二〇〇九年,一辆跑车的电池包重达一千磅,装下的能量只相当于两加仑半汽油。同一辆车却在《Top Gear》的测试赛道上,跑赢了保时捷911 GT3。马斯克坐在查理·罗斯对面,把这两件事放在一起讲,听众的第一反应通常是:这不合理。
这场访谈发生在特斯拉最危险的年份之后。二〇〇八年金融危机把公司逼到悬崖边,融资计划撞上飓风,马斯克自己掏钱填坑,还裁了一批人。一年后他坐进演播室,讲清楚了三家公司在做什么,为什么非得这么做,以及他凭什么认为自己能做成。
他的答案不靠激情演说,靠的是一串能量数字、一段电池原理,还有一个从大学时代就没变过的判断。
十七岁拿到加拿大护照,三周后人已经在加拿大
马斯克在南非长大。他描述那段经历时没有太多情绪,只说环境很偏向技术,他自己学会了编程,目的很单纯,就是想写游戏。十二岁那年他做出了第一个游戏。
真正推动他离开的,是他读到的技术新闻。他发现自己读到的那些创新,几乎都来自美国。于是他试着说服父母搬过去,父母都没同意。母亲后来先回了加拿大,再去了美国。他等到十七岁,拿到加拿大护照,三个星期后就已经人在加拿大了。
这条路看起来是运气,其实是他把唯一可用的跳板用到了极致。南非护照在当时不好用,加拿大护照给了他进入北美的资格,剩下的路程他自己走完。
大学时他判断未来只有三件事重要,其中两件后来变成了公司
PayPal卖给eBay,交易金额十五亿美元,时间是二〇〇二年。这笔钱让马斯克有了做下一件事的资本。
他回忆大学时想过一个问题:哪些领域最可能影响人类的未来。他给出的答案是三个。第一个是互联网。第二个是可持续能源和交通的转型。第三个是太空探索,具体说是把生命延伸到多个星球。
我当时从没指望自己会参与第三件事,但它看起来对未来非常重要。(马斯克)
PayPal卖掉之后,他同时进了后两个领域。能源和交通那边是Solar City和特斯拉,太空那边是SpaceX。第一个领域他已经亲手做完了一轮,剩下两个他打算重做一遍。
到太空和到轨道,中间差了六十九倍的能量
访谈里马斯克花了不小篇幅纠正一个公众误解。普通人分不清"进入太空"和"进入轨道",这两件事的难度完全不在一个量级。
他用速度来说明。一次亚轨道飞行,终端速度大约三倍音速就够了。要进入轨道,终端速度得达到二十五倍音速。能量和速度的平方成正比,所以亚轨道大约需要九个单位的能量,入轨需要六百二十五个单位。换句话说,亚轨道飞行消耗的能量,只有入轨的百分之一多一点。
这个区别决定了整个行业的资源分配。做亚轨道飞行的公司不少,杰夫·贝索斯在做,理查德·布兰森通过投资加州Scaled Composites也在做。这些项目有机会成长,但起点和入轨完全是两码事。
SpaceX选的是入轨这条更难的路。马斯克的理由很简单:入轨才真正逼近物理极限的边缘,那里的挑战才有意义。二〇〇八年,SpaceX的火箭第一次成功入轨,他把那一刻称为巨大的释放,也是一个里程碑。
接下来的日程已经排好。访谈后一个月,他们要替马来西亚发射一颗卫星。同年晚些时候,更大的Falcon 9火箭要从卡纳维拉尔角升空,这枚火箭未来要承担国际空间站的货运任务。
他顺带纠正了一个商业模式的常识:火箭公司卖的不是火箭,是发射服务。这和航空公司卖机票而不是卖飞机是一个道理。
火箭行业几十年没大进步,缺的不是钱,是愿意进来的人
查理·罗斯问了一个尖锐的问题:为什么这些本该由政府或者大企业做的事,最后是一个PayPal出来的程序员在做?
马斯克的回答很直接。私营部门在优化和创新上更强,政府更适合做基础研究这类事。真正的问题是,太空行业为什么几十年没有出现剧烈的技术迭代。
他给出的解释是门槛。创办一家火箭公司需要的资本量极大,技术难度极高,全世界真正懂火箭的人数量很少。这三个条件叠在一起,形成了一个几乎无法穿越的壁垒。没有新公司进来,就没有"创造性破坏"这个机制在起作用,行业自然缺乏改进的强制力。
这就是为什么我们看不到行业本该有的那种改进压力。(马斯克)
他特别提到自己的知识来源。大学学的是物理,物理给了他一个分析框架,火箭技术是后来一点点补上的。他把自己的核心能力归结为技术本身:如果一件事需要被设计、被发明,而且你得保证创造出来的价值大于投入的成本,那就是他擅长的事。
这段话听起来轻描淡写,其实点出了他的方法论。物理训练给他的不是具体知识,是一种从第一性原理往下推的习惯。能量和速度的平方成正比,这个关系一旦想清楚,亚轨道和轨道的差距就不需要靠经验去感受,算一算就出来了。
造跑车是为了让跑车不再是富人的玩具
话题转到车上。查理·罗斯当天下午刚试驾过Roadster,评价是很棒。他问了一个很多人都会问的问题:这车在硅谷的停车场里出现得不少,是因为这里的人爱技术、爱性能,还是因为这里有钱人多,愿意为前沿和理念买单?
马斯克的回答后来被反复引用。造一辆高性能跑车,从来不是终点。
我把大量时间和金钱投进去做这家公司,是想当催化剂,加速电动车革命的到来。(马斯克)
他接着解释为什么第一辆车必须是跑车,而不直接造一辆便宜的家用车。任何新技术在刚出现时都很贵。工程师的第一步是让它能用,第二步是优化,第三步还是优化,直到成本降下来。电脑是这样,手机是这样,早期的汽油车也是这样,一开始都是富人的玩具,后来才变得人人买得起。
再叠上特斯拉当时的处境。一家刚成立的小公司,拿不出十亿美元建一座年产几十万辆的工厂,而只有达到那个量级,车才可能便宜。所以公司同时面对两个问题:产量上不去,技术又是第一代。
解法是先在小规模上把错误犯完。
你得先达到规模,还得把系统里的毛病都跑出来,所以最好在小规模的时候犯错。(马斯克)
跑车就是这个"小规模"。它吸引眼球,验证技术,让公司在真实道路上积累数据,同时为下一款车争取时间。
一千磅电池凭什么打赢汽油,答案在效率里
电池一直是电动车的死结。马斯克没有回避这个数字:Roadster的电池包重约一千磅,能量含量只相当于两加仑半汽油。听到这里任何人都会觉得电动车没有前途。
他把这个矛盾拆成两层。第一层是电芯和电池包的区别。日常说的"电池"其实是电芯,一个装着化学物质的小罐子。很多电芯组合在一起才叫电池包。特斯拉用的是市面上常见的量产电芯,笔记本里用的就是同类东西。
真正的难点在电池包这一层。几千个电芯要组合在一起,还得保证安全、保证能撑二十万英里、保证经得起颠簸和坑洼、保证极端温度下正常、保证碰撞时不失控,同时还得让整包的充电状态和温度保持平衡。难点不在电芯,在电池包,这也是特斯拉技术积累最厚的地方。公司还自研了电机、电力电子和整套管理软件,但电池仍是最核心的一块。
第二层是效率。这一层才是电动车翻盘的关键。一台好的电动机,把电能转成运动的效率大约百分之九十。汽油内燃机呢,这个数字在百分之十七到十八之间,其余大部分能量都变成了热。
所以两加仑半汽油的能量,装进一台效率五倍的机器里,跑出的里程完全不一样。特斯拉Roadster的能效是丰田普锐斯的两倍,而普锐斯根本不算性能车。
这个对比把整件事讲清楚了。电动车不是靠堆电池赢的,是靠能量转换效率赢的。电池能量密度低是事实,电机效率高也是事实,后者抵消了前者的一部分劣势,剩下的靠电池技术进步慢慢补。
纯电和插电混动,两条路线的分歧
查理·罗斯提到通用的雪佛兰Volt,问特斯拉怎么比较。马斯克的回答很克制。Volt是插电混动架构,纯电续航大约四十英里,之后靠发动机带动发电机继续跑。特斯拉走的是纯电路线。
他特意补了一句,解释自己为什么选纯电,经常被人理解成在攻击Volt。他说自己希望Volt成功,认为它可以是一辆不错的车。这条路线分歧背后是判断不同,不是敌意。
他对趋势的判断没有留余地:
电池改进的速度摆在那里,未来会完全电动化,这是不可避免的。(马斯克)
他承认中间会有一个过渡期,但终点是确定的。说到这里他补了一个讽刺的细节:通用在破产前一年还在宣布Volt是公司未来的关键,而更早的时候,通用做过EV1。
EV1被拖走那天,有人点了蜡烛
纪录片《谁杀死了电动车》记录了EV1的结局。车被从租户手里收回,集中销毁。有车主在停车场办了烛光守夜。
马斯克把这个细节拎出来当作论据:
如果用户爱一个产品爱到愿意为它办烛光守夜,那说明你也许该再造一辆。(马斯克)
这句话的分量在于,它把"电动车没有市场"这个说法直接推翻了。市场是有的,是产品被撤走了。通用为什么撤,马斯克说自己也不清楚具体原因。但EV1的消失和十几年后特斯拉的出现,恰好构成一个对照:同样的技术方向,一家老牌巨头放弃了,一家创业公司捡了起来。
油价会到两百五十美元,Nano只是开了个头
访谈里穿插了一个关于塔塔Nano的讨论。那辆车售价两千三百美元,是全球最便宜的汽车之一。查理·罗斯问马斯克怎么看。
马斯克的回答有个转向。他认为让车变得便宜是好事,Nano是个好主意。但真正的问题不在购车价格,在用车成本。
当油价上涨,买车的一次性成本远不如用车成本重要。(马斯克)
他对油价的判断很激进。二〇〇八年油价冲到过一百四十四美元一桶,他认为那还不是顶,未来会突破两百美元,甚至到两百五十美元。时间点大概在下一轮景气周期,也就是二〇一〇到二〇一二年之间。
这个判断和他做电动车的逻辑是同一个。汽油价格没有反映真实成本,因为烧油带来的二氧化碳浓度上升、海洋酸化、相关战争,这些代价都没算进油价里。用经济学的说法,这是一场公地悲剧,捕鱼过度是一个道理。没人付这笔钱,于是油价里实际上藏着一笔补贴。要跨过这道坎,只能靠创新,把电动车做得更好、更早。
特斯拉真实的产品路线图,比口号清楚得多
马斯克把计划摊开讲了。Roadster是第一代,年化产能约一千辆,当时每周交付二十到二十五辆。第一辆量产Roadster在二〇〇八年二月交付,那辆车就是马斯克自己的。
第二代是Model S,几个月前刚发布,售价五万美元,大约是Roadster的一半。二〇一一年投产,目标是年产两万辆,整个产品周期累计约十万辆。之后会衍生出SUV等变体。
第三代平台在轿车之后,目标售价低于三万美元。这是通向大规模量产的钥匙。
他还提到和戴姆勒的合作,这是特斯拉另一条收入线:给别人供应动力总成。
二〇〇八年的融资,差点把公司淹死
查理·罗斯问到了外界的批评:融资很多,目标没达到。马斯克没有辩解,直接承认。
原计划在二〇〇八年夏天启动一轮约一亿美元的融资,结果撞上了金融危机,用他的话说,像遇到一场五级飓风,把所有东西都卷走了。公司被迫收缩计划,裁员,靠现有股东内部筹钱,他自己也投了一大笔。
那段时间公司很惊险,但现在已经回到正轨,我们预计第三季度就能盈利。(马斯克)
盈利来源有两个。Roadster的销售,以及给戴姆勒供应电动Smart动力总成的合同。提到Smart,他补了一段渊源:这款车从一开始就想做成电动车,只是电池一直没过关。
四十天做出原型,戴姆勒就签了合同
这段故事值得单独讲。马斯克想和传统车企合作,多数公司态度冷淡,潜台词是硅谷一家小创业公司能懂什么。他飞到德国,见了戴姆勒全球研发负责人韦伯博士,直接问:我们怎么做才能一起干点事?
他提了一个具体方向:把Smart做成电动车。韦伯的回答是,如果能做出原型,事情就好谈。
特斯拉的动力总成团队在JB Straubel带领下,四十天做出了原型。戴姆勒的人来参观,马斯克说车在这儿,开一圈试试。对方试完很满意,先给了一份研发合同,后来升级成一千辆的供货合同。如果执行得好,未来可能扩展到数万辆。
这件事的启示不在励志。它说明一家创业公司要打进成熟行业,靠的不是说服,是把东西做出来让对方开一圈。
谁会买Roadster,马斯克的客户画像很直白
目标客户是喜欢性能车的人,可能已经有一辆保时捷或者兰博基尼。马斯克说这辆车的百公里加速比兰博基尼还快,比大多数百万级超跑都强,而且开起来很容易。
如果你想要一辆高性能车,同时又想良心干净,这是唯一的选择。(马斯克)
Model S的定位换了个说法,面向想要一辆好轿车、同时良心干净的人,而且运营成本比同级车低。
航天飞机退役之后,别把太空全交给俄罗斯
访谈最后回到SpaceX。查理·罗斯问他是否说过两年内把私人宇航员送上太空。
马斯克说这取决于NASA什么时候给机会。白宫当时召集了一个委员会评估载人航天的未来,几个月内会出建议。他希望建议对SpaceX有利,理由很现实:航天飞机二〇一〇年退役后,如果SpaceX接不上,美国宇航员去国际空间站就只能全靠俄罗斯,而且要花几十亿美元买这个独家服务。
把几十亿美元花在一个单一的、被俄罗斯垄断的渠道上,我认为这很荒唐。(马斯克)
他自己没去过太空。他说如果纯粹出于个人兴趣早就去了,但现在不行。他有孩子,有公司要负责,做高风险的事代价不再只由他一个人承担。年轻时可以冒险,现在不行。
三家公司,他的时间怎么分
马斯克说时间大致平均分给特斯拉和SpaceX,Solar City几乎不用他操心。后者的两位联合创始人做得非常好,公司运转得很好。
这个分配透露了一个信息:他把自己定位成解决最困难问题的人,能放手的事就放手。
回到查理·罗斯最初的问题:为什么这些事最后是一个做软件出身的人做成的,而不是那些资源雄厚的老牌企业?马斯克的答案是,凡是出现巨大技术断层的领域,突破往往来自新公司。他反问了一句,谷歌为什么不是从某家老牌公司里长出来的?
这个类比把逻辑讲透了。在位者要保护现有业务,挑战者没有包袱。电动车、可回收火箭、太阳能,都是这样。
这场二〇〇九年的访谈,今天回头看什么最值钱
十六年过去,访谈里有些预测兑现了,有些没有。纯电是未来这个判断对了,油价突破两百美元没有在二〇一二年发生,Model S在二〇一二年投产而不是二〇一一年,第三代平台走得更晚。但整个方法论的骨架没变。
他讲亚轨道和轨道,用的是能量和速度平方的关系。他讲电池,先拆电芯和电池包,再算电机效率。他讲油价,把公地悲剧和补贴摆出来。每一次解释都是从第一性原理往下推,而不是从行业惯例往上套。
这也是这场访谈最值得反复看的地方。一个创始人怎么把复杂的技术决策讲给外行听,靠的不是比喻堆砌,是把关键数字算清楚,再告诉你这些数字意味着什么。
他还有一句话很能代表当时的处境:
成功对我来说,是让电动车的到来至少提前五年。(马斯克)
这句话把一家公司的目标和一个行业的目标分开了。公司可以失败,行业的方向不能倒退。这种目标设定方式,后来被很多硬科技创业者借鉴。
对今天读这篇访谈的人来说,可以带走的东西不在结论,在方法。
- 遇到一个新技术,先问它替代的是什么,再用效率去比较,而不是用营销话术去比较。电动车的答案藏在百分之九十对百分之十七这个数字里。
- 判断一个复杂系统,先分清层级。电芯和电池包是两个问题,亚轨道和入轨是两个问题,混在一起讨论必然得出错误结论。
- 看一家公司是不是真的在做难事,看它敢不敢公开路线图和时间表,以及兑现了几成。马斯克在二〇〇九年把Roadster、Model S、第三代平台的节奏讲得很具体,后来的偏差可以拿来校准他的可信度。
- 评估一个行业的创新速度,看进入门槛。资本门槛、技术门槛、人才门槛三样都高,行业就容易停在原地,这时候创业公司的机会反而最大。
- 看政策或者价格信号时,问一句这笔成本由谁承担。油价里藏着的补贴,就是电动车存在的经济理由。
- 想进入一个成熟行业,别先说服对方,先做一个能开一圈的原型。四十天的样车,比一百页PPT管用。
0:00Elon Musk is here he is chief executive of two startup companies with bold missions he leads Tesla Motors the electric car company does attracted attention from both car enthusiast and environmentalist as well the company's powerful roadster which can travel from zero to 60 in less than four seconds is entirely powered by batteries the company plans to break into the mainstream auto market with an electric sedan as early as 2011 musk has also found a sea of space exploration technologies a company trying to slash the cost of space travel last year the company signed an agreement with NASA to send cargo to the International Space Station and if that is not enough he's
0:38also chairman of a growing company called solar city that installs solar panels on homes and businesses he has thrived in Silicon Valley one of the cofounders of PayPal the online payments company that eBay bought for 1.5 billion dollars in 2002 I am pleased to have him here at this table for the first time welcome thank you thanks for having me I've been a big family show for a long time let's just talk about you first so that if the audience does not know growing up in South Africa yeah yeah and why how did you end up in Canada well I guess growing up in South
1:13Africa I was actually it was very technology oriented and I tore self how to program computers but mostly cuz I wanted program games and I went when I was about 12 I programmed my first game and whenever I'd read about technology and great innovation it's it was coming from from the United States and so it was that's where I wanted to be and I try to convince my parents to move move there and neither with me would they would have washed I tried my mother trying to fund neither would do it my mother later moved back to initially Canada and then and in the US and so when I was 17 as soon as I got my Canadian passport three weeks later I was in Canada so here you are and you
1:56come together and make it to the United States and then you and and several other guys come together and create PayPal right and you sell at eBay for one point whatever it was five billion dollars yeah so after PayPal that gave me you know a fair bit of capital and there were three areas when I was in college there were three areas that I thought would most affect the future of humanity and and those were the internet the transition to a sustainable energy and transportation sector and the third was space exploration in particular the extension of life to multiple planets now I didn't ever expect to be involved in the third one but I but it just that
2:31seemed to me that something that was to be very important for the future and with the the capital I got from sale PayPal I was able to go into both those those areas and and so hence SpaceX and and in in the space and then in energy in the sustainable energy and transportation you've got Solar City and and and Tesla let me talk about space exploration just for a moment going in terms of creating the systems that will engage us in space exploration not just for governments and not just for NASA but for private citizens as well well you have to divide the efforts that are going on into what isn't an orbit class effort versus a suborbital grants effort and there's really a very
3:15big difference but the general public doesn't understand the difference between getting to space and getting to getting to orbit and so it's it's important to make that distinction to do a suborbital flight you need a terminal velocity of about Mach 3 right not to do to get to orbit you need a terminal velocity of Mach 25 it's it's a huge huge difference and because the energy required to do that scales with the square of the velocity so suborbital might be nine units of energy orbit is 625 units of energy so it's only about one and a half percent of the energy of orbit is required to get to suborbit so so that there's there a number of efforts in a
3:52suborbital category that certainly could grow one day or two to two orbital there's Jeff Bezos right has an effort and I know that that's something that Branson involved in this Branson absolutely no not so much directly from the technology standpoint but from the he's he's funding that development at Scaled Composites in inc in california what are you doing so we're and we're in the in the in the orbit class and that's it's a lot more capital and and and that's really where you're pushing the the ragged edge of what's what's physically possible and last year we got to orbit with for
4:29the first time with with our rocket and that was certainly a huge release and a milestone you know and so what's the next step you're gonna rock it into orbit yeah so next month we we were putting a satellite for Malaysia into orbit and then Malaysia form a formulation formulation yes of Malaysian satellite and but been in the rocket business the rocket company does the launch it's not like the airline business so you don't sell the rocket you sell the launch right and and then later this year we'll be launching our big rocket from Cape Canaveral now that's the Falcon 9 and that's the one that's gonna be servicing the space station among other things is
5:07there philosophy here that somehow the private sector can do a lot more than then it has done in in areas that seemed because of them because of the size relating a reserve for government yeah definitely the private sector is very good at at optimization and innovation I mean private sector is generally better doing things than the government I think that's that's that's fair to say but you know there are certain things that the government that that are stated to the govern like basic research and that sort of thing but yeah so as far as
5:47SpaceX the the reason that there hasn't been a huge number of big improvement in in the space industry yeah I think it's because of its very difficult portion but is creative destruction process to to go into effect because it is such a significant amount of capital that's needed to start a rocket company and and it's a very difficult technical challenge and the number of people that really understand rocketry in the world is a very small number so it's just it's really huge barriers to entry and and that's why we haven't seen the forcing function of improvement that they should have been over the years and your understanding came from sort of for me
6:29this was not what you studied in college well I studied physics studying physics and studying rocket science right ya know say six gives me the basics good framework good analytical framework yeah so but now I picked it up along the way yeah what is your core competence you think you I think it's a technology
6:53technology yeah yeah technology yeah if it's something has to be designed and invented and the and you have to figure out how to ensure that the the value of yeah of the thing you create is greater than the cost of the inputs then that's that's probably my core skill now bring me to the car and I drove a car this afternoon which was terrific it's the Roadster yeah where does that stand you obviously I've been I've been in the Google parking lot yeah that's a you've seen a few they've seen a few there yeah I'm sure that's true in other places in Silicon Valley yeah I don't know whether it's particularly a car that appeals to people in salt in
7:34Silicon Valley because of interest in technology and high performance and lots of other things or what whether there a lot of rich people and who willing to spend that kind of money for something they think is on the cutting edge of causes they believe in sustainable energy right right you tell me about how where you are in this development of this electric car which has most of all
7:58this extraordinary sort of power yeah you know yes zero to sixty times three point nine inches and and and the race is extraordinary when you think about the sports cars and anything else that's out on the road today yeah in fact on the Top Gear test track our standard roads - beats of Porsche gt3 exactly and
8:19I wrote the sport will be even better yeah you've also said in terms of where you want to go that that developing a high-performance sports car is not what this is about absolutely is it about something else and you want to develop a sedan yeah the whole purpose behind has the reason I put so much of my time and money is helping create the business is is is we want to serve as a catalyst for accelerating the electric car revolution the big the price of gas at the does not reflect the true cost of gasoline because you have a consumption of a public good it's one of the most it's really a common problem ecommerce you have the same thing in fishing where
9:00because there's no cost to fishing stocks people just over fish and then you have disaster that ensues and and here we're not paying for the cost of the co2 concentration in the oceans and atmospheres we're not paying for all these the ancillary effects the wars and all the other things at the at the gas pump so you effectively have a subsidy taking place at the gas pump because of that so the only way to bridge that is with innovation is to try to try to make electric cars better sooner than they would otherwise be and this supposed this this is a hypothetical which it may or may not speak to the point but supposed 15 years ago right let's say
9:37Bill Clinton as president who talked about the road to the 21st century and all of that suppose he had said I by I believe so much in sustainable energy that I want to make a commitment and the federal government using all of its resources will develop an electric car with appropriate battery power that will change the face of automobile the automobile industry in the world was that very doable then Bill Clinton was elected in 1992 17 years ago yeah you
10:08could have made a reasonably good electric car around that time for for a lot of investment and should that I've been done should the US government have made that kind of otherwise you will not be able to change the driving habits of Americans was it a worthwhile expenditure at probably would have been a worthwhile expenditure but the thing that really that helps electric cars is lithium-ion right and when did that come around I mean let explain why batteries has always been the great dilemma for developing an electric car sure well the energy contained when their battery is is so much less than then can that is contained in gasoline that I mean it's
10:51really almost it's hard to quite describe innate the way put it is that the Tesla battery pack in the Roadster which is the most advanced battery pack in the world right that the common reference is to call what is actually a cell a battery right so a cell is the little single can of chemically chemicals and then but if you have multiple cells that's that's what actually battery does that's literally what about creamy right multiple cell the muscle cells right on and then as the batteries get bigger and bigger they get harder and harder to deal with so there's the cell that we use as a commodity cell inside anywhere pretty much and it's the same sort of
11:26thing that's in in any wonderful number of laptops right the challenge is combining those cells into and having thousands of them keep making sure they're safe making sure they'll last for two hundred thousand miles 100,000 over bumps and potholes and extremes of temperature and safe in a crash and and that compounds the problem massively and you've got to make sure the charge is and temperatures balanced across the whole thing so that the the difficulty is really at the pack level much more than it is at the cell level and and that's really where the single biggest area of Tesla's expertise although I should point out the Tesla also has we designed a bold motor and and the power
12:06electronics and the software that manages the whole thing so that those were important too but the battery is the single most important thing and the Tesla battery pack to reference it to gasoline it weighs about a thousand pounds and it has the energy content of two and a half gallons gasoline so the so that means you gotta have a lot of charges well what that means is that but but there's there's an advantage that that that's because the the consumption of that energy is much more efficient in an electric car and this then this is I'll get to you know why is the Tesla Roadster twice as efficient as as two Toyota Prius which is obviously not not
12:43a sports car right and the reason is because an electric motor is fundamentally if super efficient at turning energy into motion so a good electric motor such as the one that we have in the deserts is about ninety percent efficient at turning the electricity into motion whereas a gasoline internal combustion engine is somewhere in the range of around seventeen or eighteen percent most of what it does is generate heat so so even
13:11though it's only two and a half gallons gasoline that two and a half gallons of energy content goes really far compared with you know if you had a gift that if that was okay compared to the priests but also compared to the new GM bolt right how does it do in comparison with the Volt well the Volt is a different architecture it uses a it's a plug-in hybrid architecture so it's I think got about a forty mile or so battery that's what they say and then there's an engine with a generator that allows you to go beyond the 40 minds act right and where's I was pure electric and the
13:47strategy that we've decided to hew to is is a pure electric strategy and I mean I've been criticized sometimes for responding to questions like yours just to explain why we've gone pure electric and then people are taking that to be an attack on the vault which is it's not the case I I hope the vote succeeds and I think it can be a pretty good car it's
14:13it's it's not pathetic it's but I just wanted to - you know what I hope to do in this conversation with you is figure out what it is you've done because you've got a fair amount of attention so figure out why you're not further along than you are or figure out why you are and what your expectations are yeah to do when where is the game for you I think it's taken a while for the industry to come around to it to this point but I think it's it's largely at this point it's it's it's almost become conventional wisdom that the future is electric cars the only question is this interim period of this transitional period but but if you look at the pace of battery improvement it's
14:50clear that this one I mean it's inevitable the future will be entirely electric and the irony of all this conversation is that in the last year a year before it's bankruptcy General Motors had announced that they'd bolt and it was the key to their future right as an automobile company right yeah exactly I mean when they're at but Chris is Imai think that it is is valid providing Jim is really come to that conclusion by the way well they should have that probably on a Prius or something like that but I think if you knew they had the ev1 right right exactly didn't work didn't work but didn't make it for reasons I'm not clear right and you know there's a
15:27marketing success yeah Chris painted a movie who killed the electric car right exactly and every summer Nabisco that issue but I think it's it's notable that in in that movie it shows that the customers who had the ev1 the cars had to be taken away from them and crushed and they held a candlelight vigil right if you have people that really love a product to the degree that they're willing to hold a candlelight vigil for it that that says hey maybe you should make an Eevee - it certainly does say that you know so the the car that I drove today the roadster - I think I mean I think it was a road trip before this is right right second iteration of it yeah I came came through
16:07production what year the first roadster number one the first first production roster which was fully you know developing a transport legal and all that sort of stuff that standard yeah yeah it was February of last year and that was my car that was the car your car meaning what the one who died at one okay yeah and so then you decided immediately to make improvements on that yeah yeah absolutely yeah it was it was a little rough going in the beginning and we had some issues with some of the powertrain components in fact not that but the hard stuff that the stuff that's sort of theoretically easier and you know we were able to fix those and get get
16:43production wrapped up and now we're at the point where we're delivering about twenty to twenty-five cause a week you know that Tata Motors obviously you know in I know - thought I'd take for a moment what he's doing in India yeah developing a little sedan for 2,300 all turned on right right where do you put that in the whole equation of where the future of cars are well I think it's a good idea to have affordable cause you know I think I think we're with the problem with with with something something like like the Nano which I think by I'm sorry problem I think it's a great idea and Russia there's a gentleman it's hard not to yeah exactly
17:28it's I think where it works gonna become challenging the futures as the price of gasoline Rises the cost of acquiring the car is a much less of an issue than the cost of operating a car and and I think oil it's over everything back up and you yeah do you have some assumptions in your own calculations as to where world will level off I think it will exceed
17:52that the numbers we've seen last year 144 oh yeah sure absolutely I think we'll see it sorta approach $200 and Beyond bid by twenty ten eleven twelve somewhere I'd say whatever the next boom is so if as I say the next boom is is four years from now it'll be around that around that point of all your businesses which one do you care the most about well right now my time is but roughly evenly between Tesla and SpaceX so it's I guess it would be pretty pretty even between the two and then Solar City is doing great on its own and the two co-founders they lived in a pewter ride we've done a phenomenal job and thankfully it requires very little my attention right now the reason
18:36to create a sports car a roadster as the first stage of this is because it attracts attention or what oh that's a great great question so because I feel often misinterpret why we have created a sports car because they will say you know the implication will be stars cars for rich guys right right exactly and it would serve like that I feel that there was somehow a shortage of sports cars and rich guys or something like that if
19:07you're if any new technology is expensive when it starts out and you can point pretty much anything and and then because the first thing but that you the engineers are trying to do is make it work and then when you made a work make it work then you optimize me optimize and you optimize and you look at the early days of computers or cell phones or almost anything even the early days of gasoline cars they used to be toys for rich people until they were made affordable and for long yeah and and then you combine that with the car yeah and then you combine that with the fact that we were just a little startup and that you know there's just
19:43no way that we could afford a billion dollars to make a giant car plant that would make you know hundreds of thousands of cars a year because that's the kind of volume you have to get to you to make to make cheap cars and and then and it's also the first iteration of technology so we have both a volume problem and a new technology problem and so that naturally the that you have to reach scale you have to reach scale and you have to work the bugs out of the system and and so you got to make it and you want to make your mistakes at a small scale okay so how's that going reaching scale and and and being able to to create a marketing a
20:21business plan that will enable you to reach a large audience you know and write and create and continue the development the technology that will make it even more attractive it's a it's going really well actually so it was a we had a few bumpy hump years in the beginning but at this point we're producing at a steady state of about an annualized production rate of about a thousand rows this boards cause a year we unveiled our sedan a few months ago which is a much more functional car and it's a $50,000 car so it's basically it's about half the price that the roads and the production run say and for the year 2010 for the Roadster will be about
20:59a thousand and for the sedan so then the stern end is only coming out in two years so into 2011 will be the first year right and what's the woodsy projection for that we're expecting to do 20,000 units a year for this event it's always difficult to predict these things exactly but but our target is is is will produce a total of about a hundred thousand of them in about 20,000 a year and they're going to be many variations on that we'll do an SUV and we'll do you know other things and then we'll do a third generation platform beyond the the sedan Model S sedan will be a sub $30,000 car so we're trying to get to mass production as soon as we possibly can and and by that that's both
21:39from the cars that we make ourselves as well as the cause we do in partnership with others like the Daimler deal you may have heard about and so how do you measure the odds of success personally I would say success for me for Tesla is that we've accelerated the advent of electric cars by at least five years so that the goal just to accelerate the
22:04advent of electric cars or to breed a great electric car company well I think the tourists I mean that you do want you do the other okay yeah and why is it that it's it's happening by a guy created a start-up in 2003 rather than a whole range of sort of industrial automobile companies around the world not just here Fiat is a successful car coming in in their own Chrysler right well it's disruptive technology like to where you really have a big technology discontinuity it tends to come from new companies you know you could ask the same question of why does Google come from what a Google car and Larry and Larry Sergey I've known Larry since before he got
22:49venture funding for good for Google man is he is good is he an investor and Tesla yes Larry and Sergey are investors and Tesla and they drive them or don't grow yeah the driver absolutely it because some of the criticism that comes at you and the company now is that that you went out to seek a lot of external financing and did not reach your goals well will which taking us longer to reach our goals but what was it raised a hundred men you raised 40 or what was it what was the goal well I think you know some of the some of the the stumbles were we're selling mistakes we made ourselves some of them work we're marking externalities and we were getting ready to raise or we're in
23:29fastest raising about a hundred million dollar round that began in instead of the summer of last year and then ran into you know force 5 hurricane an economic circumstance that took everything on right yeah and so we so that with that forced us to scale back our plans a little bit we had to do a layoff and we had to raise the money internally from existing investors I had to put up a lot of the money personally and we good things there was no money and so it that that was it was sort of hair-raising time for for the company but at this point we're actually in good shape we expect to be profitable in the third quarter and that comes from the success of the Roadster yeah and then
24:10the roads then we also have a powertrain supply business to Daimler as well for the for electric smart that we're doing with them make smart car an electric car yeah you know the smart car was always intended to be an electric carpet than anything that they can never get the battery right so a year and a half ago met with Daimler
24:28and that I strike mince them to work with us we actually I mean we've really tried hard to work with a lot of different car companies and and what happened well I guess they they think well this took the attitude of what you know what are some little start-up in Silicon Valley know that that we don't know who couldn't do and would you say to them well we drive our car and look at that technology and I don't know it just never seemed to sort of sink in but they don't dime the def word I'm late did actually so III went went through stood guard went down the way to India actually and met with dr. Webber the head of global R&D and and we had conversation so what does it take for us
25:10to work together we'd love to do something we'd love to do something with you know an affordable mass-market car that you know we ourselves couldn't do right now cuz we don't have the camera line most of it yeah and and and so I said what about you know what about electric smart and because the smart was always intended to be an electric car and and and would would take for us to work together and he said well if you could do a prototype that would have you that would really go a long way so we did we worked really hard the powertrain team live by JB Straubel did an awesome job and if forty days later when went when they came out to visit we said here's
25:44the car take a drive and they really liked what they saw and so what did they do then then they said okay well let's let's take him sort of another step further and and they gave us a little little R&D contract and and eventually got to the point where we got a contract for that to supply a thousand cars for them and then if we do well in that will potentially go into you know tens of thousands of cars so so that but this is a car that everyone could afford and and and could hopefully kept to come quite soon do you have a profile of the people who you think will want to buy these roadsters yeah absolutely it's the kind of person who who likes a performance
26:19car maybe they own a Porsche or you know you know bikini or something you know this car is actually faster than a Lamborghini 0-60 yeah it's it's it's fine I think fast they don't almost study anything for anything I know of yeah yeah I mean like things the really sort of million-dollar supercar obviously with those will be Enzo but
26:42but it's it's pretty much faster than it than any normal snore Mille sports car and and it's really easy to drive if you want a high-performance car with a clean conscience this is the only option the sedan is gonna be for someone that wants a great sedan and and also you know a clean conscience and Angeles is gonna be cheaper to operate than yeah you are as you well know a controversial guy as well I try not to be it finds you
27:13because you think big you're a software guy who has been successful in the private sector yeah you know there's see no reason you can't do things that other people have not been able to no matter how large the corporate enterprise create the best electric car or be put privately astronauts in space right what you say you will do in two years well yeah sort of depends on where NASA asks us to do that so if NASA turns on the
27:49access to be that this year which we're hopeful they will the White House has a convene a panel on the future of human space flight that that panel is going to make the recommendations in a few months I hope those some of those recommendations will be favorable to to SpaceX because the alternative is if if SpaceX doesn't do it we will be entirely dependent on the Russians to carry our astronauts to the space station after 2010 and with billions of dollars will be spent on essentially a sole source situation to the Russians which i think is outrageous and you haven't taken advantage of the opportunity to go in space yourself happy no I've not have
28:21you wanted to if it was it was purely a matter a matter of personal interest I would I would have done it for Eddie yeah I mean I know Sergei is a trust I'm interested in some interest yes yeah I would like to go at some point but it's I'm also in the point where I it's difficult for me to take personal risks I used to take a lot of personal children I've got my you know kids and and and responsibilities with companies as well and and so if I if I do things for the have personal risk at this point I risk more than they're my own mind my own way yeah you've had how many trips they get one set of drifters once one set of twins yeah they have the twin
29:08Smith in New York actually so they like they like the car yeah yeah never they can't drive and I can't go in the Roadster because it doesn't you know it's not very kid-friendly but you know it's not very kid-friendly you're right the sedan will be ideal for them so much success to you thank you for coming thank you for joining us see you next time
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 视频在 B 站收看UP 主「SpaceX小工」搬运
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版