访谈·中文精读

完整通话:马斯克 Twitter 全员大会 6/16/22

FULL CALL: Twitter All Hands with Elon Musk 6/16/22

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2022 年 6 月 16 日,马斯克出现在 Twitter 的全员大会上。这是他宣布收购之后第一次面对全体员工,会议开了整整一小时。

他开口没讲宏大愿景,先做了一道除法:Twitter 的日活用户大约两亿,地球上有八十亿人,中间差着七十八亿。

这道除法他在整场会里用了三遍。讲包容性时用,讲产品时用,最后定义什么叫收购成功时又用了一次。一小时听下来,他脑子里的判断挺一致:一个全世界只有 4% 到 5% 的人认真在用的产品,这个比例本可以是 50%。

会上被问到的问题都很尖锐。裁员、远程办公、算法开源、政治立场、到底当不当 CEO。回答里有几个概念分得很清楚,值得单独拎出来看。

他爱 Twitter,因为他讨厌新闻稿

主持人第一个问题很直接:你为什么爱 Twitter,为什么想买它。

马斯克说他在 Twitter 上学到很多,文字、图片、视频、梗图都算。更重要的用途是发布消息。要宣布一件事,Twitter 是最好的渠道,信息瞬间直达所有人。

他打了个比方,说自己用 Twitter 表达自己,就像有些人用发型表达自己。

接着他讲旧时代发新闻稿的流程,语气里带着明显的不耐烦。你得先写一份关于自己的新闻稿,写得还挺谄媚,本质上是宣传材料,然后指望媒体来报道这份新闻稿,再指望他们写得跟你想要的一样。而他们通常不会。

你读到的新闻里,正面的是多少,负面的是多少?压倒性是负面的。然后当你亲身经历过某件事,再去看媒体怎么报道它,他们有多少次说对了?几乎从来没有。(马斯克)

这是他反复强调的一点:媒体报道天然带着一层负面滤镜。他自己用 Twitter 的核心动机,就是绕过这层滤镜,直接和公众说话。

他把 Twitter 叫数字城市广场,说完马上补了一句,说这个比喻其实还不够。城市广场装不下几百万人,Twitter 可以。他认为这对民主制度的健康运转是必需的,人得有自由表达的能力。

话说得很满,他立刻自己划了边界:一切表达都要在法律框架内。真去违法,公司会被关停。

言论自由和触达自由,是两件不同的事

这场会里最有信息量的一个概念区分出现在这里。

马斯克说,言论自由是一回事,触达自由(freedom of reach)是另一回事。

任何人现在都可以走到时代广场正中间,说他想说的任何话,比如否认大屠杀。是的,他们可以那么干。但这不意味着这些话必须被推送给几百万人。(马斯克)

这句话把很多争论的前提翻转了。平台之前的困境是两头挨骂:删了被指责压制表达,推了被指责纵容有害内容。马斯克给出的第三条路是,可以说,但不会被算法放大。

他认为人应该被允许说相当出格的话,只要不越界,这些话不该自动获得海量曝光。这个思路后面串起了他关于算法开源、蓝标验证、喷子成本的一整套主张。

顺带说一句,这个区分在实践里极难执行。谁来判定一条内容「合法但不必放大」,判定过程怎么被监督,他没有展开。但他把问题从「删不删」改写成了「推不推」,这一步本身就有价值。

审核的标准落在用户为什么留下来

主持人追问了一个很具体的难题:美国法律允许很多合法但让人不适的内容,比如动物虐待影像、恶作剧视频、性暴力相关的内容。放任这些东西,用户会跑。

马斯克的回答绕开了删不删,落在用户为什么留下来上。他说内容冒犯到人,人就会停止使用 Twitter,所以平台必须让人待着舒服。标准不能停在「不冒犯」这条线上。

标准应该高得多:用户得觉得非常有趣、非常有收获。你完全可以不冒犯任何人,同时让他们觉得无聊透顶,那他们照样会走。(马斯克)

他前一天晚上刚和人聊过 TikTok,会上把 TikTok 拿出来当参照。原话是,TikTok 在让人上瘾这件事上做得好极了,感觉像多动症,但高了一个量级。他甚至承认自己觉得 TikTok 上有些视频挺冒犯,紧接着说了一句:可它们不无聊。

他对 Twitter 的期待是另一种版本:也要有趣,但要能让人了解严肃议题。他认为 Twitter 在严肃议题上的表现可以好得多。

这里他给了一条具体的内容原则:一个问题如果有两面,就要把两面都呈现出来,不要推动单一叙事。

大多数议题是复杂的,没法简化成这边全是好人、那边全是坏人。如果能让人们看到多个角度,Twitter 对公众的价值会大得多。(马斯克)

全球运营的法律边界也被问到。他的回答很直接:在各国尽量做到法律允许的极限。如果某个国家有四分之一的员工会因为守法而被逮捕,那当然守法,或者退出这个国家。能让人发声到什么程度,就做到什么程度。

这段回答里藏着一个常被忽略的现实约束。跨国平台的言论政策从来不只是价值观问题,它同时是一道法律算术题。马斯克把这道题算得很直白。

两亿和八十亿之间的那道缝

主持人提到 Twitter 一直在推进多元与包容,问他的看法。

马斯克没有从公司政策切入,又回到了那道除法。八十亿人对两亿日活,差额七十八亿。他说想要至少十亿人在 Twitter 上,越多越好。

这是包容性最包容的定义:所有人。(马斯克)

逻辑链条是这样的:想覆盖更多人,就得让更多人愿意待着;人被骚扰、觉得不舒服,就会离开;所以平台必须同时做到允许表达和让人舒适。这个平衡做不好,Twitter 就永远只是个小众产品。

谈到公司内部,他说自己信奉严格的精英制(meritocracy),谁能做出好成果,谁就获得更多责任,就这样。

有员工问,公司里这么多聪明人,怎么赢得你的信任,你又怎么赢得大家的信任。他的回答带着一贯的直白:他说话尽量字面化,不用揣摩弦外之音,读字面意思就行。至于信任,他的判断落在产出上。

有人把事情做成了,那很好。有人没做成,那我就会问,他为什么还在这家公司?(马斯克)

这话在全员大会上说出来,现场气氛大概不会太轻松。它和后面的裁员回答逻辑一致:他对人的评价只有一根标尺,做出成果。

内容创作者在用 Twitter 给 YouTube 导流

聊到产品,马斯克举了一个他反复想不通的例子。

一个创作者做了视频,会把视频发到 YouTube,然后在 Twitter 上放个链接。原因很简单:YouTube 能赚钱,Twitter 不能。

创作者用 Twitter 给他们的 YouTube 视频导流量,因为那是他们谋生的方式。这真的很荒谬。(马斯克)

他的结论是,Twitter 想让创作者把内容放过来,就必须提供变现机制。否则永远只是别人的流量入口。

他顺手把这个思路推得更远,说要研究人们为什么不用 Twitter、为什么点进来又走了。把这些原因解决掉,使用量和价值自然上去。

然后他提到了微信。

中国有微信,它是个非常好的应用,但中国之外没有对等的产品。在中国你基本是「活」在微信里的,因为它对日常生活太有用了。Twitter 如果做到接近那个程度,就是巨大的成功。(马斯克)

这个参照点他后来提过很多次。把它放在全员大会上说,意思很清楚:他脑子里的对标产品落在生活基础设施这一层,社交网络这个定位装不下它。

微信这个类比还隐含着一层产品哲学:把一个高频社交入口做成支付、服务、内容的集合体,用户的迁移成本会高到几乎无法离开。Twitter 今天的问题恰恰相反,用户随时可以走,走了也不损失什么。

mDAU 是他最担心的数字

主持人问他,收购推进到现在,哪些东西已经看明白了,哪些还要深入学。

他说产品这块自己理解得比较透,因为他每天都在用。理解得最少的是机器人、垃圾账号、一人操控几百个账号这类问题。

任何影响可变现日活用户数(mDAU)的东西,是我最大的担忧。因为广告收入和订阅收入都直接由这个数字驱动。(马斯克)

他顺手把 Twitter 的收入结构说了一遍:广告、订阅。支付也是个有意思的方向。但所有这些都取决于系统里到底有多少个真实的活人。

这段回答解释了他在整场会里反复回到 mDAU 的原因。广告主付钱买的是真人注意力,订阅用户付钱买的是真人之间的互动。这个数字一旦注水,两条收入线一起塌。

关于怎么解决,他的关键词是透明。

他主张算法开源,让外界能批评、能改进、能挑出 bug 和偏见。任何自动化的处理都应该公开、说清楚。如果平台对某条推文做了加权或干预,就明确标出来,让人不用猜。

一旦处理过程不可解释,人们就会往最坏的方向想,而那往往不是事实。透明度直接建立信任。(马斯克)

他把清理机器人、垃圾账号、刷量工厂称为系统的可用性问题,用了「极其重要」这个词。在他的框架里,信任和可用性是同一件事的两面。

三美元一个蓝标,和一支太便宜的喷子军队

他提了一个具体的产品改动,讲得很细。

现在的 Twitter Blue 订阅,付了钱之后账号在系统里的标识完全不变,看起来还是普通 ID。他想改的地方在这里:如果付了订阅费,就给一个小标记,标明这个账号经过了支付层面的验证。

很多人会觉得这挺有用:至少有个标识说明我大概不是机器人、不是垃圾账号、不是一个人操控一百个号。我记得是三美元一个月。(马斯克)

配套的是排序机制:评论和提及按验证状态优先展示。他特别强调,能验证的人数量要非常大,不该是少数人的特权。

紧接着他澄清了一个容易被误解的点:验证不该成为使用 Twitter 的前提。他从来没建议过必须验证才能发帖,只是让已验证的发言和互动排在前面。

背后的成本逻辑他讲得很清楚:要让养一支喷子军队变得很贵。现在搞十万个机器人账号,几乎不花钱。加一道支付门槛,成本结构就变了。

匿名的价值他也保住了。用户可以用支付方式验证,Twitter 从支付角度知道你是谁,但不需要用真名。

比如一个人的政治观点和他的上司不一样,他并不想在这件事上和上司闹僵,那用化名会更好。但后台依然是验证过的。(马斯克)

这套设计值得多想一层。它把「身份」和「身份公开」拆开了。系统知道你是谁,其他用户不知道。这个拆法在隐私和反滥用之间找了个落点,代价是把验证权交给了支付通道,而支付通道本身也有门槛,比如没有银行卡的人。

远程办公:倾向现场,但不会开除一个远程的优秀员工

这是会上员工最关心的两个问题之一。Twitter 有一千五百人全职远程,多数人是混合办公。而马斯克刚给特斯拉高管发过一封关于远程办公的邮件。

他先区分了行业。特斯拉造车,车不可能远程造。工厂、供应链、零件进厂、组装、运到车主手上,这些环节都必须在现场完成,物理上不可能远程。

特斯拉内部有些工作确实可以远程,比如软件和设计。即便如此,他还是认为应该尽量在现场做。

但如果有个人在岗位上极其出色,他远程也能保持高效,那就可以。(马斯克)

特斯拉的具体做法是:经理必须确认这个人是优秀贡献者,才允许远程。他把这套流程称为「挺基本的」。

他也承认远程有代价,沟通效率会下降。人在同一个办公室里,隔着几张桌子,实时沟通很容易;换个物理位置,难度就上去了。

所以他补了一条:即使远程,也要偶尔来办公室,至少得认得同事。他的原话是,不要在街上走过同事身边却不认识对方,那很糟糕。

主持人当场做了确认式复述:支持远程和分布式办公,前提是产出高、有意义,关键时刻能到场,具体看岗位。马斯克说这个理解准确,同时重申倾向性明确地偏向现场办公。

他还堵了一个逻辑漏洞:如果一个员工非常优秀,只是必须远程,却因为远程就把他开掉,那是疯了。他不支持疯狂的做法。

这段问答里有个细节挺关键。他给出的是一套判定顺序:先看这个人行不行,再看这个岗位能不能远程,两个条件都满足才放行。规则越具体,执行时的摩擦越小。

成本和收入倒挂,所以必须裁员

裁员问题问得很直接。员工想知道特斯拉最近的裁员会不会复制到 Twitter。

马斯克的回答没有绕弯:这取决于公司。目前 Twitter 的成本超过收入,局面不算健康。

必须对人数和费用做一些合理化,让收入大于成本。否则 Twitter 根本无法存续,也谈不上增长。(马斯克)

他同时给了安抚:重大的贡献者没什么可担心的。他不会采取损害公司健康的动作。

现场没有人追问「重大贡献者」的判定标准。这句话在会上听起来是定心丸,事后回看,它留出的解释空间相当大。

把这段和他的精英制表态放在一起读,他的用人逻辑就完整了:留下来的标准是产出,裁掉的标准也是产出,中间没有缓冲带。这套逻辑效率很高,代价是组织安全感的流失。

SpaceX 的薪酬模式:发期权,半年一次流动性

Twitter 员工大多习惯了上市公司的薪酬结构,现在要变成私营公司,这是个实际问题。

马斯克说 SpaceX 处在两全其美的状态:股票和期权发给所有人,但不用承受上市公司的那些麻烦。股价每天涨跌是极大的干扰,还有做空者、集体诉讼,整个人被绑在股价上。

SpaceX 的做法是每半年搞一次流动性事件,员工有机会卖掉手里的股份。这套机制在公司整个生命周期里运行得很好。

我觉得 Twitter 也可以这么办:照样发期权,然后每年两次流动性机会。(马斯克)

这个安排解决的是私营公司股权最实际的痛点:账面财富变不成现金。半年一次的回购窗口,把长期激励和短期可兑现性接上了。

政治立场:他一直投民主党,这次投了共和党

有人问他怎么看待自己的政治观点,以及这些观点会不会影响他领导的公司。

他说自己的政治立场是温和的。如果画一条全国政治观点的正态分布曲线,他大概落在中间位置。

然后给了一个具体事实:在此之前每一次选举他都投民主党,最近这一次投了共和党的梅拉·弗洛雷斯(Mayra Flores)。他补充说这位候选人是墨西哥裔美国人,是个不错的候选人。

他表态支持温和政治,同时认为持极端观点的人也应在法律范围内表达出来。

如果 Twitter 上左右两边各 10% 的人被同等程度地激怒了,那大概就是个好结果。(马斯克)

这句话后来被引用得很多。它给出了一个可操作的平衡标准:不看哪一方骂得更凶,看两边的愤怒是否对称。

这个标准妙在可测量。平台做内容决策时,最容易陷入的争论是「我们是不是偏向某一边」。把它换成一个对称性检查,争论就有了落点。

广告要好看,他自己被 YouTube 广告骗过

谈到商业模式,马斯克先解释了一个常被误解的点:特斯拉和 SpaceX 不做广告,症结在需求远超产量。他对广告本身没什么意见。

广告的本质是需求生成器。产能跟不上,做广告是自找麻烦。Twitter 的情况完全不同,广告对它非常重要。

他对广告的期待有两条:一是有趣,二是不骗人。

我会想跟广告主说,咱们把广告做得尽可能有趣。广告有趣才有效,别搞得刺耳、别搞得像垃圾信息。(马斯克)

然后他讲了自己的上当经历。他在 YouTube 广告上买过一个东西,拿到手发现不能用,去谷歌一查,翻到搜索结果第二页才看到真相:这产品就是垃圾。

我当时就想,YouTube 为什么要允许这种骗人的产品投广告?这完全不酷。(马斯克)

他给好广告下的定义是三条同时成立:内容有趣、用户可能真的想要、产品本身对用户有益。第三条最容易被平台忽略,因为前两条直接对应点击率,第三条不直接进报表。

钱本质上是信息

支付这件事他提过好几次,会上给了完整表述。

他的定义是,钱本质上是一种信息,让人不用以物易物就能交换产品和服务,也让人可以把义务延后履行。而钱在今天已经是数字形态了,这个状态持续了相当长时间。

他夸了 PayPal 在支付上做得好,然后说把好的支付能力放进 Twitter 是合理的:方便转账,也包括加密货币。

我的目标是把这个服务的有用性最大化。越有用越好。如果能在上面方便地完成支付,那就是有用性的提升。(马斯克)

他把方向归成三块:新闻、娱乐、支付。判断标准只有一条,怎么让用 Twitter 这件事变得足够有吸引力,让所有人都想用。

这个三块划分和前面的微信类比咬得很紧。新闻和娱乐解决打开频率,支付解决账户价值。三块拼起来,用户才可能真正「住」在一个应用里。

头衔不重要:技术之王和财政大臣

关于他到底会不会当 CEO,会上被直接问了。

他说自己对头衔没那么执念。证据是他在特斯拉把自己改名叫「技术之王」(TechnoKing),还在 SEC 文件里正式备了案。顺带把 CFO 改名成「财政大臣」(Master of Coin),他觉得这比 CFO 酷多了。

他真正想做的是产品:改进产品,聚焦软件和产品设计。

CEO 有很多杂事要处理。我只想确保产品快速、往好的方向演进,头衔是什么我真不在乎。(马斯克)

但他也把话说清楚了:人们得听他的。如果他说产品要往这个方向改、要加这些功能,那就得改。他在 SpaceX 和特斯拉就是这么干的,主要精力放在工程和生产上。

他顺手解释了一个外界常见的误判。看起来他整天在外面发声,实际上他接受的采访数量很少。一条推文会被写成两页长的文章,于是显得他无处不在。

我在 SpaceX 和特斯拉其实非常内部聚焦,虽然看起来不像。(马斯克)

这段话透露的管理方式值得记一笔:他进公司的切入点是产品决策权,其他事务可以交出去。放在一个产品停滞多年的公司身上,这个切入点选得相当直接。

外星人没有证据,但文明只有五千年

中场闲聊时,主持人问起外星人。马斯克的回答很干脆:没看到任何证据。他被问过很多次,一次证据都没见过。

话题转回他的坐标系。他给两家公司各下了一个「根本好处」的定义。

特斯拉的衡量标准是:我们把可持续能源的转型加速了多少年。

SpaceX 的衡量标准是:我们能不能让生命成为多行星物种,能不能提高意识存续下去的概率。星链(Starlink)提供的全球互联网也归在这条线下。

再往上抽一层,他给出了一套统一的哲学:采取最有可能扩展意识的范围、规模和存续时间的行动。文明在某个时点会终结,那就尽量让它活得久一点。

他的好奇心也挂在这套框架上。宇宙的本质是什么,我们为什么在这里,生命的意义是什么,我们能不能飞到别的星系,看看有没有其他文明。也许有一大堆单行星文明在五亿年前存在过,现在什么都没留下。

从文字出现算起,人类文明只有大约五千年,跟地球的年龄比就是一闪。我们要做的,是让这一闪变成能烧很久的火焰。(马斯克)

这段听起来离 Twitter 很远。把它和后面的成功定义连起来看,逻辑是通的:他判断一家公司的价值,最终看它对文明做了什么。

收购成功的定义

最后一个问题:五年到十年后,什么算这次收购成功。

他给了两个层级。

业务层面的指标是日活大幅增长。如果日活能过十亿,那仍然只是世界人口的八分之一,但相对今天已经是巨大的改进。

更高一层的判断是:Twitter 有没有让文明变得更强、更长久,有没有让人更好地理解现实的本质。他的原话是,从正式角度讲,看 Twitter 是否显著提升了文明的强度和寿命。

会开到这里结束,他答应会有第二场。

这场会里真正值得记住的东西

回看整场问答,马斯克给出的是一套彼此咬合的判断。

他把「能说」和「能被推到几百万人面前」拆成了两件事,这个拆分同时回应了内容审核的两难和算法透明的要求。他用支付验证把喷子的成本抬高,同时保住了匿名使用权。他用 mDAU 这个数字把所有产品讨论锚定在「系统里到底有多少真人」上。他用每半年一次的流动性事件解决了私有化之后的期权问题。

他也留下了没答清楚的地方。裁员时「重大贡献者不用担心」这句话,没有给出判定标准。日活从两亿到十亿的路径,除了「让产品更有用」,没有更具体的拆解。

但有一个信号明确无误:他对 Twitter 的期待落在「更接近微信的东西」上。理解这一点,后面几年的很多动作就都能对上号。

  • 看平台政策争论时,先分清「能否表达」和「能被多少人看到」这两件事,很多吵架源于把两者混为一谈。
  • 评估一个内容平台的天花板,看它有没有让创作者赚到钱的机制。没有变现路径的平台,最终只是别人的流量入口。
  • 判断一个社区产品的健康度,别只看日活总量,看有多少是真人。可变现用户数是广告和订阅共同的地基。
  • 如果你在做一个需要抑制滥用的系统,抬高作恶成本比事后清理有效得多。一道小额支付门槛的效果,往往好过一支审核团队。
  • 算法透明度可以主动设计。把干预行为明确标出来,比让人猜要安全,猜疑的成本永远高于披露的成本。
  • 远程办公的讨论里,把「岗位能不能远程」和「这个人远程做得好不好」分开判断,比一刀切合理。
  • 听到「我们要让产品更有用」这类目标时,追问一句:用什么数字衡量,起点多少,终点多少。马斯克自己给的是两亿到十亿。
  • 任何关于公平的表态,都值得追问它的可测标准。左右各 10% 同等被激怒这类对称性指标,比「我们保持中立」这种话有用得多。
  • 如果所在公司要私有化,盯住股权的兑现机制。期权再多,没有回购窗口也只是一张纸。
语音识别自动转录(Whisper),含全部发言人,可能有识别错误。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。

0:00All right. Hello everyone. Thanks for joining this special Q&A session with Elon. Elon, thank you so much for joining us. The company's been so eager to hear from you live and direct. We all appreciate you joining us today. Absolutely. Our product is planning. It's quite good to speak to everyone.

0:19Since we started late, I'm going to go right ahead and talk to Leslie so that she can moderate this Q&A session for us. Okay, sounds good. Amazing. Thanks for a high you on. We have a lot to cover, a ton to cover. So I am going to ask you a question that usually gives us at the end, which is, you know, you come back for a part two at some point.

0:41If there are things that we don't cover. Oh, yeah. Absolutely. Okay. Okay. Great. Okay. So we have some pretty good. So I really do see this at the beginning of a conversation, obviously with the company at large, and also the teams and leaders over the next coming weeks and months and beyond.

0:56So we're just getting started. OK, so I'm going to zoom all the way out to the reason that we're actually here together today. And that is because you love Twitter. I love Twitter. Yes, I want to be fair about that. I love Twitter. In fact, I literally have tweeted, I love Twitter.

1:13You have. So tell us, say more, why do you love Twitter, and also why did you and do you want to buy Twitter? Well, let's see. I find like I learn a lot from what I read on Twitter and what I see in the pictures, videos, text, and memes that people create. I also find it's a great way to get a message out

1:53if I'm going to say something, make an announcement. I think Twitter's the best way to do that. It just goes that immediately to everyone. And I made this joke already, but some people use their hair to express themselves. I use Twitter. So I find it's for communicating with a lot of people

2:31simultaneously and getting that message directly to people. In the past, you'd have to, in order for somebody to read about something, you'd have to issue a press release or, and then you'd hope that the regular media would write about the press release and then they wouldn't write about it and quite the way you liked to write about it.

2:54I really found those like, the old style press releases kind of, like really quite strange because you're writing a press release about yourself, which is sort of something that the media, it's like some overly flattering, it's like mainly sort of propagandist, in fact, quite propagandist, and in hope that the media writes something favorable, which they usually

3:17do not. And I think that actually is maybe one of the best reasons for me using Twitter is attacking community, directed people and not through the lens of the media. I think this is obviously important role for the media to play, but as anyone knows who reads the newspaper, it's coming through quite a negative lens.

3:41I have to say, how many newspaper articles do you read that are positive? How many news articles do you read that are negative? What percentage are positive? What percentage negative? And then when you read about, it's obviously overwhelming the negative. And then when you read about something in these newspaper

4:01or it's a dated term in the news, where you actually personally understand the situation, how many times have the media got not right? I would say almost never, not never, but almost never. So this is a way for people to communicate directly with each other and not through a negative lens.

4:26And I think that's extremely important for the world. So I'm sort of going waxing on about this, but I think it's pretty important. And, you know, that, you can sort of my comments about Twitter being sort of like a digital town square, but really much more than that, because you can't put that many people in town square, you have to communicate with millions of people on Twitter. That's just an incredibly

4:56important thing and I think it's essential for functioning democracy to function well. I think it's essential to have a free speech and to be able to communicate freely. Now, But the free speech stuff, this needs to be, you know, it's free speech within the context of the law. So I'm not definitely not suggesting that we, you know, just flout the law because we'll

5:27get shut down in that case. And I think there's also this freedom of speech and freedom of reach. And you know, freedom of speech is one thing because like anyone could just go into the middle of Times Square right now and say anything they want, they just walk into the middle of of Times Square and tonight at the Holocaust, okay?

5:47Yes, to all of them, they will just do that. But that doesn't mean you have to, that needs to be promoted to millions of people. So I think people should be allowed to say, pretty outrageous things that are within the bounds of law, but then they don't, you know, doesn't get amplified, that doesn't get, you know, a ton of reach.

6:05And I think an important goal for Twitter, we're really trying to include as much of the country, as much of the world as possible. So currently, it's a relatively small percentage of the world that is, it is a small percentage of what that is on Twitter, if you say like daily active users, do you think that that's say 200 million?

6:27You've got eight billion people on Earth. That's a 7.8 billion going on on Twitter. So that's a pretty big number. I think you want as many, as much as possible on Twitter, you want to be as inclusive as possible for all this demographic. And for that to happen, people must like being on Twitter.

6:47So if they're being harassed or they're uncomfortable, they're sucking you use Twitter. And so we have to sort of strike this balance of allowing people to say what they want to say, but also make people comfortable on Twitter. Well, if they simply want to use it, it will be quite niche.

7:12And I think there's also a lot that should be done in terms of enhancing the core technology and offerings of Twitter. Like right now, if somebody does a video, like let's say a content creator does a video, then they're going to put that video on YouTube and just put a link to it from Twitter

7:32because they're able to monetize their content on YouTube but not on Twitter. And I think it's going to be really important for if you want people to put the content on Twitter we do, then there has to be a mechanism for content creators to monetize that content. And so they can do a poster, they can post it to YouTube and to Twitter.

7:52But I think it's crazy right now that content creators will use Twitter to drive traffic to their YouTube video because that's how they make a living. And that really should be on Twitter. Like, we want to basically address the reasons that people, like, why aren't more people using Twitter and why do people click away from Twitter?

8:17And if we can address those reasons, then they'll use Twitter more and they'll get greater value from service. And if I think of like WeChat in China, which is actually a great app, but there's no WeChat equivalent outside of China. And I think that there's a real opportunity to create that

8:48sort of, you basically live on WeChat in China. So because it's so useful and so helpful to your daily life. And I think if we achieve that, or even close to that with Twitter, be an immense success. Hopefully that is, you know, I really went on there, but I don't have to elaborate on any of those points.

9:11Yeah, no, it's great. And we're gonna get a little bit deeper on pre-station policy a little bit later. So I do wanna come back to this, actually. But in terms of, you clearly have a lot of thoughts around sort of the problems, which would have been that aren't working well, or sort of the barriers to what's possible.

9:26How do you see your buying the company? Is that sort of feed your desire to buy the companies? Or how do you see these things sort of together? And what's your thought process around that? Well, there's definitely an ongoing challenge with Twitter with bought accounts and spam accounts

9:54that this looked quite a lot of crypto scams on Twitter. It's gotten better, but there's still a fair bit of that. There are also people where they're not necessarily bots, but they might be operating one person's operating hundreds of accounts and trying to make them look like individuals, but they're

10:12not. So, I think a lot of this is not reiterating something I said publicly, but I'm back on Twitter. In order for people to have trust in Twitter, I think it's extremely important that there be transparency. So that's why I'm an advocate of say having the algorithm be open source, so that people can critique it, improve it, identify bugs potentially or bias.

10:43But when it's transparency, it obviously increases trust. So I think it's just very important like anything that's happening on an automated basis, be open source and be clear. And then if there is any action taken by someone with the Twitter to boost or something with a tweet, then it's just very clearly identified on the tweets of people aren't subscribing to Malice,

11:16that is the way there's no Malice. So, but when it's inscrutable, then people don't know what to think, and they will sometimes think the worst when that's actually not true. So I think that trust is extremely important, and then just for the usefulness of the system, getting rid of, it kind of sort of control farms and bots and spam is incredibly important.

11:42I'm gonna have a photo in this regard, which I think is my work, which is to, you know, this is currently just Twitter blue, but if you get Twitter blue, it doesn't, your identification in the system does not change at all. You still look up the normal user ID. But I think if it was like a little, you know, Twitter blue authenticated, not like authenticated like this, Lendredy, but authenticated at least by Twitter blue payments,

12:10just using the payment, are you backing on the payment system to your authentication? That I think a lot of people will be like, Okay, that's pretty helpful to have some designation that's my name, that in case I'm probably not a bot host spam or one person is operating 100 accounts.

12:31And that's like three bucks a month, I believe. I think that would be pretty helpful. And then also prioritizing comments and mentions whatnot by who is, verified in this broader sense the word of verification, in the sense of, you know, the it could have blew verified and just prioritized, you know, like that about someone who's not

13:00not verified. So there's so many people read access to the system, so we pull right access to the system, but you essentially, any tweets or outreactions would be prioritized according to who's verified. And then a very large number of people can be verified. I'm going to have a couple of questions on this specifically, but giving you mentioned trust,

13:26I wanted to ask when we avoid questions around trust. They said, Twitter has a lot of incredible, smart, talented people. What can we do to earn your trust and what are you going to do to earn our hours? I don't trust it as I trust it. So I can't be extremely literal in what I say.

13:55So aspiration in one does not need to read between the lines, so it can simply read the lines. And so the things that I've said about Twitter I think are you need to have in order for it to be, to really go to the next level. I mean, I think the potential is there for Twitter to have, and be accessible to an order of bang to more people, and for a lot more people to find it useful.

14:24And if not currently, I guess it would be four or four percent of the world or something like that. I don't know, it's a four or five percent of the world, optimistically is finding Twitter useful, and maybe 50% of the world find Twitter useful. So I want to take whatever actions would lead to that.

14:46And I'm very much like, it's, it's, I wouldn't say it's necessarily a cross thing. It's like, if somebody's getting useful things done, then that's great. And if they're not getting useful things done, and I'm like, okay, why are they at the company? So it's really just like we need to improve the core technology,

15:13improve the design, and you know, so. Trust emerges from that. Yeah, I mean, trust me. Yes, it's not like, I take trust. It's not exactly, but it's like, you know, if somebody's getting stuff done, great, I I love them and if they're not, I don't like the night to roll. Space report.

15:38Can we say, I would like to say on this topic of employees and how we work. So distributed work is something that has been core to our strategy. Most of our people work in a hybrid model. About 1,500 people work remote full time. We know that you recently sent a communication to Tesla executives about remote work.

15:57Can you share what your point of view is on remote work and specifically for Twitter? Yeah, so Tesla makes cars, and you cannot make cars remotely. Obviously, you have to make cars in a big factory, and the supply chain, and you have to bring in the parts, and assemble them, and then transport the car to the owner.

16:23All of these things must be done in person, because it's physically impossible to do them remotely. There are some rules at Tesla where the work can be done remotely, like say, software or design. And so that, you know, I think that's still a case where you want to aspire to do things in person.

16:46But if somebody is exceptional at their job, then it's possible for them to be effective even working remotely. So with Wathesele, I simply have asked for a list, that the manager has to confirm that they're an excellent contributor and if they do, they're allowed to work remotely.

17:10So it's pretty basic, I think. There is a hit one takes remotely because they've just reduced a speed of core and it's like it's hard to, you know, like, like, if you just, there's really, it really, it kind of matters to be in person, at least some of the time. So, like one of the things I said, even if somebody's working remotely, they're gonna show up at the office occasionally, so that they recognize their colleagues, and don't, you know, you don't have to walk down the street and pass your colleague, and, and they're, you don't recognize them, that would not be good.

17:45Yeah, no, I think this is, this is super clarifying, and resonates with us, and it's hard to wait of how it works. So thank you for clarifying that topic. It's really important to us. I would like to keep on the topic of employees and some of the questions that have come through.

18:01This one's on compensation and benefits. Most people, especially obviously here, are used to working for a public company. Can you talk a little bit about how you compensate folks at SpaceX as a private company? How does it work and what approach you plan to take at Twitter as a private company?

18:18Yeah, and so SpaceX I think operates in the best of both worlds where stock and options are issued to everyone but we don't have all the challenges being publicly traded company with stock to be up and down for one day for the next to be quite a distraction and where one is at for most of your short-sellers and

18:40class action lawsuits and just generally it's like being in the stock and there's 30 meters that you're all there. So SpaceX still allows liquidity, and so every six months, this liquidity event at SpaceX and people have the opportunity to sell their shares. And that's worked very well for the whole life of the company.

19:04So I think something like that would make sense at Twitter. So it's still be starting options, everything, and it just be liquidity events twice a year. Great, and thanks. We are getting some real-time feedback on the remote work questions, so I just want to make sure I follow up. Your approach to remote work

19:22and distributed work at Twitter, you are, is that what I'm hearing from you, is that you are supportive of remote distributed work as it is productive and meaningful and faithful show up when it's important and depending on the job. Is that an accurate reflection? Yeah, I mean the bias definitely needs to be strongly towards

19:42working in person, but if somebody is exceptional, then remote work can be okay. But then, if their work output is exceptional, then remote work is fine. There is some communication, you know, impact that one takes when working remotely, because if you're with people, you know, and they're just, you know, a few desks away, it's very

20:08It's easy to communicate in real time, but it's much harder to do that if you're in a different physical location. So I do want to emphasize that the bias is very much towards the input support. It's just that it would obviously be insane if someone is excellent at what they do,

20:23but it can only work remotely to then fire them even though they're doing excellent work would be insane. So I'm definitely not in favor of things that are like mad. I mean, they were things that will the business make it better. Thank you. Question about layoffs. We received several questions from employee on this point.

20:46Obviously, they write about the recent layoffs at Tesla. Can you speak to how you're thinking about layoffs at Twitter? Well, I think it depends on the company. This needs to be to get healthy. So right now the costs exceed the revenue. So that's not a great situation to be in. And so there would have to be some rationalization of the head count and expenses to have revenue be greater than cost.

21:18Otherwise Twitter is certainly not viable or can't grow. So I think it would just be dependent on But I said that anyone who is like a significant contributor should have nothing to worry about. I'm not to take actions which are destructive to the health of the company. So you know.

21:48And you want a question connected to that. As you're obviously learning and gaining information as we get closer to the steel being closed, what do you feel that you have sort of a deep understanding of grasp of and what are the areas that you feel you want to dive much more deeper on to understand and learn?

22:06Well, I certainly have a stronger understanding of the product, because I use Twitter every day, practically. And I think you're going to have a really good understanding of our standpoint. What I have less understanding of is, you know, like this sort of bot spam or multi-user This is anything that affects the monetizable daily user number is probably my biggest concern,

22:43because that's really what drives advertising revenue as well as subscription revenue. And really, the Twitter's revenue revenue is going to be subscription advertising. I think payments would be an interesting thing to do as well. But all of those things are only relevant as a function of how many unique humans are on the system.

23:11So that's my biggest concern and that's what I said publicly as well. Like I said, I try to be as literal as possible. And as we think about, obviously, the product and the service and serving customers all around the world, clearly it's critical and existential for us to serve diverse communities and all

23:40people, as you said earlier. So inclusion diversity is obviously core and essential to our work at Twitter both are employees and the customers that we serve. You've been both whole on a variety of different topics and issues that relate to inclusion and diversity. Can you talk about your views and also your commitment to creating a diverse and inclusive

23:59workplace and also a service where everyone can feel included and safe? Yeah, I mean, well, it's really clear. You know, if you want to talk about the, you know, that's a set of our Twitter's whole, like there's 8 billion people in the world. There's sort of, I'm told there's 200 billion, you know, daily users of Twitter.

24:22That's a 7.8 billion person gap. So I think we really want to have at least a billion people on Twitter, maybe more, as many people as you can possibly get on Twitter. So that I think is the most inclusive definition of inclusiveness. It's like all humans. So that's important. on the company standpoint, I believe in something in a strict neurotocracy.

24:54So whatever, who can remember doing great work, great, they get more responsibility than 30. And that's that. And I know you mentioned in some of our conversations about your IMD team at Tesla, we have an amazing IMD team here at Twitter as well. So continue on the journey together.

25:16I wanted to talk about content matteration go back to a number of things that you said earlier. So this is what I'll take. I'll take verbatim. So you've spoken a lot about the importance of pre-speech. Let's start with the U.S. where we have a strong tradition around this and you talk, you've touched on this earlier.

25:34A lot of what's called waffle, but on full speech is allowed here in the United States, right? Animal abuse, footage, joxing, videos of sexual violence, et cetera. So allowing this type of content obviously could cause harm and make Twitter unusable for the broad audience that you're trying to reach.

25:55What is your approach to this type of content that's legal but problematic as it relates to people actually using the service? How do you think about this tension? As I said earlier, I think people, we should allow people to say what they want, first what They want to put in the balance of the law.

26:14But that's different from them being able to reach people who don't want to be reached with that content. So if that content is offensive, then to its people, that will not most simply stop using Twitter. So it's important to make Twitter as attractive as possible. And really, that means not showing people content that they would find pay for a offensive or a simple,

26:45even frankly, content they would find boring is not good. So we don't even want them to see boring content. Unless we were talking about TikTok last night, and TikTok obviously does a great job of making sure you're on board. I mean, it does feel like ADD, but next level. But, but TikTok does a great job of making a board.

27:14I mean, I do find some of the videos offensive, I think. But they're not boring. So, the folks read, like, how do we ensure people have content that is that they find entertaining and engaging and interesting such that they want to keep using Twitter and use it more. So, that's, you know, that's essential.

27:40to the book of the service. And one of our employees asked about people who use Twitter having the right and the ability to filter out content that they don't want to see. I think this gets to exactly what you're pointing to. Yeah, I mean, too clear. It's like the standard is much more than not offending people.

27:59The standard is should be that they're very entertained and informed. Because you could not offend someone, but you also borrow them and show them a bunch of content that they don't find interesting, and then they will not use the service or they will use a glass. So that's why I use the example of TikTok, where they just hone an algorithm to be as engaging as possible.

28:22And I think we want to also hold as engaging as possible in a different way. I think that TikTok is interesting. But you want to be informed about serious issues as well. And I think Twitter, in terms of like serious issues, can be a lot better performing a lot of serious issues.

28:44I do think it's important that there be, if there are two sides to an issue, it's important to represent if there are multiple opinions, but just make sure that we're not sort of driving narrative. that we give people an opportunity to understand the various science initiatives.

29:06Most issues are complex. They're not well down to a simple, this is a hard set good and this is a hard set bad. So I think it would be, it would have a more important public if people will present it with multiple sites for an issue. One point I just wanna go back to you on sort of the law and how that impacts content and moderation.

29:32as we think globally around the world, there are some countries that have lost that limit speech and sometimes actually use these laws to silence disagree with the government etc you're talking about different points of view. So Twitter is historically focused on doing what we can do to enable

29:49people everywhere to have their voices. How do you think about that as it relates to again like the local laws and what that means? Well I mean I'm in favor of doing, you know, of going as far as the law will allow us. If the law, you know, if say a quarter of employees would get arrested in the country if we adhere to the law, then we

30:10would obviously adhere to the law or exit the country or something. So, I mean, as much as we can enable people to have a voice and speak their mind, I think we want to do that. Yeah. And I know we talked about this as well last night about the teams doing this work and sort of your desire to connect with those teams and sort of understand where we've been, where we are, where we're going.

30:40And I think that would be usually productive across the board both ways. Can we talk briefly about your political views? How if at all do your political views play into the leadership of the companies that you currently run, how would it affect Twitter, is that all? Well, my political views, I think, are moderate, at least as would be,

31:07as if you said, what is the center of the normal distribution of political views in the country? I think I'd be pretty close to the center. I voted to jump back every election until this recent one this week. And then I voted for Merritt Flores, who was Republican, which is Mexican American, and I thought a good candidate, and was voting for.

31:37So, but I'm in favor of moderate politics. People who have relatively extreme views to express those views within the balance below. So that's, you know, as I said, probably like, I think if we, let's say that all that 10% and all right, 10% will equally upset on Twitter, then that will probably be a good outcome.

32:12I want to just talk about our business for a minute. You've spoken about incentives that the AI business creates for services like Twitter. What role does advertising play in the future of your business plan? The advertising is very important for Twitter. So in the case of, say, Tesla's SpaceX, there's no need for advertising because of the demand exceeds our production.

32:38So I mean, advertising is fundamentally a demand generator. And occasionally, you want to get some other message out, but it's fundamentally a demand generator. So given that Tesla demand is far in excess of production, there's no need for Tesla to advertise. But, you know, I'm not against advertising.

33:01I would probably, I don't know, want to talk to the advertisers and say, like, hey, let's make sure the ads are as entertaining as possible. I think they're more effective if they're entertaining. Like, you want to be strident or spammy in the ad. And then of course, I don't think it's good to allow advertising of any products, which

33:26are bad products. I was literally scammed on it. I bought this thing off of a YouTube ad and it doesn't work. And then I just Googled it. And it's like, oh, yeah. Once you click on the second page, you Google search results. like, yeah, this product totally just worked in the trash.

33:50And I'm like, well, what the hell is YouTube allowing advertising of scamming products that's totally not cool? So, you know, I think if the advertising is entertaining, interesting, it's something you might actually want. And the product would be fulfilling to Twitter user. then I think that's great advertising.

34:18So yeah. So, you know, we're going to go over that, OK? Oh, yes. Awesome. Thank you. Can you talk a little bit about Twitter and payments? You mentioned a few times in different settings. What's an understanding of thinking there? Yeah, I think the money is essentially a form of information.

34:39So it's information that allows us to exchange products and services without any to barter and allows people to ship obligations in time. But money is fundamentally digital at this point and it has been for a while. And PayPal, I think, has done a great job on the payments front.

35:07I think it's going to make sense to get a great payment into Twitter. So that's easy to send money back and forth. You know, and the current state as well as crypto, you know, essentially what I would find useful. So, the next thing, my goal would be to maximize the usefulness of the service.

35:35The more useful it is, the better. And if one can use it to make convenient payments, that's an increase in usefulness. It's sort of news entertainment and payments I think are like three critical areas. It's just about sort of thinking about how to make this, how to make using Twitter so compelling

36:05that you can't look at it and that everyone wants to use it. I wanted to stand the product. I know you, again, you did that to Bondis earlier, but it's a recurring question around authentication piece in terms of yours and you want to authenticate all humans. So just to sort of double click into that, you know, balancing this with those who benefit from anonymity, right from safety perspective, especially for example, you can write back to this and marginalized communities.

36:34So it's sort of, can you just clarify again, speak to that sort of that tension and how you think about those groups specifically? I mean, the committee is sort of core to how? I don't think it's necessary for someone to use their real name. So if one say does a payment space authentication,

36:58I think it should be okay to not use your real name much whether it's, so Twitter would know who you are, at least from a payment standpoint, but you would not have to stay your real name or anything. That's obviously important, where if someone has different political views from their manager, let's say, then they don't really wanna get crosswise there,

37:23and so that it would be better for them to have a student on Twitter. But it's still back-ended authenticated. And like I said, at no point would, I suggest that you have to be authenticated in order to use Twitter. It's just that it would just be a prioritizing authenticated comments and actions on Twitter

37:47over unauthenticated. in order to combat the sort of bots and trolls. And it needs to be much more expensive to have a troll army. Whereas right now it's basically very inexpensive to have 100,000 big clear accounts. And you have certainly been very vocal on Twitter. You are very vocal on Twitter and often your tweets and even emojis create new cycles.

38:18You know, you have been also critical of the company on Twitter, which obviously impacts lots of discussions, conversations, and perceptions from whether it be partners or even our employees. How do you think about these tweets? Do you look at the reaction or think about the reaction of these tweets?

38:35I'm just curious, sort of thinking behind the tweet, if you will. Well, I think it would be helpful. But one thing about words is that it's hard to convey tone. And so it's possible for essentially people will take the words and then assume they were said in maybe an angry way or an indigent way or something like that.

39:02But I mean, I'll think until my normal tone is not. I'm not an angry person. I almost never raise my voice. So like in a year, I might not have raised my voice literally. So this is not, you know, so sometimes people may think, oh, wow, he's sort of yelling at screen yourself, but I'm really not.

39:24So if I might, because maybe some way to indicate how an immunomology sort of do that, but I don't know, maybe it could be like a, where you have like a, I don't know, iron-eat flag or something. This is ironic. You know, it's ironic to eat something like that. Listen, I think spaces are the great products for you as well.

39:54Yeah, I can do it. You'll also have voice tweets, which I don't think I've seen you use before, but I think that would add your literal voice over and color some things that you'd wait for. enough. Oh sure. I should, I should, I should, yeah maybe I could just say it. Yeah exactly, exactly.

40:13Or you could read it but then you can also see how I would have said it. Like, you know, you know, like I wonder if you said that in an everywhere and then you can see how I actually said it. Yes, absolutely, absolutely. That'd be a new thing. On your, I know we have, I'm going I'm gonna only push you about 10 more minutes at the hour, so I'm holding you until then.

40:36Your role at the company, there's an discussion about will you be CEO, will you not be CEO? What can you speak to this? And how do you anticipate your role sort of influencing strategy day to day, division? Well, I guess I'm not that hung up on titles, But I do want to try out the product in a particular direction.

41:03So it could be like, I don't really care what about being CEO. In fact, I renamed myself TechnoKing at Tesla with an official SEC filing. So we saw. Yeah. And then our CFO was renamed Master of Coin, which I think is a cooler thing than CFO. So, I mean, the, one of the least one to do is, is like try the product, improve the product and then select basically software and product design, you know.

41:43So, you know, I don't mind doing other things, you know, related to operating a company, but there are, you know, chores, there's a lot of chores to it's CEO. And I really just want to make sure that the product evolves rapidly and in a good way. And I don't really care what the title is.

42:11But obviously people do need to listen to me. If I say, hey, we need to make part, agree with the product in the following way, make the following changes. Add these features, then I can't you expect that that pool isn't doing in this regard. I mean, that's how I do it, SpaceX and Tesla.

42:32So I'm really just working really engineering and production. And like it sometimes may seem like, wow, he's going really out there a lot. But actually, I'm not. If you see how many actual interviews do I do, it's quite a small number. But when I do a tweet, they'll make an entire two-page article about it.

42:59So basically, I'm quite internally focused at SpaceX and Tesla, even though it may not seem that way. And it's really just involving the rocket technology with SpaceX and providing global internet with Starling and then Tesla, it's about accelerating sustainable energy and with electric cars and stationary battery packs and solar power.

43:26And the fundamental good of Tesla, I would say, is measured by how many years did we accelerate the atmosphere of sustainable energy. And then the fundamental good of SpaceX is, are we able to make like multi-planetary and us improve the probable lifespan of consciousness. You can always say what is a unifying philosophy?

43:53For me, it is we should take a set of actions most likely to extend the scope scale and lifespan of consciousness as we know it. So that's what interactions improve things at a civilizational level and improve the probable lifespan of civilization. The civilization will come to an end at some point, but let's try to make it last as long

44:19as possible. And it would be great to understand more about the nature of the universe, why we're here, the meaning of life, where everything's going, where we come from. Can we travel to other star systems and see if there are alien civilizations? there might be a whole bunch of long-edge, one planet,

44:41civilizations out there. That existed 500 million years ago. If you think about the span of human civilization from the advent of the first variety, it's only about 5,000 years, which is nothing. And at both this roughly 0.5 billion years old. So all of civilization as measured from the advent

45:03writing is a flash in the pan. And I think we want to take whatever actions we can to extend that flash in the pan to hopefully be a flame that lasts a long time. I can't believe I have the transition from aliens away from this conversation back to Twitter. What do you do? I'm not saying it's aliens, but yes, aliens.

45:26What does Twitter look like to you? I think I just don't have trolling people about the aliens. So people really think, I've seen no evidence. I've seen no actual evidence for aliens. I get asked that a lot and I think I've not seen anything. Yes. Okay, you've heard it here everybody.

45:51Question about Twitter, when you look five to 10 years from now, what do you consider successful for yourself in acquiring the company and for all of us in the work that we do? What does successful look like? Yeah, so I think success would be a substantial increase in daily active users.

46:18I don't know, except if Ken would get daily activities was over a billion, that would be, you know, it's still only one eighth of both. But that would be a huge improvement from what things are today. And I guess, broadly speaking, like, is Twitter helping for the civilization and consciousness.

46:51It's Twitter. I'm not seeing that. It has actually a lot of complete sessions, anyway. But is Twitter contributing to a stronger, longer lasting civilization where we're better able to understand the nature of reality. I would say my philosophy is one of curiosity of trying to understand the nature of the universe as much as possible

47:21to understand. So in order to understand the nature of us, we must expand the scope and scale of consciousness, to extend the life of consciousness. So I guess, formally speaking, has Twitter meaningfully improved the strength and longevity of civilization. I know that we have gone meaningfully over.

47:47So first of all, thank you so much for the time. Thank you for coming back for a part two. Thank you for continuing the conversation with all of us. You're welcome. That's a pleasure. Thank you so much. We'll talk very soon. Thanks, bye. Thank you, Lauren. Bye, everybody.

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份