2006年3月,一枚细长的白色火箭从太平洋中间一座小岛上升空。不到一分钟,它就失控了,撞上离发射台大约200英尺的暗礁。
火箭上搭载的那颗卫星被甩了出去,像一颗炮弹,飞了大约500英尺,砸穿一座机械车间的屋顶,劈断一根2x6英寸的木梁,落在地板上。
几乎完好无损。
这是SpaceX(太空探索技术公司)的第一次发射。埃隆·马斯克(Elon Musk)在FIRE大会(Future in Review,未来回顾大会)的太空专场讲起这段时,语气轻松得像在说别人的事故:那颗卫星落地的地方,离它自己的运输集装箱只有50英尺。
我想它无论如何都想回家。(马斯克)
他还补了一句:至少我们可以说,我们从没丢过一颗卫星。
这场对话发生在2006年。台上两个人,一个是刚把火箭送上天的马斯克,另一个是克里斯·法拉内塔(Chris Faranetta),太空探险公司(Space Adventures)的副总裁。那家公司干的事,是卖票送人去国际空间站,一张2000万美元。主持人汤姆·斯坦迪奇(Tom Standage)开场就点明了基调:每年这个专场都还在,但每年都少一点科幻,多一点现实。
十九年后回头看,这场对话里埋着的东西,比当年听起来多得多。
一发火箭600万美元,同类报价2500万
马斯克先算了一笔账。
猎鹰1号(Falcon 1)一次发射略高于600万美元,是全世界所有量产火箭里每公斤入轨成本最低的。如果找美国本土的供应商,比如轨道科学公司(Orbital Sciences),同等运力的火箭报价在2500万到3000万美元之间。
市面上确实有更便宜的选项。俄罗斯和乌克兰有翻新的洲际弹道导弹,价格落在1000万到1200万美元。马斯克当场把这笔账拆了:这些导弹是直接从货架上取下来的,早就不在生产了,价格没有可持续性,不能当成真实的市场价来比。
猎鹰1号的定位很清楚:这是一次技术验证,短期赚不到钱。它的任务是把一整套技术放在较小的尺度上先跑通,在送人上天之前证明这些技术可用。马斯克把公司的路线讲成清清楚楚的三步:
- 第一步,造运载火箭,把卫星送进近地轨道。
- 第二步,造运载火箭和飞船,为政府和私营部门提供载人入轨服务。
- 第三步,为政府和私营部门提供把人送到另一个星球的服务。
2006年,他站在第一步的起点上,讲第三步的时候没有任何迟疑。
关于那次失败,他主动做了澄清。首飞本质上是演示飞行,或者叫beta测试,卫星只是顺带的,还是一颗学生造的卫星。真正的客户是美国国防高级研究计划局(DARPA,Defense Research Projects Agency),他们付钱买的是"快速响应发射演示"。换句话说,火箭有没有把卫星送进轨道,根本不在这次飞行的考核项里。
下一次发射排在9月或10月,之后计划每两到三个月一发。
重型猎鹰能顶三分之一个土星五号
主持人翻到SpaceX官网,看到了猎鹰9号(Falcon 9),问这个大家伙还造不造。
马斯克说,年底或者2008年初。猎鹰9号和猎鹰1号最大的区别是它按载人标准设计,安全系数更高,体量大得多,近地轨道运力25吨这个级别。他还透露了一个没放在官网上的版本:50吨运力,飞两次就能拼出一次载人登月或者载人火星任务。
主持人问,这是土星五号(Saturn V)那个量级吗?
马斯克的回答很克制:重型版本大约是土星五号的三分之一,但效率更高。也就是说,运力按比例缩到三分之一,成本缩得更多。
2006年的马斯克已经在用效率这个词衡量火箭,规模只是顺带的结果。这个思路后来贯穿了SpaceX所有的设计决策。
NASA拿出5亿美元,问一句"谁能送货到空间站"
这场对话里信息密度最高的一段,是NASA的商业轨道运输服务项目(COTS,Commercial Orbital Transportation Services)。
主持人把它翻译成人话:NASA拿出5亿美元,问一句,有没有人能给我们造点东西,能把货送到空间站?
投标的有六家公司,SpaceX进了短名单,8月出结果。马斯克讲完这场对话,13分钟后就要去跟NASA通电话。
他的判断很直接:这是巨大的转变。这个项目的实质,是给航天飞机找替代方案。SpaceX是领先候选,方案基于猎鹰9号,干的就是现在联盟号(Soyuz)在干的活。猎鹰9号的最小版本,正好是联盟号那个级别。
主持人抛出一个尖锐的问题。历史上NASA和那些老牌承包商一直是"新太空"圈子里的对立面,大家的姿态是"不用管他们,我们自己上火星"。现在NASA回过头来买服务,这对你来说是不是需要一次立场上的转变?
马斯克的回答把商业逻辑摆得干干净净:
我们对客户不做价值判断。他们想把一轮奶酪送上太空,那笔钱跟别人的钱一样好使。(马斯克)
主持人追问,真的有人要送奶酪上去?马斯克说,如果有人来,要送一轮奶酪或者一个火腿三明治,我们都干。
这段话后来被引用过很多次。它听起来像玩笑,其实是一条原则:火箭公司提供服务,不做道德裁判。这条原则让SpaceX在早期能接下各种看起来奇怪的订单,活了下来。
主持人还问到当月刚在洛杉矶开完的新太空行业会议,气氛跟去年比怎么样。马斯克说他去年没去,但能感觉到气氛是乐观的,大量新资金正在进入这个行业。他点名了几个人:杰夫·贝索斯(Jeff Bezos)、保罗·艾伦(Paul Allen)、约翰·卡马克(John Carmack),后者做过《毁灭战士》(Doom)和《雷神之锤》(Quake)。
一句话概括这批人:都是在互联网和软件上赚到钱的科技人,现在把钱投到新边疆。
成为多行星物种,只能靠私营企业
主持人问,未来三到五年,你希望SpaceX是什么位置?
马斯克说,希望我们成为全世界把人送入轨道的主要机制,他认为这是现实的可能性。然后他加了一句:
到2020年,我希望我们能送人上另一个星球。(马斯克)
这个时间表后来没有兑现。但更重要的是他给出的理由,因为这套逻辑决定了SpaceX此后二十年的所有动作。
他说,人类要成为多行星物种,唯一的路径是私营企业,靠政府不可能。原因很朴素:政府在成本优化上非常糟糕。
接着他给出了一个衡量标准。什么时候去火星这件事会变成"放热反应",也就是自己会往前跑、不需要外部推动?答案是,当把一个人送到火星的成本降到跟加州一套中位数房价差不多的水平。
这个类比很有意思。房价每年在涨,所以这个目标每年都在变得更容易达成。他补了一句:你只要原地不动,就离目标更近了。
主持人顺势接了个南极的类比。100年前去南极的探险,私人资助的那些比政府资助的便宜得多,死的人也少得多,政府主导的那些往往出问题。
这个类比放在2006年是有分量的。当时没人相信私人公司能把人送上轨道,更别说火星。马斯克没有去争辩信念,他一直在算成本。
招不到人,是比技术更难翻的墙
话题转到监管,马斯克的火气明显上来了。
他说SpaceX的技术百分之百是美国技术,这一块没有问题。麻烦出在客户和员工两端。如果客户不是美国公司,从国务院拿到许可以便跟对方沟通、集成对方的卫星,要花六个月。
更难的是招人。公司不能雇没有绿卡或者不是美国公民的人。
五年前我自己都雇不了我自己,这太荒唐了。(马斯克)
这句话说得轻,但指向的是一座真实的墙。一个南非出生、后来入籍美国的人,在2006年如果按当时的规则去申请自己的公司,会被卡在身份上。
主持人问,这是你面对的最大监管问题吗?毕竟你还在跟范登堡(Vandenberg)空军基地的事情纠缠。
马斯克提到,SpaceX正在跟波音(Boeing)和洛克希德(Lockheed)就范登堡太空港的使用权打一场硬仗,想把他们从国防部发射服务的主要供应商位置上拉下来。他评价对手的做法:在一些小事情上玩得很脏。
但他明确说,范登堡这件事是次要的。真正的障碍是身份和出口管制。2008年之前,SpaceX所有发射都会从太平洋上那座小岛进行。
主持人开玩笑说,你该抱一只白猫才对(这是《007》里反派布洛菲尔德的标准造型)。马斯克接得很顺:是挺难以置信的,但每年回来,东西都更多一点,证据更多一点,事情更多一点,虚构的成分更少一点。
主持人还问了一个关键问题:这5亿美元算不算一个"奖品"?
马斯克的回答纠正了一个常见的误解。这笔钱的发放方式是按里程碑节点付款,外界常以为全部做完才一次性发奖,实际情况并非如此。它也不是传统的成本加成合同(cost-plus),那种合同是花多少报多少,超支由甲方兜底。COTS的机制是把行业往固定价格、按结果付费的方向推。
他还把两个合同放在一起对比。一个是NASA为重返月球开发的乘员探索飞行器(CEV,Crew Exploration Vehicle)合同,规模在150亿到200亿美元。另一个是COTS,5亿美元,他自嘲地叫它"小小的一笔"。
主持人提醒,COTS有可能最终比CEV更重要,因为它是一张门票,进了门就能做别的事。马斯克承认有这个可能。
然后他起身去打电话了。这个细节本身说明了很多:2006年的SpaceX,创始人需要亲自在会议中途离场,去跟NASA通电话。
2000万美元一张票,已经送了三个人上空间站
克里斯·法拉内塔接过了话筒。
他所在的太空探险公司做的事情很直接:你如果真想去太空,他是那个可以打电话的人。票价2000万美元,公司已经送了三个人上国际空间站,后面还排着队。
他们也做抛物线飞行。主持人用了那个流行的外号"呕吐彗星"(vomit comet),法拉内塔立刻纠正:我们不喜欢这么叫。原因很实在,一次飞行要做大约60个抛物线,人体大概在第15个之后开始难受。所以通常到那个点就够了,足够了。
他们还做飞到太空边缘的飞行。至于造飞船,法拉内塔说得很坦白:我们不自己造,我们把整个太空项目外包出去。
具体来说,他们用的是米亚西舍夫设计局(Myasishchev Design Bureau),这家机构设计过苏联暴风雪号航天飞机(Buran)的机体。不过法拉内塔强调,真正用的是整套俄罗斯航天体系,背后有一整批分包商。
他们正在做的亚轨道飞行器叫"探索者号"(Explorer),飞到100公里以上,也就是62英里以上,可重复使用,是一架火箭飞机,由母机驮载。他特意补了一句带点玩笑的说明:这个设计在伯特·鲁坦(Burt Rutan)之前就有了,区别是我们的飞行器在母机上面,他们的挂在下面。
时间表是2008到2009年。
联盟号本来就是为登月造的
太空探险公司真正让人坐直身体的项目,是环月飞行。
法拉内塔先讲了一段很多人不知道的历史:联盟号飞船最初就是为登月设计的。这个事实后来被遗忘了。
他们做环月项目的出发点其实很务实。当时国际空间站能不能一直用下去,存在不确定性。万一空间站没了,联盟号还能去别的地方。于是公司开始投入研究环月任务。
整个方案的巧妙之处在于,它几乎全部建立在现成技术上。
第一段:乘员坐联盟号去国际空间站,在上面待大约16天。
第二段:另一枚火箭发射一个上面级。他们打算用质子号(Proton)。这个上面级来头不小,它原本是苏联登月计划里用来送人上月的,苏联取消登月后,俄罗斯把它转去做商业通信卫星发射。
这个上面级被送入跟空间站相同的轨道,位置在空间站后方。乘员从空间站解缆,坐联盟号跟上面级交会对接。上面级点火,把飞船推进一条高椭圆轨道,绕到月球背面。最近的时候距月面大约60英里,去程两天半,回程两天半。
整个方案最聪明的地方,是绕开了载人认证这道最贵的关卡。上面级是无人发射的,所以不需要为了载人而对那枚大火箭做任何额外加固;交会对接发生在太空里,而不是在发射台上。这一下省掉的钱是数量级的。
成本:2亿美元,包含研制和一次无人试飞。换算到座位,每个座位1亿美元,一共两个座位。
主持人开了个玩笑:2000万美元去空间站,再加这个,等于把太空站度假免费搭进去了。如果上面级出问题,发射推迟,至少你还能去空间站。
这个设计有个隐含的好处,很多人没注意到:环月任务的所有风险,都被拆成了两段独立的、可以单独失败的任务。
太阳耀斑来了怎么办
现场提问环节,第一个问题就很硬:环月任务怎么处理太阳耀斑?如果耀斑爆发,乘员在返回途中没法比牛顿定律更快地回来。阿波罗时代基本是靠运气。
法拉内塔不接受"靠运气"这个说法。他指出,NASA当年是实打实建立了太阳耀斑预报这门科学,轨道上有探测器在盯着太阳。现在更是有一整支探测器编队在持续监测。
飞船上的应对手段也具体:联盟号有一个加固舱段,可以当辐射屏蔽用;返回舱本身就相当厚。空间站上正在测试塑料辐射屏蔽材料。他还提到一个很多非专业人士不知道的常识,水是很好的辐射屏蔽材料。
第二个问题更尖锐:你觉得下一个登上月球的是谁?美国、中国,还是私营企业?
法拉内塔的回答没有犹豫:太空探险公司。
然后他给出了支撑这个答案的数字。登月舱正在开发中,他们认为重返月球的成本可以控制在20亿美元以内。这比阿波罗便宜一个数量级以上。
主持人问,你打算送几个人上去?
答案是两个人,任务形态跟阿波罗差不多。
主持人又追问,市场够吗?能付得起空间站往返票的人本来就不多,能付得起登月价格的人只会更少,真的有两个吗?
法拉内塔给出的数据是:他们开发出了轨道飞行的市场,至少十几个人在排队。每天都能收到更可信的问询。全球范围内,他们识别出大约1500人具备登月的财务能力,其中有了一些扎实的线索。
主持人提到,这批人里很多是在科技行业赚到钱的,天然就倾向做这种事。法拉内塔同意,还补了一点:感兴趣的还有政府,客户不一定是私人。
他最后讲了一段话,是这场对话里最有画面感的表达:
休息的时候出去看看太平洋。你们电脑里大部分零件,都是在太平洋对岸造的。当年跨过那片海洋,大概比今天送一船人去火星还难。月球只有25万英里远,那是一大块没人开发的房地产。(法拉内塔)
他也承认,月球到底能用来干什么,他有一些想法,但不打算硬编一套理由去论证。未来会证明月球的用处。
这场2006年的对话,值得今天重读的三件事
把这场对话当成历史看,会漏掉它真正的价值。它记录的是一个行业从"讲故事"切换到"交东西"的那个时点。主持人开场那句话就是判词:每年这个专场还在,但每年都少一点科幻,多一点现实。
第一件值得重读的,是成本怎么算。马斯克没有说"我们要让太空更便宜",他给的是可比的价格:自己600万美元,本土同行2500万到3000万,翻新洲际导弹1000万到1200万但不可持续。他也没说"我们要去火星",他给的是一个可验证的经济条件:成本降到一个加州中位房价,这件事就会自己跑起来。把宏大的目标和可测的数字绑在一起,这是SpaceX后来能不断压缩成本的方法论起点。
第二件,是那次失败的处理方式。首飞火箭撞了礁石,卫星砸穿屋顶。马斯克在台上主动交代:这次飞行的考核项是快速响应发射演示,卫星是学生造的、是顺带的。这个说法既是事实,也是一种能力:把一次看起来像灾难的失败,重新定义为一次有明确验收标准的测试。此后二十年,SpaceX一直保留着这个习惯,把失败当作数据。
第三件,是法拉内塔那套"用现成技术拼出新任务"的结构。环月方案里没有一样东西是全新研制的:联盟号是老飞船,质子号是老火箭,上面级是苏联登月计划的遗产。他做的事情是把这些模块重新组合,并且用一次太空中的交会对接,绕开了最贵的载人认证。2亿美元、两个座位、一次无人试飞,这个数字背后是极强的结构设计能力,技术突破的分量反而很轻。
至于那些没兑现的部分:2020年送人上另一个星球没有实现,2008到2009年的亚轨道飞行器也没有按期飞起来,环月任务至今没有载人执行。这些都写在记录里,没必要回避。
但另一部分兑现了。马斯克在台上说的那句"希望成为全世界把人送入轨道的主要机制",在2020年代成了事实。NASA真的从自己造火箭变成了买服务。而那枚从太平洋小岛起飞的火箭,后来一次次飞,最终把那家当年创始人要中途离场打电话的公司,送成了行业的主承包商。
如果你只记得一件事
这场对话里最反常识的细节,跟600万美元的火箭无关,也跟1亿美元一个的月球座位无关。它是一颗卫星。
火箭撞了礁石,那颗卫星被弹飞500英尺,砸穿屋顶,劈断一根木梁,落地后几乎完好无损,离自己的集装箱只有50英尺。
马斯克在台上拿它开玩笑,说它想回家。但这个故事真正说明的是另一件事:那个年代的火箭和卫星,是被设计成能扛住极端冲击的。硬件够不够结实从来都不是问题所在,真正的变量在整件事的组织方式、成本结构和监管环境。
这也是为什么这场2006年的对话,聊技术的时间其实不多,聊钱、聊合同、聊签证、聊出口管制的时间反而更多。
- 遇到一个看起来不可能的目标,先去算它的成本结构,别急着讨论它是否可能。马斯克算的是火星票价对标的房价,法拉内塔算的是怎么绕开载人认证这一笔最贵的开支。
- 把大目标拆成能在小尺度上验证的步骤。猎鹰1号的存在意义在于把技术跑通,运货只是副产品。
- 失败发生时,先回到当初约定的验收标准,看这次失败到底证明了什么、没证明什么。首飞撞礁石,从交付卫星的角度是灾难,从演示快速响应发射的角度是数据。
- 设计新方案时,优先盘一遍现成的模块。环月任务里每一个部件都是旧的,新的是组合方式和风险切分。
- 对客户不做价值判断,只要钱是干净的。这条原则让一家早期火箭公司在订单稀少的年份活了下来。
- 把监管和身份问题当成一等一的技术问题来对待。马斯克说五年前他雇不了自己,这句话听起来像抱怨,实际上指出了一条真实的增长瓶颈。
0:07hey chris okay so this is the space panel now and rather like the nanotech panel every year we have the panel and every year it all gets a bit less science fiction and a bit more so i'm very pleased that of the representatives of the new space industry the two we have here elon musk and chris actually flown farrell they've actually built things and there's a lot of talk in the new space sector and here are some people who've actually delivered things elon actually has to get away because he has to talk to nasa at 28 minutes past the hour so we're going to start with elon and and then we're going to hear from you chris and then i hope we'll have a bit of a discussion
0:48with the both of you before you before you have to brush off so i'm sure many of you familiar with with elon musk and with space adventure sorry with spacex but if perhaps you could give us the the elevator pitch just to bring people who aren't familiar with with where you're coming from up to speed certainly so i think we have some videos as well if if you're to play some of the videos that might be a good way to start
1:16all the spacex videos right can we have the first video please well while we're waiting for the video i will describe spacex so anyway since we last saw you you've flown a rocket yes yes so in fact okay so we're gonna see this is a video from our island we launched from a small island in the in the middle of the pacific
1:50just a close lift off let's switch to the next video that's the falcon 1 rocket that you see there so so far so good yeah so the next clip rocket business is a tough business there hasn't been a single rocket in the history of the business that flew the first time hasn't it well no new well no new design yeah space shuttle space shuttle arguably yeah plus three plus four plus five plus six plus seven plus eight plus plus ten we have liftoff confirmed copy good signal strength
2:47this is the ic on the countdown nasty falcon 1 is airborne at this time so that video was taken from a nearby island this is the onboard video camera we're about to see which goes all which is the round trip actually so this camera is on the second stage of the rocket looking down obviously
3:29you may want to skip for a few seconds that's the water deluge system
4:08some insulating phloem still clinging to the rocket okay so we can see there's a bit of a problem there actually no you can't that's not really the nature of the problem the problem occurred right here the engine shut down
4:59all right right so so spacex spacex i founded approximately four years ago with the goal of revolutionizing access to space the it's a simple three-step plan which is build launch vehicles to put satellites into low-earth orbit then step two is build a launch vehicle and spacecraft to provide humans to orbit services to the government and to private sector and then step three would be to provide humans to another planet services to the private sector and the government we started with a small launch vehicle of falcon 1 and the idea behind falcon 1 is to be able to test out all the technologies at a relatively smaller scale and prove that out well before we put
5:53any people on board and this this rocket was carrying a a satellite and you're offering something like is it six million dollars yeah the the falcon 1 launch vehicle is a little over six million dollars a launch it's the lowest cost per flight to orbit of any rocket in the world of any production rocket and how much would you typically have paid for that the if you yeah if you want some with a domestic provider like orbital sciences the cost for an equivalent rocket would be about 25 to 30 million there are lower cost rockets available from from russia and ukraine which are refurbished icvms but those are not really currently in production they're taken off the shelf
6:37and and those are much more competitive they're more in that 10 to 12 million range but that's not a realistic price so the satellite tell us what happened to the satellite i'll board that rocket oh okay so when the rocket hit the hit a dead reef about 200 feet away from the launch pad the satellite got punted like a cannonball
6:59it flew about 500 feet and landed back on the island went through the roof of the machine shop split a 2x6 wooden beam and landed on the floor more or less intact so now satellites are designed to withstand taking off of the rocket can they withstand landing again like that well this was a pretty robust satellite and it actually landed about 50 feet away from its shipping container
7:29and so i think it was trying to get home one way or another but you know at least we can say we never lost a satellite right so you changed i hope i have a non-voodoo microphone now do it does that sound a bit less voodoo that sounds a bit less booty okay cool so when are you going to fly the falcon 1 again then later this year or yeah the next scheduled flight is september october and one thing i should mention about the first flight is it was fundamentally a demo or beta flight it was not about the satellite the satellite was there as an afterthought it was a student built satellite and our customer our beta customer which is darpa defensive mass
8:06research projects agency what they paid for was a responsiveness launch demonstration and in fact they bought another launch demonstration which is in the september october time frame and then we've got launches scheduled every two to three months thereafter now i see from your website that you have a falcon 9 which is the big rocket launch slated for next year is that is that still planned yeah it's either end of next year or possibly early 2008. right the falcon 9 unlike the falcon 1 is a man-rated vehicle it's designed with higher factors of safety and it's much bigger it's much bigger yes it's like 25 tons to orbit kind of stuff it's up to up to 25 tons to orbit yes in fact
8:48we have another version on the drawing board that's not on the website that's capable of putting 50 tons to orbit and that vehicle would be capable of if you did two launches of doing moon missions or mars missions manned moves so this is a saturn v scale thing not quite it's about the the heavy version would be about a third the scale of a saturn five but it's more it's more efficient right so it's capabilities proportionate to its size or better well the other big thing that's changed since last year aside from the fact that you've flown something is the well i want to i want to hear from you how important you think it is that nasa has has put up this contract called cops
9:26which does not stand for commercial off the shelf but kind of does yeah so what does it actually stand for commercial it's commercial orbital transportation services so basically they're saying here's half a billion dollars can somebody build us something that can get to the space station please right and they've now got six companies and you're on the shortlist of six to provide that service they're gonna make the decision in august you're gonna speak to them in about 13 minutes about this do you think that's a big shift is that kind of nasa saying okay there is something to this new space business after all it's a huge shift nasa essentially has put put forward a
9:59as you say a half billion dollar program for a replacement to the space shuttle is what it amounts to so spacex is on the shortlist to build the replacements the space shuttle i think we're the lead candidate and this would be a falcon 9 based yes would it so it would essentially be doing what the soyuz is doing now exactly in fact the falcon 9 in its smallest version is a sawyer's class launch vehicle right and i suppose the question for those of you in this business is historically nasa and the incumbent builders of stuff have been the bad guys and you were sort of well nevermind about them we'll go to mars on our own and all this kind of stuff and now here they are saying well
10:37actually we'd like to buy some services from you i mean is there that is a big change does that require a philosophical change for you as well that you actually have to collaborate with them or do you do you not care who buys your rockets as always someone does i'm acknowledging okay i you know we don't make value judgments about our customers they can put a wheel of cheese into space that money is as good as anyone else's is the point absolutely if they if they want if somebody comes to us and they want to put a wheel of cheese in his face we'll do that okay right oh they're a ham sandwich and they're absolutely into something else so has this resulted you've just had
11:09this conference earlier in the month the you know the where all the new space guys get together in la and what was the mood like that was it a big change from last year has this has this changed the landscape i wasn't at the conference last year but i can't see the the the mood was buoyant right i think there's a there's a lot of new investment coming into the space sector you have guys like obviously jeff bezos paul allen john carmack who did people that you know doom and quake and and seriously it's all these dot-com guys who are who are using the money well technology guys i want to say it's really yeah so you made your money in technology now this is the new the
11:50new frontier okay well i'd like to i'd like to talk to chris then maybe we can have a bit of discussion about something so so chris your company is adventures and you are the go-to guy if you actually want to go into space now and you've got your 20 million dollars is that the price yes yep so you've sent three people to the space station already correct and you've got a queue of others coming through and you also do vomit comet flights don't you and well we don't like to call it that okay sorry we only the reason they call the vomit comic is they they do about 60 parabolas right so they they die for the parents you start feeling sick after about 15 and that's when okay that's
12:26enough that's enough for me and you also do big flights to the edge of space and that's the sort of thing now you're starting to get into the business of actually well you're not building any spacecraft are you but you we outsource our space program and you have you have a russian firm that designed the buran russian shuttle or the people who did that tell us about that because you actually have that we use that we're using the messichev design bureau which designed the the airframe for the boron program so thank you but really we're using the whole russian space program right because of well there's a whole cadre of subcontractors that will be involved so
13:00this vehicle the explorer what right what sort of thing will it let you do well it's a suborbital vehicle it'll go up above 100 kilometers 62 miles and it's reusable it's a reusable rocket plane carried by it's very similar to spaceship one and i should add that we had that design before bert's design right but ours is on top bert's is a drop when do you hope to be able to actually start 2008 2009. so basically in the next three to five years we're going to see competition look we're not just going to see the first first sub-orbital we're going to see i mean we have we have an operational orbital program right now and that's that's what i work on and we're actually developing
13:43a circumlunar program where we're taking we use the soyuz spacecraft to go to the international space station and and actually we have a clip oh you've got a clip as well it's a scenario but the idea is that the soyuz few people know that the soyuz was originally built to go to the moon and this is sort of a thing that was forgotten and we came up with the idea of the circumlunar mission because you know in the unlikely event that the space station isn't available we could still use the soyuz to go somewhere and so we we began developing on this circumlunar mission and we have just how would that work because there are already flights going backwards and forwards to the space
14:23station video can we see the video please and we can just talk over it but i mean the point is that those flights are running already and they're like empty seats that you're putting people in in effect well for the for the space station okay so this is the this is a soyuz fg launch vehicle this is a standard launch vehicle in operation right now i guess the beauty of this mission is that we're using a lot of existing technology and you know the nice thing about the soyuz launcher is that it has a launch escape system so if anything goes wrong with the rocket you can get the crew off and they've actually had to use it on several occasions so that's this is a
15:01launch escape system just being jettisoned fairing and here's the soyuz spacecraft it's a solar powered soul battery powered and so essentially it's it's deployed this is a modified vehicle there we would have to make some modifications to this vehicle in order for it to do the the lunar mission we'd have to beef up the life support system we'd have to thicken the heat shield on it so it would be able to survive the reentry coming back from the moon you come back faster you come back to about 24 000 miles per hour so first phase of the mission would be to go to the space station you'd spend about 16 days there with the crew and then an upper stage
15:44another stage is launched on another launch vehicle and we could we're probably going to use a launcher called the proton now this upper stage is very interesting it was originally developed to carry manned crews to the moon and the russians took that from their lunar program when they canceled it and they used it they're now using it for commercial launches of communications satellites so that upper stage is is essentially put into the same orbit as the space station the crew undocked with their soyuz and and then would rendezvous and dock with the upper stage which essentially would be trailing behind the the space station and i apologize for the sort of
16:24low-grade cgi here and the reason for that is that this is a mathematical model of the actual ballistics of the mission and the animation is kind of an afterthought we were just interested in in the orbital mechanics of this and so the soyuz docks to the upper stage the upper stage fires and puts it into a highly elliptical orbit which would then orbit the the soyuz spacecraft around the the illuminated far side of the moon and we would get within about 60 miles of the lunar surface and it's about two and a half days there and and then two and a half days back and another one of the beauties of this mission is that we don't have to bear the expense of man rating that big
17:08rocket to carry a crew on it it's launched unmanned and so we don't really have to do anything new to the rocket to make it safer the the rendezvous with the upper stage takes place in st in space and so we save a lot of money there and this is this is a 200 million dollar with development and a test flight this is an unmanned test flight this is a 200 million dollar mission 100 million dollars a seat there's two seats available coming soon the price tag is 100 million dollars there for anyone come and see me after this checkbook's out everyone okay so that makes the the 20 million to the you piggyback this on the price and you get you get the free
17:42holiday on the space station throw it in there that's right and so if anything happens to the upper stage let's say the launch is delayed or there's this there's a problem with the stage you still get to go to the space station that's great i'm sure elon's gonna have to go into tech i just wanted to ask because i'm not gonna get the chance to ask you right at the end but where do you see obviously the next year you hope to win this this contract and you hope to fly rockets where do you see this where do you see your company in in three to five years time well i hope that we're the the primary mechanism of getting people to orbit in the world i think that's that's a
18:17realistic possibility so that's where we want to be in three to five years and i frankly by 2020 i'd like to see us take somebody to another planet and do you feel that the space policy is in is sort of up for grabs at the moment i mean there seems to be no one seems to be very happy with the status quo everyone seems to think it's pretty stupid do you think there's a a chance to to completely start over and and to have private enterprise is a big component of it well i think the only way that we're going to become a multi-planet species is through private enterprise it's certainly not going to be through the government not the governments are terrible at
18:55cost optimization and you know so you know i think really to to the point at which becoming a multi-planetary species can happen i think you know point at which it becomes an exothermic reaction is if you can reduce the cost of moving to mars which is i think the only realistic possibility to someone in the order of the cost of the you know the price of median house from california
19:26now so that's one analogy that yeah the price is growing so i think you know that target is getting easier to achieve so every year it gets closer you just stay where you are now my favorite example of this is if you look at the missions to antarctica 100 years ago the the privately funded ones were much cheaper and lost far fewer people than the government funded ones which tended to go wrong so there's a there's a number of interesting analogies here but okay well that's that's great going back to you chris what do you think about the the the current state of play in the industry i mean obviously the nasa seems to be changing its position does that affect you or
20:01does that just mean you have stuff to sell people what really affects us and and this also affects elon is technology transfer barriers the us government seems to think that it has this proprietary space technology and it doesn't want it to proliferate around the world meanwhile india has a very vibrant man's or not man but space program they're building satellites they want satellites to geostationary orbit china has a manned space program and a very vibrant communication satellite program and so this technology is pretty much already proliferated so it's it's very frustrating that to a certain degree we have to be very careful that we don't
20:44transfer any technology to to the russians and and really the the only thing that they could learn from me is what not to do you know and we learn we learn all kinds of stuff about operations from them and it's been very beneficial and but for elon it's it's it's a huge barrier and you know it's actually i wouldn't say it's a huge barrier it's it's a pain in the butt yeah but it is i mean our technology is 100 americans so there's no technology issues there it's just that if we have a non-us customer it takes us six months to get a state department permit to talk to them on and integrate their satellite you know and i think the the biggest single issue
21:22is that we can't hire people who do not have a green card or or not a us citizen so i couldn't have hired myself five years ago which is ridiculous so that's the biggest single regulatory problem you face i mean you have all these other you have the fight going on with over vandenberg and so on but well we have a we have a titanic struggle underway with boeing and lockheed about the right to use the spaceport at vanderbilt oh no that's that's minor we're trying to unseat them for as the primary provider of launch services to the defense department right one of the things they're doing is playing dirty on these these sorts of little things that's our opinion yeah but you hope to
22:02launch for vandenberg next year right so actually probably 2008 all of our launches through 2008 are going to be from our small tropical island in the middle of the pacific i feel that i should have a white cat or something it is it is unbelievable isn't it but the thing is every year you come back and it's there's more and there's more evidence and there's more more going on and it's less fictitious do you regard this 500 million dollar contract as a prize by the way i mean it's well it's not a prize in our sense that it's all awarded at the end only after you achieved everything it is awarded at milestone points right so it is but it incentivizes the industry in the
22:41same way it's not a cost plus contract like the standard development contract in fact there's really there's really two contracts going on one is the crew exploration vehicle contract which is what nasa is developing to return to the moon that that is about a 15 to 20 billion dollar contract right then there's the little itty bitty contract which is the half billion dollar cuts program okay although it's possible that that the cost program ultimately trump the the crew exploration vehicle because you might get your foot in the door and you can then start to do other things yeah possibly yeah okay no it's hot past i'm very aware that you need to call
23:16someone so yeah and i need what if anyone has any questions i'm happy to answer them in the breakout section we've got three minutes now so if anyone would like to come and ask chris anything he's going to stay up here all right go go go make your phone call thank you
23:40two questions one what are your plans on the circumlunar project for dealing with solar flares and killing the crew while they're can't get back any faster than newton's laws which was a problem during apollo they just were lucky basically and then the second question is who do you think is actually going to land on the moon next the u.s the chinese or private industry well i'll answer the second question first will be space adventures and regarding solar flares that nasa they weren't lucky they actually developed the science of solar flare forecasting and there were space probes in orbit and there is a whole essentially fleet of space probes right
24:30now that monitor the sun and there there's a hardened section in the soyuz which can can be used as a radiation shield and the reentry capsule is fairly thick they're actually testing radiation shielding plastic radiation shielding on the space station and so any thick material ideal material would be let's say some form of plastic water is a good radiation insulator so i think we have the problem well under control you have planned then how does that work i mean do you have a well we've identified and exist another existing launch vehicle the lander is essentially under development and we we believe that we can go back to the moon for under two billion dollars
25:20that's an even bigger price tag but how many people would you imagine taking it would be you could get two people back it would be similar to apollo type mission you get is there i mean clearly there's demand there's demand of at least 10 people also for the space station round trips but the number of people who have the kind of money you're talking about for these other things must be even smaller is there are there even two people we developed we developed the the market for orbital and we've we have at least a dozen people in line for that and we we get more credible inquiries every day we've identi identified about 1500 people worldwide that are
26:01financially qualified to do a lunar mission and we have some solid leads now it must help you that a lot of them made their money in the tech industry so they're kind of naturally inclined to do this kind of stuff think about yeah it has and and there are there are governments that are also interested and we don't necessarily have to use a private individual and but you know go during a break go out here and look at the pacific ocean and the the components for most of your computers are made on the other side of the pacific ocean at one time that was a you know crossing that ocean was a lot like it was probably a lot harder than maybe sending a crew to mars
26:44and you know the moon is only 250 000 miles away and it's this huge untapped piece of real estate and you know there we have a few ideas of what it could be used for but i won't even pretend to try and justify it i mean the future will will prove out the moon's utility okay well i think we'll leave it there thank you very much indeed thanks
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版