马斯克的原话是:设计投入的精力,相对制造系统,可以四舍五入到零。
他举了个例子。假如有人跑来说,我要一千台 Raptor 发动机,你能做出来吗?答案是不能。造不出来,跟画不画得出图纸毫无关系。这个区别听起来很细,但它决定了整个星舰计划的成败。
这期 Everyday Astronaut 的 Starbase 工厂参观,马斯克带着 Tim Dodd 走了两个多小时,素材分成三段发布。上半部分全在厂房里,聊的是制造哲学、助推器结构、栅格翼、级间分离,还有那套被他反复念叨的五步算法。信息密度极高,几乎每一段都能单独拎出来写一篇文章。
下面把这些内容拆开讲清楚。
设计占零,制造占全部
提问的人先抛出一个观察:公众总是盯着火箭长什么样、发动机多先进,没人关心它怎么被造出来。马斯克接得很快:制造被低估了,设计被高估了。
他给了一个量级对比。设计 Raptor 发动机,和设计 Raptor 的制造系统,投入的精力比例大概是十比一到一百比一。换句话说,把发动机画在图纸上这件事,在整个工程里的权重几乎可以忽略。
这个判断不含谦虚成分。星舰的生产线上,真正卡住进度的是焊接、吊装、测试、运输,是那些看起来毫无戏剧性的环节。马斯克说,他们造助推器和飞船的速度,比造发射场快得多。发射系统的塔架、用来夹住火箭的筷子机械臂,复杂度不亚于任何一级火箭,甚至更高。
他补了一句更狠的话:所有设计都是错的,只是错多错少的问题。这句是整个方法论的底层假设。设计天然不完美,那就不该在设计上无限打磨,资源要挪到制造和迭代上去。
他还讲了一个常见误解。很多人以为生产像复印机,设计定了,复制就完了。真实情况是,把第一个样品做出来只走完了很小一段路,把第一千个做出来又是另一场完全不同的仗。前者靠灵感,后者靠产能爬坡、良率、节拍、供应链,全是脏活。
Raptor 难在每吨推力多少钱,不在燃烧循环
有人会问,全流量分级燃烧(full flow staged combustion)难道不难吗?马斯克的回答很直白:难,但没到那个程度。
苏联人搞了几十年分级燃烧,做过几百种设计。Raptor 确实是更高压力、全流量,可相对苏联已经完成的那些工作,这只能算相对小的增量。设计一台能工作的分级燃烧发动机,这个问题早就被解决了。
真正难的地方在别处:怎么把每吨推力的成本压到一千美元以下。
这个指标很少被人拿出来讨论。通常聊发动机,说的是比冲、推重比、室压。马斯克把话题拽到成本上,因为在他看来,人类能不能成为多行星物种,取决于每吨载荷进入轨道的成本。所有技术选择都得服从这个总目标,最终版本的目标是每吨载荷送到火星表面的成本。
所以 Raptor 的迭代方向指向更便宜,强度上的提升排在后面。这也解释了后面 Version 2 为什么愿意牺牲一点比冲去换推力。
五步算法:先让需求变蠢,再把零件删掉
这段是整场访谈里最系统的一段。马斯克说他一直在试图把一套五步流程严格推行下去。
第一步,让需求变得不那么蠢。
他的原话是 make your requirements less dumb。这里有个关键细节:需求蠢不蠢,跟你从谁那里拿到它无关。给你需求的人如果很聪明,情形反而更危险,因为你不太会去质疑他,你会把它当福音接受。而无论你是谁,你总会有错的时候。
还有一条硬规定:任何需求或约束,必须挂一个人的名字,不能挂部门的名字。部门没法被追问,人可以。马斯克说这情形发生过好几次,某个需求在几年前被一个实习生随口提了一句,人早离职了,需求还挂在气动载荷部门名下,而那个部门现在根本没人认同它。
他甚至开了个玩笑,说也许有人 Kerbal 玩多了,非要在火箭顶上装一对翼,然后这事就这么一直传下来了。真实世界里的需求,往往比你以为的更随意。
第二步,尽最大努力删掉零件或流程。
他给了一个判断标准:如果你不是每隔一阵就往回加东西,说明你删得不够狠。工程师的默认倾向是“以防万一,先加上”,可这个理由能套在无数东西上。对一枚追求完全可复用的火箭,边距必须卡得很紧,稍微松一点,就什么都送不上轨道。
栅格翼不折叠,就是这个原则的产物。折叠机构算一整套额外的机械结构,而他们的仿真显示,只要发动机有足够的控制权限,在低层大气里就能把姿态掰回来,栅格翼本身对气流干扰很小,攻角差个一两度也无所谓。于是折叠这件事被直接删掉。马斯克说功劳不在他,是团队里有人提的,他听完只说了一句:好主意,为什么要折叠?
第三步,简化或优化。
注意顺序,简化排在第三,不在第一。原因是他见过太多聪明工程师犯同一个错误:去优化一个本来就不该存在的东西。
他解释了这个思维定式的来源。从高中到大学,所有人受的训练都是收敛式逻辑:题目给了,你必须解出来,跑去告诉教授这题出得不对,只会得零分。于是每个人脑子里都套着一个看不见的枷锁,习惯了去优化那个不该存在的问题。
他举了猎鹰一号早期的例子。当年他和 Tom Mueller 在厨房里用表格搭火箭,最初方案是 NTO/MMH 上面级,也就是四氧化二氮加甲基肼,自燃推进剂,点火可靠、可以深度节流,TRW 的登月舱下降发动机走的就是这条路,针栓式喷注器也来自这个谱系。
麻烦在于这两种东西贵得离谱,而且剧毒,处理成本高得吓人。马斯克的说法是:就算爱迪生和特斯拉生了个孩子,这孩子比他俩加起来还聪明,你让他去优化一台 NTO/MMH 上面级,他也救不了你。方向本身错了,优化救不回来。
他还顺带吐槽了安全标准的矫枉过正。早年 NASA 的人会把一杯肼传着闻,让新人记住那个味道,现在则被当成氰化物对待。两种做法都过头。他的原话是:它不是氰化物,你不会死。
龙飞船确实还留着这套推进剂,理由充分。它需要对 Draco 发动机做大量短脉冲的精细点火,非自燃推进剂很难做到。可一旦排除自燃和低温两类,剩下的选项就变得很差:要么往过氧化氢那条路上走,要么用极冷门的单组元推进剂,两者都又贵又麻烦。
第四步,加快循环周期。
限定条件很明确:前三步没做完,别急着提速。原话是,别把你的坟墓挖得更快。
第五步,自动化。
这一步排最后。马斯克说自己犯过很多次错,把顺序整个倒过来做,Model 3 时期尤其严重。他承认自动化、加速、简化、删除这几件事他全做反过,所以现在才要把这套流程反复讲。
特斯拉电池包:两百万美元的机器人,在贴一块没人说得清用途的垫子
Model 3 电池包和底盘之间夹着一层玻璃纤维垫。这层垫子卡住了整条产线的节拍,马斯克当时几乎住在电池包产线上,天天琢磨怎么把它解决掉。
他犯的错按顺序来。先是想办法让机器人跑得更快,缩短路径、加大扭矩、删掉螺栓反转 720 度这类多余动作,改成单向快速拧紧;接着优化点胶方式,原本整面涂胶,后来改成点几滴,因为垫子本来就只是被夹在电池包和底盘之间,只需要固定到螺栓拧紧为止;再往后才是加速。
最后他才问了一句:这垫子到底干嘛用的?
他去问电池安全团队,对方说不清楚,可能是防火的。他去问 NVH(噪声、振动与声振粗糙度)团队,对方说可能是防火的。两边互相以为对方负责,实际上谁也没负责。他形容那种感觉像被困在卡夫卡或者吉尔伯特漫画里。
验证方法很朴素:装垫子和不装垫子各跑一台车,塞个麦克风进去,看人耳能不能分辨。分辨不出来。垫子删掉,那台价值两百万美元的机器人单元整个被绕过。
他在这里补了另一个制造上的常见错误:制程中放了太多测试。
产线刚建的时候,你不知道问题出在哪个环节,所以要在中间设检查点做隔离,通过排除法定位故障。等产线跑顺了、末端良率很高了,那些中间测试就该撤。实际情况是,负责调试产线的工程团队忘了撤,测试工位反而成了节拍瓶颈,还会产生误判,把好零件判成坏的,直接报废。
他的建议是:量产阶段,几乎所有测试都该挪到末端,只在极少数末端测不了的环节保留中间测试。判断依据也很简单,如果东西都能顺利走到末端并且通过,中间那些关卡就是纯负担。
还有一个更荒诞的例子。电池包需要防水,正确的做法是在包内抽真空,看外界空气会不会渗进来。他们当时的做法是往电池包里打压,方向正好反了。电池包上盖用树脂粘合,树脂还没固化,一打压就把树脂挤了出来。这个测试失败率很高,高到大家都以为是工艺问题,其实是测试本身设计反了。
顺带说个侧面证据。马斯克提到网上那些特斯拉涉水视频,有人在哈萨克斯坦开着 Model S 穿过被水淹没的隧道,其他车全趴了,他把车当船开,靠车轮旋转推进,一路开了出去。电池包密封性确实重要,也正因如此,测法错了才格外要命。
助推器的体重账本
走到助推器旁边,马斯克开始报数。
29 台发动机,每台连安装结构大约两吨,合起来 58 吨。液氧箱和燃料箱目前偏重,大概 80 吨。级间段装着栅格翼、电池和一堆杂项,大约 20 吨。推进剂残余,大约 20 吨。加起来 160 到 200 吨之间,具体看最终的减重结果。
他强调推进剂残余是个大事。这个数字压不到零,着陆时必须留余量,归零就会砸出坑。猎鹰九号到现在着陆时还带着大约一吨没烧完的燃料,而为了从发动机上抠掉一吨重量,他们花了巨大精力,一台发动机也就减一百多公斤。两件事的性价比完全不在一个量级。
助推器设计装 3600 吨推进剂,液氧按质量占大约 78%,甲烷 22%,混合比 3.5 到 3.7 之间。为什么偏向氧?氧密度更大、更便宜,成本本质上只是分离和蒸馏的电费,而甲烷的原料来自植物和浮游生物,几乎等于免费。提升运力、压低每吨成本这两件事,都指向同一个方向。
有人问,轻分子按理说喷得更快,为什么不把燃料比例调高?马斯克的回答是:你会先撞上化学当量比的熔点问题。太接近当量比,燃烧温度高到能把发动机融化,所以在比冲掉下来之前,材料先撑不住。真正限制混合比的因素在材料,不在理论比冲。
栅格翼单只大概三吨,用眼睛估的,他自己也说这数字别当真。目前的设计目标是够用就行,只需要提供足够的控制权限,把助推器穿过大气层送到一个位置,剩下的误差交给发动机点火后修正。他还提到,栅格翼的驱动电机直接用 Model 3 的电机,现成、可靠、便宜,何必另起炉灶。
翼面上的锯齿有明确的用途:跨音速段效果好,尖头形状在那一区间控制效率更高。当然尖也有极限,太尖反而不好。
电池这块有个反直觉的细节。栅格翼的电池当时是按能量优化设计的,可栅格翼只需要工作两三分钟,跟电动车要跑几个小时完全不是一回事。这里需要的是功率优化电池。换过来之后,电池质量大概能降一个数量级。他把它当成“还有很多减重空间”的一个现成例子。
栅格翼的力怎么传出去?顶部燃料穹顶周围有一圈通道结构,电机带减速箱转动翼面,载荷在圆形接口和穹顶上的通道之间互相抵消。听上去复杂,落到结构上就是穹顶上多了一圈环。
级间分离:删掉分离机构,靠惯量差甩开
这段技术含量很高。
传统火箭的级间分离要靠爆炸螺栓、气动推杆或者分离弹簧。星舰的做法是把这件事整个删掉。
原理是这样的:主发动机关机之前,先让整个堆叠体开始旋转,俯仰和偏航同时给。一级和二级连在一起转,可两者的转动惯量不同。主发动机关机之后,约束消失,惯量差异让它们以不同速率运动,于是自动分开。马斯克把这形容成把一捆干草往外一甩。
猎鹰九号放星链卫星用的是同一套思路。60 颗卫星捆在一起,释放固定杆,整捆像干草垛一样被甩出去,卫星之间偶尔以每小时一英里的速度碰一下,可它们已经扛过了发射段的恶劣环境,这点碰撞无关紧要。之后各自上电、找到位置、开始工作。
星舰的分离更精细。主发动机先给堆叠体一个旋转,然后关机,两级靠惯量差自行分开。分开之后,飞船用冷气推进器做小幅姿态调整,助推器则用另一套东西。
马斯克说这是相当复杂的太空芭蕾,每一步的时间点都要对得极准。
把废气当推力器用
助推器降落时,主贮箱里有大量没烧完的热氧气和热甲烷。这些气体本来就要排掉,带着它们飞是纯死重。
马斯克的想法是:既然要排,为什么不控制排放方向,让它产生推力?
于是他删掉了整套独立的热气推进器系统,也删掉了冷气推进器系统。助推器用贮箱排出的热气做姿态控制,通过控制排放口朝向,让气体往有用的方向喷。配合前面说的“关机前先把整个堆叠体甩转”,助推器已经有足够的控制权限,不需要额外的推进器。管这叫 RCS 还是 ACS,取决于问谁,反正都是小型姿控推力器。
有人问,贮箱压力只有六巴左右,这么低的压力做推进器,比冲不是很差吗?
马斯克的回答是:在真空里,六巴其实不算差。龙飞船的 Draco 推进器室压也就八到九巴,大约 120 psi 到 130 psi,跟贮箱压力差不了太多。所以根本不需要把气体存进 200 巴的高压瓶再拿来做 RCS。热气温度越高,比冲越好,只要不把壳体烧软就行。热气本来就在那儿,压力容器本来也在那儿,反正最后都要扔掉,用它做事等于白赚。
他顺带承认,这个逻辑对飞船同样成立。飞船刚起飞时全是低温推进剂,没法这么干;等到它大部分推进剂用完、进入轨道之后,处境和助推器一样,都是满满一罐热气。所以未来的机动,绝大部分应该用飞船自己的热气来做。他说这话的语气像是刚意识到这件事,紧接着来了一句:这个我们得改。
月球着陆:先搞清楚会不会给自己挖个坑
话题转到 HLS(Human Landing System,载人着陆系统)。公开渲染图里,着陆推进器装在舱体上方一圈,大概二十几个。
马斯克说这个设计还可能变,正在跟 NASA 商量。核心问题是:能不能直接用主发动机登月?
如果直接用主发动机,尾焰会在月壤上吹出一个大坑,然后飞船落进自己挖的坑里,翻了。他的原话是,挖自己的坟墓,然后掉进去。
现在的方案把着陆推进器装在高处,压力低、位置高,对月壤的冲击小,基本不会挖坑,属于稳妥路线。可他认为更好的做法是去验证主发动机到底会不会挖出大坑:找一种力学性质接近真实月壤的模拟材料,真的把一艘飞船落上去,量一量坑有多大。如果能证明坑不大,那一圈推进器就可以删掉。
这又是五步算法的现场演示。先质疑需求(真的需要独立着陆推进器吗),再想办法删掉这个零件。
还有个细节:真空版猛禽不能摆动,所以如果月球版只装真空版,姿态控制就只能靠三台发动机的差动节流。月球没有大气扰动,这么做理论上可行,可一旦其中一台出问题就没有备份。所以更可能保留一台海平面版猛禽在中间,提供摆动权限。具体怎么配,取决于优化目标,毕竟这玩意儿大概率只造一艘。
Raptor 2:少三秒比冲,多三十吨推力
关于 Raptor 2 的进度,马斯克给的时间点是:推力室组件已经造好,泵的设计基本完成,接下来造泵,大概一个月后能测第一台。
产能布局上,加州霍桑工厂继续负责研发型号和真空版猛禽,麦格雷戈负责批量生产。
关键数字:Raptor 2 海平面推力 230 吨,室压大约 300 巴。他补了一句,技术上说是 298 巴,不过他觉得应该再挤出两个巴来。
这里有个取舍值得说清楚。Raptor 2 主动把喉部开大、降低面积比,用这个换推力。代价是比冲掉两三秒,收益是推力涨一大截。对第一级来说这笔账划算,因为在稠密大气里,推重比的权重远高于比冲。
他还给了一个判断:推重比低于一的推力毫无价值。从 0.4 涨到 0.5,意义远大于一个漂亮的比冲数字。真空版猛禽当时推力还是 200 吨左右,真空优化带来的面积比优势留在那里。
马斯克顺手吐槽了单位制。他坚持用吨来表示推力和质量,因为这样可以心算推重比。用牛顿的话,火箭推力是天文数字,你得先除以十,再除以一万,才能换算成吨,脑子根本转不过来。他的原话是:只有傻瓜才会在设计火箭的时候用牛顿。
压力用巴,不用帕斯卡。所有人都知道一个大气压大概是多少,而帕斯卡小得离谱,被帕斯卡砸中大概跟被老鼠撞一下差不多。这些单位让理解变难,让计算变慢。他还开玩笑说,应该专门做一期节目,盘点他讨厌的单位,共同特征就是把简单的事搞复杂。注意,吨是公制吨,别误会成英制单位。
让每个人都是总工程师
访谈里有一条管理原则,比技术细节更值得记。
马斯克说,他希望公司里每个人都是总工程师。意思是每个人都要在高层次上理解整个系统,这样才能判断自己手上的优化是不是一个坏优化。
他举了个真实案例。团队曾经花巨大精力去减发动机重量,却几乎没花精力去减推进剂残余。结果着陆时剩下一整吨没烧完的燃料。一吨残余对上一百多公斤的发动机减重,前面那笔投入显得很滑稽。这种情形现在还在发生,猎鹰九号着陆时依然带着一吨燃料。
只有当每个人都理解全局,才能发现“我在优化的这个东西,在整个系统里根本不重要”。这是五步算法能真正推下去的前提。
他还提到星舰前几次爆炸。事后复盘,没有任何一次爆炸的原因出现在风险清单上。真正出问题的地方,全是没人预料到的未知的未知。这解释了星舰为什么坚持快速迭代:在一堆同时演进的新技术面前,纸面分析找不出答案,只能靠飞。新技术太多,全部在同步演化,风险清单能列出的只是已知的那部分。
接下来该做什么
这篇访谈信息量很大,如果只带走几件事,建议这几条:
- 下次做产品或者做项目,先问一句“这个需求是谁提的”。找不到具体的人,只说得出“部门规定”或者“一直这么干”,它大概率可以被质疑。
- 审视手上的工作,判断你在优化一个本来就该存在的东西,还是在优化一个本该被删掉的东西。后者是聪明人最常犯的错。
- 把“删掉”当成需要刻意练习的动作。你很久没有往回加东西,说明删得不够狠;你从来没删过东西,说明根本没在删。
- 流程顺序别搞反:先质疑需求,再删零件,再简化,再提速,最后才自动化。自动化一个错误的流程,只会让错误发生得更快。
- 产线跑顺之后,回头清理中间测试工位。它们往往已经变成节拍瓶颈和误判来源。
- 用能心算的单位。推力和质量都用吨,压力用巴。单位的选择直接影响思考的速度。
- 让团队里每个人都理解系统的全貌,不然他们会用一百二十分的努力,去优化一个只值五分的环节。
- 遇到“以防万一”式的设计,逼自己说清楚万一具体是什么、概率多大、代价多少。说不清楚就删。
0:00hi it's me tim dodd the everyday astronaut welcome to starbase texas this is where spacex is building testing and even launching their mars-bound rocket starship today i'm going to take you inside the gates and show you things that have never been shared outside of spacex best of all we have the ultimate tour guide elon musk who answers all of my questions and gives us unbelievable insights to the rocket's development we talked and walked around for over two hours so i'll be cutting this up into three parts the first two are at the starbase factory and the last one is at the launch pad each section has a gold mine of valuable information so make sure you're subscribed you've
0:39got your notifications on and you've got your notepads ready to shot some notes now heads up we talk about some pretty advanced concepts and subject matter that can be pretty intimidating on first listen but don't worry i've got you covered with lots of informational videos here on my channel so perhaps if you're new to starship or really all of this stuff consider watching my complete guide to starship that'll be a really good overview for you for some of the things that we talk about here in this conversation and i'll also be linking to some of my other videos that will help out with some of the stuff that we talk about as well now you might
1:12notice we mentioned soviet rocket engines quite a bit in this conversation maybe it's because i was wearing my new soyuz shirt that you can get at everydayastronaut.com shop or perhaps it's because i've been working on a complete history and family tree of soviet rocket engines for almost two years now and that video is currently in the works and it will be out when it's done and one last thing this video is broken up into sections and we have links in the description for those sections we also will occasionally be putting up a little map courtesy of ring watchers on twitter that will help you keep your bearings as we're walking around i think that'll
1:49help quite a bit and we also have an article version of kind of our conversation some of the key points that we bring up over at everydayastronaut.com there is a link in the description to that as well okay enough talking let's go hang out with elon so the camera followed with a camera and then somebody else with the camera just camera envy at this point he's just trying to he saw me with this and he's like i'll get my camera out yeah yeah you take a video of me you can take a video of this of you guys taking a video over make sure this is going through there just shoot the screen the whole time i don't want anything else all right so this this is okay so this
2:24is i'm being videoed here and then the video of the video this is the video on the video of the video go back there
2:44so i feel like i got here maybe about the most exciting peak of insanity definitely a very exciting time because we are in a kind of a final push to complete the the launch launch system stage zero essentially and it's worth saying that the launch system the tower and the you know the chopstick arms to catch the rocket are as complex as either of the stages
3:14really yeah absolutely if not more so like we we could produce boosters and ships way easier than we could make the launch site so so therefore i'd say it is harder certainly than any single booster or ship yeah well that's i think that's one of those things people don't even realize is the manufacturing out here that's kind of one of those things that you harp on so much is how you know how that's so important and that's in the long scheme the hardest part of all this is just yeah manufacturing generally manufacturing is underrated and design is overrated so people generally think that like this like this eureka moment of like you come up with this idea and
4:02and and that's it now it's good but the design like this literally a thousand percent maybe ten thousand percent more work that goes into the production system than the then the the thing itself so if you say like how much effort have we put into say designing raptor versus designing the manufacturing system it's ten to a hundred times more effort to design the manufacturing system than the engine even of raptor oh yeah absolutely especially with raptor so all of our basically call it basically the amount of effort that goes into the design rounds down to zero right right relative to the amount of effort that goes into the manufacturing system
4:49and if if this was not true great i'd like a thousand raptors please oh you can't make him oh okay right right so this is like just very fundamentally underappreciated if people have not been in manufacturing especially manufacturing of something that's relatively new then they don't understand and they they think the design is the hard part and not and they think production is like a copier or something like that right so it's completely false it's definitely not as sexy as the end thing like you know the end product is very sexy and you know that's what draws people's attention but the whole back end of it is yeah what makes it possible i can't emphasize enough i'm trying to
5:30correct the misperception that design is the hard part it is not the hard part there have been lots of great rocket engine's design do you spend a lot of time looking at the russian rocket engine designs there's some amazing russian rocket engine science they've been doing stage combustion for a long time yeah and they have done i don't know hundreds of different designs literally so but so so the the hard part is not can you design a staged combustion rocket engine this has been done yeah now admittedly ours is a higher pressure than before and it is a full flow stage combustion but these are that's a relatively minor increments relative to what the
6:08russians have already done right what is super hard about raptor is how do we make a raptor where the cost per ton of thrust is under a thousand dollars yeah i mean we definitely don't want to cut our the fundamental thing that needs to be fixed is the cost per ton to orbit yeah so things that that address the cost per ton to orbit are good like humanity will be a multi-planet species if we get cost per ton to orbit to the point where we can afford to become a space wearing civilization and a multi-planet species right so this is at at its heart it is a fundamentally an optimization of cost per time to orbit and then ultimately cost per ton to the surface of mars
6:56right well if you're working on getting the cost even when you're starting to think of it as dollars dollar per ton of thrust i mean i don't know if anyone's ever considered that as a key metric yeah you know that's a new new thing that i i've never thought about you know never considered well and then even raptor is kind of unique because now you're starting to also think about the instead of thrust to weight ratio when you have a fixed diameter and a fixed circle area you're also worried about the nozzle exit to thrust ratio as being a pretty strong consideration too yeah you basically end up end up filling up all the area under the rocket so
7:35with this version we have 29 engines there's a lot of beeping i'm not sure having this many things beat is actually helpful sensory overload yeah it's like it's like everything around you is crying wolf if everything's in danger and you're thinking he's gonna tune it out yeah exactly so it's pretty silly but
8:06wow so yeah what are the the little so obviously those are where the grid fins go right yeah and then what's the thing in between them that's that's basically that's actually the mount point so that's there are two it's debatable whether this is a the right design or not in fact just like all the designs are wrong just a matter of how wrong but that's one of the load points for picking up the booster so you see yeah that yeah it says like tiny little it looks small yeah it looks like a but it's actually not that small like close up this thing's just high in the air like all your sense of perspective is wrong yeah and when this when this lands it
8:49has like basically the density of an of a beer can right you know an antibiotic right what is this with like some mass you know in the engines obviously well the dry mass are you under 200 tons we should be on our charter tons the mass is a moving target so you want to say like what are your propellant residuals when you land all right that's a big deal like both how much marginal will you have and what's your own use for the unusable propellant like you can't just go to zero margin you know right because the kick's gonna crater yeah so
9:34it should be under 200 tons though so but as a rough rule of thumb like the engines including mounting mass are roughly two tons so if you've got 29 inches of 58 tons then the the sort of the fuel tank itself and the oxygen tank it's probably on on the order of well it's a little heavy right now so maybe it's like 80 tons or so then you know you've got the inner stage with the where you've got the grid fins batteries and a bunch of other things yep so that's right maybe around 20 tons and then you've got propellant residuals which
10:25might be on the order of 20 tons too okay so all that should come to i don't know it caught 160 to 200 tons depending on the sort of final mass numbers but like right now everything's hit too heavy like avionics too heavy the the avionics even yeah i thought it's just a little i mean it should be but the the grid pins are electrically powered so cool we have batteries that are
10:53energy optimized instead of power optimized so like this grid vents only needs to work for like two or three minutes right right so it's it's very different from like a like the electric car which you want to have several hours of driving so these really we need power optimized batteries not energy optimized batteries this is just a short-term thing right so the battery mass can probably drop by maybe a factor of 10.
11:21right so that's just one example yeah let's playing yeah and then we're trying to get the cranes in here and do work you got a lot of people on set right now yeah i mean this like but that residuals number is a super big deal on the mass though because the booster is designed to have 3 600 tons of propellant which is in almost 80 oxygen liquid oxygen by mass yeah like 78 did you burn it what is it three point five three point five three point seven okay so and you want to bias it in favor of oxygen because oxygen is denser and cheaper right so in terms of improving your payload and you know reducing cost per ton oxygen is is basically plants make it for free
12:17and plankton yeah so it's just it's basically like electricity cost of separation and distillation right now so remind me though is it like as far as the ratio goes fuel of ratio having the lighter molecule what don't you kind of want that to be spewing out faster or something because it's less reaction it can you can accelerate it quicker okay there's a trade-off between well i mean what you tend to get limited by is you don't want to go too close to stoichiometric because the heat's too you can basically melt your engine yeah so that tends to limit you on the os on on trying to go to higher off right that's the actual thing limiting you you you tend to hit the
13:03stoichiometric melting point before you roll over on isp okay okay generally so that makes sense yeah and remind me of the grid fins are they do they still fold in no no is that gonna be permanently that way yeah so the the the what i'm trying to have a solo just implement rigorously is the sort of five-step process first make your requirements less done your requirements are definitely done does not matter who gave them to you it's particularly dangerous if a smart person gave you the requirements because you might not question them enough yeah you might take it as like gospel like i have to do this thing everyone's wrong no matter who you are everyone's wrong
13:52some of the time so make your requirements less dumb then try very hard to delete the part or process this is actually very important if you're not occasionally adding things back in you're not just leading enough right the bias tends to be very strongly towards let's add this part or process step in case we need it but you can you can basically make in case arguments for so many things and for a rocket that is trying to achieve try to be the first fully reusable rocket there's never been a fully useful rocket people don't understand like this is like the holy grail of rocketry okay and so you really need you have to run at tight margins because if you don't run tight margins
14:35you're going to get nothing to orbit right so so you've got to delete the power process step super important and you can't like hedge your vets so that's why the quick lines for example do not hold both down because that's a whole extra mechanism that we don't need and there's an having strong enough engine authority to steer it in the lower atmosphere actually our simulations so we don't really need any extra engine authority as long as the griffins you know basically follow the flow they're not really disturbing the flow it's really neither here or there so so the songs have a high angle of attack right it doesn't matter a few degrees or something or within a degree
15:19or two so but in any case it's a thing we could add later right so now these grid fins are humongous we'll go see them but they're like i mean like a dinosaur bear trap okay it's like you create a bear trap or a dinosaur that's what these things look like and if you have a whole mechanism for folding them that's like clearly a part that we don't need so this was a good design decision that actually i didn't come up with and it was like great but it followed the principle of like delete the part leave the process i was like great good idea let's not fold them why are we folding them anyway right somewhat random like like oh and also if whatever if you
16:00whatever requirement or constraint you have it must come with a name not a department because you can't ask their apartment you have to ask a person and that person who's putting forward the requirement or constraint must agree that they must take responsibility for that requirement otherwise you can have a requirement that basically an intern two years ago randomly came up with off the cuff and they're not even at the company anymore right and and and but it came from the let's say aeroloads department they're like actually there's no one in the air flows department actually it currently agrees with that this is now this is by the way happened
16:34several times so again it could be literally you don't want to pick on the arrow but there's like there's every department so it can be thought of as gospel again but it might be something that's just totally in passing like yeah yeah or someone played too much kerbal and had fins at the top of the rocket and then it just you know did this these things are often just way
16:58just more silly than you'd think so anyway so step one make your requirements less dumb step two delete the part or process step if you're not adding if you're not deleting a plot or processed step at least ten percent of the time it basically if you're not adding things back in ten per time you're clearly not deleting enough right and and then only the third step is simplify or optimize the third step not the first step the reason is the third step is because it's very common possibly the most common error of a smart engineer is to optimize the thing that should not exist right okay and say well how do we get why would people do that well everyone's
17:41been trained in in high school and college to that you've got to answer the question convergent logic yeah so you can tell the professor your question is done but you'll get a bad grade you have to answer the question yeah so everyone's basically without knowing it they got like mental straight jacket on that is they'll work on optimizing the thing that should simply not exist right right i'll give you an example from way back in the the day of falcon 1. so in the in the original sort of like when tomio and i were like batting around like okay what should this rocket look like i was i think i was literally in like tom's kitchen or something and and we had like the spreadsheet
18:22like okay we need to like make a minimum so minimally viable rocket like half a ton or whatever it's something like that and and then initially the spreadsheet had we had an nto mmh upper stage so a sort of hyper goal upper stage kind of like a variance of the trw limby yep so which i think tom worked on right yeah well tom the people who trained tom worked tonight it was like a baby you know
18:52a very advanced baby but his mentors did work on lmd so you know luna module sand engine so you know basically a panel injector right that's where the panel injector comes in right like you can also deep throttle it and everything so now the problem with that is how much does antiox cost oh it's super expensive okay it's like a rare chemical so even if you're like you know if edison and nick and tesla had a baby and that baby was smarter than both of them combined and said your job is to optimize an nto mmh upper stage you're screwed okay so like nitrogen tetroxide and monomethylhydrazine are super expensive and they're also toxic they're super nasty yeah
19:47yeah i mean handling costs are probably pretty yeah i mean i do think like save the safety is overcorrected on the anterior mmh went from like nobody had any protection and breathed the fumes all day to its cyanide okay and neither of those are true it's not cyanide you won't die and bill gosmere told me like a story of like when he started nasa they actually i think passed around around like a cup of like hydrazine so that everyone knew what hydrosteen smelled like so like because it's like a rotten egg smell or something like that so literally an open cup of hydrazine and like obviously he's still alive so so that's an example of like don't you know don't optimize the
20:32thing that shouldn't exist we should not have intel mmh upper stage right now dragon does have that but that's because dragon's got to do a lot a lot of like nuanced firings of the draco engines you know with very short pulse durations and if you have a you know trying to have something that's not hypergolic it's very difficult and now it can be done like but if you say not not hypergolic and not cryogenic now your options tend to suck yeah so you know then you start going down the peroxide barking up the peroxide tree or something like that and that's or or super esoteric monoprops right and it's that's that's like again back to big money so
21:16yeah let's see yeah yeah so exactly so getting through these quite laborious sorry for the laborious explanation here but and then finally you get to step four which is accelerate cycle time you're moving too slowly go faster but don't go faster until you have worked on the other three things first you know your grave don't dig it faster stop digging your grave right right so
21:53but it's you can always make me feel faster and then the final step is automate and now i have personally made the mistake of going backwards on all five steps multiple times so i have to repeat this yes multiple times on model three where literally i automated accelerated simplified and then deleted like one one example i've talked about before is like the with these like fiberglass mats on top of the model 3 battery pack they were in between the full pan and the battery and it was one point choking the battery pack production line and i was like basically living on the battery pack production line like trying to fix the line because it was like it was it was
22:42like choking the entire military production program so so the first mistake was we should not have i i like try to fix the automation like make the robot better make it make it like robot move faster a shorter path increase the torque delete the reverse 720 degrees on the the bolt because that's unnecessary just goes forward go forward fast not a 20 rate at 100 percent or rate and instead of spackling glue on the entire battery pack just put little dabs of glue because the the fiberglass mats are sandwiched between the the battery pack and the floor pan anyway so all you need is like something to hold it in place until you bolt the battery pack into the car gotcha
23:26so anyway so automating was a mistake then accelerating was a mistake then optimizing was a mistake and finally i said what the hell are these mats for and and i asked the the battery safety team because i like are these mats for what were these maps well they said oh these masks i said are they for fire protection or something they said no they're for noise and vibration so you don't get that and i said but you're the battery department then i asked an nba short and noise vibration harshness team what's it for they said fire safety so literally it was like being in a gilbert cartoon okay it was like actually i feel like a minute dober could turn quite
24:04frequently so i'm like you know like is it are we in some simulation where i like i'm like trapped in some like kafka-esque slash goldberg cartoon situation but that's what it feels like a lot so then finally okay great let's let's try a car with the fiberglass mats and without and they put a microphone in both and if you can tell the difference you cannot can i tell in fact i was like which one is which so we just deleted them and just bypassed this two million dollar robot robot cell it was just a complete pile of nonsense
24:49another mistake that tends to happen in production is too much in-process testing so in the when you're first setting up a production line you don't know where the most like where things are are breaking you don't know where things are breaking so you'll test like work in process at various steps and because you want to isolate where's where we where's the mistake occurring so a very common mistake issue with production alliance is to have is to not remove the end process testing after you've diagnosed where the problems are so basically if you have like a very high acceptance if like if things are getting to end of line testing and or passing then you don't need to
25:33do in-process testing so but what has to happen is there'll be an initial like development engineering team that will be like basically debugging the production line but then they will forget to take out the unprocessed testing steps so then what happens is the in-process test tester will often choke the cycle time choke the line for action time it'll be like the limiter it'll also have some number of false positives or false negatives but i mean there'll be like false positives like then you're like rejecting good parts right so really in volume production if you have if things are working well you're really just taking a risk will this part be
26:17will this subsystem be rejected at during in the during the production process or at the end and so you just really want to move things pretty much almost always to just test at the end line that's it maybe there's like one or two in process steps that are hard to test at the end of line but but basically remove almost everything there's another thing with battery pack where this is so crazy
26:49like one of the things the battery pack has to do is is to resist water ingress so it has to be leak-proof so if you drive through deep water water doesn't come into the battery pack and short off the battery pack you want to see some of the videos of like people driving tesla's in like extremely yeah flooded water just like this week china like yeah i feel like there was literally a guy i believe in kazakhstan literally drove a model s through a submerged water tunnel like it was and all the other cars were were out and he basically scared the car with the wheels yeah and use the wheel rotation yeah to like a boat yeah and and drove out the tunnel so
27:26you this is important to have the battery pack resist water ingress but then instead of us doing a a pressure test on the battery pack we were actually pressurizing the inside of the battery pack which was the up wrong direction and the battery pack lid was glued but you know we basically had resin that was not not cured and so we were just blurting out the resin which doesn't make any damn sense right because you should actually be drawing a vacuum on the on the back and not not trying to not not pressurizing it right and especially not pressurizing it when this uncured resin is what's holding down the battery pack yeah so so the pack was failing quite often on the
28:14pressurization test which should have been a vacuum test anyway speaking of grid fin yeah great look at that [Music] man that thing is huge yeah that's what i said it's like a dinosaur dinosaur bear trap oh wait that'd be a diet just a dinosaur trap wouldn't it crap that's insane yeah honestly this thing could catch a t-rex oh my gosh that's crazy and of course it's got the serrated teeth which help it help in the transonic regimes right yeah is there any other reason for the teeth other than than that no it's just well it actually helps in transphone against sonic but
29:11it's it's your the effectiveness is better if you've got a pointy 4.8 basically there is a limit there's pointiness sorry hey wow so how heavy are these guys man these are i started to think actually i don't know the number of hand but probably on at least three tons i'm guessing it's eyeballing it but this is not this is why i like what it says like moving target this is not the like i wouldn't take this to the bank like it's not you know we'll there's quite a lot of mass we can get out of this right right yours is just good enough for now like that's yeah it's good enough for now but like you know the we're basically just need to need like an enough control authority
30:09to get this through the atmosphere and positioned well enough so that when the engine's light the engine can correct whatever error is left after the you know that we couldn't take out with the griffins right right so man that is crazy those are huge yeah until it looks like the motor will mount to the that lever arm there is that just yeah so this is
30:40yeah there's a motor that's this will basically be this will react onto the the dome basically the fuel dome so there's like kind of like a c-channel around the the fuel the fuel dome at the top and there's a motor that's going to rotate this with a gearbox and that that's basically the load will be reacted between the circular feature that you see there and the the sort of i should say c channel sort of l channel on the dome so it's just a simple sort of ring on the dome okay and then is that so what i'm seeing there where there's the the ropes actually threw it on the end here is that the lever arm for the thing or is that just yeah wow so i see it slides over it's
31:29like a yeah okay that's that's basically the that's where the motor will interact so it's yeah wow but it's just basically i was using like model 3 motors basically yeah which is so cool yeah yeah might as well use them so you you mentioned you're you know really trying to simplify it there's been talks if they're not did you say it on twitter that you weren't going to have full you're going to eliminate thrust the cold gas thrusters or hot gas sources on the on the b4 for the first orbital test yeah but we can we can move to like maybe a more a quieter location
32:20i mean i'm pretty sure we could cut the weight of that in half like that's you know we're not even really trying to optimize the gauge that's just basically plate yeah that's just like cut cut plate right welded together so the first just gotta make the damping work and then we'll optimize it yeah of course which again some of the soviet union was so good that was like minimum viable product basically get it get it good enough to fly and test and obviously you guys did that with starship big time with the with 8 9 10 11 15 was like let's just get it out there see what works see what doesn't and iterate you know yeah and if you look like the various reasons like
33:01where we blew up starships like and you looked at the risk list no no none of the reasons that blew up were on the risk list really it was like [Music] [Applause] [Music] i i available there's a crazy amount of new technology happening here and it's all evolving simultaneously so we need to iron out like the unknown unknowns so to speak [Music] yeah the unknown unknowns are the big ones and there's we got the new is that the new flaps for 20 down there yeah
33:49so remind me the the numbering scheme because you were talking about version two raptor the other day what we've seen so far and are those version two yet are like the green the green nozzles are those aren't version two yet right have you started have you started making version two we've made parts of version two so we're gonna make the thrust chamber ascent we've made the thrust chamber assembly and we have i think pretty much finished the design of the pumps we're gonna make the problems so hopefully we'll we'll have on a raptor two you know in about a month we might be testing the first one okay so and and will that be you said you're gonna be kind of producing stuff
34:38or the prototypes are kind of gonna be always in hawthorne then eventually you're gonna be moving mass production to mcgregor yeah we're doing volume production of of raptor mcgregor who will keep california factory operating basically for development development engines and the raptor vacuum motion yeah crap back so yeah yeah so you're if you're reaching 230 230 ton on version two what what bar are you going to be what's that going to be at like 3 30.
35:13300 technically i think 298 but but we i think we should come on we gotta like get two more bar out of that thing yeah so wait wait so even only only 300 big air quotes on 300 you're getting 230 already yeah but we're opening the throat and reducing the area ratio okay so the extra thrust is it like there's a slight i think we lose like two or three seconds of isp but we gain a lot more interest yeah and the increase in thrust outweighs the slight drop in isp yeah especially on the first stage yeah yeah but what's the basically any thrust to weight below one is worthless it's worth us yeah yeah so if you go from point four to point five it's a massive leap compared to
35:54even yeah yeah okay so that makes that makes total sense so the the rap back what's that ex what's currently what's that for thrust is it still around that same number about 200 tons but you know the the raptor vacuum arvac we'll call it it will actually be the 230 ton rust number is the thrust at sea level of the the the sea level version of version 2 of the it's essentially it's like helpful to you and like some people like quibble about like why are you talking about thrust in tons that's not technically a scientific thing it's because you can do the math in your head really easily if you have a rocket in tons and thrust and tons right of course that's why and and
36:40newton's gonna like divide by 10 all the time right this is like annoying yeah and then you only get kilograms now you gotta like divide by ten thousand to get tons right it's ridiculous yeah it is okay so you're like what this is absurd yeah only a fool would use newtons in my opinion if they're designing a rocket so and like especially big rockets you because you just like have a zillion newtons so yeah so but if you measure things in tons and you measure twice in tons now you know thrust to weight very easily right so now is that so is that like the only imperial thing you measure then no these are still metric times metric tons okay okay that makes sense
37:18okay i was getting nervous for a second pressure's in bar yeah and and because everybody kind of knows like what's one atmosphere yeah so yeah pascal's another trash unit i hate past girls so why is it so tiny it's absurd right right we should have a whole a whole segment of units that elon hates and it's just it's like units that make understanding things more harder instead of easier yeah but everyone understands like bar or an atmosphere essentially and everyone understands like cruel can get their mind around a ton like you have an intuitive sense for a ton okay like a your car is like two tons yeah sure yeah yeah you have some context yeah before you
38:04got hit by a ton you'd know what that meant if you got hit by a pascal that's like i don't know a mouse part it's like one pass right so wow so the because i it's another important principle which is that you really want everyone to be chief engineer so everyone as chief engineer means that people need to understand the the system at a high level to know what they when they are making a a bad optimization it's like like when they are like say like we've done this many times where we've like put immense effort into reducing the engine mass but not but hardly any effort into reducing propellant residuals or like order magnitude less efficient reducing profile residuals
39:02and then you end you you land with a literal ton of unused fuel and actually we still kind of do that with falcon 9 it has about a ton of unused fuel upon landing which is pretty annoying right oh that's still not much in the grand scheme of everything it's still not much but that is in context so it still is quite a bit though yeah but like we've spent so much effort getting a ton out of engines like you know that's sort of whatever like 130 kilograms per engine like that's 100 yen so 120 ish so yeah wow look the sunsets out here are pretty hard to beat that's insane
39:45god that's amazing so congrats on the hls solidifying a little more today that was cool the g.o is a source defender of good contracting can we head over and check out the mock-up there because there's still a lot that we don't know about hls publicly at least i assume that you know oh i teased them out more i don't know if i do but well first off i guess the most obvious one that i'm excited about is those thrusters oh yeah at the top okay so yeah so the thrusters are a good example of running that algorithm i just mentioned laboriously mentioned which which is a question the requirements the maker requirements less dumb delete the part yeah so
40:46[Music] when looking when looking at what what does the booster actually need to do [Music] with stage separation if you put rotation into the stack before stay like before you turn off the main engines yep so they're both they're both rotating they're going to rotate sorry like pitching and yawning yeah so like you've got the integrated stack yeah we do this with darling we're starting yeah so we rotate the stage okay and it kind of flings it out yes but the like the they they basically have different amounts of inertia it's initially rotational moving to linear inertia so that they're they basically move at different rates so if you if you rotate the thing depending
41:36on where you are you will move at a different speed and so it automatically separates if you if you rotate okay and then separate so there's no actual separation mechanism for the stalling satellites and they technically can bump into each other and occasionally do but they bump into each other for like one mile an hour it doesn't matter right right so it's bouncing they already made it through the pretty harsh environments of launch yeah it's it's fine so but like i'm pretty sure this is like this might be the only right like we're like literally tossing 60 satellites off with no like like i hate a bundle of hay like dry you know yeah dumping the the you know rods that hold
42:14them down like like a hay bale and just flinging them it's clean and it's fine they just separate boot up and go to their position so that's right anyway so so if you go to stage step instead of it instead of asking the the attitude control thrusters the reaction control thrusters to do the booster rotation which is a lot of force you have the main engines initiate rotation now this is quite complex space ballet because everything's got to happen in just the right way but you basically initiate the initiate the rotation of the stack stop the main engines then the two will actually separate by themselves and you need like a little bit of we we have like call gas
43:15acs or reaction control system it's like depending on who you ask it's a reaction control system or an attitude control system it's basically like small maneuvering thrusters yep so you fire those on the on the ship that gives you a little bit of maneuvering and then on the booster we actually have quite a lot of outlet gas like basically the you've got a lot of hot gaseous oxygen and hot methane which actually have you know if you've got a big enough area it's got decent thrust in vacuum the actual the actual the vents yeah yeah just literally used to vent vent the stage yeah so not in a separate gas bottle but literally like the oldage of the the main tanks
44:03yes okay so just use the oled as your as your thrusters and just just control the orientation of the venting so it is not just venting out sideways but it is venting in a direction that is useful so which can be sideways sometimes anyway we've got like basically a lot of gas in this thing and which would have to actually just vent to vacuum anyway because it's got too much gas and that's just extra mass that you don't need right so so if you've got basically enough control authority because of the kicking the whole stack over before main engine cuddle plus
44:50using the old gas to vent then you don't need you don't need a separate hot gas thruster system you don't even need a cold gas thruster system you already have hot gas for for the booster right so definitely question the requirements delete the part yes yes but this is only for the booster right yes although arguably now you mentioned it we should we might might be wise to do this for the ship too how can you have you'd think that because at least mostly well the tanks are what six or eight bar or something the main tanks yeah they'll be like six six-ish bar okay and so wouldn't those be pretty low pressure you know low isp gas thrusters if you're only doing the
45:40gas from there or is there some trick you can do to no in in vacuum you don't like it's different in atmosphere so like six bar in in vacuum is is actually decent like it's it's like common to have thrusters in space thrusters that are let's say eight bar like like the the the draco thrusters for that maneuver dragon are operating around chamber pressure of around eight or nine bar what yeah really you don't need a like dragon is still in psi so it's like to 130 psi technically it's a pressure pulse but right it sucks you know so 120 psi is like roughly eight bar ish maybe eight and a half hour so so it's not that far from the tank pressure right so you don't even
46:38need to store the gas in an even higher like in a bottle that's at like 200 bar or something you don't even need to do that to operate rcs no if you've got hot gas first of all it's like it's it's we really want the all the gas to be as hot as possible up to the point where it is impacting the the strength of the of the hull like we don't want to soften the metal so much that it pops basically so the hotter the gas is the the higher the isp so having hot gas is good and it's and it's already there and it's you already have the pressure vessel right and you're gonna chuck it away anyway yeah so obviously it's it as attitude for adequate trouble to control
47:27so so like obviously now now initially you can't do this with the ship because everything's cryo but once the ship is mostly empty and it's delivered to orbit it also is in the same situation with a lot of hot gas yeah so actually we should really be the vast majority of our maneuvering should be with the hot gas that's in the in the ship i thanks now that we're going to fix that jeez that's but yeah okay so the thrusters on hls that are going to be around the ring the render showed like 24 or something though of of like you know the lane though those are different those are landing on the moon okay yeah yeah are those are those pressure fed like
48:11what are those do you have a name for them yet or anything let's just say like like this is this is the tentative design right now but with the agreement of nasa we i think we may see that design evolve okay and it may be better actually so like like a big question here is like can you learn or can you land on the moon with the main engines or do you need a separate thruster system that's way up there like basically if you if you land with the main engine you're gonna dig a big ditch in the moon and then fall over because you landed in a ditch that you dug and you shot literally dig your own grave yeah that would be obviously bad you know right so
49:04we don't want to go right dig around dig around grave and then fall in it right right but more analysis is like i think we could probably land with the main engine and not dig it dig a grave and die in it but we would have to prove that you know get something that's like i don't know the consistency of like lunar regolith and and like something that's like a good good analog analog of that and and then like land land a ship in that and see how big a whole big how big is the hole that we did yeah if you've got low pressure engines that are high up naturally you're going to have a much you're not going to dig a hole basically right so that's kind of like the sure thing
49:52but i think if we can prove that the main engines do not dig a giant hole then then we could land with the main engines and then not have the not have any of those yeah the ring yeah what about the are you gonna have any sea level raptors on the lunar variant or will you only have vacuum optimized
50:13because i assume like on a normal starship even at stage separation you'll probably light all six at first just to minimize gravity loss or something right so you'll still fire all six then probably shut down the sea levels and let the vacuum optimize you know like they probably do what like half the half the second stage burn time or something with sea level or if you well so the the vacuum engines don't
50:38don't gimble yep so you'd have to have something to provide the control authority i mean technically you could say like well if you if you're in a low disturbance situation like the moon has no atmosphere right man this is beefing city yeah so if you're not if you're if you're not facing like a lot of atmospheric disturbances then you need much less control authority and you could possibly probably land with three just by differential throttling of three engines yeah but if you did if you lost any of the engines you'd be toast yeah yeah so probably makes sense
51:20i don't know probably keep the same config you know or or like you can even just have one in the middle that would offer you know a decent amount of gimbal authority and all that it depends on how much optimization is we're aiming for here right because you're only probably gonna make one of these things right are you planning on like is nasa wanting multiple or oh my word so by the way i think there's a good chance that itar and comms might not want all this up wait until you see part two it is unbelievable and i promise i'm going to get it to as soon as i can thank you elon for spending so much time with me and allowing me to ask all of the questions i had it was
51:58amazing and thanks to the teams of spacex for allowing me to share this all with you and thanks to kazakh perspective for helping shoot this and just kind of helping out all the time find them on youtube and on patreon as well and i owe a huge thank you to my patreon supporters for helping make this and everything else we do here at everydayastronaut possible if you want access to our discord channel where we'll probably end up talking about this conversation a lot or live streams or lots of other fun stuff head on over to patreon.com everydayastronaut and while you're online be sure and check out our awesome web store we can find shirts like this the r7 slash semi orca
52:35slash the predecessor to soyuz new shirt that we have that is awesome as well as our new mars hats but you can also find some classics like the full flow stage combustion cycle shirt and hoodie and the future martian shirt and schematics collection and lots of other fun stuff so head on over to everydayastronaut.com shop thanks everybody that's going to do it for me i'm tim dodd the everyday astronaut bringing space down to earth for everyday people [Music] you
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版