Seth.
1:25:59You're hanging with you got three right here. That's true. Jeff Bezos, I don't necessarily necessarily like I think there's there's a lot of people that would be interesting to talk to. you know I don't know Is it living or dead you said? Yeah. Living or dead. This is this is just you know extremely conscious is not like a carefully thought out answer but it would be like I don't know like Shakespeare, Ben Franklin, maybe Newton or Einstein.
1:26:31Okay. It's a good group. Bunch of white men. Yeah. All drinking White Claws. Cleopatra sounds fun. Whiskey or beer or I guess White Claw. 100% He went right for the whiskey so. Nice. All right. what would be the first thing you would do as president? Well the the presidency in the US is designed to be a weak position or relatively weak position because you know obviously the founders of the of the country did not want to create a monarch. They wanted to avoid like a king situation.
1:27:11so the so the presidency in the US is is is meant to be weak weaker than say a parliamentary system where the majority essentially the speaker of the the house would be the the Prime Minister or president. so you would say like what what what can you do as the president? in the in the US there's a lot of limitations unless you have the support of Congress you obviously cannot change the laws.
1:27:40But I I would I probably aspire to reduce the size of government. and you know and take a look at the regulatory situation and just make sure there's there's good garbage collection of regulations. So if they're updated as there there are many outdated and unnecessary regulations but but you know there's there's a there's a strong forcing function for creating new laws and regulations but a weak forcing function for getting rid of of of of bad laws and regulations.
1:28:17and and and and I think this this is just generally a problem as civilization ages without war where there are new laws and regulations created every year. and so there's like more and more constraints on what you can do but there's there's very little effort put to remove laws and regulations.
1:28:36And so this is like hardening of the arteries of civilization. And eventually it'll be like Gulliver's Travels where you're just tied down by you know thousands of little strings. And and so like any one string is the issue but there's so many strings that you can't get anything done.
1:28:56you know that's why part part of the part of why I moved to Texas is just like there's just pure strings tying you down. Hm. so yeah yeah I think like the the the value of of of someone just being a a a very competent executive officer is is under undervalued in the in the president.
1:29:25just like how good are you at running things and getting things done. Mhm. because if you're the president you're kind of like the CEO of the country. and and and so are you good at doing things? Are you effective and productive? This is very said a CEO is a meaningless title. What does that mean? I'm just curious how that like Well CEO is not not like a a legal title.
1:29:51Okay. I'm just saying that that there there are all these titles in corporations that are that are kind of made up. and you can see what is actually required for a corporation when you fill out the form to create one. And so you need a a president, a secretary, and a treasurer. Same thing as like if you're forming a chess club or a glee club or something like that.
1:30:12Same same thing. and and actually technically all they all three can be the same person. So that's what that's what's legally required. If you don't have those three things, you cannot function as a as a corporation. Everything else like a general counsel, CFO, CEO, these are all made up.
1:30:27Like they they have no legal no no meaningful legal bearing. Sounds cool. So you only need those president, secretary, treasurer. so there's all these like CXO titles which you know just are somewhat like resume inflators. I was just making the point that like people think CEO is a real title, but it's not.
1:30:52It's it's not it's not a legally meaningful title. You need someone who is defined as the as the president or particularly that's that that's that's it. So and now you have like chief marketing officer, chief information officer, chief everything officer, you know. That that's one thing like like you should have like a like chief a chief sorcery officer, you know.
1:31:21So this this is our SVP of sorcery. Raise raise the title. Yeah yeah. Great question number eight. The master general. oh yeah. Have you ever punched anyone or have you ever been punched? You got any cool punching stories? If you don't have an answer for that, we have a follow-up.
1:31:44It's even worse. I don't have cool punching stories, but I where I grew up was extremely violent. I I I never a fight. except with my brother, actually. One exception. I did I did beat my brother up, which I'm I just had I don't know. That's how it goes. We all did. but South Korea was growing up was just an inherently very violent place. I got punched in the face many times.
1:32:16I almost got beaten to death once. So many times. And I think if you have not been punched in the face with a fist, you don't know what you have no idea what it's like. Shocking sensation. Have you been punched, Ethan? Yeah, just by like high school kids. Yeah. It's still it's just like your face never touches anything and then suddenly Yeah.
1:32:40Punch in the nose. Yeah. Like you can't even see straight. so yeah. it's funny that people think words are that they're so sensitive to words. It's like, man, if you've ever been punched in the face, words don't mean nothing. All right, question number nine. You get to go to one concert, any band in history. Who do you go see?
1:33:11Any band in history? Mhm. I don't know. Take your pick. Maybe the Rolling Stones with their, you know when they The Rolling the peak Rolling Stones seems like Band heyday, yeah. Yeah. Big pick. All right, final question to close our time out here. Yeah, I mean we're here. We're you know the Babylon Bee is a Christian organization, you know, and we're a ministry.
1:33:35Well well how come we're doing the show on a Sunday? On a Sunday? Is this Why why aren't you why aren't you a heathen? Why aren't you heathens in church? Exactly. So we have to make it church right now. to be a day of rest. did Zoom church. To justify my idea like God said don't work on Sundays.
1:33:52Okay. Unless you're going to guys you're going straight down to those ones. Can't into the whole Jesus is rest thing. Straight out. This is true. This is true. I So okay, so to make this church, we have to do We have to make sure just We're wondering if you could do us a quick solid and accept Jesus as your Lord and Savior.
1:34:10On the show. Personal Lord and Savior So quick prayer. I mean, let's just say like I agree with the principles that Jesus advocated. and that the You know, there are some some There's great wisdom in what in in the teachings of of Jesus. and I agree with those teachings. and things like turn the other cheek are a very important because as opposed to an eye for an eye.
1:34:50an eye for an eye leaves everyone blind. So forgiveness, you know, is important and treating people as you would wish to be treated. Love thy neighbor as thyself. Very important. So it's like a 60 70% yes? as Einstein would say, I believe in the God of Spinoza. so But hey, if you know, if if if Jesus is is saving people, I mean, I I I wouldn't stand in his way. You know, like they'll be true.
1:35:30I'll be saved. Why not? Sweet. We did it. Yeah. I think he just said yes. We got him. All right. We got him. Yes, we got him. Praise the Lord. Sounds good. You want to get baptized or anything real quick or I was baptized. Oh, okay. Anglican, you know. Yeah. So yeah, he's done. They they dunked They dunked me in the water when I was just a baby.
1:35:48Cool. Second time. I I even had like, you know, whatever the whatever blood and body of Christ which was kind of weird, you know, if you're a little like you get to give you some weird tasting you know, whiskey and and wine. Yeah. And I'm like, what the hell is this? And I'm like, isn't this kind of weird?
1:36:09when he said yes. I'm like, is this some like weird metaphor for cannibalism or something? I I don't get like what what the hell? I remember thinking that was just crazy when I was a kid. and I'm like this to like whoa, you know. I mean even as a metaphor it's kind of odd, you know. So it is and it's like and should we be giving alcohol to minors? I was like We do grape juice. We're better.
1:36:35Okay. I think it's unusual even be thinking about that as a kid. Like as a kid you just go through the motions and it's later on that you think wait a minute. What does this actually represent? What am I doing? No, when I was a kid I was like like is this actually blood and body? What what?
1:36:50You know, I I don't I I don't know if I want to eat somebody. And then I was like, what? This is And then I did it anyway and I'm like this seems like okay man, I don't know if this is just pretty odd, you know. I remember thinking that even at age five. So I was like, you know.
1:37:07And I know I was definitely like you know, Sunday school there like whether it's telling all the stories and I was like asking questions and like they really were upset that I was asking questions. And I was like, you know, how Jesus like fed the crowd with like five loaves of bread and three fish and I'm like how big was the crowd? And and like where did the fish and bread come from?
1:37:29Did like from his cloak or something? Like cuz I was like reading books and and I was like is this like did they materialize? Is it kind of like come out of like I don't know. How where did it come from, you know? Like how did it would you like take a bite of the bread and would just the would the bread would just come back to being a full bread?
1:37:47Yeah, you look away and it just kind of comes back out. They left out the details. Where did the universe come from? well, yeah. I mean I wouldn't say I know all the answers here. I'm just you know, it's just the and and Jesus was obviously very pro alcohol, you know, because one of his miracles was turning water into wine.
1:38:08Mm. Yeah. And then it was like they were having a party. They ran out of wine. And they're like let's keep this bender going. Good stuff. Who who who can who can solve this problem? We're out of wine claws. The freaking stores closed. Jesus is like I got you. Okay. Water, now wine. And like party on.
1:38:30So you know Accurate. Pro partying without alcohol is literally one of the miracle. Bible story time with Elon Musk. You are the It's like you're definitely you're the savior. Kept the party going with lots of wine. That's great. so yeah. Well thank you. I appreciate you coming here and talking with us so very much.
1:38:55You're welcome. It's pleasure to meet you in person and you know we'll we'll continue to throw out the the satire that we hope you'll respond to and you know keep that going a little bit. Oh we didn't ask Onion or the Bee but I guess that was kind of answered earlier. Wasn't it? Yeah. Yes, we already covered that.
1:39:14Yeah. I mean I I think Onion has done some extremely funny stuff over time. it's just it just seems to been you know in recent years somewhat infected by the woke mind virus so that that just makes everything less funny. Yeah. It's woke mind virus is a world without humor. Yeah. I'm hoping Neuralink can solve the woke mind virus issue.
1:39:36Thank you very much. Thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. This was awesome. Thanks so much. All right.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版