2014年1月,温哥华,加拿大投资者大会(Canadian Investor Conference)现场。剑桥能源(Cambridge House Live)的主持人瓦妮莎·科莱特(Vanessa Collette)把话筒递给了豪斯山合伙公司(House Mountain Partners)总裁克里斯·贝里(Chris Berry)。她先问初级矿业市场的现状,接着把话题转到能源金属:价格现在被什么推着走?
贝里的回答里蹦出一个跟矿业不太搭的名字:埃隆·马斯克。他说,现在是马斯克在推价格,这句话只算一半开玩笑。
那时候特斯拉的超级电池工厂(Gigafactory)还停在图纸上,投资规模五十亿美元,选址只说了在美国西部某处,2020年投产。可就是这样一个连地基都没打的工厂,让一批跌到没人愿意接盘的锂矿、石墨矿初级公司重新有了买盘。贝里在访谈里用的词是顺风。
一个还没开工的工厂,凭什么把价格抬起来
要理解这件事,得先理解矿业的时间结构。一座矿山从发现到投产,八年十年算快的。需求端的故事可以在一个季度里被改写,供给端的反应要按十年计。中间这段时差,就是初级勘探公司全部的价值所在,它们卖的是未来供给的选择权。
贝里把超级工厂的规模讲得很清楚。
「他要建一座五十亿美元的工厂,到2020年产出相当于今天全球总量的锂离子电池。你需要多得多的锂、多得多的石墨,什么都需要更多。」(克里斯·贝里)
注意后半句:相当于今天全球总量。2014年全球锂离子电池的产能基本被消费电子和早期电动车吃掉,一座工厂的规划产能就等于把全球需求翻一倍。这个数字一旦被资本市场接受,后面的事情就顺理成章:谁手里握着北美境内的锂、石墨、稀土矿权,谁就先涨。
贝里提到锂、石墨、钴这几个品种的股价都动了。他还点出一个容易被忽略的细节:这些公司里有相当一部分,在马斯克开口之前,股价已经到了"真的出问题"的地步。超级工厂的公告没有创造任何价值,它干的事情是重新定价预期,把一批快要出局的公司从退市边缘拽了回来。
这也解释了为什么消息会精准落在北美矿权上。马斯克说要放在美国西部,市场的第一反应是先买离工厂最近的矿,全球锂盐的边际供给那笔账往后放。预期定价从来不精确,它先定方向,再慢慢修正细节。
「我不会押注马斯克输,但这个计划很激进」
贝里没把自己归到看空马斯克的那一边。他讲得很坦白:开过 Model S 的人都知道,那套技术在商业上是成立的,车本来就能开,跟 PPT 上的概念完全是两码事。
「我不会押注马斯克输,他在好几个不同的行业里都赢过。这个计划很有野心,如果有人能把它融到资,那会非常有意思。」(克里斯·贝里)
他真正质疑的是另一件事:钱从哪来,工厂怎么按时建成。他用的词是"激进",在2014年这个判断并不刻薄。
这句话里藏着一个后面贯穿整场访谈的分析框架:技术可行性、融资可行性、执行可行性是三件不同的事。技术已经被产品验证过,融资和执行才是变数。上游的矿业投资者得把这条区分放在心上,因为锂矿和石墨矿是先扩产还是先观望,取决于电池厂到底建不建得起来。
五十亿美元在2014年是什么概念?当时整个锂行业的总市值都未必有这个数。一座工厂的资本开支超过整个上游行业的体量,说明上游没有谁能独自承接这个需求,必须靠外部资本进场。而2014年的初级矿业市场,恰恰是最缺外部资本的时候。这两件事摆在一起,就是贝里说"激进"的底气所在。
把能源金属装进一个篮子,是最容易犯的错
主持人问,哪一种能源金属最有可能跑出最大的涨幅。贝里的答案是钪(scandium),一个大部分人没听过的名字。
先纠正一个常见误解。钪经常被归进稀土,因为它的化学性质和稀土有重合,应用场景也常被放在一起讲。可在元素周期表上,它并不在镧系元素那一排。这种分类上的模糊,直接导致它在投资名单里长期缺席。贝里的原话更狠:把锂、钪、石墨装进同一个篮子,然后说"这是个好机会"或者"这是个烂机会",等于什么都没说。
他看好钪的理由,是供需两头都极端。
「全球年产大约十五吨。是十五吨,不是一百五十吨,也不是一万五千吨。」(克里斯·贝里)
十五吨的年产量,任何一座像样的工厂都能一口吃掉。需求端挂着两个方向:一个是航空航天,钪可以跟铝做成合金,改善强度和焊接性能;另一个是固体氧化物燃料电池(solid oxide fuel cell),这块业务当时正以两位数速度在增长。
钪的死结在供给端。贝里的判断很直接,眼下没有可靠的来源。只要有一座靠谱的钪矿投产,下游那些做燃料电池的公司会"飞到月球上去"。反过来,如果供给始终不稳,材料性能再好,工程师也不敢把它写进设计图纸。
这就是小众金属的普遍困境:需求一直都在,缺的是一个能签长期供货合同的卖家。等不到,需求就一直停留在实验室和样品阶段。
初级矿业市场:一场已经持续两年的血洗
聊回市场的底色,贝里对初级公司的处境没有任何粉饰。
「过去两年被叫做血洗。我老实预期这种情况还会持续十二到二十四个月。」(克里斯·贝里)
理由是全球经济还在找立足点。新兴市场以中国为首在放缓,欧元区和美国找不到方向,这对大宗商品需求是负面的。
他也看到了变化。成本纪律开始出现,他关注的几个小众金属领域,公司数量在减少,行业规模在收缩。在他看来这是好事,一个只剩三家公司的行业,比一个有三十家公司的行业健康得多,因为价格战停了,人也不乱挖了。融资窗口也开了一条缝,有少量钱在往外走。
活下去的标准变了。贝里说得很直白:现在的游戏规则跟过去不一样了,盯着钻孔、盯着见矿结果,这些都不再是重点,可持续性和活下去才是。他愿意看的公司只有两类,一类资产负债表干净,一类相对同行握着某种可持续的、别人抄不走的竞争优势。剩下的事情都是次要的。
这段话放到任何一次行业下行里都成立。勘探公司的本质是把现金换成地下的不确定性,行情好的时候市场奖励冒险,行情差的时候市场只奖励活着。
铜价里藏着的中国读数
主持人问到中国增速放缓会怎么影响金属价格,贝里的第一句话是:每种金属都要分开看,别一起算。
他拿铜举例。中国大概占全球铜需求量的四成。铜价从4美元跌到3美元,当时在3.15美元附近,看起来已经横住了。如果中国是全球最大的铜消费国,而铜价不再往下走,那他倾向于认为中国的增速在筑底。
他也留了余地。中国的增长统计你得打个折扣看,这话他自己先说了。但消费端的表现是实打实的,还在健康区间。所以他的结论是,基本金属整体不太可能再跌多少。
铜在行业里有个外号叫铜博士,因为它的下游铺得太广,建筑、电力、家电、制造业都要用,工业活动的温度变化会先从铜价上透出来。用铜价去反推中国需求,比用官方增速去推要可靠一些,这也是贝里那套判断的底层逻辑。
新兴市场真正的问题:有没有一份工资
贝里把新兴市场的数字摆了一排。中国从10%掉到7%出头,印度从8%掉到最近一次公布的4.8%,俄罗斯掉下了悬崖。这套组合对自然资源意味着一个需求受抑的画面,未来两三年都难改。
他还点了全球经济里一个更根本的过剩:劳动力的过剩。
中印中产阶级壮大、生活方式向发达国家趋同,这个故事他依然认可,逻辑也依然成立。可他补了一句很多人不愿意听的话:一个新兴市场的普通人,得先有一份工资,才能真正参与到全球经济里。没有收入,所谓的中产阶级扩张只是统计口径上的数字。
中国、印尼这些国家内部都还有一堆失衡。长期的需求故事完整,短期的不确定性很大,而且这种状态他预计还要持续十二到二十四个月。这两句话不矛盾,长期趋势和短期价格从来走的就不是一条线。
铀:六成产能在28美元的价格下活不下去
福岛之后,日本的反应堆一直没有重启,铀价一路阴跌。主持人问,什么能触发重启?
贝里的答案很政治。他说,大概是东京出现轮流停电这类事情。只有能让普通选民有切身感受的事件,才会真正让政客和电力公司动起来,光靠行业报告和听证会推不动。
他承认自己没料到铀价会跌这么深。当时全球大约六成的铀产能在28美元的价位上是不经济的,这个比例意味着供给端的收缩会持续发生。
他对铀价的路径判断很有意思。他不相信工业金属会出现剧烈的暴涨暴跌,因为这些品种大多靠握手协议和固定价格成交,价格传导天然迟钝。但铀价必须涨,因为需求就在那里,而供给收缩的速度比他原本预想的还要快。
肥料拿了最少的尊重,干了最基础的那份活
访谈最后拐到粮食安全。贝里把这条线归入长期趋势,而且是他们重仓相信的那一类。
逻辑很朴素:要吃饭的嘴在变多,耕地面积在减少,那就只能想办法提高每亩、每公顷的单产。钾肥、磷肥、氮肥就是干这件事的。
「我一直觉得肥料从来没得到过锂那种性感金属的尊重,但它的重要性至少不亚于锂,甚至更高。」(克里斯·贝里)
他随后提到一家公司,文字稿记作 Arian Resources,从上下文看应该是魁北克的 Arianne Phosphate。这家公司的差异点是高品位火成岩矿床,同行大多是沉积型。磷矿石的供应有相当一部分来自"不那么令人愉快的"地区,比如俄罗斯。所以一个矿床只要同时满足三个条件,落在政治可靠的司法管辖区、经济性好、手里有可融资可行性研究(bankable feasibility study),在当时的市场里就算稀缺。贝里在访谈里主动披露了利益关系,他是这家公司的顾问。
这一段值得单独拎出来看。一个分析师愿意在镜头前主动交代"我给它做咨询",这件事本身就说明当时那类项目的融资有多难,好项目也得靠人脉去推。
颠覆性投资:便宜钱到处都是,总需求不在
主持人最后问他的投资策略。贝里把它叫颠覆性投资,落点却相当朴素。
他先把宏观画面铺开。不光初级矿业,整个大宗商品市场都是供给充足、劳动力充足、资本充足、产能过剩,便宜钱到处找地方去,而总需求就是不在。
他给了一个刺眼的数据对比。美联储往美国经济里灌了4.5万亿美元,作为增长和通胀基准的十年期国债收益率却上不了2.5%。市场呈现的是通缩或者反通胀的倾向。
在这样的环境里,他不认为应该把大宗商品整个扔掉。他的原话是不能把婴儿和洗澡水一起倒掉。他觉得现在就在底部,只是不知道什么时候转向。他自己也拿这事开玩笑:如果他知道拐点在哪天,他就能给马斯克融资了,那他早就成有钱人了。
所以标准回到那一条:只找那些握有可持续的、或者"不讲道理"的颠覆性竞争优势的公司。在总需求缺席的市场里,涨起来的从来只有那么两三家把成本、资源禀赋或者地缘位置捏在手里的公司,整个行业不会一起涨。
把整场访谈串起来看,贝里其实在反复讲同一件事:宏观决定水位,个体决定谁能浮起来。中国增速、美联储资产负债表、日本反应堆,这些是水位。超级工厂的选址、钪的十五吨年产量、魁北克的矿床品位,这些决定谁能浮起来。2014年那个时点上,马斯克的一句公告,相当于给一小片水域突然开了闸。
给读者的行动清单
- 把"能源金属"这个标签撕掉,逐个品种做供需表。锂看电动车产能爬坡,石墨看负极材料,钪看航空航天和燃料电池。混在一起判断,结论一定是错的。
- 遇到小众金属,先问供给端的绝对量。十五吨、一千五百吨、十五万吨,量级不同,投资逻辑完全不同。小到极致的品种,一个项目投产就能改写行业,也意味着流动性极差。
- 用"能不能活过二十四个月"筛初级公司。看现金余额、烧钱速度、有没有在削成本,再看它有没有别人抄不走的东西。钻孔结果放在最后看。
- 把铜价当中国需求的温度计。官方增速可以打折听,铜、电、水泥这些实物消费数据骗不了人。
- 跟踪政策类品种时,找那个能让普通选民有痛感的触发点。日本重启反应堆的钥匙不在行业报告里,在东京的停电表里。
- 对马斯克式的宏大叙事,把技术、融资、执行拆成三层分别打分。技术层看产品,融资层看资本开支和行业体量是否匹配,执行层看时间表。三层里只要有一层崩了,上游的涨价故事就得重算。
- 粮食安全这条线值得长期留一个仓位观察位,重点看司法管辖区和可行性研究的完成度,别只看储量数字。
- 在便宜钱泛滥、总需求缺席的环境里,别买行业,买那两三家有真护城河的公司。等拐点这件事没人做得到,包括受访者本人。
0:00the following is brought to you by gold seek mint.com silver and gold bullion directly from the mint gold seek mint.com
0:21welcome to cambridge House live I'm Vanessa Collette here at the Canadian investor conference vancouver i'm joined by chris berry president of house mountain partners welcome Chris and I see you again nice to see you too Chris what's your overall impression of the state of the junior market right now well you know i'm sure you're asking a lot of people that question and there's not a lot of value that i could add in terms of a unique response it's been a real challenging time I mean I've heard it referred to as a bloodbath over the last couple of years you know I honestly expect that to continue for the next 12 to 18 to 24 months and the reason is
0:59you're you're dealing with the global economy that's still trying to find its footing you know the emerging markets of course led by China are slowing down and again I'll take a seven percent growth rate in China any day relative regardless of what it was but you know the US and the eurozone are sort of struggling to find direction and you know that's compounded by the emerging markets slowing down generally and that of course has a direct I think negative implication for commodity demand at least in the near term and just specific to the junior research sector are you seeing any signs of recovery well you
1:35know I think you started to see a lot more cost discipline out there I think that some of the numbers of companies in particular with some of the niche metals that I focus on those the sizes of those industries are starting to shrink somewhat I think that's a good sign you know there is a little bit of money that's getting raised out there I just think that you know the name of the game right now rather than worrying about drilling or drill holes or grill results the name of the game is just to focus on sustainability and to stay alive and so the juniors that I'm most interested in either have the strong balance sheets from a financial perspective or have
2:11some sort of a sustainable or competitive advantage relative to their competitors that they can leverage to you know to push forward now moving over to China there's been a lot of concern about slowing growth despite the seven and a half percent target that they have just related to how it affects metal prices how separate our metal prices from China today would you think well I think that's a good question i think every metal needs to be viewed differently in that context you know for example my numbers may not be exact on this but China is responsible for forty percent of global copper demand and consumption so you know we saw copper fall from let's say four
2:50dollars down to three and now it's at about 3 15 that seems to have leveled off so if China is is the largest consumer of copper in the world and you see the price of copper sort of levitate or be range-bound my sense is that the growth rates in China are are bottoming out and you know I'd be the first to admit that you might want to take some of the Chinese growth statistics with a grain of salt but generally speaking when you look at the consumption patterns in that country they're still very healthy and so you know I don't expect to see a lot of the base metals in particular go much lower at all based on what's happening in China now you pointed out that emerging markets seem
3:32to be bouncing back a bit where does girls stand and how is it how is it affecting the resource markets well it's you know look I mean it's definitely lower than it was say three or four years ago you had China at ten percent India at eight percent I think the most recent GDP print in India was four point eight percent Russia has fallen off of a cliff you know this to me implies a a
3:58subdued demand scenario or profile for natural resources out over the next couple of years you know I think you want to look at the excesses that I see in the global economy for example an excess of labor you know we talk a lot about the growing middle class in China and India and this idea of convergence of lifestyles you know that is still valid and still makes sense but the average emerging market citizen has to be able to earn you know a wage to participate in the global economy so there are a number of imbalances again in countries like China indonesia the long-term demand profile and the story if you will is still very much intact but it's very uncertain
4:43right now and I expect it to stay that way for the next you know 12 to 18 to 24 months moving over to energy metals you've been following them for a while keeping a close eye on them what's driving the price there right now well right now Elon Musk is driving the price and I say that only half joking you know his is gigafactory announcement for Tesla is revolutionary and it's
5:09revolutionary in the sense that if he is going to produce a factory I don't care where it is in the western United States or anywhere in the world if he is going to build this five billion dollar factory that by 2020 will be producing the same number of lithium-ion batteries that's produced globally today you're going to need a lot more lithium a lot more graphite a lot more of everything and so you know I'm not going to bet against mr. musk who's been successful on a number of different industries but i think the plans are ambitious and back to your original point that's what's really breathed life into a number of junior stories in particular for example
5:47lithium the graphite plays even some cobalt plays are all of a sudden much more interesting to investors based on Elon Musk pronouncements all coming from this gigafactory you know that's my general take I mean some of these lithium juniors quite frankly were in real trouble from a share price perspective and you know he made the pronouncement and talked about how it's going to be in the located somewhere in the western United States and so these North American deposits again of lithium and graphite and even some of the rare earth plays kind of caught a tail wind there look it's an audacious plan if you can get it financed I think it's going
6:29to be really interesting I mean anyone that's ever driven a Model S or used any of his products knows that that technology is certainly commercially viable it just seems like it's pretty aggressive at this point in time I think you can test drive them up on that Robson Street oh yeah you can test right of them in Brooklyn New York too just as an FYI do to your Watchers now which of these energy metals you think is poised to make the biggest games well I think actually one of the ones that I'm most focused on right now is scandium and that is a a metal that is widely considered to be a rare earth element it shares a lot of the similar properties but it's not near the
7:10lanthanides for example on the periodic table you know scandium has a number of different uses first of all when you look at supply and demand and that's one of the things that I think is most important with everybody watching you want to look at each energy metal individually so lumping lithium and scandium and graphite under the same umbrella and you know saying it's a great opportunity or a terrible opportunity you're sort of missing the point and one of the reasons why i like scandium as much as i do is because there's very limited supply it's about 15 tons per year with 15 not 150 or
7:4615,000 and the demand really hinges on the aerospace industry because you can you can alloy it with aluminum and also the solid oxide fuel cell business and the fuel cell business is growing at you know very sound double-digit rates per year so you know there's a lot of detail that we can get into about it but scandium is a metal that if a reliable source can come online and right now there are no reliable sources you will see some of these other ancillary industries like the fuel cell business absolutely rocket to the moon for lack of a better phrase now talking about uranium prices we've seen that the prices have continued to drag since Japan hasn't restarted reactors what do
8:31you think could trigger them restarting the reactors there well two things obviously what would I think will restart the reactors I think you'll have you know roving brownouts in Tokyo or something like that I mean those types of events which affect the average voter I think are going to get the attention of the politicians and the the utilities in in Tokyo you know look I'm I'm actually surprised that uranium has fallen as much as it has I think sixty percent of global production right now is not viable at $28 uranium so that
9:06will change you know I'm not a believer that there are violent moves up or down with these industrial metals because of how they trade their usually traded on you know my handshake agreements and things like that with set prices so you know you won't see a violent move higher or lower with uranium but the uranium price has to increase and it has to increase because the demand is there and the supply has contracted probably a little bit faster than certainly I I anticipated let's talk a little bit about food security and supply what's your take there again that's another long-term trend that that were big believers in you know you've got a situation we've talked about before with
9:48many more mouths to feed both today and in the future you have a situation where arable land generally speaking is decreasing so you're going to need to find a way to increase the average yield on an acre a hectare of land and so that's where the pot ashes of the world and the phosphates and the nitrogens come into place so I always sort of felt like the fertilizers never got the respect that some of the the sexier metals like the lithium's got but they're as important if not more so longer chart are you looking at any fertilizer companies or working with any of them yeah there's one in particular that we like and we're consultants to them in the interest of full disclosure
10:33is arian resources you know this is a quebec-based play it's a high-grade igneous deposit which is one of its main differentiators from its peers you know the supply of fog is is dissipating most of the phosphate rock that's produced comes from let's just say less savory parts of the world like for example Russia we mentioned before hand so if you're looking for an opportunity in a let's just say a reliable safe geopolitical jurisdiction to try and take advantage of a deposit that has very sound economics there's also a bankable feasibility study out on it you know arion is a very interesting opportunity what's your as your strategy of disruptive investing sure so well it
11:20kind of comes back to what I had talked about beforehand where you have a situation in the not just in the junior markets but in I would argue in the commodity markets in general where you have ample supply you have an ample supply of labor you have ample supply of capital and excess capacity and cheap money sloshing around all looking for a home and the demand the demand just
11:44aggregate demand in general general just is not there you know you've had the Federal Reserve in the United States pump four and a half trillion dollars into the economy and the 10-year note which is sort of the benchmark for growth and inflation can't get above two and a half percent so you know we see deflation or disinflationary tendencies in the markets and so that you have to think about what that does and doesn't mean with respect to commodities and in particular junior investing and we we don't think I call it throwing out the baby with the bathwater we don't think running away from commodities at this point in time is wise we think we're at
12:21the bottom you know if I knew when it was going to turn I would I'd be able to fund Elon Musk the effect would be a wealthy guy but no so we think that if you're going to look at the junior space or even commodities in general you want to find those companies that have some sort of a sustainable or an unfair disruptive competitive advantage excellent well Chris it was a pleasure having you back on and look forward to seeing you in the sure great appreciate it you
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版