访谈·中文精读

马斯克对话凯文·罗斯(Foundation)

Elon Musk and Kevin Rose (Foundation)

一场平静、坦诚的对话,谈2008年——他人生中最糟糕的一年,以及他最喜欢的方法的起源:用第一性原理推理,而不是靠类比。著名的电池成本例子就出自这里。

B 站版本为网友搬运,时间点可能差几秒
中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

1995年夏天,一个24岁的年轻人站在硅谷Netscape公司的大厅里,手里攥着简历,不知道该跟谁开口。

他在大厅里待了很久,最后什么也没说,转身走了。

十七年后,这个人在自己工厂的会议室里聊起这段往事,语气很平淡:

“我给Netscape投了简历,没收到任何回复。我还试着去他们大厅里晃,想找个人聊聊,但我太害羞了,不敢开口,就在大厅里学习。然后我就走了。”(马斯克)

这个年轻人叫埃隆·马斯克(Elon Musk)。2012年,他41岁。那年5月,SpaceX的龙飞船成为第一艘造访国际空间站的商业飞船;6月,特斯拉Model S开始交付。凯文·罗斯(Kevin Rose)的Foundation节目把他请到工厂,聊了一个多小时。

大部分人对马斯克的印象停留在“狂人”两个字。这段访谈里没有豪言壮语,有的是一个接一个具体的决定,以及每个决定背后怎么算账。

一个南非小孩的美国梦,从一本漫画开始

马斯克1971年出生在南非比勒陀利亚(Pretoria),在约翰内斯堡和德班(Durban)也住过。17岁离开南非,一个人走。

10岁左右,他去过一趟美国。非洲其他国家也转过一些。真正让他记住美国的,是漫画和书。

“我读了很多漫画和书,关于技术的东西。我发现每次有酷的技术出现,事情都发生在美国。所以我小时候的目标就是去美国。”(马斯克)

他读漫画不挑。Batman、Superman、Green Lantern、Iron Man、Doctor Strange,货架上有什么读什么。

提到Iron Man,他特意补了一句:“我得先说别的,不然大家以为我第一个说Iron Man。”这个细节挺有意思。2010年他已经在《钢铁侠2》里客串过自己,这会儿是2012年,他还是先撇清一下,怕别人觉得他往钢铁侠身上靠。

真正改变轨迹的是9岁或10岁那年,他在南非一家商店里看到一台Commodore Vic 20。

“我觉得这是我见过最牛的东西。你可以用它写程序、做游戏。我之前玩过Atari之类的游戏机,大概六七岁。能自己创造游戏,这个想法让我很兴奋。”(马斯克)

第一台电脑,8K内存。很多创业者小时候都有类似的“第一次接触”,区别在于马斯克很早就把“做酷东西”和“去美国”这两件事绑成了同一个目标。

斯坦福只待了两天,第一次当CEO被换掉

去美国之后,他先在加拿大皇后大学待了两年,后来转到宾夕法尼亚大学,拿了物理学和经济学双学位。1995年,他到了斯坦福,读应用物理材料科学的博士。

只待了两天。

“1995年,我觉得互联网会以某种方式大幅改变世界,我想参与进去。我本来想先去Netscape找份工作,没成。然后那个夏天我一直在写软件,到了斯坦福开学的时候,我得做决定,所以我决定推迟入学。”(马斯克)

他去找系主任,说推迟六个月,可能很快就回来。系主任说,你大概再也不会回来了。

他说对了。马斯克再也没联系过那位系主任。

他和弟弟金巴尔(Kimbal),还有朋友格雷格·库里(Greg Kouri),三个人成立了Zip2。最初的想法很简单:帮媒体公司上网。

“我们帮《纽约时报》、赫斯特(Hearst)、奈特·里德(Knight Ridder)这些公司上线。很多人不知道,那时候这些媒体根本不在网上。”(马斯克)

Zip2是他第一次当CEO,干了一年左右。拿到风险投资之后,投资方要求换一个“职业CEO”。

他当时觉得这主意不错。

“我不太清楚自己在干什么,他们能找个更厉害的人来,公司成功概率更高。我可以去做软件和产品方向,那是我喜欢的事。”(马斯克)

后来他的评价很直接:那个人不怎么样,公司能成,是“在那个人之外”成的。

这段话值得多停两秒。很多创始人第一次听到投资人要换CEO,第一反应是愤怒。马斯克当时的反应是如释重负,因为他真心觉得自己不会管公司。他的错误不在这里,他的错误在于把“找个更专业的人”当成了默认最优解,没去验证那个人到底专不专业。

罗斯问他,第一次创业这么难,有没有找导师。

马斯克的回答很平实:没有单独一个导师,读很多书,跟很多人聊,从周围人那里拿反馈,也从历史里拿反馈,书就是历史。

他推荐传记和自传。富兰克林的自传,还有艾萨克森(Walter Isaacson)写的那本富兰克林传记。理由很具体:富兰克林就是个创业者,一个离家出走的孩子,白手起家建起印刷生意,后来又搞科学、搞政治。

他也推荐读科学家和工程师的传记,比如特斯拉(Nikola Tesla)。

聊到特斯拉,罗斯提到当时有个众筹项目要建特斯拉博物馆。马斯克说他捐了钱。

“Oatmeal(发起众筹的漫画网站)干得漂亮。我喜欢他们那句口号:建一个他妈的特斯拉博物馆吧。”(马斯克)

这里插一句。特斯拉汽车和尼古拉·特斯拉的名字撞在一起,很多人以为是马斯克致敬。特斯拉汽车2003年由马丁·艾伯哈德(Martin Eberhard)和马克·塔彭宁(Marc Tarpenning)创立,马斯克是早期投资人,后来当了董事长。名字确实来自尼古拉·特斯拉,只是起名的人不是他。

大学时列出的三件事,后来全干了

访谈里有一段,马斯克解释了他为什么同时干这么多大事。

大学时,他在想一个问题:什么最影响人类的未来。

他列了三件。

“互联网。可持续能源,包括生产端和消费端,生产就是太阳能,消费就是特斯拉这种可持续的消费方式。还有太空探索,具体说,让生命成为多行星的。”(马斯克)

他当时没打算全都干。只是觉得这三件事影响最大。

结果他全干了。

Zip2之后那家公司叫X.com,后来跟康菲尼迪(Confinity)合并,变成PayPal。2002年eBay收购PayPal,马斯克作为最大股东拿到一笔钱,这笔钱后来成了SpaceX和特斯拉的启动资金。访谈里他没展开这段,只提了一句“后来那家公司叫PayPal,很成功”。

罗斯问他,决定干这些事的时候,有没有想过可能失败。

回答是:“当然,绝对有。”

往火星送温室:一场预期血本无归的慈善

最早,马斯克想做的跟火箭公司没多大关系,他打算搞一个慈善项目。

往火星表面送一个小温室,里面放种子和脱水营养凝胶,着陆后加水,让植物长出来。红色背景上出现一片绿色,拍照传回地球。

“公众对‘第一次’和‘最什么’的东西反应很强烈。我觉得这能让人对火星上有生命这件事兴奋起来。”(马斯克)

他自己算过账:这个项目预期100%亏损,也许能靠广告或赞助收回一点,基本等于把钱扔了。

开火箭公司呢?至少财务回报率大于零。

“刚开始做SpaceX的时候,我觉得最可能的结果是失败。”(马斯克)

这句话放在2012年听,分量不轻。那一年龙飞船已经两次往返空间站。他说的“刚开始”,指的是2002年。

一个把钱全部押在自己认为“最可能失败”的事情上的人,图的到底是什么。访谈里没有直接回答,但他前面那句“什么是确定真的”其实已经回答了:他赌的是概率低但后果极大的那一头,赌注是别人不愿意押的时间。

EV1被压成废铁那天,他决定自己造车

电动车这条路,马斯克一开始没打算自己走。

加州有个法规,强制车企生产一定比例的零排放车。通用汽车因此搞出了EV1,第一款量产电动车。

马斯克当时想:世界最大的车企在做电动车,EV1出来了,就会有EV2、EV3、EV4。

通用把项目砍了。

“那非常不明智,短视。他们不光是取消项目,还强行把已经租出去的车收回来。车只租不卖。他们把车从客户手里拿走,压碎,扔在废车场,确保这些车再也不能上路。”(马斯克)

客户不干,打官司想保住车。官司没赢。他们在废车场门口点了蜡烛守夜。

“你什么时候见过人们为一个产品点蜡烛守夜?还是一个通用汽车的产品。你得有多迟钝,才会看不出至少有一部分人真心想要这车。你不用做客户调研都看得出来。”(马斯克)

这件事后来被拍成纪录片《谁消灭了电动车》。马斯克在访谈里的判断只有一句:必须有一家新公司进来,证明电动车能做好。

核心要证明的只有一件事:你能造出一辆好看的、高性能的、长续航的电动车,而且有人愿意买。人们对汽油车没有那么深的执念。

注意他给特斯拉定的第一目标是“证明”,第二目标才是“卖车”。顺序反了,产品就会变成一堆妥协。

2008年,把所有筹码推上桌

特斯拉2003年成立。马斯克是董事长和最大投资人,一开始不想当CEO。

“我在管SpaceX。同时管两家公司,工作量太大了。你本来有一份很吃力的工作,现在要干两份,乐趣全没了,社交生活也没了。总得放弃点什么。”(马斯克)

他的计划是:找个人当CEO,自己管产品设计和整体战略,日常运营交给别人。

找了几个,没找对。

2007年,他成了联合CEO。2008年,金融危机来了。

“市场崩了,经济崩了。我面临一个选择:把剩下的资源全押进特斯拉,否则它必死。我想,如果我要押上全部筹码,那我就得自己来打这手牌。”(马斯克)

2008年对马斯克是地狱的一年。特斯拉融资艰难,SpaceX前三次发射全败。他在采访里没展开这些,只说了“把筹码推上桌就得自己打”这个决定。

同年9月28日,猎鹰1号第四次发射成功,成为第一枚进入轨道的私人研制液体燃料火箭。12月23日,NASA给了SpaceX一份16亿美元的商业补给合同。特斯拉那轮融资在圣诞前夜关闭。两家公司都活了下来。

这两件事之间隔了不到三个月。差一点,今天就没有特斯拉,也没有SpaceX。

为什么别的车那么丑,成本根本不是理由

罗斯问了一个很直接的问题:为什么别的车那么丑?看起来像是没在听消费者说话。

马斯克的回答也很直接。

“你拿一块车身面板,可以冲压成这个形状,也可以冲压成那个形状,成本一样。但他们偏选难看的形状。材料质量和装配精度确实有些要花钱,但大部分不花。你可以造一辆难看的贵车,也可以造一辆好看的贵车。便宜车也一样,成本差很小。”(马斯克)

为什么车企还是造丑车?他的猜测是:公司被自己的历史困住了。

这个猜测不算新鲜,但他给的做法很具体。特斯拉的设计流程,他讲得很细。

每周五下午,他跟设计总监弗朗茨·冯·霍兹豪森(Franz von Holzhausen)和设计团队开会,过一遍车的每一个细节。每个保险杠、每条曲线、每个小零件。

“哪个地方对,哪个地方不对,然后要拿工程需求、人体工学、法规要求去过滤。你不能想造成什么形状就造成什么形状,还要通过碰撞安全这些法规。所以要大量迭代,在乎每一毫米。好产品就是这么来的。”(马斯克)

这段话信息量很大。很多公司也有设计评审,但很少有CEO每周花一个下午,跟设计师过每一个毫米,而且是连续几年。Model S在2012年拿了一堆设计奖,这件事有原因。

罗斯追问他有没有做过焦点小组,马斯克的回答干脆:没有,就是每周迭代。

Hyperloop:地面上的协和式飞机

访谈里绕不开Hyperloop。2012年,这个话题刚开始在硅谷流传。

马斯克说得很谨慎。

“我得找时间把细节写下来。我不想说一些完全愚蠢的话。我在跟SpaceX的空气动力学团队和特斯拉的空气动力学团队一起弄,确保我拿出来的东西真的能跑。”(马斯克)

罗斯问,这算火车吗?

“它真的会是一种新的交通方式。你可以把它想成地面上的协和式飞机。如果你要让什么东西在地面上跑得跟协和一样快,你会怎么做?”(马斯克)

轨道呢?

“我觉得不需要轨道。”

2013年8月,马斯克发布了Hyperloop白皮书。设计是低压管道里的铝制胶囊,靠线性感应电机和空气轴承推进,理论时速1200公里,洛杉矶到旧金山大约35分钟。他没申请专利,直接公开了。

一个上市公司CEO,把自己憋了快一年的技术方案免费放出来,还劝别人去做。这种事在商业史上不多见。

好想法都从哪冒出来

罗斯问他,这么多想法从哪来。

马斯克的回答很诚实。

“听起来很老套,但淋浴的时候最多。早上醒来去洗澡,其实是潜意识里一直在处理,洗澡的时候结果冒出来了。有时候是深夜睡不着,有事情揪着你,想法就来了。还有一个超音速垂直起降电动飞机的想法,是在Burning Man想到的。Burning Man出了不少好想法。”(马斯克)

这段听着像闲聊,其实说清了一件事:想法不产生于会议室,产生于大脑后台跑完一轮的时刻。前提是后台得有东西在跑,也就是前一天真的把问题装进脑子里了。

把负面反馈当金子,正面反馈当耳边风

访谈最后,罗斯问给创业者的建议,以及有什么是绝对要避免的。

马斯克的第一条建议:主动去找负面反馈,仔细听。

“这是人们常犯的错误。因为负面反馈让人痛苦,所以大家躲着它。你得主动去挖。”(马斯克)

具体怎么做?

“我身边每个人都是反馈来源。朋友拿到产品,我跟他说:别告诉我你喜欢什么,告诉我你不喜欢什么。否则朋友不会说不喜欢,他会说我爱你这个那个,然后把不喜欢的那部分藏起来,因为他想跟你做朋友,不想冒犯你。所以你得把负面反馈哄出来。”(马斯克)

还有一句更狠的:

“如果一个人是你的朋友,至少不是你的敌人,他给你负面反馈,他可能说错,但出发点是好的。有时候你的敌人也能给你好的负面反馈。”(马斯克)

正面反馈怎么处理?

“像鸭子背上的水,滑掉。负面反馈要放大。”(马斯克)

这套方法之所以反常识,是因为它的方向跟人的本能相反。本能让创始人收集赞美来维持信心,他的做法是收集批评来维持准确。

把电池拆到元素周期表,再看价格

第二条建议,也是马斯克最常讲的一条:用第一原理(first principles)推理,别用类比推理。

“我们平时的思维方式是类比。做这件事因为别人也这么做,或者因为以前是这么做的。‘我也是’类型的想法,在原来的主题上迭代。类比推理脑力消耗小。第一原理是物理学看世界的方式:把事情拆到最基本的真相,问什么是确定的,然后从那里往上推。这要费更多脑力。”(马斯克)

他举了电池的例子。特斯拉最核心的成本问题就出在这。

“有人说电池组很贵,而且会一直贵,因为历史上一直贵。这个逻辑很蠢。如果你把这种逻辑套到任何新事物上,你永远得不到新东西。就像当年有人说,没人想要汽车,马很好,我们习惯了,马吃草,到处是草,汽油没地方买,所以汽车永远不会有。”(马斯克)

电池的历史价格是每千瓦时600美元。用类比推理,未来也不会好到哪去。

用第一原理:电池由什么材料构成?

“钴、镍、铝、碳,还有一些用于分隔的聚合物,一个密封罐。把这些拆开,按伦敦金属交易所的现货价格算,每种材料值多少钱?算下来大概每千瓦时80美元。所以很明显,你只需要找到聪明的方式把这些材料组合成电池的形状,电池就能比任何人以为的便宜得多。”(马斯克)

600美元到80美元,中间是组合方式的成本。特斯拉后来干的,就是把中间那520美元一点点压下去。十年后,4680电池、结构 pack、干法电极,还在压同一笔钱。

罗斯问,电池是特斯拉最大的挑战吗?

马斯克说,是最大的单项成本,但当时还卡不住他们。

99%完成的车,等于没完成

最后一个问题关于造车的难点。马斯克的回答,对做硬件的人都值得抄下来。

“一辆车有几千个独特零件。90%没问题,5%有点小问题,3%到4%有问题,1%极其有问题。但你不能交付一辆99%完成的车。软件可以只上线部分功能,车不行,你不能交一辆没有方向盘或者没有后座的车。”(马斯克)

这句话解释了为什么硬件创业比软件创业难一个数量级。软件可以带着bug上线,快速迭代,用户几乎无感。硬件不行,任何一个零件卡住,整条产线停摆,钱每天在烧。

访谈到这里差不多结束。罗斯最后说,你激励了很多创业者。马斯克说,谢谢你来工厂。

整段对话里,马斯克很少讲宏大叙事。他讲的是:在大厅里不敢开口的那个下午,被压碎的EV1,每周五下午的设计评审,伦敦金属交易所的现货价格,还有那1%卡住整车的零件。

2012年,特斯拉差点死过一轮,SpaceX也差点死过一轮。坐在工厂里聊这些的时候,他41岁,两家公司都刚站稳。他说“最可能的结果是失败”的时候,用的是一句陈述句的语调,像在说天气。

回头看,这段访谈最值钱的地方,是他把做判断的方法讲得很具体。那些方法放到今天,做产品的、做硬件的、做投资的,都能直接拿来用。

给读者的行动清单

如果要从这段访谈里带走点什么,下面这几条可以马上去做。

  • 主动去挖负面反馈,别等它来找你。产品给朋友看的时候,明确说“告诉我你不喜欢什么”。朋友的赞美没有信息量,朋友的批评才是数据。
  • 把正面反馈的权重调低,负面反馈的权重调高。这么做看着像自虐,作用是纠偏。人天生高估自己的作品,负面反馈是唯一的解药。
  • 遇到“一直这么贵”“一直都是这样”的说法,把它拆开。问一句:这东西由什么构成?原材料按市场价值算多少钱?中间的差价去了哪里?
  • 别用类比推理做重要决定。“别人都这么做”只能说明过去,说明不了对错。用第一原理从基本事实往上推,费脑力,但结论更可靠。
  • 做硬件的人,把“99%等于0”贴在墙上。几千个零件里只要有一个卡住,车就交不出去。排优先级的时候,先解决那1%,别安慰自己“大部分都好了”。
  • 设计这件事,交给设计师并不算完。创始人真的在乎产品,就得每周坐下来,跟团队一个毫米一个毫米地过。外包出去的设计,做不出好产品。
  • 好想法不会在会议室里出现。淋浴、深夜、Burning Man,共同点是大脑在放松,潜意识在后台跑。给自己留出这种时间,也别把日程排满到没有缝隙。

最后补一句访谈里没明说、但贯穿始终的东西:马斯克做判断的时候,很少问“这事以前有没有人做成过”,他问的是“这事在物理上是否可行,成本结构是否成立”。这个习惯,比任何一条具体建议都值钱。

YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00[Music] welcome to Foundation a show where we profile some of the world's most interesting entrepreneurs for more episodes check out foundation. KR today we're talking to Elon Musk a Founder at Tesla SpaceX and PayPal let's go talk to [Music] him so let's start at the beginning where did you grow up I was born in South Africa lived till I was 17 and then TR moved by myself should I give you the whole story or yeah love to hear okay the very beginning sure so yeah I was born in Petoria South Africa lived at lived in Johannesburg and Duran as well was able to travel to a few countries growing up within Africa and around the world went to the US when I

0:44was I don't know 10ish or something like that and I read a lot of comics and books and stuff and it always seems and and stuff and things on technology it always seemed like when there's cool technology or things happening it was kind of in United States so my goal as a kid was to try to get to get to America basically what were your favorite Comics well I I read I read every comic in the store and I like obviously the the the you know Batman Superman stuff I mean the Green Lantern Iron Man got to not say Iron Man first cuz then people will think you know but I thought I did think that was a pretty cool one and but I read everything like dror

1:28strange you know just if if there was a comic on the rack I read it awesome yeah and when did you decide to get into computers and technology did you start coding or was it is it just a lot lot of noise lot of construction going on can you still hear okay okay we're good so did you start coding yeah so when I was about 10 years old I was went into a store in South Africa and saw a Commodore Vic 20 and guess maybe

2:02I was nine years old I don't know some about that time and I thought this was like you know the most awesome thing I'd ever seen and you could like make this right computer programs and make games and and I've played you know Atari and other things for other games consoles before I was like maybe six or seven so the idea of being able to play create games I thought was really exciting and so I got that was my first computer was a commod or Vic 20 I think it had like 8K of memory and then what led you into entrepreneurship was it something that you always knew that you wanted to be an entrepreneur and start start something on your own or did you just stumble into

2:40it yeah I I know I wouldn't say that I always knew that I wanted to be an entrepreneur I I actually wasn't sure what I wanted to to do growing up and I think at one point I I thought well like in inventing stuff or creating things would be a cool thing to do but I wasn't really sure if that meant starting a company or whether that meant working for a company that made cool stuff and in fact when I first

3:10came out to Silicon Valley it you know was to do a do gr St of Stanford in app physics Material Science and then I I sort this in ' 95 I kind of thought the internet would be something that would change the world in a major way MH and I wanted to be part of it and actually what I what I first tried to do was I Tred to get a job at Netscape so I would actually try to start a company I tried to get a job at Netscape and then that didn't work out no I didn't get any I didn't get any reply so I I I mean I had a physics and economics degree or physics and Business Degree from from from whorton and I was doing grad studies and applied physical Material Science and I I guess that you

3:53know I didn't have a computer science degree or or several years working at a software company for so what for whatever reason I didn't get a a reply from ncape and I actually tried hang out in the lobby but I was I was too shy to talk to anyone so I was just like studying in the lobby and I and and then I you just walked in did you have your resume with you or was it yeah actually it was pretty embarrassing I was just sort of standing there trying to see if there's someone I could talk to and then I just couldn't I couldn't it was I was too scared to talk to anyone so then I left amazing so then you went on to do what from that point I so so then I just I was just

4:34writing software that summer and it got to the start of the quarter for Stanford I had to make a decision so I decided go to ferment so I figure if I start a company and it doesn't work then I can always go back to grad school it's just you know so I talked to the chairman of the department and he let me go on deferment and I said I'd probably be back in 6 months and he said he's probably never going to hear from me again and he was correct I've never spoken to him since so so yeah so started company with my brother and a friend of mine Greg curri who and and the three of us created Z two which where the initial idea was to to create software that

5:17could help bring the media companies online so we helped in a small way bring companies like the like New York Times Hearst night rer and and so forth bring them online cuz they weren't actually always online people don't realize that were you the the CEO at the time or did you give that role to someone else yeah I started off being the CEO so as was CEO for probably the first year and then but but

5:42after we got VC funding the V capitalists wanted to hire a professional CEO was that frustrating or were you were you like I just this is over my head I'm I'm ready to give up this role to someone else I at the time I thought it was a good idea because I don't really know what I was doing and I figured they would hire someone who' be way really good and that person would increase the chances of success the company and so that seemed like a good thing and then I could work on software and kind of product Direction and that's that's what I like doing so that seemed like a great thing now in retrospect I think that that that wasn't the best thing cuz I the

6:27person that was hired in in my opinion was was actually not that great so so I think yeah I mean I think quite frankly the company succeeded in spite of that person not because of them what what you know starting a company for the first time is is very challenging for a lot of people that they don't even know where to begin you must have run into a lot of I mean we all made mistakes of starting our first company as far as hiring like you said the people you bring in like CEO that that replaced you did you surround yourself with mentors how did you who did you look to for advice I I read a lot of books and talk to lots of people I didn't have any

7:08any one person who was a mentor but I I always look for feedback from from people around me and feedback from in historical context you know which is books basically so that's any any book Stand Out is something that was like something that you really relied upon or well they just general business books or I didn't read actually very many General business books but I I I I I liked

7:37biographies and autobiographies I think those are pretty helpful so I like and actually some lot of them aren't really business although like something like Franklin's both his autobiography and say the biography that's recently been written by by or not that recently but in I guess 5 or 10 years ago whenever was written the biography by isacon on on the Franklin is really good and you can sort of see how he kind of cuz he was an entrepreneur I mean he he sort of started from nothing actually just like a runaway kid basically and created his his printing business and just sort of how he went about doing that and and then over time you also did

8:19science and politics so that I would say certainly he's one of the people I I most admire like Franklin's Prett pretty awesome but then I think it's also worth reading book on scientists and Engineers Tesla obviously did you hear about that Tesla Museum that they're having built yeah I actually contributed some funing to to save the land oh that's great awesome yeah that was a very cool thing that oatmeal did yeah I thought it was pretty cool I like I like the the way that they put it too it's like let's have a goddamn test the museum awesome so fast forward a little bit you know you obviously did PayPal that was very successful and then at some point in time you're like I'm

8:57going to do something crazy something that's never been done before with Tesla and the space related stuff you're into I mean why take on such huge very ambitious type projects I mean did you have ever have a feeling like this might not work oh yeah absolutely well so this kind of goes back to college where I was trying to figure out what are the things that would most affect the future of humanity and the things that I thought would most affect the future would be with the internet sustainable energy which is both production and consumption and so effectively solar cities like production Tesla's consumption in a sustainable way and then also space

9:36exploration and specifically making life multiplanetary now I didn't expect at the time to be involved in all of those areas but those are just the areas that I thought would would most affect the future and as it turned out I've been fortunate enough to be involved in those areas but that's the threat that connects them it's like is kind of my best guess at What would most likely affect the future in big way and and when I when I first

10:04thought about doing something in space the thing I was going to do was actually going to be kind of a philanthropic mission to to Mars to to land a small Greenhouse in the surface of Mars with with with seeds and dehydrated nutrient gel that that you'd hydrate upon Landing you'd have this this little greenhouse on on Mars and and you have this great shot of green plants on the red background and the public tends to resp respond to precedents and superlatives so I thought that would people get people really excited about setting life to Marks and and my expectation from that project would be 100% loss because you know I wouldn't expect maybe you can make a

10:43little bit back on advertising or sponsorship or something but but it would be essentially a complete loss so starting a a rocket company was necessarily be have a greater likely outcome than 0% Financial return right right but at the beginning of starting SpaceX I thought that the most likely outcome was failure mhm and how about Tesla Motors like walk me through your process of of wanting to launch something like that yeah so in terms of an electric car company the at first I thought that there would be no need to do an electric car company startup because California regulations basically forced General Motors to create the vault or rather the

11:29ev1 I should say so so when General had the ev1 I thought hey this is great biggest car company in the world is making electric car it's called the ev1 that that would imply there's going to be an ev2 3 4 You know and they killed that project off though right they did and that was very unwise I

11:51mean it's sort of really shortsighted I think action I mean retrospect that seems perhaps obvious but at the time not only that they cancel the project they forcibly removed the ev1s that they had given out which they only gave out on lease they they removed them from from customers against their wishes took the cars and crushed them in a yard so that they could never be used again

12:17and the the the customers who whose cars had been taken away they tried legal action to try to to to to they try to sue General motives to keep their car they actually had a a candle it vigil at at the at the yard where the cars got crushed and it's like you know when's the last time there was a candate vigil for for a product right you that's pretty ridiculous right and let alone a General Motors product I mean you have to be pretty show the passion the level passion the exct you have to be pretty pretty toned deaf to to I mean you don't need to run a customers you don't need to do a customer survey to figure out that that that at least some number of people

12:58want the cars if they are treating it like somebody's being sent to death family yeah totally you know and so what so when I saw that I was like holy crap you know something this is not going to happen and so that we we there there really needs to be a a a new call company that that comes in and shows that it can be done and the key thing that needed to be done was to show that you can make an electric car that was good-look high performance long range and and that if you made such a car that people would buy it that they didn't have some fundamental affinity for gasly mhm so that's where do you get started

13:43you have the capital to obviously put into something a new Venture but you know you're sitting there and you're like okay I want to do this like who you surround yourself with well I the my my initial thought was that I did not want to run to to create an electric car company and run it myself because I was running SpaceX and the idea of running two companies that's a lot of work and

14:11you know it's just like imagine if somebody had two pretty demanding jobs and then now or you had one really demanding job now you got to do two of them it's you know it kind of takes the fun away and and you know it's makes it pretty pretty uous yeah the social life goes away or something has something's got to give so my initial thought was okay I'll I'll hire some people and work work with a team and and I'll I'll work I'll just sort of work on the product design and sort of maybe the overall strategy or something but I'll leave the day-to-day operations to a CEO that I'd hire so unfortunately that didn't work out I actually tried hiring a couple of CEOs and and I

14:57guess I don't know I couldn't find the right person and and so then then it came to 2008 I was kind of co-ceo from 2007 in 20072 2008 while while trying to bring up you know some other people up to speed M and then when the market fell apart this the financial Market fell apart and and the economy fell apart in in 2008 and I I had a choice of like basically commit all of my remaining resources to Tesla or it's going to die for sure and I thought okay if I'm going to do that then I got to bite the bullets and run the company mhm cuz it's just too much at stake you know if you got all your chips on on the table you got to play the hand yourself yeah why do why do other car

15:49companies just really suck like a lot of their designs are horrible it seems like they're not really listening to Consumers there's no like you're the seem like obviously bad I mean it's yeah they seem obvious you look at them and you're the first company I feel has that kind of app esque design aesthetic you know like why do other car companies just make horrible looking cars do they Outsource I don't know it blows my mind I don't know how because it just seems like you know you can take a body panel and you can stamp it with that shape with this shape or that shape and yet they chose they choose to do the the bad shape but it costs the same either way right I

16:26mean there are some things that cost a little more into terms of the quality of materials and the you know getting things really to fit accurately and so there a few things that cost more but a lot of it doesn't you you know you can make an ugly expensive car you can make an you know a good-looking expensive car and actually the same goes I think you can make a an affordable good-look car or or an ugly good looking car and I think the cost differences are really actually relatively small and I mean I I I I don't know it just I think maybe there some of the logic H companies are just trapped in their o with in their own history did you do like did you have focus groups

17:09where you decide on the decision or was it very much I like the way that looks let's go with that no it's just literally just series of weekly iterations with with the design team H awesome so just every every Friday afternoon I I meet with France and and the design team and we go over the every Nuance of the car you every every bumper every curve every little tiny piece of the car what's right what's wrong and then that has to be filtered against you know the engineering needs and the ergonomic needs and regulatory requirements MH so it's a really there's a lot of constraints yeah and you can't just make a car any old shape you want and still achieve meet

17:56all the regulatory requirements be livestock crash safe and all that so it just requires a lot of iterative activity and and caring about every millimeter of the car and that's that's what results in a good product so I know we have limited time I want to jump towards the future talk to me about this hyperloop I think you're calling it yeah so the the hyperloop I I I I need to set

18:33aside some time to actually write down some some of the details and I want to make sure that I don't say something completely stupid so so I'm I'm I'm spending time with the both the SpaceX aerodynamics team and the Tesla aerodynamics team just to make sure that whatever whatever I put out there really will work and are we talking train here or is this just an alternative something that we haven't thought of before yeah I think it's it's genuinely it would genuinely be a new mode of Transport mhm it's exciting maybe I think the one way to think of it is like it's

19:15it's kind of like a groundbased Concord wow like if you could make something go as fast as a Concord on the ground how would you do that right would you require rails in that sense or I mean is it interesting we shall see no actually I think rails are not needed awesome yeah so I mean do you have a lot of ideas like this is it where you have a a sketch P I've got more ideas than you know time to implement yeah I think so is it something where where do you come up with your best ideas are you on vacation or you kind of just like in the middle of the night you wake up and start drawing things down or you know this sounds really cliche but like

19:53the shower is probably like you know wake up and go to shower in the morning and I think actually what's really happened is of stuff is percolated in the subconscious right and it's not really occurring in the shower but you're kind of getting the results of last night's you know computation basically right and then sometimes it's it's late at night if I can't sleep and there's something bothering me then it it'll occur then and

20:18one one one key idea for a supersonic vertical take off from Landing electric plane occurs me at Burning Man a lot of good ideas come out of Burning Man actually absolutely so certainly it's a very very creative place so so yes yeah that's that's it shower and buman awesome one last question I always ask of everyone that I interview for the new entrepreneurs that are just getting started out there what's one piece of advice that you would always recommend to an entrepreneur something that you've learned over the years that they can take with them in their new Venture and then something you'd completely avoid like something that you really screwed

20:56up on that you'd never do again okay sure so I think in terms of advice I think it's very important to to seek out to actively seek out and listen very carefully to negative feedback and this is something that people tend to avoid because it's it's painful but but I think this is a very common mistake is to to not actively seek out and listen to

21:28negative feedback where do you do that do you go into forums do you go into Twitter like what what are your areas where you go to look for feedback on let's say the Tesla well it's like every everyone I talk to is in fact when when friends get a product I said look I don't tell me what you like tell me what you don't like right and and because otherwise your friend is not going to tell you what he doesn't like right it's it's going to say oh I love this and that and and and then and leave out the this is the stuff I don't like list because he want to be your friend want you know doesn't want to offend you so so you really need

22:03to to to to to to sort of coax negative feedback and you should you know that if somebody is your is your friend or at least not your enemy and they're giving you negative feedback then they may be wrong but it's coming from a good place and sometimes even your enemies give you good negative feedback yeah absolutely so so I think that's important umill just feel like positive feedback like water of a duck's back that's like you know really underweight that and overweight negative feedback and then I think it's also important to reason from first principles rather than by analogy so the normal way that we conduct Our Lives is we we we we Reason

22:46by analogy it's we're doing this because it's like something else that was done or it's like what other people are doing me too type ideas yeah it's iterations on a theme and and and it's because it's it's it's kind of mentally easier to Reason by analogy rather than from first principles but by first principles is kind of a physics way of looking at the world and what that really means is you kind of boil things down to the most fundamental truths and and say okay what are we sure is true or or as sure as possible is true and then reason up from there MH that takes a lot more mental energy give me an example of that like what's one thing that you've you've done that

23:34on that you feels work for you sure so somebody could say in fact people do that battery packs are really expensive and that's just the way they will always be cuz that's the way they've been in the past you're like well no that's that's pretty dumb you know because if if if you applied that reasoning to anything new that then

23:58you wouldn't be able to to ever get to that new thing right so you know it's like you can't say oh you know horses nobody wants a car because horses are great and we're used to them and they can eat grass and there's lots of grass all over the place and you know there's not like a there's no gasoline that people can buy so people are never going to never get never going to get cars right people did say that you know and and for batteries they would

24:28say oh it's going to cost you know historically it's cost six $600 per $600 per kilowatt hour and so it's not going to be much better than that in the future and you say no okay what what what are the batteries made of so so first principles be say okay what are the material constituents of the batteries what is the spot market value of the material constituents so you can say okay it's got Cobalt nickel aluminum carbon and some poly for separation and a seal can so break that down in on a material basis and say okay what if we bought that in the London Metal Exchange what would each of those things cost like oh geez it's like $80 per kilowatt hour mhm so clearly you just

25:14need to think of clever ways to take those materials and combine them into the shape of a battery cell and you can have batteries that are much much cheaper than anyone realizes is is that your big challenge at Tesla is is battery it's it's the single biggest item but it's right now it is not is not it's not any kind of obstacle to us there are a whole bunch of of little issues that are kind of trivial that are challenges when you're making a new product because there are several thousand unique Parts in the car 90% of them are fine 5% of

25:53them are slightly problematic 3% or 4% are problematic and 1% are extremely problematic but you cannot ship a car that is 99% complete so like software you can stable functionality but with a car you know you can ship it without like a steering wheel or like without back seat or something like that you yeah well thanks for being on the show you're a huge inspiration to a lot of entrepreneurs out there so I know they're going to enjoy this and and thanks for having us in your Factory here it's awesome sounds good thanks yeah thanks for coming by [Music] for [Music]

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份