2009 年,一辆电动车停在查理·罗斯的演播室里。它叫 Roadster,售价十万多美元,两个座位,0 到 100 公里加速比兰博基尼还快。罗斯把问题直接扔了过去:你造这台车,是因为有钱人缺玩具吗?
这个质疑在当时几乎是共识。电动车本来要解决能源问题、排放问题、普通人的用车成本问题,结果第一家像样的电动车公司端出来的,是一台只有富人才买得起的跑车。逻辑上说不通。
马斯克的回答,是整段访谈里最能体现他思维方式的部分。他没辩解情怀,也没讲愿景,他讲的是成本曲线。
新技术刚出来的时候,一定是贵的
他的原话大意是:任何新技术在起步阶段都很贵,你可以随便找例子。工程师做的第一件事是让它能用,等它能用了,才开始优化,一轮一轮优化下去。回头看电脑的早期、手机的早期,甚至汽油车的早期,全都是富人的玩具。直到成本降下来,普通人才买得起。
这个逻辑听起来很朴素,但很少有人真的顺着它往下推。马斯克推下去了:既然新技术必须先贵后便宜,那第一步就该造一台贵但足够惊艳的车,用它把注意力吸过来,把供应链跑通,把技术迭代起来。
Roadster 在这套逻辑里扮演的是入场券的角色。它的任务,是把电动车从“环保人士的妥协方案”变成“性能车迷会认真考虑的东西”。这两个标签之间的差距,比价格差距大得多。
罗斯追问得很尖:所以你的意思是,先服务有钱人,再服务普通人?马斯克承认了,而且承认得很坦然。他举的例子是福特。汽油车最早也是富人的玩物,直到福特把生产线跑起来,价格才掉到工人也买得起的位置。
这里有个容易被忽略的细节:马斯克说的“优化”,指的是电池成本、电机效率、整车重量、生产线节拍,每一项都要用真实的量产车去磨。没有第一批车在路上跑,就没有数据;没有数据,成本曲线就下不来。软件可以靠模拟,硬件不行,硬件只能靠跑。
还有一层意思他没明说。第一批买 Roadster 的人,实际上在为整个行业的成本下降买单。他们付的是溢价,换来的是技术往前挪一格。这个循环在任何一个硬件行业都成立,只是很少有人把话说得这么直。
一家创业公司买不起十亿美元的工厂
访谈里马斯克说了一句很实在的话:以特斯拉当时的体量,根本不可能拿出 10 亿美元去建一座年产几十万辆的巨型工厂。
而便宜车必须靠量。年产几千台的车,单车成本压不下来;要压下来,就得年产几十万台;要年产几十万台,就得先有一座几十亿美元的工厂。这是个死循环。传统车企靠几十年的积累才跨过去,一家 2003 年成立、账上没多少钱的硅谷公司跨不过去。
所以特斯拉面对的是两个问题叠在一起:产量问题,和新技术问题。前者要求规模,后者要求试错。两件事都还没解决的时候,最理性的做法是把试错放在小规模上,把错误控制在能承受的范围里。
马斯克的说法是:你得先在小的量级上把 bug 抠干净,再去谈规模。这句话听起来像常识,但绝大多数创业公司死在这一步,因为小规模试错的成本同样会压垮一家现金流紧张的公司。一千台车卖出去,工程师能拿到真实的故障数据、真实的用户反馈、真实的供应链报价,这些东西在实验室里买不到。
跑到哪一步了
罗斯问得很务实:现在进展怎么样?
马斯克的回答给了几个具体数字。2009 年这个时点,Roadster 已经进入稳定生产,年化产能大约 1000 台。几个月前,特斯拉发布了四门轿车,售价 5 万美元,大概是 Roadster 的一半。
轿车 2011 年投产。目标年销 2 万台,累计生产约 10 万台。再往后是第三代平台,车价要压到 3 万美元以下。
他补了一句,说这类预测从来都不精确,但方向是清楚的。除了轿车,还会有 SUV 和其他衍生车型。
把这三个价格点连起来看,路径就清楚了:10 万美元的跑车证明技术可行,5 万美元的轿车证明市场存在,3 万美元以下的车才是真正进入大众市场的那一步。每一代产品的定价,都是上一代成本下降的结果,拍脑袋定不出来。定价在特斯拉这里承担的是产品路线的功能,营销的功能排在后头。
还有一条线是很多人当时没注意到的:特斯拉不只卖整车,还卖动力总成。访谈里马斯克提到了和戴姆勒的合作,特斯拉为电动版 smart 供应电池和驱动系统。
2009 年特斯拉的整车销量只有一千台,动力总成业务的战略价值反而更大。它向外界证明了一件事:特斯拉的电池和电驱系统,能被全球最大的商用车集团之一接受,能通过德国人的工程审查。这个背书对一家硅谷创业公司的分量,远超那笔合同本身的金额。
他衡量成功的标准,是把电动车时代提前五年
罗斯问了一个定义性的问题:你怎么衡量特斯拉是否成功?
马斯克的答案是:如果特斯拉让电动车的普及至少提前了五年,那就算成功。他用的词是 accelerate,加速。
“对我来说,特斯拉的成功意味着我们把电动车的到来至少提前了五年。”(马斯克)
罗斯立刻追问:目标是加速电动车的到来,还是创建一家伟大的电动车公司?马斯克说这两个是一回事,做成一个就等于做成另一个。
这个回答值得停一下。它透露的是一种很少见的成功观:一家公司的价值,可以由它把整个行业往前推了多少来定义,市值只是这个过程的副产品。如果特斯拉失败了,但传统车企因此加快了电动化,他也会认为这件事有意义。
这些话听着像场面话,实际有账可算。2009 年,几乎全球所有主流车企都在做电动车项目,多数是应付加州零排放法规的合规车,产量几百台,只在租赁市场流通,用户体验一塌糊涂。特斯拉改变的是叙事:一台 0 到 100 加速 4 秒内的车,没法再被归类成高尔夫球车的升级版。
一旦性能这条线被跨过去,整个行业的产品定义就必须重写。这个影响,比多卖几台车大得多。马斯克很清楚这一点,所以他用“提前几年”来衡量成败,而不用“卖出多少台”。
颠覆为什么来自硅谷
罗斯的问题问到了根上:为什么这件事是一个 2003 年成立的创业公司干的?全球那些成熟的汽车集团在做什么?他提到了菲亚特、克莱斯勒,这些公司有钱、有工厂、有工程师、有经销商网络。
马斯克的回答很干脆:真正的颠覆性技术,也就是出现技术断层的领域,往往来自新公司。
他举的例子是谷歌。为什么搜索这件事是拉里和谢尔盖做出来的,当时的行业巨头在做什么?因为技术不连续。在连续演进的领域,在位者占优势,它有积累、有渠道、有品牌。一旦出现断层,积累反而变成包袱,因为既有产线、既有供应商、既有人才结构都要推翻重来。
访谈里还有个小插曲。马斯克说他在拉里拿到风险投资之前就认识他了。罗斯顺势问:拉里是特斯拉的投资者吗?马斯克说是,拉里和谢尔盖都投了特斯拉,而且他们自己开这车。
这段对话在 2009 年听起来像个趣闻,回头看更像一个信号。硅谷的资本和技术圈子,正在把汽车当成下一个可以被软件重构的行业。底特律当时没把这个信号当回事,它正忙着处理自己的破产重组。
那个夏天,融资计划撞上了五级飓风
罗斯提到了当时针对特斯拉的一类批评:融了很多钱,但没有完成既定目标。
马斯克没有回避。他说目标确实推迟了,原因有两部分:一部分是自己犯的低级错误,一部分是外部市场环境。特斯拉原计划融资大约 1 亿美元,2008 年夏天启动,结果撞上了金融危机。
他的说法是“像撞上五级飓风”,把一切都卷走了。
后果是具体的:计划被迫收缩,公司裁员,融资转向内部,由现有投资人补上,马斯克本人投了一大笔钱。他说“当时市场上根本没有钱”,这是 2008 年底到 2009 年初的实况。那几个月,美国汽车业正在经历通用和克莱斯勒的破产重组,一家硅谷小公司想融一亿美元,难度可以想见。
但他给出了当时的判断:公司状况已经好转,预计第三季度实现盈利。盈利来源有两个,一是 Roadster 的销售,二是给戴姆勒供应动力总成的业务。
这段自述里有个值得注意的诚实:他把失败的原因拆成了“自己的低级错误”和“外部环境”两部分,没有把责任全推给金融危机。这种拆分方式在创业者身上并不常见,多数人愿意承认运气好,不愿意承认自己笨。
40 天做出原型车,戴姆勒的态度就变了
戴姆勒这段故事,是整段访谈里最像创业电影的部分。
背景是这样的:smart 从设计之初就被设想成一台电动车,但戴姆勒一直解决不了电池问题。一年半以前,特斯拉和戴姆勒接触上了。
马斯克说他飞到德国,见了戴姆勒全球研发负责人韦伯博士。他开场就问:我们怎么才能一起做点事?他给出的方案很务实:特斯拉想做一台普通人买得起的大众市场车型,自己没那么多钱,戴姆勒有。
然后他抛出了具体提议:做电动版 smart 怎么样?
韦伯的回应是典型的德国工程师风格:如果你能做出原型车,这件事就很有说服力。
“他说,如果你能做出一个原型车,那会很有帮助。我们做了。”(马斯克)
JB Straubel 带的动力总成团队用了 40 天。40 天后戴姆勒的人来访问,特斯拉把车钥匙递过去:就停在那儿,去开吧。
结果对方很喜欢。先是一份小额的研发合同,然后是 1000 台车的供应合同,如果执行得好,后面可能是几万台。
这段故事的重量在程序,不在速度。一家创业公司想让巨头相信自己,最有效的说服方式,是把一台能当场开走的车停在门口。40 天做原型看着像拼命,实际上是最经济的说服成本:用六周时间,换掉一场可能持续两年的商务谈判,还顺手拿到了对方的工程信任。
罗斯问,其他车企是什么态度?马斯克的回答带着点无奈:大多数公司的心态是,硅谷一家小创业公司能懂什么,我们有什么做不到的。
他的应对方式也很直接:那就开我们的车,看看我们的技术。他说这话的时候,那种“说不通”的挫败感是听得出来的。传统车企的组织结构决定了,采购部门不会因为一台原型车表现好就改变路线,除非这件事已经威胁到自己的市场份额。
戴姆勒之所以成了例外,有它的特殊性。smart 这个产品线本来就在亏损,电动化是它唯一的出路,而戴姆勒内部没有现成的电池方案。一家公司只有在自己的路走不通的时候,才会认真看别人的路。
买 Roadster 的是哪种人
罗斯问了个很具体的问题:你心里有买家画像吗?
马斯克说有,而且很清楚:喜欢性能车的人,车库里可能停着一台保时捷或者兰博基尼。Roadster 的 0 到 100 加速比兰博基尼快,比几乎所有常规跑车都快。他不装谦虚地补了一句:真正比它快的只有百万美元级的顶级超跑,比如法拉利 Enzo。
然后他说了整段访谈里最像广告语的一句:
“如果你想要一台高性能车,同时又想保持良心清白,这是唯一的选择。”(马斯克)
“良心清白”这个词,在 2009 年的语境里有具体所指。当时主流的环保车叙事是牺牲:牺牲动力、牺牲空间、牺牲设计感,用这些换取低排放。Roadster 把等式反过来了:你不牺牲任何东西,甚至得到更多,只是换了一种动力形式。
这个卖点的商业含义被低估了。它让电动车第一次有了“加法”的叙述方式,以前所有的环保产品都是“减法”叙述,买它是因为你愿意放弃点什么。愿意做减法的是少数人,愿意做加法的是多数人。特斯拉后来的所有产品,都沿着这条加法路线走。
轿车面对的是另一类人:想要一台好轿车,同时也想要良心清白。马斯克顺带提了一句,轿车的使用成本比同级燃油车更低。电比油便宜,保养项目少,这两笔账在 2009 年就已经算得平。
还有个小细节被他提到:Roadster 不太适合带小孩,因为它是两座跑车,上下车不方便。轿车会解决这个问题。罗斯后来问他孩子喜欢那车吗,他说喜欢,但确实不适合,得等轿车。
争议会自己找上门
罗斯说,你是个有争议的人。
马斯克的回答有点无奈:我尽量不去制造争议,但争议好像会自己找上来。罗斯替他总结:因为你敢想大的,一个在私营领域成功过的软件人,看不出有什么理由别人做不到的事你不能做,不管对面的企业有多大。
这个总结点到了他在 2009 年最容易被误解的地方。他把制造业当成一个可以重新设计的系统,从成本结构和供应链入手。软件出身的人看汽车,看到的是一百年的工艺传承之外的东西:几万个零部件的成本结构,一套可以被垂直整合的供应链。看火箭,看到的也不只是国家实力象征,还有每公斤入轨成本。
这个视角的差别,决定了提问的方式。传统车企问的是“这台车能不能造得更好”,他问的是“这台车为什么是这个成本”。前一个问题在既有框架里优化,后一个问题有可能把框架拆掉。争议大多来自后一种问法,因为它默认了对方的做法有问题。
送私人宇航员上太空,取决于 NASA 点不点头
访谈的后半段转到 SpaceX。罗斯问,你说两年内能把人送上太空?
马斯克的回答有个前提:这取决于 NASA 是否委托 SpaceX 来做。如果 NASA 今年就下单,他希望两年内能实现。
当时的背景是,白宫成立了一个人类太空飞行未来委员会,几个月内会提交建议。马斯克希望其中一些建议对 SpaceX 有利。
他把不做这件事的代价算得很清楚:如果 SpaceX 不做,2010 年之后美国送宇航员上国际空间站将完全依赖俄罗斯。数十亿美元会花在一个几乎是单一来源的采购关系上。
“数十亿美元实质上会花在对俄罗斯的单一来源采购上,我认为这很离谱。”(马斯克)
这段话说在 2009 年,也就是航天飞机退役前夕。后来发生的事和他描述的一模一样:2011 年航天飞机退役后,美国确实靠俄罗斯的联盟号运送宇航员,单个座位的价格从几千万美元一路涨到 8000 万美元以上,直到 2020 年载人龙飞船首飞才结束这段依赖。
他用的词是“离谱”,不是说贵。贵是可以谈的,单一来源是没得谈的。一旦一个国家的关键能力只有一家供应商,价格和进度都不再由自己决定。这个判断逻辑,和他在特斯拉身上做的事是一致的:垂直整合的目的,是把关键环节的定价权拿回来。
罗斯问他,你自己为什么没上去过?
马斯克说没有。罗斯追问,你想去吗?
“如果纯粹是个人兴趣的问题,我早就去了。”(马斯克)
他说谢尔盖表达过一些兴趣。他自己也想在某个时候去,但现在这个阶段,他很难承担个人风险。
这段话他讲得很坦白:以前他承担过很多个人风险,2008 年特斯拉和 SpaceX 同时濒临破产的时候,他把最后的钱都投了进去。现在情况不一样了,他有孩子,有几家公司的责任在身。如果他现在去做有个人风险的事,被押上的不只他自己。
他提到自己有一组三胞胎和一组双胞胎。罗斯问孩子们喜欢那车吗,他笑了,说喜欢,但 Roadster 不适合小孩,轿车会更合适。
这段访谈里真正值得抄走的东西
2009 年的马斯克还没有被神化。他讲的话里有大量具体的数字、具体的人名、具体的失败,没有后来那种布道式的口吻。回头看,这段访谈的价值在于他展示了一套可以复用的判断方式。
他把新技术进入市场的顺序想清楚了:先贵后便宜,先小众后大众,先证明性能再谈普及。他把资源约束想清楚了:没能力建大工厂的时候,就在小规模上试错,用真实的量产车换数据。他把说服成本想清楚了:与其反复解释,不如做出原型车让对方自己开一圈。他把外部依赖想清楚了:一个国家的载人航天长期压在单一供应商身上,早晚要为这个便宜付代价。
这四条,任何做产品、做技术、做供应链的人今天都能直接用。
- 推一个新技术产品时,先问清楚它现在处在成本曲线的哪一段。如果还在早期,别急着做大众市场版本,先做一台让目标用户无法忽视的旗舰产品,用它换数据和供应链。
- 资源不够的时候,把试错规模压到能承受的范围,别把整个计划砍掉一半。前者买到的是信息,后者买到的是延期。
- 面对不愿合作的强势方,把说服成本前置。能用 40 天做出可体验的原型,就别用两年做商务谈判。
- 评估任何关键业务时,算一遍单一来源依赖的代价。今天的便宜,往往是明年的议价权丧失。
- 衡量自己做成的事,用“把行业往前推了多少”来当标准,别只盯着“占了多少份额”。前者会逼你做长期正确的选择,后者只会逼你打价格战。
- 承担风险的尺度要跟着责任变。年轻时可以押上全部,有了团队和家庭之后,风险计算里必须加上别人的份量。
0:05right now the reason to create a sports car a roadster as the first stage of this is because it attracts attention or what oh the the so good great great question so because people often misinterpret why we have created a sports car because they they will say you know the implication will be those cars for rich guys right did i solve the energy problem right exactly and they were sort of like that did i feel that there was somehow a shortage of sports cars or rich guys or something like that and that was the problem that's right and not only you know if if you're if any new technology is expensive when it starts out and you can point pretty much anything and
0:44because the first thing that that you the engineers are trying to do is make it work and then when you made it make it work then you optimize and you optimize and you optimize and if you look at the early days of computers or cell phones or almost anything even the early days of of gasoline cars they used to be toys for rich people until they were they were made affordable and that measures came along yeah and and and then you combine them with the better the garbage yeah and and then you can find that with the fact that we're we're just a little startup and that you know there's there's just no way that we could afford a billion dollars to make a
1:15a a giant car plant that that would make you know hundreds of thousands of cars a year because that's the kind of volume you have to get to to make to make cheap cars and and then and it's also the first iteration of technology so we had both a volume problem and a a new technology problem and so that naturally that you have to reach scale you have to reach scale and you have to work the bugs out of the system and and so you've got to make it and you want to make your mistakes at a small scale okay so how's that going reaching scale and and and being able to to create a market a business plan they'll enable you to reach a large audience you know and right and create
1:58and continue the development of the technology that'll make it even more attractive it's it's going really well actually so it was we had a few bumpy bumpy years in the beginning but at this point we're producing at a steady state of about an annualized production rate of about a thousand roads to sports cars a year we unveiled our sedan a few months ago which is a much more functional car and it's a 50 000 car so basically it's about half the price of the roads and the production run say for the year 2010 for the roadster will be about a thousand and for the sedan so then the sedan is only coming out in two years so in 2011 will be the first year right and what's the what's
2:37the projection for that we're expecting to do 20 000 units a year for the sedan it's always difficult to predict these things exactly but but our target is is we'll produce a total of about 100 000 of them in about 20 000 a year and they're going to be many variations on that we'll do an suv and we'll do you know other things and then we'll do a third generation platform beyond the the the sedan the model sedan will be a sub 30 dollar car so we're trying to get to mass production as soon as we we possibly can and and but that's both from the cause that that we make ourselves as well as the cars we do in partnership with others like the daimler
3:15deal you may have read about and yeah so how do you measure the odds of success personally i would say success for me for tesla is that we've accelerated the advent of electric cars by at least five years so that that is that the goal to to accelerate the advent of electric cars or to create a great electric car company i i think the two are synonymous i mean or i mean you do one you do the other okay yeah and why is it that it's it's happening by a guy who created a startup in 2003 rather than a whole range of sort of industrial automobile companies around the world not just here fiat is a successful car company in their own chrysler right well
4:04disruptive technology like where you really have a big technology discontinuity it tends to come from new companies you know you could ask the same question of why does google come from why did google come from larry and larry sergey right right right by the way i've no i i've known larry since before he got venture funding for for good for google ned is he is but is he an investor in tesla yes larry and sergey are investors in tesla and they drive them or don't drive yeah they're driving absolutely it because some of the criticism that comes at you and the company now is that that you went out to seek a lot of external financing and did not reach your goals
4:39well we're it's taking us longer to reach our goals but we're different what was it raise 100 million to raise 40 or what was it what was the goal well i think it's you know some of some of the the the stumbles were were silly mistakes we made ourselves some of them were market externalities and we were getting ready to raise or we're in the process of raising about 100 million around that began in in sort of the summer of last year and then ran into you know force five hurricanes an economic circumstance that took everything out yeah and so we so that that forced us to scale back our plans a little bit we had to do a layoff and we had to raise the money
5:21internally from existing investors i put up a lot of the money personally and there was just no money and so it that that was it was sort of a hair raising time for for the company but at this point we're actually in good shape we expect to be profitable in the third quarter and that comes from the success of the roadster yeah and and the roads then we also have a powertrain supply business to daimler as well for the for electric smart that we're doing with them make the smart car and electric car yeah you know the smart car is always intended to be an electric car but they never got nothing they could never get the battery right so a year and a half ago we met
5:58with daimler and that australia convinced them to work with us so we actually i mean we've really tried hard to work with a lot of different car companies and and what happened well i guess they they think well they took the attitude of what you know what is some little startup in silicon valley know that that we don't know or couldn't do and what would you say to them well we'd say drive our car and look at our technology and i don't know it just never seems to sort of sink in but daimler that predominantly did actually so i i i went i went through stood guard went down the way to india actually and met with dr weber the head of global r d and and we
6:38had a conversation so what does it take for us to to work together we'd love to do something we'd love to do something with you know an affordable mass-market car that you know we ourselves couldn't do right now because we don't have the capital resources most of it yeah and and and so i said what about you know what what what about electric smart and because the smart was always intended to be an electric car and and and what would take for us to work together and he said well if you could do a prototype that would that would really go a long way so we did we worked really hard the powertrain team led by jv straubel did an awesome job and 40 days later when when they came out to
7:12visit we said here's the car take a drive and they they really liked what they saw and so what did they do then then they said okay well let's let's take it sort of another step further and they gave us a little little r d contract and eventually got to the point where we got a contract for to supply a thousand cars for them and then if we do well in that we'll potentially go into you know tens of thousands of cars so so but this is a car that everyone could afford and and and could hopefully come quite soon do you have a profile of the people who you think will want to buy these roadsters yeah absolutely it's the kind of person who who likes the performance car
7:50maybe they own a a porsche or you know lamborghini or something you know this car is actually faster than a lamborghini zero to 60. yeah it's it's it's fine i think faster than almo almost anything and for anything i know of yeah i mean there's like things like the the really sort of million dollar supercars obviously those will those will beat it like the ferrari enzo is going to be faster it's pretty much faster than any normal normal sports car and and it's really easy to drive if you want a high performance car with a clean conscience this is the only option and the sedan is going to be for someone that wants a great sedan and and also you know clean conscience and
8:29it's also going to be cheaper to operate than yeah sorry you are as you well know a controversial guy as well i try to i try not to be controversial but it seems controversial it finds you it it finds you because you think big you're a software guy who has been successful in the private sector yeah you know and see no reason you can't do things that other people have not been able to no longer how large the corporate enterprise create the best electric car or b put privately astronauts in space right which you say you will do in two years well yeah it sort of depends on where nasa asks us to do that if so if nasa turns on the on ask us to do that this year which we're
9:20hopeful that they will the the white house has a convened a panel on the future of human space flight that that panel is going to make the recommendations in a few months i i hope that some of those recommendations will be favorable to to spacex because the alternative is if if spacex doesn't do it we will be entirely dependent on the russians to carry our astronauts to the space station after 2010. and billions of dollars will be spent on essentially a sole source situation to the russians which i think is is outrageous you haven't taken advantage of the opportunity to go in space yourself have you no i have not have you wanted to i if it was it was purely a matter a
9:55matter of personal interest i would i would have done it already i mean i i do want to do sergey interested in that or no sergey is expressed some interest in some interest yes yeah i i would like to go at some point but it's i i'm also in the point where i it's difficult for me to take personal risks i used to take a lot of personal risks for children i've got my you know kids and and and responsibilities with the companies as well and and so if i if i do things where they have personal risk at this point i risk more than than my own my own being you've had how many trips do you have one set of drippers and one one set of twins yeah they have the twin smithy new york
10:38actually so they they like they like the car yeah yeah yeah if they can't drive and they can't go on the road because it doesn't you know it's not very kid friendly but yeah but you know it's not very kid-friendly you're right the sedan will be ideal for them sorry much success to you thank you for coming you
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版