访谈·中文精读

马斯克:从发射私人火箭到下一代电动车——Future in Review 2009 #FIRE09

Elon Musk From Launching Private Rockets to the Next Electric Cars - Future in Review 2009 #FIRE09

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2008年12月,NASA把一份货运合同交给了一家只有七百多人的公司,最低16亿美元,全部执行完是31亿美元。合同的意思很直白:航天飞机退役之后,往返国际空间站的货物运输,主要交给这家公司。

而就在三个月前,这家公司的火箭才第一次成功入轨。在此之前,它连续失败了三次。

公司叫SpaceX,老板叫埃隆·马斯克。2009年,他在Future in Review(FIRE)大会上讲了一场,把火箭、飞船、电动车、太阳能,还有一笔被媒体反复误读成“政府救助”的贷款,全部摊开讲了一遍。这场对话的技术密度高得不像公开访谈,很多细节平时只在工程评审会上才会被拿出来讨论。

主持人开场讲了个段子:他接到朋友电话,说在沙丘路(Sand Hill Road)上看见一辆车突然腾空,翻了三个跟头,最后栽进灌木丛。朋友说,这听起来特别像我认识的一个人。那是他第一次把马斯克和“速度”放进同一个句子里。后来马斯克飞到星期五港(Friday Harbor)吃了顿午饭,讲了讲火箭的事,那是他第一次听说SpaceX。

八岁那封信,和三十年后的九台发动机

猎鹰1号(Falcon 1)在2008年9月第四次发射成功,成为第一个完全由私人研制的、以液体燃料为动力的入轨火箭。

马斯克特意把“私人”这个词的边界划清楚。轨道科学公司(Orbital Sciences)的飞马座(Pegasus)火箭更早入轨,但它大量使用了军方开发的固体火箭发动机,所以算不上一枚纯粹的私人火箭。猎鹰1号没有这个问题,从发动机到结构,都是自己从头做的。

马斯克对这件事的评价只有一句:“火箭科学(rocket science)之所以是个贬义词,是有原因的。”

猎鹰1号用的是单台梅林(Merlin)发动机。猎鹰9号(Falcon 9)用九台。这个数字背后有一段更早的故事。

马斯克八岁的时候,看美国的火箭,觉得它们都太像猎鹰1号了:一级装一台大发动机,上面再摞一堆死重。

我给沃纳·冯·布劳恩(Wernher von Braun)写了封信,说火箭应该长得像猎鹰9号那样,所有发动机同时点火,不要背任何用不上的重量。(马斯克)

冯·布劳恩没理这个小孩。倒是苏联人干了这件事,R-7火箭和后来的联盟号,一级就是一圈发动机并联点火。这条路子在当年被主流航天界视为异端,因为一台出问题就可能炸掉整个火箭。

马斯克的答案是把异端变成工程优势:九台发动机意味着容错。一台失效,甚至一台在空中爆炸,任务仍然可以完成。具体能承受几台,取决于故障发生在飞行哪个阶段。如果在飞行后期损失第三台,猎鹰9号还能把载荷送进轨道。

这个思路在2009年听起来像是给自己找台阶下,毕竟没人愿意承认自己的火箭需要“容错”。但十年之后,猎鹰9号和星舰走的正是这条路。八岁那封信,某种意义上是真的寄到了。

把加速度压在5个G以内

访谈里有个细节,主持人问得外行,马斯克答得认真。

猎鹰9号在正常飞行中会主动关掉两台发动机。关掉它们跟故障无关,纯粹是控制G载荷。马斯克说得很直接:“我们要把G载荷压在5个G以内。”

人体能承受多少?马斯克的回答分情况。如果人平躺着,身体有支撑面能贴合背部,短时间内可以扛住20个G,几秒钟的量级。但这不会好受,也绝对不会写进宣传册。常规做法是把载人飞行的G值控制在5以下,而且是“压向胸口”的正G。反方向就难得多,那种眼球要被甩出去的负G,人扛得很痛苦。

这段对话看着像科普,其实透露了猎鹰9号的一个设计约束:推力太大,反而要主动关掉一部分。火箭的性能余量,最后要用在保护载荷和人身上,不用全部换成速度。

一次故意的“退步”,让第三次发射没能入轨

猎鹰1号前三次发射都没成功。第三次失败的原因,马斯克讲得最细,因为那是他自己选的。

当时他们有机会在第三次就入轨。只要继续用老发动机,火箭就能上去。但团队决定换成新的再生冷却(regeneratively cooled)发动机,因为这台发动机将来要用在猎鹰9号上,他们想在猎鹰1号上先飞一次,拿到真实的飞行数据。

换句话说,他们主动放弃了入轨,去换一个更重要的东西:猎鹰9号的确定性。

再生冷却是怎么回事?简单说,把燃料当成冷却液。燃料在进入燃烧室之前,先流经燃烧室壁和喷管,把那里的热量带走,然后再喷进去烧掉。马斯克形容它像一台超级换热器,只是工作尺度完全超出日常经验。

他们最早用的是烧蚀冷却(ablative cooling)。燃烧室壁在高温下从里往外一层层烧掉,像一根烧得极快的蜡烛。这条路走不通,才改到再生冷却。

问题出在“关机”这个动作上。再生冷却系统的推力瞬变比烧蚀式长得多。原因很朴素:冷却夹套里存着一些残余燃料,关机之后还会滴滴答答漏出来;液氧也会有一点点蒸发。这点残余产生的推力大约只有正常推力的1%,持续时间一秒多。

地面试车完全看不出来。燃烧室压力只有10 psi,而海平面大气压是14.7 psi,大气压足以把这点残余“堵”在喷口里,仪器上什么都读不到。到了真空,没有大气压兜底,这1%的推力就变成了实实在在的一股力。

后果是这样的:一级和二级该分离了,那股残余推力刚好把两级顶在一起,分不开。然后二级发动机在级间段内部点火。马斯克的原话是:“别在屋里玩火柴。”五千度的等离子体往回吹,把二级烧得面目全非。

他说这是个好消息,因为这个错误在猎鹰1号上暴露了,不用等到猎鹰9号再去学一遍。

第二次失败:一罐会晃的燃料如何杀死一次入轨

第二次失败的原因更微妙,也更像一堂工程课。

二级贮箱里的推进剂在晃(slosh),晃动的频率恰好和二级推力矢量控制系统的频率耦合上了。结果火箭开始“鱼摆尾”(fishtail),摆着摆着变成了锥形运动(coning),像一个快倒的陀螺在地上画圈。

制导系统其实干了件正确的事:它顺着锥形运动走,把平均方向维持在入轨矢量上。从摄像机画面看很吓人,但理论上还能接受。

真正的麻烦出现在燃烧末期。锥形运动把推进剂离心甩到了贮箱侧壁上,发动机的吸入口吸进了一个氦气气泡,然后熄火。位置是入轨前一分钟。

解决方案是两个:加防晃隔板(slosh baffles),改二级控制系统的增益参数。前者改变流体的行为,后者改变控制律对这个行为的反应。

这两次失败放在一起看,有个共同的教训:地面测试再怎么充分,也测不出真实环境里的物理。一个是真空,一个是微重力下的流体行为。两者都不可能在地面完全复现。

首席设计师这个头衔,是招不到人招来的

主持人问他,你一个读物理和经济出身的人,怎么就成了火箭的首席设计师?

我本来没打算当火箭的首席设计师,事情就是这么发展下来的。招不到人,所以只能自己干。(马斯克)

他也承认自己智力并不均衡,好些领域都不擅长,人的聪明分很多种。但说到火箭,他给了一句很硬的话:在SpaceX,没有谁比我更懂这枚火箭。

他的团队里有推进负责人、结构负责人、导航控制负责人、发射运营负责人,都是各自领域的顶尖工程师。他干的活集中在技术路线的裁决上:某个分系统选哪套方案,风险压在哪儿,推进、结构、航电之间怎么交换。

这个“交换”是整场访谈里最有价值的一句话:

有时候你可以在一个领域把事情做得非常轻松,但代价是另一个领域变得极其困难。我的工作就是在两者之间做仲裁。(马斯克)

很多人以为总设计师的活是“什么都懂一点”,实际是“知道每个决定的代价落在谁头上”。

顺便说个细节。主持人介绍他是斯坦福的,他当场更正:他被斯坦福录取了,也打算去,开学两天后给系主任打电话,把研究生学业搁置了。他当时跟系主任说,自己大概会回来。1995年那个夏天,他觉得最可能的结局是创业失败,然后回学校继续读书。结果没回去。

龙飞船:三冗余、四冗余,和一个歪脖子的锥体

龙飞船(Dragon)是SpaceX的货运飞船。猎鹰9号负责把它送上轨道,它自己用推进器调整轨道,靠近空间站,对接,卸货,然后脱离,返回地球。

为此他们专门做了一款小推力发动机,叫天龙座(Draco),单台推力100磅。这东西单看很不起眼,麻烦在于要装很多台,而且方向要覆盖所有姿态,因为它得在空间站旁边做精细操作。

对接时的冗余要求是:能同时失去任意两台推进器,仍然安全。马斯克的原话是,他们不想在太空里制造车祸。

飞行计算机更夸张,四台,做投票(voting)。要对抗软错误(soft error)做到双故障容错,四台是数学上的最低配置,跟洁癖式的冗余无关。

返回这一段,马斯克的解释值得单独拿出来讲,因为大多数人对胶囊式飞船的理解是错的:它其实受控再入,只是没有翅膀。

控制方式靠两样东西。第一,返回舱大约有0.25到0.3的升阻比,也就是说它在高速再入时会产生一点升力。第二,重心故意不放在几何中心上,整个舱体就像一个歪脖子的锥体。这两样加起来,它就有了一个可调的升力矢量。想往左偏,用推进器把舱体转一下,升力方向就跟着变。转动所需的力量很小,控制权限却很大。

阿波罗时代就能把落点精度控制在一英里半径内。误差主要来自惯性测量单元(IMU)的精度和风。把IMU误差消掉之后,无风的日子,它能落在数字上。

回收方式也顺便讲了:一开始是海面溅落,落点离加州海岸很近,直升机直接过去把整个舱吊起来带回陆地。海军、海岸警卫队,甚至森林灭火用的那种吊水直升机都能干这活。

至于陆地着陆,技术上可行,但需要末段减速机构。要么像跳伞运动员那样,落地前用气动活塞把伞收一下;要么像俄罗斯人那样上反推火箭。没有这套东西,陆地着陆就是硬砸。

航天飞机退役后,谁给空间站送货

2008年12月,SpaceX拿到了商业补给服务合同(CRS)。CRS是运营合同,COTS奖项只是能力演示,两个合同的分量完全不一样。

CRS最低16亿美元,NASA全部行使选择权是31亿美元。马斯克引用了一句别人的话:“现在才算在谈真金白银。”

合同的实际含义是:航天飞机2010年底退役以后,SpaceX成为国际空间站货物运输的主要替代方案。宇航员运输暂时交给俄罗斯的联盟号。马斯克对此的评价是“相当尴尬”,美国不该在这件事上依赖俄罗斯人。

他希望能说服NASA在这一年就让他们做载人运输的演示。刺激法案里有大约1.5亿美元是划给商业载人演示的。这笔钱正在被某些参议员阻挠。主持人问是哪一党的,马斯克说是共和党,具体是阿拉巴马州的谢尔比(Shelby)参议员。阿拉巴马是洛克希德和波音的大本营,这两家正在做另一套火箭。

这段对话没有愤怒,也没有阴谋论,就是陈述产业地理。

猎鹰9号的订单簿上当时有21个任务,总价值略超20亿美元。发射节奏也讲了:猎鹰1号初期一年飞两三次,之后到一年六次左右。猎鹰9号会更频繁,因为它的市场更大。

猎鹰1号只能送小卫星。猎鹰9号能接三类活:NASA的空间站补给、商业广播卫星、通信卫星。虽然单次报价高得多,但可服务的总量更大,所以发射次数反而更多。这是个容易被忽略的商业逻辑:贵的东西不一定卖得少,得看它能干多少种活。

卡纳维拉尔角的工位也讲了两句。他们接手的是泰坦四号(Titan IV)原来的发射台,美国现役最大运载火箭退役后留下的重型工位。猎鹰9号不需要泰坦四号那些庞然大物,比如巨大的移动服务塔。设计上采用水平组装:火箭在机库里躺平装好,拖到发射台再起竖。马斯克给团队定的设计指标是:从机库到升空,60分钟以内。

老式发射塔的移动速度是三到五英里每小时,走完全程要很久。猎鹰9号轻得多,全程不含推进剂只有4万磅,180英尺长,走的路也短。这个指标当时还做不到,需要几次发射来磨合,但它被写进了设计需求。

戴姆勒想要什么,特斯拉想要什么

话题转到特斯拉。马斯克的时间分配是SpaceX和特斯拉各占一半。

特斯拉和戴姆勒(Daimler)合作了一年半,做电动版Smart。奔驰的工程师和特斯拉的工程师互相看得上眼,原因很实在。

戴姆勒能给的:梅赛德斯供应链的准入、工程和生产方面的经验、量产体系。特斯拉能给的:世界领先的电动动力总成能力。

这笔合作里有一层更深的动机。戴姆勒投资特斯拉,最大的单一因素就是Model S。他们把这款电动轿车当成整个品类的风向标。如果Model S做砸了,所有人都会说电动轿车这条路走不通。所以戴姆勒希望它尽可能好,愿意把供应链开放出来帮它。

马斯克对特斯拉的定位说得很清楚:想成为一家严肃的汽车公司,产品线从跑车一路铺到经济型车和卡车,但不为规模而规模。第三代车型的目标是年产10万到20万台,价格压在3万美元以下。

这个数字放在汽车行业里是微不足道的。主持人说这是“显微级别”,马斯克同意。但他补了一句:从那儿可以往上长。

一辆轿车的空间是怎么变出来的

Model S的布局值得单独讲,它从电池这个约束倒推出来。

电池包放在地板下面,卡在前后轴之间。电机、变速箱、电力电子器件平铺在后轴之后。结果车头没有发动机,就有了前备箱;车尾有后备箱。马斯克的说法是:Model S的行李空间超过任何一款轿车,包括比它大得多的轿车。

后排座椅可以往前放倒。他举的例子很具体:能同时塞进一块冲浪板、一台50寸电视、一辆山地车。用他的话说,还需要什么?

座舱是五加二。五个成年人,加后排两个儿童座椅。车身形态是掀背车,不是三厢。为了在造型和功能之间找平衡,团队做了不少取巧的布置。

性能参数:标准版0到60英里加速5.6秒,对一辆轿车来说相当够用。最高时速130英里。续航最高300英里。五个乘客满载时会略低于300,两个人开差不多能跑满。

造型和功能的矛盾,马斯克用了一个很形象的说法:你可以把车做得很流线,但那样一来尺寸就变成超模身材,功能全废。

45分钟和3分钟

充电是电动车的死穴,访谈里花了很长一段讲这个。

Model S的充电时间是45分钟。马斯克认为这是个关键的临界点,因为它刚好等于一顿午饭的时间。城市之间跑长途,路边吃个饭,车在餐厅旁边的车位上充电,吃完就走。

这套充电方案已经跑通,实验室里就有。所谓4500充电,指的是400到440伏的直流电直接给电池包充电,用的是非车载充电器。它是车上那套充电系统的升级版本,没有停留在纸面上。

充电站会装在哪里?高速公路的休息站。马斯克判断休息站能从中获利,因为它会把车流引到餐厅和礼品店。特斯拉会免费安装一批,先把事情跑起来,摸清问题,再谈规模。

另一条路是换电。电池包被设计成3到5分钟能拆换下来。技术上可以做到一分钟以内,但那没必要。3到5分钟是什么概念?就是你换笔记本电池的时间,只不过尺寸大一点。马斯克的说法是,这东西本质上就是一个放大版的笔记本电池。

用户会选哪一种?他也不知道。所以策略是保留选择权(optionality),两种都做。最坏的情况下,快换结构也就是让日常维修更方便一点。

城市内部需要充电站吗?马斯克的算术很干脆:250英里续航,城市平均时速25到30英里,等于每天8到10小时的驾驶能力。除了家里和公司,你为什么要去别的地方充电?

短期内,长途需求靠家里的第二辆车解决。大部分家庭有两台车,一台烧油跑长途,一台电动跑日常。这套方案只覆盖过渡期,但够用。

3.5万美元的账怎么算

Model S定价5万美元,含联邦补贴。这个数字一出,现场的反应是“这可不便宜”。马斯克当场把账重算了一遍。

他先讲了一个对比:电费比油费便宜太多了。把五年省下的油钱折现,一辆5万美元的Model S,等价于一辆3.5万美元的汽油轿车。

听众的反问很典型:我不想等五年才把这笔钱省回来。

他的回答是租赁。你可以租Model S,也可以租一辆汽油轿车,从第一天起,月供的差额就是省下来的钱。不需要等待期,现金流当场就对上了。

3.5万美元买到的是什么?他给的锚点是宝马5系。质量、做工、功能都对标那个级别,价格是那个级别的一半。他在戴姆勒的活动上想讲这个点,被现场气氛压住了没讲成。

美国以外的情况更极端。欧洲油价大约是美国的两倍,政府补贴力度更大。伦敦进城要交拥堵费,一天10英镑。去年夏天伦敦的油价是每加仑10美元。加上欧洲城际距离本来就短,电动车的账算起来更好看。

电动版Smart年底出第一批车,投放地点由戴姆勒决定。马斯克希望有一部分能分到美国,但这款车在欧洲和任何其他地方都能被市场吃干净。戴姆勒已经让特斯拉报了一个很大的量,如果真按那个量走,就是量产成本。

另外还有一个没公布的车型项目,年底可能宣布。

Roadster那边也有更新。Roadster Sport的0到60加速做到3.7秒,配可调悬挂。从6月起,所有Roadster的内饰都会升级。

那笔被说成“政府救助”的贷款

访谈最后,马斯克专门澄清了一件事,语气里带着明显的不满。

特斯拉没有拿过任何政府资金,一分都没有。市面上流传的很多说法是错的。

特斯拉申请的是一笔贷款,来自ATVM项目,全称先进技术车辆制造(Advanced Technology Vehicle Manufacturing)贷款。这个项目跟当前的经济危机没有关系,国会两年前就开始写立法了,是一个独立的、为了推动从汽油向电动转型的低息贷款计划,总盘子250亿美元。

特斯拉申请了大约4.65亿美元,不到5亿,占整个项目的2%左右。剩下的98%流向通用、福特、克莱斯勒。

马斯克在这里说了一句颇有分寸的话,他说自己有信心,同样一笔钱给到这些公司里任何一家,特斯拉会用出最大的效果。这话不算谦虚,但也没直接贬低谁。

这笔贷款对Model S意味着什么,他给了一条清楚的时间线。去年因为经济环境,Model S的开发资源从30%砍到10%,还裁了员。之后一点点回补,回到20%。戴姆勒的投资进来,可以加速。能源部的贷款一旦批下来,就是全速推进,资源占比会升到60%到80%。

量产时间:2011年底。距离当时还有两年半。

预订量已经过了一千台。订金5000美元,作用是确保你拿到最早下线的那批车。

顺便说一下当时公司的规模。SpaceX七百二三十人,SolarCity大约五百人,特斯拉接近五百人,加起来一千八百人左右。一家造火箭的公司,比一家做太阳能安装的公司人还少。

SolarCity那一段讲得很短。尽管经济形势很差,第一季度收入同比翻了三倍。管理层还有点不满意,马斯克的反应是:同比翻三倍已经相当可以了。公司已经是美国中小规模(非公用事业级)太阳能安装市场的最大供应商。太阳能税收抵免的改进会在7月生效,对生意有帮助。

他也是在那一段承认,自己基本不花时间管SolarCity,那家公司本身运营得很好。

这场访谈值钱的地方

十六年过去了,回头看这场对话,最值得琢磨的地方,是他解释问题的路径。

火箭失败三次,他讲的第一层是物理,第二层是地面测试的局限,第三层才是“幸好这个错我们早犯了”。Model S卖5万美元,他不辩解价格,直接把油钱折现、把租赁方案摆出来,把决策门槛从“五年回本”降到“这个月月供”。有人骂他拿政府钱,他不用情绪回应,而是把项目名称、立法时间、申请金额、占比全部报一遍。

这些话术含量很低,内核是把复杂问题拆成可验证的单元,然后一个一个交代清楚。

对做技术、做产品的人来说,这场访谈里有几条可以直接拿走的东西:

  • 做系统权衡时,把每个决定的代价写清楚。推进上省的事,结构上要还。省下来的复杂度不会消失,只会转移。开会时先问一句“这个简化谁付账”。
  • 警惕只在台架上成立的测试结论。真空、微重力、极端温差、真实用户,这些环境里的物理和实验室不一样。猎鹰1号那1%的残余推力,地面上永远读不出来。关键系统要争取在真实环境里飞一次,哪怕代价是推迟一次成功。
  • 冗余要按“能失去几个”来设计,别按“多装几个”。对接要能失去任意两台推进器,软错误要双故障容错,所以计算机得四台做投票。先把容错指标定下来,硬件数量是算出来的结果。
  • 主动放弃一次小胜,换取关键系统的实飞数据。第三次发射本来能入轨,他们换发动机换掉了这次成功。判断标准是:这个错误如果留到下一代产品上,代价翻几倍。
  • 定价被质疑时,重算账,别辩护。把使用成本折现,把付款方式改成月供,把对比对象换成用户熟悉的东西(宝马5系)。让客户在自己的账本上完成决策。
  • 找合作伙伴,先想清楚对方缺什么。戴姆勒缺电动动力总成,特斯拉缺量产体系和供应链。互补的谈判能谈成,单向求助的谈判谈不成。
  • 碰到事实被误读,用可核对的数字回答。项目名称、立法年份、申请金额、占比,四句话说完。事实清单比情绪声明有力得多。
  • 新产品先想清楚使用场景的边界。城市里不需要充电站,因为每天的通勤里程远小于续航;长途靠第二辆车过渡。把不必要的基建需求砍掉,产品的落地成本会低一个量级。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:06so i was talking to this friend of mine and he said i was just the radio in the morning and i heard about this this car that suddenly on sand hill road it kind of lifted up and turned around three times and ended up in the bushes someplace that sounds an awful lot like my friend elon and i think that was the first time i'd heard about you and speed in the same in the same sentence and then i got a phone call and this guy said i'd like to come up to talk to you in friday harbor about this idea i've got would you be available for lunch and you flew up and that was the first time i heard about about spacex there are there may be people in the world who don't know what you're doing

0:44i doubt it but in that case chairman ceo and product architect of tesla motors ceo and cto of space exploration technologies and chairman and principal shareholder of solar city the leading provider of solar power systems in california obviously lots of time for hobbies and collecting stamps so we're gonna talk about a lot of things pretty fast today and i think maybe what we ought to start with is my favorite film from the last 12 months okay if that's if that's all right with you so those of you who didn't happen to see this my son and i watched this in real time on the net that was one of those moments let's let's take a look at this movie

1:52triggered you got it five last 20 seconds first stage propulsion is nominal

3:12return we've answered confirmed all right 175 kilometers this transmission is coming to you you've got it this transmission transmission is coming to you you've got it

4:48good night thanks but it's certainly nice to come back to fire and actually got into orbit you know the last couple times yeah we had some took a little while yeah we were close but best things in life take a little while really really totally cool thanks so let's talk about that first we'll start with rockets falcon 1 we just saw it happen first private launch into space right yeah orbital i mean it's falcon 1 is arguably the the first fully privately developed rocket to reach orbit and certainly it's unequivocally the first liquid first privately developed liquid fuel rocket to reach orbit there was the pegasus from orbital sciences although that did rely on a lot

6:27of solid rocket motors that had been developed for the military so it wasn't private and yes but it's certainly yeah pretty pretty tough i have to say there's a reason why it's called rocket science yeah right you've used that line before so now where do we go we falcon one is going to go again in july is that right yeah okay and and with what payload that'll be carrying a satellite for the government of malaysia it's an basically an earth monitoring satellite for monitoring natural natural disasters like floods and fires and that kind of thing right from malaysia right i i assume that basically the dream for that part of the program now is just to roll it out just just

7:18start launching doing launches yeah fill up the calendar with with customers and every every how often you think well falcon one i think will probably initially fly you know two to three times a year and then probably getting up to around half a dozen flights and if falcon 9 the bigger rocket we actually think will probably fly more frequently because it has both it has a larger market that that it can access right nasa space station resupply emissions commercial broadcast and telecommunications satellites and so this even though falcon 9 costs a lot more the market's actually bigger until there's a total number of launches bigger market yeah so

8:01yeah would you keep using quash line for i'm saying for your falcon one launches yeah yeah and we're actually probably going to build a falcon 9 launch slider kwajalein as well to take advantage of the low latitude yes and 90 degrees north latitude -huh all right so let's so everybody understands what we're talking about here let's talk in one the definition of one is its first and also it's using a single engine a single merlin engine falcon 9 uses nine engines right yeah and for those of us who are old enough to remember this this kind of takes us back to saturn five or right delta four or you know some of the the big rockets saturn five was for the biggest

8:37is that right yeah there was a russian rocket that was that had more thrust yeah but yeah i mean the biggest american biggest american rocket and and certainly the biggest rocket that ever successfully reached orbit yeah the russian russians had something called the n1 which had some spectacular failures yeah and certainly on certain metrics the saturn 5 is the largest rocket ever ever built even bigger than the n1 volumetrically for example right i know i told you the story when we were having lunch with that first meeting but when i was eight years old i was looking at the us rockets that were like falcon one and wrote a letter to warner von braun that they should all

9:13look like falcon 9 and have all the you know all the firing all the engines at once right and don't carry any dead weight you don't have to carry you get it all done but he didn't believe in that the russians had it though the russians said it boss stock and some other rockets yeah so falcon 9 yeah falconer also has the advantage that it has engine out capability so if you if if there's a malfunction on an engine or even an explosion on an engine it can actually complete its mission successfully you can afford to lose how many one depends on the phase of flight we can lose up to three if the third if the third one occurs late in latent flight right

9:52and pretty wild stresses in terms of navigation no it's we actually in a normal flight of falcon 9 we shut off two of the engines to control g loading okay it's that big that's that good yeah we want to keep the g loading top it out in five g's five all right and what are the what does the human take before he blacks out well it depends on your orientation humans can take very high g loading if they're flat flat in the bed you know like lying lying on their back yeah yeah and if you're in a say on a soft or you know something that can conform to your body so would you say very high the number would be you for short periods you could take 20 g's oh really yeah for

10:38a few seconds type of thing but you wouldn't want to he would not that would not be pleasant yeah you wouldn't put that in the brochure really no i think as a general rule you want to keep g loading for humans under five okay and and but that's five kind of going into your chest yeah negative it's much harder to take negative these sort of eyeballs out yeah yeah g's are a lot harder to take

11:03we've all seen that yeah okay so yeah the the testing that you when you go through this the part part of what you're doing with this stuff it all blows my mind i mean it's all just totally impressive but one of the parts that i like the best and i know you're you know stanford train not really actually i was oh i really never actually went to stanford we've rewritten them well i was accepted at stanford and i was gonna go to stanford and two two days into the quarter i called the chair of the department and asked put my grad studies on hold so i told him i'd probably be back you know it's the bill gates approach to higher ed all right well this summer of 95 it

11:44was like either i you know i was going to either do my first internet i i thought actually the most likely outcome was that it would fail and then i would be back at school that was the most likely idea i thought but it it worked out okay okay i'll skip that part yeah but what does it say is even though whatever training you've had the fact that you could kind of walk into this situation cto right yeah it wasn't my intention to be the chief designer of the rocket it just worked out that way people say things like that i don't know what to do with it i didn't mean to do the atom bomb it's just on my lap you know right well it really wasn't it's just that i wasn't able to hire

12:26anyone and so i had kind of had you know i had to do it there's no there's no way through this tunnel without just well we i do have very good people in these specific areas of expertise right so so we i have you know a great guy who's who heads up propulsion guy heads up structures and the one who hands up against navigation and control another one he ends up launch operations yeah so your job is to manage them basically right to kind of yeah and so i mean we're really good kind of generals if you will and but you know my job is to say well okay we're presented with a few different technology choices in those areas which ones do we take where do we take the

13:08risk where are the system trade-offs between propulsion structures avionics because you know sometimes you can make you make things really easy in one area but then you make it way more difficult than another area that's how you arbitrate between those two yeah but i mean i know the rocket inside and out i mean i certainly isn't anyone that knows rocket better than i do at spacex so i'll just say it it's just because you're so damn smart there's no excuse for this there's no other way a guy could do what you just did you just you've just well i have high engineering redone the whale or something here yeah i'm very impressed but but there's definitely different

13:47types of intelligence and i'm not that smart in a lot of ways all right we'll talk about those later but you're very good at rockets so what i was gonna ask also is i assume in your own kind of private lifestyle as you're going through the original design the first very first iteration of falcon one final you finally go through all the heartbreaks not stuff launch what yeah and you get it done your perspective on how to launch a new rocket probably evolves with that experience yeah absolutely and so falcon 9 comes up and i see things like here's the first test of the first engine right here's the first test the multi-engine it looks like you're really methodically

14:23going through this thing and yeah yeah trying to anticipate which one it assumes you would do it anyway but so i guess the question here is is that true and describe that process well for sure the experience of falcon 1 is extremely helpful with with falcon 9 and not just that but also the the component hardware in falcon a lot of that is heritage from falcon 1.

14:49on purpose intentionally absolutely so in fact the reason we didn't get to orbit on flight 3 of falcon wine was because we used we decided to swap out the main engine and use the the the upgraded main engine that would be used in falcon 9 in order to have flight experience with that engine before we got to falcon 9. if we kept the old engine in there we would have got forward on flight 3.

15:12but the new engine which is something called which is called it's a term called a regeneratively cooled which is means you've you use the the fuel as a cooling medium to you flow it through the chamber and and nozzle before it goes into the chamber to get combusted it's like a heat exchanger before you yeah it it's it's like a super super heat exchanger i mean but it's at a scale that's just not any kind of normal frame of reference i mean didn't the russians do that kind of sure and americans absolutely in fact that's that's an example of an error that we made in development which is that we decided to use initially a an ablatively cool chamber ablative just means it kind of

15:56burns away from the inside right like a really hot candle yeah and that ultimately would was that turned out not to be a good a good path and so we went regen and and that's been great actually but but one of the nuances of the regen system was that the thrust transient is longer with a region than an ablative system because you've got some residual fuel in the cooling jacket and it trickles out and that's the issue that we had with flight three was that that thrust transient ended up being just just a few seconds actually about a second and a quarter we're firing too long we were trying to separate right well yeah so as that residual fuel trickles out and

16:41then there's also a little bit of liquid oxygen that's boiling off yeah you get this very slight residual thrust it's about one percent of normal thrust and you actually don't even see it on the on the test stand because the the the thrust chamber point seven pounds right fourteen point seven psi is is sea level is enough to keep it air pressure yeah right and and so and the the chamber pressure here was 10 psi yeah so an obvious screw up right

17:09i don't miss that we didn't see any we didn't see any issues on the on the test stand but when it got to vacuum that was enough to generate about a about one percent thrust for a little over a second yeah and and and so we we initiated stage separation there was just a little bit of thrust that was just enough to keep it together keep it together and then the second stage effectively the second stage engine lift indoors which is bad that idea

17:40don't play with matches inside have the basically blue 5 000 degree plasma back at the second stage and and and fried it pretty badly yeah so anyway that's an example of of you know it's a good thing we were able to learn that on falcon 1 and it's not something we need to learn with falcon 9.

18:04and and then we've made improvements to the the structural efficiency and using some some more advanced materials you put some flanges inside so the fuel would move differently you had that rotation issue right and that get fixed well we've had so many issues yeah never mind there's a lot of checklists of yeah i mean there was yeah i'm not sure which specific issue you're referring to but there's been so many but the fuel was moving in a strange way that caused rotation problems on the two flight i think yeah and oh just by putting it down

18:49production tank of the second stage was sloshing and that slash the frequency of the thrust the second stage thrust vector system yeah so basically engine would it sort of potentially kind of resonating or something yeah it's a fishtail then this results in kind of a coning motion yeah which actually the the guidance system control system just merely sort of coned along along the initial along the main insertion vector and that would have been okay even though it looked crazy on the on the on the camera where that became a problem is just toward just as it was nearing the the end of it of its burn because it was during this coning motion the

19:41propellant was getting centrifuged to the to the side wall of the tank and so it ran it basically sucked in a helium bubble and flamed out about a minute before orbit insertion on flight two yeah and we solve that problem with the slash baffles and changing the gains in the same stage control system all right so let's go back to nine and now you've done the single engine testing in texas this is quite an operation well you've got the texas yeah what's what's it called the texas texas test site yeah the texas we just call it texas all right and in texas you have done other single engine firings you've done the multi-engine firings you did the

20:27dragon i recently did the dragon thruster firings yes so and dragging it do you want to describe dragon for a second yeah so dragon is our spacecraft so you think your falcon 9 is is the booster that delivers the dragon spaceship or spacecraft to orbit and then it goes to a parking orbit near the space station and then dragon will with its onboard thrusters synchronize its orbit with the space station approach birth deliver the cargo you know back away and return return back to earth and and we developed a special engine for dragon called the draco thruster which is just a little 100 pounder but you have to have a lot of them because of the the fact that you got to

21:11do this careful steering yeah you've got to essentially dock with the space station so you have to have thrusters that are pointing in all directions and are redundant and and you you have to have triple redundancy when you're approaching the space station so you if you can you have to be able to lose any two thrusters and still be okay they don't want car accidents up there right yeah it's pretty hardcore yeah and then the the flight computers are actually quad redundant really yeah the quadrodon to avoid a we have to have voting and in order to have two failure tolerance against a soft error you have to have four computers no kidding compared to the old apollo 13 this is

21:52quite something yeah yeah yeah absolutely quite cool and when you land is it a sea landing or a land land well initially it's going to be a sea landing and we'll dragon will land just off the coast of california one thing that isn't sometimes appreciated with what looks like a you know with a capsule type architecture is that it actually is a controlled reentry it looks like you know how can you control it because there's no wings but the way you control it is by having you have a lift vector so it's about a 0.25 to 0.3 left over drag and then you

22:26have an offset center of gravity or center of mass so it's kind of like a tilted cone yeah and and and you can control that lift vector because you can just rotate the rotate the vehicle so you have something with it's coming in with a lift vector that looks like this and then you can just rotate the thing and it'll go that way or rotate this vector goes that way and the rotation is done with the onboard thrusters and that requires very little force just gives you a lot of control yeah in fact even in apollo in the polar era they were able to get the the capsule to a landing accuracy of of one mile radius yeah and and that one and and that error was

23:00a function of in the imu the initial measurement unit inaccuracy to some degree but then also the fact that and wind wind yeah so we can completely remove any inaccuracy except for wind related inaccuracy so if it's a calm day it'll literally range right down on the numbers and so so we we can bring in so you've got your boats out there or is it going to be yeah all those davey boats no no navy navy is expensive well i thought so and and no they're actually faster ships that we can well actually we're not going to use ships i should say for dragon it's going to be landing close enough to the coast that we can send a helicopter out to go pick it up okay

23:44so she's going to pick the whole capsule out of the water and bring it bring it back to land and we can use either a navy chopper or a coast guard chopper or a you know like one of the the choppers that drops water on forests you know that kind of thing yeah and i'm just gonna mention that from texas we jump over to florida and you already have a cape canaveral site this is from green fields right this is built from no the cape canaveral site is actually we've taken over the former titan iv site really so the titan 4 used to be the largest it's retired now but it was the largest vehicle in the u.s fleet and so it's a great launch pad for us because it's a

24:26heavy lift launch pad now we don't need a lot of the things that that titan 4 needed such as the you know the big mobile service tower and all that sort of stuff the way that we've designed falcon 9 is that it's a horizontal integration it comes out to the pad rotates vertical and then and then goes and the design requirement i've said is it's got to be able to go from the hangar to in the air in under 60 minutes you know that no it's going to take us several launches to get there yeah but but that's pretty tricky because you go to it's only three to five it used to be three to five miles an hour on those old machines i don't know how fast you're moving oh i i mean ours will so

25:01can certainly go faster than that plus less distance to cover yeah and and much less mass yeah you know with this with the space shuttle you've got those big solid rocket boosters which have you know yeah they've got the propellant in there yeah so it's super heavy right our cases i mean the falcon 9 without propellant weighs about 40 000 pounds nothing it's nothing it's 180 feet long yeah right okay and and the next anticipated i guess i should insert the cots thing so congratulations we already talked about that once you got the cots award that's still in place yeah well more important the cost award was an award for basically demonstration of

25:47capability but we in december we were awarded the cargo resupply services contract which is the operational contract and that's what i'm really referring to right yeah and and that that's a minimum of 1.6 billion upwards of 3.1 billion if they fully exercise so as ed dirksen would say now we're talking real money right yeah so that i mean what that means essentially is that nasa has picked spacex as the primary replacement for the space shuttle as far as cargo transport to the space station and back is concerned okay so the space shuttle retires at the end of next year and we will take over at full cargo the russian soyuz will take over for a

26:24shuttle as far as astronaut transport but what we hope to get done this year is have nasa ask us to demonstrate astronaut transport as well so we'll take a we'll replace the soyuz because i think that that's really kind of embarrassing that you know the u.s would have to rely on russians and you've totally anticipated my next question so so when would be the most likely earliest manned flight that you would conduct well it depends on if nasa asks us to to do the demonstration is willing to to help us help fund that if that occurs this year and there is some money in the stimulus by the way so there's about 150 million in the stimulus in it towards

27:08what's called commercial crew demonstration yeah although that's being fought by certain senators of course i won't even ask what party they're from unfortunately they're from the republican party right we've had some opposition from senator shelby in alabama which is where lockheed and boeing have some very big operations yeah okay so so you're set to go on all those fronts falcon one is set to go for july falcon 9 is set to go for september october november somewhere in there one from kwajalein one from cape canaveral building 40 yeah and and then the we're just gonna assume a slight delay on the countdown on nine it's the first time and then a

27:55successful launch and when that happens this is the same store where you start putting nine on a regular schedule and yeah absolutely well we actually have 21 missions on manifest for falcon 9 21 right yeah what's the topic besides nasa yeah you know what's the total value of all those missions i haven't actually added up when you count sheep at night that's what you're counting isn't it cargo visions it's a little over two billion okay yeah it's another sns poker chip so you got two chips though right four billion pretty good i i'd love to talk about this for 19 more hours but i see we better very quickly switch over i'm just going to mention solar city is that going great

28:36yeah it is solar city actually despite the the negative economy tripled its revenue in the first quarter in a quarter of a quarter you know quarter one last year versus quarter one this year and did the three exits revenue now i mean they're a little disappointed actually yeah i mean i think i tried telling me like hey guys you know tripling year over year is pretty good yeah but so so they've done they're actually doing pretty well overall and there's some you know some improvements to the the solar tax credits and all that stuff that was good that worked out right yeah although those haven't come into some of them haven't come into effect yet they're

29:26supposed to come into effect in july and so that's going to be really helpful yeah solar city is currently the the largest provider of solar power for small medium-sized installations basically outside of the utility scale yeah installations in the united states right so they're they're really doing doing a great job and yeah which i was trying to say thank you thank goodness i i don't really spend any time on solar city they're just awesome yeah i kind of i mean you're allocating mostly towards spacex isn't that well actually it's it's about 50 50 between spacex and tesla nice segway so tesla

30:02i guess by now everyone here has either ridden in the roadster seen the roadster drooled over the roadster dreamed of having the roadster and let's just do the deal so that you were in stuttgart two nights ago we all talked about this for the last two days circuit is lovely this time of year i'm glad to hear it you'll probably see it again so tell us what happened what what's the deal with daimler well so we've been working with daimler for about a year and a half on an electric smart and they've been a great partner very very easy to work with and they're they've got some really good engineers i think that you know they sort of feel the same way about tesla

30:44and they that they actually are quite interested in helping us with the model s because they see that as kind of a bellwether for you know electric sedans yes and and they want it they want that to be a good car so that it's not sort of impaired in some way that that you know so they wanted to be the best possible car that it can be and so they're giving us access to to the mercedes supply chain to engineering production expertise because it tesla is a world-leading capability as far as electric power training and they recognize that and but where tesla is not as strong is is on the traditional automotive side of things you know with the noise vibration and

31:28handling and you know just the things all the you know mass mass production and that kind of thing so they want to help us out with that production is a huge new yeah world i mean that's just going to mass production you're you're into production on the roadster going to mass production is going to be a big deal yes yeah yeah and you retain the dream of this being a big car company is that true well you know i think we we do want to have a big can mean lots of things so i think we certainly want to be a serious car company and have a wide range of models ranging from sports cars all the way to economy cars and trucks and that kind of thing i don't i i wouldn't want to pursue size

32:12for its own sake yeah you know and and i don't i think that's that's the fullest game you know you you want to just be focused on making good products and make trying to make every every product that comes out a little better than the last put it in a different way when you look at internally at production of the s what do you see in five years how many cars you making well without third generation we'd like to step it up by an order of magnitude so we'd like to be in in kind of the 100 to 200 000 units a year all right with with the third generation and have a a price point below 30 000 okay that's a pretty big car cut well among car companies that's tiny

32:52small yeah that's microscopic yeah i understand but it could go from there to being bigger yes okay absolutely all right we are almost out of time i want to see the dragon thing so we can roll that quickly yeah this is a you want to key this in this is yeah so this is a simulation of falcon line with dragon out of the dragon spacecraft and i i think this is the crew configuration version all right

33:19t-minus 45 seconds and counting dragon spacecraft is on internal power spacex is go for launch 3. launch vehicle carrying the cots d crew to london with the international space station

34:04second stage standing by for escape tower escape tower jettison confirmed all systems are nominal for dragon separation dragon separation confirmed

34:47dragon is on final approach confirm docking is complete preparing for ingress

35:29foreign we can make it land on land but there needs to be some final velocity attenuation mechanism such as either you know having a pneumatic piston pull the chutes just before it lands like like a parachutist would do it or the russians use retro rockets when there was so we can make it land on land i mean in fact in land on land without that it just would be a really hard landing yeah so it doesn't have to land on the ocean gotcha before we finish here give me the quick rundown on the specs for the sedan and for the new roadster so the okay so roughly you know five-seater yeah so the sedan is actually five adults plus two kids wow two kid

38:18seats in the rear so it's kind of it's actually a hatchback and we've done some sort of creative things to get the packaging to work for four seven right and with the sedan the battery pack is actually in the floor plan between two axles and the motor and transmission power electronics also laid flat just behind the rear axle so you don't have anything in the front you've got a trunk in the front and a trunk in the back so as a result the model s has more cargo space than any other sedan even much bigger sedans and the rear seats fold forward so you can have very big things there you can put you can literally put a surfboard 50 inch tv and a mountain bike in the in

38:57the back seat what else do you need right so it's it's got tremendous cargo space and functionality and the trick there was making something that's aesthetically appealing while retaining the functionality you know because you can make something look like a very sleek sports car you can have but then you start to have sort of supermodel type dimensions and that your you know your functionality gets impaired so it was a tough balancing those two things the sedan standard version of stan will have a 5.6 second zero to 60 which is pretty good for a sedan yeah a tough speed of 130 miles range of up to 300 miles really which is up to 300 yeah so that with

39:39five passengers or with one passenger well probably with two pad you'd probably be slightly under 300 miles with five passes that's a great number yeah so charging time for so 45 minute charge time that was that was huge yeah for 45 minutes is a critical inflection point because if you travel between cities that's lunch yeah you have lunch and then your car is recharging in the parking lot next to the restaurant is it a 220 110 the 4500 charge is actually at 400 volts 440k yeah it it actually is the very special station or can you bring that with you and convert it that would be direct dc directly to the pack so that would be with an off-board charger

40:24but but we actually have that working we have we have the high-speed charger working in our lab at tesla so there's no there's no speculation in fact it's really just a upgraded version that's built into the car yeah people in various places around the country you're going to have these things where you can charge your car absolutely it's really going to be to the advantage of of highway rest stops to have these charging stations there because they can it'll draw people to go to their restaurants or their you know their gift shops and we're going to install some of these for free by the way ted tesla will do it yeah to sort of get things going and try it out and work

41:00out the kinks and then and then another another thing is we're designing a battery pack such that it can swap out in in about three to five minutes three to five yeah i mean technically you could do it in like under a minute but you know caught so reasonably three to five minutes three to five minutes yeah well it's really no different it's just a big version of what's in your laptop so how long does it take to switch out a laptop battery pack or some laptops yeah that's incredible yeah so now we're not quite sure how you know whether people will will choose to swap out their pack when they're doing in or faster 45 minute charge you want to do the three minutes yeah we want to

41:41preserve the optionality and worst case scenario you know it's just an easy service yeah so it does require a little bit of engineering effort but i think well worth the effort and yeah and it's important note that you really don't need anything within a city because if you've got a say 250 mile range your average speed in the city is 25 to 30 miles an hour so you've got eight to 10 hours of driving capability per day right why the hell would you need to charge anywhere except your house yeah or maybe work you know so you don't really need charge stations all over the city or anything like that it's just between cities where you want to do a

42:16distance thing that that you need to solve this problem long term in the short term there are other ways to solve it because typically people have more than one car in the household and so if they've got a gasoline car they can just basically use the gasoline car for long long trips and you use this for for daily driving and an important point to make regarding the model s and i try to make this in the leadman show and it couldn't get a word in edgewise towards the end there the important point i was trying to make was that the cost of of gasoline is so much greater than the cost of electricity that if you compare our model s at fifty thousand dollars to

42:48an equivalent gasoline sedan you can subtract fifteen thousand dollars off the price yeah and and people say okay well great i'm not gonna wait five years to recover the cost difference well you don't have to because you'll be able to lease our sedan and you can lease a gasoline car and and you get the savings from day one wow so so if you're buying it outright what's the price today you fifty thousand dollars beyond that no that's inclusive of the research that's included and then you get that that's inclusive of the federal rebate so some states have 35 you're considering gas costs and all that kind of stuff yes yeah okay it's like a five series bmw for 35 i

43:27mean it's that that kind of quality of fit and finish and actually more functionality fantastic price yeah so the you know the key great great great companies involved in great products so what tesla's really focused on is is making sure that that sedan is just an awesome car an awesome product and then we've got some upgrades coming out for the the roadster which she alluded to with the roadster sport which will have a 3.7 second zero to 60 and and an adjustable suspension also all of the roadsters starting in in june will be come up with an improved interior so that you'll have a better interior than you tried out today and there are a bunch of improvements here and there

44:05that that are gonna make it a better car so really cool i was just going to say about the s it looks like you took all the barriers away you take away everyone that that's the goal better disciplines better price financing and batteries a huge part of why daimler invested in tesla was the model s that that was the single biggest factor for the investment actually yeah all right well anything else we should know about tesla motors well oh so the the smart the electric smart we're working on with daimler the first cars that should come out towards the end of this year daimler's it's up to dime list to where they deploy those we're hoping daimler

44:45will allow some of this to come to the us but there's such high demand for this car that it can be like totally absorbed in any any country basically this yeah a huge huge demand for the electric expanse their production plan you know i i don't know exactly but i mean they've asked us to bid on a very large number so if if if that number comes to fruition it's they're really it's a mass production cost they're already looking forward if this yeah absolutely i mean the economics in europe where gasoline is twice as expensive and and they're the the government incentives are even greater than that that they are here it becomes an extremely compelling car

45:22you know in london for example you don't pay any you don't pay the toll fee if you're and that's ten pounds a day wow and even in the city yeah going into the city and and gasoline in london was it was last summer was it was ten dollars a gallon so yeah yeah obviously so it's really and in europe you have shorter distances as well so so i'm hoping that they will at least have some allocation for the u.s but very easily absorbed in europe and then there are there's some other vehicle programs that we haven't announced yet with daimler a very exciting vehicle program that will probably be announced towards the end of this year and just because i have to ask so the

46:06the government stimulus money you've been talking about in public your hopes for that are strong so tesla actually will not be receiving any stimulus money the the money that tesla has not received any government funding at all right it's a lot of misinformation out there what tesla has applied for is a loan under the atvm program which is the advanced technology vehicle manufacturing program okay congress started writing that legislation two years ago and approved a totally different program unrelated to the current economic environment i haven't really thought you're right in any media yeah yeah there's just a lot of misinformation so i totally understand so the atvm

46:47program is is a 25 billion dollar program and it's basically it's a loan program to with low-cost loans for the transition from gasoline to electric and tesla's applied for just under 500 million around 465 million so it's about two percent of the program the other 98 percent will go to you know gm ford yeah chrysler all those hard driving i i i feel changes right i feel i felt confident in saying that of of all the people that those loans go to we will make the best use of that you're the most bang with money i feel confident i think you're right of of that the tax those taxpayer dollars will even before you go i think you're right yeah competition okay so and that's

47:40going to open the door to the production of the s yes yeah you know we've continued to do a lot of development work on on model s although we had to scale back our plans last year and do a layoff because of the economic environment but we continue we basically last year went from about 30 of our resources applied to the model s to down to about 10 of our resources although we've continued to build back up and now we're back at around 20 of our resources on model s with the diamond investment we're gonna ramp up that ramp that that up and then with the the doe loan which will hopefully be announced soon that that's when we'll we're going to really high gear

48:1960 or 80 or so that's fantastic so when i when we talk with yes if you had to guess just guess when do you see production when you see the first car rolling off the assembly line it's probably late late 2011. so a little so two and a half two and a quarter two and a half years from now yeah and you've sold a bunch of pre-orders on yes already yes right outside you know so how many over a thousand i haven't looked at the numbers the last week or two but it was over a couple weeks ago we passed what does it take to do this if somebody wants to get one now it's a it's a five thousand dollar reservation fee right and that basically gets ensures you get one of

48:54the first cars off the line if i said let's do five of those i get a roadster which maybe we should have a program like i think we should have for you like that all right well we've obviously gone over but i think it's totally worth it and a couple more things i want to talk to you about one is you've been a stalwart here and we we've been you're your great supporters and now you've got it all pretty much wrapped seemed like the right time to invent up an award so we did okay and we would like to give you the very first entrepreneur of the year award from fire okay well thanks this comes in

49:38so we have joe are you there so joe has been nice enough joe sterling who's well known to anyone from fire who does all of our interpretive drawings as as an example of our feelings has done a special we'll hold this up i guess everyone can see it it says it's got it's it's rather beautiful it's solar city spacex space station it's got the whole story here california canada family musk brothers must come from other places so it's your whole life story in one page and this is for you to put wherever you wish and then in addition to that let's see we want to do a photograph so if we have is sandy here okay i'd like to just shake your hand while we're

50:28showing that and that's it okay oh god a guy it's like this nice job all right and and one more piece to this although this is lovely is how many employees have you got at spacex we're about 720 or 730. okay say 700 how many of you got at solar city like 500 i think so we're at 1200 now we've got at tesla 400 actually almost 500 tesla as well so 17 say 1800 people well i was trying to think of something useful to a guy who's got everything and the only thing i could think of that would carry value is queuing into sns so we're gonna give every one of those employees sns for a year okay thanks thank you all right

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份