大会演讲·中文精读

马斯克轻松访谈(2013)

Elon Musk lighthearted interview (2013)

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2013年,马斯克刚在硅谷讲完一场话,赶到可汗学院(Khan Academy)的时候迟到了。他没能好好吃顿饭,直接从特斯拉位于弗里蒙特的工厂过来。主持人随口问:工厂那边是不是出什么事了?

马斯克说,工厂里永远有事。汽车有几千种零件,缺一个就造不出车。今天这场乱子,缺的是一根三美元的USB线。没有它,内饰装不进去。想先把没有内饰的车造完再回头补?行,但那样得派一队人跑到停满成车的停车场,一辆一辆钻进去重新装。这根线偏偏还藏在脚垫地毯下面,位置刁钻。

结果就是,特斯拉派人把湾区周边的 RadioShack 扫了一遍,一家一家买USB线回来救急。

“你不能停整条产线。所以我们基本上就是派人跑遍整个湾区,去像 RadioShack 这样的店买USB线。”(马斯克)

更离谱的是源头。供应商在中国的工厂没有按原包装发货,而是把这批线混进了给别家公司的货里,凑了一个极慢的船期运到洛杉矶。到港之后,同船的其它货被海关扣了,文件也不齐,特斯拉的线跟着一起在码头上躺了几个星期。

Plan B 是用空运。结果跟美国子公司下单,订单金额超了信用额度,又被弹回来。

马斯克讲这件事的样子,是在一个笑话里带出整车厂的真实日常:供应链是个蛮不讲理的系统,一根三块钱的线就能让价值上亿美元的产线原地卡死。这个开头,很像理解他后面所有选择的一把钥匙。他做的三家公司,本质上是同一件事:把系统里那些荒唐的、冗余的、低效的部分,一个个拆掉重装。

大学里想清楚的三件事,他后来真的去做了

有人问他,互联网支付、电动车、火箭,这是三个八竿子打不着的行业,为什么一个人会同时扎进去?

马斯克说,他小时候并没有立下这份志愿,也没人给他画好一条路线。大学时他只是在想一个问题:哪些领域最可能影响人类的未来?他给出了三个答案,互联网、可持续能源、太空探索。第三个的具体形态,是让人类成为多行星物种。

他当场讲了个很马斯克的判断。人类的未来大概会分成两支:要么我们散落到很多星球上,要么我们被困在地球上,等到某次必然的灭绝事件发生。

他并不悲观。他自己也补了一句,他对地球上的生活是乐观的,只是“变好”的概率还不足以抵消“早晚来一次”的概率。他提到黄石超级火山,说它每隔七十万年左右喷发一次,而现在已经过了七十万年。话题就这么拐到了超火山上,像两个书呆子聊天。

他真正想说的逻辑是:文明存在的时间,放到演化尺度上短得可怜。地球已经四十五亿岁,人类文明才几千年。如果技术继续以当前速度推进一百万年,我们会走向哪里,是灭绝不是我们今天能轻松给出的答案。所以他愿意把人生押在有分歧的那一侧。

他最早研究的领域,是电容器

很多人以为马斯克一开始就要造车。其实他读博时研究的是先进电容器,目标是让电容器的能量密度超过电池。

电容器的优点是功率密度极高,充放电几乎不衰减,循环寿命近乎无限。缺点是能量密度太低,存不了多少电。如果能做出一款电容器,能量密度接近电池,同时又保留超高功率和近乎无限的寿命,那移动场景的储能问题就解决了。

他在硅谷一家叫 Clinical Research 的公司干过,那家公司做的电解电容已经能做到接近铅酸电池的能量密度,对电容来说这是了不起的数字。问题是材料:他们用钌钽氧化物,而当时全球一年的钌产量可能只有一两吨。这条路没法规模化。

于是他想到用芯片制造里的精密设备,做固态方案。

接下来的这段自述,值得反复看,因为它几乎是马斯克判断所有项目的模板:

“我不确定成功是不是可能的结果之一。很难把这个问题的边界框住,说‘好,成功在可能结果的集合里’。我当时觉得这更像是一条注定失败的路。”(马斯克)

他解释得很直白:一般你要开始一件事,至少得先确认成功是可能性之一。失败可以是可能性,没问题,但你得把成功框进这个范围里。他当时没能确认。

他还顺带损了一下学术界。就算做不出能用的东西,也能发几篇论文,加几片叶子到知识树上,那片叶子上写着“此路不通”。他承认这是一条路,但他不想走。

他没选择“看着互联网发生”

转折点是互联网来了。马斯克判断,互联网这事,成功肯定在可能结果的范围内。摆在面前的选择很简单:读博,然后眼睁睁看互联网发生;或者跳进去,亲手参与。

他说他受不了只是看着。

“我就是受不了‘看着它发生’这个念头。”(马斯克)

1995年,他把学业搁下,开了一家互联网公司。做的是在线出版、地图导航、黄页这类东西。客户和投资人是媒体公司,纽约时报公司、Knight Ridder 这些。为什么找媒体公司?因为1995年互联网上根本没有广告收入,只有媒体公司手里有钱。

那时候在互联网上做广告,听起来是个荒唐的主意。很多媒体公司自己都不确定该不该上网,觉得没什么意义。二十多年后再看这个判断,反差足够大。

PayPal:一个月十万用户,靠烧钱烧出来的

主持人问他,当初有没有想到 PayPal 会长成后来的样子。

马斯克的回答很坦率:没想到,而且增长太快,直接制造了大麻烦。网站上线一个月,用户就到了十万。

怎么做到的?直接发钱。开户给20美元,推荐一个人再给20美元。后来网络变大,降到10美元,再降到5美元。整套激励大概花了六千万到七千万美元。

他打了个很准的比方。用户增长就像培养皿里的细菌,你要让一个用户带来两个,最好是三个,而且要快,用同样的数学模型去推,它会迅速铺满整个培养皿。铺满之后,碰到皿壁,速度就慢下来。

驱动这套打法的是两样东西:给用户塞钱,和把使用摩擦降到最低。他反复强调的是后者,每减少一点使用阻力,网络的自我复制就快一点。今天这套东西叫增长黑客,2013年他讲的时候还带着“这事儿其实很朴素”的语气。

飞了三趟俄罗斯,想买两枚洲际导弹

PayPal 卖掉之后,马斯克想弄明白一件事:为什么阿波罗之后,人类没有再送人上火星?

按常识,登月的下一步就该是火星。1969年你问任何一个美国人2013年什么样,他们会说月球有基地,火星上可能也有人,近地轨道上有太空酒店。结果2013年的现实是,美国连送人上近地轨道都做不到,但每个人兜里都有一个能接通全人类知识、能和地球上任何人通话的设备。

他去 NASA 官网找答案,想找那个写着“我们什么时候去火星”的页面,没找到。后来才发现,NASA 当时压根没有送人上火星的计划,连重返月球都没有。

他先以为这是“国家意志”的问题,觉得只要重新点燃公众对太空的热情,给 NASA 更多预算,事情就能推进。于是他搞了个叫“火星绿洲”(Mars Oasis)的方案:送一个小的温室上火星,里面是脱水的凝胶和种子,着陆后加水,让绿色植物长在红色星球上。第一株火星生命,生命走过的最远距离,一张红底绿植的照片,足够让公众沸腾。

方案卡在了火箭价格上。他算了算,两次发射才稳妥,一次失败还有第二次。美国的火箭太贵,德尔塔2号(Delta 2)一次要6500万美元。两发就是1.3亿,预算直接爆掉。

于是他飞了俄罗斯,前后三趟,谈的是买两枚最大的洲际弹道导弹(ICBM)。2001年前后,一枚大概一千万美元,两枚两千万,加上飞船和任务,总共四千万左右,这个数他能接受。

第三趟俄罗斯回来,他在飞机上想通了另一件事。

“我意识到我第一个前提就错了。我以为缺的是意志,实际上美国的太空探索意志非常强。美国本质上就是一个探险者的国家。”(马斯克)

真正缺的是“怎么做”。愿意去火星的人很多,他们怕的是花费高到要砍掉医保。如果成本只占GDP的0.25%到0.5%,那完全可以接受。

把火箭拆成原材料,他发现成本只占2%

接下来是这场访谈里最有价值的一段推理。

历史上所有火箭都贵,所以大家默认未来的火箭也会贵。马斯克不接受这个默认。他问了一个最基础的问题:火箭是用什么做的?

答案是铝、钛、一些铜,可能还有碳纤维。那就把这些零件的原材料成本加起来。如果把这些材料堆在地上,挥一下魔法棒,让重新排列原子的成本变成零,那这枚火箭值多少钱?

算下来,原材料成本只占火箭售价的2%。

“所以很明显,问题在于原子是怎么排列的。那你就要想,怎么才能更高效地把原子排成正确的形状。”(马斯克)

他接下来做的事非常“马斯克”。他每个周六和几位在大航天公司工作的人开会,反复问同一个问题:这里头是不是有什么我没看出来的陷阱?为什么大家都不这么干?他找了很久,没找到。

于是 SpaceX 成立了。

结果呢?猎鹰1号(Falcon 1),第一枚火箭,前三次发射全失败,第一次直接砸在离发射台几米的地方,碎成小块。这枚火箭最终的成本大约是600万美元,同级别火箭的市价大概是2500万美元,四分之一。

主持人以为这个数字已经够夸张了。马斯克说,还有更大的一步:可重复使用。

现在买一枚全新的 SpaceX 火箭,价格大约是波音同类产品的四分之一。如果火箭能回收复用,价格能降到百分之一,两个数量级。

火箭的燃料便宜到什么程度

他给了一个具体数字。猎鹰9号(Falcon 9)售价大约6000万美元,而推进剂成本只有约20万美元。推进剂是三分之二液氧、三分之一燃料。

这个数字有多低?给一枚火箭加满燃料,花的钱和一架波音747加满油差不多。

也就是说,火箭贵,钱主要压在那一枚用完就扔的箭体上,燃料那部分便宜到可以忽略。这也解释了为什么可复用是整件事的关键:如果箭体能反复用,你付出的主要成本就只剩下那20万美元的燃料和检修。

可复用的难度在哪?马斯克讲了个物理约束。地球重力很强,一枚先进的火箭把载荷送上轨道,效率也就2%到3%。可复用要加装着陆腿、栅格翼、保留再入推进剂,这些重量一减,效率再掉2%到3%,剩下的载荷可能就是零,甚至是负的。

所以解法是两步。第一步,把发动机效率、箭体结构效率做到极致,让消耗状态下的载荷效率提升到3.5%到4%。第二步,把可复用带来的效率损失压到1.5%到2%。这样净载荷还能保住2%左右,同时成本降一到两个数量级。

2013年,SpaceX 成立11年,回收过从轨道返回的飞船,但火箭级一次都没成功回收过,每次再入基本都炸了。马斯克说他们大概想明白原因了,并且“希望明年能做到”。

这句话放在2013年听起来像吹牛。放到今天回头看,它是那份时间表里最接近兑现的一条。

火星:他觉得那是迟早的事

主持人问,什么时候会有人站在火星上?

马斯克给了一个年份,含糊但方向明确,大意是十几年后。他强调这不会是一次往返,而是永久殖民地。

他把路径讲得很清楚。第一步,先活着。发射商业卫星,广播通信、测绘、地球观测、GPS、科学任务,还有给国际空间站运货、送人。这些业务养活公司。第二步,在赚钱的同时持续改进技术,直到完全可复用跑通。第三步,有了规模和成熟度,才能把人送上火星。

顺序不能反。这一点他在整场访谈里反复出现:先解决生存,再解决野心。听起来不浪漫,但这是 SpaceX 没在2008年死掉的原因。

特斯拉的野心:当催化剂,把时间提前十年

话题转到特斯拉。主持人问,通用、丰田这种几百亿美元体量的巨头都做不好,你凭什么?

马斯克给出的定位,和大多数人理解的不一样。特斯拉的目标,用他自己的说法,是加速可持续交通的到来。做最大的汽车品牌、跟本田思域抢市场,都不在这个清单上。

他给了一个经济学解释。汽油的价格里没有计入外部性,二氧化碳进入海洋和大气造成的环境成本没有被定价,所以市场价格机制在这件事上是失灵的。特斯拉要做的,是当那个催化剂,让本该发生的市场反应提前发生,也许是提前十年。

为什么只做电动车,不做别的车?因为这就是目标本身。特斯拉还把动力总成卖给丰田和奔驰,未来可能卖给更多公司。逻辑一样:目标落在整个行业的转向,独占没有意义。

“胜利条件大概是,所有造出来的车里有一半是电动的。到那一天,我觉得就可以了。”(马斯克)

他说,如果特斯拉只做高端,那永远只是小众。所以价格要一路往下压,直到整个行业彻底电动化。他强调特斯拉不打算造出全部的电动车,它只负责把这件事推过临界点。

电动车的S曲线,和他三年前打的一个赌

主持人问,这个“一半是电动车”的时刻什么时候来?

马斯克说,他三年前跟人打过一个赌,赌它会在20年内发生。那是2010年前后,现在算还剩17年。他的判断是,20年这个数字偏保守,实际可能是13到14年。

然后他讲了一段关于技术采用曲线的话,这场访谈里最有普适价值的一段。

新技术的渗透遵循S曲线。人们习惯用直线外推,所以在早期总是低估它,觉得这事成不了。等到了S曲线中段,又被斜率带着过度乐观,开始高估它。再往后,因为还有一批晚期采用者迟迟不动,实际落地会比中段预期的更慢。所以真实的规律是:早期比所有人想的快,中期比所有人想的慢。

他还特意加了一句:储能技术的进步速度,比任何人以为的都快。

创业的真实滋味:盯着深渊,嚼碎玻璃

有听众问:你的成功里,多少来自那些大胆的目标,多少来自不被短期利润和投资人牵着走?

马斯克的回答,把创业的浪漫滤镜当场撕了。

他说,一个人当然必须关注短期和现金流,否则公司会死。但很多人以为创业很好玩,其实不好玩。有开心的时段,也有糟糕透顶的时段。当你是CEO,你就是公司所有最恶劣问题的浓缩器。时间不会花在顺利的事情上,全花在出问题的地方,而且是别人搞不定的那些问题。你相当于给公司装了一个过滤器,只留下最恶心、最疼的那部分。

“我一个朋友说,创业就像盯着深渊,同时吃玻璃。这话有点道理。”(马斯克)

他解释了这两半。盯着深渊,是因为你随时面对公司的死亡,90%、甚至99%的创业公司会失败,你得一直对自己说:这个搞不定,公司就完了。吃玻璃,是因为你必须去做公司需要你做的事,而不是你想做的事。这种状态会持续很久。

但他没有把利润说成坏东西。他的原话大意是:如果行业的规则设置正确,利润动机本身没有问题。利润只说明人们愿意为你创造的价值付更多的钱,这是好事。赚不到利润,说明你提供不了足够的价值,出局是应该的。当然有人为了利润干坏事,但那是少数,因为大多数行业的规则大致是合理的。

这段话值得反复读。它同时否定了两种流行叙事:一种把创业讲成热血励志,一种把利润讲成原罪。马斯克两个都不接受。

加州高铁的反面教材,和Hyperloop的由来

最后一个问题是 Hyperloop。

马斯克说,起因是他看了加州高铁的方案,然后被气到了。加州纳税人要建全世界最贵、同时最慢的高铁。预算估计在1000亿美元上下,从洛杉矶到旧金山要两小时。而坐飞机只要45分钟。

“我们在加州,我们造最高科技的东西,为什么要花一千亿美元,去做一件飞机45分钟就能干完的事?”(马斯克)

他的思路是先抛开现有方案,问最理想的状态是什么。答案很清楚:比现有交通工具快一倍,票价便宜一半,不会撞车,不受天气影响,最好还能靠太阳能自供能。

然后倒推:有没有一种方案能满足这些条件?他研究下来,结论是有的,某种真空管道的形式可以做到,而且可行。

他当时还没公开细节。理由很实在:等特斯拉开始盈利、财报发布之后再说。现在手上已经有一堆事,再塞一个进来,像在学吉他一样,练小提琴也是难的。

他讲了一个判断新技术值不值得做的标准,很值得记下来。如果一个新东西,你告诉一个中立的普通人,对方会不会期待它出现的那一天?Hyperloop 就算早期假设错了、经济账算错了一点,光是“值得专程去坐一趟”这件事,就足够让它成立。

他顺手吐槽了航空业。协和式退役之后,世界上没有超音速客机了。波音787即使一切顺利,也只是稍微好一点的777。这不够让人兴奋。

为什么孩子打游戏不用催,上课却要逼

主持人问,你对可汗学院有什么建议?

马斯克先说,你们做的事情杠杆率极高,一个小团队对成千上万不在场的人产生了巨大影响。然后他给出了自己最在意的一点:尽可能把学习游戏化。

他举了自己孩子的例子。打游戏完全不用催,相反要从他们手里把设备抢下来,像从瘾君子手里夺走针管。

接着他批评了传统课堂。很多教育非常“杂耍式”(vaudevillian):一个人站在前面,对着下面讲同一套讲了二十年的课,自己早就不兴奋了,而这种缺乏热情会直接传递给学生。学生会想,我为什么要学这个,我根本不知道我为什么在这儿。

他给了一个刻薄的比喻。克里斯托弗·诺兰的《蝙蝠侠:黑暗骑士》,剧本好、特效好、演员好、声音好,非常吸引人。同样的剧本,如果交给美国每个小镇的业余剧团去演,服装是家里凑的,台词念得没底气,长得也不像电影里的人,没有特效,结果会惨不忍睹。

这就是今天的教育。

“如果你能解释‘为什么要学这个’,对人的动力会有巨大改变。他们理解了目的,就不一样了。”(马斯克)

他还补了一句:很多知识其实学了也用不上,那就更应该老实告诉学生为什么还要学,而不是让他们在教室里困惑。

这场2013年的对话,今天最该拿走的几件事

十二年过去,再回看这场访谈,有意思的地方跟他说对了多少关系不大,重点是他怎么想问题。几乎所有回答都能归结到同一种方法:先拆到底层,再重新往上搭。火箭贵,那就拆成铝、钛、铜、碳纤维,看原材料占多少。电动车推不动,那就找到定价失灵的环节,当催化剂而不是等市场自己反应。课堂没劲,那就问学生为什么坐在这儿。

对今天做产品、做技术、做内容的人,这场对话有几条可以直接拿来用的建议:

  • 先确认成功在可能结果的范围内。马斯克放弃电容器研究,理由跟难不难无关:他框不出“成功长什么样”。开始一件大事之前,先问自己:如果它成了,那个“成了”具体是什么?说不出来,就别急着投入。
  • 把成本拆到原材料。遇到“这个行业一直就这么贵”的说法,别接受。拆开看,钱到底花在材料、工艺还是流程上。如果材料只占2%,那98%的空间就是你的机会。
  • 在早期用直线外推,会系统性低估新技术。反过来,在S曲线中段,又会系统性高估。判断一个新东西时,先想清楚自己站在曲线的哪一段。
  • 用激励换增长,但知道它的上限。PayPal 花六七千万美元买用户,前期有效,网络效应起来之后,激励的价值就低于网络本身。补贴只能当点火器,跑长途还得靠网络自己。
  • 创业的真实成本是注意力,不是钱。CEO 的日常就是处理公司里最烂的那批问题。想清楚自己能不能长期吃这份苦,比想清楚商业模式更重要。
  • 把“为什么”讲清楚。不管是带团队、做课程还是写文档,先告诉别人这件事为什么值得做。人被要求的时候未必会投入,理解了目的才会。
  • 判断一个新产品值不值得做,用一个朴素的标准:告诉一个中立的普通人,他会不会期待它出现的那一天?如果连这个都做不到,再精巧的方案也很难撑起来。

最后说一句题外话。2013年的马斯克还在为三美元的USB线派人跑遍湾区,还在说“希望明年能回收火箭”,还在等特斯拉盈利后才敢公开 Hyperloop 的细节。那一年他讲得最多的一句话,其实是这家公司明天可能就死了。十二年后再看,那些看起来最疯狂的目标,恰恰是靠这种对死亡的清醒,一步一步走出来的。

YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00so first of all I just want to thank Alon for coming hungry absolutely even have dinner and we didn't even feed you properly sorry to be a bit late oh no it came from the Tesla factory in Fremont yes is it was something wrong there's always something you have to like at any given point there's always something wrong yes because there's just too many things going on yeah we won the trick is things about a car is that there's this there's thousands of individual components the thousands of unique components and even if one of those things is missing you can't make cars yeah I mean today's Fiasco was I kid you not we were missing

0:36$3.00 USB cable okay so we could not complete cars because the whole line was stopped yeah so essentially because you know it's part of the wiring harness no you can't put the interior in without this cable hmm and so we can either make a whole bunch of cars - an interior which means that you gotta come up in the yard the resale value would be good and it's way more

1:08it's it's way more in if it's what you can't you don't have a music movie production line they have to send people out to hundreds of cars that are sort of sitting in the storage yard and so we then this happens to be particularly pernicious cable it's kind of like routed under the carpet and yeah it's a difficult place and it's literally three dollars and so we basically had to send

1:33people throughout the Bay Area to go and buy USB cable like a Radio Shack you like fries fries fries oh that's better getting a USB calf right oh well every one of them that's good and and so we were able to continue production and under a blade with anecdote but essentially the the suppliers in China and we had plan a and Plan B and plan a was like the normal supply chain process and but but what the supplier did was instead of sending our parts it in their

2:11own package they grouped it together with a bunch of other stuff for other companies and sent that or via some extremely slow boat from trying it to LA and when it got to LA the other stuff didn't pass customs oh so they wouldn't they wouldn't let our stuff through because they put it in like a barrel of fruit or something this

2:33something that customs didn't like and the paperwork wasn't in order or whatever so it got stuck there for for like a couple weeks and then we had plan B just like so it was so we called and said look you've got a air freight some of these cables there's little cables yeah to us and we talked to their US subsidiary and ordered order from the US subsidiary who then communicated China but then because this was another batch of pots it was kind of double the order exceeded the credit limit that we had oh yeah you got it so it bounced off with a credit limit so they didn't ship it fascinating so so so someone's losing their job now this is non point no no you should it's I

3:16mean it's pretty farcical Oh anyway so it's coming like tonight at 11:00 p.m. or something Wow and these things are happening like all the time this was an unusual circumstance yeah that's that's like one example but there's many things like that so I guess I mean that's actually a really good example because that kind of leads into what I've always been fascinated by a lot of what you're doing is well I guess that well I'll start with how did you get into this I mean you know it cars it oh into cars into taking over NASA into we're not taking over NASA of being a contractor for for for Nassau the record yes you're not taking over NASA they're an independent

3:57organization the but you are becoming a major provider of services for NASA obviously of kind of internet payments and payments generally I mean these are very three completely different spaces I think a lot of people would not take someone seriously if they kind of had a business plan in one of these right well oh yeah you take picture time what was your I mean what did you always think you were going to be doing this or when dawn on you that you would try to revolutionize three industries well when I was in college I didn't actually expect to do it so it was not like this is some long fulfilled expectation but but when I was in college I thought

4:40about what were the areas that would most affect the future of humanity in my opinion and the three areas were the Internet sustainable energy and space exploration particularly humanity becomes a multi-planet species you know there's kind of like a pretty substantial bifurcation in our sort of future if we're either out there among stars on multiple planets or if we're confined to earth until some obviously a ventral extinction event yeah not that I'm pessimistic about life on Earth I mean I think so these are likely to be good but even more likely to be good yeah Yellowstone's due for an explosion every hundreds ever right exacting sideways about that yeah yeah

5:17it's everything it's been seven hundred thousand since right right but yeah yeah supervolcano for those of you don't know it would envelop that well yeah no exactly we really the same book like right absolutely I mean something bad is bound to happen you should give if you give it enough time and civilization has been around for such a very short period of time that you know these these timescales seem like very long but on a evolutionary timescale a very short a million years on evolutionary timescale is it was really not much and you know it's been around for four and a half billion years yeah so that's you know a very tiny tiny amount of time really but

5:57for us that would be and we key imagine if if human civilization continued anything remotely like the current pace of technology advancement for a million years where would we be no I mean I mean I think we're either extinct or on a lot of planets yes everybody but given that I mean one that's that's kind of as epic as one can think about things I mean literally I mean how how did you make that concrete how does that turn into SpaceX Tesla and and PayPal

6:31well so I thought about those these things kind of in the abstract not for the expectation that I would actually have careers in those arenas but but I wanted to be involved in at least one of them and at first I thought the best bet was going to be electric cars and so the area that I was studying was advanced capacitors right so essentially capacitors that have an energy density exceeding that of batteries because they have a very high power density but but a low energy i season a lecture to that oh yeah

7:08so obviously if you could make a capacitor that had anywhere near the energy density of battery and it was incredibly high power density as quasi an infinite cycle and calendar life then you'd have an awesome solution for energy storage in mobile applications so that I was going to sort of work on that and try to leverage the equipment that was developed for advanced chip making photonics to create ultra precise

7:36capacitors at sort of and this is when we're going to go into grad school yeah you had a brief stint at Stanford that's right for the PhD in Applied Physics Applied Physics material side right this is what you were so even then you were thinking of kind of trying to do something in the space well this was yeah this was to work on energy storage solutions for electric cars yeah and and I'd actually worked at a company in Silicon Valley called clinical research which did advanced capacitors there they were electrolytic capacitors sort of and

8:08but the problem and actually were pretty good they had like the energy density of a lead acid battery which for a capacitor is that's a big deal but they used ruthenium tantalum oxide and as I think at the time there was maybe like one or two tons of ruthenium mine per year and so it's not a scalable solution but there I thought there could be some solid state solution like just like you know say using chip making equipment now it's gonna be the basic idea but one of those things were I wasn't sure if success was one of the possible outcomes you know and like you kid it's difficult to bound that problem exactly and say okay so you're saying I wasn't I felt

8:48like this was a destined failure is another way to parse that scent but anyway so I would fail but I wasn't sure that success was a possibility okay yes you know and generally you want to embark on something it's desirable to figure out if success is at least one of the possibilities right exactly because sure failure is one of the possibilities yes but but ideally you want to try to bracket it and say success is in the envelope of outcomes yeah and I wasn't quite sure if that was the case I mean I think success on an academic level would have been quite likely because you can publish some useless paper and the most papers are pretty useless you know we have a few

9:35don't take of how many peers 50 papers are actually used by someone ever I mean it's good point sentence wise it's not it's not good no and so so it could've been one of those outcomes where you add some leaves to the tree of knowledge yeah yeah and that leaf is nope it's not possible so that was weren't one path

10:06and I was prepared to do that but then the internet was era came along and it's like okay the internet I'm pretty sure a success is one of the possible outcomes and it seemed like I could either do do sort of do a PhD and watch the internet happen or I could participate gonna help bullet in some fashion you know sort of you know it like I just couldn't stand the idea of watching it happen yeah yeah so that that's so I decided to put things on hold and start an Internet company and that was kind of a we worked

10:36on in order like publishing software maps and directions yellow pages kind of things and and we had as investors and customers that the media companies like New Times Company the knight-ridder this was just at the early stages and this was like late 1995 so it's really early stages just really out the gate yeah absolutely yeah and so then we you know we were the

11:01the reason we worked with media companies because we had money like there was no advertising money in 95 right right in fact the idea of advertising internet seemed like a ridiculous people obviously not so ridiculous anymore but at the time it was it seemed like a very unlikely proposition and a lot of the media companies weren't even sure that they should be online all right like what's the point of that and did y'all think that PayPal was just going to be a you know simple little you know internet way or do you think it was going to turn into the major kind of transaction processing engine that it is right now I didn't expect PayPal's growth rate to be what it was you know

11:33so and that actually created major problems so it's not a PayPal on University Avenue no after the first month or so of the website being active we had a hundred thousand customers really that that wow I didn't realize yeah it was nutty oh wow and how did it start how did people just even know to use it and I mean obviously both buyer and seller have to be involved yeah well the we started off first by

11:58offering people $20 if they open an account hmm and $20 if they referred anyone oh and then we dropped it to $10 and then we dropped it to $5 as the network got bigger and bigger the value of the network itself exceeded any sort of carrot that we could offer how much they wanted you don't spend with that kind of five ten twenty dollar incentive to get that critical mass going oh it was a fair amount I think was probably 60 or 70 million dollars oh wow okay so it was a substantial okay so we're not talking peanuts here yeah this is yeah it depends on your relatives game yeah it's a peanut to Google yes no that's right that's right yes yes yes I mean

12:40like Google's got 50 billion apples got I don't know 150 billion some crazy amount of money wise yeah yeah yeah so it's not about land well yeah I know that I didn't realize I didn't realize that was so cool - would be 500 million dollars so you know that's point 1 percent of Google's that's true you're right that's it expensive it's relative sensitive so it's probably pretty inexpensive that's right on and and then we did it we just did a bunch of things to decrease the friction because and it's just like bacteria in a petri dish yeah so the what what do you want to do is try to have one customer generate you

13:20know that like two customers yeah okay or something like that maybe three customers ideally and then you want that that to happen really fast and if you probably Madol model it just like bacterial growth in a in a in a in a petri dish and and it will just expand very quickly in full hits the side of the sides of the pantry dish yeah slows down and then after PayPal then I mean to some degree you know the especially else in Silicon Valley we can understand the Internet we we know people I mean PayPal obviously of a scale that you know is is noteworthy but then SpaceX just seems really you know like well what how did

13:58you decide that I'm definitely gonna do that and then like what's the first thing that you do like how do you even like go out like I don't even know how to start trying to make a rocket company well neither than I really the and in fact the first three launches failed so as though it was like you know spot on

14:18but II but even getting the point that you're launching rockets I don't even know how to like how do you get there and like what did you do on like one how did you decide and then what did you do on day one like who did you call or did you write a plan do you start I don't know I mean the PayPal is or other there SpaceX is is that I was trying to figure

14:37out why that we'd not sent any people to Mars because the obvious next step after after Apollo was to send people to Mars so but but what in fact happened was that we sent a few people to the moon and then we didn't send anyone after that to the Moon or Mars or anything but if you'd asked people in 1969 what word 2013 look like they would they would have said there'll be a base on the moon there would be we would have at least had some people to Mars and maybe they'd even be a base on Mars would be like orbiting space hotels yeah and they billed us or some stuff in space yeah and and and that's what people expected and if you said well actually the united

15:15states in 2013 will not be able to send anyone to of it but i'll tell you what will exist is that they'll be this device yoga and you that's like the size of it it's more than a deck of cards that has access to all the world's information and you can talk to anyone on planet earth you know and even if you're like and you know some remote village somewhere as long as there's something called the Internet they would know what that means of course then you would be able to communicate to anyone instantly and have access to all of humanity's knowledge said like there's not a way that that's gonna right right right and yeah we all have that and and space

15:51is not happening so after I figure out like what was deal here and this was 2001 I was just a friend of mine asked me what I'm going to do after PayPal I said well you know we're interested in space but I don't think there's anything that an individual could do in space because it's the province of government exactly large government but I'm curious as to when we're going to seem someone tomorrow so I went to the NASA website try to figure out look where's the place that tells you that I couldn't find that so they're all like even I'm like bad look at the website or they have a terrible website because surely there must be that should be a big date yeah

16:22yeah like yeah this is but this is real a front page and then I discovered actually that NASA had no plans to send people to Mars and or even really back to the moon yeah so this was really disappointing I thought well maybe this is a question of national will like have have do we do we need to get people excited about space again and and try to get NASA a bigger budget and then that then then we would send people to Mars and and so I started researching the

16:58area becoming more familiar with space reading lots of books and countless idea to do so called Mars Oasis which was to send a small green house it was seized in dehydrated jail that land on landing you hydrate the jail you have green plants on a red background and the public is the public responds to precedents and suppose yeah so it's the first life on Mars the furthest that life's ever traveled and you'd have this money shot of green plants on a red background yeah so that that seemed like it will get people pretty excited yeah so that that I started getting into this and trying figure out okay well can I afford to build the spacecraft because

17:43I add some money from as well to PayPal but had to fit within that budget and I figured we had to do two missions because if we if we only do one and it failed then it might have like the opposite effect but you are willing to bet the farm so to speak on this yeah well yeah I figured like I was willing to spend half the money that I got no he fell yeah with no expectation of return right because I thought this is just something that was pretty important and yeah I'm like it seemed like I could spend half the money I made a pea fell in this and OB if that got NASA a bigger budget and resulted in us going to Mars that would be a good pretty good outcome

18:22and when your friends can or your family came up to you said look you know there's nations that can't do this you know your your guy but you have some resources what did you say or do or think well so a lot of friends tried to talk me out of starting a rocky company because they thought it was crazy and what friend of mine maybe watch a video of rock is blowing up and you know there were just

18:48lots of people thought it was a really crazy idea and there was some people that had tried to start rocket companies not succeeded and they try to talk me out of it and but the thing is that the premise for talking me out of it was what we think you're gonna lose the money that you invest I was like well that was my expectation anyway so I don't really mind if I lose you know I mean not mine but I mean it's so it's not like I was trying to figure out the rank-ordered best way to invest money right on that basis you know space right

19:17it's not like that's yeah I thought wow you're wondering it like money money market bonds triple-a by rocket comfort that you weren't lying to real estate I really you know invest in shoemaking and and watch this is just highest ROI yes that is not what I wasn't it's thought that it was important that humanity expand beyond Earth and we weren't doing that so maybe you know something I could do to kind of spur I swear that on and then I I was

19:49able to compress the costs of the spacecraft everything down to a relatively manageable number and I got stuck on the rocket the the u.s. rockets were way too expensive I ended up going to Russia flew to Russia three times to negotiate purchase of a an ICBM that tried to buy two of the biggest ICBMs the Russian fleet in 2001 and 2002 and

20:10actually the negotiator I'll just let that statement stand I might even get like who did you call I mean how does this and I don't get too much in the wit but I am this is one particular thing you are you decide at some point you need to buy an ICBM yeah well actually I first I try to buy just a normal rocket launch vehicle that they used for satellites right or too expensive oh I see I see the the Boeing Delta 2

20:44would have cost 65 million dollars right each and so two would have been a hundred thirty and then was like whoa okay that breaks my budget right there yeah and and try to negotiate with them and that was not how much does an ICBM go fo I'm curious what's the market rate for one of those well this was right after fall we might have gone up yeah yeah it's gone up a lot right but in 2001 it would have been about 10 million dollars each for so - in the twenty and then and then I thought I could get the rest of the mission down to also around ten pursue a dual mission with like two identical launches to an eagle spacecraft and you know for like roughly

21:28forty million dollars and so I thought that okay I can do that and but you must have had some like you know rocket scientists advising you at this point I mean this is hounds like you were Syria I mean you were yeah yeah engaged a bunch of circuit consultants right and kind of so to get familiar with the space industry and but then after the third trip to Russia III can trust that I was actually wrong about that my first premise that that there was a lack of will in fact I think that there's a tremendous amount of will in the United States for Space Exploration cuz United States is essentially a nation of explorers I mean it's a distillation of the human spirit

22:08of exploration so of course it was quite so easy to think that that people like motivation but what people don't want to think is that okay going to say if you will tomorrow is gonna be so expensive that it they'll have to give up like health care or something right yeah I'm gonna do that so it's got to be think it's good it's going to be that going to Mars is not going to cause some meaningful just drop in their standard living right yeah so if it's like maybe a quarter of a percent ill half a percent of GDP so I'm like that was palatable anyway so I thought okay it's

22:45not good really going to maybe matter that much if I do this mission because what really matters is is having out away so so I was wrong I thought I thought I hoped it was it wasn't enough will but there actually was was plenty of well if people thought there was a way so so then I said okay well I need to work on the way how hard is it really to make a rocket in history historically all Rockets have been expensive so therefore in the future more rockets will be expensive but actually that's not true if you say what does the rocket made it and say okay it's made of aluminum titanium some copper it's

23:22common fiber if you want to go that direction and and you can break down and say what is what is the for material cost of all these components and if you have them stacked on the floor and could wave a magic wand so that the cost of rearranging the atoms was zero then what would the cost of the rocket be yeah I was like wow okay it's really small it's like you know two percent of whatever so clearly be in how the atoms are arranged right the the other so you got to forget sort of okay how can we get the atoms in the right shape much more efficiently yeah and so it has series of meetings on

24:04Saturdays with people that were somewhat working at the big aerospace companies just to try to figure out is there some catch here that I'm not negotiating I couldn't figure it doesn't suit for any catch so started SpaceX and and you and you ended up though I mean you had some failures but I'm obviously some huge successes what was the cost that you were able to build this rocket for relative to what they were being built for before so absolutely the foot for the Falcon one which is the first rocket we both and that most three flights did not make it in fact yeah I mean we got it sort of progressively further but like the first rocket like came and

24:41cracked landed maybe couple yards away from the launch site and had tiny fragments so yeah anyway that that that rocket ended up costing around six million dollars Wow compared to other rockets in that class which were about 225 million but now so significant yeah they're like a quarter Wow Wow and but

25:11but there's an even better step beyond that which is to make Rockets reusable so right now our that that is around around what what our comparison prices excluding the refurbished ICBMs so if you say bullying rocket from new how does the SpaceX rocket compared to a rocket from Boeing a latke it's about a quarter of the price however if we make

25:35it reusable then it can be at tours magnitude cheaper two orders of magnitude cheaper or 100th the price that's right so so I mean into and that's you go away today we know more they say oh oh what what and I've seen some you are doing like these vertical landings yeah like like Liberty out of like the 1950s like like sci-fi movies yeah and that's what you're talking about yeah yeah essentially the rock needs to come back and land at the launch site and then reload propellant take off again and how far do you think we are from that like when do you think like you know your best guess is we'll actually see that happening I'm hopeful we can do it next year oh okay yeah

26:18let's we got we got some ambitious stuff at Khan Academy for the next year Jason we can compare we're redesigning the site you know we're gonna work at her for a long time I know I should say it SpaceX has been around for 11 years and thus far we have not recovered any rockets we've recovered the spacecraft from orbit so that that that was great but none of our attempts to recover the rocket stages have been successful the rocket stages have voice blown up basically on reentry yeah now we think we've we think we figured out why that was the case and it's a tricky thing because Earth's gravity is really quite strong and with advanced and advanced

27:02rocket you can do maybe two to three percent if you look both master orbit typically and then reusability subtracts 2 to 3% so then you've got like nothing to orbit or negative all right and and that's also helpful and so the trick is to try to shift that from say to 3 percent in an expendable configuration to make the rocket mass

27:32efficiency engines efficiency and so forth so much better that it moves to around maybe three and a half to four percent in an expendable configuration and then try to get clever about the reusability elements and try to drop that to around the to one and a half to two percent level so you have a net payload to orbit of about two percent but you're doing it at one of two orders of magnitude cheaper yeah absolutely because so our Falcon 9 rocket costs about sixty million dollars but the propellant cost which is smooth where's the oxygen as two-thirds oxygen one-third fuel is only about $200,000 Wow it's much like a like a 747 cost as much to refuel our rocket as it is to refuel

28:17747 you know within you know pretty close so what happened if assuming y'all are successful and you all have proven yourself to be multiple successful on kind of these audacious things in the past I mean what happens I mean that seems like it's I mean what happens the next 5-10 years in the space industry if y'all are successful there I mean do we get to Mars do we do we have kind of market forces commercialization of space starting to happen yeah see well the

28:46first step is that we need to earn enough money to keep going as a company so we have to make sure that we're launching satellites the New York commercial satellites like I broadcast communication is mapping and it governs headlights that do scientific missions earth-based cycle or space-based missions GPS satellites that kind of thing and and then also servicing the space station transfer cargo to infer on the space station which are done a few times and and then taking people to and from the space station so so we've got a we've got a service the sort of needs earth-based it needs to watch satellites and that pays the bills but but in doing

29:31that keep improving the technology to the point where we can make full reusability work and we have sufficient scale and sophistication to be able to take people to Mars Wow so you think this is going to be a reality and what's your best guess when we're gonna have someone on Mars well that's despotic and you think it'll be a round trip it will be yeah it won't just be able some type of permanent colony on on Mars yeah I think it's probably around wow I could I could talk

30:05about this right I mean the Jubilee aspiration will be around true ya know this yeah this is mind-blowing and I mean and then on Tesla I mean Tesla is obviously from from our from my vantage success I mean it's I mean what do you think is in in that in - well one I mean I'll ask kind of the same question what did you think you you know this is something that was a GM and Toyota and these massive multi-billion dollar organizations have been trying you know what gave you the confidence to kind of pursue it and and now that it seems to be a huge success where do you think this industry is going to be in the next 5-10 years yes so with with Tesla the goal is to try to accelerate

30:44the advent of sustainable transport I think would happen anyway could just add necessity but because we have a none price to externality in the cost of gasoline we're pricing in the environmental effects of co2 in the oceans and atmosphere that that's causing the norm of the normal market forces to not function properly and so the goal of Tesla is to try to act as a catalyst to accelerate that those sort of normal forces that the normal sort of market reaction that would occur we're trying to have a catalytic effect on that yeah and and try to make it happen I don't

31:25know maybe 10 years sooner than it would otherwise occur yeah that's that's that's the goal of Tesla so that's reason we're making electric cars and not any other kind of car and we also have supply power trains to Toyota and to Mercedes and maybe to other companies in the future to accelerate their

31:46production of electric vehicles so that that's that's the sort of goal there and so you know working at RIT pretty well I mean I just saw a news report earlier today that y'all are sold more Model S's than you are leading that segment of the industry that the Mercedes s-class the BMW 7-series are the Lexus ls400 or

32:05whatever it is yeah actually that that seems to be the case and it's yeah I didn't realize they sold so a few cars in that segment that's my quarter you know twelve out here they seem like you know every yeah I mean yeah yeah yeah team you know so it's a wee bit us all out of the berry yeah yeah yeah no but that's and and well I

32:33mean it seemed similar thing I mean what how did you start what gave you the confidence and I mean do you see yourselves I mean it's kind of a major automotive mainstream brand in 5-10 years all the way down to kind of the you know the competing with the Honda Accords and civics yeah I mean I mean I goal is not just it's not sort of to become a brand big brand or to compete with Honda Civics but rather to advance

33:00the course electric vehicles so we're just going to keep making more and more electric cars and driving the price point down until the industry is very firmly electric you know like maybe half of all cars made our electric or something like that which is not to say that we expect to make all helpful because we we want to just have that catalytic effect until at least that occurs I think the point which there's you know we're approaching half both your cars made our electric then I think that's I would consider that to be kind of the victory condition Wow and and so the faster we can bring that day but the better one would be your guest when that

33:40happens well I made a bet with someone about three years ago that it would be sooner than twenty years so it's 17 years from now but right but that's I think that's conservative I think is probably you know maybe we've thirteen or fourteen years Wow right right about the time happen like right when we run to Mars it'll be exciting exciting time yeah absolutely true that's just good yeah exactly as this thing about that it was like this time K frames are kind of coincident yeah yeah I mean the nature of new

34:21technology adoption is a test to follow an s-curve so so what usually happens is people under predicted in the beginning as people tend to extrapolate on a straight line and and then they'll over predict it kind of at the midpoint and because there's there's late adopters you know it'll actually take longer than people think at the midpoint but much shorter than people think at the beginning yeah yeah and yeah but I'm pretty excited about how things going it's in fact I think I think that the pace of Technology improvement is in energy storage like the lectionary storages is really moving faster than anyone thinks Wow Wow I got one more but what are we doing on

35:00time where's Esther 9 o clock so how much time do you have okay I guess we're another 15 okay okay so I'll finish with one last question then we'll open it up I mean what advice do you have for us at Khan Academy we're doing really great so yeah I was worried if you have advice for me oh no well yeah I mean it seems like

35:21you're doing they're doing an amazing job of really really super leveraged you know I mean hopefully small team and you're having a dramatic effect on half these people don't even work here so like it's even yeah right it's right so it's I think very impressive thing you're doing to spread knowledge and understanding you know throughout the world the universe assumes you if you follow up your end of the bargain yeah yeah I mean it's actually kind of funny like you know if you think like what is it occasionally basically downloading data and algorithms into your brain and it's it's it's actually amazingly bad in conventional education because like it shouldn't be like this

36:02huge chore so you're making it way way better but I mean I think I think a lot of things that I would say it you've probably heard a hundred times and in effect are if not doing like the more you can gamify the process of learning the better like for my kids I do not have to encourage them to play video games yeah okay yeah I like pry them from their hands it's like like a crack yes yes like drop that crack needle yeah

36:40so it's it's yeah it's it's it's agree that you can make somehow learning like a game but that's better and I think unfortunately like a lot of education is very vaudvillian at you've got someone standing up there kinda of lecturing at people and they've done the same lecture twenty years in a row and they're excited about it and that lack of enthusiasm you know is conveyed to the students that they're not very excited about it I don't know why they're there like why are we learning this stuff we don't even know why in fact I think a lot of things people learn probably there's no point in learning them because it that they never use them in the future because

37:19who's gonna launch a rocket into space I mean that's just like yeah exactly that never happens well you have to say like feel I think don't stand back and say well why are we teaching people these things and we should tell them probably why we're teaching those things because the like kids just in school kinda puzzled as to why they're there I don't think and I

37:40think if you can explain the why of things then that makes a huge difference to people's motivation yeah then they understand the understan purpose yeah so think that's pretty important and just make make it entertaining but I think just in general like a conventional education should be massively overhauled I'm sure you very much agree with that but yeah so I mean the knowledge is uses like we've seen but like Batman like the Chris Nolan movie like the recent one and it's pretty freakin awesome right and you've got incredible special effects great script multiple takes amazing actors and

38:19great sound and it's very it's very engaging but if you would instead say okay that even if you have the same script so at least it's the same script and you said okay now that script instead of having movies we're gonna have does that that script performed by the local town troupe right okay and and so every in every small town in America if movies didn't exist they would have to then recreate the Dark Knight right you know with like home like home so in costumes yes in like you know just the stage not giving their lines quiet and

38:52not really looking like you know the kid the people in the movie and and no special effects and everything I mean I would suck that's right that's yeah that's education that's so so with that and and I polished all of you guys for hogging up all of the time because obviously I could talk for hours about this stuff but we do have time I think five or ten minutes for for a handful of questions if none of you all have any I have about nine more but yes yeah so I noticed I picked up two kind of themes from from what you were discussing one was somewhat audacious goals and the other was I don't think I heard use the word profit and anything that you spoke of

39:35but you seem to be each each thing is pointed out like reinvigorating in industry or bringing back space missions how much of your success do you attribute to having really audacious goals or versus just not being focused on the short term you know money coming in or other investors I personally I I when one does have to be focused on we're short term and money coming in when creating a company because otherwise the company will will die so that I think that a lot of times people think like creating company is gonna be fun I would say it's not it's really not that fun I mean there are periods of fun and there are periods of where to where she's awful and particularly if you CEO

40:24of the company you actually have a distillation of all the worst problems in the company there's no point in spending your time on things that are going right so you only spend on things on your time and things that are going wrong and and there are things that are going wrong that other people can't can't take care of so you're like the worst you have a filter for the crappiest problems in the company most pernicious and painful problem so I

40:51wouldn't say it's it's it I think you have to feel quite compelled to do it and have a fairly high pain threshold and there's a friend of mine who says like starting companies like staring at the abyss and eating glass and there's some truth to that we're starting to the best part is that you're going to be constantly facing the extermination of the company because what most startups fail it's like 90 percent probably 99% of starts fail so I

41:25so you that that's the staring in to give this part your constant constantly saying okay this if I don't get this right the company will die it should be quite right for quite stressful and and then if the eating class part is you've got you've got to do you've got to do the problems you're gonna start you got to work in the problem that the company needs you to work on that promise you want to work on and so that the that's you and I've working on problems that that you really wish you weren't working on okay so that's the eating glass part and that goes on for a long time so how do you keep your focus on the big picture when you're constantly faced

42:04with we could be out of business in a month well it's just a very small percentage of mental energies on the on the big picture like you know you know you know where you generally heading for and and the actual path is going to be some sort of zigzagging thing in that direction and try not to deviate too far from the path that that you want to be on but you're gonna have to do that some degree but I don't want to I don't to

42:34diminish the I mean I think the product the profit motive is it is a is a good one if the rules of an industry are properly set up so there's only fundamentally wrong with profit in fact profit just means that people are paying you more for the that whatever you're doing then you're spending to create it that's a good thing and if you're not if that's not the case then you'll be out of business and rightfully so sure you're not adding enough value now

43:02there are cases of course where people will do bad things in order to achieve profit but but that's actually quite unusual I mean because because usually the rules are set up mostly correctly like not completely with mostly correctly well I think we have time for one more question Joel the same an important one okay very good yeah okay so a few months ago ut's Hyperloop we haven't heard anything since so first of all a few of us engineers we're talking about it I think we have a few ideas if you need help but if you feel comfortable maybe you could tell us a little bit more I was reading about the California high-speed rail and it was quite depressing because

43:51California taxpayers are going to be on the hook to you know to build the most expensive high speed rail per mile in the world and the slowest which is they're also not the superlatives yeah and and it's like damn like we're in California we make super high-tech stuff why are we gonna be spending 100 and not know the estimates are around a hundred billion dollars for us something that that will take two hours to go from LA to San Francisco I'm like okay well I can get our plane to do that in 45 minutes it doesn't make much sense and isn't there some better way to do it than that so so if you just say okay

44:36well what would you ideally want in it you know transportation system you'd say okay well you'd want something that relative to existing modes of transportation is faster or let's say twice as fast costs half as much per ticket can't crash is immune to weather and is you know you can make the whole thing like self-powering with like solar panels or something like that that would create that would be that'd be great yeah good outcome yes and so what would do that and what's the fastest way short of inventing teleportation that you could do something like that it's some of the elements of that solution of fairly obvious and some of some of them

45:17are not so obvious and then the details The Devil's in the details of actually making something like that work but I came to the conclusion that that there is something like that they could work and would be practical is this the around evacuated tubes the the vacuum tubes the old bank that it something like that yeah well you haven't been more public with with what this is no although I did say that once Tesla was profitable that I would talk more about it but we haven't done our earnings coil yet I think yeah after the earnings cool and the things like I kind

46:01of strung out on the things that I'm doing so adding another yeah doesn't you know it's learning the guitar right I tried learning the violin yeah that's by the way a hard thing to learn yeah launching rockets electric cars yeah revolutionising transportation yes I can't believe Alan at all very horrible you thinking about the future you want a future that's better than the past and and so if we had something like the Hyperloop and that would be like cool like you'd look forward to the day that that was working yeah and and if something like that even if it was only her only was in one place you know from LA San Francisco or New York to DC or

46:46something like that then it would be cool enough that it would be like a tourist attraction yeah like a riot yeah yeah so even if some of the initial assumptions didn't work out the economics didn't didn't work out quite as one expected we like cool enough like I want to journey that place just to just to ride on it that'd be pretty cool and so that's I think how if you coat

47:10with the new technology it should feel like that you should really know like if you told it to an objective person would they look forward to the day that that thing became available yeah never like you know be pretty exciting to do something like that or an aircraft like I thought was really disappointing one that when the Concorde was taking out a mission and there was no supersonic transport available and of

47:32course the 787 has had some issues yeah so but it's but the thing is that 787 even the best case scenario is only a slightly better version of the triple 7 yeah and it's like okay I'm not that exciting so they're there this is something that you are working on and and one day in the not too far future or there's some plans or consultants involved or something made some phone

47:59calls to Russia it's like it's sort of percolating away and then I'm gonna actively think about it but then there were some new elements that I'll think oh well you know this would make it better yeah no well I mean I think I'm speaking for everyone this is like the most epic possible conversation one could have over the course of an hour and I think all of us would love to chat with you for hours on end but thank you so much I mean I know you have a lot of free time so it probably wasn't that big of a deal for you to come here but yeah it was a huge honor and I think it inspired all of us to go out and change the world and the universe cool thank you thank you very much

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份