播客·中文精读

The Babylon Bee 在 Twitter 总部对话马斯克

The Babylon Bee Talks With Elon Musk at Twitter Headquarters

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2023 年 5 月,旧金山市场街的 Twitter 总部。三个 Babylon Bee(巴比伦蜜蜂,美国一家讽刺新闻网站)的编辑走进会议室,递给马斯克一张纸。那是一张手写欠条,金额 440 亿美元,收款人写着他的名字。

“我会把这份礼物珍藏起来。”(马斯克)

一年多以前,这家网站被 Twitter 永久封禁。理由是拿跨性别议题开了个玩笑,他们拒绝删帖,账号被关。2022 年 11 月马斯克把账号放了回来,2023 年 5 月,他们坐在“敌人的宫殿”里喝威士忌。编辑们自己都觉得荒唐:野蛮人冲破了大门,正在洗劫纪念品。

这场对话里,马斯克把接手 Twitter 之后的账本、代码、动机和恐惧都摊在了桌面上。信息密度很高,值得逐段拆。

接手第一天:一架引擎着火、还在俯冲的飞机

很多人以为马斯克入主 Twitter 是带着剧本来的。他自己给出的版本是:根本不知道现场发生了什么。

第一个麻烦是找人。Twitter 当时几乎全员远程办公,总部大楼是空的,世界各地办公室也是空的。他想找人开会,Zoom 上都凑不齐。他的描述很具体,正常公司你可以走一圈,跟人打招呼、聊天、认识人。Twitter 不行,楼里没人,会议室里也没人。

第二个麻烦是组织结构。交易交割后第一个小时,他让 12 个高管走人。随后一大批人主动辞职。他把当时的组织架构比作“放进微波炉的瑞士奶酪”:全是洞,还化了。

他把整个过程形容成一句很有画面感的话:

像是被瞬间传送到一架正在俯冲的飞机上,引擎着火了,操纵杆还不响应,你得马上把它从俯冲里拉起来。(马斯克)

这中间他还要同时管特斯拉和 SpaceX。他说当时的第一优先级就是“把轮子留在车上”,别让整辆车散架。代码库比外界想象的复杂得多,需要大量照料。当时大批人预测 Twitter 会在某个周末死掉,还有人说世界杯的流量会把它压垮。这些预测一个都没实现。

账本:年收入 45 亿,年成本 45 亿,利息 15 亿

财务是这场访谈里最硬的部分,马斯克没有绕弯子。

Twitter 正常年份大概做 45 亿美元收入,45 亿美元成本。也就是说,它从来就不是一台赚钱机器。按他的说法,Twitter 成立以来累计亏损大于累计盈利,本质上是一家“非常昂贵的非营利组织”。

真正让账本崩掉的是收购本身。收购带来了 125 亿美元债务,光利息一年就要 15 亿美元。一笔在收入 45 亿、成本 45 亿的生意上,硬生生多出来的固定支出。

然后是广告。2023 年 5 月前后开始,整个行业出现广告周期性下滑,Facebook、Google 都在裁员,Twitter 也在同一条船上。更难受的是叠加效应:很多广告主在收购完成后直接把投放按了暂停,理由是对“言论自由”方向不确定,怕品牌受牵连。

两个因素叠在一起,收入几乎腰斩。马斯克给出的数字是:

现金流大约是负 30 亿美元一年,也可能更糟,负 40 亿到 50 亿,很难说底部在哪。账上大概 10 亿美元,也就是说,大约还能活四个月。(马斯克)

他提到 2022 年 12 月卖特斯拉股票,就是为这个做准备。当时不确定 Twitter 到底需要多少钱,得先拿到手。他说现在回头看,这笔卖出“有点后悔”。

到访谈时,情况已经开始转向:接近盈亏平衡,至少飞机进入平飞状态。他用的判断标准很朴素,别坠机就行。工程技术侧改善更明显,他给的说法是:

过去六个月 Twitter 上线的新功能和能力,比过去六年加起来还多。(马斯克)

为什么这个价格也值:所有平台都在齐步走

记者问他,花这么离谱的价钱买一家亏钱的公司,后悔吗?

他的回答很干脆:不后悔,即使价格“高得离谱”。他给出的理由跟财务报表关系不大,跟叙事有关系。

他当时的判断是,几乎所有社交媒体公司、搜索引擎公司,加上传统媒体,都在往同一个方向走。同一个事件、同一套措辞、同一个结论。这种情况下,普通人还能去哪里找真相?如果所有人都在齐步走地重复同一个说法,这个说法本身就已经无法被检验了。

他举了奥巴马的一个采访。奥巴马在 CBS 说,让他夜里睡不着的事,是媒体出现了多元化,不同人有不同叙事,住在不同的现实里。马斯克的解读是:奥巴马怀念的是那个只有一套叙事的“黄金年代”,三个频道讲同一件事,大家都不用争。

他给 X(原 Twitter)定的目标相当克制。他没打算让平台变成真相裁判所,他说的是:

成为互联网上最不虚假的地方。平台上一定会有不真实的东西,但我们希望比任何地方都更接近真实,并且呈现对同一件事的不同视角。(马斯克)

他还补了一句:人本来就有犯错的权利。

社区注释:让互相不同意的人一起同意

访谈里马斯克花了不少时间讲 Community Notes(社区注释)。这是他认为最值得骄傲的产品机制。

核心规则一句话就能说清:一条注释只有在“历史上观点不同的人”都给高分时才会显示。就算某一派系人数极多、另一派只有寥寥几个,只要后者不同意,注释就上不去。靠单一阵营刷票很难奏效,这套设计的门槛卡在“跨立场的共同认可”上。

他称社区注释是“诚实放大器”。一旦被注释过几次,人就会开始谨慎,因为注释是公开的、无法删除的、来自不同立场的人共同认可的。

马斯克自己也被注释过,大概三次。Babylon Bee 没被注释过,编辑开玩笑说因为他们本来就不做真实性声明。马斯克顺势讲了句实话:现在很多真新闻的标题,和讽刺新闻的标题已经无法区分。有人相信假新闻,不能全怪读者。

他也提到社区注释的一个副作用:它正在被当成一种新的公共羞辱工具,比被“ratio”(回复数超过点赞数,一种社交媒体上的公开羞辱)更难受。很多政客、政府官员第一次被注释时非常不适应,他们习惯了单向输出,没习惯被公开纠错。马斯克的原话是:

他们不习惯这种问责。(马斯克)

2012 年的代码幽灵:一个“suck”引发的影子封禁

访谈里最荒诞的一段,是马斯克讲他们上周在代码里挖出来的东西。

他们在代码里发现了一个 2012 年留下的隐藏审查层。里面有一份大约 1000 个词的清单,任何推文只要包含清单里的词,就会被大幅降权。清单里包括“suck”这种词。

有个用户叫 @suck2020,一直觉得自己被影子封禁,找不出原因。查下来发现,就是因为他用户名里有 suck。

同一批被发现的还有一份被压制的 URL 清单。里面有不少明显的诈骗网址,也有 babylonbee.com。

马斯克把这件事形容成考古挖掘:一层一层往下挖,挖完以为到底了,下一周又挖出一层新的。他给 Twitter 代码库下的判断是,需要从地基开始重写,不然永远是在一座闹鬼的宅子里一只一只抓鬼。

他给了一个具体数字:主时间线的混排代码原来是 70 万行,现在压到了 7 万行,只有原来的十分之一,效果反而更好。

言论自由,但不等于触达自由

这部分是整场访谈里最容易被截断传播的观点,值得完整还原。

马斯克说,广告主担心自己的广告出现在什么内容旁边,这个诉求本身是合理的。他举了两个例子:儿童电影的广告不该出现在 NSFW 内容旁边;迪士尼乐园的广告不该出现在乌克兰尸体的报道旁边。这就是所谓的 adjacency controls(相邻内容控制)。

他真正坚持的底线在另一条线上:平台不会因为内容有争议就把它删掉。

他用一句话概括了这套逻辑:有言论自由,但没有触达自由。意思是你可以说,但平台不保证你的内容被大规模推荐。如果大量认证账号标记某条内容有问题,平台就不会给它流量放大。

代价是真实的。他透露,因为有广告主被社区注释,而 Twitter 拒绝撤销这条注释,公司直接损失了大约 4000 万美元广告收入。

我们就是实实在在地丢了 4000 万美元,这个数字不是估算出来的。(马斯克)

他同时反驳了“Twitter 仇恨言论暴涨 2000%”的说法。他的版本是:仇恨言论的浏览量下降了三分之一到一半,同期平台使用量创历史新高。他还顺带吐槽了仇恨言论的定义,曾经有一份清单把“乔治·索罗斯”这个名字本身算作仇恨言论。他说这定义太宽了。

关于广告主,他的判断是大部分已经回来了。他们自己在平台上用了一段时间,发现这里并没有变成仇恨言论的避风港,不确定性消除之后,投放就恢复了。但平台不会在言论自由这条线上让步。

从 Twitter 到 X:钱也是一种信息

访谈后半段,话题转向了 X 的长期愿景。马斯克说,其中一部分是兑现他 24 年前做 x.com 时的想法:做一家综合金融服务提供商。

为什么把支付和金融放进“言论自由”的框架里?他给出的论证是:如果掌握资金流转的人能因为政治立场切断你的账户,那言论自由就是空的。

他举了加拿大卡车司机抗议的例子。参与者被封了账户,等于被从社会里经济性地放逐。他也提到 PayPal 曾以看起来像政治理由的方式冻结账户。

他的核心命题是:钱是一种信息。信息要自由流动,钱也得在合法范围内自由流动。

所以他要把 X 做成一个集合体:文字、图片、视频、实时互动、加密通讯、语音、视频通话、完整的金融服务。到那个阶段,“Twitter”这个名字就不匹配了。这个名字对应的画面是 140 个字符的群发短信,是短内容。X 能容纳任何东西。

访谈里几个人还就 X 玩了个文字游戏:X marks the spot(X 标记宝藏的位置),XXX 是色情内容,X-rated 是限制级。马斯克说了一句更正经的:目标是强化民主的支柱,让文明继续往前。

AI 是黑洞,文明处于晚期

记者问他对文明寿命的看法。马斯克说,他最近看到很多“晚期文明”的迹象。

他把风险分成几层。短期是金融危机之类的经济波动,这种事周期性发生,不算致命。中期是地缘政治,乌克兰和台湾。最上面一层是 AI。

他用了一个很马斯克的比喻:

它叫“奇点”是有原因的。你不知道会发生什么,就像掉进黑洞,进去了会怎样,没人知道。我们正处在 AI 奇点的事件视界上,绕着黑洞转。(马斯克)

有人问他是不是“AI 末日论者”,他给了一个俄罗斯轮盘赌的比喻:好消息是六个弹膛里有五个是空的。

关于监管,他给出的路径分阶段。先成立一个洞察委员会(insight committee),成员包括独立人士和头部公司代表,目标只有一个,先搞清楚发生了什么。然后再跟行业协商,提出规则。他说这套流程在制药、航空、汽车行业都跑通过:只要一件事对公众构成危险,就会有监管机构充当裁判,防止企业偷工减料。

喜剧的本质是揭示一个真相

访谈里有一段关于喜剧的讨论,逻辑非常清楚。

马斯克说,大量喜剧的内核是“被揭示的真相”。观众心里其实知道那个真相,只是平时不说。笑点来自那个突然被点破的、人人默认但不公开承认的事实。

由此推出一个结论:如果你的前提是假的,你就讲不了笑话。因为没有一个真实的落点可以让人接住。

他由此解释为什么很多左派讲不了笑话。聪明程度不是问题,问题是禁区太多。禁区一多,能碰的真相就所剩无几,剩下的只有站队和鼓掌。

他引用了 Joe Rogan 的一个说法:觉醒(woke)本身就好笑,因为那些想法太离谱了。问题是最好笑的东西恰恰不能碰,于是讽刺媒体活了下来,因为有人愿意碰。

他还区分了两个东西:clapter(鼓掌)和 laughter(笑声)。白宫记者协会晚宴上,讲者得到的是掌声,不是笑声。掌声代表认同,笑声代表共鸣,这两件事在机制上完全不同。

他给 Twitter 提了一个产品需求,虽然是玩笑,但说出了真问题:推文里没法表达讽刺,需要一种“讽刺字体”。语气和反讽在纯文本里丢失,是所有社交平台共有的沟通损耗。

最有趣的结果最有可能发生

访谈里最有意思的一段,是马斯克讲他自己的“预测理论”。

他朋友 Jonah 有个说法:最具讽刺意味的解释,往往最可能成立。马斯克在此基础上加了一个自己的变体:

从一个不在局中的第三方视角看,最有趣的结局,最有可能发生。就像看一部外星人拍的肥皂剧。(马斯克)

他用战争片做类比:你坐在电影院里,喝着汽水吃爆米花,看人被炮弹炸飞,你觉得很精彩。对银幕上被炸的人来说,一点都不精彩。“最有趣”是从旁观者视角定义的,当事人拿不到这个视角。

所以他被问到 2024 年大选会怎样时,给出的答案是:按这个理论,最有趣的那个结局会发生。

他也承认自己身处剧中。“Twitter 这件事从外面看非常有趣,从里面看就是地狱。”他说过去六个月是一场大规模的开胸手术,现在趋势是积极的,过程一点都不轻松。

关于游戏、交接和一些不重要但真实的细节

访谈里有些轻松段落,也透露信息。

马斯克没玩过塞尔达。他说自己只玩 PC 游戏,主机上唯一认真玩过的是《光环》(Halo)。他把《光环》的传奇难度战役通关了。早年他打过《雷神之锤》(Quake)竞技赛,队伍在美国第一届有奖金的电竞赛事里拿了第二名,奖金大概 3000 美元。决赛时队里最强的那个人电脑崩了。

他最近通关了《死亡空间》(Dead Space)重制版,评价是“真的吓人”,还说比起看邮件和 Slack,他更愿意玩这个。

关于 CEO 交接,他说还在确定时间,Linda Yaccarino 在 NBC 还有一些义务要处理完,大概一个月左右。交接之后,他继续负责软件开发和公司的“宪法”,也就是言论自由这条核心原则。他明确说 Linda 支持这条原则,而且签了字。

他还讲了一句关于上市公司的观察:Jack Dorsey 说得对,作为一家上市公司,Twitter 没法完成改革。因为不做利润最大化的事,就可能被股东起诉,市场上的做空和诉讼会把公司撕碎。

这场访谈真正的信息量

把整场对话拆完,马斯克的论证可以归纳成三层。

第一层是钱的现实:负 30 亿现金流、10 亿现金、四个月寿命。他承认这是一条“超级痛苦”的赚钱路径,也承认要保证其他投资人回本。

第二层是产品的取舍:社区注释、开源算法、邻接控制、订阅收入。这些机制共同指向一件事:把“真相由谁决定”这个问题,从少数人的编辑部,交给跨立场的用户共识。

第三层是他真正的赌注:如果所有信息渠道都在齐步走,社会就失去了纠错能力。他把 X 定位成那个还允许不一致的地方。这个定位本身不赚钱,这就是他愿意亏钱的理由。

至于这套东西能不能跑通,他自己在访谈里也说了句实话:“我们走着瞧。”

  • 看一个平台的产品哲学,先看它的北极星指标。马斯克把 Twitter 的指标从“用户时长”改成“无后悔用户时间”(unregretted user time),这直接对应他批评 TikTok 的那句话:用户刷完会恨自己。做内容产品的人可以拿这个指标自查,你优化的是停留时长,还是用户停留之后的感受。
  • 社区注释值得当成一个产品模板研究。它的机制核心是“跨立场共识门槛”,投票数只起辅助作用。任何做内容治理、评论排序、事实核查的团队,都可以把这套东西拆开看一遍,尤其是它如何防止单一阵营刷票。
  • 算法透明化会变成合规议题,不只是道德议题。马斯克提出的建议是立法要求社交平台开源推荐算法。这个方向在欧洲的《数字服务法案》里已经有影子,做出海产品的人要提前准备可解释性文档。
  • 创作者变现,先做订阅,再做广告分成。马斯克给出的顺序很清楚:订阅增长“像野火”,广告分成还在写代码。对内容创作者来说,把付费用户抓在自己手里,比等平台分广告钱靠谱得多。
  • 如果你的业务涉及资金流转,把“账户被封”当成一级风险来设计。马斯克做 X 支付的理由来自政治风险,跟商业机会关系不大。做金融科技、跨境支付、创作者打赏的人,都该想清楚:账户被单方面冻结时,用户有没有申诉通道。
  • 代码库的老化是隐形的债务。Twitter 主时间线混排代码从 70 万行压到 7 万行,效果反而更好,同时还挖出 2012 年的隐藏降权逻辑。任何跑了十年以上的系统,都值得做一次“考古式审计”,你永远不知道哪一行老代码还在默默影响今天的业务。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00no white cloth of course you could stare just Devil's first bit of Bud Light there we go that worked do you enjoy seeing Broadway musicals yeah I mean I like it if they don't break into something too often you know elon's on Twitter [Music] he's tweeting about this right now it wasn't until it wasn't until March of . we got kicked out a little snack included you made me buy the company well speaking of we must sound like we need it right there it's the Babylon B at Twitter headquarters oh and Elon Musk is there too

0:48we wanted to give you something actually to restore the liberty of the bee it was very expensive guys this is a gift it's a it's an IOU worth 44 billion dollars so yeah well you know preseason 44 billion won't be with that much anyway that's a good point so I might want to hang on to that one yeah hang on to that one okay that's big one I will treasure this gift but it's seriously crazy to us we come into the Twitter headquarters we were you know banned from Twitter in March 2022 you restored us on a bunch of other accounts in November 2022 and then now we're invited and we get to come here and we weren't even allowed to go into our account you know

1:29absolutely it's like barbarians to storming The Barbarians not really at the gate they're through the gate and pillaging the merch yeah that's what we were doing we're in and we're pillaging the merch okay I want to ask about that so the restoring of accounts yes when you came in so you took over you closed the deal there was the lawsuit there was all that there was the drama we were we were like riding a roller coaster wondering what was actually going to happen because we had no idea if he would ever actually take over the company if we would ever actually get out of Twitter jail because we had vowed to never delete that tweet right so we were watching and just kind

2:11of wondering what's really happening then you finally take over and you go in on day one what are the conversations like take us behind the scenes like what happened behind the scenes where you're talking with the team you're trying to figure out what to do with advertisers and all of that what was the conversation behind the scene around restoring accounts there were a few questions around why it's kind of sink wait where is this thing is the sync still here I think security has it somewhere do they really yeah it's here yeah I've still run into people who don't don't actually do not they ask me why did you walk into lovey with a sink because I didn't understand us yeah

2:50yeah making a pun let that sink in they couldn't help it you know I've I felt like if I showed up with the sink they'd have to let me in right [Laughter] you can't help but let that sink in it's impossible it seems like the perfect Halloween you know costume yeah presuming you want to get into people's houses yeah that's hysterical so you

3:15came in though and you said bring back the Babylon B bring back these accounts like and then there was like pushback right didn't you get pushback internally that's what was reported anyway just going off of what was in the news yeah I mean it was chaos in the beginning I was trying to figure out you know how to run this place and what was going on and very difficult when the whole company works from home so you know it's like who do you even Zoom with you know right like I don't know it's like normally you could walk around introduce yourself to people and have conversations but Twitter gone to almost fully work from home so this building was empty

4:00and Twitter followings around the world were empty so it was just very difficult actually just trying to understand what was going on I would say it like the analogy it would be like being teleported into a plane that's in a nosedive with engines on fire and the controls don't work and you gotta take it out of the nose now yeah yeah you gotta click reconnect the controls you know like who's what's what's the over structure what's the management team because unlike literally the hour one of the thing closing I exited the you know 12 people the company and then then a whole bunch of people also quit so it was like you know organizational structures like

4:42Swiss like swiss cheese that you put in the microwave yeah it was like full of hills and melted how's your Twitter feed if I need to be better these days or what well I only use the following tab because to me that's what I always wanted social media to be was just everybody I follow in order exactly the order that's posted so the 4u is more you know the algorithm driven stuff yeah but I think you should try the for you try it out yeah and I use it predominantly and I I might time on the app is insane because I just there's it's feeding me so much stuff you know like stuff I'm watching like crazy fight scenes

5:24like no context humans or CCTV videos exactly yes uncensored video I'm getting drawn into these things you know the CCTV stuff yeah I think it's it's good I mean I'm seeing a mix of opinions too I'm seeing people that I disagree with pop up that I don't follow that's good which a lot of people object to right they don't want to see that they only want to see people that they that they agree with yeah well well the system actually does take into account your interactions so if basically if somebody if you argue with someone else it'll assume that you want you want you like arguing right which probably maybe someone secretly does actually like arguing they don't want to

6:02admit it but they actually like it it's like that Monty Python sketch you know if you've ever seen that one where I'm here for an argument yeah for an argument you accidentally goes into the insults room first abuse [Laughter] so if if if One account argues with another account but algorithm will assume that that's what you want you want you want more of more arguments or more of that you know because you chose your time to spend your time that way so it will actually then show you content that that other content you might want to interact with but I think that over time the recommended for you tweets should be extremely compelling I suspect

6:46that you'd probably want 80 20 recommended versus following because it'll also put it'll the most compelling tweets from your followers are also in for you so so skip the boring ones that people pretty much yeah and go right to the good stuff I mean there's some casts that I follow that tweet you know 20 times right a day or more so it tends to fill up the following

7:14but you know and you if you'd want like say the best of the people that you follow should be in for you or something's wrong but the antennas to maximize unregretted user time so that's that's a I best I think the the Metro that's the metric I've got the whole organization focused on is unregretted user time I mean so because I frequently hear someone said tell me they spent a lot of time on Tick Tock but they they kind of hate themselves afterwards and so that's how cool that you know regretted user time and

7:54you know so if we can we wanted to do that you spent the time on on X Twitter and you're glad you did like you were informed and entertained and I do I think get more laughs from Twitter per day than everything else combined frankly yeah because everybody's moving towards algorithm Facebook's algorithm and YouTube's all algorithm driven Tick Tock so what's Twitter doing differently that's getting you that unregretted user time compared with these other apps well I guess it matters where content is on on a system to be recommended in the first place okay so you know Tick Tock has a lot of teen dance videos so clearly it's a popular topic

8:41Twitter is more of you know intellectual debates and you know learning things humor and and humorous it's it's a much more a variety of a variety show but but includes you know serious information and the brand breaking news so you know if it's what it matters that what even if you had identical there were identical algorithms between Facebook and and Twitter if Twitter's content is better or more interesting in that way you still prefer Twitter and and as as you've seen we've open sourced the algorithm and made at this point I think well over 100 changes based on user feedback but how will we stay informed if NPR isn't there anymore you know at any given point I'm not sure

9:32if NPR is there or not I I wasn't aware that they were there until they said they were not going to do that that's how it was with Jim Carrey when I found out Jim Carrey was leaving Twitter I'm like I didn't know Jim Carrey was on Twitter yeah and maybe he's back I don't know love to find out I mean we're trying to apply the rules consistently at Twitter so that you know the NPR thing is like well if we're gonna call some media State Affiliated we'll there's plenty of main organizations in the US that are or in the west that are State Affiliated so then we should apply the label equally and then they get very upset about that and said that there will stay

10:19Affiliated implies that the state has editorial authority of an influence over the content and like so you're saying you don't have that right all right how software are you you know it was on their website well yeah I mean they they well NPR are literally on their own exactly on their own website said you know Government funding is essential to their operation right and so we even changed it from State Affiliated to state-funded so that's just literally a statement of fact right I mean we could actually just lift the same text from their website and put it at the label and but they're still there and they're unhappy with that yeah they're unhappy

11:00with that it gives the wrong impression the true impression well I mean I think they're going to pull their punches in critiquing the government at NPR that's just a guess you know based on their extreme dependence on Government funding I mean you don't generally bite down that feeds you let's real quick though back to the when you came into Twitter okay so the plane is going down and you and you're at the controls and trying to save it so you're doing all these things but you also did want to restore band accounts yeah and so like the trust and safety team and everybody was were they arguing with you about that pushing back on that or was it primarily Advertiser so we're

11:35giving you the most pressure and saying if you restore all these accounts we're pulling our ads what was happening there with pressure you were getting well I mean it was just a totally chaotic situation because it's still going to run Tesla SpaceX while trying to figure out anything about how Twitter runs you know where you know I actually Exodus the top four people in the first hour and then there were a ton of others that either got exited or quit so I was really just trying to keep the wheels on the bus is the top priority Twitter code base is very it's actually much more complex than you think and it's not something that just works you know it requires a lot of care

12:19and feeding and there were many people who predicted that the service would go down and would Twitter Twitter's not going to exist after this weekend there was a whole world cup was going to kill it right because yeah I was gonna be a Crush by the World Cup right a number of predictions that Twitter is about to die were ridiculous I mean we can just go like almost farcical frankly yeah it's like but but it was still they didn't they did kind of have a point in that it wasn't super easy to keep things running there are so many sshr corners of the Twitter software and the system operations that make it hard to you know it's hard it's hard to keep

12:59running it's not it's not can emphasize that enough it's not a you know so like some app on the phone that just works it's a super complicated thing financially it was a very tough situation because Twitter in a normal year would do probably four and a half billion dollars in Revenue four and a half billion in cost so it's a it you know it's they'd probably lose a little bit money because I you know so I called a really expensive non-profit because Twitter is of course lifetime I believe negative on on profitability like it's lost more money than it's made but because the higher price the acquisition which is very foolish foolishly high on my vibe

13:46there's 12 and a half million dollars of debt and Debt Service saying is a billion and a half so and then there's a cyclic decline in advertising that seems to start maybe around May of this year but was pretty significant that's what you saw Facebook and Google and others also do some layoffs as a result so there's a cyclist decline in advertising and then a pretty major pause in advertising where advertisers weren't they just put their their campaigns on pause they didn't definitively say no I mean a few cases they didn't but most men in response to you taking over and processing free speech like oh we don't want free speech Yes well it's more

14:30like they are worried about something that would affect their brand I suppose although it seems like sometimes they worry about the wrong things yeah yeah the things they should be worried they should be worried about some things and they aren't and aren't worried about other things and should be but not nonetheless there were a lot of the advertisers put their advertising on pause they kind of like see where things go and that causes about a it's almost 50 reduction in Revenue immediately so so in rough terms we're doing about negative three billion dollars a year in cash flow and possibly training to do worse than that possibly four or five it's hard to tell

15:22where the bottom was and a billion dollars in the bank so hold roughly four months to live what were the options if you got if you ran out like you would have to continue to fund it you'd have to seek funding from outside yeah I mean it's limited you know how how much tells the stock I can sell and I can't sell it all the time I mean the reason I sold stock in December last year was which I regret at this point was because I wasn't sure how much money Twitter would need I thought you know I might just the you know in October it was a six million

15:56six billion dollar cash burn and and we don't know where revenue is going to bottom out I have to get the company to financial stability which we I think more we're close to financial stability roughly not quite Break Even but close to it and I think trending positively you know I think I think it's it's at least the planes in level flight the engine of engineering software engineering is is in much better shape I think we've deployed more Futures and capabilities in the last six months than Twitter has done in the last six years so whether 25 as a team that's crazy yeah

16:36do you do you feel like it was worth it I mean do you ever regret it and go why did I do this thing just to make a stand for free speech or I think it was necessary and I I wouldn't say that there's anything that's in retrospective caused me to like I think it was still the right move to acquire Twitter even at the outrageously high price

17:02yeah I think it's gonna turn out to be important well the price wasn't just Financial either it's like no I mean this is a I mean I should say like you know I do there were there are other investors besides me and and Twitter you know I'm the majority owner but I have to I want to make sure that those who invested with me do not suffer losses so I'll make sure that the ultimate outcome is better than their original investment but it so I want to be capable of us you know so it's it's but but certainly getting this will be this is a hard way to get richer that's for sure this is this is the Mega pain way to make money there's a lot of pressure on whoever's running

17:48Federal you know to do this or that on the platform as you might imagine at any given point someone you know someone powerful is unhappy basically so anyway but I I think it was it was still important to do and I because the the you're pretty much all of the social media companies and the search companies were acting in unison and along with Legacy Media so it was just where do you find you know actually where do you find the truth and you know if everyone is in lockstep with a lie well you just did you see Obama's comments recently in a CBS interview I think it was CBS where he was talking about how the thing that keeps him up at night is how the media there's like diversity in

18:48the media now and there didn't used to be and so now you have different narratives and people basically inhabiting different realities and that's the thing that's like keeping him up at night is like the big problem that we face right now he wanted to go back to the Glory Days yeah there was one narrative the media was unified three different channels all telling you this so you disagree you're telling us you disagree well I haven't seen the full video so it's possible there may be some contextual elements that mitigate Community notes will help us with that one yeah curious is being pretty good yeah I'm watching it closely to make sure because the as Community knows

19:22gains credibility the the value of gaming it increases so we're going to make sure that it is as ungameable as possible I mean the you may know this but the the I mean the essential idea behind Community notes is that a note is only shown if it is rated highly by people who historically have different opinions so where where do people who would normally disagree agree yeah and so even if there's a lot of people from say like one political point of view or doesn't have to be political but one point of view and it's only a small amount of number from another political point of view it they still have to agree you can't just Brigade the thing with

20:12with one ideology I think the value in community notes goes so far beyond just like fact checking though it's it's actually entertaining when somebody gets noted it's like it's better than getting ratioed it's it's it's awesome it is awesome yeah the human value of some of the hypnosis yeah and I think it's it important Checkers get noted it's like it's so ironic you know it's beautiful well we have so much experience with fact checking because we were getting fact checked by Snopes all the time for our jokes you know but that was just one blue-haired lady or something getting mad at one of our jokes and it's so much more powerful when it's like you said

20:52people that disagree yeah the community coming coming together to fact check something and yeah I mean the ones that I see are they're solid it's like rare to see a wrong one so and anyone can can get a community noted including me obviously as well as advertisers and and presence of countries and whatnot so I think once you get noted a few times you it's and honesty amplifier

21:23you know so well they're not used to it people they're not used to it yeah yeah people that are on the left or just in their own Echo chamber government leaders they're not used to that kind of accountability they're not I think it definitely comes as a surprise when they get a community notifications the first time have you been noted how many times have you been noted on I'm not sure right maybe three times I don't know I've never been Community noted I don't think Babylon B hasn't been Community not yet I was wondering about that if we're if we're gonna get like marked like this with satire if people believed it was true or something like

21:54that but it hasn't happened no we don't make any truth claims really right I mean so I don't know that was the weird thing about the fact checks yeah people believe it sometimes they can't tell if it's real I can't blame them or I I can't or some of these articles are I can't tell it I mean I can tell that it doesn't have a b logo on it but but the actual text of the headline is indistinguishable from the you know peace so it's very very common at this point it's a crazy world we're living yeah that's why I don't blame people when when someone says that they you know they make fun of people who think that satire is true I'm like I don't you know it's the real the real

22:32headlines are so satirical in nature they seem like a parody so if you believe a b article it's just yeah that naturally is going to happen so you want to see you know like you see some of these things where it's like free speech is bad from free speech so you know if there was like one headline to that effect yeah yeah wait is this is a Santa or real yeah I don't know okay you know whatever New York Times had like critical thinking is bad for our democracy or something I remember that I'm like what are you talking about that's insane there's a lot of those there's a lot of those but you want to see Twitter be a place where truth prevails through debate right

23:14where people actually go back and forth rather than you having somebody from the top down deciding this is what's true and this is what everybody needs to believe and in lockstep unison putting that out there and silencing it and stamping on everybody else yeah so we definitely want devotion narratives it doesn't mean they have to be you know that that people need to get get violent about it or anything but I think you want to have a Marketplace of ideas where people you know have different viewpoints they argue the viewpoints and maybe some minds are changed along the way so you know this there's both it's also it's the narrative true and who's

24:00choosing the narrative who's choosing narrative is a bigger deal than you know is the article is everything the article accurate because there's a lot of things you can write about on Earth why write about that thing yeah so yeah so the aspiration here for X Twitter is to be article the least the least untruthful place on the internet like we should acknowledge that there will be things that are untrue on the platform but we'd like to be the least untrue of any place and people have a right to be wrong anyway they have right be wrong you know but I think we're succeeding if if it's if Twitter is the place where you can get the most accurate the

24:43closest to the truth and different perspectives on the truth to agree that to agree that it's subjective that's that's the goal pretty straightforward and Elon even thinks that he has the right to share his opinion yeah who has the audacity which we found out the audacity to share your own opinions I was thinking the opposite so in this this is a reference to the interview that you had recently with CNBC and and you were asked why you tweet certain things why do you why do you share that publicly why do you share it widely why don't you why don't you keep it in the question if they're like sources Magneto yeah yes sorry Magneto things like that I

25:21shouldn't have said that it's unfair to Magneto it's unfair to Magneto exactly I my mind goes the opposite direction I'm like what's in your unsent drafts I want to know what you're holding back we promise we won't publish this yeah yeah we'll turn the cameras on I I probably there have been a few cases where I you know if if this tweet if I still want to send this tweet in the morning yeah I will do so and they've been a few cases where I should have done so that would have saved a lot of grief so there was some truth that like a good friend of mine said you know not gonna suggest that I stopped tweeting but but you might want to consider saving it as draft and

26:07seeing if you want to tweet it in the morning yeah that's good advice that should be a Bible verse yeah I think like Lincoln did something where he he used to write these like Angry letters to people and then he came to the conclusion that it really wasn't doing any good and so he'd write the angry angry letter and then see if you wanted to mail it the next day yeah right I believe that was and then he almost never mailed it I mean you don't write angry tweets

26:35sometimes not my treats are seen as angry when they're not so it's difficult to convey tone you know sarcasm in a tweet we need that sarcasm font that's a feature there yeah Twitter you seem kind of what is a sarcasm point I don't know we gotta make it up man oh it's like the SpongeBob it's the you know the capital letters and the capital yet letter everything yeah make a sarcasm font on Twitter and we can use it okay you seem taken back by that question though like I'm sorry like how would you visually show that something a sock has oh yeah I don't know there's no way to do that you need a disclaimer

27:19he's thinking about it he's now he's calculated now it's no problem you can animate the font yeah in a sarcastic way sarcastic animation [Laughter] can't you tell we've lost him now he's just trying to solve this problem you call that animation of course not a sarcastic animation seeing a lot of people who are saying they want to put their video on Twitter now they can't Tucker Carlson is going to do his show on Twitter right and that wasn't like a deal you worked out you said it wasn't there's no deal at all and I I you recommended it to Don Lemon too did he respond did he say he's gonna do it I don't know I actually haven't looked it up but I in general I

28:01think it would be cool yeah yeah so I mean he he you know we did talk and he just asked me like if he does something on Twitter will we censor it and I was like well no we you know we believe in like the first amendment and second moment too for protecting the question Amendment amen exactly amen so you just want to confirm that like you know we wouldn't sort of like suspend his account or whatever and I said well as long as it's like as long as a it's lawful and then then we will not to spend the account so that was enough for him to say this is yeah just what you want to confirm you want to confirm that you know is the free speech he wasn't concerned about

28:53monetization we want monetization that's how can we make money I think is actually in a pretty good financial position he's not like you know struggling to pay the mortgage so no so I mean I did say like that we've got the subscriptions thing and that we will be also sharing ad Revenue with creators kind of normal stuff really you know in order for someone to put their video on Twitter as well as say YouTube then they need to at least you know make money on that like equivalent amount of money or maybe more on Twitter ideally yeah because we make we make about 27 a month on Facebook video nice YouTube's only a little bit better are you serious we don't make much on

29:41Facebook's it's very very little yeah basically it's really bad on the monetization yeah YouTube's a little bit better but still not nothing nowhere near the number of views you're getting you know you'll get millions and millions of views especially on these shorts videos and they throw pennies your way so what is the plan for Twitter video monetization for users well we also have subscriptions and I yeah subscribe to the video course thank you you're welcome can you look at that camera and say subscribe to the Bell subscribe to The Babylon video you won't regret it so are the interviews done we got what we needed so we got subscriptions obviously

30:19we're also gonna be surfacing tweets that are subscription tweets where you see the first line we saw that singing it already yeah yeah so that's going to be really a big deal for a growing subscriber base because people want to kind of see like what is the Tweet you know right so we'll keep like you know providing penalizing content that that is for subscribers only you know I think it'll take a moment for users to get used to it but the the rate of growth of subscriptions is crazy like

30:50yeah I mean I've never this is the fastest I've seen anything grow it's like wildfire so I think it's gonna be good so the subscriptions and then there's a share of advertisement Revenue and we just really need to complete writing the software for figuring out like what what ads were associated with what content and then figure out like you know some reasonable Revenue share and from the date that I said we would you know compensate creators we will back data to that and send people rejects so with the advertisers are the advertisers that paused back for the most part are you continually see problems with him being concerned about your free speech stance and the new hire

31:43that you have coming in as CEO is she going to be addressing some of those issues and trying to work with advertisers to make sure that they feel comfortable on the platform but then also how do you balance that with a commitment to free speech that's kind of yeah so I mean I think it's reasonable for an Advertiser to decide what what what what content they appear next to you know we'll make sure that that their ad doesn't appear next to something controversial or what do they make whatever they consider controversial you know so I mean something is fairly obvious like you don't want say a kids movie showing up next to some racy content of some kind like you know

32:23NSFW stuff [Music] or you know come visit Disneyland next to dead bodies in Ukraine you know it's like that's that's reasonable to have these adjacency controls just like you know advertisers could pick a particular time of day to advertise if they're going to advertise you know up up through I don't know where it was eight or nine PM versus like you know midnight average but it's going to be different so you know just we have we have those controls in place with advertisers and we said like look this freedom of speech but not freedom of reach necessarily so it's like if somebody remember be careful what that that doesn't become dystopian but

33:13people can basically say what they want to say but if if a lot of verified accounts flag it as you know questionable content then it will not get Amplified so we're doing it like so we need you need to make sure this doesn't have bad effects this new hire though there's been people you made kind of both sides mad about it right you got people on the left for their reasons you know people on the right who are mad for their reasons you seem satisfied with that outcome because it means that you know if you've got people on the fringes on both sides upset then you're doing something right right yeah but when it comes to the lgbtq and Q and on right

33:51simultaneously upset I was thinking that's why I think you know things go full circle lgbtq and on you could probably get me in trouble if you like well probably will you were saying you're saying you you want to speak your mind even if it costs you something you want to be able to say what you want even if it costs you something you said that very emphatically in that interview you just did sure and so that matters to you a lot and that in in so in a context where you've got like a new CEO coming in who's gonna be taking over and you want everybody else to have that same freedom to be able to say what they want even if it costs them something

34:31personally in their lives or whatever to have that freedom it would seem to me that the number one thing you'd be looking for is someone who's going to come in and be as committed to free speech As You Are that Trump's even advertising Revenue in your view if you're willing to lose money to be able to personally speak freely then yeah we've also lost money advertising money because some advertisers have got community noted right and we wouldn't take the community note down right 40 million dollars in advertising because of that because the big ones pulled out because of community you know it's right and refusing to pull Community notes that was a willingness to lose money

35:10yes we literally just lost 40 million dollars it's not it's not out of approximation will things change along those lines whether will there be more willingness to compromise to keep the revenue to keep coming in from these big advertisers is that a concern of yours no I think I think we've actually largely addressed the concerns the advertisers a lot of them like weren't necessarily against me taking over Twitter they just weren't sure what it would look like you know is it you know is it are there sharks in the water or what you know is there going to be rampant disinformation is it going to be some like massive right-wing takeover or what so they're

35:53just like uncertain and I think we're getting to the point here where they're like you know and a lot of them use Twitter every day and it's like it's actually obviously it's obviously not filled with hate speech like anyone who uses it knows that well the media keeps trying to say that they keep publishing these articles that they hate speeches on the rise hates two thousand percent yeah it's completely false the view counts are down by a third maybe a half and that's despite usage of the you know all-time record usage or Twitter and how do they Define hate speech is a is a big question mark well to that one of the ways that one of the hate speech terms

36:30was literally George Soros his name yes just saying it we counted as a hate speech thing so I thought well you know maybe the difference is a little broad yeah I'm calling him Magneto is considered hate I mean you know it's like it's not love it's a comic book you know it's like let's relax you know it's not the end of the world here does that make you Professor X or who's Professor X in this [Laughter] well well I do know a lot of smart people I I think we'll be fine like I think the advertisers at this point are comfortable with the fact that Twitter is gonna be you know fair and and and not sort of a Haven of hate type of thing and they've they've used it enough time

37:25for themselves at this point to like they know that from their usage it's actually fine we've vastly reduced the amount of spam and scam stuff that happens on Twitter it's quite rare at this point to see spammers whereas Mike videos be filled with them before I think we can we're not gonna make all advertisers happy but I think we'll make most of them happy and they'd be enough that are happy that support the you know this platform but we're not gonna compromise on Free Speech well it's you see Twitter as more than social media you know you've got X and the everything and and yeah what is the Future Vision for them you know some of that will be fulfillment of

38:11the vision I had for x.com 24 years ago which was you know to be it only comes in financial services provider and you know that's actually an important part of freedom of Freedom as well if if those doing you know the money exchange or running the money system can stop people who disagree with them athletically that's a huge problem I mean so that happened in Canada with the trucker strike where people bring like basically financially ostracized from society or for just protect you know being in a peaceful strike and you know I saw some some strange things with with PayPal where they were like suspending accounts that they what appeared to be political reasons

39:08I don't know if you saw any of that yeah yeah so like you know if like so that's the freedom of your information that's it but money is a form of information so I think it's important that we have have a within the within the balance of the law that we enable freedom of flow of money which is the form of information and you see that living on Twitter eventually yeah yeah I think we need to broaden The Branding yeah like Twitter makes that made sense as a name you know if people are sending you know texts basically group text at 140 characters a piece between each other that's that's kind of a short thing I tweet you know not a long thing

39:58but the point of which you've got not just text but pictures video live interaction you know a full array of financial services a full array of communications encrypted Communications voice video Everything Twitter I think is the wrong branding for that it works I believe in descriptive writing so whereas X is is kind of can excavate anything so x mark you know x mark is a spot X is where the treasure is XXX is where the porn is we're Christians said we wouldn't know

40:45X-rated but I think you know a general the goal here is like look let's just make sure we take that the actions that strengthen the pillars of democracy and further civilization you know we want to have a future we can look forward to that we're excited that we're excited about the future not one we're sad about it so and the civilization is more fragile Than People realize if you study the rise and fall of civilizations in history you know when they're at the top they never think they're gonna fall but they always do eventually yeah every every civilization has a lifespan about how many years do you think we got left well I'm seeing a lot of late stage

41:35civilization Vibes these days seriously I don't know man there's so many wild cards I mean the short term we've got with the financial crisis probably some economic thing but whatever those things happen from time to time but we've got you know some geological geopolitical wild wild cards with Ukraine and Taiwan and and then AI which is you know called this it doesn't it's called The Singularity for a reason like because you don't know what's going to happen it's like a black hole you go in the black hole what happens I don't know we're on the we're on the singularity AI Singularity Event Horizon circling the black hole well and does AI concern you more than

42:43those other things like geopolitical nuclear war or whatever and where does that evolve on the scale for you I know you've said some cautionary things about it but I don't know if you're like as much of a Doomer as some people are about AI I mean the good news about Russian Roulette is five of the barrels are unloaded that's encouraging yeah that's good [Laughter] look on the right side yeah it just seems like a lot of times people that are in Tech are pushing these things forward without any guard rails or consideration you know for what could go wrong despite all the cautionary deals what is right that's what sci-fi is all about you know that's

43:25why there should be regulation and stuff like that right but what does that look like how do you regulate AI for example well I think you start off with a an Insight committee that has you know people that are independent from the leading players as well as maybe some Representatives representatives from the leading players and that's the inside committee the goal is simply to learn things and then consult with industry and propose rules that's basically how it's worked for Putin drug or for aircraft or cars yeah

44:03so is that when that when there's something that is a danger to the public there's some regulatory body to kind of like a referee make sure companies don't cut corners and stuff when it comes to just coming back to speech real quick and Twitter I've often wondered in our case with you you know we had a situation where this benevolent billionaire comes in and decides I'm gonna make sure Free Speech exists for people because there's no place where they can speak freely right now so I'm gonna I'm gonna buy Twitter and restore free speech on this platform great we're glad that you did that thank you but should we have to rely on benevolent billionaires to solve these problems for

44:42us or should there be legal changes should there be like right now the law currently protects us from government censorship obviously right well the first amendment does that but it doesn't protect us from private companies that want to muzzle our speech so should there be legal changes that prevent Viewpoint discrimination and do you do you support laws like that are you aware of some of the the legal the current bills like in different states that are that are being pushed along those lines strawberries bills I mean we have to be careful that that the bill that is intended to good do good does not pave the road to hell so

45:21I think so something I think would be very powerful is so that all social media companies have to open source their algorithms so that if so at least it's known what they're suppressing and they can't secretly suppress things right there's a massive amount of secret suppression going on Facebook Google Instagram massive it's just non-stop secret suppression and there was a Twitter and yeah absolutely but not anymore right right it was a people called Shadow Banning yeah correctly it's like there's nothing okay there's nothing it says that you're banned or but you're you're you're you're you are effectively you know stuck in the basement well that would be a legal change that

46:06would be a law that requires open source that if you're gonna censor you better do it transparently yeah yeah the things that people it really doesn't take much to sort of sense or something so there's a lot of censorship that goes on Google and people don't realize because all that needs to happen is just move just move that link to page five right you know I mean the thing about the little joke about Google is like what's the best place to hide a dead body well the second page of Google search results right and nobody ever looks there so you if you just nudge something to page even page two it's going to drop the visibility by 100. but if you

46:43apply that to the principle of freedom of speech but not of reach isn't that the same thing is there a difference potentially yeah that's why that's where you're saying there's you got to be careful with how you handle that yeah well one of the craziest things you did when you took over Twitter was start releasing the Twitter files which yeah like who takes over a company and then says look how horrible all this stuff is going on we need to have like Truth and Reconciliation here yeah you know so if we're not going to expose the things that were done wrong why should we will believe us in the future so the you know that's why like we're trying to be as transparent as possible

47:16so it's like don't take my word for it literally look at the algorithm you should be able to recreate the results that you see on Twitter with you know using that algorithm so and we're trying to try to make sure that that everything is brought to light not just it says no no hidden layers or anything we just discovered a you know last week a hit like some hidden layer of censorship that was written in 2012.

47:44the wrong word it would it would basically suppress it had like a list of words and any of those words some of them were like like suck if you put suck just as you see K actually even with other words it it gets massively deamplified and that was searching a code from like 2012. it was not about we found this like Relic of code last week and it was being applied to like all tweets yeah wow so there's like the guy that's bought a flight on Starship in Japan is

48:24his name is his you Twitter handles you suck 2020. it was like listen there's something wrong with my account you know I think I'm Shadow band yeah yeah and sure enough it's because his Twitter handle had suck in it so anyway it turned out there's there was about a a thousand words from some ancient list that was were tweets were being suppressed and then we just found a list of URLs that are being suppressed you know some of them are like not obviously renowned scammer URLs but but some of them aren't like babylonbee.com yeah [Laughter] so this is the like it's like an archaeological dig frankly you know you talk a lot about wokeness and the woke mind virus and all that was

49:22is it do you feel like that's what was driving those kinds of decisions here or yeah absolutely yeah we're it's like you know around here it's not about whether you have the you know had some of the work Kool-Aid you're swimming in the world Kool-Aid it's like you know it's like a fish doesn't see the water or swimming in it right it'll it just seems normal like if you're in the cold it's normal the the things like there's actually so much material like there's a God knows how many lines of slack for example yeah this company ran on ran on slack so it was like one massive group text situation so it's a lot of material not that many emails emails mostly

50:09before people coming from outside you know outside Communications and then there was that weird government portal that destroyed everything after two weeks which doesn't sound legal but yeah I thought it was amazing how you were from day one basically handling customer service yeah you were like personally looking at purports from people trying to dig into things yeah and that was like around the clock for you for a little while I mean yeah the sheer layers the the like this is a termacy of basically so many layers

50:49I mean really the there needs to be a ground up rewrite you know otherwise we're like going through like this ghost mansion you know trying to get the ghost out one at a time but still finding ghosts as recently as last week so but but we are actually slimming down the code base we are rewriting a lot of it the main sort of Home timeline mixer was

51:24700 100 000 lines of code now at seventy thousand so it's down by a factor of ten and does a better job and his pastor so and that's the side of the business you're going to stay involved in and personally invested in is the tech side yeah yeah I mean I'm setting the overall ground rules and like the Constitution type of thing which is you know very clearly free speech and and and that will that is that is not a revenue optimizing strategy so but we don't need to make a ton of money we just need to not go back up so

52:08that's part of the reason for having some amount of subscription Revenue it says not you know we respect the advertisers but we don't want to be too dependent on them not go bankrupt that's the business that's the end goal you know hopefully make at least some reasonable return for investors but it's not like you know it's it's not like just to some sort of Mercantile optimization so do you think it's possible to run a free speech platform that is profitable we're gonna find out so I think so I mean like I'm not sure like you can definitely sell your soul to the devil here and and increase Revenue that's for sure yeah so that you know that's and I think it

52:57becomes tough especially for a publicly traded company you can be sued for not you know taking the actions that maximize profitability so you know you know Jack was right that it was impossible to reform as a public company because you you just get excoriated in the market and have a zillion lawsuits anyway so it's like I I'm hopeful the platform can be like I said the the least untrue closest to close to closest to true and complete you know that it's gonna be you know probably the whole truth probably not nothing but the truth because there'll be some things that aren't true but but the whole but but diversity diversity of perspectives so and a diversity of narratives

53:48so people you know can decide what they want to focus on and not reinforce their things also recommend a Twitter Twitter lists are actually pretty great yeah you know so and we're now it made it easy to find like lists created by experts on various subjects so that's another way to stay you know stay informed on on any subject whether it's sports or politics or video games or whatever how worried are you about Mastodon and a tribal well once I tried using them I was like it's not gonna be it's not a threat that was my conclusion most importantly you brought up video games have you played the new Zelda game yet is it good is it great it is you know I've never played a Zelda games

54:43you haven't wow surprising I I only with lyrics I've only I played Just PC games it's all done on PC Nintendo only not legally okay Halo was the only game that I ever played on a console okay what are you playing right now I'm actually looking for something good to play so I finished Dead Space which is the Dead Space remake is really good is it yeah I heard it was will because it woke the Dead Space where you make I would not not look okay no I mean it's it's literally trying to make things as scary as possible it's like as it's maximizing fear yeah it's gruesome I played the original I haven't played the Remake so no it's it's it's gruesome yeah

55:41ha I mean it's it's a it's like it's my really the stuff of nightmares yet I I prefer doing that than email [Laughter] or Slack are you on the side channels do you go in there I don't use slack because there's just there's too much too much yeah exactly it's like being in a million group chats did space not as terrifying as a group chat I like it yeah better than email yeah better than email

56:26the horse say at least you play first person you played Halo did you ever play multiplayer or did you just do the campaign well this there's the recent one which is I I finished I you know to brag a little I did I completed the campaign on legendary wow all right which is hard thank you I mean that last battle was really difficult

56:58but you don't go online and play against random people on the on the internet just multiplayer like Team Deathmatch no well I I did I did that for a split second with friend it's it's tough so I actually trying to ask if you'll be his friend on Xbox I'm just wondering if every now and then I'm maybe playing against you under some I used to play a lot of video games a lot of competitive games so way back in the day I it's quite I was quite competitive at Quake and my sort of team of four I was the second best guy in the team we came second in the first I would I think was the first paid e-games tournament in the US that's where you got your money your start yeah

57:46I think I think we got like three thousand dollars or something we need Community notes it wasn't the emerald mines it was a quake tournament we need Community notes to fact check this this claim yeah it was so yeah we were actually we almost won but the the guy who's the best on the team Brandon Spikes he he has his computer crashed so we came second instead we still got yeah money and stuff anyway I've made money playing video games that's amazing yeah I have not so yeah these days I kind of like a campaign with a with a good story it's it's hard to match reflexes with like you know 16 year olds yeah there's got to be some strategy element to it

58:31they're always saying mean things about your mom and stuff on there kind of yeah I have some friends to play League of Legends oh yeah they're pretty mean in those communities yeah they are toxic they call it toxic Community yeah league is intense yeah league is a lifestyle yeah one of those lifestyle games yeah like I think my son Griffin put more time in the league than he doesn't did into his college applications I mean if he was awake at like five in the morning that's like he's playing league so

59:09yeah I'm kind of looking for you know a game sort of take your mind of things for half an hour or whatever well I'll try to come up with some recommendations for you you know the new Jedi game I'm gonna I'm gonna get that soon can't recommend it yet because I haven't played it well what what's a fun game for phones called vampire survivors oh I'll check that out yeah that's good my my recommendation well what what do you do in what do you like to watch in terms of comedy and entertainment I know you share a lot of memes and you know obviously comments about B articles and stuff like that you commented what you tweeted one time about how wokeness is destroying comedy

59:48and how or it it was it was how well you can't write com comedy from a leftist place of wokeness because there's no truth claim or the truth claim is wrong I mean I'm butchering it but I mean you know hardly needs to tell you guys but the you know the essence of a lot of Comedy is a revealed truth like the hidden truth that people understand intuitively or explicitly and there's a there's that sort of moment of revealed you know kernel of true of often unacknowledged truth and in that unacknowledged truth is the humor so if you're you know premised on a lie you can no longer be funny because there's no real truth and this is you know why a lot you know a lot of

1:00:39people on the left have no sense of humor they're not funny and if if there if there's so many no-fly zones you know that you have to you you have to avoid all the time then how do you what what what is their what like there's nothing left to make to have fun about you know yeah so well Rogan was saying like wokeness is funny like a lot of the woke ideas are so outrageous they are funny and so when you're not allowed to make fun of the funniest thing right that's why sites like ours do well is because we are willing to do that there's a lot of people who are just holding back on the things that are right for comedy well have you been at the mothership

1:01:22club yet in Austin where he's yeah I know no I'd love to go there he's like he's trying to make it so that you know comedians can come there cancel free environment make the jokes you're not supposed to make I mean if you see any comedies from times past I mean it they're they're so sort of verborton at this point it's insane

1:01:45you know they're making fun of all sorts of things that would be totally unacceptable these days those are Twitter once like just you know legalize comedy you know yeah if you keep you know saying that you can't make fun of things or something's always punching down you know like well you're not gonna be anything left to make humor I don't think we want a humorless future

1:02:16I mean it's the same thing that you have with speech where it's like you know if only the the popular narrative is being promoted and it's never being challenged then that's a problem that's a problem for it's a problem for comedy too yeah so you you can't be funny just propping up the popular narrative and trying to get people to clap for you like yeah like it's it's Applause it's not laughter yes true clapter somebody called it yeah yeah I was probably seeing some of the Snippets from the White House correspondence Club dinner you know where fine was getting a lot of claps but it was like it's a strict cheering squad or what you know a lot of applause

1:03:01you know yeah whoever stuff clapping glasses out of the [Laughter] you just want someone normal to be president you said recently someone normal a normal human being I mean I think so no no the thing is that it just caught it just contrary to my prediction of the most entertaining outcome is most likely yeah

1:03:25you may have heard me say that like this the simplest sex explanation is most likely my friend Jonah has this you know his theory is the most ironic explanations most likely and then my variant is the most entertaining outcome is the most likely as viewed from a third party who's not in the show so you you could be watching a World War One movie where people were getting blown to beds and you're just having a soda and popcorn you know it's fine but it's rough for the people getting blown up by Cannon gels right we're in there getting blown up by Canada's whatever the so or or a very good thing happening but my theory is that the more often than not the most entertaining outcome

1:04:08as as though we were an alien soap opera is the is the most likely so if you can say what is the most entertaining outcome for the election next year that's probably what's going to happen isn't that because God is a jokester and is messing with us or what or because we're in a simulation or is it because of simulation I mean ratings man just for them God is doing it for the ratings well they're saying that that's often the case the most entertaining outcome as viewed by a third party like in it like it's a alien so far is is the dull Twitter thing has been very entertaining from the outside yeah on the inside it's been hell or hellish movements yeah yeah some

1:04:59definitely been some knowledge moments yeah so it's been I was just a rough it's been a rough six months but right at this point training positively it wasn't easy some a lot of open heart surgery but things need to be you know knocking wood headed in a good direction and your Chief twit still right now but you hand that off when we're still figuring that out because Linda's got access to her obligations at NBC so

1:05:33a month or so I suppose oh but I you know also be responsible for software development and the core principles the car you know the constitution of the company being free speech is Linda understands that she supports that it's good yeah so she signed something like it's in right yeah yeah yeah I mean a lot of things that they need to get done for a company are you know there's a lot of chores it's not things that need to be done and legal HR Finance you know

1:06:14yeah solving interpersonal arguments that people have you know there's a lot of sort of just general management stuff that take it takes a lot of time so I'm hopeful Linda can handle that and I will manage the software team well do you have any questions for us no just you know jurors I suppose

1:06:42Cheers Cheers thank you for taking the time this is awesome well you're welcome here yeah pretty crazy go from Twitter jail to sitting down on Twitter HQ The Barbarians burst through the gate and I'm having a drink in the in the enemy Palace [Laughter] drinking from the skulls of art what is best in life what is best in life exactly criminal Barbarian underrated I just feel like it feels like victory yeah it does yeah toss anyway yeah yeah I feel great didn't cost us much didn't cost us 40.

1:07:21well we did give them an IOU oh yeah yeah we're on the hook for that I owe you you didn't sign it did you foreign

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份